Chapter 26 Exercises — Third-Down Defense
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and independent study
Answers to selected exercises are in Appendix J. Short worked answers to Part C appear here in <details> blocks.
All Sentinels, Outlaws, Stallions, and Ospreys people, games, and numbers are fictional composites.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. Define the sticks and the line to gain. Why does Ed Talley say third down is "the only down where the offense has to tell you its homework"?
A2. Name the four third-down distance bins the Sentinels use, give the yardage range for each, and write the defense's posture in each as one short phrase.
A3. Owen says the Sentinels' 9% conversion rate allowed on 3rd-and-11+ "is mostly the distance, not us." What does he mean, and which bin does he think the coordinator's calls affect most?
A4. Why does Owen never show Russ the third-down conversion rate without the average distance to go on third down beside it? Which part of the defense "owns" each number?
A5. State the chapter's governing principle for third-down calls in one sentence, then explain it using a fire zone on 3rd-and-8 versus 3rd-and-3.
A6. What is four-down territory, and how does it change what counts as a third-down stop?
A7. Third-and-medium is called the hardest down to defend. Give two reasons, and name at least four kinds of plays the offense can credibly call on 3rd-and-5.
A8. What does the defense need to do to load the box on third-and-short? Use the gap count from Chapter 5 to explain why a running quarterback changes the count.
A9. What is a dime package in this book? Who comes on the field for the Sentinels, who leaves, and what's the run-defense cost?
A10. Give the three jobs of a third-down four-man rush in Big Lou's order. Which job matters most against Darius Vance, and why?
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
B1. Pre-snap: the Sentinels show two high safeties at about 12 yards against 11 personnel, 2x2, on 3rd-and-2. The field corner is pressed a yard off the flanker. Post-snap: one safety spins to the deep middle, the other rotates down onto the tight end, every eligible receiver has a defender in man coverage, and the Mike drops to about seven yards in the middle of the field. Name the call. What is the Mike's job called, and what does he do if the quarterback crosses the tackle box?
B2. Pre-snap: two-high shell against 3x1 trips on 3rd-and-5. Post-snap: the backside corner plays the single receiver man-to-man, the backside safety goes to the middle and reads #3, the trips-side safety carries #2 vertically, and the Mike walls #3 before sinking under a dig. Name the coverage and the check word, and identify which defender is responsible for the dig first and which only second.
B3. Same pre-snap as B2. Post-snap: every receiver is covered man-to-man, the backside safety spins to the deep middle, and the trips-side safety steps down to about nine yards and drives into an in-breaking route. Name the coverage. Why does it start from the same pre-snap look as B2?
B4. Study the diagram and identify the call, the rushers, the droppers, and the deep defenders. Then answer: where is the sticks line relative to the underneath droppers, and is that a mistake?
POST-SNAP (3rd-and-8)
[DEEP 1/3] [DEEP MIDDLE 1/3] [DEEP 1/3]
C F $
- - - - - - - - - - - STICKS (8 YDS) - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
[CURL/FLAT] [MIDDLE HOOK] [HOT WINDOW]
E * T
E N W M C
vv vv vv vv vv
O O O O O
Q
📊 Diagram (described): Three deep defenders: a corner on the left third, the free safety in the middle third, and the strong safety on the right third. Three underneath defenders: a defensive end in the left curl-to-flat zone, the nickel in the middle hook, and a defensive tackle in the right-side hot window. Five rushers: an end, the nose, both inside linebackers, and the right-side corner. The sticks are drawn at eight yards, above all three underneath defenders.
B5. On the broadcast copy of a third-and-6, you pause the moment the ball is released. Both underneath linebackers are standing about a yard in front of the yellow first-down line, and the receiver is breaking open behind them. Name the mistake from the chapter and the fix.
B6. Pre-snap: 3rd-and-11, two-high shell, six defensive backs on the field, and one linebacker aligned over the center at six yards. Post-snap: both safeties bail to deep halves, four defenders trail receivers man-to-man underneath, the running back stays in to block, and the linebacker mirrors the quarterback from about six yards. Name the personnel, the call, and the linebacker's rule.
B7. A third-down completion is caught three yards short of the sticks. The nearest defender comes from the outside, the receiver cuts back inside, and he converts. Name the rallying rule that was broken and its three parts.
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
C1. ⭐⭐ Make the call. Week 11 at St. Louis, second quarter. 3rd-and-1 at the Stallions' 34. The Stallions are in 21 personnel (two backs, one tight end), with Gus Mahler at fullback and Antoine Day at tailback, and Tyler Haugen under center. Owen's note: on 3rd-and-1, the Stallions ran on 9 of 11 snaps in the sample, mostly iso and power toward the tight end, and threw both passes as play-action boots. Choose personnel, a front, and a coverage, and name what you concede.
Answer
Use base or big nickel with a Bear front (or Over with the linebackers tight), and Spin 1 behind it. The Bear front covers both guards and the center, so no interior lineman can climb cleanly to a linebacker, and the linebackers can fill downhill against the fullback lead. Behind it, Spin 1 gives you man coverage on the tight end and a deep safety, which protects against the boot throw over the top. The edge rule matters as much as the front: the backside end has "squeeze, then stay home" against a bootleg team (Chapter 4), so Haugen can't run the boot clean. Concedes: a perfectly executed boot to the tight end in the flat if the backside end chases, and a quarterback sneak if your interior players don't get low. This is the Week 11 call that produced the Bear stop on an iso, no gain, followed by a punt.
C2. ⭐⭐ Make the call. Game 3 (playoff), second quarter. 3rd-and-4 at the Sacramento 47. Austin is in 11 personnel, 3x1 trips to the field, the same Harlan/Powers/Gaines look as in the chapter. In Game 2 you showed Robber on the trips dig, and the Q3 counter was Harlan's seam against man coverage. Pick a call from the third-and-medium panel and justify it against what Petrakis has now seen. Include personnel and the depth of your underneath players.
Answer
There are two defensible answers, and both stay in nickel on 3rd-and-4.
- Quarters Lock, with underneath players at the sticks plus one (about five yards). Petrakis has seen Robber take away the dig and will expect it again. He'll probably attack man coverage, with Harlan's seam or a rub on the trips side. Lock is zone on the trips side, so a seam by #2 or #3 is handed off and carried, not run against one man-to-man defender. Bell's card line covers the flat: "#3 to the flat — you're the cutback." Concedes: the dig against the second job, if he still throws it, and the backside slant against Brennan on the island.
- Mug look with a four-man rush and quarters behind it. This shows the protection a pressure without paying for it.
Not recommended: Robber again. It's on film, and the counter that beat it is too.
Whichever call you choose, measure what it concedes against four yards. On 3rd-and-4, Austin is at the Sacramento 47, between the 40s and in four-down territory, so 4th-and-1 is a live risk there.
C3. ⭐⭐⭐ Draw it. Draw Dime Over Two Man against Austin's 3x1 trips (Harlan #3, Powers #2, Gaines #1 to the field; Sutton backside; Ruffin in the backfield) on 3rd-and-12. Label every defender's assignment and draw the sticks line. Count your defensive backs.
Answer
Four linemen rush (Rollins, Tuipulotu, Coleman, Weller). Royce and Holloway play deep halves. Underneath, in trail man: Brennan on Sutton, Simmons on Gaines, Vo on Powers, Lucas on Harlan, and Bell on Ruffin ("back blocks, you spy"). The sticks line is at 12 yards, and the underneath defenders trail beneath their receivers' routes toward it. Count: six defensive backs (Simmons, Brennan, Vo, Lucas, Royce, Holloway), one linebacker (Bell), four linemen — eleven. A good answer also notes the risk on the trips side. Three man-to-man defenders are trailing three receivers, so a mesh or rub concept there needs a switch/banjo rule (Chapter 15). Without one, a crossing route can beat trail technique before the safety's half-field help arrives.
C4. ⭐⭐⭐ Make the call. Game 2, third quarter, tied 13–13. 3rd-and-7 at the Austin 38. Same situation as Anchor B, with one change: Austin comes out empty (five receivers, Ruffin split out wide). Mug Cat Fire is called. What happens to the call, who makes that happen, and what do the Sentinels end up playing?
Answer
Echo. Against empty with a pressure called, Bell checks Echo. That kills the pressure, and the defense plays Buzz 3 with a four-man rush. Echo overrides any coverage check, and Bell owns it (Royce owns coverage checks, Bell owns pressure kills). The mugged linebackers can hold the look until the snap and then bail. The Mug Cat Fire design depends on a running back in the protection: Ruffin was supposed to be the blocker assigned to Weller, the dropper. With five receivers out, the protection math, the hot throw, and the dropper's window all change. The Sentinels' third-and-long page also lists Dime Over Two Man against empty for exactly this reason. If Austin had shown empty before the substitution, Hector Salas would have sent dime.
C5. ⭐⭐ Make the call. Ospreys at Oklahoma City, fourth quarter. The Sentinels lead by 4. 3rd-and-14 at the Ospreys' 22, 6:10 left. The Ospreys are in 10 personnel, 2x2. Oduya gets the ball out in about 2.4 seconds. Choose the call, the personnel, and the depth of your underneath players. What is the goal of this down?
Answer
The goal is a punt, not a sack. Use dime, and either Dime Over Two Man (trail man under two deep halves) or Dime Over Spin 3 with every underneath dropper finishing at the sticks, about 14 yards. Rush four with lane discipline. With a 2.4-second quarterback, pressure rarely arrives anyway. Everything is in front of the defense, and the tackling rule is "nobody misses the first tackle." A Two Pole (Tampa 2) call is also defensible against 2x2, because the Ospreys' quarterback is a pocket passer, not a scrambler. Don't blitz. A blitz turns the hot throw plus yards after the catch into the Ospreys' only realistic way to convert.
C6. ⭐⭐⭐ Draw it. Draw the 3rd-and-6 sticks picture for Quarters Lock vs. trips, showing only Vo, Bell, and Royce, and the three trips receivers running the flood: #1 clears vertically, #2 runs an out at seven, and #3 runs to the flat at three. Mark where each defender's drop ends, where the ball should go, and where the tackle should happen.
Answer
- Vo walls #2 and then sinks under the out, finishing at seven yards (the sticks plus one). That takes away the conversion route.
- Bell walls #3 and then, because #3 goes to the flat, becomes the inside-out cutback defender on the flat throw.
- Royce, reading #3 from the middle, sees the flat and looks for a crosser or the dig. Against the flood he's the last line inside.
The ball should go to #3 in the flat at three yards, three yards short of the sticks. The tackle should happen at four or five yards: Bell comes from inside, and Vo drives down from the out. If you drew Bell turning to the middle, compare your drawing to the chapter's "Whose fault?" drill.
C7. ⭐⭐ Make the call. High school, Friday night. 3rd-and-6 at midfield, your team up 14–10 in the third quarter. The opponent runs a spread offense with a quarterback who keeps the ball on about a third of his third-and-medium snaps, according to your film. You have one practice period a week for third down. Pick a call and write the one rule your underneath players need for this down.
Answer
Use a sound zone you already play well (Cover 3 or Quarters) with a four-man rush, and put one defender on the quarterback: a linebacker or rolled-down safety with a "QB run" rule, or an end with strict contain. Rule for the underneath players: "Third-and-six: finish your drop at seven, eyes on the quarterback, drive on anything in front." At the high-school level, add a run-first reminder. A third of this quarterback's third-and-mediums are keeps, so the contain player's job matters more than any coverage nuance.
Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. Vic Maddox's third-down page had one line: pressure. Make the strongest honest case for Vic's approach against a rookie quarterback with a weak offensive line. Then explain why the same approach fails against Darius Vance, and why it eventually fails even against the rookie.
D2. Russ accepted a realistic worst case of 4th-and-2 at the Austin 43 when he called Mug Cat Fire on 3rd-and-7. Petrakis goes for it often. Was that the right acceptance? Argue both sides, including what Russ would have had to call on 4th-and-2.
D3. Your best underneath linebacker is a great blitzer but a poor rally tackler in space. He is very effective on third-and-long pressures and is the reason you lose third-and-medium after the catch. Design his third-down role across all four bins, and decide whether he plays on 3rd-and-5 at all.
D4. The Money Period is "thud," and the quarterback is never touched. A veteran player tells you the period "doesn't feel real" and asks to go live on the last six snaps "just this once, for the Austin game." Answer him as Russ would, using player safety, the purpose of the period, and what actually transfers to Sunday.
D5. Owen's 14-of-22 tendency is a small sample. A colleague argues that you should ignore any tendency under 30 snaps. Respond. When is a small-sample tendency worth building a call around, and how do you protect yourself if it turns out to be noise?
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (Ch 26 + Ch 13) Chapter 13 says a fire zone works when its dropper is "standing where the ball wants to go." Chapter 26 says the dropper's window is deliberately short of the sticks. Explain how those two ideas fit together in Mug Cat Fire, and say what would happen to the call on 3rd-and-4.
M2. (Ch 26 + Ch 18) Austin kept Ruffin in to block on 19 of 27 dropbacks on 3rd-and-7 or longer. Using Chapter 18's protection math, explain what that tendency does to a five-man pressure, and why dropping a lineman (as in Mug Cat Fire) answers it better than adding a sixth rusher.
M3. (Ch 26 + Ch 14 + Ch 8) On 3rd-and-5, the Outlaws motion from 2x2 into 3x1 trips with 12 seconds on the play clock. You called Home. Walk through the communication: who signals what, who echoes, which word wins, and what the defense plays at the snap. What changes if the motion happens with 4 seconds left?
M4. (Ch 26 + Ch 25) Using Chapter 25's threshold concept, design a three-question self-scout for your third-down calls. Then show how one answer, "we play nickel on third-and-long only when we pressure," would change your personnel plan.
M5. (Ch 26 + Ch 23 + Ch 5) A third-and-medium completion caught short of the sticks is "a run play that starts at the catch." Use Chapter 5's ideas of force and alley and Chapter 23's tackling progression to write the rally rules for the two nearest defenders.
M6. (Ch 26 + Ch 6) "The shell is not the coverage." Explain why the Lock/Robber pair on third-and-medium is a direct application of Chapter 6's threshold concept, and what the pair would lose if Robber were called from a one-high look.
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. The sticks chart. Watch the third downs from two full NFL games, using the broadcast copy or All-22 if you have it. For every completion, record the distance to go, where the ball was caught relative to the yellow line, the yards after the catch, and whether the play converted. Then compute what share of conversions came on catches short of the line. Compare the two defenses, and write a paragraph on which one coached sticks depth.
E2. Third-down bins from public data. Using a public play-by-play source such as nflverse/nflfastR (or a published season summary from a charting service), find one team's third-down conversion rate split into the chapter's four bins, along with that team's average distance to go on third down. Write a one-page "Owen memo" that separates what the team's early downs earned from what its third-down calls earned. Report sample sizes and state at least one limitation of the data.
E3. A coordinator's third-down personality. Pick one NFL defensive coordinator and chart 30 or more of his third downs across several games. Record the distance bin, personnel (count the defensive backs), pre-snap shell, number of rushers, and post-snap coverage family. Build his third-down page as Petrakis would see it, and name the one tendency you would attack.