Chapter 24 Exercises — Defensive Game Planning
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and research
All Outlaws data refer to the Week 6 tendency report in 24.3: Owen's and Tess's 247-snap, four-game sample, which is fictional. Selected answers are in Appendix J.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. Define playbook, game plan, and call in one sentence each. Then explain why a coordinator can't skip the game plan and call straight from the playbook on Sunday.
A2. Most NFL staffs scout the opponent's last three or four games instead of the whole season. Give two reasons for using the recent games, and one kind of question where a longer sample is actually better.
A3. Tess kept plays that were wiped out by penalty in the 247-snap sample, but removed kneel-downs and spikes. Explain the logic of each choice, and explain why writing the choice down matters more than which choice you make.
A4. What is the difference between a tendency and a tell? Give one Outlaws example of each from the chapter.
A5. What is a base rate, and why is "14 of 22" on third-and-medium only meaningful when you compare it with "22 of 108" on their other called passes?
A6. Owen insists every tendency be written as a count ("14 of 22"), never a bare percentage ("64%"). What does a bare percentage hide? Describe Owen's rough confidence ladder in your own words.
A7. The weapon table in 24.6 has five columns. What is the fifth column called on the Sentinels' staff, and why does Russ say a weapon row without it is "a wish, not a decision"?
A8. Explain why the Outlaws' best weapon was defined as a condition ("Vance against pressure") rather than as a player. What does that definition point the defense toward?
A9. The game plan gets smaller from Tuesday to Saturday. Why? What does it usually mean when a plan gets bigger during the week?
A10. Name three ways a tendency report can be misleading even when every number in it is correctly counted.
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
B1. Name the concept. Outlaws, 3rd-and-6, 11 personnel, 3x1 trips to the field. At the snap, Gaines (#1) runs straight down the sideline, Powers (#2) pushes vertically to about 12 yards and breaks to the sideline, and Harlan (#3) releases to the flat at about 2 yards. Ruffin stays in to block. Is this the dig version or the flood version of their trips concept? Which level does each receiver occupy?
B2. Find the read key. Outlaws, 1st-and-10, first play of a drive, 2x2 with Harlan attached on the left. The line zone-blocks to the right, Ruffin takes the mesh, and Powers (the right slot) runs a quick slant. Vance's eyes never leave one Sentinels defender. Which defender, and what is Vance asking him?
B3. Tag the snap. Fill in these tags for the following play: down & distance, field zone, personnel, formation family, motion, play type, concept, result. "Second quarter, Outlaws ball on their own 28, 2nd-and-9. Brandt and Harlan both on the field, Brandt on a wing left, Harlan attached right, Sutton and Gaines wide. No motion. Vance fakes outside zone right to Ruffin and hits Harlan on a dig at 14 for 17 yards."
B4. Spot the tagging error. Tess's original tags show 9 digs and 2 deep crosses on third-and-4 to 6 from trips. Owen's agreement check found that two of the "deep crosses" broke at 11 yards and stayed flat across the field. Using the tag dictionary definition of a dig from 24.2, what should they be tagged, and how does the fix change the dig count?
B5. Read the picture.
PRE-SNAP: Outlaws, 11 personnel 2x2
$ F
C M W * C
E N T E
X Y O O O O O H Z
Q <~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
R
📊 Diagram (described): The Outlaws are in a two-by-two formation with Harlan attached on the left. Powers has started in the right slot and is running across the formation toward the left, just in front of Vance. The Sentinels show two safeties deep, a nickel over the slot, two linebackers, and four linemen.
Name the type of motion. According to the motion table in 24.3, how often did this family of motion become a jet sweep or a flood toward the motion? What tag did the Sentinels put in the call for it, and what does the tag tell the safeties to do?
B6. Which direction does the tell run? "All 9 of the Outlaws' scissors came from a reduced split by Gaines." A young defensive back says, "So when Gaines reduces, it's the scissors." Using the numbers in 24.4, explain what's wrong with that conclusion.
B7. Two pictures. On a 12-personnel snap, the Sentinels' big-nickel defender over Harlan sees Harlan's inside foot step down and his hands come up as if to block. A half-second later, Harlan releases into the route. Using the "two pictures" coaching point from 24.5, what should the defender have done on each picture?
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
Use the front page and the situation table in 24.7. Give the call in Sentinels call grammar (personnel, front, modifier, pressure, coverage, tag) and justify it with the report.
C1. Week 6, Q1, Outlaws' first possession, 1st-and-10 at their own 25. 11 personnel 2x2, Harlan attached left, Powers in the right slot. Make the call and give Ames his coaching point.
Answer
Home — Nickel Over Quarters, four-man rush. The front page says the first snap of a drive from 2x2 is the inside zone/slant RPO (7 of 11). Ames sits in the slant window instead of triggering on the run, and Holloway is the run fitter behind him. The call isn't special; the coaching point is.
C2. Week 6, Q2, 2nd-and-6 at the Sacramento 41. Brandt (#84) jogs onto the field. 12 personnel, Brandt on the wing left, Harlan attached right. Make the call and tell your safeties what to look at.
Answer
Big Over Quarters (Big Over Spin 3 is the second call). 12 personnel always gets big nickel. Run on 31 of 49 snaps; 11 of the 18 passes were play-action with Harlan the most common target. Safeties and the big-nickel defender: eyes on the tight end before the run fit. Tight end blocks, play the run. Tight end releases, sink under him.
C3. Week 6, Q3, 3rd-and-11 at the Austin 30. 11 personnel 2x2. Make the call. What's the danger in it, according to the scramble numbers?
Answer
Dime Over Two Man (Dime Over Spin 3 as the second call). Third-and-10+ is where the Outlaws fall off (1 of 6 converted); their favorites there are dagger and the deep crosser off play-action. The danger: Two Man is man underneath, and Vance scrambled 9 times against man for 81 yards and 6 first downs. The rush lanes must stay intact, and the Mike's rule ("back blocks, you spy") matters.
C4. You've called a five-man fire zone on 3rd-and-8. The Outlaws line up 2x2, and then Ruffin motions out of the backfield to empty. What happens to your call, who makes the change, and why does the tendency report agree?
Answer
Echo: Bell kills the pressure, and the defense plays Buzz 3 with a four-man rush. Ruffin motioning out produced 19 of the Outlaws' 21 empty snaps, and empty means quick game: Vance will have the ball out before five rushers get home, with every receiver out against fewer coverage defenders. Echo overrides any coverage check. (The "Stay" tag that keeps a pressure on against empty is never used against a Vance-type quarterback.)
C5. Week 6, Q4, 3rd-and-5 at the Sacramento 38. Trips to the field again. Sutton has beaten Brennan twice on the backside isolation already. Do you stay with Lock? What's your second call, and what does it give up?
Answer
This is the moment the plan prepared for. The second call in the third-and-medium row is Nickel Over Six, with the Cover 2 half (the "cloud side") to the boundary on Sutton. Brennan gets a safety over the top. The cost: the trips side plays quarters without the Lock help, so the dig is harder to take away completely. You go to Six because the fifth column said "Sutton vs. Brennan," and the offense has now collected on it twice. Decide before the game how many times you'll let the "live with" play beat you. Two in a game is a reasonable trigger.
C6. Draw it. Draw the post-snap picture of Quarters Lock against the dig version of the trips concept, labeling all eleven defenders' jobs. Then answer: if Powers (#2) runs vertical instead of the out, who takes him, and what happens to Holloway's eyes?
Answer
See the Lock post-snap diagram and rules table in 24.6. If #2 goes vertical, it's Holloway's — the quarters safety takes a vertical #2 man-to-man — and Simmons is alone on #1. The dig by Gaines then becomes Simmons's alone with Vo and Bell underneath, and Royce still has #3. This is the Chapter 11 #2 read inside a trips check.
C7. Week 6, Q2, 2nd-and-2 at midfield. 11 personnel, Harlan attached, Ruffin offset. Make the call. What item from the second-down tendency table drives your coaching point?
Answer
Home, with Nickel Over Spin 1 as the second call. On 2nd-and-1 to 3, the Outlaws took a downfield play-action shot on 6 of 17 snaps, all from this exact look. That's a lean, not a plan, so it doesn't drive the call. It drives the eyes: safeties and corners see their man before the run fit. A safety who triggers on the run fake on 2nd-and-2 gives up a touchdown.
C8. Build the front-page line. Tess hands you this raw tendency from the Week 6 sample: "3rd-and-7 to 9: 9 snaps, all dropbacks; converted 2 of 9; Gaines first read on 6." Turn it into a front-page-style line with all four parts: count, confidence-ladder label, decision, and what you'll live with.
Answer
Line: "3rd-and-7 to 9: Gaines is the first read (6 of 9); they convert 2 of 9." Ladder: Fewer than 10 snaps, so it's a story about the concept. But it's consistent with the bigger third-down target number (Gaines 19 of 41, 13 on 3rd-and-6+), so the player part is a plan. Decision: Nickel Over Spin 3 (Nickel Over Robber as the second call); the rotation puts a post safety on top of Gaines, and the underneath defenders rally and tackle short of the sticks. Live with: Checkdowns to Ruffin and the hitch to Sutton, short of the line to gain.
C9. Plan the counter to your own plan. Austin's Week 6 tape shows the Sentinels in Quarters Lock on most third-and-mediums from trips. You're Petrakis, game-planning Week 15. Name two calls you'd use to attack Lock. Then switch back to Russ's chair and say which item on the Sentinels' plan already anticipates each one.
Answer
Petrakis's attacks: (1) Isolate Sutton backside against Brennan with a back-shoulder fade or a hitch-and-go. Lock leaves Brennan in man with no help. (2) Use #3 (Harlan) on a drag or a short option route so Royce, who reads #3 in Lock, comes off the deep middle, then throw behind him. Russ's plan: The first is the "live with" item, and its second call, Six with the cloud to the boundary on Sutton, is already written on the sheet. The second is answered by Royce's rule: he reads #3 only vertically and stays deep when #3 goes short, while Bell and Vo handle the short #3 routes. Watch for it on film, because Petrakis will test that rule early.
C10. Echo or Stay? Week 6, 3rd-and-9. You've called a five-man fire zone (not Mug Cat Fire; a different pressure from your package). Ruffin motions out and the Outlaws go empty. Your call sheet does not have a "Stay" tag on this pressure. What happens, and could a coordinator ever justify putting "Stay" on a pressure against this quarterback?
Answer
Bell Echoes: the pressure is killed and the defense plays Buzz 3 with four rushers. Without a Stay tag, Echo is automatic against empty. Against Vance, "Stay" is very hard to justify. Five rushers against empty takes away his checkdown, but it gives him five receivers against six coverage defenders, and the Week 6 report showed him at 9.4 yards per attempt against pressure. The Chapter 14 rule — Stay is never used against a Vance-type quarterback — exists for exactly this case.
Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. Week 6, Q4, tied, 3rd-and-8. The front page says four-man rush and rotation. Your gut says it's time to "make something happen." Write the three sentences you would want a smarter version of yourself to say to you on the headset. Then explain where in the game-plan process that voice should be built, so it's there on Sunday.
D2. Gabe wants to build a special call for the 2nd-and-short play-action shot (6 of 17). Owen says it's a story, not a plan. Make the case for each side, then decide. Your decision should say what goes on the call sheet, what goes into practice, and what goes nowhere.
D3. For the Week 15 rematch, Tess considers two samples: (a) the Outlaws' last four games, which don't include Week 6; or (b) Week 6 plus their last three games. Argue for each. Which did the Sentinels choose, and what extra step protected them from over-weighting one game?
D4. An assistant proposes bracketing Gaines (two defenders on him) on every third down of the game, since he's their third-down weapon (19 of 41 targets). Fill in all five weapon-table columns for this plan. Where does the "what they get instead" column land, and would you live with it against this offense?
D5. Owen's tagging found one game in the sample with a 21-point fourth-quarter lead, in which the Outlaws ran on 9 of 11 snaps. A junior analyst wants to delete those 11 snaps "to clean the data." Owen refuses but flags them. Explain the difference between deleting and flagging, and name one tendency question where those 11 snaps are exactly the right data (hint: think about Chapter 28 and protecting a lead).
D6. Tess's hot-throw cutup for Week 15 (Case Study 24.1) found 8 of 8 hot throws to one window when the A-gaps showed pressure. Russ built Mug Cat Fire on it and limited it to twice per game. Argue for and against a limit of once per game. What does each choice assume about how fast Petrakis adjusts?
D7. A head coach tells his coordinator, "Our plan is to take away everything they like." Explain, using the chapter's "plan that takes away everything" mistake, what will actually happen on Sunday, and write a better one-sentence plan for the same opponent.
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (Chapter 6 + Chapter 24) Vance: 31 of 52, 6.1 yards per attempt, 3 INT against a four-man rush with post-snap rotation; 24 of 36, 7.2, 1 INT against a four-man rush with the shell held. Explain the difference using Chapter 6's threshold concept. Then name one disguise from Chapter 6 you would put in this game plan and say on which down and distance.
M2. (Chapter 7 + Chapter 21 + Chapter 24) The inside zone/slant RPO puts one defender in conflict. Using Chapter 7's conflict-defender idea and Chapter 21's eye-discipline rules for linebackers, write Ames's key-and-read card for the first snap of an Outlaws drive from 2x2, and for every other snap.
M3. (Chapter 13 + Chapter 18 + Chapter 24) The front page allows pressure only "with a lineman dropping into the hot window." Using Chapter 13's fire-zone structure (5 rush, 3 under, 3 deep) and Chapter 18's protection math, explain why a five-man pressure that drops a defensive tackle can be safer against Vance than a five-man pressure that drops nobody from the line.
M4. (Chapter 14 + Chapter 24) List every check word from Chapter 14 that the Outlaws tendency report makes necessary, and match each one to the tendency-table line that justifies it (formation family, motion, empty, condensed, unbalanced).
M5. (Chapter 22 + Chapter 23 + Chapter 24) The "live with" list gives up Sutton's hitch and Ruffin in the flat. For each, name the Sentinels defender who has to make the tackle, his run-support or pursuit angle from Chapter 22, and the tackling technique from Chapter 23 that keeps the play a short gain.
M6. (Chapter 11 + Chapter 24) The scissors (#1 post, #2 corner) produced 5 of the Outlaws' 15 explosive passes. Using Chapter 11's quarters rules, explain why the scissors stresses quarters specifically, and why the "reduced split" alert is a reminder to Royce rather than a check.
M7. (Chapter 1 + Chapter 24) The Sentinels' philosophy is "coverage first, pressure on purpose." Using three lines from the Week 6 front page, show how the game plan expresses that philosophy against one opponent. Then name the line that Russ broke in the fourth quarter at Austin and which part of the Chapter 1 hierarchy (philosophy, scheme, system, playbook, game plan, call) failed.
M8. (Chapter 3 + Chapter 24) "12 personnel always gets big nickel." Using the Chapter 3 package menu and the 12-personnel row of the tendency report, explain who comes on and who comes off when Brandt (#84) jogs onto the field, and why that substitution fits the Outlaws' 31-of-49 run tendency better than staying in nickel.
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. Build a mini tendency report. Pick one NFL offense and watch its last two games (broadcast or All-22). Tag every third down with: distance bucket, personnel, formation family, concept (as best you can tell), target, and result. Build the third-down-by-distance table from 24.3. Write a front page of three items, each with a count and a decision. Note which tags you could not fill in from the broadcast angle, and why.
E2. Test a tendency. Using public play-by-play data (for example, the nflverse / nflfastR data sets), compute one team's run rate on first down over its last four games and over the full season. Compare them. Then find one game where game script (a big lead or deficit) changed the run rate, and recompute the four-game number with and without that fourth quarter. How much did it move? Write two sentences that Owen would sign off on.
E3. Watch a game plan. Watch a game in which one defense clearly took away the opponent's best receiver or best concept (look for repeated brackets, rolled coverage, or a spy). Chart every snap where the offense's best weapon was targeted, and every snap where the "what they get instead" option was targeted. Did the defense live with its fifth column, or abandon it? At what point in the game, and after what play?