Chapter 15 Exercises — Cover 1: Man-Free
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall and definitions · ⭐⭐ recognition and application · ⭐⭐⭐ judgment, trade-offs, and multi-step reasoning · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension, research, and film study.
All Sentinels, Outlaws, Stallions, and Ospreys people, plays, and numbers are fictional.
Selected answers are in Appendix J. Short
answers to Part C appear in <details> blocks below each problem.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. In one sentence each, define man coverage, man-free, and post safety. Then explain what the "1" in Cover 1 counts.
A2. Do the Cover 1 arithmetic for a nickel defense against 11 personnel with a four-man rush. List the four jobs and how many defenders each takes. What is left over, and what does this book call him?
A3. Name five ways to spend the spare in Cover 1. For each, give the depth or position and the route family it is designed to take away.
A4. The Sentinels' Will has a man rule that says "first back out," not "the running back." Why is the wording important against a two-back formation such as the Stallions' 21 personnel?
A5. State the leverage principle from 15.3 in one sentence. Then explain why the Sentinels' corners play outside leverage while the nickel plays inside leverage in base Cover 1.
A6. What does it mean for a man defender to be in phase, on top, and out of phase? What are the two things a defender who is out of phase should do, and what is the one thing he must not do?
A7. Explain the difference between an under/over bracket and an in/out bracket. Which one does "Spin 1, Bracket Z" use, and which does "Spin 1, Hole H" use?
A8. Define rub and pick. Name four rub families an offense uses against man coverage.
A9. State the Sentinels' Banjo rule in your own words. What happens if both receivers in the stack run vertical routes?
A10. What is the "plaster" rule, and why do man defenders need it more than zone defenders do?
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
B1. Pre-snap you see two safeties at 13 yards and corners at 7 yards with an outside shade. After the snap, the strong safety drives down to a tight end and runs with him up the seam, the free safety runs to the deep middle, and the Mike drops to about six yards in the middle with his eyes on the quarterback. Every other underneath defender turns and runs with a receiver. Name the coverage and the Sentinels' call word. Who is the spare?
B2. Study this post-snap picture and identify the call. Who is the spare, and what is he taking away?
EXERCISE B2 -- POST-SNAP
F [POST]
$ [10-12 yds, eyes on QB]
C W M * C
on X on R on Y on H on Z
E N T E
vv vv vv vv
X O O O O O Y H Z
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): The offense is in trips to the right with a tight end attached on the right, a slot, and a flanker; a split end is alone on the left; the back is offset. After the snap, the free safety is in the deep middle, the strong safety sits at ten to twelve yards in the middle of the field watching the quarterback, the Mike covers the tight end, the Will covers the back, the nickel covers the slot, and the corners cover the two wide receivers. Four linemen rush.
B3. On film, a defender on the outside receiver of a stack stays outside and takes the flanker when the flanker breaks out, while the defender who aligned inside takes the slot on a slant. Name the combination call and explain how you know it wasn't "follow your man."
B4. A corner is pressed on the boundary receiver with inside leverage, eyes on the receiver's hips. The opposite corner is 8 yards off with outside leverage. One safety is at 12 yards, the other at 15 and a yard outside the hash. What two tells has the defense given the quarterback, and which chapter's "disguise busts" do they match?
B5. In a Cover 1 clip, the quarterback breaks the pocket to his right. The corner on that side turns to look at the quarterback and steps toward the line of scrimmage. One second later his receiver, who had been running a deep comeback, is wide open behind him at 14 yards. Name the rule the corner broke and the offensive concept that punished him.
B6. After the snap, the free safety stays deep over the flanker on his side, and the corner on that flanker plays underneath and trails him. The strong safety runs from the far hash to the deep middle. The Mike runs with the tight end. What call is this, and what has the defense given up to get it?
B7. Study this pre-snap and post-snap pair. Name the call, identify the spare, and explain what the quarterback would most likely have expected before the snap.
EXERCISE B7 -- PRE-SNAP
$ F
M W
C * C
E T N E
X Y O O O O O H Z
Q
R
📊 Diagram (described): Two-by-two with the tight end attached on the left. The defense shows two safeties at about thirteen yards on the hashes, corners off, the nickel a half-step outside the slot receiver, the Mike and Will at linebacker depth, and four linemen down.
EXERCISE B7 -- POST-SNAP
F
[POST]
\
\ M [inside H]
C $ W * [outside H] C
on X on Y on R on Z
E T N E
vv vv vv vv
X Y O O O O O H Z
Q
R
📊 Diagram (described): After the snap the strong safety rotates down onto the tight end and the free safety spins to the deep middle. The Mike does not drop to the middle; he widens to a spot about six yards deep just inside the slot receiver, while the nickel plays outside the slot. The corners and the Will are in man on the wide receivers and the back, and four linemen rush.
B8. You're charting a game and see a defense play what looks like Cover 1 on a third down, except that after the snap there is no defender deeper than 12 yards anywhere on the field and six players rush. Is this Cover 1? Explain what you'd write in the "Coverage" column and why.
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
C1. Make the call ⭐⭐. Game 2 vs. Austin, first quarter, 3rd-and-6 at the Outlaws' 34. Eleven personnel, 3x1 trips right with Harlan attached on the trips side. Owen's sheet says dig or flood to the trips side on 14 of 22 such snaps. You have shown two-high on every snap so far. Choose a Cover 1 variant and justify it in four sentences or fewer, naming the cost.
Answer
Nickel Over Robber from the home look. Holloway rotates to the robber spot at 10–12 yards in the middle, where the dig to Gaines lands, and Royce spins to the post. The cost is Bell in man on Harlan — a seam matchup you don't love — but Royce in the post sits directly over that seam. You're spending the spare on the throw the data says they trust.
C2. Draw it ⭐⭐. Draw the post-snap picture of base Spin 1 (rat) against 10 personnel: four wide receivers in a 2x2 set and one back. Label every defender's assignment. Who covers the second slot receiver, and would you rather have a different player there?
Answer
Corners on the two outside receivers; Vo on the slot to his side; Holloway rotates down on the other slot (his rule: "the tight end, or #2 to the other side"); Ames on the back; Bell as the rat; Royce in the post; four rushers. Against a fast slot, you'd rather have Andre Lucas, the dime back, on him — which means calling dime before the snap or living with the safety-on-slot matchup.
C3. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐. Week 11 at St. Louis. 3rd-and-3 at the Stallions' 46. The Stallions are in 21 personnel, I-formation, Gus Mahler at fullback, Antoine Day at tailback, one tight end, two receivers. They run a play-action bootleg on about one-third of their third-and-short snaps. You're in base. Choose between one-high Cover 1 with a rat, Spin 1, and Cover 1 pressure. Which would you call, and what coaching point would you give the Will?
Answer
One-high Cover 1, rat, pressed corners. On 3rd-and-3 there's no time for the rotation (Spin 1 costs a step), and pressure against an I-formation with a boot threat risks a rusher chasing the run fake past the quarterback. The one-high look also puts an extra defender near the box for the run. Coaching point for Ames: "Your key is your man. First back out is yours. If Mahler leaks on the boot, he's yours — don't play the fake."
C4. Draw it ⭐⭐⭐. The Outlaws align in a bunch to the right: Powers on the point, Gaines behind and outside, Harlan behind and inside. Draw a Banjo-style rule for three defenders (Simmons, Vo, Holloway) against the three bunch receivers. State who takes the first out, the first in, and the first vertical.
Answer
One workable rule: Simmons (outside) takes the first receiver out; Vo (inside) takes the first receiver in; Holloway (deep, over the top of the bunch) takes the first vertical. Whoever remains is taken by the defender whose zone of responsibility he enters last — typically the spare (the rat) helps on the third receiver. Many systems handle bunch with a three-man "box" or "zone-out" rule; the principle is the same: assign by route, not by name.
C5. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐. Divisional playoff vs. Austin, second quarter, 3rd-and-8 at the Sentinels' 44. Vance has scrambled twice already for first downs against man. Trey Gaines has two catches. You want to play man coverage. Which way do you spend the spare, and what do you tell the edge rushers?
Answer
Spend the spare on the quarterback: Spin 1, Spy (or keep the rat with a strict "rat to QB" rule). On 3rd-and-8 the threat that has hurt you is Vance's legs, not Gaines. Edge rushers: contain — rush to Vance's outside shoulder and never get deeper than his launch point. Accept the cost: no robber on crossers, so the man defenders must win.
C6. Draw it ⭐⭐. Draw "Spin 1, Hole H" against 2x2 and show what happens to a slot fade. Who is responsible, and what help does he have?
Answer
Vo is outside of Powers, so a slot fade is his, with Royce in the post able to help only if the fade bends toward the middle. Bell, inside Powers at six yards, has nothing to do on a fade; he becomes a late rat. Hole H takes away in-breakers and makes outside-breaking and vertical routes Vo's job.
C7. Whose fault? ⭐⭐⭐. Game 2 vs. Austin, third quarter, 3rd-and-5 at the Sentinels' 36. The call is Spin 1 with Bell as the rat. The Outlaws run mesh from 2x2 with Ruffin running a wheel out of the backfield behind it. Holloway and Vo correctly call "Switch!" and exchange on the crossers. Ames sees the switch, yells "Switch!" himself, and steps toward the crossing point. Ruffin runs the wheel up the sideline, and Vance throws it to him over Ames's head for 24 yards. Royce, in the post, arrives late to make the tackle. Who broke which rule, and why does the rule exist?
Answer
Ames. The Sentinels' mesh rule says the Will never switches; he stays on the back no matter where the back goes. That clause exists because the wheel behind the mesh is the offense's built-in answer to a switch rule (it's exactly what Sorensen predicted in the Thursday meeting): when underneath defenders converge on the crossing point, the back runs up the sideline behind them. Royce is not at fault; the post safety cannot cover a wheel near the sideline from the deep middle.
C8. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐. Week 3 vs. the Stallions, fourth quarter, Sentinels lead 20–13, 3rd-and-7 at the Stallions' 30 with 3:05 left. The Stallions are in 11 personnel (unusual for them), 2x2. Haugen is a precise pocket passer who rarely scrambles but is lethal on play-action. Choose among Home (quarters), Spin 1 (rat), and Robber, and justify your call with reference to what Haugen does well and what a third-and-7 throw needs.
Answer
A strong answer is Robber. On 3rd-and-7, the throw has to reach 7+ yards; Haugen's best completions are timing throws in the middle — digs and in-breakers — which the robber sits on. He doesn't scramble much, so the spare doesn't need to spy. Spin 1 (rat) protects the shallow crosser, which on 3rd-and-7 usually comes up short. Home is also defensible (it's your base and handles the dig with the safety's #2 read), but Robber tightens every window with man coverage while keeping a post. Name the cost: the tight end matchup on the Mike.
Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. Your boundary corner is a second-year player who plays well in off-coverage zone but loses about half his one-on-one reps against good receivers in practice. Your coordinator wants to play Cover 1 on 30% of third downs. Write a short memo (150–200 words) arguing for how much Cover 1 to play and what protections (brackets, matchup exceptions, personnel) you'd build in.
D2. "Cover 1 pressure is just Cover 1 with an extra rusher." Explain in a paragraph why this is misleading, referring to leverage, the spare, crossers, and scramble defense.
D3. Player safety: your team runs mesh against your defense in practice every day of game week. Two defenders nearly collided at full speed on the crossing point on Thursday. What practice-design changes would you make to protect players while still repping the Switch rule? Address tempo, contact level, and how you'd teach the trigger.
D4. Robber vs. Bracket: the opponent's best receiver runs a dig on third down about half the time and a deep post about a quarter of the time. Which variant would you favor, and what does each choice concede? Answer in terms of the throw the offense trusts and the cost of being wrong.
D5. Owen reports that 4 of the 11 explosive passes allowed in the Sentinels' Cover 1 family came on crossers, and 3 of those 4 came when the spare was rushing or bracketing. A young assistant wants to ban Cover 1 pressure entirely. Write a response (150–200 words) that respects the data, names its limits (sample size, opponents, situations), and proposes a narrower rule than a ban.
D6. A colleague argues that because Cover 1 is "simple," it's the best coverage to install first with a young high school team. Agree or disagree in a paragraph, using the hash-mark geometry and the rub problem.
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (Chapter 15 + Chapter 6.) Spin 1 and Spin 3 come from the same home look. List what the quarterback sees before the snap, then what changes after the snap in each. Which one is harder to identify in the first half-second, and why? Use the phrase "shell is not the coverage."
M2. (Chapter 15 + Chapter 13.) Compare "Mug Cat Fire" to a five-man Cover 1 pressure with the Mike blitzing. For each, state who covers the hot window under the slot and what the quarterback sees when he throws hot.
M3. (Chapter 15 + Chapter 11.) In quarters, the free safety's job depends on #2's route; in Cover 1, the free safety is the post. Describe one snap where the same pre-snap look produces each, and explain how the quarterback's read of the safety changes.
M4. (Chapter 15 + Chapter 14 + Chapter 8.) The Outlaws motion Powers from left to right in jet motion. In zone, the Sentinels Bump; in man, the call is Ride. Explain what each response tells Vance, and design one way to make the response not a tell. Include who must echo the call.
M5. (Chapter 15 + Chapter 5.) In Spin 1 the Outlaws run inside zone and Harlan blocks the defensive end. Using the run-fit idea that every gap has an owner, explain Holloway's job and the spare's job against the run.
M6. (Chapter 15 + Chapter 3.) Using the personnel packages from Chapter 3 — nickel, dime, big nickel — explain how the Cover 1 matchup table changes against Outlaws 12 personnel (two tight ends) when the Sentinels go to big nickel with Pruitt at strong safety and Holloway at the nickel spot. Who covers Harlan and Brandt in man, and who is the spare?
M7. (Chapter 15 + Chapter 9.) Cover 3 and Cover 1 are both one-high. Name one route concept that Cover 1 handles better than spot-drop Cover 3, and one that Cover 3 handles better than Cover 1. Explain the mechanism for each.
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. Chart the spare. Watch the third downs of one NFL game on All-22 (coaches' film). For every snap you identify as Cover 1, chart: the pre-snap shell (one-high or two-high), who the spare was, his depth, and the result. Build a table of at least 8 snaps. What did the defense seem most afraid of?
E2. Rub hunting. Pick one NFL offense known for heavy motion and condensed formations. Over two games, find every stack, bunch, or mesh concept run against man coverage. For each, note whether the defense used a combination call (look for defenders exchanging receivers) or followed through the traffic, and the result. Write a one-page summary of what you found.
E3. Scramble audit. Using public play-by-play data (for example, nflverse) to locate quarterback scrambles, and film to identify the coverage, watch 10 scrambles against man coverage. For each, freeze the frame when the quarterback crosses the tackle box and count defenders with eyes on him. Compare scrambles that gained a first down with those that didn't. Describe the method you used to decide "man coverage," because public data rarely labels coverage reliably.