Chapter 5 Exercises — Gap Integrity and Run Fits
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and research
Use the book's notation from the chapter: gaps A–D on each side of the center; technique numbers 0 (head-up on center) through 9 (outside shade of the tight end); offense at the bottom, defense at the top. Selected answers are in Appendix J. Short answers to the Part C items are given below each item.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. Define gap integrity in one sentence. Then explain why a defender who fills an occupied gap reduces the defense's gap integrity instead of adding to it.
A2. List the gap count for each structure: (a) 10 personnel, empty, pocket quarterback; (b) 11 personnel with one attached tight end, quarterback hands off; (c) 12 personnel "Ace," two attached tight ends; (d) 11 personnel with a zone-read quarterback. Which of these is the "eight gaps" of the chapter title, and which one gives the defense the most runners to account for?
A3. Define force, alley, cutback, and contain. For each, name the player who most commonly has it in a Cover 3 Sky call.
A4. In your own words, describe the three ways a defender can play a block — box, spill, squeeze — and state where each one "promises" the ball will go.
A5. Why does the chapter say "the technique is a promise to your teammates"? Give one example in which keeping the promise means the defender never touches the ball carrier.
A6. What is an extra hat, and why is the extra hat, not the defender who beats his block most dramatically, usually the one who makes the tackle in a sound fit?
A7. Explain how a two-gap nose tackle like Viliami Tuipulotu "finds" a missing box defender for a nickel defense. What does the defense give up in exchange?
A8. In inside zone, what are "bang," "bend," and "bounce"? Which of the three was the 45-yard run in Austin, and which defenders' errors produced it?
A9. Why does the chapter insist that "you cannot install a coverage without installing its run fit"? Use Cover 2 and Cover 4 as your two examples.
A10. State Dre Whitaker's rule for linebackers about open gaps, and explain the offensive reason the rule exists.
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
B1. Study the diagram and identify the gap count, the empty gap (if any), and the defender most likely responsible.
PRE-SNAP: who owns the right C-gap?
F $
M W
E N T E
C B A A B C D
X H O O O O O Y Z
R Q
📊 Diagram (described): An 11-personnel, 2x2 offense with a tight end attached on the right and seven gaps marked. On defense: an end outside the left tackle, a nose head-up on the center, a 3-technique outside the right guard, and an end in a 5-technique outside the right tackle — inside the tight end. The Mike is over the left B-gap and the Will over the right B/C area. Two safeties are deep. Nobody is aligned outside the tight end.
B2. On All-22 film you see the following: at the snap, the tight end blocks down on the 5-technique, the right tackle blocks down on the 3-technique, the left guard pulls to the right, and the fullback runs at the outside linebacker aligned outside the tight end. Name the run scheme and identify the end man on the line of scrimmage.
B3. Describe what you would expect to see from a spill player and from a box player when each is kicked out by a fullback. What does each player's outside arm do?
B4. You freeze the end-zone camera when the back plants. You see: nose on the center, 3-technique in the B-gap, the playside linebacker also in the B-gap, the playside end outside the tight end and holding, and the alley safety ten yards deep and three yards inside the tight end. The back is cutting into the C-gap. Who busted? What is the likely result?
B5. On a counter play, the backside end flies upfield after the back's first step and the quarterback pulls the ball and runs behind him. Name the backside end's assignment on counter, and the specific eye error he made.
B6. Draw (or describe precisely) the post-snap picture of a correct fit against outside zone toward a 9-technique Sam, with a Cover 3 Sky strong safety outside him and a Mike linebacker aligned over the backside B-gap. Include where the ball should cut and who should meet it.
B7. A strong safety's path on film goes straight from his alignment to the spot where the handoff occurred. The back bounces outside. Name the error and describe the correct path.
B8. Identify the run scheme, the technique the end man on the line used, and whether the linebacker's fit matched it.
POST-SNAP: name the scheme -- did the fit match?
$
M
\
v
E N T E S
O O O O O Y B
LG ----->
Q
R -----> ^ cuts inside S
📊 Diagram (described): The tight end and right tackle have blocked down, and the left guard is pulling to the right behind the line. A fullback has run at the Sam linebacker, who is outside the tight end; the Sam has kept the fullback in front of him and stayed outside. The Mike linebacker has come downhill toward the hole just inside the Sam. The tailback is cutting up inside the Sam toward the Mike. The strong safety is outside and deep.
B9. You are charting a high school game. The offense is in split backs. On the snap, the right back runs into the B-gap, the quarterback rides him while staring at your defensive end, and the left back swings wide behind the quarterback. Name the play, name the three runners the defense must account for, and identify the quarterback's first read.
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
C1. Draw the fit. Sentinels "Bull Quarters" vs. Outlaws 11 personnel, 2x2, Harlan attached right, Ruffin offset left. Austin runs inside zone left (away from Harlan). Build the full run-fit table: every defender's gap, technique, and special job (force, alley, cutback, contain, QB).
Short answer
Playside (left): Rollins (5-technique) owns the weak C-gap and is the edge — box technique against the left tackle's reach. Bell owns the weak B-gap and fills downhill. Big V (0) owns both A-gaps. Vo, apexed over Powers, is the weak force/alley outside Rollins. Royce reads #2 (Powers); if Powers blocks or the run is clear, Royce fits the alley inside-out. Brennan reads #1 (Sutton), pass first, then outside-in force. Backside (right): Coleman (3-technique) squeezes down the line and chases the cutback; Ames owns the C-gap and becomes the cutback player inside-out; Greer is backside contain and the QB player on any keep or boot; Holloway is the backside safety — cutback alley and pursuit to the pylon; Simmons plays pass first on Gaines.
C2. Make the call. Stallions at Sentinels. 2nd-and-3 at the Sentinels' 38, second quarter, 10–7 Stallions. The Stallions are in 21 personnel (Mahler at fullback, Day at tailback). Owen's tendency report says that from this personnel and formation on short yardage, they run power to the tight-end side on most snaps and play-action bootleg on the rest. Do you call spill or box at the point of attack? Who has the bootleg?
Short answer
A strong argument exists for spill: on short yardage the danger is the downhill hit for 3 yards, and spilling the kick-out and the puller kills the designed hole and makes Day run sideways, where Bell scraping over the top and Holloway as force can tackle him short of the sticks. The bootleg belongs to the backside edge (Rollins) as contain, with the backside linebacker holding his ground for one count before flowing. A box call is also sound if your edge player is stronger than your fullback matchup; what matters is that the Mike's rule matches the call.
C3. Draw it. Draw the post-snap fit for power right against a box call in base "Bull" (Sam at 9, strong end at 5, 3-technique, 0 nose, Mike over the weak B-gap, Will stacked as plus-one, Cover 3 Sky). Label who fills inside the kick-out and who is the safety valve.
Short answer
The Sam takes on the fullback with his inside shoulder, outside arm free — the edge stays closed. The strong end squeezes the tight end's down block. The Will (plus-one) fills inside the kick-out and meets the pulling guard in the hole, taking him on with his outside shoulder so the ball stays inside him. The Mike fills inside-out behind the Will. The strong safety stays outside as force — the safety valve if anything gets outside the Sam. The nose holds the center's back block.
C4. Make the call. Ospreys at Sentinels. 1st-and-10 at the Oklahoma City 25, first quarter, no score, tempo offense. The Ospreys line up in 10 personnel, 3x1, empty of tight ends, with Marcus Oduya in the shotgun and a running back beside him. Oduya is a quick-game passer who almost never runs. How many gaps must you fit? Would you play two-high with six in the box? Justify with box math.
Short answer
Six gaps (no tight end, non-running quarterback). Six in the box — four linemen and two linebackers — is a hat for every gap. Two-high is defensible: the offense has five linemen to block six defenders, so one box defender is unblocked by design. The risk is the running back's single-back runs against a light box if a lineman gets moved; the reward is two deep safeties against a quick-game, four-wide offense.
C5. Whose fault? Week 15 rematch, Austin inside zone right against "Bull Quarters." Tavon Greer keeps his outside arm free and sets the edge against Harlan's reach. Jordan Ames fills the C-gap. Coleman is driven out of the B-gap by the double team, and the right guard climbs to Ames. Ruffin hits the B-gap for 9 yards. Who busted, and was the fit structurally sound?
Short answer
The fit was structurally sound — every gap had an owner. The failure was Coleman's technique: he lost his gap to the double team (the "bang" failure). Ames correctly stayed in C rather than abandoning it, and Holloway's job was to arrive as the alley player and limit the gain. This is a defensive-line technique correction, not a fit correction.
C6. Whose fault? Outlaws at Sentinels, divisional playoff, first quarter, 1st-and-10 at the Austin 40. 12 personnel, Harlan attached right and a second tight end attached left. The Sentinels are in nickel "Bull Quarters" because the Outlaws went no-huddle and the Sentinels could not substitute. Austin runs outside zone left, away from Harlan. Rollins (weak 5-technique) gets reached by the left tight end. Bell (weak B-gap) fast-flows and fits outside Rollins. Vo, apexed outside, is cracked by the left wide receiver. Royce (weak safety) is reading the second tight end and is late. The back cuts up inside Rollins for 14 yards. List every gap on the left side, who owned it, and what broke first.
Short answer
With a second tight end on the left, the left side now has a D-gap the nickel "Bull" call never assigned, because "Bull" was built against one tight end — eight gaps, seven assigned. That is the first break: an uncounted gap, a coaching and communication problem when the offense used tempo to keep the nickel on the field. Rollins was then reached, which pulled the C-gap outside; Bell compensated by fitting outside him, which left the B-gap, and the back cut up through it. Vo's crack and Royce's late read are secondary. The fix lives in the call sheet: a tempo-safe check for 12 personnel (for example, a rule that the weak safety or nickel fits the new D-gap whenever a second tight end attaches), covered in Chapter 29.
C7. Make the call. You are the defensive coordinator of a college team. Ball on the left hash; the opponent has a tight end to the boundary (the short side) and two receivers to the wide field. They run outside zone into the boundary on a high share of first downs. Who should be your boundary force player, and why might that differ from your NFL-style coverage-based rule?
Short answer
Make the boundary corner the force player. With college hashes 40 feet apart, the boundary is short enough that the corner can play force without abandoning a huge pass area, and a cloud (corner-force) rotation to the boundary keeps both safeties available to the wide field and the alley. In the NFL, with hashes much closer together, coverage-based force rules (whoever the coverage puts in the flat) are more practical than field/boundary rules.
C8. Make the call — the RPO preview. A run-pass option (RPO) pairs a run play with a quick throw and lets the quarterback read one defender — often the linebacker or nickel whose run fit takes him away from a receiver. Using the "Bull Quarters" fit, identify which Sentinels defender is most likely to be the RPO read when Austin pairs inside zone with a quick slant to Mekhi Powers, and explain why a perfectly sound run fit can still give up a completed pass.
Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. Spill or box as your default answer to gap schemes? Write a one-paragraph argument for each, then choose for a defense whose linebackers are very fast but undersized and whose edge players are long and strong. Explain how the choice changes if your linebackers are slow but powerful.
D2. The chapter's two-gap nose lets a nickel defense fit seven gaps with six box players. What does the nose's two-gap role cost the pass rush on early downs, and how would you decide whether that cost is worth paying against a team like the Outlaws, whose 11-personnel run game is heavily inside zone?
D3. Player safety. You want your defense to run "fit and freeze" with full contact every day in the week before a game against a power team. Your head coach is worried about practice load. Propose a weekly plan that still builds the fits (consider thud tempo, walk-throughs, and limited live reps) and explain how you will check that players fit with their heads out of contact.
D4. After the 45-yard run, Russ put his own name on the board. A colleague argues that this "lets players off the hook." Make the case for and against a coordinator owning a player's bust in front of the room. What does Russ's choice teach Tavon Greer about the difference between a bust and a coaching error?
D5. Rotating a safety down gives you a hat for every gap, but it moves the force to one side (see the Try It in 5.7). How would you decide whether to rotate toward the tight end or away from it against the Stallions, who like to run outside zone away from your rotation and bootleg back?
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (With Chapter 4 — Defensive Fronts.) Take your Chapter 4 Base Front Sheet. For each defensive lineman in your base front, write his technique number and the gap he controls. Now count: do your linemen and linebackers cover every gap against 11 personnel with one attached tight end? If not, who is your seventh fitter? Repeat against 12 personnel.
M2. (With Chapter 3 — Personnel.) The Outlaws switch from 11 personnel to 12 personnel and you stay in nickel instead of subbing to base or big nickel. How many gaps do you now face, and who is the eighth fitter? Compare this to subbing Tre Holloway in as a big nickel. What does each option cost you against play-action to Brooks Harlan?
M3. (With Chapter 1 — Defensive Philosophy.) Russ's philosophy is "coverage-first, pressure on purpose." Explain how that philosophy shows up in his run fit (two-high shell, two-gap nose, safeties as alley players). How would a pressure-first defense like Vic Maddox's fit inside zone differently?
M4. (With Chapter 2 — The Evolution of Defense.) The 1985 Chicago Bears' 46 defense is widely described as overloading the line so that offensive linemen could not easily reach the linebackers. In run-fit language, what problem was that front solving, and what do modern spread formations do that makes such a front harder to play?
M5. (Preview of Chapter 6 — Coverage Shells.) Before the snap you show two-high. After the snap you spin to single-high Cover 3. Who is your alley player against a run toward the strong side before the rotation and after it? What happens to the run fit if the offense snaps the ball before the rotation is finished?
M6. (With Chapter 3 and Chapter 4 together.) Write a one-paragraph scouting note for a coordinator facing the Stallions, who live in 12 and 21 personnel and run outside zone with play-action bootlegs off it. Recommend a personnel package (Chapter 3), a front with technique numbers (Chapter 4), and the run-fit rule for your edge player and your backside linebacker (this chapter). State the gap count for each Stallions personnel group and identify your extra hat.
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. Explosive-run autopsy. Pick one NFL game this week and find every run of 12 or more yards. For each, freeze the frame when the back plants to cut and record: (a) formation and gap count, (b) which gap the run went through, (c) whether that gap was empty, doubled, or owned, (d) which defender, by position, should have owned it, and (e) whether a missed tackle followed. Summarize: what share of the explosive runs began with a fit error rather than a missed tackle? Treat your result as a small sample, not a league truth.
E2. Spill or box? Choose one NFL defense and watch at least ten gap-scheme runs (power, counter, or other plays with a pulling lineman) against it. On each, record whether the end man on the line spilled or boxed the kick-out, and where the linebackers fit. Does the defense have a consistent rule? Does it change by opponent or situation?
E3. Public data. Using public play-by-play data (for example, the nflverse / nflfastR play-by-play, which records run location and the gap the run was charted through), compare one team's success rate on runs charted to the end of the line versus runs charted between the tackles across a season. Write one paragraph about what the numbers can and cannot tell you about that team's edge play, given that play-by-play does not record defensive assignments.