Case Study 1 — Paying Them to Block Nobody: Mug Sim at St. Louis
A fictional Sentinels snap from Week 11 at St. Louis, the Sentinels' 17–13 win. Told by Russ Kimbrough.
Setup
The game. Week 11, at the St. Louis Stallions, our division rival. The Stallions are a wide-zone, play-action, bootleg offense built around Tyler Haugen, a precise pocket passer who is lethal when you bite on a run fake. On third-and-long, though, there's no run fake to bite on, and the Stallions become a different offense: Haugen in the shotgun, three or four receivers, and a protection that keeps a lot of people home.
The situation. Fourth quarter, 3:20 left. Sentinels 17, Stallions 13. Stallions' ball at their own 41. 3rd-and-9. A conversion puts them in field-goal range with the clock running; a stop gives our offense the ball with a chance to run out most of what's left.
Personnel. The Stallions came out in 11 personnel — one back (Antoine Day), one tight end (Reggie Fant, flexed a few yards off the left tackle), three receivers — in a 2x2, with Day on Haugen's right. We were in nickel.
What the scouting said. Owen Kessler's protection chart on the Stallions, built from their last four games and the first three quarters of this one, had a line Tess had underlined twice:
| Stallions protection on 3rd-and-7+ (Owen's charting) | Count |
|---|---|
| Third-and-7+ dropbacks in the sample | 23 |
| Defense showed 6+ potential rushers within 5 yards | 16 |
| ...Stallions kept seven in (Day and Fant) | 11 of 16 |
| ...Stallions kept six (Day only) | 5 of 16 |
| Defense showed a normal four-man look | 7 |
| ...Stallions kept seven in | 1 of 7 |
The Stallions' offensive line coach was doing exactly what a good one should. When he saw a pressure look on a long third down, he kept extra blockers in, slid toward the crowd, and trusted Haugen to beat coverage with three receivers and time. Against man pressure, that's an excellent plan: seven blockers handle six rushers, and three good receivers against man coverage with time to throw will get you a first down a lot of the time.
Owen's sample is small — sixteen snaps — and he said so. But the shape was clear, and it matched the film.
The Wednesday ledger
On the Wednesday before the game, Tess and I ran the ledger for our two Mug calls against the protection the Stallions were most likely to use.
| Mug Cat Fire | Mug Sim | |
|---|---|---|
| Rushers | 5 | 4 |
| Blockers (Stallions keep 7) | 7 | 7 |
| Wasted | 2 (on Coleman and on Weller) | 3 (on both mugged linebackers' assignments and on Weller) |
| Effective | 5 | 4 |
| Free | 0 | 0 |
| Coverage | 6 droppers vs. 3 receivers, Simmons blitzing | 7 droppers vs. 3 receivers, both corners home |
Tess: "Neither one gets anybody free."
Russ: "Against seven, nothing gets anybody free unless we send eight, and we're not sending eight. So stop asking who's free. Ask what they paid for the seven."
Tess: "Two receivers."
Russ: "Two receivers. If they're going to pay that, I want every defender I've got in coverage — including the corner. Mug Sim. If they ever start releasing Fant against the Mug look, Mug Cat Fire comes back."
That exchange is the whole case. A simulated pressure isn't a pressure that failed to produce a free rusher. It's a coverage call that charges the offense two receivers to look at it.
What happens
The Stallions broke the huddle. Haugen walked to the line and looked at our picture: Royce alone deep at 13, Holloway at eight over the slot, and seven men near the line — Rollins, Big V head-up on the left guard, Ames and Bell in the two A-gaps, Coleman, Weller, and Vo walked up outside Weller.
🎙️ On the headset: Tess from the booth: "Fant's in a two-point flex. Day's right. Haugen's pointing — he's got Bell." Me: "Good. Let him count to seven." I'd made the call at 26 seconds on the play clock and Bell had it in. Nothing to check. The only word I was listening for was "Empty," and it didn't come.
Haugen pointed at Bell. The center tapped the right guard. Fant took a half step inside. Day squared up in the gun.
At the snap, four Sentinels rushed: Rollins off the boundary edge, Big V through the boundary B-gap, Coleman through the field B-gap, and Vo off the field edge as the contain. Seven dropped. Ames came out of his A-gap and ran to the boundary curl-to-flat. Bell bailed from the other A-gap to the boundary-side hook. Weller, who'd been in a three-point stance outside the right tackle, stood up and ran back to the field-side hook. Holloway played the field curl-to-flat. Brennan, Royce, and Simmons played the deep thirds.
POST-SNAP (Mug Sim vs. a seven-man protection, 3rd-and-9)
[DEEP 1/3] [DEEP MIDDLE 1/3] [DEEP 1/3]
C F C
^ ^ ^
[CURL/FLAT] [HOOK] [HOOK] [CURL/FLAT]
W <- M <- -> E (Weller) -> $
E N T *
vv vv vv vv
X Y-blk O O O O O H Z
blocks: E N air T air R: air Y: *
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): Three receivers run routes — the split end on the left, the slot and the flanker on the right — against seven Sentinels droppers: Ames in the boundary curl-to-flat, Bell in the boundary hook, Weller in the field hook, Holloway in the field curl-to-flat, and Brennan, Royce, and Simmons in the deep thirds. Four Sentinels rush: Rollins, Big V, Coleman, and Vo. The Stallions keep seven in: the tight end (marked "Y-blk" where he steps down) and the running back join the five linemen. The left tackle blocks Rollins, the left guard Big V, the center slides to an A-gap that Bell has left (air), the right guard Coleman, the right tackle sets on Weller, who dropped (air), the running back steps up for Ames, who dropped (air), and the tight end works across to pick up Vo off the field edge. Eleven defenders.
Three receivers. The split end ran a deep comeback at Brennan, who had a deep-third cushion and Ames underneath him. The slot ran a dig at 14 yards, straight into the window between Bell and Weller — two hook defenders where Haugen expected one. The flanker ran a post; Royce sat on it.
Haugen hitched once. Twice. At about 3.0 seconds he started to step up, and Big V, who had been held up by a guard with no help to give, collapsed the pocket from the boundary B-gap. At 3.6 seconds Rollins came around the left tackle, who had blocked him one-on-one for three and a half seconds, and took Haugen down at the Stallions' 34. Sack, 7-yard loss, 4th-and-16. Punt.
The scoreboard didn't change on that snap. The game did. Our offense took over at our own 21 with 2:49 left and ran nearly two minutes off the clock before punting, and the Stallions never got back across midfield. Sentinels 17, Stallions 13.
Analysis
Why it worked: Line 2, not Line 5. The ledger said nobody would be free, and nobody was. The Stallions kept seven blockers in against four rushers — three wasted (the center, the right tackle, and Day). What they bought with those three blockers was protection against a pressure that wasn't coming. What it cost them was two receivers. Three receivers against seven droppers is a mismatch no quarterback wins quickly: every route had a defender in front of it or over it, and the dig — the route Haugen most wanted — ran into a double hook.
Why the rush got home anyway. A four-man rush with one-on-ones across the board is still a four-man rush, and Owen's timing table says four-man rushes rarely get home before about three seconds. This one got home at 3.6 because the coverage gave it 3.6. That's the sim's bargain: you trade rush speed for coverage, and the coverage buys the rush back.
Why Owen's caveat matters. Sixteen snaps is a thin sample. If the Stallions had released Fant — the one-in-three chance Owen's chart allowed — Mug Sim faces six blockers and four receivers, nobody is free, and the coverage is seven against four instead of seven against three. That's still a sound call. The sim's floor is high; its ceiling depends on the protection.
What the Stallions could do next time. Their line coach isn't going to keep paying two receivers for a look that turned into four rushers. Next meeting, expect them to release Fant against the Mug look on third-and-long. That's when the ledger flips: six blockers against Mug Cat Fire is R 5, B 6, W 2, effective 4 — one free. Sims and real pressures from the same look protect each other.
The risk we accepted. A sim with only four rushers can't afford a lane violation. If Vo had cut under the tackle instead of keeping contain, Haugen — not a scrambler, but not immobile — would have had the field edge for a first down. Lane discipline was the one thing on the play that had no backup.
Discussion Questions
- The Wednesday ledger showed zero free rushers for both Mug calls. Why did Russ choose the sim instead of Mug Cat Fire, and what single scouting fact would have flipped the decision?
- Three Stallions blockers blocked air. Name them and the Sentinels defender who caused each.
- Rollins won a one-on-one rep at 3.6 seconds. How much of that sack belongs to the rush, and how much to the coverage? Defend a split.
- Owen's protection chart was 16 snaps. What would make you trust it more, and what would make you ignore it?
- If you were the Stallions' offensive coordinator watching this on Monday, what are two protection or play-call changes you'd make against the Mug look on third-and-long?
Your Turn
Build the Stallions' answer and then beat it. On one sheet: (1) draw the same Mug look against the Stallions' 2x2 with Fant released and Day staying in (six blockers); (2) run the ledger for Mug Sim and for Mug Cat Fire against that protection; (3) choose one, and write the one-sentence reason you'd give Tess on the headset. Then write the scouting note you'd want Owen to update if the Stallions start releasing Fant: what number, out of how many snaps, would make you switch?