Case Study 27.1 — Nine Yards, Three Points: A Goal-to-Go Series at St. Louis

A Sentinels red-zone stop that worked, told by Russ Kimbrough. All teams, players, and plays are fictional composites.


Setup

The game. Week 11, at the St. Louis Stallions, our division rival. We won it 17–13. The Stallions are the purest run-and-play-action offense on our schedule: wide zone, bootlegs, 12 and 21 personnel, a fullback named Gus Mahler who likes contact, a tailback named Antoine Day who runs patiently behind it, and a quarterback, Tyler Haugen, who is precise in the pocket and lethal on play-action.

The situation. Second quarter. A 14-yard play-action completion to their tight end, Reggie Fant, gave the Stallions 1st-and-goal at our 9. In Chapter 16 you saw the last snap of this series: third-and-goal at the 3, Base Over Mac Fox Zero with a hug, Haugen's bootleg thrown away because DeShawn Rollins stayed home. This case study is the whole series, because the third-down call only worked because of what happened on first and second down.

What the scouting said. Owen Kessler's notes on the Stallions in the red zone, from their previous four games:

Item Value
Red-zone snaps 29
Runs 18 (outside zone toward the tight end on 11)
Play-action passes 9 of 11 passes
Bootleg / naked off outside zone 5 of the 9 play-action passes
Most common target Tight ends (6 of 11 targets), mostly to the flat and on drags
Personnel inside the 10 12 or 21 on 15 of 16 snaps

Owen's comment: "They don't throw fades. They throw behind your eyes. Every red-zone pass is built on a run fake, and the target is whoever your run fit forgot."

Our plan. Base personnel against 21 and against 12 with both tight ends attached inside the 5; big nickel against 12 above the 5. Red-zone rules on. Rollins's rule for the whole game: "squeeze, then stay home." And one sentence I wrote at the top of the red-zone box: Every eye on your key. The fake is the play.


What happens — snap by snap

Snap 1: 1st-and-goal at the 9 — Base Over Sky

The Stallions stayed in 21 personnel: Mahler and Day in an I-formation, Fant attached on the right, two wide receivers. We were in base: Tavon Greer and DeShawn Rollins at end, Big V Tuipulotu and Rashad Coleman inside, Grant Weller at Sam, Marcus Bell and Jordan Ames at linebacker, and the four DBs. The call was Base Over Sky: Cover 3 with Tre Holloway rotating down to the strong side as the force player, with red-zone landmarks. Royce played the middle of the end zone, not a deep middle third.

Outside zone right, toward Fant. Fant reached for Weller, Weller stretched with him and kept his outside arm free, and Holloway, rotated down at about six yards, came downhill as the force player outside Weller. Day pressed the edge, saw Holloway's helmet outside him, and cut back into the B-gap. Bell was there.

Day for 4. Second-and-goal at the 5.

Nobody made a highlight play. Weller set the edge without getting reached, Holloway forced the ball back inside, and Bell filled where the cutback goes. Three defenders, three jobs, four yards.

Snap 2: 2nd-and-goal at the 5 — Base Over Two

The Stallions subbed: Mahler off, a second tight end, Colby Strand, on. Twelve personnel, both tight ends attached, Day alone in the backfield, Haugen under center. At the 5, with both tight ends attached, our match rule says base. The call was Base Over Two: Cover 2 with the red-zone rules on. The corners squat at the goal line, the safeties play halves of the end zone from the end line forward, and five defenders play underneath with the goal line as their landmark.

PRE-SNAP: WEEK 11 AT ST. LOUIS, Q2, 2ND-AND-GOAL AT THE SAC 5
"BASE OVER TWO" (RED-ZONE RULES) vs. 12 PERSONNEL

  ======================== END LINE ===========================
            F                                      $
  ======================== GOAL LINE ==========================
                   W          M          S
   C          E      T     N       E                    C
   X        Y    O    O    O    O    O    U             Z
                           Q
                           R

📊 Diagram (described): Second-and-goal at the Sentinels' 5. The Stallions have a split end wide left, Fant attached on the left end of the line, Strand attached on the right end, a flanker wide right, Haugen under center, and Day deep behind him. The Sentinels are in base: both safeties at the back of the end zone, the corners about three yards off the wide receivers, four linemen (Greer, Coleman, Big V, and Rollins from left to right), and three linebackers — Ames on the left, Bell in the middle, Weller on the right over the second tight end. Eleven defenders.

Haugen faked outside zone to Day going right. The whole Stallions line stepped right. Fant blocked down on Greer for one count, then slipped off the block and leaked into the left flat, behind the flow, which is exactly where Owen said the ball would go. At midfield that's a 15-yard play: the linebackers flow with the fake and the tight end catches it in open grass. At our 5, there was no open grass.

POST-SNAP: PLAY-ACTION, FANT LEAKS TO THE FLAT

  ======================== END LINE ===========================
            F (half: over X's fade)               $ (half)
     X ^
  ===  |================== GOAL LINE ==========================
     C (squats at the goal line)
          Y --> flat   <-- W (eyes on Y, not the fake;
                                 drives, tackles at the 3)
                               M (hook)   S (walls U)   C on Z
              E      T     N       E
              vv     vv    vv      vv
                 O    O    O    O    O    U
                           Q  fakes --> R

📊 Diagram (described): Haugen fakes the handoff to Day going right and the Stallions' line blocks to the right. On the left, the split end runs a fade, with Royce over the top from his half of the end zone and Brennan squatting at the goal line underneath. Fant blocks Greer for a count, then releases into the left flat. Ames, who never took a step toward the fake because his eyes were on Fant, drives down from the goal line and tackles him at the 3. Bell sits in the middle hook, Weller walls Strand on the right, Simmons is on the flanker, and Holloway has the right half of the end zone. Four linemen rush.

Jordan Ames had the left curl-to-flat in Two. His key was Fant, not the backfield. He saw Fant's block soften, heard Dre's voice in his head — the fake is the play — and didn't take a single step toward Day. Haugen threw the flat. Ames was already coming downhill from the goal line, and he tackled Fant at the 3.

Fant for 2. Third-and-goal at the 3.

Snap 3: 3rd-and-goal at the 3 — Base Over Mac Fox Zero (hug)

You know this one from Chapter 16. Same 12 personnel. Six rushers including Bell (Mac) and Holloway (Fox), man on all five eligible receivers, Ames on Day with the hug rule. Haugen faked to Day and booted right. Day blocked, so Ames hugged and became the seventh rusher. Rollins never chased the fake and was waiting for Haugen at the edge. Every receiver had a man. Haugen threw it out of the back of the end zone.

Incomplete. The Stallions kicked a 20-yard field goal.

Nine yards, three snaps, three points. Day ran into the force player. Fant ran into the linebacker whose eyes were on him. Haugen ran into the defensive end who stayed home.


Analysis

Why it worked: the series, not the snap. Each of the three calls answered a different Stallions weapon, and each one also set up the next.

Snap Their weapon Our answer The red-zone rule that mattered
1st-and-goal at the 9 Outside zone to the tight end Base Over Sky: force player rotated down, edge set, Bell on the cutback Every gap owned; the end line let Royce play shallow in the middle
2nd-and-goal at the 5 Play-action to the leaking tight end Base Over Two: five underneath with eyes on keys, the goal line as their landmark The goal line is the sticks; zone eyes, man feet
3rd-and-goal at the 3 Bootleg off the run fake Zero with a hug; Rollins stays home The end line kills zero's deep-ball risk; man defenders' eyes can't be faked

The first-down run mattered most. Owen's split from the chapter says trips that reach goal-to-go become touchdowns about two-thirds of the time. This trip had already reached goal-to-go, so the job was the next-best thing: make second and third down long enough that the Stallions had to throw. Four yards on first down left 2nd-and-goal at the 5, not the 2. From the 2, the Stallions would have run it twice with Mahler and Day. From the 5, they had to fake the run and throw, and play-action against eyes that aren't fooled is just a slow pass.

Eyes beat fakes. Play-action works because defenders' eyes go to the backfield. Two of these three calls attacked that directly. In Two, Ames's key was the tight end, not the ball. In zero, every defender's key was his man. The Stallions' whole red-zone offense was built on the defense looking at the wrong thing.

What we gave up, honestly. Base Over Two left the middle of the field underneath to Bell alone. If Haugen had kept the ball on a naked bootleg left instead of throwing the flat, Greer would have been the only defender at that edge, and Greer had just spent a count being blocked by Fant. He might not have recovered in time. The Stallions didn't call it. Next time, they might.


Discussion questions

  1. Why was a 4-yard run on first-and-goal from the 9 a good outcome for the defense, when a 4-yard run on first-and-10 at midfield is roughly average for the offense?
  2. On second down, Ames's key was the tight end, not the backfield. What would have happened if his key had been the running back, as it often is on early downs? Use the term "conflict" from Chapter 7.
  3. Base Over Two asked the corners to squat at the goal line. Which Stallions route would have beaten that squat, and why didn't the Stallions call it?
  4. All three calls came from base personnel. Would big nickel (a third safety for a linebacker) have been better on the second-down snap? Defend your answer with Owen's scouting table.
  5. The third-down call depended on Rollins staying home. Which first- or second-down rep in this series reinforced that rule, and which did not?

Your turn

Pick an opponent you know (or use the Outlaws from Appendix G). Write a three-call goal-to-go series for 1st-and-goal at the 8: one call for each down, assuming the offense gains 3 yards on first down and 2 on second. For each call, name the offense's weapon it answers, the red-zone rule it depends on, and what it gives up. Then write one sentence explaining how your first-down call sets up your third-down call.