Chapter 8 Exercises — Defensive Communication
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and research
All Sentinels, Outlaws, Stallions, and Ospreys people, calls, and numbers are fictional composites. Selected answers appear in Appendix J; short answers to Part C are given below each item.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. Define call, signal, check, and echo in one sentence each, and give a Sentinels example of each.
A2. What is the difference between a communication bust and a technique error? Why does Russ insist that Owen chart them separately?
A3. The NFL allows one defensive player at a time to wear a radio helmet. When does that radio go silent, and what does that mean for the design of checks?
A4. List the six slots of the Sentinels' call grammar in order. For the call "Nickel, Under, Star Fire," name which slot each word fills and which slot is empty.
A5. Give the three tests every Sentinels call word must pass, and explain the "Sky/Spy" story from Russ's second coordinator stop in two sentences.
A6. Why is the Sentinels' default call ("Home") a four-man-rush Quarters call rather than the defense's best pressure?
A7. What is the look-in, who coaches it, and why does a lineman get a minus for skipping it even on a snap where the call never changed?
A8. State the echo rule in five words. Then explain why it is the backside safety's echo, rather than the corner's or the Mike's, that makes a coverage check live.
A9. Name four post-snap alert words, who usually yells each, and what each tells teammates to do.
A10. What does the rule against disconcerting signals forbid a defense from doing, and why does it matter more for mugged and amoeba looks than for a standard four-man front?
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
B1. You're watching end-zone film of a road game. Four seconds before the snap, after a slot receiver motions to create trips, you see the trips-side safety raise his fist into his palm and hold it. The backside safety's head never turns toward him. The backside corner is staring at the receiver in front of him. What do you predict about this snap's coverage integrity, and what would you look for in the first two seconds after the snap to confirm it?
B2. Study this picture.
PRE-SNAP (11 personnel, 2x2; TE attached on the left of the page)
$ F
C W M * C
E T N E
X Y O O O O O H Z
Q
R
📊 Diagram (described): An Over front set to the tight end on the left of the page: the strong end outside the tight end, the 3-technique outside the guard on that side, the nose shaded to the other side of the center, the weak end outside the right-side tackle. Linebackers stack on the strong side and middle; the nickel is over the slot on the right. Two safeties are deep.
The tight end now shifts to the right side of the formation. Using the Sentinels' late-shift rule, describe exactly which defenders move and where, and what word Bell says. Then draw the post-shift front on paper.
B3. On film you see a nickel defender run with a jet-motion receiver all the way across the formation, and at the snap the two safeties stay deep. What call family does this suggest, what motion word would the Sentinels use for it, and what did the defense just tell the quarterback?
B4. On a different snap, the jet-motion receiver crosses the formation and nobody follows him; the linebackers and the nickel each shift a step toward the motion, and both safeties stay deep and level. Name the Sentinels' word for this adjustment and say what the quarterback cannot conclude from it.
B5. A defense shows two linebackers mugged in the A-gaps. The offense motions its back out to make the formation empty. At the snap, both linebackers drop: one to the middle hook, one out toward the flat; four linemen rush; a safety drops down to the hook/curl on the three-receiver side; the other safety goes to the deep middle. Name the Sentinels' check and its owner, and explain why the mug look stayed until the snap.
B6. You see a cornerback on the boundary side lift his hand and repeat the same signal the safety in front of him just made. Ten seconds later, the offense shifts and the safety makes a different signal, and the corner does not repeat it. What should the safety do with the time left, and what is the corner most likely to play if the ball is snapped right now?
B7. You are charting a defense from the end-zone view. On a third-and-7, the defense shows two linebackers mugged in the A-gaps. With about six seconds left on the play clock, the middle linebacker turns to his left and right, raises both flat hands, and pushes them toward the ground. Both linebackers stay in the A-gaps. At the snap, they both drop into coverage and only four rush. If this were the Sentinels, what check was made, and what in the picture tells you the defense wanted the quarterback to keep believing in the pressure?
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
C1. Make the call. ⭐⭐ Week 6 at Austin (the Game 1 road game). First-and-10, Outlaws ball at their own 35, first quarter, 0–0. Your radio has just failed — Bell signals to the sideline that he has nothing in his helmet. Play clock: 22. The Outlaws are in 11 personnel and breaking the huddle. What call does the defense play, how does it get it, and what do you do before the next snap?
Answer
With the radio out and the call not delivered, the defense plays the default — "Home" (Nickel, Over, Quarters, four-man rush) — unless the sideline signalers can deliver a different call in time; the signalers are the backup channel and every player should look to them. Bell calls "Home, Home," the safeties signal it to the corners, and the corners echo. Before the next snap, tell the equipment staff and the officials about the radio failure and confirm the backup green-dot arrangement under the current rules; for the rest of the series, lean on the signalers and wristbands, and keep calls to the ones everyone knows best. The point: the defense never plays without a call — it plays the default.
C2. Draw it. ⭐⭐ The Outlaws line up 3x1 with trips to the field and Jalen Ruffin in the backfield. The call is "Nickel, Over, Quarters." Draw the pre-snap picture with the signal path (who signals, who echoes, who tells whom), then draw the post-snap Lock assignments for all seven coverage players (Simmons, Brennan, Royce, Holloway, Vo, Bell, Ames).
Answer
Pre-snap: Royce (boundary safety) signals Lock; Holloway (field safety, trips side) echoes; each relays to his corner — Royce to Brennan, Holloway to Simmons; both corners echo. Bell may yell "Trips!" as information but doesn't make the coverage check. Post-snap: Brennan man on X (the single receiver); Royce leaves the backside and works to the middle, reading #3 (vertical = his man; otherwise deep middle help); Holloway plays the quarters read on #2; Simmons plays the deep outside quarter over #1; Vo plays the apex, curl-to-flat area on the trips side; Bell and Ames take the two hooks.
C3. Make the call. ⭐⭐⭐ Game 3, divisional playoff at Sacramento. Fourth quarter, the Outlaws ball, 2nd-and-8 at your 41, you lead 20–17. You've called "Nickel, Over, Dog Fire" (Ames blitzing). At 9 seconds on the play clock, Austin motions Ruffin out of the backfield to make the formation empty. What happens, and who says what?
Answer
Empty triggers "Echo" — owned by Bell. He yells "Echo!" with its signal; Ames and Vo echo. The Dog pressure is killed, the coverage becomes Buzz 3 with a four-man rush, and Bell drops into the low hole. Because Ames was showing blitz, he can stay in his pre-snap posture until the snap and then drop to the curl/flat on the two-receiver side, keeping the pressure picture in Vance's head. Royce doesn't need to make a separate coverage call, because Echo carries its coverage. (Remember Vance's numbers against five or more rushers in Owen's sample: 28 of 36, 9.4 yards per attempt, 4 TD, 0 INT. Leaving five rushers against five blockers with a quarterback who throws hot that well is the bet Echo is built to avoid.)
C4. Make the call. ⭐⭐⭐ Home game against the St. Louis Stallions. The Stallions are in 12 personnel (one back, two tight ends) and Tyler Haugen is at quarterback. You've called "Big, Over, Sky." The Stallions shift both tight ends from the right side to the left side at 13 seconds on the play clock, and then the fullback, Gus Mahler, motions to the left. How many re-calls does this create, who owns each, and what's the biggest communication risk on this snap?
Answer
At minimum two: (1) the strength re-call — Bell says "Ram" or "Lion" for the new strength, and the line holds while the front renames (Over becomes Under) and the linebackers re-declare; (2) any motion adjustment from the fullback's movement — a Bump or a Roll, depending on the coverage rules, owned by Bell for the linebackers and Royce for the safeties. Because Sky is a rotation coverage, the side the safety rotates to may need to be re-confirmed with the strength. The biggest risk: the defense is still executing the first adjustment when the second movement happens, and Haugen snaps on the second movement. The protection is rules tied to where players are at the snap, a front adjustment that needs only the two linebackers to move, and the default that a player who isn't sure plays the original call.
C5. Make the call. ⭐⭐⭐ At Oklahoma City against the Ospreys. They've gone no-huddle and are snapping the ball at about 28 seconds on the play clock. Tess calls "Tempo!" from the booth. You have nickel on the field; the Ospreys have 10 personnel (four receivers, one back). It's 2nd-and-5. Describe what call you give, how you give it, and what the players should not be trying to do.
Answer
Give one of the tempo call set — a one-word call that's sound from the personnel already on the field (nickel vs. 10 personnel is fine) and needs no checks beyond the automatic ones — for example "Home" or "Sky." Give it by the method that reaches all eleven fastest: one word on the radio to Bell plus one picture board or signal from the sideline. Players should not be trying to substitute, run complex stunts, or make multi-relay checks; tempo punishes any communication that needs more than one step. Bell repeats it, the safeties signal it, and the defense lines up and plays.
C6. Whose fault? ⭐⭐⭐ Game 2, at Sacramento. Third quarter, 1st-and-10 at the Outlaws' 30. Call: "Nickel, Over, Quarters." The Outlaws line up in 2x2, then run return motion: Mekhi Powers goes in motion from the right slot toward the left, stops just past the center, and comes back to the right. On the first movement, Bell yells "Bump" and the underneath defenders slide left. On the return, Bell yells "Bump" again and Ames and Bell slide back — but Kenny Vo, the nickel, stays where the first Bump put him. At the snap, Powers runs a quick slant from the right slot into the space Vo vacated and gains 14 yards. Using the Sentinels' rules, who broke a rule, which rule, and what's the fix?
Answer
Vo broke the motion rule: Bump applies to where receivers are at the snap, not to where they were when the first check was called. When Powers returned, the receiver count went back to 2x2, so the underneath defenders' spots went back with it. Vo stayed on the first Bump. The communication relay worked — Bell made both calls — so this is a player habit error, not a system bust, but it's one the system should anticipate. The fix: (1) teach Bump as a re-count ("every time he moves, count again"), not a direction; (2) rep return motion specifically in walk-throughs, since Petrakis uses it to test exactly this; and (3) because Vo is the hinge, make sure he isn't also hearing a Roll signal from Royce on that snap — if he is, the "Roll overrides Bump" rule governs.
C7. Draw it. ⭐⭐ Draw your own wristband panel for a high school defense with eight calls (four coverages with a four-man rush, four pressures). Use a numbering scheme where the first digit groups the calls by type. Then write a one-paragraph explanation of how the sideline tells the defense which panel is live and how often it changes.
Answer
Answers will vary. A sound panel groups four-man-rush coverages in one decade (for example 11–14) and pressures in another (21–24), so players can find the row fast and so a signal's first digit doesn't reveal the exact call to an observer who hasn't matched panels. A second panel lists the same eight calls under different numbers. The sideline indicates the live panel with one signal at the start of each series (or each quarter), and the live/dummy signaler rotation is set before kickoff. Check that every call on the band is something your players have repped and that none of the check words are on it.
Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. Vocabulary size. A first-year college coordinator wants 34 coverage words because his NFL mentor had that many. His players have 20 hours a week of countable practice and meeting time, and half of them are freshmen and sophomores. Write him a one-paragraph memo explaining what to cut and how to decide. Use the Sentinels' "one page" rule and the bust-to-explosive rate from Section 8.1.
D2. Who wears the green dot? Your Mike linebacker is the best communicator on the team but comes off the field in your dime package, which you play about 20% of snaps. Your free safety is on the field for every snap, is a solid communicator, and is 20 yards from the defensive line. Argue for one choice, and describe how you'd cover the weakness of that choice.
D3. Echo-rule costs. The echo rule means that when the backside safety doesn't echo, the defense plays the original call — sometimes a coverage that's weaker against the formation the offense just showed. Describe a situation where that cost is significant, and decide whether you'd keep the rule in that situation. Justify it with the logic of "a whole bad call vs. a split good call."
D4. Signal security at the high school level. You coach a high school defense with no radios. The opposing staff stands about 40 feet from your signaler. List three specific measures you'd take, rank them by cost to your players' learning time, and explain which one you'd install first.
D5. Player safety and the "Crack!" call. A safety running downhill toward the line can't see a wide receiver coming at him from the side to block. Explain how the "Crack!" alert protects that player, what the correct response technique is, and why you'd grade the corner who didn't yell it on film.
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (Chapters 4 and 8) Using the technique numbers from Chapter 4, write out the alignment of every Sentinels defensive lineman in "Over, Ram" against an 11-personnel formation with the tight end on the defense's right. Then write the alignment after a "Lion" re-call under the Sentinels' late-shift rule (linemen don't flip, linebackers do). What is the front called now, and which linemen are now on the strong side?
M2. (Chapters 5 and 8) In Chapter 5, Anchor C — the 45-yard run in Game 1 — came from Tavon Greer squeezing when he should have set the edge and Jordan Ames filling B instead of C. Suppose that on that snap, Austin had shifted the tight end just before the snap and the front had needed a strength re-call. Explain how a missed re-call could produce the same result — two defenders in the wrong gaps on the same side — even if both players played their assignments perfectly for the call they heard. What would the bust chart category be?
M3. (Chapters 6 and 8) Anchor D, the disguise interception: two-high pre-snap, Holloway rotates down, Royce spins to the deep middle — "Spin 3." List every communication relay that had to work for that disguise to hold on 3rd-and-9 with 2:41 left in a playoff game. Which single missed echo would have produced the classic Cover 2 hole Vance was expecting?
M4. (Chapters 7 and 8) From Chapter 7: the RPO puts a conflict defender in a run/pass bind. Write a pre-snap communication rule that tells the nickel, Kenny Vo, which responsibility is primary on a given snap, and identify who owns that call and who must echo it.
M5. (Chapters 1 and 8) In Chapter 1 you wrote a philosophy statement. Pick one of your non-negotiables and show how it should appear in your communication system — as a default call, a kill rule, a vocabulary limit, or an echo requirement.
M6. (Chapters 3 and 8) Personnel matching from Chapter 3 depends on the offense substituting. Explain why the communication timeline in Section 8.3 starts with Tess's personnel call, and what changes in the timeline when the offense keeps the same personnel and snaps quickly.
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. Find the green dot. Watch one full NFL game on broadcast or All-22 film. For the first 20 defensive snaps of one team, chart: (a) who appears to be relaying the call (pointing, signaling, turning to teammates); (b) how many seconds before the snap the defense is set; (c) whether any defender is still moving or signaling at the snap. Summarize what you learned about that defense's communication structure in one paragraph. Note any snaps that look like a communication bust (two defenders playing different coverages) and describe how you'd confirm it.
E2. Home vs. road. Pick one defense and watch one home game and one road game from the same season. On every third down, chart whether the defense's pre-snap communication looks primarily verbal or primarily visual (hand signals held above the shoulders, players turning to look at a relay). Compare. Are there differences in how early the defense sets, how many checks you can see, or how many snaps look disorganized? Be honest about how small your sample is.
E3. Rules research. Using the current NFL Rulebook and, if you coach at that level, the current NFHS or NCAA rules, write a one-page summary of the rules that govern defensive communication at your level: play clock lengths, coach-to-player communication devices (if any), substitution protections, and disconcerting signals. Note any rule that has changed in the last several seasons and how it would affect your Communication System.