Chalk-Talk and Simulation Guide
Whiteboard drills, the DC vs. OC call-sheet game, the mock booth, and halftime
Russ Kimbrough's rule is the course's assessment standard: "If you can't draw it, you don't know it. If you can't say it in one sentence, they can't play it." This guide gives you four tools for making learners draw, say, and decide under pressure: a bank of whiteboard drills, a dice-and-card game that turns a call sheet into a live contest against the Austin Outlaws' tendencies, a mock game-day booth, and a halftime simulation.
1. Whiteboard drills
Each drill takes three to ten minutes. Use one to open every session. Rotate the marker so every learner
draws at least once a week. All drawing uses the book's notation (defense on top looking down at the
offense, pre-snap and post-snap pictures — see Appendix A), and every diagram ends with a spoken
one-sentence description, the classroom version of the book's 📊 Diagram (described) line.
| Drill | Setup | The ask | What a strong answer sounds like |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ninety-second diagram | Name a call and a formation ("Cover 3 Sky vs. 11 personnel, 2x2") | Draw pre-snap and post-snap in 90 seconds | Eleven defenders counted; zones labeled; the rotator named; one sentence: "Strong safety drops to the curl-flat, free safety spins to the middle, corners bail to thirds." |
| Count it | Draw an offensive formation only | Count the gaps and the box; say how many defenders the front needs | Honest count: six gaps for five linemen, one per attached tight end, plus one for a running quarterback (Ch 5 §5.1) |
| Every gap has an owner | Front plus a run scheme (Over vs. inside zone to the TE) | Write a name in every gap; mark force and alley | Exactly one owner per gap; the force player and the alley player named by coverage (Ch 22 §22.4) |
| The ledger | A pressure call and a protection | Fill in all six lines | Rushers, blockers, blockers blocking nobody, effective blockers, free rushers, and the hot throw with the defender standing in it (Ch 18) |
| One look, three endings | A pre-snap two-high picture | Draw three different post-snap coverages from it | Three endings with the same safety depth ("twins") so the shell tells the quarterback nothing (Ch 6, Ch 38 §38.4) |
| The formation changes | A coverage on the board; then the instructor moves a receiver (trips, empty, motion) | Say the check and who makes it | The right word (Lock, Echo, Ride, Bump, Roll) and the right speaker — Royce alone owns coverage checks, and a check is live only when echoed (Ch 14) |
| How would I attack that? | A learner's drawn call | A second learner, playing head coach Mike Sorensen, names the concept that stresses it | A real beater from the honest cycle (Ch 38 §38.3), and the defender answering with the check, rule, or sister call that patches it |
| Whose fault? | A described failed play | Name the first error and the code | First cause, not proximity (Ch 40 §40.5) |
Grading board work. Three things, equally: the drawing is correct and complete (eleven defenders, right alignments, labeled zones or gaps); the one-sentence rule is playable; and the learner can answer one follow-up question about a weakness. Don't grade artistry.
2. The DC vs. OC call-sheet game
What it teaches
Calling a defense inside a clock, against an offense whose tendencies you know only as a sample — and discovering that your own calls become a tendency the offense can read. It is the most effective way to teach Chapter 25's threshold concept: your tendencies are the opponent's scouting report.
Roles and materials
- DC (one learner or a pair): holds a call sheet built in advance from the menu below.
- OC (one learner or a pair, playing Lyle Petrakis): holds the Outlaws decks and a d6.
- Booth (one or two learners): keeps the call log and the drive chart; calls "Tempo!" and "Range!"
- Head coach (the instructor): holds the veto.
- Materials: index cards, one or two six-sided dice, a timer, a drive chart on the board.
The offense: dice tables built from the Outlaws' tendencies
All offensive selection comes from Owen's 247-snap, four-game scouting sample in Appendix G §G.3, rounded to twenty-sided tables. If you have no d20, use a deck of twenty cards marked to match.
First and second down (from §G.3.2, down × play type):
| Play type | 1st down (108 snaps) | d20 | 2nd down (79 snaps) | d20 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Designed run (outside zone, duo, inside zone) | 44 | 1–8 | 25 | 1–6 |
| RPO (inside zone / slant or glance to Powers) | 22 | 9–12 | 15 | 7–10 |
| Play-action | 21 | 13–16 | 18 | 11–15 |
| Dropback / quick game | 16 | 17–19 | 16 | 16–19 |
| Screen | 5 | 20 | 5 | 20 |
Third down uses decks, because distance matters and the samples are small — which is part of the lesson. Build each from §G.3.3 and §G.3.4:
| Deck | Cards (one per snap in the sample) | Owen's label |
|---|---|---|
| 3rd-and-1–3 (14) | 7 run (6 designed runs, 1 RPO) · 7 quick-game passes | A lean |
| 3rd-and-4–6 from 3x1 (22) | 9 dig to trips side · 5 flood to trips side · 3 backside isolation to Sutton · 2 mesh / shallow cross · 1 Harlan option route · 1 screen to Powers · 1 quarterback draw | A lean, close to a plan |
| 3rd-and-7+ (15) | 13 dropback passes (Gaines the first read on 6 of them) · 2 draws | A story |
Before the game, ask the DC which deck they would trust most. A DC who builds the whole plan around the fifteen-card deck has missed Owen's confidence ladder.
The defense: the call menu
The DC's call sheet uses calls from the book, organized by situation boxes. Keep it to eight:
| Call | What it is | Rush |
|---|---|---|
| Home | Nickel Over Quarters | 4 |
| Two | Cover 2 | 4 |
| Six | Quarters to one side, Cover 2 to the cloud side | 4 |
| Sky | Cover 3 Sky from a one-high look | 4 |
| Spin 3 | Two-high look, rotate to Cover 3 at the snap | 4 |
| Spin 1 | Two-high look, rotate to Cover 1 | 4–5 |
| Mug Cat Fire | Fire zone from the mug: 5 rush, 3 deep, 3 under | 5 |
| Zero | Cover 0 | 6 |
Resolving each snap
Every combination of offensive play type and defensive call is rated D (defense favored), N (neutral), or O (offense favored). The ratings below are a teaching approximation built from the book's beater logic (Chapter 38 §38.3, Appendix B, Appendix E), not data. Edit any cell your room disagrees with — the argument about a cell is good chalk talk in itself.
| Offense ↓ / Defense → | Home | Two | Six | Sky | Spin 3 | Spin 1 | Mug Cat Fire | Zero |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Run | N | O | N | D | D | D | N | D |
| RPO | N | N | N | O | N | N | O | O |
| Play-action | O | N | N | N | N | N | D | N |
| Quick game | O | D | N | N | N | N | N | O |
| Dropback (dig, flood, post) | D | O | N | O | D | N | N | O |
| Screen / draw | N | N | N | N | N | N | O | O |
The OC rolls a d6 on the matching row:
| d6 | D (defense favored) | N (neutral) | O (offense favored) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Gain 7 | Explosive: gain 20 | Explosive: gain 35 |
| 2 | Gain 4 | Gain 9 | Gain 18 |
| 3 | Gain 2 | Gain 5 | Gain 11 |
| 4 | No gain / incomplete | Gain 3 | Gain 7 |
| 5 | Sack or tackle for loss, −6 | No gain / incomplete | Gain 4 |
| 6 | Takeaway (on a pass); −3 (on a run) | Sack or tackle for loss, −5 | No gain / incomplete |
Three modifiers carry the book's big ideas. Apply them by shifting the rating one step (O → N → D or the reverse):
- The disguise bonus (Chapters 6 and 30). If the DC calls Spin 3 or Spin 1 and has shown the same two-high look on at least three of the previous five snaps, shift one step toward D. The quarterback was baited.
- The tendency penalty (Chapter 25). If the DC makes the same call three snaps in a row, or calls 5+ rushers on more than one in five third downs, shift one step toward O. The offense has the answer key.
- The Vance rule (Appendix G). Against Mug Cat Fire or Zero on any pass, the OC may re-roll a result of 5 or 6 once. He was 28 of 36 against five or more rushers.
The clock and the veto
Each snap, the OC announces down, distance, and (on third down) the formation, then starts a 40-second timer. The DC must signal a call by the 15-second mark — the book's radio cutoff. No call by 15 seconds means the defense plays Home, the default call. The head coach may say "Card" to any call not in the DC's call-sheet box for that situation; the DC then plays Home.
Drives and scoring
Start each drive at the Outlaws' 25. First downs and touchdowns as normal. A stalled drive inside the Sentinels' 20 is a field goal; between the 20 and the 35, roll a d6 — 1 through 4 is good. Anything else is a punt. Play four drives per half.
The self-scout reveal
After every eight snaps, hand the OC the DC's call log for sixty seconds. The OC may then swap two cards in any third-down deck for two cards of a play type rated O against the DC's most-used call. This is Petrakis adjusting to Russ — and it is why the DC needs the mix line, the HOLD line, and the zero card from Chapter 25's call sheet.
Debrief questions
- Where did your call log become a tendency before you noticed?
- Which deck did you build your third-down plan on, and how many snaps stood behind it?
- When did the disguise bonus fire, and what did you give up to earn it?
- Was any explosive play a CALL grade, or was it just the dice? How would you know the difference over a season? (This is the bad-call vs. bad-outcome question at the center of Chapter 16 and Chapter 34 §34.8.)
3. The mock game-day booth
Run this once the class has played the call-sheet game at least once. It adds the communication layer from Chapter 8, Chapter 25 §25.2, and Chapter 37 §37.2.
Room layout. The DC sits at the front ("the sideline") with the call sheet. The booth — the learner playing Tess Navarro, and one playing Owen Kessler — sits at the back, facing away from the board, with the drive chart. The two communicate only through one "headset": a single learner messenger, or a phone on speaker. The green dot (a learner playing Marcus Bell) stands with the DC and must say back every call word for word before it counts. Position coaches (Big Lou, Dre, Gabe) each own one question per series: Lou the rush, Dre the fits, Gabe the coverage.
The booth's job. Tess charts every snap — personnel, formation, call, result — and gives the DC one fact from the booth between snaps, never three. She applies the three-snap rule from Chapter 37: the first time the offense shows something new, she marks it NEW and says nothing unless it scored or went for an explosive; the second time she says it on the headset; the third time, the DC owes the staff a decision — change something, or say out loud why you accept it. She makes the booth calls from Chapter 28: "Last timeout!", "Range!", "Goal line!"
Owen's job. Track the DC's call mix by situation and announce, at each change of possession, the one number that matters: "Pressure on 3rd-and-7+ is two of four." He gives sample sizes every time.
Instructor injects. Interrupt the flow with situations the book teaches:
- Tempo (Chapter 29): the OC announces "no huddle" and runs the next three snaps with a 15-second clock. The DC may call only the four tempo-board calls — Home, Sky, Robber, Fire — and Tess calls "Tempo!"
- Two-minute (Chapter 28): 1:50 left, Outlaws need a field goal, two timeouts. Clock math is now the DC's problem.
- Sudden change: after a turnover, the defense is back on the field. The book's rule: the call is Home.
- Empty: the OC motions the back out. Did the green dot echo the right word?
Grading. Not the score. Grade the communication: calls in before 15 seconds, say-backs correct, booth facts single and relevant, and the three-snap rule followed rather than chasing one play.
4. The halftime simulation
The constraint is the lesson. Chapter 37's hook is "one page, three lines, twelve minutes." Give the staff exactly that.
Inputs. The booth's first-half chart from the call-sheet game or mock booth (or, for a stand-alone session, a chart you prepare from Game 2's first half as described in Chapter 37 §37.3).
Minutes 0–4: the halftime sheet. Tess and Owen answer the four questions, in order: What did they run most? What hurt us — and for each, whose fault (scheme, call, or execution)? What did we stop? What is different from the scouting report?
Minutes 4–8: the six-question test (§37.4). For each candidate change, the staff asks: Is it a pattern or a play? Is it costing us? Whose fault? Do we have an installed answer? What does the answer cost? Can every player say it in one sentence? Candidates that fail go to WATCH or KEEP. Nothing new — no new technique, call, or word — goes in at halftime, per the adjustment ladder in §37.2.
Minutes 8–12: two or three changes, on cards. Write each on an index card in one sentence and walk it to the "rooms" (position-coach learners), who say it back. Russ's Game 2 halftime made three: corners up, Spin on schedule, and open the Mug box.
Second half. Resume the game — and give the OC a halftime too. The OC gets four minutes and may swap three cards in any deck. Petrakis adjusts as well (§37.7). The debrief question: which of your changes created a new tendency the OC could read (§37.8)?
Debrief. Ask the staff which change they erased and why. The best answer sounds like Russ's: the fourth change was real, but three changes the players can execute beat four they half-remember.
5. Making it work in different rooms
- A lecture hall. Run the call-sheet game as a demonstration with two volunteers, and have the whole room write their own call on a card before each snap. Collect the cards after eight snaps; the room's own tendency is a better self-scout lesson than the DC's.
- A high school staff. Replace the Outlaws decks with your next opponent's tendencies, built from your own tagging in Chapter 24. The matrix and dice stay the same; the decks become yours.
- An analytics course. Have analysts run the booth and present Owen's numbers at halftime with sample sizes and confidence labels. The football learners decide; the analysts are graded on whether their one number was the right one.
- Solo learners. Shuffle the deck, write the call before flipping, and self-scout the log after twenty snaps.