Chapter 27 Exercises — Red Zone Defense
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and research
All Sentinels, Outlaws, Stallions, and Ospreys players, plays, and numbers are fictional composites. Selected answers are in Appendix J.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. Define a red-zone trip and the red-zone touchdown rate allowed. Why is a red-zone trip that ends in a field goal worth about four points to the defense?
A2. Name the three field zones the Sentinels' call sheet uses inside the 20, give the yard lines for each, and say in one sentence what changes in each.
A3. What does "the end line is the lid" mean? Name one coverage whose midfield landmarks stop working inside the 10 and explain why.
A4. State the Sentinels' five red-zone coverage rules in one sentence each.
A5. What is the difference between a fade and a back-shoulder throw? Which of Gabe Lindqvist's fade rules answers the back-shoulder throw?
A6. Under NFL rules, where is the ball placed after defensive pass interference in the end zone? Why does Russ say a corner who grabs on a fade "gives the offense four more tries"?
A7. Explain the in-out rule. Why does assigning routes instead of receivers beat a rub?
A8. Why are spot-drop fire zones dangerous inside the 10? What do the Sentinels call instead?
A9. Define gap control as Big Lou teaches it on the goal line. What are his three cue words, and what does "lose forward" mean?
A10. What is the "worst-formation check," and why does every goal-line call need one?
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
B1. On end-zone film, inside the 10, you see both safeties standing at the back line of the end zone before the snap, and the linebackers drop about 10 yards at the snap. The offense completes a stick route to the tight end at the 2. Which red-zone rules did this defense violate? Which one cost the play?
B2. Pre-snap: the offense has a two-man stack to the right at the 4. The two defenders over the stack are side by side, both about four yards deep. At the snap, the front receiver runs a slant and the back receiver runs a flat route; the two defenders collide, and the flat route is caught untouched. Name the concept, name the alignment error, and describe the alignment that would have prevented it.
B3. Read the diagram and identify the call (front, coverage, and the red-zone rule it is following).
PRE-SNAP AT THE SAC 7, 2ND-AND-GOAL
======================== END LINE ===========================
F $
======================== GOAL LINE ==========================
C * W M C
E T N E
X H O O O O O Y Z
Q R
POST-SNAP: four rush; F and $ sit in the halves near the end line;
C, *, W, and C each run with one receiver; M runs with the back
and, when the back stays in to block, stands and watches the QB.
📊 Diagram (described): Before the snap, the Sentinels show two safeties in the end zone, corners and the nickel over the three wide receivers, and two linebackers off the ball, with four linemen down. After the snap, four linemen rush, both safeties sit in the two halves of the end zone near the end line, the corners, the nickel, and the Will each cover one receiver man-to-man, and the Mike covers the running back but, when the back stays in to block, stays put and watches the quarterback.
B4. You're watching a goal-line snap from the 1 against 22 personnel. Six defensive linemen line up in the gaps, not on the blockers; two linebackers stand two yards deep; a defensive back stands just outside each tight end. At the snap, the right tight end blocks down, and the defensive back outside him steps up and turns a bounce run back inside. What front is this, what is the defensive back's rule, and what does it resemble from Chapter 16?
B5. A corner is in press on a split end at the 5. The receiver releases outside, runs the fade, and at two yards deep in the end zone stops and turns back. The corner keeps running for two more steps and the receiver catches the ball. Which fade rule did the corner break? Which earlier rule probably caused it?
B6. On 3rd-and-goal at the 8, the defense shows seven players at the line. At the snap, four rush and seven drop. The quarterback throws a quick slant to the slot, and a defensive end who was at the line a second earlier is standing at the goal line in the slant's path. Name the pressure type and explain why it fits the low red zone.
B7. On the TV copy of a game, the offense reaches 1st-and-goal at the 7 and the defense substitutes: two defensive backs come off and a defensive lineman and a linebacker come on. The offense, which had three wide receivers on the field, answers by keeping the same eleven players on and lining up in a four-wide shotgun formation without huddling. What mistake is the defense at risk of making, which chapter rule does it violate, and what are the defense's options if it's caught in the wrong personnel?
B8. A broadcast graphic says a defense is "first in the league in red-zone defense" after six games, allowing touchdowns on 6 of 17 trips. What two questions would Owen Kessler ask before he believed that the defense is actually good in the red zone?
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
C1. Make the call ⭐⭐. Game 2, Week 15 (hypothetical snap). First-and-10 at the Sacramento 17. Austin is in 11 personnel, 3x1 trips right, Sutton alone left. Owen's red-zone sheet: in the four-game sample, 8 of Austin's 19 red-zone passes came from a bunch, stack, or tight split, and Sutton had 5 fade or back-shoulder targets. Choose a call from the red-zone box (11–20) and explain the red-zone rules your players will apply.
Answer
Home (Quarters with red-zone rules) — which checks to Quarters Lock against 3x1 trips is the starred call, and it fits. Against 3x1 trips, Lock puts Brennan in man on Sutton with Royce in the middle reading #3, so the fade side has a safety whose eyes are inside but who can help over the top as the end line closes in. The three-receiver side plays quarters with the end line as the lid. Rules: the deep defenders play from the end line forward; underneath defenders drop to the sticks (the 7) or the goal line, whichever comes first — on first-and-10 at the 17, that's the sticks; if Austin condenses into a bunch, the in-out rule turns on. A Spin 1 call is a reasonable alternative, but on first down in the upper red zone the job is to keep Austin out of goal-to-go without giving up a quick first-down throw, and Home handles both run and pass.
C2. Draw it ⭐⭐. Draw Nickel Over Spin 1 against Austin's 2x2 at the 3 (Sutton and Powers left, Harlan attached right, Gaines wide right, Ruffin in the gun). Show pre-snap alignment and post-snap assignments, including who owns Vance.
Answer
Pre-snap: two-high in the end zone, corners pressed on Sutton and Gaines, Vo over Powers, Ames and Bell off the ball, four linemen down. Post-snap: Holloway rotates down to play Harlan man-to-man, Royce spins to the middle of the end zone as the post, Bell drops to the rat, Ames takes Ruffin if he releases, Brennan has Sutton, Vo has Powers, Simmons has Gaines. Bell owns Vance ("Rat to QB" when Vance crosses the tackle box), and the ends rush with contain. Count it: 4 rushers + 5 man + post + rat = 11.
C3. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐. Week 11 at St. Louis (hypothetical snap). Third-and-goal at the Sacramento 6. Stallions in 21 personnel, I-formation, Fant attached right. Owen: inside the 10, the Stallions threw on 3rd-and-goal from 5+ yards on 4 of 5 tries, all off a run fake, and all to the tight end or fullback. Choose between Base Over Mac Fox Zero (Hug), Base Over Two, and Base Over Sky. Defend your choice.
Answer
Base Over Two is the strongest answer, with zero a defensible second. Run Chapter 16's grid: six yards to go is outside zero's best range (1–3), but the field is compressed and the Stallions' fullback gives a hug defender a likely seventh rusher, so zero isn't crazy. Two wins because of the scouting: every 3rd-and-goal pass from 5+ yards came off a run fake to the tight end or fullback. Two puts five defenders underneath whose keys are those players, not the backfield, with the goal line as their landmark and two safeties over the fades. Sky (Cover 3) is sound against the run but leaves the underneath defenders reading the backfield, which is exactly what the fake attacks. Write the keys into the call: Will on the fullback, Sam on Fant, and the ends' rule is "squeeze, then stay home" for the boot.
C4. Diagram it ⭐⭐⭐. Draw Heavy Goal Zero against 22 personnel with the split end on the right and Fant attached on the right, Strand attached on the left. Show every gap owner, every man assignment, and the force player on each side.
Answer
Six linemen in the C-to-C gaps. Bell and Ames on the two backs. Simmons pressed on the split end (now right). Holloway outside the left tight end (Strand) — man on him and D-gap/force on that side if he blocks. Brennan outside Fant on the right — man on Fant and D-gap/force if Fant blocks. On the right, Simmons's man is wide, so Brennan is the force player inside him. Ten run defenders vs. eight blockers. (Which safety goes to which side can flip with your strength call; say which rule you used.)
C5. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐. Week 9 at Oklahoma City (hypothetical snap). The Ospreys are in tempo, no huddle, 11 personnel, and have just gained 9 on first-and-10 from the Sacramento 15. It's 2nd-and-1 at the 6, and they're already at the line. You have nickel on the field and no time to substitute. Which tempo-board call do you make, and what red-zone rules change it?
Answer
From the tempo board (Home, Sky, Robber, Fire), Home is the right call: the red-zone rules turn it into a man-matched quarters coverage with the goal line as the underneath landmark. Not Fire: it's a fire zone, and fire zones are illegal inside the 10 under the red-zone pressure rules. Sky is acceptable against the run, but against Oduya's quick game a rotated-down safety leaves a fade side thin. On 2nd-and-1 the Ospreys may run; Home's run fits are your base fits. The real lesson: tempo calls need red-zone rules attached, because you won't have time to make a red-zone call.
C6. Make the call ⭐⭐. Divisional playoff (hypothetical snap). Fourth-and-goal at the 1. Austin brings on 13 personnel (Harlan, Brandt, and a third tight end) with Ruffin in the I behind Vance. What personnel and call do you send, and who owns the quarterback sneak?
Answer
Heavy (or Base if Heavy isn't available), Heavy Goal Zero, with Simmons on the third tight end. The six linemen own the interior gaps; the A-gap players (Big V and Fifita) are the sneak defenders, and their job is to get lower than the center and guards and create a pile. A linebacker (Bell) has Ruffin in man, but on a sneak his rule is to fill over the top of the pile and meet the ball at the line. The zero card allows zero against 13 personnel inside the 10. Have the worst-formation check ready if Austin shifts to spread.
C7. Whose fault? ⭐⭐⭐. Week 3 vs. St. Louis (hypothetical snap). Second-and-goal at the Sacramento 2. The Stallions are in 22 personnel; the call is Heavy Goal Zero. At the snap, Fifita, the right A-gap player, stands up out of his stance to look for the ball. The center and right guard double-team him and drive him two yards into the end zone. Mahler leads through the right A-gap at Ames, who fills and meets him at the goal line, but Day cuts behind Mahler into the space Fifita gave up and scores standing up. Bell, the backside linebacker, folded behind the pile but arrived after Day was in. Whose fault is it, and which rule was broken?
Answer
Fifita's. He broke Big Lou's gap-control rule: "Low. Through. Pile." By standing up, he gave the center and guard a high target, they combined on him, and he lost backward instead of forward. That's exactly what gap control is supposed to prevent: a lineman in a gap who gets under the pads can't be double-teamed without the offense leaving another gap uncovered. Ames did his job (he met the lead blocker at the goal line), and Bell's fold was correct; his timing would have been fine if the A-gap had become a pile instead of a hole. This is the first-contact chart in one play: the first defender to meet the runner did it in the end zone.
Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. Russ says "bend but don't break" is "only half a philosophy." Using Owen's caveat about the stability of red-zone defense, explain why a defense that plans to give up yards and stiffen in the red zone is betting on its least reliable number. Is there any team or situation for which bend-but-don't-break is the right plan anyway?
D2. Two Man gives Brennan a safety over Sutton's fade but leaves the middle of the field empty underneath, with the Mike spying the quarterback only if the back blocks. Spin 1 keeps a rat in the middle but leaves both corners alone on fades. Against Austin on the goal line, which risk would you rather take, and why? Use Owen's red-zone table.
D3. Goal-line periods are where football's worst contact habits show up. Design a weekly goal-line practice plan for an NFL team (or a high school team) that gives the defense enough reps to learn gap control while limiting full-contact reps. How many reps at what tempo, and what will you coach on every rep to keep heads out of the contact?
D4. The zero card allows Cover 0 on a two-point try from the 2 against Austin, because a try from the 2 is like fourth-and-2. Make the case for calling zero on that try, as strongly as you can. Then explain why Russ chose Two Man in the chapter's drill. What evidence would change his mind?
D5. Your best corner is your field corner, but the opponent's best fade receiver lines up into the boundary on almost every goal-line snap. Do you travel your best corner with him inside the 10, play Two Man so the boundary corner has help, or leave it alone? Weigh the communication cost of traveling a corner (substitution, alignment, the relay rule), the matchup gain, and what the offense learns when you do it.
D6. Petrakis is aggressive on fourth down. How should that change the way you defend third-and-goal at the 4? Is a stop that leaves fourth-and-goal at the 1 a win?
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (Ch 27 + Ch 26) Chapter 26 taught "defend the sticks." Write one paragraph explaining how red-zone Rule 3 ("the goal line is the sticks") is the same rule, and one example where the sticks and the goal line are different inside the 20. Which comes first, and what should the underneath defenders do?
M2. (Ch 27 + Ch 5) Count the gaps for each of these goal-line formations and say how many run defenders a 6-2 front with man coverage provides against each: (a) 22 personnel, I-formation, two attached tight ends; (b) 23 personnel with a wing; (c) 11 personnel, shotgun, running quarterback. Which one should never see your 6-2, and why?
M3. (Ch 27 + Ch 14 + Ch 15) The in-out rule (Chapter 14) and the banjo/"Switch!" rules (Chapter 15) are both combination rules. Describe one goal-line situation where you'd use each, and explain why both are better than pure man coverage against rubs.
M4. (Ch 27 + Ch 16) The Week 11 zero at the 3 and the Week 6 zero on 3rd-and-8 at midfield were both Cover 0. Use the "when allowed" grid from Chapter 16 to explain why one was a good call and the other wasn't. Which rows of the grid flip between midfield and the goal line?
M5. (Ch 27 + Ch 13) Rewrite one of the Sentinels' fire zones (Nickel Under Mac Dog Fire, for example) for the red zone (11–20) using the red-zone landmarks: where do the deep three align and how do they play, where do the underneath three drop, and what happens to the hot throw? Then explain why the same call is off the sheet inside the 10.
M6. (Ch 27 + Ch 25) Chapter 25 taught that every box on the call sheet needs a "NO" line. Write the "NO" line for each of the three red-zone boxes against an opponent of your choice, and give a one-sentence reason for each item.
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. Red-zone touchdown rate, honestly. Using public play-by-play data (for example, the nflverse / nflfastR play-by-play files), compute each NFL defense's red-zone touchdown rate allowed for two consecutive seasons. Define a trip carefully (a possession with at least one snap inside the 20) and write your definition down. Then compare: how well does a defense's rate in season one predict its rate in season two? Compare that with a per-play measure such as yards per play or success rate allowed. Write one paragraph on what you found and one on what you'd tell a head coach about the number.
E2. The fade, charted. Watch the red-zone snaps from three NFL games (All-22 or end-zone film if available). For every fade or back-shoulder throw, chart: the corner's alignment (press, off, leverage), whether he had safety help, whether he turned his head before the receiver's hands came up (the peek), and the result. Do your charted fades support Gabe's rule 3? Note your sample size and don't overclaim.
E3. Goal-line history. Find film or a detailed account of two famous goal-line plays: the final play of Super Bowl XXXIV (a receiver tackled short of the goal line on the last play of the game) and the goal-line interception at the end of Super Bowl XLIX. For each, describe the defensive alignment you can see, the offensive concept, and which of this chapter's rules the defense followed. Be careful to separate what you can see on film from what has been reported about the play.