Chapter 23 — Instructor Notes
What this chapter is for
Chapter 23 closes Part IV by finishing the play every earlier chapter set up. Its argument is arithmetic before it is technique: §23.1 shows what one miss costs on one snap, and Owen's chart in §23.8 shows what a staff can change in a year — from 14.0% missed tackles in Russ's first Sentinels season (149 of 1,066) to 9.0% last season (91 of 1,012), with angle misses falling from 41 to 19 while "runner won" barely moved (20 to 18). The improvement came from what the staff taught.
The second argument is the one that matters most to anyone teaching this chapter to real coaches: the Sentinels tackled better while tackling live less. The chapter separates the tackle into phases (approach, breakdown, strike, wrap, finish), teaches each at the lowest contact level that can teach it, and treats head-out technique, contact limits, and concussion response as one subject. That is the frame to put on the first slide.
The hook — Gabe, two cones, Tre Holloway, and forty reps of "Track" in the week after Game 1 — is about angles, not toughness. Tre's 45-yard-run error is charted as one missed tackle, category "angle." "He missed the tackle on his third step."
Teaching objectives
By the end of the session a student should be able to:
- Name and sequence the five phases of a tackle and give a coaching cue for each, using the head-out, shoulder-in model ("eyes up, head out, shoulder in").
- Distinguish Hawk from Track and say when each applies.
- Choose an aiming point for a pursuit angle from 5, 8, and 12 yards, and explain why a deeper start requires a deeper aim (§23.3 and its 🔍).
- Describe a sequenced gang tackle (first man stops, second attacks the ball, third finishes) and distinguish it from piling on.
- Match each tackle phase to the lowest practice tempo that teaches it (Air, Tag, Bags, Thud, Live).
- State the concussion-response rule for any level — remove on suspicion, medical clearance before return, "when in doubt, sit them out" — and who makes the return decision (a medical professional, never the coach).
- Chart tackles by category and turn a weekly chart into a practice decision.
Timing
In a 75-minute session: 10 minutes on §23.1 (the arithmetic of a miss). 20 minutes on §23.2 (the anatomy, with both 🩺 callouts — head-first contact and the swivel hip-drop). 15 minutes on §23.3 pursuit geometry, opening with its 🧩 Productive struggle before you show the answer. 15 minutes on §23.7 (the tempo table and the concussion callout — both required). 15 minutes on §23.8, Owen's chart and the charting 🧩.
In a 150-minute block: the above, plus 15 minutes on §23.4 team pursuit and gang tackling (Game 2's Q4 cutback at the Austin 31: Ames, Bell, Vo, +2), 15 minutes on §23.5 open-field tackling (the Week 9 Ospreys bubble, Simmons forcing and Holloway's Track tackle for +3) and the 📋 Whose fault? (Week 11 at St. Louis, Ames lunges, Day gains 19), 10 minutes on §23.6 ball attacks, and 25 minutes on the 📋 Make the call practice plan (Week 15 short week, Thursday and Friday only).
What to cut when you are behind: §23.6 (strips and punches) goes to reading; Chapter 35 develops the takeaway culture. Then §23.5's "snap where it worked." Do not cut the 🩺 material in §23.2 and §23.7, and do not cut the concussion callout. If you only have 30 minutes, teach the five phases, the head-out model, the tempo table, and the concussion rule — in that order.
Player-safety teaching guidance (read before you teach this chapter)
This is the chapter where an instructor's framing matters most, because some students — especially former players and young coaches — arrive with habits from an older way of teaching. Hold these lines:
- Teach the technique and the rule together. The chapter's 🩺 callout in §23.2 is explicit: the crown of the helmet is never the point of contact, and a tackler never lowers his head to initiate contact. NFL, NCAA (targeting, with ejection), and NFHS (targeting and spearing) rules all penalize it in some form. Do not quote a specific current penalty or definition from memory; have students look up the current rulebook for their level (exercise E3 is built for this).
- Retire the old phrase out loud. Russ retired "head across the bow." The Sentinels' phrase is "head out, shoulder in." If a student uses the old cue in a drill write-up, correct it every time.
- Do not show big hits as models. Use the chapter's own snaps — they are deliberately undramatic. The best tackle in the chapter is a +2 cutback stop made by three players.
- Distinguish a roll finish from a hip-drop on film, not by demonstration on a live partner. The difference is whether the tackler lands beside the runner or on his legs.
- Contact limits are the frame, not an obstacle. The §23.7 🩺 callout says design inside your limits, "not around them." Every practice plan students submit must state their level's current limits, looked up, not guessed.
- Concussion response is non-negotiable and not a coaching judgment. Case Study 2 is the chapter's most important teaching tool here: Russ, as a young Pine Hollow coach, left Danny Cobb in the game after a head-first tackle and visible concussion signs, and Cobb missed the rest of the season. Russ calls it a culture failure — his. Teach it as a staff failure to recognize and remove, not as bad luck.
- If you run any physical drills in a clinic or class, stay at Air or Tag tempo, have no live contact, and follow your institution's rules. This course teaches coaches to design tackling practice; it does not require anyone to tackle.
Where students get stuck
"Good tacklers are tough; bad ones aren't." Diagnostic: ask the room why Tre missed Ruffin. Expect "he didn't want it enough" or "he dove." Intervention: the hook and §23.3. Tre's want-to was fine; his aiming point was wrong from his first step. Owen charts it "angle." Then show the category table: angle was the biggest category, and the biggest drop.
"More live tackling makes better tacklers." Diagnostic: exercise D1, the veteran assistant's argument. Intervention: the tempo table plus the chart — the Sentinels went from 14% to 9% while tackling live less. Exhausted players taking each other to the ground "learn to survive collisions, not to place their feet." Be careful to present the Sentinels' numbers as a single team's charted trend, which is how Owen presents them ("Our trend is real; the decimal points aren't").
Breaking down by stopping. Diagnostic: §23.2's "stopped breakdown" common mistake; quiz item 8. Intervention: a breakdown shortens and widens the steps while the feet keep moving. The 31-yard hitch against the Ospreys in Russ's second season is the cautionary example.
Confusing gang tackling with piling on. Diagnostic: exercise A6. Intervention: the §23.4 🩺 callout — once the runner is down or forward progress is stopped, contact ends. The sequence (stop, attack the ball, finish) is about arrival order, not extra hits.
Treating "15%" as a fact. Diagnostic: quiz item 12. Intervention: the chapter frames it as Russ's rule of thumb, not a cited statistic, and §23.8's 📈 callout explains why public services' numbers differ by definition.
Whiteboard / film-room activity
The pursuit-geometry board. Draw the strip from §23.3 as two players only:
PURSUIT ANGLE -- flat path vs. Track path (two players only)
$
|\
| \ Track: aim 1 yd in front of the near hip
| \
flat v \
------------>X <- where R will be
R ======>
📊 Diagram (described): A two-player close-up. The strong safety starts deep and to the inside of a runner who is moving toward the sideline. One path, labeled flat, goes straight down toward the runner's current position and ends behind him. The other path, labeled Track, angles ahead of the runner toward a point marked X, a yard in front of the runner's near hip at the spot he will reach, so the safety arrives with the runner in front of him.
What to ask. "The runner moves about as fast as the safety. If the safety aims at where the runner is now, where does he arrive?" (Behind him.) "Move the safety from 5 yards to 12. Does the aiming point move?" (Further in front — the deeper start means more time for the runner to move.) Then: "What does the sideline do for you?" (It is a defender; aim to pin the runner against it.)
What a strong answer sounds like: "Aim a yard in front of his near hip at the point he'll reach, near shoulder to that hip, head behind, wrap and roll. If I miss, I miss behind him into the pursuit, not in front of him into open grass."
Film-room version: run the §23.8 charting 🧩 — Tess's three snaps — and have students chart them independently before comparing. The disagreements are the lesson: two coaches must agree before a miss is charted "runner won."
Assessment notes
Assign: A1, A4, A8, A9 (roll vs. hip-drop), B4 (face mask in the middle of the receiver's chest — a safety-correction item), C2 or C6 (practice plan from a chart), D1 (live vs. limited contact), and D3 (the "tough guy" safety after a hard hit — required). E3 (rules study) is the best assignment for a coaching-methods class.
Quiz: items 2, 3, 7, 13, and 15 are essential; item 15 (may a player return because he says he feels fine?) should be graded as must-pass in any coaching-certification setting.
A strong Project Checkpoint (Tackling Curriculum & Tracking Sheet) has no more than two or three tackle words with a safety cue for each; tempo words with the student's actual current contact limits written beside them and a source; four to six drills covering angle, breakdown, open field, team pursuit, and ball disruption; a weekly schedule that keeps Live a small share; a concussion protocol naming who removes and who clears; and a tracking sheet whose weekly summary drives next week's drill choice. Mark down any curriculum that uses head-first cues, omits the protocol, or schedules live tackling without stating limits.
Any-level adaptation
High school staff: this is the most important chapter in the book for you. Use the checkpoint's high school example row and summary as a template. Your state association's contact limits and your state's concussion law are the first two lines of the curriculum. Case Study 2 is set in East Texas high school football on purpose.
College class: pair §23.7 with the Dartmouth history (Buddy Teevens's program, widely credited with eliminating live tackling of teammates around 2010 and developing a mobile robotic dummy) as a case in institutional change, and have students design a spring-practice plan inside NCAA and conference limits.
Analyst course: build around §23.8 and exercise E2 — compare how two public charting services define a missed tackle, and why the numbers differ.
Connections
Backward: Chapter 5 (the fit that put Tre in space); Chapter 21 (eyes, and Ames's lunge); Chapter 22 (the alley angle this chapter finishes).
Forward: Chapter 35 builds effort grading and the takeaway circuit; Chapter 36 puts contact limits into a full installation calendar. Appendix K holds Track, Eye-Opener, Sideline, Team Pursuit, and Fit and Punch; Appendix H defines missed-tackle rate.