Chapter 24 — Instructor Notes

What this chapter is for

Chapter 24 opens Part V and turns the book outward, from installing your own defense to preparing for one opponent. Its argument is in the hook: Tess's first Outlaws report was a 38-page binder with the most important number in it — 3rd-and-4 to 6, 3x1 trips: dig/flood to the trips side, 14 of 22 — buried on page twenty-three, "organized the way the data was organized. It was not organized the way a game is decided." By 1 a.m. Tuesday it was a front page of five items, each with a count, a sample size, and a decision.

Three ideas carry the chapter. First, a game plan answers three questions (§24.1): what do they like, what is their best weapon, and what will we make them do instead — and most bad plans never ask the third. Second, read a tendency honestly (§24.4): counts before percentages, compare to the base rate, ask what defense produced it, filter game script. Third, a plan has to survive the coordinator (§24.8): the front page said "never Cover 0," and Russ called it anyway on 3rd-and-8 in Week 6. The "never" list goes on the call sheet in red for that reason.

This is also the chapter that builds the 247-snap Outlaws sample that the capstone uses, so students should handle the numbers carefully.

Teaching objectives

By the end of the session a student should be able to:

  1. State the three questions every game plan answers, and identify which one a given scouting report fails to answer.
  2. Design a tag list and tag dictionary precise enough that two people tag the same snap the same way (and explain Owen's 25-snap blind agreement check).
  3. Grade a tendency with Owen's confidence ladder — under about 10 snaps is "a story," about 10–25 "a lean," about 25+ "a plan" — and against its base rate.
  4. Distinguish a tell from a tendency, using Gaines's reduced split (all 9 scissors came from 23 reduced-split snaps).
  5. Complete a weapon table row, including the "what we'll live with" column.
  6. Write a five-item front page and a "never" list of no more than three lines.
  7. Build a situation plan with a first and second call for each down-and-distance bucket.

Timing

In a 75-minute session: 10 minutes on the hook and §24.1. 15 minutes on §24.2 (sample, tags, definitions — and the "tagging what you expected" mistake). 20 minutes on §24.3–§24.4, centered on the third-down-by-distance table and the 🧩 Productive struggle (rank three tendencies). 15 minutes on §24.6, the weapon table and Quarters Lock vs. the trips dig. 15 minutes on §24.7's front page and the 📋 Make the call (3rd-and-5 from the Outlaws' 44, trips to the field).

In a 150-minute block: the above, plus 25 minutes on §24.5's four concepts drawn (trips dig, first-play RPO, 12 personnel run and play-action, jet sweep), 20 minutes on §24.8 (Week 6 "the report was right" and the Week 15 rebuild that produced Mug Cat Fire), and 15 minutes on the 📋 Whose fault? (the reduced-split tell coached backwards in Wednesday practice).

What to cut when you are behind: §24.5 goes to reading — students can study the diagrams on their own and every concept returns in later chapters. Second cut is §24.2's "who watches what." Do not cut §24.4 or the front page. Reading tendencies honestly is the transferable skill of the whole of Part V, and the front page is what the Project Checkpoint asks for.

Where students get stuck

More data = better report. Every student's first report is Tess's first binder. Diagnostic: give them the §24.3 tables and ten minutes to produce "the report." Count pages. Intervention: the hook's question — "Why is the most important number in this report on page twenty-three?" — then the 120-word front page. The rule: every item has a count, a sample size, and a decision. No decision, no item.

Percentages without counts. Diagnostic: the 🧩 in §24.4, especially item (c), "roughly doubled" on 16 snaps. Intervention: Owen's ladder. Then the base-rate move: dig/flood was 14 of 22 on 3rd-and-4 to 6 from trips, but showed up on only 22 of their other 108 called passes. The contrast with the base rate is what makes 14 of 22 meaningful.

Treating a tendency as an offensive mistake. Diagnostic: quiz item 13 (true/false: a tendency is a mistake by the OC). Intervention: the §24.4 🔍 — an offense is a system of plays built to work together, and every system has a center of gravity. Petrakis knows he's scouted; he has tendencies because his best plays are his best plays.

"Take away everything." Diagnostic: exercise D7 or D4 (bracket Gaines on every third down). Intervention: the §24.6 common mistake — a front page with nine "take it away" items takes away nothing, because each one costs a defender. The fifth column of the weapon table ("what we'll live with": Sutton vs. Brennan, Ruffin in the flat, long drives) is a choice, not a concession.

Reading a tell in the wrong direction. Diagnostic: the 📋 Whose fault? — Simmons sees Gaines's reduced split, bails for the scissors corner, and gives up a hitch. Intervention: the coaching point in quiz item 6. All 9 scissors came from a reduced split, but the reduced split appeared on 23 snaps. The tell narrows the menu; it doesn't call the play. Coached as "reduced split = scissors," it becomes a tell the offense can use.

Whiteboard / film-room activity

Build the front page live. Put the third-down-by-distance table on the board (55 snaps, 26 conversions; 4–6 was 26 snaps and 13 conversions; trips on 22 of the 26). Then draw the call it produces — Quarters Lock vs. 3x1, trips to the field:

PRE-SNAP: Nickel Over Quarters "Lock" vs. 3x1 trips (field right)

     F                                     $
C               W     M          *              C
            E   T   N   E
  X            O  O  O  O  O      Y    H       Z
                     Q  R

📊 Diagram (described): The Outlaws have three receivers to the right, the field side: the tight end flexed as #3, the slot as #2, and the flanker wide as #1. The split end is alone on the left, the boundary. The quarterback is in the shotgun with the back beside him on the trips side. The Sentinels show two safeties deep, the nickel over the slot area, the two linebackers inside, four linemen, and a corner over each outside receiver. On the Lock check, the boundary corner will play the lone receiver man-to-man, the boundary safety will move to the middle and read #3, and the field safety will read #2.

What to ask. "Who has the dig?" (Holloway drives on it if Powers breaks out, with Simmons on top; Royce in the middle reads Harlan as #3.) "Who is alone?" (Brennan on Sutton.) "Is that a mistake?" (No — it's line five of the front page.) "What's your second call if Sutton beats Brennan twice?" (Six, cloud to the boundary.)

What a strong answer sounds like: "The front page says the dig/flood comes on 14 of 22 here, against a base rate of about 1 in 5 elsewhere, so it's a plan, not a story. Lock takes it away with Royce on #3 and Holloway driving on the dig. I'm giving up Sutton's hitch at about 6.8 yards a catch on 3rd-and-5 — a coin flip at the sticks, and I'll tackle it. I'm not blitzing: 28 of 36 and 9.4 a throw."

Assessment notes

Assign: A-level definitions of tendency, tell, base rate; C-level make-the-call items (especially the trips 3rd-and-medium and C10, Echo or Stay); D1 (the fourth-quarter "make something happen" urge — a direct look at Russ's mistake), D2 (Gabe vs. Owen on the 6-of-17 play-action shot), D5 (garbage-time snaps: flag, don't delete), and M1 (Ch 6 + Ch 24, Vance's two four-man rows). E2, using nflverse/nflfastR play-by-play to test one team's tendency against its base rate, is the best analyst assignment in Part V.

Quiz: items 3, 4, 6, 9, 12, 16, and 19 are the core.

A strong Project Checkpoint has a tag list with one-line definitions, a tag dictionary (concept names, formation families, explosive-play definition) that would pass a blind agreement check, and an Outlaws report whose front page has five items or fewer, each with a count, sample size, and decision, plus a "never" list of three lines or fewer. The best submissions flag sample-hygiene issues the way Owen does (the 21-point fourth-quarter game; the one opponent in the sample that rotated like the Sentinels, 61 of the 247 snaps). Mark down reports that cite percentages without counts or that "take away" more than two things.

Any-level adaptation

High school staff: follow the chapter's 🏫 note — two or three games from an exchange service, eight to ten tag columns, done by you, an assistant, and a manager. The hash matters more: NFHS hashes divide the field into thirds, so hash tendencies are stronger. Case Study 2 (Pine Hollow vs. Dalton Creek's fullback trap, 7 of 8 on 3rd-and-1 to 3) is the high school version of this whole chapter.

College class: emphasize the staff division of labor in §24.1 and the Tuesday meeting in §24.6. Have groups play Russ, Owen, Gabe, and Tess building a front page under a time limit.

Analyst course: §24.2's tagging and agreement check plus §24.4's honesty rules are a full unit. Owen's blind re-tag (25/25 on play type, 23/25 on concept, both misses dig vs. deep cross) is a model of inter-rater reliability for students who have never heard the term.

Connections

Backward: Chapter 1 (the hierarchy that places the game plan between playbook and call); Chapter 7 (the RPO and motion weapons the report quantifies); Chapter 14 (Lock); Chapter 16 (the call that broke the plan).

Forward: Chapter 25 turns the front page into a call sheet and points the same method at your own defense. Appendix F holds the scouting forms; Appendix G reprints the full Outlaws packet for the capstone.