Chapter 24 — Discussion Guide

Opening question

"You've spent four days building a 38-page scouting report. Your coordinator reads it, stops on page twenty-three, and asks why the most important number in it is on page twenty-three. What's your answer?"

Let students try to defend the binder. They'll say "it's organized by down," "everything's in there," "he can find what he needs." Then ask: How many minutes will the coordinator have between the end of one play and the next call?

Why it works: almost every student, analyst or coach, believes the job of a report is to be complete. The chapter's claim is that the job is to decide. Tess's binder was organized the way the data was organized; a game is decided on five or six third-and-mediums. The question makes students feel the gap between information and a plan before they hear the three questions in §24.1.


Discussion questions

Tier 1 — Recall

1. What are the three questions every defensive game plan answers? Which one did Tess's first binder skip? Listen for: what do they like; what is their best weapon; what will we make them do instead. The binder was "all question one." Follow-up probe: "Why is the third question the 'real decision'?" (Every time you take something away, you give something back.)

2. What is the difference between a tendency and a tell? Give one of each from the Outlaws report. Listen for: tendency — dig/flood on 14 of 22 third-and-mediums from trips; tell — something visible before the snap, like Gaines's reduced split (all 9 scissors came from 23 reduced-split snaps). Follow-up probe: "Is a reduced split a scissors call?" (No — 9 of 23. It narrows the menu.)

Tier 2 — Analysis

3. Rank these three tendencies by trustworthiness: 12-personnel runs on 31 of 49; play-action shots on 2nd-and-short on 6 of 17; next-play play-action "roughly doubled" after an RPO gain, on 16 snaps. What would you do with each? Listen for: the chapter's 🧩 answer — the first is a plan (build Big around it), the second a lean (a coaching point on eyes, not a call), the third a story (tell the safeties, don't build a call). Strong answers name the cost of a wrong guess, not just the count. Follow-up probe: "Which matters more, the size of the sample or the cost of being wrong?"

4. Why does "dig/flood, 14 of 22" mean more once you know it appeared on only 22 of the Outlaws' other 108 called passes? Listen for: base rate. A concept that's common everywhere tells you nothing about a situation; one that jumps in a situation tells you what the offense believes. Follow-up probe: "In Case Study 2, what did the base rate hide?" (Dalton Creek's trap-action play-action was already in their offense, on first down.)

5. In the Week 15 rebuild, Tess kept the Week 6 game in the sample but cut it separately. Why both? Listen for: it's the only film of Petrakis against this defense — the most relevant game anywhere — but it's one game, and one game is a story. Follow-up probe: "What's the danger of a sample made entirely of games against you?"

Tier 3 — Judgment and ethics

6. The front page said "never Cover 0." Russ wrote it. Tied 27–27 with 4:12 left, he called Cover 0 anyway. What does a staff do to make a plan survive its own coordinator? Listen for: the "never" list on the call sheet in red; a named person (Owen, Gabe) with standing to say it; the plan's exception clause written so the urge to "do something" has a sound outlet. Follow-up probe: "Is it appropriate for a quality-control coach or analyst to push back on a coordinator during a game? How?" Connect to Chapter 25's "Card" veto.

7. An assistant wants to bracket Gaines on every third down because he's the third-down weapon (19 of 41 targets). Make the case for and against. Listen for: for — he's the weapon; against — a bracket costs a defender every snap, Petrakis will move him or throw to whoever's left, and the plan stops being able to disguise. The chapter's "plan that takes away everything" warning. Follow-up probe: "What would you put in the 'live with' column if you did bracket him?"

8. A junior analyst wants to delete the game where the Outlaws had a 21-point fourth-quarter lead and ran on 9 of 11 snaps. Owen flags it but keeps it. Who's right? Listen for: deleting data you don't like is a habit that eventually deletes data you need; flagging lets the reader decide. Honesty in the report is the coordinator's protection. Follow-up probe: "What other sample-hygiene issue did Owen flag?" (One opponent in the sample rotated like the Sentinels — 61 of the 247 snaps, and 2 of Vance's 3 rotation interceptions.)


Structured debate: Gabe Lindqvist vs. Owen Kessler — "Build the call or coach the point?"

Setup. Week 6 week, Tuesday meeting. On 2nd-and-1 to 3, the Outlaws took a play-action shot on 6 of 17 snaps, all from 11 personnel with Harlan attached and Ruffin offset. Gabe wants a special call for it — a safety who stays deep on 2nd-and-short. Owen says it's a lean, not a plan.

Roles. Gabe (build the call), Owen (coach the point, keep the call sheet clean), Mike Sorensen (the offensive coordinator's view: "What does Petrakis do if he sees that call?"), and Russ (decides, and writes the line for the front page or doesn't).

Rules. Each side gets three minutes and must use the confidence ladder and the cost of a wrong guess. Mike gets one minute to describe the offense's breaker. Russ must state the decision in the front-page format: item, count, decision.

What to draw out. Both are reasonable. The chapter's worked answer leans to Owen — a coaching point on eyes discipline, not a call — because a wrong guess on 17 snaps costs a defender on every 2nd-and-short. But Gabe's point that a touchdown is expensive is real. The skill being practiced is writing the trade-off down.


Connecting to the case studies

Case Study 1 — the hot-throw cutup. Tess pulled Vance's 36 attempts against five or more rushers and found 15 hot throws, 11 of them to the field-side slot curl/flat window — and 8 of 8 to that window when the A-gaps showed pressure. Owen: "Fifteen hot throws is a lean, not a plan." Big Lou: "Not Vo. Coleman." Ask: how did a report whose first line was "don't blitz" produce the best pressure of the season? (The exception clause, built from the same report.)

Case Study 2 — Pine Hollow and Dalton Creek. Russ at 31, the fullback trap on 7 of 8 short-yardage snaps, "THUNDER ON 3RD-AND-SHORT VS. I" written in red — and nothing else on the page. Dalton Creek installed trap-action play-action that week and won 21–14. Ask: map each of Russ's misses onto the chapter's tools — base rate, fifth column, second call, trigger to switch.


Closing synthesis prompt

"In 120 words or fewer, write the front page for an opponent you know."

Give them eight minutes, then read two aloud. The test is the chapter's: every item has a count, a sample size, and a decision, and there's a "live with" line. Close on Russ's coach's point: the hardest part of game planning isn't finding the answer — it's keeping it in the fourth quarter. Write the "never" list on Tuesday, when you're calm, and treat it as an order from a smarter version of yourself.