Chapter 40 Exercises — Watching Defense Like a Coordinator

Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ apply the method · ⭐⭐⭐ judgment and trade-offs · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and film study

All Sentinels, Outlaws, Stallions, and Ospreys people, games, and numbers are fictional. Selected answers are in Appendix J.


Part A — Conceptual ⭐

A1. Name the two questions a coordinator answers on every snap, in order. Why does the order matter?

A2. List the five defensive checks of the pre-snap checklist in the order this chapter teaches them. What four things do you name about the offense before you start?

A3. Define middle of the field open (MOFO) and middle of the field closed (MOFC). Which one describes Cover 3? Quarters? Cover 1? Six?

A4. Why is the box count the most reliable of the five pre-snap checks, and why is safety alignment the least reliable?

A5. A coordinator watches every snap three times. What is the one job of each look, and why does the ball come into it only on the third?

A6. What is the difference between the sideline (All-22) angle and the end-zone angle? Which would you use to grade a run fit, and which to grade a coverage?

A7. In your own words, explain why "grading by proximity" produces wrong grades. Use Anchor C (the 45-yard run in Game 1) as your example.

A8. Define the three coaches' codes — RULE, CALL, and CREDIT — and give one example of each from the chapter's film session.

A9. Why does the chapter say a sack can "belong to the coverage"? What number would you check to decide?

A10. What does it mean to "grade with humility when you don't know the call"? Write the conditional grade you'd give a corner who lets a 6-yard hitch be caught in front of him when you don't know whether the coverage was Cover 3 or Cover 1.


Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐

B1. Pre-snap: 11 personnel, 2x2. Two safeties at 12 yards, both on the hashes. Corners 7 yards off with outside shade. Linebackers at 5 yards. Four down linemen. At the snap: both safeties pedal slowly with their eyes on the slot receivers; both corners sink straight back over the outside receivers; four rush. Name the coverage, and name the defender whose job changes if the slot receiver to his side goes vertical past 7 yards.

B2. Pre-snap: the same picture as B1. At the snap: the left safety drives down and out toward the flat; the right safety runs sideways to the deep middle; both corners bail; four rush. Name the coverage and the "giveaway" step. What is the Sentinels' name for this call?

B3. One second after the snap, you count five rushers. The boundary corner is one of them. A defensive end has dropped to the boundary curl-to-flat, and the boundary safety is running to the deep outside third on that side. Name the coverage family, the number of deep and underneath defenders, and the throw the quarterback most likely has against it.

B4. Look at this post-snap picture and identify the coverage.

POST-SNAP (identify it)

      ^                                                   ^
       \                                                 /
        $                                               F
   [FLAT]       [HOOK/CURL]    [MIDDLE]     [HOOK/CURL]    [FLAT]
   C (squats)        *             M             W      (squats) C
                         E      T      N      E

📊 Diagram (described): Two safeties bail backward and outward toward the numbers. Both corners stay low in the flats with their eyes on the slot receivers. Underneath them, the nickel takes the left hook-to-curl zone, the Mike the middle, and the Will the right hook-to-curl zone. Four linemen rush. Eleven defenders.

Name the coverage. Then count: how many rush, how many underneath, how many deep? What is the coverage's classic weak spot, and which defender would a smash concept (hitch plus corner route) to the right side put in conflict?

B5. On a broadcast replay you see a receiver run a crossing route from left to right. A linebacker drops to the left hook and lets him go; the right-side linebacker picks him up in his zone. Is this zone or man underneath? What would you expect to see in the other coverage?

B6. Pre-snap: one safety at 13 in the middle; the other walked down to 8 over the tight end; corners at 7; eight defenders within 8 yards of the ball counting the walked-down safety and the nickel; four down. At the snap the walked-down safety backpedals to a deep half on his side and the middle safety moves to the other deep half. Name the move, the resulting shell, and the throw the offense thought it had before the snap.

B7. Austin motions Powers from left to right across the formation. The Sentinels' nickel runs with him all the way. What does that suggest about the coverage? What would the Sentinels' word "Bump" have looked like instead? What about "Roll"?

Short answers, B1–B7

B1. Quarters. The safety to that side: if his #2 goes vertical past about 7 yards, he takes #2 man-to-man; if #2 breaks in or out, he tops #1 for a bracket with the corner (Anchor A).

B2. Cover 3 from a two-high rotation; the Sentinels call it Spin 3. The giveaway is the left safety's first step going down and out instead of back, while the right safety moves sideways to the middle.

B3. A boundary fire zone: five rushers, three deep, three under, with the dropping end in the boundary curl-to-flat (the hot window). The quarterback's most likely answer is a quick throw to the receiver the blitzing corner left — the boundary #1 on a hitch or slant — before the rotating safety can get there. (That's exactly how Austin beat Mug Cat Fire in Game 3, to the field side.)

B4. Cover 2: four rush, five under (two flats, two hook/curls, one middle), two deep halves. Its classic weak spots are the deep middle between the safeties and the sideline hole between the squatting corner and the half safety. A smash concept to the right (hitch by #1, corner route by #2) puts the right corner in conflict: squat on the hitch and the corner route goes over him; sink with the corner route and the hitch is open. The half safety has to get width to help.

B5. Zone. In man coverage, the left linebacker (or whoever has that receiver) would run across the field with him, and the crosser would never be "handed off."

B6. A climb: a one-high look that becomes two-high at the snap (Climb 2 or Climb 4 in the Sentinels' words, depending on what the corners do). Before the snap, the offense thought it had one-high: the outside throws against corners without help and play-action against a loaded box.

B7. Man coverage (the Sentinels' Ride). With Bump, the nickel would stay home and the linebackers would slide one spot toward the motion — zone, giving away less. With Roll, the safety on the motion side would rotate down with the motion as the force player and the other safety would spin to the middle — one-high, shown before the snap.


Part C — Make the Call / Draw It ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

C1. ⭐⭐ Diagram it. Draw the post-snap picture of Nickel Over Spin 3 against Austin's 11 personnel 2x2 with Harlan attached left (the Anchor D formation). Label every defender's zone, the four rushers, and the route that Anchor D's interception came on. Count to eleven.

Short answer

Holloway down and out to the left curl-to-flat; Royce to the deep middle third; Brennan left deep third; Simmons right deep third; Ames left hook; Bell right hook (walls the dig); Vo right curl-to-flat; Weller, Coleman, Tuipulotu, Rollins rushing. The interception came on Gaines's post from the right into the deep middle. Eleven: 4 rush + 4 under + 3 deep.

C2. ⭐⭐ Whose fault? Week 9 at Oklahoma City (hypothetical drill). Ospreys in 10 personnel, 2x2. The Sentinels play Quarters. The field slot (#2) runs a 5-yard out; the field outside receiver (#1) runs a post. Royce, the field safety, follows #2 toward the sideline. The post is caught 25 yards downfield with no one near it. Who is at fault, which code, and which rule?

Short answer

Royce, EYES (or ASG). In Quarters, when #2 breaks to the flat or out, the safety "tops" #1 — he works over the top of #1's post, creating a bracket with the corner. Following #2 outside abandons that job. It's Anchor A's read played the wrong way.

C3. ⭐⭐⭐ Make the call — as a film grader. You're grading Game 3, snap 8 (zoom motion, quick out, 3rd- and-2). Your head coach asks, "Why isn't that a minus on Simmons? He got beat on third down." Write the two-sentence answer you give him, and the one-sentence rule change you propose.

Short answer

"Simmons did exactly what our motion rule says: a moving receiver means Hands depth, and the rule gave him inside leverage. Petrakis attacked the part of the rule we hadn't written, so the grade belongs to the rule, not the player." Rule change: zoom motion toward the ball on short yardage — the corner flips to outside leverage.

C4. ⭐⭐⭐ Diagram it. Draw the pre-snap and post-snap pictures for a Cover 1 robber call from a two-high look against 11 personnel 2x2 (Spin 1 with a "rat" or hole player). Then write the one post-snap movement a film watcher would use to tell it apart from Spin 3.

Short answer

Pre-snap: the same Home picture as Spin 3 — two-high, twins, corners off or pressed, four down. Post-snap: one safety spins to the deep middle; the other comes down to a man assignment (often the tight end) or the short middle as the robber; the corners, nickel, and a linebacker turn and run with receivers; one linebacker or the down safety sits in the hole. The tell that separates it from Spin 3 is the corners' eyes and hips: in Spin 1 they turn with their receivers (man); in Spin 3 they bail to deep thirds with their eyes inside (zone). A crossing route settles it — in Spin 1 someone runs across with him.

C5. ⭐⭐⭐ Whose fault? Game 1 (hypothetical drill, not one of the season's actual snaps). The Sentinels call Home. Austin runs outside zone to the tight end. Weller sets the edge and keeps contain; Ames scrapes over the top; Bell, the backside linebacker, overruns the play, and Ruffin cuts back into the backside B-gap for 13 yards. Holloway makes the tackle. Grade Weller, Ames, Bell, and Holloway with codes.

Short answer

Weller +, Ames + (if he filled his frontside gap), Bell FIT (backside B-gap / cutback responsibility abandoned — the first error), Holloway + (made the tackle from the alley after the breakdown). The 13-yard run is an explosive by the book's definition; its first-cause code is a fit error by a linebacker.

C6. ⭐⭐⭐ Make the call. You are calling the defense against a team that, like Austin, has a rule: "Quiet front, two-high on third-and-long: it's two-high." You have shown honest two-high on every third-and-long for six games. It's the fourth quarter, 3rd-and-10, and you lead by 4. What do you call, what do you check before you call it, and what is the cost if the quarterback reads it?

Short answer

A late rotation from the honest two-high look — the Sentinels' Spin 3 — with a plain four-man front so the front is an alibi, not a lie. Before you call it, check three things: your self-scout (are your safeties truly twins on these snaps, or is there a depth tell?), the opponent's favorite two-high beater on third- and-long (if it's a post or post-dig, the rotation puts a safety on it), and your rotator's landing-spot time against their quick game. The cost if the quarterback reads it: Cover 3's weaknesses — the seams, curl-flat, and four verticals — and, more importantly, you've spent the tendency; the next opponent's film will show it.

C7. ⭐⭐⭐ Whose fault? (communication). Game 1, Q1, 2nd-and-7 at the Sacramento 47 (an actual snap from the season): a Lock / Quarters split bust. Half the secondary played the Lock check against trips and half played the original Quarters call, and Gaines caught a 41-yard post with nobody within ten yards. Grade it with the codes. Who gets the first cause, and which rule from Chapter 8 was written because of it?

Short answer

First cause: BUST — a communication failure, not one player's technique. Every defender played a coverage correctly; they played two different coverages. The coaches' share belongs to the communication system (the coordinator owns the system). The rule that came from it: "No echo, no check" — a coverage check is live only when the other safety echoes it, and Royce alone owns coverage checks. Under that rule, an unechoed Lock is off, and all eleven play the original call.


Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐

D1. Tess graded snap 5 (the back-shoulder touchdown) as eleven pluses and CREDIT. A position coach argues that a touchdown should always produce at least one minus "so players stay accountable." Write a one-paragraph response for or against him, using the chapter's "every touchdown needs a villain" common mistake.

D2. Snap 7 (Mug Cat Fire) was graded CALL. Russ said "That one's mine" in front of the staff. What does a coordinator gain by grading himself in front of his staff and players? What does he risk? Would you do it at every level (high school, college, NFL)?

D3. The chapter says outside graders "never know the call." A media analyst publishes player grades for every defender every week. How should a coach, a fan, and a bettor each use those grades? What are the honest limits?

D4. The 🩺 Player safety callout says a crown-of-the-helmet tackle gets a minus even if it caused a fumble. A player says, "So I'm graded down for making the play?" Write the conversation you'd have with him, and explain why the grade sheet is the right place to enforce the standard.

D5. Owen's full-game grade (22 non-plus grades in 671, about 3 percent) is very different from the ten-snap reel (1 in 110). Which number should a coordinator show players on Monday, which should he show the head coach, and why might he show different numbers to different audiences without being dishonest?


Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

M1. (Ch 40 + Ch 6) Chapter 6's threshold concept is "the shell is not the coverage." Using snaps 4, 6, and 10 from the Game 3 film session, explain how a film watcher's checklist must change because of it. Which pre-snap check becomes a prediction rather than a conclusion?

M2. (Ch 40 + Ch 5 + Ch 23) Grade Anchor C (Game 1, 2nd-and-6 at the Sacramento 45, inside zone, 45-yard touchdown) with the chapter's codes for Greer, Ames, and Holloway. Then grade Game 3's snap 3 (the same play, +2) for the same three players. What does the comparison teach about where explosive runs come from?

M3. (Ch 40 + Ch 18 + Ch 13) For snap 7 (Mug Cat Fire vs. Austin's "rule 2" protection), write the full six-line protection ledger. Then write the ledger for Anchor B in Game 2. Which line changed, and what does that change tell you about how the offense solved the call?

M4. (Ch 40 + Ch 31) Chapter 31 asks, "Did a player break a rule, or did a rule break?" Apply the question to snaps 4, 8, and 9. Which code does each answer produce?

M5. (Ch 40 + Ch 34) Owen codes the first cause of every explosive play. Take the three classic faults in 40.5 (the outside-leverage slant, the safety triggering on a run fake, the late Cover 6 climb). For each, give the first-cause code, the dashboard number(s) it moves, and the practice period that fixes it.

M6. (Ch 40 + Ch 25 + Ch 16) Russ's Week 6 Cover 0 and Game 3's Mug Cat Fire both earned a CALL grade. Compare the two: what did Russ ignore in each case (Owen's numbers, Gabe's advice, the film the opponent had), and what in the Chapter 25 call-sheet conventions ("Card" veto, mix line, HOLD) was built to prevent each?


M7. (Ch 40 + Ch 14 + Ch 29) Snap 1 of the film session used "Home, Roll on jet." Explain what each of the Sentinels' motion words (Ride, Bump, Roll) would have shown a film watcher before the snap, and why a tempo offense (Chapter 29) makes motion answers even more revealing.

Short answer

Ride shows man (a defender runs with the motion). Bump shows little — linebackers slide one spot, which both zone and some man-switch schemes do. Roll shows one-high before the snap (a safety rotates with the motion as the force player). Against tempo, the defense has less time to disguise and often defaults to simple calls (Home, Sky, Robber, Fire), so its motion answers are more likely to be its true coverage — which is why offenses pair tempo with motion to force the defense to declare early.


Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐

E1. The three-number game. Watch one full half of an NFL game on television. On every defensive snap you can see, write three numbers: deep safeties before the snap, box defenders against blockers, and rushers at one second after the snap. Mark "can't see" honestly. At the end, report: how many snaps you could chart fully; how often the pre-snap shell matched the post-snap shell (when you could see both); and the defense's rush-count distribution. Write one paragraph on what the broadcast hid from you.

E2. Grade a touchdown. Find a touchdown pass from a recent game with a high or end-zone replay (or All-22 if you have access). Apply the five-step method: the ball, the space, the owner, the first error, then RULE / CALL / CREDIT. Write a one-sentence fault statement that names a coverage, a defender, a rule, and the consequence — or explain why the correct grade is CREDIT. State your confidence (high / medium / can't see) and what you'd need to raise it.

E3. The calibration notebook. For three consecutive weeks, predict the coverage family (one-high or two-high after the snap) before every snap you watch of one team's defense, then record what was played. Report your hit rate each week. Then answer: did your hit rate rise because you got better, because the defense was predictable, or because of who they played? How would you tell the difference? (This is the same honesty question Owen asks about Tess's booth numbers in 40.7.)