Chapter 24 Key Takeaways — Defensive Game Planning

Key Takeaways

  1. A tendency report describes them; a game plan decides for us. Every page of the report should end in a decision: a call, a check, a coaching point, or "we live with this."
  2. Every game plan answers three questions: What do they like? What is their best weapon? What will we make them do instead?
  3. Sample: the last 3–4 games, ~150–250 snaps, after checking for coordinator or QB changes, injuries, blowouts, and opponents who defend like you. The game against a defense like yours is the most valuable film in the sample.
  4. Tag every snap the same way. Use fixed columns, a written tag dictionary, and an agreement check. Drift and "tagging what you expected" quietly corrupt front-page numbers.
  5. Counts before percentages; compare to the base rate. "14 of 22" against "22 of 108 elsewhere" is a tendency. "64%" by itself is a rumor. Under ~10 snaps is a story; ~10–25 is a lean; ~25+ is a plan.
  6. Tells run in one direction. All 9 scissors came from reduced splits, but only 9 of 23 reduced splits were scissors. Check the direction before you coach it.
  7. The best weapon may be a condition, not a player. Vance against pressure: 9.4 Y/A against 5+ rushers, 6.1 Y/A with 3 INT against four rushers plus post-snap rotation. Look for the weapon your decisions control.
  8. Take away one or two things completely, and write down the cost. The fifth column — "what we'll live with" — is the plan. Against Austin: Sutton vs. Brennan, Ruffin in the flat, long drives.
  9. Organize the plan the way the game arrives: front page, early downs, third down by distance, red zone, two-minute, backed up, short yardage, tempo, alerts, and the "never" list.
  10. A plan has to survive the coordinator. The Week 6 report said "never Cover 0." Russ called it anyway: 52-yard touchdown, 34–27 loss. In Week 15, the report's exception clause produced Mug Cat Fire: sack, punt, and a 23–20 win.

The Outlaws in one table (Week 6 report, fictional)

Item Value
Sample 247 snaps, last 4 games
Personnel 11: 168 · 12: 49 · other: 30
Motion / RPO 134 motion · 38 RPO
Vance vs. 5+ rushers 28 of 36, 9.4 Y/A, 4 TD, 0 INT
Vance vs. 4 + rotation 31 of 52, 6.1 Y/A, 1 TD, 3 INT
Third down 26 of 55 (47%); 23 of 40 at 1–6 yards, 3 of 15 at 7+
3rd-and-4–6 from trips Dig/flood 14 of 22
12 personnel 31 of 49 runs; 11 of 18 passes play-action
Gaines 19 of 41 third-down targets

Action Items (this week)

  • [ ] Write your tag list and tag dictionary; run a 25-snap agreement check with a second tagger.
  • [ ] Build the standard cutups for your next opponent and assign a first viewer to each.
  • [ ] Write a five-item front page: count, sample size, decision for every item, plus one "live with" item.
  • [ ] Fill in a five-column weapon table for at least two weapons.
  • [ ] Write a "never" list of no more than three lines, and plan to put it on the call sheet in red (Chapter 25).
  • [ ] For every tell you plan to coach, write which direction it runs and its count in both directions.

Common Mistakes (and the fix)

Mistake What happens Fix
The binder organized like the data The game-deciding number ends up on page 23 Front page first: five items, each ending in a decision
Bare percentages 3 of 4 looks like 150 of 200 Always "X of Y"; use the confidence ladder
No base rate A concept they run everywhere looks like a situational tendency Compare the situation against all their other snaps
Coaching a tell backwards "Reduced split = scissors" is wrong 14 times in 23 Write the tell's count in both directions
Ignoring the defenses they faced Tendencies against single-high get planned against your two-high Isolate the game against a defense like yours
The plan that takes away everything Fourteen jobs for eleven players; busts by the second quarter Take away one or two things; write the fifth column
No second call When the first call gets broken, you call it again Every situation box gets a second call and a trigger to switch
Not keeping the plan Fourth-quarter itch overrides Tuesday's thinking A "never" list in red on the call sheet

Decision Framework

From film to front page in seven questions:

  1. Is the sample right? Recent, same coordinator and QB, flagged blowouts, and one game against a defense like ours.
  2. What do they do most, by situation? Personnel, down and distance, formation, motion: always in counts.
  3. Is it really a tendency? Count on the confidence ladder, gap from the base rate, and confirmed on film.
  4. Can we see it coming? Find the tell, and check which direction it runs.
  5. Which of our decisions changes their results the most? That's the best weapon to take away.
  6. What do we give them instead, and can we live with it? Fill in the fifth column. If you can't live with it, pick a different answer.
  7. What will we never do against this team? Three lines, in red.