Grading Rubrics

These rubrics cover the Playbook Project (one per part, plus the Chapter 39 capstone), the Chapter 40 film-grading assignment, chalk-talk presentations, the call-sheet simulation, and discussion participation. Every rubric uses the same four levels:

Level Points (of 100) What it means in a staff room
4 — Coordinator 90–100 You could hand this to a staff on Monday and install it Wednesday.
3 — Position coach 75–89 Sound and usable. One or two pieces need a second pass before players see them.
2 — Quality control 60–74 The pieces are there, but the connections between them, or the reasons, are missing.
1 — Not yet below 60 Not installable. Wrong rules, missing parts, or a document nobody could teach from.

Hand these out in Week 1. A rubric students have never seen is a grading tool. One they've read is a teaching tool.

Two principles override every row below (they come from the overview). First, grade the reasoning, not just the call. The book never claims one coverage is universally right, so a student who calls Cover 3 where you'd call Quarters, and defends it with the down, the formation, and the opponent's tendency, has done the job. Second, grade whose-fault answers by first cause. Grading the defender nearest the ball is the most common film error, and it should cost points everywhere it appears.

One safety rule overrides everything. Any deliverable, presentation, or simulation that teaches or endorses head-first contact is returned for revision whatever its other scores. That includes any cue that puts a tackler's head in front of the ball carrier, crown-of-the-helmet tackling, and full-speed live contact where Chapter 23's tempo ladder (Air, Tag, Bags, Thud, Live) calls for less. The book's only tackling cue is head out, shoulder in: near foot, near shoulder, head to the side and behind the runner, eyes up.


Rubric 1 — The Playbook Project: per-part milestones

How the project is graded

Students build forty deliverables, one per chapter. Mark each deliverable complete / revise when it comes in, then grade at the end of each part with the milestone rubric below. That keeps feedback arriving while it can still change the next piece. A student without a Shell and Disguise Menu can't build an honest Cover 3 Install Sheet with Sky, Buzz, and Cloud variants, so be strict about milestone dates and lenient about revisions.

Crosswalk to the 15-week syllabus. The 15-week syllabus groups deliverables into eight milestones (1–5, 6–11, 12–17, 18–23, 24–29, 30–35, 36–38, and the Chapter 39 capstone). The per-part rubrics below work under either grouping. If you use the syllabus milestones, grade each milestone with the general criteria and borrow the "what level 4 looks like" notes from whichever part each deliverable belongs to.

Level choice. Each student declares a level in Week 1: high school, college, pro, or film-room. Read every deliverable at the declared level. A high school Personnel Package built around the roster the student actually has is a level-4 document. A film-room student's checkpoints become identification and grading products, such as a Cover 3 recognition sheet instead of an install sheet. Grade them on accuracy of seeing, not on installability.

General milestone criteria (use for every part)

Criterion Weight 4 — Coordinator 3 — Position coach 2 — Quality control 1 — Not yet
Completeness 15% Every deliverable in the part is present and meets its Project Checkpoint spec One deliverable thin or missing a required element Several deliverables thin; one missing Multiple deliverables missing
Diagrams and notation 20% Every front, coverage, and pressure has a pre-snap and post-snap diagram in the book's notation, with 11 defenders counted (nickel = 4 DL, 2 LB, 5 DB), receivers numbered outside-in, and a plain-prose described line after each Diagrams present and correct; one or two missing the post-snap view or the described line Diagrams present but with counting errors, missing pairs, or nonstandard symbols Diagrams missing or wrong
Rules a player can play 20% Every assignment is stated as a rule a player could say in one sentence ("If #2 goes vertical, I take him") Rules mostly clear; a few are descriptions rather than rules Rules are vague ("play your zone") or contradict each other No usable rules
Internal consistency 20% Uses the same words, strength rule, safety alignment, and check vocabulary as the student's own earlier deliverables, and says so when it changes them One or two inconsistencies, noticed and flagged Inconsistencies the student hasn't noticed Each deliverable written in isolation
Honest trade-offs 15% Every call names its weakness and what the student will live with ("every coverage has a weakness") Weaknesses named for most calls Weaknesses named only when obvious Calls presented as unbeatable
Level fit 10% Built for the declared level's personnel, hashes, practice time, and rules Mostly fits; one element assumes the wrong level Reads as a copy of the Sentinels' system regardless of level Ignores the declared level

Part I — Defensive Foundations (Deliverables 1–8)

Philosophy Statement, Lineage Map, Personnel Packages and Role Cards, Base Front Sheet, Run-Fit Chart, Shell and Disguise Menu, Problem List, Communication System. Chapters: Ch 1–Ch 8.

What level 4 looks like. The Philosophy Statement has a one-sentence thesis and 3–5 non-negotiables that later deliverables can be checked against. The Run-Fit Chart gives every gap an owner against inside zone, outside zone, power, and counter, and names the force and alley players. Its gap count is honest: five linemen make six gaps, each tight end adds one, and a running quarterback effectively adds one more. The Shell and Disguise Menu lists every pre-snap look with every post-snap answer it can become (Chapter 6's "the shell is not the coverage"). The Communication System uses a fixed call grammar (personnel → front → modifier → pressure → coverage → tag) and names who owns the front, who owns coverage checks, and what happens when the call isn't in by the 15-second cutoff.

Automatic revise: a Run-Fit Chart with an unowned gap, or the same gap owned twice. A communication system with no default call.

Part II — Zone Coverages (Deliverables 9–14)

Cover 3 Install Sheet, Cover 2 / Tampa 2 Sheet, Quarters Install Sheet, Split-Field Rules, Zone Blitz Package, Adjustment Check Chart. Chapters: Ch 9–Ch 14.

What level 4 looks like. The Quarters sheet states the safety's #2 read as a rule with a depth (vertical past about seven yards means man on #2; inside or flat means top #1), which is Chapter 11's "a zone that plays like man." The Tampa 2 decision is explicit and justified. The Split-Field Rules say which side gets Cover 2, how the call is made, and who declares it. Each zone blitz has five rushers, three deep, and three under, with a named dropper in the hot window. The Adjustment Check Chart handles trips, empty, condensed sets, and motion for every coverage so far, with one check word per snap and a stated priority when checks conflict.

Automatic revise: a fire zone with no defender in the hot window. A trips check that leaves the backside corner alone without saying so.

Part III — Man Coverage and Pressure (Deliverables 15–19)

Cover 1 Package, Cover 0 Rules, Corner Technique Menu, Pressure Package, Rush Plan. Chapters: Ch 15–Ch 19.

What level 4 looks like. The Cover 0 Rules are a when-allowed list, short and specific, with the protection data that would forbid it (the lesson of Russ's Week 6 call). Every designer pressure carries the six-line protection ledger: rushers, blockers, blockers blocking nobody, effective blockers, free rushers, and where the hot throw goes and who's there. The Corner Technique Menu ties press, off, and bail to situation and opponent, including how motion changes the technique. The Rush Plan targets a specific opposing tackle and guard (the Outlaws' line is in the book for students who need one), with a setup move, a counter, and a plan for the chip.

Automatic revise: any pressure without its ledger. Cover 0 with no restrictions.

Part IV — Run Defense and Tackling (Deliverables 20–23)

Run Defense Plan, Linebacker Key and Read Cards, Secondary Run-Support Rules, Tackling Curriculum and Tracking Sheet. Chapters: Ch 20–Ch 23.

What level 4 looks like. The Run Defense Plan answers zone, gap, and option schemes and states one-gap or two-gap technique by position, with the reason. The LB cards give a key by run scheme and an RPO eye-discipline rule. Force and alley players are named for every coverage in the playbook, not just the base. The Tackling Curriculum teaches head out, shoulder in as its only cue, rations contact with the tempo ladder (most reps at Air, Tag, and Bags), tracks missed tackles by type (angle, lunge, no breakdown), and includes heat and practice-load safeguards appropriate to the student's level.

Automatic revise (safety): any tackling technique that puts the head in front of the ball carrier or uses the crown. Live-tackling volume that contradicts the curriculum's own tempo ladder. No missed-tackle tracking.

Part V — Game Planning and Situational Defense (Deliverables 24–29)

Scouting Template and Outlaws Tendency Report, Call Sheet v1 and Self-Scout Checklist, Third-Down Package, Red Zone and Goal-Line Package, Two-Minute Package, Tempo Package. Chapters: Ch 24–Ch 29.

What level 4 looks like. The Tendency Report states every number with its sample. It labels Owen's 247-snap figures as a four-game sample and any larger count as season-long, and it says what each number means for a call in one sentence. The Call Sheet has situation boxes, a mix line, a pressure limit, a veto rule, and a default call. The Self-Scout Checklist looks for the student's own tells. The third-down menus are split into short, medium, and long, with underneath droppers working off the line to gain. The two-minute package has a range line. The tempo package uses calls simple enough to be signaled without substitution.

Automatic revise: tendency numbers with no sample sizes. A call sheet with no default call.

Part VI — Modern Defensive Innovations (Deliverables 30–34)

Rotation Plan, Pattern-Match Rules, Exotic Package, Mobile-QB / Screen / Play-Action Plan, Defensive Metrics Dashboard. Chapters: Ch 30–Ch 34.

What level 4 looks like. The Rotation Plan says how two-high defends the run (who becomes the extra fitter and from what depth) and sets a mix target per look, with no look always rotating or always holding. The Pattern-Match Rules include in-out or banjo against stacks and bunches and say when a carrier releases. The Exotic Package has two sims and one mug or amoeba look, each with a ledger, a draw line, a legal "quiet rule" (no words or signals that simulate the snap count), and kill conditions. The Dashboard tracks eight numbers, each with a definition, why it matters, and an honest caveat about sample and definition.

Automatic revise: an exotic look with no rules line, since disconcerting signals are a foul at every level. A dashboard that reports numbers with no definitions.

Part VII — Coaching and Synthesis (Deliverables 35–38; 39 and 40 have their own rubrics)

Culture Document, Installation Calendar, In-Game Adjustment Protocol, System Map. Chapters: Ch 35–Ch 38.

What level 4 looks like. The Culture Document defines effort grading so that a second coach confirms any loaf, and it treats medical limits as a separate category. The Installation Calendar installs in an order that respects dependencies and builds the student's likely in-game adjustments into midweek practice. The In-Game Adjustment Protocol has a three-snap rule, an adjustment ladder with a "never in-game" line, a halftime clock with the medical report first, the four-question halftime sheet, and a template capped at two or three changes. Each change has a stop-or-mix trigger (Chapter 37: every adjustment has a half-life). The System Map shows each coverage and pressure as an answer to another's weakness, using the honest cycle from Chapter 38 rather than a claim that anything "beats" everything.

Automatic revise: a halftime template that allows new techniques or words. A System Map with a coverage that answers nothing.


Rubric 2 — The Chapter 39 Capstone: The Complete Playbook + Outlaws Game Plan

The capstone has three parts (Chapter 39, Project Checkpoint): A, the assembled playbook with its audit log; B, the Outlaws game plan; and C, a twelve-minute defense of one package against a classmate playing the offensive coordinator.

Criterion Weight 4 — Coordinator 3 — Position coach 2 — Quality control 1 — Not yet
A. Assembly and audit 15% All 38 deliverables in the 39.2 format, with a System Map front page and a table of contents. All five 39.3 consistency checks were run, and the audit log lists real failures and fixes Assembled; audit log present but thin (few failures found) Assembled without an audit, or the audit finds nothing ("a binder with no failures in its audit log hasn't been audited") Deliverables missing; no audit
B1. Opponent on one page 10% Five items, each with a count, a sample size, and a decision, drawn from the Austin data (Appendix G) and labeled four-game or season-long correctly Five items; one missing a sample or a decision Numbers listed without decisions Numbers invented or misquoted
B2. Weapon table and early downs 15% Each Outlaws weapon (motion, RPO, play-action, quick game, Vance vs. pressure) has its evidence, how it's taken away, what that costs, and what the student will live with. The call sheet's side one covers 11 and 12 personnel, has a first-series script, and has a NO line Complete but with one weapon's cost unstated Weapons named without evidence or cost Generic plan, not Austin-specific
B3. Third down and situation boxes 20% Third-down page by distance bin and formation, with a pressure line and limit, a NO line, a mix line, and a HOLD if one is being built. It honors Vance's numbers against 5+ rushers and against rotation. Red zone, low red, goal line, two-point, two-minute with a range line, tempo board, backed up, fourth-and-short, and sudden change are all present All boxes present; one thin Third down built without regard to Austin's splits; several boxes missing Third-down page missing or unsound
B4. Checks, pressure menu, halftime template 15% The check page names owners and an Austin trigger for each word. The pressure menu gives each pressure's box, rush count, hot-window defender, screen player, and limit, plus a not-in-this-plan list. The halftime template pre-loads at least five if-then adjustments, each using an installed call Present; one element missing per piece Pressure menu without hot-window defenders, or a halftime template with new calls Missing
C. The defense (twelve minutes) 20% Answers the minimum four questions (What does it give up? What does it look like before the snap? What else comes from that look? What if I go empty?) with diagrams and one-sentence rules. Writes down unanswered questions and fixes the page Answers most questions; one answer is a description rather than a rule Defensive or vague under questioning; doesn't concede costs Can't explain the package
Professional judgment 5% Shows Tess-level restraint: a smaller sheet of repped calls, with tendencies banked on purpose Sound but unexamined Kitchen-sink sheet No judgment visible

Level notes. A high school student may build Part B for a real upcoming opponent from two games of film and cut side two to red zone, two-minute, and one third-down page. Grade the cut version at full credit. College students add field/boundary notes to every coverage box. Film-room students build Part B for an NFL team's upcoming opponent from public play-by-play and two games of All-22, then check it against what the defense called that Sunday. Grade the check heavily.


Rubric 3 — Film-grading assignment (Chapter 40)

Use this for Deliverable 40 (the Film Grading Rubric and 10-snap self-test) and for the film practical on the final exam. It has two layers. The student's own 50-point self-score (five points a snap: correct shell, correct rusher count, correct coverage family, correct owner of the ball's space, and a fault statement that names a rule) checks accuracy. The four-level rubric below grades method.

Criterion Weight 4 — Coordinator 3 — Position coach 2 — Quality control 1 — Not yet
The rubric page 15% Pre-snap checklist in a fixed order (box, safeties, corners, LBs, DL, plus the offense first); three post-snap questions; the five-step fault method; a code list where every code names who fixes it Complete, with one element loosely defined Codes with no owners, or a checklist with no fixed order Missing or copied without understanding
Snap selection 10% Ten snaps chosen to teach: at least one run, one pressure, one rotation, one completion over 15 yards, and one uncertain snap Meets the minimum mix Highlights only, or no run snaps Fewer than ten snaps
Pre-snap reading 15% Box counted against blockers; safety depth, width, and twins noted; prediction hedged ("two-high or a rotation") Accurate; predictions slightly overconfident Shell read as the coverage Pre-snap column empty or wrong
Post-snap identification 20% Rushers counted at about one second; the safeties' first two steps named; zone vs. man by the eyes; coverage named from the signature table One or two misidentifications on hard snaps Frequent family errors Coverage guessed from the result
First-cause fault grading 25% Walks backward from the ball to the first error. Never grades by proximity. Fault statements name the coverage, the defender, the rule, and the consequence. Uses RULE, CALL, and CREDIT correctly and is willing to give eleven pluses on a touchdown Mostly first-cause; one proximity grade Several proximity grades; CREDIT never used; every touchdown has a villain Grades the result, not the process
Humility and confidence 10% Confidence column used honestly ("can't see" when the angle hides it); conditional grades when the call is unknown; "what I'd have called" kept in a separate, labeled column Confidence column present, rarely used Certainty about what the film doesn't show Grades the defense the student would have called
Safety standard 5% Grades tackling on technique (head out, shoulder in, eyes up, wrap). A crown-first hit is a minus even when it produced a takeaway Notes tackling technique inconsistently Grades tackles only on outcome Rewards dangerous contact

Converting the self-score. The chapter's scale is 45 and up for coordinator eyes, 35–44 for a good QC coach, and below 35 for a return to weeks 5–8 of the §40.7 plan. Don't let the 50-point score stand in for the rubric. A student who scores 46 by choosing ten easy snaps has earned less than one who scores 38 on a hard, honest set with every uncertainty marked.


Rubric 4 — Chalk-talk presentation

Each student takes the board for ten minutes, twice in a term: one coverage or front install, and one game-plan or situational talk. A classmate plays Mike Sorensen and asks at least one "how would I attack that?" question.

Criterion Weight 4 — Coordinator 3 — Position coach 2 — Quality control 1 — Not yet
Drawing accuracy 30% Pre-snap and post-snap in the book's notation, 11 defenders counted aloud, receivers numbered, zones labeled, drawn fast and clean Correct with one notation slip Counting errors or a missing post-snap picture Can't draw it ("if you can't draw it, you don't know it")
The one-sentence rule 25% Each player's assignment said in one sentence a player could repeat Most assignments in one sentence Explanations, not rules No rules stated
Know your enemy 20% Names the offense's best answer (the beater) unprompted, and how the defense disguises or pairs the call to protect it Names the beater when asked Names a beater but has no answer Claims the call has no weakness
Handling the Sorensen question 15% Answers with a drawing and concedes the real cost; offers the partner call from the same look Answers correctly but defensively Answers vaguely Can't answer
Accessibility and clarity 10% Describes each diagram aloud in plain language (the spoken version of the 📊 line); defines every term on first use Mostly clear Relies on jargon Unintelligible to a newcomer

Game-plan talks (the second presentation) substitute "evidence" for "drawing accuracy" at the same weight. Every claim about the opponent comes with a count and a sample size.


Rubric 5 — Call-sheet simulation (DC vs. OC game, mock booth, halftime)

Use this with the chalk-talk and simulation guide's DC vs. OC call-sheet game, mock game-day booth, and halftime simulation. Grade the decisions, not the dice. A sound call that loses to a roll of 1 is still a sound call, and that's Chapter 16's bad-call-versus-bad-outcome lesson.

Criterion Weight 4 — Coordinator 3 — Position coach 2 — Quality control 1 — Not yet
The sheet 20% Situation boxes, a default call, a mix line, a pressure limit, a zero card, and a NO line, all built from the Outlaws' tendencies before kickoff Complete with one missing control Boxes without limits No sheet; calls improvised
Calls under the clock 15% Calls in before the 15-second cutoff; uses the default call deliberately, not by accident Occasional late call Frequent defaults by accident Can't operate under the clock
Reasoning per call 20% Can give a one-sentence reason for any call, tied to down, distance, formation, and tendency Reasons for most calls Reasons after the fact "It felt right"
Managing own tendencies 20% Keeps a running self-tally; never three of the same in a row; survives the self-scout reveal with no read-able pattern One pattern the OC exploited, noticed afterward Patterns the OC exploited repeatedly Calls one thing all game
Booth and halftime protocol 15% Booth applies the three-snap rule. Halftime produces two or three one-sentence changes from installed calls, each with a ladder level, a cost, and a stop trigger, plus a keep list. The "Card" veto is respected Protocol mostly followed; one change too many or too vague Halftime lecture instead of changes New calls invented at halftime
Debrief honesty 10% Grades own explosive plays as CALL, RULE, or dice with reasons; owns errors first Honest with prompting Blames the dice for every loss Doesn't engage

Role variants. A student playing OC (Petrakis) is graded on the same scale for exploiting the DC's tendencies with evidence from the call log. A student playing booth (Tess) is graded on chart accuracy, timely "That's two / That's three" flags, and tallies of the defense's own calls.


Rubric 6 — Discussion participation

Grade across the term, not per session. Two or three quick notes per student per week is enough.

Criterion Weight 4 — Coordinator 3 — Position coach 2 — Quality control 1 — Not yet
Preparation 25% Cites real sections, snaps, players, and numbers from the chapter ("Game 3, snap 8, the zoom motion") Usually prepared Speaks generally Unprepared
Reasoning 30% Argues from first cause, evidence, and sample size; separates the call from the outcome Sound reasoning, sometimes outcome-driven Opinions without evidence Contributions unrelated to the question
Respect for the offense 15% Treats the offensive coordinator as the smartest opponent in the room; argues the other side well in role-plays Engages the other side when asked Dismisses offensive answers Treats opponents as foolish
Building on others 20% Extends or productively challenges classmates' points; invites quieter voices Responds to others Parallel monologues Interrupts or dominates
Safety stance 10% Holds the book's player-safety position (medical first, head out, shoulder in, rationed contact) when the discussion pushes against it Agrees when prompted Silent Endorses dangerous practice

A note on quiet students. Accept a written contribution (a closing-synthesis paragraph, or a "whose fault?" note on a snap) as equivalent to speaking. The skill being graded is reasoning about defense, not volume.


Quick formative check — any single deliverable

For weekly complete/revise marking, under three minutes per student:

☐ Check
☐ Meets the Project Checkpoint spec for its chapter
☐ Diagrams paired and described. Pre- and post-snap, 11 defenders, a 📊 line under each
☐ Rules in one sentence. A player could say each one back
☐ Consistent with the student's earlier deliverables
☐ Cost named. What it gives up, and what the student will live with
☐ Safe. Contact technique and practice volume meet the book's standard

One line of comment: the single change that would move the deliverable up one level.