Chapter 4 Exercises — Defensive Fronts
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and independent film study
Work these with a pencil and a blank sheet of paper. Draw every front you're asked about — defense on top, offense on the bottom, ball in the middle — using the notation from the chapter. Selected answers are in Appendix J; short answers to Part C appear here in <details> blocks.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. Define a defensive front in one sentence that does not use the words "4-3" or "3-4." Then list the three classic questions a front answers and the fourth question the modern game added.
A2. Write the technique numbers in order from the center out to the tight end on one side, and say for each whether it is head-up, an outside shade, or an inside shade. Then explain the 6/7 swap in one sentence and what a staff should do about it.
A3. Name the four gaps on one side of an offense that has an attached tight end, and say exactly where each one is.
A4. How many gaps are along the line of scrimmage in each case? (a) Five linemen, no tight end. (b) Five linemen and one attached tight end. (c) Five linemen and two attached tight ends. (d) Case (b) plus a quarterback who is a real run threat on a read-option. Explain (d) using the term "plus-one."
A5. What is an uncovered offensive lineman, and why does a defensive coordinator care where the uncovered linemen are? Use the word "bubble" in your answer.
A6. Contrast one-gap and two-gap defensive line play in four respects: alignment, first movement, body type that thrives, and what each gives the defense.
A7. In the 4-3 Over and the 4-3 Under (strength to the tight end), where is the 3-technique, where is the 1-technique, and which guard is uncovered?
A8. Give the two different definitions of "odd front" and "even front" you'll hear in coaching rooms. Which definition matters most to an offensive line coach, and why?
A9. Why does a 3-4 front create protection problems for an offense even when it rushes only four players?
A10. Explain in two or three sentences why most NFL defenses now play a nickel front on the majority of their snaps, and why that makes "4-3 vs. 3-4" a weak description of a defense. Hedge any league-wide number honestly.
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
For each, identify the front (and the strength, if it applies) from the pre-snap description, then answer the follow-up.
B1. Pre-snap: the tight end is attached on the right. A defensive tackle is on the right guard's outside shoulder. Another is shaded on the center toward the left. Both ends are on the outside shoulders of the tackles. One linebacker is outside the tight end, off the ball; two are off the ball inside. Identify the front. Which offensive lineman is uncovered?
B2. Pre-snap: tight end attached on the right. A linebacker is standing on the line just outside the tight end. A defensive end is on the right tackle's outside shoulder; a tackle is shaded on the center toward the right; another tackle is on the left guard's outside shoulder; an end is outside the left tackle. Identify the front. Which linebacker has to handle the uncovered guard?
B3. Look at this alignment and name the front.
PRE-SNAP
$ F
C * M C
E T N T E
X O O O O O Y
H Z
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): Against 11 personnel with the tight end attached on the right, the defense has five players on the line: an edge outside the left tackle, a lineman on the left tackle's inside shoulder, a nose head-up on the center, a lineman on the right tackle's inside shoulder, and an edge just outside the tight end. One linebacker is off the ball toward the tight end side; a nickel is over the left slot; two safeties are deep.
Which interior offensive linemen are covered? Which run does this front invite?
B4. Pre-snap: three down linemen — a nose head-up on the center and two linemen in 5-techniques — with two outside linebackers on the edges and two inside linebackers off the ball over the guards. At the snap, all three linemen stand up blockers and don't penetrate; the inside linebackers wait, then fill opposite sides. Name the front and the style of line play. What does that style free up?
B5. Pre-snap against a 21-personnel I formation on 3rd-and-1: a nose head-up on the center, two tackles on the outside shoulders of both guards, ends outside the tackles, a linebacker on the line outside the tight end, two linebackers off the ball over the A gaps, and the strong safety down. Name the front. What can't the center and guards do on the snap, and what is the offense's best answer?
B6. All-22, third-and-9 against a spread team: both edge rushers are aligned two full yards outside the offensive tackles. A tackle is on a guard's outside shoulder; another is shaded on the center. Seven defenders are standing back. At the snap, the four rushers take four separate lanes and nobody crosses. Name the front family and the principle the rush is demonstrating.
B8. Freeze-frame description, end-zone camera: the defense has a lineman head-up on the center, linemen on the outside shoulders of both guards, and two edge players outside the tackles. Behind them, the two inside linebackers are at about four yards, each directly behind an A gap. The offense is in 21 personnel on 4th-and-1. Name the interior picture. Which offensive linemen are uncovered? Where would you expect the offense to attack, and with what kind of play?
B7. Before the snap, the Outlaws motion Harlan from the right side to the left. The Sentinels' four defensive linemen don't move. Bell shouts "Under, Under," and the two linebackers trade spots. What front were the Sentinels in before the motion? Why didn't the linemen move?
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
C1. Draw it. The Outlaws line up in 11 personnel, 2x2, Harlan attached on the left (the boundary). The Sentinels' strength rule is "front to the attached tight end." The call is nickel Over. Draw the front pre-snap with every Sentinels front player labeled, then write each player's gap. Identify the bubble and who lives behind it.
Answer
Strength is to the left (Harlan). Weller is the strong end in a 5 on the left tackle — left C. Coleman is the 3-technique on the left guard's outside shoulder — left B. Bell is off the ball over the left A gap — left A. Big V is a 1-technique shaded on the center to the right — right A. Ames is off the ball over the right B gap — right B. Rollins is a 5 or wide 5 outside the right tackle — right C. The left D gap (outside Harlan) belongs to the rotating safety or another outside fitter. The right guard is uncovered — the bubble — and Ames is behind it.
C2. Make the call. Week 11 against the St. Louis Stallions. 2nd-and-2 at midfield. The Stallions come out in 21 personnel, I formation, tight end on the right. Owen's note: on 2nd-and-short from 21 personnel, the Stallions ran an isolation or power play on 11 of 14 snaps in his sample, nearly all to the tight-end side. Choose a front and strength, and name the risk you're accepting.
Answer
A strong answer is Bear (3-0-3) from base personnel with the strong safety down, or an Under to the tight end with the strong safety rolled down as the eighth defender. Bear covers the center and both guards, so the isolation has no free climber to help the fullback, and power's down blocks have no easy angles; it fits a team that runs inside on short yardage. The risk is play-action and boots: the Stallions' quarterback, Tyler Haugen, is lethal on play-action, and an eight-man front with one deep safety leaves the tight end and a deep crosser in one-on-one situations. Name who has the tight end on a boot before you call it. (Fourteen snaps is a small sample — a strong tendency, not a certainty.)
C3. Draw it. Draw a 4-3 Under against 21 personnel (tight end right) pre-snap and post-snap, with each front defender's gap. Then redraw it as a 3-4 "Under look" with 3-4 personnel and show which position names change and which alignments don't.
Answer
4-3 Under: weak end 5 on left tackle (left C), 3-technique on left guard (left B), Will over left A (left A), nose shaded on the center to the right (right A), Mike over right B (right B), strong end 5 on right tackle (right C), Sam on the line in a 9 on the tight end (D), strong safety as the alley player. In the 3-4 version, the Sam becomes the strong outside linebacker (same spot), the weak end becomes a weak outside linebacker with his hand down or standing (same spot), the 3-technique becomes a defensive end (same spot, sometimes a 4i), and the two off-ball linebackers become inside linebackers. Every alignment is identical; only the names change.
C4. Make the call. Oklahoma City Ospreys, 3rd-and-7, their own 40. They're in 11 personnel with the tight end detached into the slot (no attached tight end), Oduya in the shotgun. He gets the ball out in about 2.4 seconds. You want to rush four. Choose the front alignment and explain your rush lanes.
Answer
Over Wide: edges in wide-9 alignments for a running start; a 3-technique on a guard; a 1-technique nose. Rush lanes: both edges rush outside the tackles and contain; the nose takes his A gap; the 3-technique takes his B gap; nobody crosses another rusher's lane. Against a 2.4-second thrower, sacks are unlikely, so the purpose is to compress time and take away escape lanes so Oduya has to throw on rhythm into coverage. With no attached tight end there are only six gaps, so a draw is the run risk — the linebackers must keep their eyes on the back before they drop.
C5. Make the call. You are a high school defensive coordinator. The ball is on the left hash (NFHS hashes divide the field into thirds). Your opponent is in a two-back set with the tight end to the boundary, and your scout report says it runs a sweep to the wide side on 60 percent of its first-down snaps. Your rule last week was "front to the tight end." What do you change, and why?
Answer
Set the front to the field, not the tight end, on first down from the hash. The boundary is only about seventeen yards wide at the high school level, so the sideline helps you there; the field side is over thirty-five yards wide and is where the sweep goes. Put your best edge player and your 3-technique (or your strongest one-gap defender) to the field side, and have the boundary-side front squeeze inside with the sideline as an extra defender. Trade-off: a tight end into the short side now faces a lighter front, so check that your boundary corner or safety can fit the D gap on a run into the boundary.
Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. Your best interior player is a 335-pound nose who can stalemate a double team but has almost no pass rush. Your second-best is a 285-pound tackle with explosive get-off. Design a base front and explain who plays which technique, in which style (one-gap or two-gap), and what you're giving up.
D2. A coordinator says, "We play Tite because it stops inside zone." Write the follow-up questions you'd ask in the staff meeting before you agreed. Consider edge personnel, the safeties, the opponent's outside run game, and third down.
D3. Your strength rule is "front to the field" and has been all season. Your self-scout shows the opponent has figured it out: they align their tight end into the boundary and run duo at him. Weigh three options — (a) switch to "front to the tight end," (b) mix strength calls by game plan, (c) keep the rule and fix it with a safety rotation — in terms of teaching load, predictability, and risk.
D4. Player safety. A young defensive line coach wants to make two-gap play "tougher" by running full-speed, full-contact double-team drills every day in-season. Write the case for a different plan: what technique you'd emphasize, how you'd progress the drill, and how you'd manage contact load. Reference the hand-placement and head-out-of-contact points from the chapter.
D5. Grant Weller is your strong edge. He's 260 pounds, sets a strong edge, and can drop into coverage. Your opponent plays 12 personnel 20 percent of the time and 11 personnel 68 percent of the time. When should Weller be on the line in a 9 on the tight end, when should he be a 5-technique, and when should he be standing up off the edge? Build a short decision table.
Answer sketches for D1, D3, and D5
D1. Build around the nose as a two-gapper in a 0 or a shaded 1 — he's the player who can stalemate the center-guard double, which frees a linebacker. Put the 285-pound tackle in a one-gap 3-technique, where his get-off attacks the guard in the B gap and gives you an interior pass rush. A nickel Over or an Under fits this pair; Tite fits only if you have a second big body for the other 4i. What you give up: the nose won't collapse the pocket on third down, so your third-down front may need a different interior pair (or a mug look) to keep the rush honest.
D3. (a) "Front to the tight end" is a small teaching change and fixes the specific problem, but it's still one rule an offense can scout — they'll start putting the tight end where your 3-technique doesn't want to be. (b) Mixing strength by game plan is the least predictable but the heaviest teaching load: every week the players must learn which rule applies, and every busted echo is a run through an empty gap. (c) Keeping the rule and rotating a safety to the tight end side is the lightest teaching change for the front, but it changes your coverage tendencies and still hands the offense the double teams they want. A sound answer usually chooses (a) as the new default and keeps (b) as a weekly option for one or two calls, practiced in a motion period.
D5. A reasonable table: against 12 personnel or 21 personnel on early downs, Weller plays on the line in a 9 on the tight end (Under), because the edge must be reach-proof. Against 11 personnel with an attached tight end on early downs, he plays a 5 in Over to the tight end, with the safety rotation owning the D gap. Against 11 personnel with no attached tight end, or on passing downs, he stands up as a wide edge — ready to rush from a wide 9 or drop into the flat on a simulated pressure. The deciding questions are always the same: is there an attached tight end on his side, and how likely is a run?
D6. Your nickel Over has given up three explosive runs in two weeks, all through the bubble over the uncovered guard. Your linebackers coach wants to move to the Under; your line coach wants to slant the line into the bubble at the snap; your analytics director points out that three runs is a tiny sample. Write the staff-meeting decision in one paragraph: what you'd change, what you'd keep, and what evidence would change your mind.
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (Chapters 3 and 4) The Outlaws switch from 11 personnel to 12 personnel. Explain the personnel change you'd make (Chapter 3's matching principle) and then the front change, including how the honest gap count changes with the second tight end.
M2. (Chapters 1 and 4) Russ's philosophy is "coverage-first, pressure on purpose." Explain how that philosophy shows up in his choice of a one-gap nickel Over as the default front and Tite as his favorite first-down change-up. Then describe how a pressure-first philosophy might choose differently.
M3. (Chapters 2 and 4) For each front, name the era and offensive problem it is most associated with answering: the 4-3 (Landry), the 46/Bear (Ryan), the two-gap 3-4, and the Tite/Mint front of the two-high era. Keep facts to the well-documented level and hedge dates you aren't sure of.
M4. (Chapter 4 previewing Chapter 5) In the hook's Game 1 snap, list every front defender and his gap. Then explain why the "short" gap in a nickel front against an attached tight end is a front decision before it is a run-fit decision.
M5. (Chapters 3, 4, and the call structure previewed for Chapter 8) Write the full call for the Week 15 fix in the order front–coverage, and describe who on the field makes the strength call and who echoes it. Why does the echo matter more on a Y-trade than on a static formation?
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. Front chart. Pick one NFL defense and one full game of All-22 or end-zone film. For every first- and second-down snap, chart: offensive personnel, the defense's front (use the chapter's names: Over, Under, Tite, Bear, Over Wide, other), the strength (to the tight end, field, or passing strength), and the run play's direction relative to the 3-technique. At the end, calculate what share of runs went toward the 1-technique side and what share toward the 3-technique side. Write three sentences about what you'd do as the offensive coordinator, and three as the defensive coordinator. Report your sample size honestly.
E2. Strength rule detective. Using the same game or a different one, try to reverse-engineer the defense's strength rule. Look for snaps with the tight end into the boundary, snaps with no attached tight end, and snaps with tight-end motion. Did the front follow the tight end, the field, or the passing strength? Did the defensive line move on motion, or did only the linebackers adjust? Write the rule as you think their playbook states it, then list the snaps that don't fit it.
E3. Historical comparison. Watch publicly available footage of the 1985 Chicago Bears' defense and a modern two-high defense from the 2019–2024 period. Without relying on any specific statistic you can't verify, describe how many players each puts near the line on early downs, how the interior linemen align, and how each answers the dominant offense of its time. Two to three paragraphs.