Chapter 35 Exercises — Defensive Culture
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and original research
Selected answers are in Appendix J. Short answers
to the Part C items are given in <details> blocks below each one.
All Sentinels, Outlaws, Stallions, and Ospreys players, games, and numbers are fictional.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. Define defensive culture in one sentence, using the chapter's definition. Then explain in two sentences how culture differs from scheme.
A2. What is the difference between a rule and a standard? Give one example of each from a defensive meeting room, and explain how each one is enforced.
A3. State the Sentinels' full definition of a loaf. For each of its three key phrases ("visible," "before the whistle," and "could still affect the play, or whose job required him to keep running"), explain what mistake in grading that phrase prevents.
A4. Name the five loaf categories the Sentinels chart, and give a one-line film example of each.
A5. List four things that are not loafs, and say where each is charted instead.
A6. What is the two-coach rule? Which other Sentinels chart uses the same rule, and for which category?
A7. Define hats at the whistle. On which plays does Owen chart it, and why does he call it "partly an outcome stat"?
A8. Define a ball attack. Why does Owen chart ball attacks per game rather than takeaways as the weekly coaching number?
A9. What does "name it, own it, fix it" sound like in a meeting? Write the three parts for a corner who peeked into the backfield and lost his receiver on a double move.
A10. Why did Russ cross "angry" off the poster-word list, and what word did he use instead? What two numbers on Owen's sheet measure the difference between them?
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
B1. Here's a freeze frame from a run that gained 14 yards. The ball carrier is at R. The ring is five yards around him.
FREEZE FRAME at the whistle: run right, +14
. . . . .
. .
. W R * .
. $ .
. . . . .
M (jogging) E (sprinting) C (carrying #1)
T (on ground, getting up) N (walking)
E (holding backside) F (pylon angle) C
📊 Diagram (described): A frozen picture at the whistle of a 14-yard run to the right. A ring marks five yards around the ball carrier. Inside the ring are three defenders: the Will linebacker, the strong safety, and the nickel. Outside the ring: the Mike linebacker is labeled jogging, one end is sprinting, one corner is carrying the outside receiver downfield, a defensive tackle is getting up off the ground, the nose is labeled walking, the other end is labeled holding the backside, the free safety is on a pylon angle, and the second corner is far away.
(a) What's the hats-at-the-whistle count? (b) Which defenders outside the ring are probably graded +, and why? (c) Which are candidates for an L, and what more would you need to see on the film before charting them? (d) The defensive tackle is getting up off the ground. What category might that be, and what's the one condition under which it should be marked M instead?
B2. Read the effort-dot rows below (one dot per second; wider spacing = faster) and grade each defender + or L with a category.
1 C . . . . . . . |whistle
2 T . . . . . . . . . . . . . |whistle
3 W . . . . . . . . |whistle
4 E . . . . (hold) . . . . |whistle
📊 Diagram (described): Four rows of dots, one dot per second from the snap to the whistle. Row 1, a corner, has evenly wide gaps all the way to the whistle. Row 2, a defensive tackle, has small, evenly spaced dots throughout. Row 3, a Will linebacker, starts with wide gaps, then the dots bunch tightly together and stop well before the whistle. Row 4, an end, bunches briefly while holding, then runs with wide gaps to the whistle.
Row 2 is the hard one. What would you need to know before grading it?
B3. Watch the Game 3 slot-screen description in 35.2 again. Without looking, list the order of arrival of the first five defenders and say what each one's pursuit job was.
B4. On the first-season screen in the hook, five defenders were jogging. Using the five loaf categories, which category fits "jogging after deciding the play belongs to somebody else"? Which category would fit the nose, who was getting up off the ground, if he wasn't hurt?
B5. A broadcast replay shows a defensive end chasing a quarterback scramble and slowing down as the quarterback steps out of bounds a yard short of the sideline. The whistle blows a half-second later. Is that a loaf? Explain your reasoning in terms of the whistle rule ("to the whistle, not past it").
B6. Describe what you'd see on the end-zone copy that tells you an overlap man in Tip and Overlap did the drill correctly. Describe one thing that tells you he did it wrong.
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
C1. (A hypothetical drill, not one of the season's actual events.) It's the Monday after Week 11 at St. Louis. Owen's sheet shows seven confirmed loafs, more than twice the team average. Five belong to the defensive line, and four of those five came in the fourth quarter on a drive where the Stallions ran 12 plays. The Sentinels won 17–13. Write the next three things you do, in order, and say what you're testing with each.
Short answer
(1) Check whether they're really loafs. Re-watch the four fourth-quarter clips with the second coach and ask whether these were speed losses or tired defenders still going at full speed. (2) Check the rotation. Pull the snap counts. If the line played 12 straight snaps without the rotation Big Lou planned, the loafs are at least partly a staff problem (substitution and practice load), and you fix the rotation before you put anyone on the reel. (3) Show the confirmed loafs on the reel anyway, with names and the fix, and show the rotation chart in the staff meeting. The standard doesn't bend for fatigue, but the coaches own the part that's theirs. If the confirmed loafs are spread across the whole line, talk to the council's DL seats (Rollins and Big V) before Monday.
C2. Draw it. From the Home pre-snap picture in 35.2 (Outlaws 11 personnel 2x2, tight end right), Austin runs a bubble screen to Mekhi Powers in the left slot instead of the slot screen. Draw the post-snap pursuit job of all eleven Sentinels. Mark the force defender, the inside-out pursuers, the backside holder, and the deep pursuers.
Short answer
Vo (nickel) is the force: he attacks the bubble from outside-in and keeps Powers from bouncing outside. Simmons fights Sutton's block, staying outside if he can. The Will (Ames) and Mike (Bell) pursue inside-out, half a step behind the ball's inside hip. Royce comes down from the left deep spot as the alley player. Rollins and Big V turn and retrace when they see the ball go out. Coleman retraces from the far side. Weller, the backside end, holds a count for the reverse or throwback, then chases. Holloway takes the deep pylon angle on the backside, and Brennan carries Gaines and then pursues deep. Hats at the whistle will probably be 6–8, and all eleven should be graded +.
C3. Your leadership council asks for two changes: (a) cut Wednesday's practice by fifteen minutes because the veterans are sore, and (b) leave a specific starter's two loafs off Monday's reel because "he's going through some stuff at home." Make each call and explain it using the "who owns what" table in 35.7.
Short answer
(a) Listen, and probably yes, after checking with the strength staff and the athletic trainers. Practice load is something the council can raise, and Russ has shortened practice twice in four seasons because the council was right. (b) No on the reel, but yes on how it's handled. The reel is the coaches' column, and a standard that bends for one player stops being a standard. But a player going through something at home is a human being first. Talk to him privately before Monday, put the clips on the reel without any added commentary, and make sure he knows what help the team offers (player engagement, counseling). Then tell the council what you did and why.
C4. Design a takeaway circuit for a college team: 64 defensive players, five defensive assistants plus two graduate assistants, 12 minutes available three days a week, and NCAA and conference contact limits that your head coach has already assigned to team periods. Specify stations, tempo, coach per station, rotation time, and what you'll chart.
Short answer
Six stations at two minutes each with five assistants and one GA, or five stations with the second GA charting reps. About 10–11 players per station, in two lines. Stations: Fit and Punch (Bags), Rake and Rip (Air → Bags), Tomahawk with a dummy QB (Bags), Tip and Overlap (Air), Scoop or Fall (Air), and a DB high-point ball drill (Air). None of it uses contact minutes. Chart ball attacks per game, forced fumbles, and passes defensed, and track them by position group so each assistant owns his group's number.
C5. It's training camp in a heat wave. The athletic trainer tells you the heat index is high enough that she wants to cut the afternoon practice by 30 minutes and move the Team Pursuit period indoors at walk-through speed. Your head coach wants to know whether the defense will lose its "effort culture" this week. Make the call and write your one-paragraph answer to the head coach.
Short answer
Take the trainer's recommendation without argument. Her call overrides the coordinator's on heat. To the head coach: "Effort culture is built on grading every rep, not on running in the heat. This week we'll grade the walk-through pursuit for angles and 'nobody passes the ball,' keep the takeaway circuit at Air tempo in the shade or indoors, and run Team Pursuit at Tag tempo once conditions allow. The fastest way to lose a culture is to put a player in the hospital to prove we're tough."
C6. Make the call: Game 2 week. Owen's Game 1 sheet shows that Austin ran two throwback screens to the side of the field where the Sentinels' backside end had chased early, and both gained 12 or more yards. Is this an effort problem, an assignment problem, or a self-scout problem? What changes in this week's practice?
Short answer
It's primarily an assignment and self-scout problem: a backside end chasing early is a bust of the "hold for the reverse or throwback, then chase" job, not a loaf, and Austin has clearly charted it (Sorensen's "the offense scouts effort" point). This week: rep the backside hold against throwback screens in the scout-team period, add the throwback to the screen-alert list on the call card, and make Friday Hats' pursuit period include a throwback picture. If the end slowed down after the hold, that part is a loaf and goes on the reel separately.
C7. Make the call: You've just been hired as coordinator of a college defense that went 4–8. Your first spring film review (charted the Sentinels' way) shows about 11 loafs a game, hats at the whistle of about 4, and 13 takeaways. The head coach wants "a new culture by the opener" and suggests an emotional team meeting on your first day. You have 15 spring practices and a summer. Lay out your first 30 days: what you say on day one, what you build before you say anything else, and the first three things you'd measure.
Short answer
Day one: say less. Introduce two or three standards in plain language and promise that they'll be graded, not that the team will "change." Russ's hook is the warning here: a speech without a system teaches players to wait and see. Build before you preach: loaf definitions and categories, a +/L/M grading sheet, the two-coach rule, the medical rule, the reel format, and a three- to five-station takeaway circuit at Air/Bags inside NCAA spring contact limits. Elect a council (with a young seat) by the second week. Measure: loafs per practice period (graded from practice film in spring), hats at the whistle in scrimmages, and ball attacks. Show the first reel by the end of week one, and make sure an established starter is on it if he earned it.
Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. A fellow coordinator argues: "Showing loafs with names on a big screen is humiliating. Do it privately." Make the strongest case for his position, then the strongest case for the Sentinels' approach. Where would you land, and what would you change about the Sentinels' process (if anything) to address his concern?
D2. Owen estimates that a quarter to a third of the drop in loafs from Russ's first to second season may be the grader (Owen retroactively versus position coaches in real time). What does that do to the credibility of the culture story, and how would you design a grading audit to keep the numbers honest from year to year?
D3. "Celebrate stops like touchdowns" can produce taunting penalties, and a takeaway ritual can encourage players to chase the ball when they should be tackling. Write the two rules you'd add to your celebration policy to keep the benefits and cut the risks.
D4. A star edge rusher, the best player on your defense, has a high loaf count on screens and runs away from him, but he's also your best pass rusher by a wide margin. The head coach says, "Let him rush. Don't make him chase." Analyze the trade-off: effort culture, scheme (who's responsible for the screen and the backside), and the message to the rest of the room. What would you propose?
D5. A youth coach wants to "toughen up" his twelve-year-olds with a daily Oklahoma drill and a team-wide "no water until you earn it" rule as part of building a physical culture. Using the 🩺 callouts in this chapter and Chapter 23, explain everything that's wrong with that plan and propose a replacement that builds the same culture safely.
D6. Owen's hats-at-the-whistle number rose from 3.9 to 6.1 over three seasons, while the missed-tackle rate fell from 14 to 9 percent. A skeptical analyst says, "Your hats number went up because you missed fewer tackles. Plays that end at the line collect more hats. You've got cause and effect backward." Evaluate the critique. What part of it is right? What evidence from the chapter (the loaf counts, the category table in Chapter 23, the Game 3 screen) would you use to respond, and what additional charting would settle it?
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (Ch 35 + Ch 1) Take your Chapter 1 Philosophy Statement. Which of your non-negotiables are culture, and which are scheme? For each culture non-negotiable, write the effort or behavior grade that would measure it, in the format of the table in 35.1.
M2. (Ch 35 + Ch 23) Chapter 23 credits much of the drop from 14 percent to 9 percent missed tackles to better form (Hawk, Track) and lower-contact practice. Chapter 35 credits much of it to pursuit. Using the category table in Chapter 23 (angle misses 41 → 19, lunge 37 → 22, and so on), explain which categories each explanation predicts should fall the most, and whether the data supports one, the other, or both.
M3. (Ch 35 + Ch 25) Sorensen says offenses scout effort. Using Chapter 25's self-scout idea ("your tendencies are the opponent's scouting report"), design a self-scout question about effort tendencies: what would you chart about your own defense's backside pursuit, and what offensive plays would that chart predict an opponent would call?
M4. (Ch 35 + Ch 16) In Chapter 16, Russ took ownership of the Cover 0 call in the Monday meeting before showing any player's mistake. Explain how that act connects to the "coaches go first" principle in 35.4, and predict what would have happened to the accountability language in the Sentinels' room if he'd shown the 45-yard run first.
M5. (Ch 35 + Ch 5 + Ch 21) Anchor C had two busts, one missed tackle, and zero loafs. Write the owner-language statements for Greer, Ames, and Holloway (as in 35.4), and then the fix each position coach assigns, naming the drill or rule from Chapters 5, 21, or 23.
M6. (Ch 35 + Ch 34) Choose the three culture numbers from this chapter you'd add to your Chapter 34 dashboard, and for each one, write the honest caveat you'd print beside it (sample size, grader judgment, outcome contamination).
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. Hats at the whistle. Pick one NFL game with All-22 or end-zone film available to you. Chart hats at the whistle for one defense on every run and every completion caught within five yards of the line (expect roughly 30–45 plays). Then pick the five plays with the lowest counts and decide, for each defender outside the ring, whether he was doing a job (+), loafing (L), or unknown. Write up what you'd need to know about the defense's calls to grade the unknowns.
E2. Takeaway anatomy. Using public play-by-play data (for example, nflverse play-by-play) and broadcast replays, find ten forced fumbles from one recent season. For each, record: was it the first or second defender who attacked the ball? Was it a punch, rake, rip, or strip-sack? How many defenders were within five yards when the ball came out? Compare your findings with the second-man rule.
E3. Culture without contact. Research the practice-contact limits for one level you coach or follow (the NFL collective bargaining agreement, NCAA rules for your division, or your state's high school association) and the heat-acclimatization rules at that level. Then write a one-page "effort and takeaway week" practice plan that fits completely inside those limits, citing the actual rules you found. Don't guess; if you can't find a rule, say so.