Chapter 25 Exercises — Defensive Play Calling
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and research
All Sentinels, Outlaws, Stallions, and Ospreys people, calls, and numbers are fictional composites. Selected answers are in Appendix J. Short answers for Part C appear in <details> blocks.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. Define call, check, and adjustment. For each, name who makes it on the Sentinels and when it happens.
A2. The NFL play clock is usually 40 seconds. At what point does coach-to-player radio communication end, and what does the Sentinels defense play if the call hasn't arrived by then? Name two other situations in which the defense plays that same call.
A3. List the seven filters a coordinator applies to a call, in the order this chapter uses. Explain why "our own tendency" comes last rather than first.
A4. What is a "starred call" on a call-sheet box, and what must be true of it before any other call in the box is considered?
A5. In your own words, state the threshold concept of this chapter. Then write one sentence describing how a coordinator thinks about a call before crossing that threshold and one describing how he thinks after.
A6. Explain the difference between a rate and a tell in a self-scout. Give one Sentinels example of each from the bye-week report.
A7. What are the three bins in the Break / Bait / Accept sort? Give a one-line definition of each.
A8. Why does the Sentinels' Echo check trigger against an empty formation only when a pressure is called? What happens against empty when Home is the call?
A9. What does "Card" mean on the Sentinels' headset, who can say it, and what must the coordinator do when he hears it?
A10. In plain English, what does it mean that a defense has found the "right mix" between pressure and coverage on a given down?
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
B1. You're charting a defense's third-and-long snaps across one game. Here's your log:
| Snap | Pre-snap safeties | Rushers |
|---|---|---|
| Q1 3rd-and-8 | Two-high | 4 |
| Q1 3rd-and-9 | One-high, SS walked to 8 | 5 |
| Q2 3rd-and-7 | Two-high | 4 |
| Q2 3rd-and-11 | One-high | 5 |
| Q3 3rd-and-8 | One-high, both ILBs in A-gaps | 6 |
| Q3 3rd-and-10 | Two-high | 4 |
| Q4 3rd-and-7 | One-high | 5 |
What tell does this defense have? Write the line a quarterback coach would put on his pre-snap checklist, then name one call the defense could add to break the tell without giving up anything sound.
B2. Read this pre-snap picture and say what an offensive quality control coach would suspect.
PRE-SNAP: 3RD-AND-8, 11 PERSONNEL, 2x2
F (13) $ (10)
C * (2 yds off the LOS) W M C
E N T E
X H O O O O O Y Z
Q
R
📊 Diagram (described): Third-and-8 against a two-by-two formation. The free safety is 13 yards deep on the left; the strong safety is 10 yards deep on the right, on the tight end's side. The nickel is walked down to two yards off the line of scrimmage, inside the slot on the left. The Will and Mike are at normal depth, the corners are over the wide receivers, and four linemen are in an Over front. Eleven defenders.
Name the two alignment habits from the Sentinels' bye-week self-scout that this picture shows, and what each predicted.
B3. On film you see a defense in a mug look (both inside linebackers in the A-gaps) on a third-and-7. At the snap, both linebackers bail to the hook zones, the four linemen rush, and the safeties play quarters. What Sentinels call is this, and which self-scout line was it designed to break?
B4. Describe what you would see on the All-22 if Royce signals "Lock," Holloway does not echo, and the defense follows the Sentinels' rule. What coverage does everyone play?
B5. A defense is in Six (Cover 2 to the boundary, Quarters to the field) against 2x2. The boundary split end runs a 6-yard hitch, the boundary tight end runs a corner route, the field slot goes up the seam, and the field flanker runs a 14-yard dig. Describe which defender should be on each route and where the quarterback's check-down is likely to go.
B6. Look at Tess's call log for one half and identify the problem.
| # | Situation | Call | Time reaching Bell |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1st-and-10, own 25 | Home | 26 |
| 2 | 2nd-and-7 | Nickel Over Sky | 25 |
| 3 | 3rd-and-7 | Nickel Over Mug Cat Fire | 22 |
| 4 | 1st-and-10, midfield | Home | 27 |
| 5 | 3rd-and-8 | Nickel Under Mac Dog Fire | 21 |
| 6 | 3rd-and-9 | Nickel Over Star Fire | 19 |
| 7 | 1st-and-10, own 30 | Home | 28 |
Name two patterns an opponent could exploit and one pattern about the coordinator himself.
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
C1. ⭐⭐ Make the call. Week 15 against Austin. Outlaws' ball, 3rd-and-5 at the Sacramento 44, second quarter, tied. Hector: "Eleven!" Using the Week 15 third-down page from 25.4, name your starred call and what it becomes if Austin aligns in 3x1 trips. Then state the one tendency number that chose the call.
Answer
The starred call in the 3rd-and-4-to-6 box is Home (Nickel, Over, Quarters, four-man rush). Against 3x1 trips, Royce checks Lock and Holloway echoes; the defense plays Quarters Lock — Brennan locks on the single receiver, Royce goes to the middle reading #3, and the trips side walls the dig and carries the flood. The number in the box: Austin ran dig or flood to the trips side on 14 of 22 third-and-4-to-6 snaps from 3x1.
C2. ⭐⭐ Make the call — the cutoff. Week 9 at Oklahoma City. The Ospreys snap a 6-yard completion and hustle to the line without substituting. Your call isn't in when the play clock hits 15. What does the defense play, who calls it on the field, and what single rule should every player apply if a signal from the sideline shows up after that?
Answer
The defense plays Home, and Bell calls it — the call wasn't in by the cutoff. Any signal that appears after the cutoff, or any signal that conflicts with what Bell called, is ignored: conflicting signals mean Home. (Against tempo, the Sentinels also have the picture-board calls from Chapter 8, but those are signaled by Tess's "Tempo!" before the cutoff, not after.)
C3. ⭐⭐⭐ Make the call — score and time. Labeled hypothetical. Sentinels trail 20–13 with 2:30 left in the fourth quarter. The opponent (not Austin; a quarterback whose numbers against five or more rushers are well below his average) has 3rd-and-6 at the Sentinels' 41. You have one timeout. Which way do the score-and-time and opponent-tendency filters push you, and what kind of call do you make? Name a Sentinels call from the book that fits.
Answer
Both filters push toward pressure and variance. Trailing by seven late, a merely good outcome (a long drive that ends in a punt with no time left) can still lose; you need the ball back soon, and a takeaway would be ideal. And this quarterback is worse against pressure than against coverage. A fire zone like Nickel Over Star Fire or Nickel Over Mug Cat Fire keeps three deep defenders while bringing five; a Cover 1 pressure is also defensible. Zero is worth checking against your zero card: "trailing in the last 4:00" may put it on the card, but at the Sentinels' 41, a busted zero is a game-ending touchdown, and a field goal doesn't end the game. A fire zone gets most of the pressure benefit without leaving nobody deep.
C4. ⭐⭐⭐ Draw it. Call: Home against Austin's 11 personnel. They break the huddle in 3x1 trips to the field with Harlan attached on the trips side. Draw the pre-snap alignment of all eleven Sentinels after the Lock check, and then the post-snap assignments against this route pattern: Gaines (#1) runs a 12-yard dig, Powers (#2) runs a 6-yard out, Harlan (#3) runs a seam, Sutton (single receiver) runs a go, and Ruffin releases to the backside flat.
Answer
This is the Game 2 snap in 25.5. Pre-snap: two-high (Royce backside, Holloway trips side), Brennan over Sutton, Simmons over Gaines, Vo over Powers, Bell inside on the trips side, Ames on the backside, and four linemen in the Over front to the tight end. Post-snap: Brennan man on Sutton with no help; Royce to the middle, carrying Harlan's seam after Bell walls him; Vo jumps the out; Holloway, freed because #2 went out, drives on Gaines's dig; Simmons stays over the top of Gaines; Ames takes Ruffin in the backside flat; four-man rush. Eleven defenders.
C5. ⭐⭐⭐ Make the call — the mix. Labeled hypothetical. Austin, second half. Tess's count on third-and-7-plus: five calls so far, one pressure (Mug Cat Fire, Q3, a sack). Owen's pressure slots for this half are "the second and fifth third-and-7-plus." It's now the fifth such snap of the half: 3rd-and-9 at the Outlaws' 40, 11 personnel, 2x2. Do you call pressure? Name the call and explain how the slot, the mix line, the per-half limit, and the situation filters interact.
Answer
The slot says "pressure here," but the slot never overrides the box. The per-half limit for Mug Cat Fire is spent, and Mug Cat Fire is the only pressure in the 3rd-and-7-to-10 box against Austin. The mix line ("1 in 5 or fewer") is already met — one in five. So no pressure call is available inside the box, and calling one from outside the box would draw a "Card." The answer is a four-man call: Nickel Over Mug Quarters is the strongest choice (it uses the mug picture Austin just watched produce a sack), with Nickel Over Six as the safe alternative. The lesson: tools like slots are helpers for mixing within the menu. They don't create new menu items.
C6. ⭐⭐⭐ Draw it — Echo. Call: Nickel Over Mug Cat Fire against Austin in 2x2. Before the snap, Ruffin motions out of the backfield and Austin is in 3x2 empty (three receivers to the field). Who calls the check, what is it, and what does each of the eleven Sentinels do? Which part of the pre-snap look stays until the snap?
Answer
Bell calls "Echo!"; Ames and Vo echo it. The pressure is killed and the defense plays Buzz 3 with a four-man rush: Holloway buzzes to the hook/curl on the three-receiver side, Vo plays the curl/flat on that side, Bell takes the low hole, Ames plays the curl/flat on the two-receiver side, the corners take the deep outside thirds, Royce takes the deep middle, and the four linemen rush. The mug look stays until the snap: Bell and Ames remain in the A-gaps, so Vance still has to identify a pressure that isn't coming.
C7. ⭐⭐⭐ Build a box. Using Owen's Outlaws numbers from Chapter 24, build the "vs. 12 personnel, 1st-and-10" box for the Week 15 call sheet: no more than five calls, ranked, a starred call, and the tendency number printed in the box. Justify the starred call in two sentences.
Answer
A strong box: ★ Big Over Quarters [12 personnel: 31 of 49 runs, mostly outside zone and duo]; Big Over Sky; Big Under Cloud; Big Bear Sky (short yardage only). Justification: Austin runs on about 63 percent of its 12-personnel snaps, so the starred call has to fit the run with eight defenders near the box — Big Over Quarters does that with both safeties as run-support players while keeping two deep defenders against play-action. Sky adds a rotated safety to the box as a change-up; Cloud protects the boundary against the play-action shot to the second tight end.
Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. A young coordinator argues: "Self-scouting is a waste. If my call is the best call for the situation, it doesn't matter whether the offense knows it's coming." Write a response that agrees with one part of his argument and refutes another. Use the Break / Bait / Accept sort and at least one Sentinels example.
D2. The "Card" veto lets a quality control coach in the booth stop the defensive coordinator's call. Some coaches would never accept that. Make the case for it and against it. Then propose one rule that keeps the benefit and reduces the cost (for example, the 25-second call target).
D3. In the illustrative pressure/coverage table, the best mix against an average quarterback was about one pressure in four, and against Vance about one in five or six. Explain why the "right" mix depends on the quarterback, and why using one league-wide pressure rate as a target for every opponent is a mistake.
D4. Your best defensive player is a linebacker who is a devastating blitzer and an average cover player. Your self-scout shows he blitzes on 80 percent of third-and-longs. List the costs of breaking that tendency, the costs of keeping it, and the decision you'd make. Include player-development and morale considerations, not just scheme.
D5. "Bait" tendencies have a shelf life. The Sentinels kept "two-high on 3rd-and-long stays two-high" through Game 2 and spent it in the playoff. What are the risks of holding a bait tendency too long? What are the risks of spending it too early? How would you decide when to cash it in?
D6. Field position changes which mistake is expensive. For each of these four situations, name the single most expensive mistake the defense could make and the cheapest mistake it can afford: (a) 3rd-and-6 at the opponent's 4 (backed up); (b) 3rd-and-6 at midfield; (c) 3rd-and-6 at your own 30, with the opponent's kicker reliable from about 50 yards; (d) 3rd-and-goal at your own 6. Then say which of the four situations you'd be most willing to call zero in, and check your answer against the Sentinels' zero card.
D7. Tess logs the time every call reaches Bell. Suppose that through six games the call is arriving a little late on average, and the coordinator's fix is to reorganize the sheet rather than to "think faster." Explain why reorganizing a document is a better fix for a timing problem than trying harder on game day, and propose two specific changes to a call sheet's layout that would save a coordinator time.
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (Ch 25 + Ch 16) Re-grade the Week 6 call twice: once using Chapter 16's eight-row "when allowed" grid, and once using this chapter's seven filters. Which framework would have stopped the call faster on the sideline, and why? What does each framework catch that the other misses?
M2. (Ch 25 + Ch 6) Chapter 6 says the shell is not the coverage. Using the Holloway depth tell from Week 3, explain how a self-scout tests whether your disguise is real. Then describe the sequence of decisions (break, bait) that made the playoff Spin 3 interception possible.
M3. (Ch 25 + Ch 8) Chapter 8 charted 29 communication busts in Russ's first Sentinels season and 9 last season, with about a third becoming explosive plays. Using this chapter's "call for the checks your players can make" rules, propose two call-sheet rules for a road game in a loud stadium and explain how each reduces bust risk.
M4. (Ch 25 + Ch 13) Mug Cat Fire and Nickel Over Mug Quarters are a "pair." Using Chapter 13's protection arithmetic (who is counted, who is left free), explain what the offense learns from the first call of the pair and how the second call punishes what it learned.
M5. (Ch 25 + Ch 14) Chapter 14 sets an order of check words (Echo > Kill > Tilt > Roll > one coverage word > Bump/Ride). A coordinator calls a pressure, the offense shifts into an unbalanced line, then motions to empty. Walk through which words get said, by whom, and what is finally played. What does this tell the coordinator about which calls to avoid against an offense that shifts and motions on more than half its snaps (Austin: 54 percent)?
M6. (Ch 25 + Ch 1) Chapter 1 asked you to write a philosophy statement with an "exception clause" for high-volatility calls. Rewrite your exception clause as a line on a call sheet — something the coordinator in the fourth quarter could read in two seconds. Then write the "Card" sentence that would justify invoking it.
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. Self-scout a real defense. Pick one NFL defense and chart every third-and-7-or-longer snap from three of its games (All-22 or broadcast). For each snap, record the pre-snap shell (one-high, two-high, zero-high), the number of rushers, the coverage after the snap if you can identify it, and the score and quarter. Build the "rates" and "shell-to-coverage" tables from 25.6. Identify at least one tendency and sort it into Break, Bait, or Accept from that coordinator's point of view. Be honest about your sample size.
E2. The late-and-close test. Using public play-by-play data (for example, the nflverse / nflfastR datasets, which include down, distance, quarter, and score), find a way to identify long third downs in the fourth quarter of one-score games for one team across a season. Public play-by-play does not reliably include the number of pass rushers, so combine it with film or a charting source for that field. Does the defense change its behavior late and close? Write a one-page report with your method, your sample, and your caveats.
E3. The offense's chair. Watch a full game from the offense's perspective. Each time the defense shows a pre-snap look on third down, write down what you think the quarterback expects. After the snap, note whether he was right. By the fourth quarter, can you predict the defense's call? Write a short memo, in Lyle Petrakis's voice, describing the opposing coordinator's tendencies and the two calls you'd keep on the wristband for the next meeting.