Case Study 31.2 — Eleven Words in Two Weeks: A High School Match Install That Failed First
A high school case. Riverbend High School, its coaches and players, and Dalton Creek are fictional composites. Ray Medina is the Riverbend coordinator you met in Chapter 9's second case study.
Setup
Ray Medina, the defensive coordinator at Riverbend High School, came back to my spring clinic a year after the season you read about in Chapter 9, where his "Sky Field" rule fixed Riverbend's field-side pass defense in the second half against Foothill Ridge. This spring the clinic topic was pattern-matching, and Ray took more notes than anyone in the room.
He went home and installed all of it. In two weeks of August camp, with about twenty-five minutes a day of team defense, Riverbend's secondary learned:
- Cover 3 with the seam-carry rule (curl/flat defenders carry #2 vertical)
- A trips rule for #3 vertical (the free safety takes him)
- In-out against stacks and bunches
- A "Meg" tag for his best corner (man everywhere he goes on #1)
- A "Palms" tag for the field side (corner reads #2 and jumps the quick out)
Counting the handoff calls ("Mine," "In," "Flat," "Wheel"), that was eleven new words.
Riverbend's Week 2 opponent was Dalton Creek, a spread team whose coordinator loved bunch formations: three receivers in a tight triangle, one on the line of scrimmage and two a step behind him on either side. On the film Ray had from the previous season, Dalton Creek lined up in a bunch on about four of every ten passing snaps, nearly always to the wide side of the field.
That last detail matters more in high school than in the NFL. Under NFHS rules, the hash marks sit 53 feet 4 inches from each sideline and divide the field into thirds. With the ball on a hash, the wide side of the field is about 35½ yards from the ball to the sideline. On an NFL field, it's about 30. A bust to the field side on a Friday night leaves a lot of grass for a receiver to run into.
What Happens
The first bunch
First quarter, second-and-6. Dalton Creek puts its bunch to the field. Riverbend is in Cover 3, and the bunch triggers in-out: Jaylen Ortiz, the senior field corner, is the outside defender; Eli Dawson, a junior who plays the apex, is the inside defender; and the strong safety is over the top for any vertical release.
PRE-SNAP: DALTON CREEK BUNCH TO THE FIELD (field side only)
$ (Riverbend SS, 11 yds)
* (apex: inside) C (corner: outside)
W
T E
O O O H
Q Y Z
R
📊 Diagram (described): Only the field side is shown. Dalton Creek has three receivers in a bunch: the point man (H) on the line of scrimmage, with one receiver (Y) a step behind and inside him and another (Z) a step behind and outside him. The quarterback is under center with a back behind him. For Riverbend, the strong safety ($) is about eleven yards deep over the bunch, Dawson, the apex defender (*), is inside the bunch at about five yards, and Ortiz, the corner (C), is outside the bunch at about six yards. A linebacker (W), a defensive tackle (T), and a defensive end (E) are shown in the box.
At the snap, the point man runs straight up the field. The outside receiver, Z, runs a quick slant inside. The inside receiver, Y, runs underneath to the flat.
Under the in-out rule, the first receiver to break out is Y, going to the flat, and he belongs to the outside defender, Ortiz. The first receiver to break in is Z, on the slant, and he belongs to the inside defender, Dawson. The point man's vertical release belongs to the safety.
Here's what happened instead.
POST-SNAP: THE BUST - TWO ON THE SLANT, NONE ON THE FLAT
^ <- H: vertical
$ ---------->| (safety has him)
|
Both the apex (*) and the * | C
corner (C) drive on Z's \ | /
slant, the first IN. \ | /
v <----- /
|\
W | \
+--|--|--------------> OPEN
O O O | H | (Y: flat = first OUT,
Q Y Z nobody takes him)
📊 Diagram (described): The point man (H) runs straight downfield and the strong safety goes with him. The outside receiver (Z) runs a slant toward the middle. Dawson, the apex defender, correctly drives down onto the slant as the first receiver breaking inside. But Ortiz, the corner, also drives inside onto the slant, following the outside receiver. The inside receiver (Y) runs underneath both of them to the flat, toward the sideline, and nobody is there. The flat is open all the way to the sideline.
Ortiz had played Z. Asked about it on the sideline, he said what high school players always say: "He's my guy." He was the outside receiver, and in the Meg tag Ortiz had learned the same week, the outside receiver was his guy, everywhere he went. Under pressure, the newest rule lost to the stronger habit.
The flat route went for 44 yards and a touchdown.
The first half
Dalton Creek's coordinator saw it as clearly as we would have. Riverbend saw the bunch to the field five more times before halftime. Two of those snaps produced the same bust, Ortiz chasing the outside receiver and the flat left empty: one more touchdown and a 23-yard gain. On another, Dawson and Ortiz both peeled off the slant late, each thinking the other had it. Only one of the five bunch snaps was played correctly. It was 28–7 at halftime. Riverbend lost 35–20.
The phone call
Ray called me on Sunday. I asked him one question before he finished describing the film.
Russ: How many words did you install?
Ray: Counting the handoffs, eleven.
Russ: How many of them can Ortiz say back to you, correctly, in the fourth quarter, when he's tired?
Ray: (a pause) Four? Maybe.
Russ: Then you have four words. Which four do you need against bunches?
They cut the install that afternoon. Meg and Palms came out entirely. The trips #3 rule stayed on the sheet but went back to a simple version: the free safety plays the deepest receiver in the middle. What stayed was Cover 3 with seam-carry, and in-out against stacks and bunches, rewritten in the players' own words. Before the snap, the corner says "Out!" and the apex says "In!", out loud, to each other. That's a reminder, not a check. After the snap, the rule is "first to break, not first in line": the receiver who changes direction first toward your side is yours.
Riverbend spent ten minutes of every practice for the rest of the season on bunch cards at walk-through speed, then at full speed with no tackling, before any team period.
The rematch
Riverbend and Dalton Creek met again in the second round of the state playoffs. Dalton Creek lined up in a bunch to the field 14 times. Riverbend gave up 7 completions for 61 yards on those snaps, and nothing longer than 14 yards. Riverbend won, 17–14.
Analysis
The rule was right; the install was wrong. In-out is a sound answer to bunches at every level. It failed in Week 2 for two reasons that had nothing to do with its logic.
First, the new rule collided with a stronger one. Meg (man on #1 everywhere) and in-out (take the first receiver out) give the corner opposite instructions against the same bunch whenever the outside receiver breaks inside. A professional corner with months of reps can hold both rules in his head and apply the right one by the call. A high school senior with two weeks of reps applies the one he learned first or liked best. Ray's install didn't just add words; it added words that fought each other.
Second, "first" was never defined. To Ortiz, "first out" meant the outside receiver, the one first in line from the sideline. The rule means the receiver who breaks first. That one-word ambiguity turned a combination rule back into man coverage on alignment, which is exactly the coverage bunches are designed to beat.
Third, the field multiplied the cost. On a high school field, the wide side is about 35 yards from the hash to the sideline. A bust in the field flat isn't a five-yard catch; it's a footrace with nobody in it. The wider the field, the less a defense can afford a combination call that isn't automatic.
The fix was subtraction. Riverbend's defense in the rematch knew fewer things than its defense in Week 2. It knew them well enough that two players could say them to each other before every snap. That's the high school version of the chapter's rule about vocabulary: a word your players can't use under stress isn't a word, it's a hope.
Compare the professional case. In Case Study 31.1, the Sentinels carried three quarters calls, a formation trigger for Meg, and an alignment rule inside the tag, and they used all of them against a professional coordinator's plan. Those layers took the Sentinels three seasons to build, with practice time a high school staff will never have. The principle is the same at both levels: match rules are only as good as the players' ability to apply them at full speed. The amount of match a team can own is different.
Discussion Questions
- Identify the two rules in Riverbend's install that gave the corner contradictory instructions against a bunch. How would you have sequenced them across a season if you wanted both?
- Rewrite the in-out rule in words a high school sophomore could repeat back to you. Test it against a bunch where the point man breaks out and the outside receiver goes vertical. Does your wording still work?
- The pre-snap "Out!" and "In!" calls are reminders, not checks. Why might a reminder call help more at the high school level than at the NFL level? Is there a cost?
- How does the NFHS hash placement change the risk of playing a combination rule to the field instead of the boundary? Would you consider aligning your bunch defenders differently to the boundary?
- Ray kept the trips #3 rule on the sheet in a simplified form. Was that the right call, or should it have come out too? Defend your answer with what Dalton Creek's film showed.
Your Turn
You're a high school defensive coordinator with twenty-five minutes of team defense per practice and a bunch-heavy opponent in three weeks. Write a three-week install plan for in-out against bunches and stacks only: what you teach each week, at what speed, how you define "first," what your players say to each other before the snap, and what you'll grade on film. Then name one tag or rule you'll deliberately not install this season, and explain why leaving it out makes your in-out better.