Chapter 7 Exercises — Understanding Modern Offenses

Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and independent film study

Work these with a pencil and a blank sheet for drawing. Every diagram you draw should follow the book's notation: offense at the bottom, defense at the top, O O O O O for the line with the center in the middle, and a plain-language description underneath. Selected answers are in Appendix J; short answers to Part C appear in <details> blocks below.


Part A — Conceptual ⭐

A1. State the book's thesis about defense in one sentence, then name the three tools a defense uses to close the information gap.

A2. For each of the five modern weapons — RPO, motion, play-action, tempo, and the spread — name the defensive tool (preparation, recognition, disguise) or the arithmetic it primarily attacks.

A3. Define conflict defender in one sentence. Then explain why the phrase "the quarterback gets to go second" summarizes the RPO problem.

A4. What are the three things a quarterback counts on a pre-snap RPO (the "access" or "alert" throw)? Define each in a phrase.

A5. In the NFL, how far beyond the line of scrimmage may an ineligible offensive lineman be when a forward pass that crosses the line is thrown? Why does that rule shape where post-snap RPO throws go?

A6. Count the gaps: (a) five offensive linemen and no tight end; (b) five linemen and one attached tight end; (c) five linemen and two attached tight ends; (d) case (b) with a quarterback who is a real run threat.

A7. Explain the difference between motion and a shift under NFL rules. What must happen after a shift before the ball can be snapped?

A8. What is the "void" in play-action, roughly how deep is it, and which routes live there?

A9. State the NFL substitution rule that makes tempo work, in your own words.

A10. Define constraint play and give one base-play/constraint-play pair from the chapter.

A11. What is a bootleg, and how is a naked bootleg different? Which defender's discipline decides whether a naked bootleg works?

A12. Explain in two sentences why the chapter says tempo attacks the same three tools as every other weapon — preparation, recognition, and disguise — rather than being a separate kind of problem.


Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐

B1. Name the RPO family. On the end-zone film, the Outlaws line up 2x2. Before the snap, Vance looks left, then turns and throws immediately to Powers, who has drifted backward and outside behind the line of scrimmage. The offensive line run-blocked; Ruffin ran a zone path without the ball. Was this a pre-snap or post-snap RPO? What were the defensive alignment clues that likely triggered the throw?

B2. Find the conflict defender. Study this pre-snap picture.

PRE-SNAP: 11 pers., 2x2, gun

          F                                         $

   C          *           W           M                    C
                    E      T       N        E
   X       H         O   O   O   O   O   Y                 Z
                         R   Q

📊 Diagram (described): Standard 2x2 with a slot and split end on the left, a tight end attached and flanker on the right, and the running back to the quarterback's left. The defense is in nickel with two deep safeties; the nickel is halfway between the left tackle and the slot, and the two linebackers are in the box.

The run is inside zone to the right; the slot runs a slant; the split end runs a go. Identify the most likely conflict defender, his two jobs, and the direction each job pulls him.

B3. Man or zone? The Outlaws motion Powers from the left slot across to the right. Describe what you'd see if the defense were in (a) a "Ride" man call, (b) a "Bump" call. Then explain which one the Sentinels prefer on third-and-medium against Vance, and why.

B4. Play-action or real run? On two snaps from the same Stallions formation, the right guard's first step looks like this: on Snap 1, he fires out low and drives the 3-technique; on Snap 2, he punches the 3-technique and then pops up, helmet rising, sliding back. Which snap is play-action? Which defender should be reading the guard, and what should he do on each snap?

B5. Diagram it. Draw the POST-SNAP picture of the Stallions' bootleg from 7.5 as it should have been defended: Rollins staying home on the boot side, the linebackers flowing with the fake, and Royce in the deep middle. Then write the 📊 Diagram (described) line. Which receiver is still the most dangerous, and who has him?

B6. Count the box. The Outlaws line up in 12 personnel with both tight ends attached, Vance under center, Ruffin at seven yards. The Sentinels are in nickel, two-high. Count gaps, blockers, and box defenders. Where are you short, and by how many?

B8. Read the drawing. Study this post-snap picture and answer the questions below it.

POST-SNAP: 11 pers., 2x2 -- run action right, QB keeps and rolls left

          F                                         $
                  [VOID]
   C          W ->          M ->                           C
   ^      E (chased the run)     T      N        E
   |                 O   O   O   O   O   Y                 Z
   X      <~~~~~~~ Q              R ---> run fake right

📊 Diagram (described): After the snap the running back fakes a run to the right and both inside linebackers flow right with him. The defensive end on the left side has also chased the run fake down the line. The quarterback keeps the ball and rolls out to the left with nobody in front of him. The area behind the flowing linebackers, labeled the void, is empty; both safeties are still deep.

(a) Is this play-action, an RPO, or a designed quarterback run — and what single visual clue would you check on the end-zone film to be sure? (b) Who is the first defender at fault? (c) Which receiver route would you expect the offense to pair with this action, and who should be carrying it?

B7. Tempo tells. Describe three things you'd see on the sideline (TV) copy that tell you the Ospreys are about to go fast before they snap the ball.


Part C — Make the Call / Draw It ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

C1. First-and-10 against the RPO. Game 2 rematch, first quarter, 1st-and-10 at the Austin 30. Outlaws 11 personnel, 2x2, Powers in the left slot. Owen's data: 11 of their 38 RPO-tagged plays in the sample are inside zone with a slant tag to Powers from exactly this look. Your options: (a) Cover 4 with Ames as a two-way player; (b) two-high look rotating to Cover 3 at the snap, Ames as the pass player, Royce rotating down; (c) Cover 1 with Vo in man on Powers. Choose, justify, and state what you are willing to give up.

Short answer

(b) is the best fit. It keeps a two-high picture for Vance's pre-snap read, gives Ames one job (the slant window), and adds a run fitter after the snap (Royce) that the read doesn't count. You accept the inside zone gaining 3–4 yards. (a) recreates the Week 6 problem. (c) works against the slant but turns the motion game on — if Powers motions and Vo travels, Vance has a man tell, and he's 28 of 36 against five-plus rushers and lethal against man-beaters. Use (c) only as a change-up on short yardage.

C2. Twelve personnel. Outlaws in 12 personnel on 2nd-and-6 at midfield. Owen: 31 of 49 snaps from 12 are runs (mostly outside zone and duo). Do you stay in nickel, go to big nickel, or go to base? What shell do you show, and who is your alley player?

Short answer

Big nickel (Holloway in for a corner or as the fifth DB), so you have a player who can fit the tight end in the run game and carry Harlan up the seam if it's play-action. Show two-high and rotate Holloway down at the snap to get the seventh box defender; Holloway is the alley player to the tight-end side. Stay in your structure on play-action: Holloway's key is Harlan — if Harlan releases, Holloway is a pass player.

C3. Empty on third down. Ospreys, 3rd-and-5, empty 3x2, Oduya. Your options: a six-man pressure, a five-man fire zone, or a four-man rush with seven in coverage. Choose and justify with the box count and Oduya's time to throw.

Short answer

Four-man rush, seven in coverage — most likely a match or zone coverage with defenders sitting at the sticks. Empty means five blockers, no back, and a quarterback who throws in about 2.4 seconds. Six rushers leaves five defenders for five receivers with no deep help and no time to get home; a fire zone leaves three under against five receivers with an automatic hot throw. The goal is to make him throw short of the sticks and tackle the catch.

C4. Draw it: the bump. The Outlaws motion Powers from the left slot to the right, turning 2x2 into 3x1. Draw your PRE-SNAP picture after the motion (bump, not ride) and the POST-SNAP picture if the call was Cover 3. Label who has #1, #2, and #3 to the trips side underneath. Write both 📊 Diagram (described) lines.

Short answer

Pre-snap after motion: Vo stays on the left side and sinks toward the box; Ames slides toward the middle; Bell bumps out toward the trips side over the new #3 (Harlan); both safeties still at 12–13 yards. Post-snap Cover 3: Holloway buzzes down to the trips-side curl/flat, Bell has the trips-side hook, Ames the middle hook, Vo the weak curl/flat, corners deep thirds, Royce deep middle. Underneath to the trips side: Holloway is responsible for the flat area #1 or #2 runs into; Bell carries #3 through the hook.

C5. Whose fault? Week 11 at St. Louis, 1st-and-10 at the Stallions 38. Stallions 21 personnel, I-formation. Call: base, Cover 3, Holloway in the box. Outside zone fake right, Haugen boots left. Rollins stays home and forces Haugen to pull up. Ames, Bell, and Weller flow right. Royce, the deep middle safety, sees the boot and drives forward to the flat to help on Mahler. The flanker's deep crosser is caught at 16 yards and run for 25 more. Who broke his rule?

Short answer

Royce. The deep-middle safety in Cover 3 is the last line against the deep crosser and the post. Mahler in the flat belongs to the boot-side curl/flat defender (and Rollins forcing Haugen to pull up already limits the flat throw). Driving forward to the flat vacated the deep middle and left the crosser free with nobody behind him. Rule: deep middle stays deeper than the deepest receiver in his area until the ball is thrown.

C6. Make the call against tempo. Ospreys race to the line after a 9-yard completion; it's 2nd-and-1 at their own 44, nickel on the field, no substitution. Your tempo menu: Home, Sky, Fire. What do you call and what's your one alert for Bell?

Short answer

On 2nd-and-1 the offense will often take a shot or run quickly. Sky from a two-high look (the rotation adds a box defender for the short-yardage run while keeping a deep middle against the shot) is reasonable; Home is also defensible. The alert to Bell: "Shot alert — safeties stay deep on any run action." Avoid Fire; a blown fire-zone alignment against tempo is how a 1-yard down becomes a 56-yard touchdown.

C7. Name the quarterback player. Second-and-goal at your 4, the Outlaws in 11 personnel, 2x2, with the same zone-read-plus-bubble "triple" that scored in Case Study 7.1. You may change exactly one assignment among Rollins (backside end), Ames (Will), Vo (nickel), and Royce (weak safety). Make the change, state who now has the running back, the quarterback, and the bubble, and say what you are giving up.

Short answer

One sound version: keep Rollins squeezing to the back, and have Royce rotate down to take the bubble at the snap so Vo can play the quarterback off the edge. Now the back (Rollins and the inside fitters), the quarterback (Vo), and the bubble (Royce) each have an owner. You give up a safety deep on the weak side — acceptable at the 4-yard line, where the end zone is the back line of the coverage. An alternative is a scrape exchange: Rollins squeezes, Ames scrapes outside to the quarterback, and an interior defender takes Ames's inside gap. Either way, the fix is naming the quarterback player before the snap.


Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐

D1. The honest linebacker. Jordan Ames asks you, "If I'm going to be wrong either way, why not just guess?" Write the 150-word answer you'd give him in the meeting room. Include the phrase "one job at full speed."

D2. Man versus the RPO. Man coverage on the slot makes the RPO slant irrelevant. List three costs of playing man as your primary RPO answer against the Outlaws, using Owen's data where you can. Then describe one situation where you'd use it anyway.

D3. Rush-lane discipline and DeShawn Rollins. Rollins is your best pass rusher; his instinct to chase the ball is part of why he's great. On bootleg-heavy opponents like the Stallions, how do you protect the defense from his instinct without coaching the aggression out of him? Consider assignment, call structure, and how you talk to the player.

D4. Tempo and player safety. A tempo offense keeps your defensive line on the field for nine straight snaps. Discuss the performance and safety trade-offs of (a) staying with your starters, (b) rotating at the first pause even if it costs you a busted alignment, and (c) using a timeout to rotate. Which would you choose in the first quarter? In the fourth? (Do not consider faking an injury — that's a sportsmanship and rules issue, not a strategy; Chapter 29 explains why.)

D5. Accepting yards. Your Problem List says, "Against the Outlaws' RPO, we accept inside zone for 3–4 yards." Your head coach asks, "Why are we accepting anything?" Explain, using the idea that you can't take away everything and the Outlaws' blitz numbers (28 of 36, 9.4 yards per attempt, 4 TD, 0 INT against five-plus rushers).

D6. The scripted opener. Most offensive coordinators script their first eight to twelve plays, and the Outlaws' Week 6 opening drive (Case Study 7.1) was built to gather information. One school of thought says a defense should play its most vanilla calls early so the script learns nothing useful; another says it should show its most complex looks early so the script learns the wrong things. Argue for one side in 200 words, then name the single biggest risk of your choice. Consider what each approach does to your own players' confidence in the first quarter, and how each interacts with your self-scout later in the season.

D7. The bust you can live with. Against tempo you will occasionally be caught in the wrong personnel — say, your dime on the field against a sudden switch to a heavier look the offense reached without substituting (for example, by shifting a receiver into a tight-end alignment). Rank these three outcomes from least to most dangerous and explain your ranking: (a) a light box against a run, (b) a linebacker matched on a slot receiver, (c) a coverage bust with nobody deep. What does your ranking imply about the one thing your tempo menu must never sacrifice?


Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

M1. Chapter 5 + Chapter 7. In the RPO answer from 7.3, Ames gives up his run gap and Royce rotates into the alley. Using the run-fit language from Chapter 5 — force, alley, spill, squeeze — describe what the defensive end on that side must do so that Royce's fit and the end's fit don't leave a crease like the one in the Week 6 45-yard run.

M2. Chapter 6 + Chapter 7. Explain how motion threatens the threshold concept "the shell is not the coverage." Then describe two disguise principles from Chapter 6 (for example, equal-depth safeties, showing late, moving on the cadence) and how each one holds up — or doesn't — against (a) return motion and (b) motion at the snap.

M3. Chapter 4 + Chapter 7. The "win up front" answer to the RPO relies on your defensive line. Using technique numbers from Chapter 4, describe a four-man front alignment and line movement that could make inside zone fail toward the tight end without the Will linebacker's help. State the risk if the offense runs the opposite way.

M4. Chapter 3 + Chapter 7. Write a role card (five lines) for Kenny Vo as the nickel against the Outlaws, listing his alignment rule, his bubble-alert rule, his motion rule, his RPO job, and his run-fit job.

M5. Chapter 1 + Chapter 7. Vic Maddox, the blitz-everything coordinator from Russ's past, would answer tempo and RPOs by blitzing more. Using the Chapter 1 discussion of pressure versus coverage philosophies and the box-count logic of this chapter, explain when Maddox's approach would work against a modern offense and when it would fail.

M6. Chapter 2 + Chapter 7. Chapter 2 traced how every great defense answered the offense of its era. Pick two of the five modern weapons from this chapter and, for each, name an older offensive idea it descends from (for example, option football, the no-huddle, the classic play-action pass) and the historical defensive answer to that older idea. Does the historical answer still work against the modern version? Explain what changed — usually it's the combination of weapons, not the weapon itself.


Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐

E1. Chart the conflict defender. Pick one NFL offense known for RPOs and watch two of its games (the All-22 or end-zone copy is ideal; the broadcast copy works if you're patient). For every first- and second-down play where the line shows low hats while a receiver runs a quick route, record: formation, the defender you think is being read, what he did, and whether the quarterback handed off or threw. Look for a pattern: does the offense read the same position every week? Write a one-paragraph scouting note to a defensive coordinator.

E2. Motion reactions. Choose one defense and chart 30 snaps with pre-snap motion. For each, record the motion type (jet, orbit, return, short, shift), how the defense reacted (ride, bump, safety rotation, no visible change), and the coverage you believe was played after the snap. Did the pre-snap reaction tell you the coverage? Score the defense's disguise on a 1–5 scale and justify it.

E3. Tempo and the defensive line. Find a game against a high-tempo offense. Chart the defensive line's snap-by-snap participation for three long drives (who was on the field each snap). Note every pause where the defense rotated linemen and every snap where the same four linemen had played four or more in a row. Compare pass-rush effectiveness (pressures, hurries, sacks you can see) early and late in those drives. Public charting sources such as Next Gen Stats, PFF, or nflverse-distributed charting data can help with time-to-throw and participation if you can access them; describe what you used.