Chapter 29 — Discussion Guide

Opening question

"A defense faces 22 tempo snaps and has zero communication busts. It also gives up 6.2 yards a play on those snaps, against 4.6 on everything else. Did it defend tempo well?"

Let students split. Some will say yes — the communication worked. Others will say no — the results didn't. Then show Owen's split: 4.7 on snaps 1–3 of a series, 9.4 on snaps 4 and later, with his warning that seven snaps is nothing.

Why it works: it separates two things students assume are the same — being organized against tempo and being good against it. Tess's line, "We were clean on tempo," and Owen's, "We weren't good on tempo," frame the whole chapter. It also lets you name early what tempo really takes, in Mike Sorensen's order: personnel, legs, and only then a bust.


Discussion questions

Tier 1 — Recall

1. State the substitution rule that makes tempo work. Why isn't an incompletion a window? Listen for: if the offense substitutes, the defense gets time to match; if it doesn't, the defense gets no such protection. An incompletion stops the clock but doesn't protect your substitution — the offense can sprint to the line and snap with your sub running on. Follow-up probe: "Name four real windows." (Offense substitutes, a timeout, change of possession, end of quarter or two-minute warning, review or long walk-off, a genuine injury stoppage.)

2. Recite the six questions of the tempo test. Which does Russ say most staffs skip? Listen for: one word/board/signal; starts from the Home shell; automatic formation rules; playable by every stranded package; sound vs. 2x2, 3x1, empty, and run; thirty reps in noise. Question 2. Follow-up probe: "Why does question 4 matter more against tempo than in a huddle game?" (You might be stuck in any package.)

Tier 2 — Analysis

3. Why does every tempo call start from the same shell? What does that protect besides simplicity? Listen for: nothing to move before the snap, nothing to reveal — and "the shell is not the coverage" still holds at speed, because the quarterback sees the same picture before Home, Sky, Robber, and Fire. Follow-up probe: "What would a tempo offense do if your Fire call always came from a different shell?" (Read it and throw hot.)

4. Sort into "on the board" and "off": Home, Mug Cat Fire, Quarters Meg, Sky, Six to the boundary, Mac Dog Zero. Give one reason for each rejection. Listen for: Home and Sky on; Mug Cat Fire fails question 2 (three pre-snap movements); Quarters Meg is a fragile partnership at speed; field/boundary Six fails the strength-rule test (Six Weak passes); zero fails soundness when stranded. Follow-up probe: "What goes in the weekly fifth slot, and who decides?"

5. The hook's 14-yard run came on the twos' fourth straight snap after a legal window. What should Lou have done differently? Listen for: the tempo group rule — Fifita isn't in it against 10 personnel; starters start every series; rotate only at windows with the designated group. The window was legal; the personnel choice wasn't built for tempo. Follow-up probe: "What does 'the tap' let a player do that going down on the field would also do — honestly?"

Tier 3 — Judgment and ethics

6. A college coordinator says faking an injury against a tempo team is "no different from icing a kicker." Respond. Listen for: icing uses a legal timeout the rules give you; a faked injury deceives officials and medical staff to take away an advantage the rules give the offense. Then Russ's other reasons — it endangers the next player who's actually hurt, it teaches players the scheme includes lying, and film shows everything. Follow-up probe: "If you think tempo is genuinely a player-safety problem, what's the legitimate way to act on that?" (Argue the rules — the 2014 NCAA proposal is an example.)

7. In Case Study 29.1, Russ overrode his own stranded-dime card with "Dime Over Two," and the Ospreys ran a draw for 17. What should happen to the coordinator after that snap? Listen for: the same thing that happens to a player who breaks a rule — it gets graded, named, and fixed. The Sentinels' fix: the stranded-dime call now sits in a red border in the tempo box and "Card" applies to it. Follow-up probe: "Why is it important for players to see the coordinator held to the card?"

8. A head coach wants tempo conditioning done in one brutal Monday session "so they're ready." What do you say, and who has the authority to stop a tempo period? Listen for: the 🩺 guidance — build gradually across the week and season, follow the athletic trainer's heat and hydration plan, and give the trainer real authority to pull a player. Tired players tackle with their heads down and arrive late to collisions. Follow-up probe: "How do you make practice fast without making it longer or more violent?" (Pace, the two-ball method, thud tempo, set-time standards.)


Structured role-play: the hamstring signal

Setup. Adapted from Case Study 29.2. A Division II staff is down 14–0 after the first quarter against Ridgeway State's no-huddle spread. The coordinator, Dale Purcell — not a villain, a decent coach under pressure — tells his graduate assistant to relay "the hamstring signal" to a senior defensive tackle.

Roles. Purcell (makes the request and the case for it: "everybody does it," "we're getting run off the field"); the graduate assistant (young Russ — must decide on the spot); the head coach (arrives a minute later and asks what's going on); the head athletic trainer (speaks only to what happens to the next real injury).

Rules. Four minutes. The GA may refuse, comply, or propose an alternative — but must say it out loud to Purcell. The trainer must describe, concretely, what happens when trainers and crowds start doubting injuries. Do not play this for laughs.

What to draw out. In the case, Curtis Boone faked twice; later, sophomore free safety Sam Whitlock suffered a real, season-ending knee injury while the crowd booed. Russ refused to relay the signal again, and every staff handbook he has written since opens with "We do not fake injuries." Ask students what sentence will open theirs, and who on a staff has the standing to refuse.


Connecting to the case studies

Case Study 29.1 — Stranded in Dime at Oklahoma City. Third quarter: Oduya converts 3rd-and-7 against dime and goes tempo. Sky, incomplete. Then Russ overrides the card — "Dime Over Two" — and gives up the 17-yard draw Chapter 22 described from the safety's side. Sky holds a run to 2; a fresh Ospreys back (a window) lets the Sentinels get back to nickel; Robber on 3rd-and-3 and Vo breaks it up; punt. Ask: which snap in that series was the coordinator's, and which were the players'?

Case Study 29.2 — The Hamstring Signal. Use it for the role-play above. Then ask: what would an honest version of the same afternoon have looked like? (The tap, windows, a timeout, a simpler board — and accepting the yards.)


Closing synthesis prompt

"Write the first line of your staff handbook's tempo section."

Collect a few. Some will be schematic ("Every tempo call starts from the Home shell"); some will be ethical ("We do not fake injuries"). Read one of each aloud. Then close on Russ's coach's point from §29.8: if tempo is beating you, the fix is on Wednesday, not on the turf. Every answer in this chapter is legal. Use all of them before you're ever tempted by the one that isn't.