Midterm Exam — Chapters 1–20

NFL Offensive Coordination

Coverage: Part I (Offensive Foundations), Part II (The Run Game), and the first six chapters of Part III (The Passing Game): Chapters 1–20 — philosophy and lineage, formations and personnel, the line and the skill positions, reading defensive structure, the language of the call, the five run families, RPOs and short yardage, route concepts, the coverage-beaters and man-beaters, deep passing, play-action, and screens. Format: Closed book. One handwritten 4x6 index card allowed (front and back). Blank paper for drawing. 120 minutes. Total: 150 points.

Part Items Points Suggested time
A — Multiple choice 35 35 (1 each) 30 minutes
B — Short answer 10 40 (4 each) 30 minutes
C — Draw it up 4 40 (10 each) 35 minutes
D — Film scenario: "Whose fault?" 2 35 (D1 = 20, D2 = 15) 25 minutes
Total 51 150 120 minutes

Instructor notes — read before you copy this

What this exam is testing. The book's thesis is that the offense owns one structural advantage — it knows where the ball is going — and multiplies it three ways: conflict, sequence, and illusion. Part A checks the vocabulary and the established facts students need for Part IV onward (call grammar, technique numbers, route digits, the box-count rules). Parts B, C, and D decide the grade. They ask students to use the first four threshold concepts on pictures and plays: the defense tells you where to go (Chapter 7), you block an area, not a man (Chapter 9), you can block a defender with a decision (Chapter 12), and the quarterback reads a defender, not a receiver (Chapter 15) — plus the Chapter 19 threshold, the run is the first half of every play-action pass. A student who aces Part A and cannot draw Part C does not yet understand offense. Weight your feedback accordingly.

Why closed book with a card. Open book on a diagram exam turns into copying the chapter's drawings. The index card forces students to decide what is worth carrying, which is itself a coordinator skill: Lyle's rule "More than ten words, call the band" is the same discipline at a smaller scale. If your course runs the analyst and film-study syllabus, you may run the exam open-book and drop Part A; the diagrams and film essays still discriminate.

How to subset it. Every item is tagged with its chapter so you can cut it to your scope.

Syllabus Midterm scope Use these items
15-week university (Week 8, after Chapter 20) Ch 1–20 The whole paper. If you need a 75-minute version, run Parts B–D only (115 points) and assign Part A as a take-home retrieval set.
Analyst and film study Recognition-heavy Part C (all four), Part D in full, plus B3, B4, B8, and B10 (90 minutes, 91 points)
High school staff development Staff clinic, not graded Run Part C as a whiteboard competition between position rooms (line coach takes C2 and C4, quarterback coach takes C1 and C3) and Part D as a staff discussion
Self-paced Everything The whole paper, timed, then self-graded against the key

Diagram conventions students must use. The book's notation (Appendix A): offense at the bottom, defense at the top, offense moving up the page. Offense: O linemen (or LT LG C RG RT), Q quarterback, R running back, B fullback, Y tight end, U second tight end, X split end, Z flanker, H slot. Defense: E end, T tackle, N nose, S Sam, M Mike, W Will, * nickel, D dime, C corner, F free safety, $ strong safety. Routes end in an arrowhead; blocks end in ]; ~~> is pre-snap motion; ==> is a blitz path; ...> is the ball's path; ( ) marks a read defender; [ ] labels a zone. Receivers are numbered #1, #2, #3 from the outside in on each side. Every drawing must be followed by one plain-language sentence describing it — the same accessibility rule the book follows. Print the notation key on the cover page; this is not a memory test of symbols.

The count rule — both sides. Any Part C answer that does not show exactly eleven offensive players and eleven defenders loses the "count" point automatically, even if every assignment is right. On offense, also check legality: seven on the line, the two ends of the line and the backs eligible. A drawing with a covered tight end loses the count point too. Counting to eleven twice, and checking who is eligible, is the first job of every offensive coach before every snap.

Rules and safety note. Several items turn on rules that differ by level and change over time — ineligible linemen downfield (NFL one yard; college has historically allowed three, high school two), pre-snap motion, rub/pick contact, and low blocks. The key gives the NFL rule the book uses and accepts any answer that names the student's own level correctly and says "check your current code." Do not award credit for an answer that teaches a chop block or describes a rub as "blocking the defender." No item asks students to teach contact technique; if a student's answer prescribes a crack or cut block, it must be legal under the code named and described as the book does (in front, hands first, above the waist, head out).

All Outlaws, Sentinels, Pioneers, Forge, and Stallions people, games, calls, and numbers are fictional composites used throughout the book. Students should cite them as the book does. The companion book, NFL Defensive Coordination, tells the same season from Sacramento's sideline; it is not needed for this exam.

Chapters covered

Reference appendices for building your own variants: Appendix A — Terminology and Notation, Appendix B — Run Game Encyclopedia, Appendix C — Pass Concept Encyclopedia, Appendix D — Protection Reference, and Appendix E — Defensive Structure Recognition Guide.


PART A — Multiple Choice (35 points, 1 point each)

Choose the single best answer. Suggested time: 30 minutes.

A1. (Ch 1) Which ordering of the book's hierarchy runs from the level that lasts longest to the level that lasts shortest?

  • A. System → philosophy → game plan → playbook → call sheet → call
  • B. Call → call sheet → game plan → playbook → system → philosophy
  • C. Philosophy → playbook → system → call sheet → game plan → call
  • D. Philosophy → system → playbook → game plan → call sheet → call

A2. (Ch 1) The book says a great offense multiplies its one structural advantage in three ways. Which three?

  • A. Tempo, motion, and play-action
  • B. Run, pass, and screen
  • C. Conflict, sequence, and illusion
  • D. Formations, personnel, and matchups

A3. (Ch 2) Clark Shaughnessy's T formation with a man in motion is tied to which documented result?

  • A. The 1940 Chicago Bears' 73–0 championship win over Washington
  • B. The 1960s Packers' power sweep
  • C. The early-1990s Bills' K-Gun no-huddle
  • D. Boise State's "Statue of Liberty" in the 2007 Fiesta Bowl

A4. (Ch 19) Austin's "two receipts" rule says that before calling a play-action pass off a run:

  • A. The defender being lied to must have shown the reaction you will exploit twice, from the same picture, in this game.
  • B. The run must have gained at least ten yards twice in the game.
  • C. The offense must have run the play twice in practice that week.
  • D. The quarterback must have completed two passes from the formation.

A5. (Ch 3) Austin lines up with Brooks Harlan attached on the right and Trey Gaines on the line outside him. What has happened?

  • A. Nothing; both are eligible because they are on the line.
  • B. Gaines is ineligible because he is outside the tight end.
  • C. Harlan is covered up and is now an ineligible receiver.
  • D. The formation is illegal because only six players are on the line.

A6. (Ch 3) Which of these is not one of the five things Chapter 3 says a formation can do to a defense?

  • A. Force a strength call
  • B. Remove a defender from the box
  • C. Guarantee man coverage
  • D. Add a run gap

A7. (Ch 4) "Twelve" personnel means:

  • A. One running back, two tight ends, two wide receivers
  • B. Two running backs, one tight end, two wide receivers
  • C. One running back, one tight end, three wide receivers
  • D. One running back, two tight ends, and an extra lineman reporting eligible

A8. (Ch 4) "Heavy to throw, light to run" means:

  • A. Throw on early downs from big personnel because defenses expect the run, and run from spread personnel because the defense subs small to match.
  • B. Use heavy personnel only for play-action and light personnel only for screens.
  • C. Never run from 10 personnel.
  • D. Substitute every snap so the defense cannot match.

A9. (Ch 5) A 3-technique is aligned:

  • A. Head-up on the guard
  • B. On the outside shoulder of the guard
  • C. On the inside shoulder of the guard
  • D. On the inside shoulder of the tackle

A10. (Ch 5) Five offensive linemen plus one attached tight end create how many gaps along the line?

  • A. Five
  • B. Six
  • C. Seven
  • D. Eight

A11. (Ch 20) Vance turns to throw the slip screen and a retracing defensive end is standing in front of Ruffin. By Rome's rule, Vance should:

  • A. Throw it anyway; a screen caught behind the line is always safe.
  • B. Pump and throw downfield to the nearest receiver.
  • C. Throw it forward at Ruffin's feet — "throw it forward or don't throw it," and if it's covered, "eat it at his feet."
  • D. Pitch it backward to Ruffin so it counts as a run.

A12. (Ch 6) In the Outlaws' route tree, which digit is the dig (an in-breaker at 12)?

  • A. 4
  • B. 5
  • C. 8
  • D. 6

A13. (Ch 6) Mekhi Powers runs an option route and isn't sure whether he is facing man or zone. His rule is to:

  • A. Break out, away from the nearest defender
  • B. Break in, under the linebacker
  • C. Run the go
  • D. Sit and face the quarterback

A14. (Ch 7) Which two coverages are MOFC (middle of the field closed)?

  • A. Cover 1 and Cover 3
  • B. Cover 2 and Cover 4
  • C. Cover 2 and Cover 6
  • D. Cover 0 and Cover 4

A15. (Ch 7) Chapter 7's "six reads" begin with which read, and why?

  • A. The front, because it decides the run blocking
  • B. The corners, because they decide the quick game
  • C. The safeties, because how many are deep tells you how many defenders can be near the ball
  • D. Pressure, because the quarterback must protect himself first

A16. (Ch 7, 5) Against a double-A-gap mug look, the book's working assumption is:

  • A. Both linebackers are coming.
  • B. Neither linebacker is coming.
  • C. Assume one drops — and build an answer that survives whichever one does.
  • D. The Mike is always the rusher.

A17. (Ch 8) The Outlaws' call grammar, in order, is:

  • A. Formation → Personnel → Play → Protection → Motion → Tags
  • B. Play → Formation → Personnel → Tags → Protection → Motion
  • C. Personnel → Protection → Formation → Motion → Play → Tags
  • D. Personnel → Formation → Motion/Shift → Protection → Play/Concept → Tags

A18. (Ch 8) The coach-to-quarterback radio cuts off at 15 seconds on the play clock. Which Outlaws rule exists mainly because of that?

  • A. "Tags can't eat the concept."
  • B. "More than ten words, call the band."
  • C. "Kill the zeros."
  • D. "Hands before climb."

A19. (Ch 8) The huddle call is "Inside, Kill, Slants." At the line Vance sees nothing that makes him switch. Which play is snapped?

  • A. Inside — the first play is live until the switch is called
  • B. Slants, because the second play is the default
  • C. Whichever play Vance prefers; Kill gives him a full audible
  • D. A check-with-me from the weekly menu

A20. (Ch 9) On Austin's inside zone, Jalen Ruffin aims at the outside leg of the play-side guard and reads:

  • A. The Mike linebacker's first step
  • B. The first down lineman play-side of the center
  • C. The backside end
  • D. The free safety's depth

A21. (Ch 9) Against a bear front (a 0 on the center and 3-techniques on both guards), inside zone struggles because:

  • A. The back has no aiming point.
  • B. The tight end is always ineligible against a bear.
  • C. The bear front has two deep safeties.
  • D. All three interior linemen are covered, so there are no combos and nobody climbs to the linebackers.

A22. (Ch 10) The one blocking rule that covers every lineman on outside zone is:

  • A. "Nobody crosses my face."
  • B. "Block the man over you."
  • C. "Never touch the trap man."
  • D. "Hit, don't travel."

A23. (Ch 10) In Austin's convention for the call "Wide PA Boot Right":

  • A. The run fakes right and the quarterback boots right; nobody pulls.
  • B. It is the same as "Naked Right."
  • C. The quarterback boots left, and the backside tackle pulls.
  • D. The run fakes left, the quarterback boots right, and the boot-side guard pulls to protect the edge.

A24. (Ch 11) On the Outlaws' Counter Right, who kicks out and who wraps?

  • A. Lorusso kicks, Fitch wraps
  • B. Moss (LG) kicks, Achterberg (LT) wraps
  • C. Fale kicks, Lorusso wraps
  • D. Szabo kicks, Moss wraps

A25. (Ch 11) The rule "never touch the trap man" exists because:

  • A. Touching him is a penalty.
  • B. A chip warns the penetrator, who stops, squeezes, and meets the trapper in the hole.
  • C. The trap man is always a linebacker.
  • D. The center needs him for a combo.

A26. (Ch 12) Inside Read: the backside end squeezes hard down the line toward Ruffin. By Rome's rule, Vance should:

  • A. Pull and keep — "If he can tackle Jalen, he can't tackle you"
  • B. Give, because the end is attacking the dive
  • C. Throw the bubble regardless of the end
  • D. Pull, then hold the ball and look for a receiver

A27. (Ch 12) A defense answers the zone read with a scrape exchange ("Swap": the end takes the dive, a linebacker scrapes to the quarterback). Which Outlaws counter beats it?

  • A. Bash
  • B. Arc — the tight end arcs to block the scraper
  • C. Speed option to the boundary
  • D. Inside Read with no tag

A28. (Ch 13, 20) Under the NFL rule, an ineligible lineman may be no more than one yard beyond the line when a forward pass is thrown. Which pass does this limit not apply to?

  • A. The slant on Inside Slant
  • B. The glance on Inside Glance
  • C. A now screen caught behind the line of scrimmage
  • D. The pop pass to the tight end on Duo Pop

A29. (Ch 13) On Anchor A's second snap, Jordan Ames sat and bailed toward the slant window. What happened, and why?

  • A. Vance threw the slant anyway; Powers +17.
  • B. The play was flagged for an ineligible man downfield.
  • C. Vance kept on the zone read for 4 yards.
  • D. Vance handed off into the box Ames had left — five blockers on five — and Ruffin gained 7.

A30. (Ch 14) Vance comes to the line on 3rd-and-1 and sees a bear front: both A gaps are empty of linemen, with 3-techniques outside the guards. By "count the A gaps," the call is:

  • A. Wedge
  • B. The quarterback sneak
  • C. Toss crack
  • D. Power Pass, Y Leak

A31. (Ch 15) In the chapter's timing table, an intermediate route breaking at 10–12 yards is paired with:

  • A. A three-step drop and hitch, about 2.3–2.7 seconds
  • B. A catch-and-throw, about 1.0–1.3 seconds
  • C. A seven-step drop, about 4.0 seconds
  • D. Any drop, as long as the receiver is open

A32. (Ch 16) Which defender does levels attack, and what does it need to work against Tampa 2?

  • A. The flat defender; a back in the flat
  • B. The deep-half safety; a post
  • C. The hook defender; a vertical to carry the Mike ("no levels without a vertical")
  • D. The corner; a hitch at six

A33. (Ch 16) Against Cover 3, smash is best described as:

  • A. The perfect call — the corner is in a hi-lo
  • B. Illegal, because the corner route crosses the safety
  • C. A man-beater
  • D. Mostly a hitch read, because the corner bails to his deep third and sits over the corner route

A34. (Ch 17) The book says every man coverage has a "spare." Which of these is not a spare?

  • A. A rat or robber in the middle
  • B. A lurk player
  • C. A spy on the quarterback
  • D. The corner pressing the X

A35. (Ch 18) Why is four verticals ("All Go") "four on three" against Cover 3?

  • A. Four receivers run vertical against three deep defenders, and both seams land in the free safety's third.
  • B. Three receivers run against four rushers.
  • C. The offense keeps four blockers in against three rushers.
  • D. Four underneath defenders cover three short routes.

PART B — Short Answer (40 points, 4 points each)

A focused paragraph each. Name players, calls, and numbers where the question asks for them. Suggested time: 30 minutes.

B1. (Ch 1, 7) The book's hierarchy is philosophy → system → playbook → game plan → call sheet → call, and Lyle's rule is to solve every problem at the lowest level that can solve it. Austin lost the divisional playoff on the "Mills" interception, thrown into a post-snap rotation on the thirtieth third-and-long snap after twenty-nine straight two-high looks. At which level does Lyle's fix (the "middle-read tag") live, and why would rewriting the philosophy be the wrong level? Name the Outlaws "never" that the interception violated.

B2. (Ch 3, 4) Marisol's self-scout found that Austin's Twelve personnel started with a run action on 42 of 49 snaps, and Sacramento answered with a rule: "12 personnel always gets big nickel." (a) Define Twelve personnel. (b) Explain, using "personnel is not formation," why the tell lived in the personnel rather than the formation. (c) What does Marisol's "kill the zeros" rule tell you to do next, and what was Austin's spring install for Twelve?

B3. (Ch 7) State the Chapter 7 threshold concept in one sentence. Then apply the box count: Austin is in 11 personnel, Gun Doubles Right, Harlan attached. (a) Two-high nickel, six defenders in the box — how many blockers does inside zone have, and is the run "right"? (b) At the end of the cadence the strong safety walks down to eight yards over Harlan. What is the count now, and what are Austin's three ways to handle the extra man? (c) What happened on Week 12's 2nd-and-8 at the St. Louis 40, and what habit does it teach?

B4. (Ch 8, 16) Break the Week 12 call "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Zip, 60 Left, Smash, X Fade, Alert Post" into the six grammar slots. Then explain (a) where smash goes and why — what would have happened to the concept without the Zip — and (b) who owns the "Alert Post."

B5. (Ch 5, 9) Define covered and uncovered in Austin's inside-zone rules, including the shade rule. Then explain "hands before climb," and name the Week 2 result at St. Louis that produced the rule "Seven or fewer, run it; eight, take the throw."

B6. (Ch 3, 11) Marisol's Monday report after Game 2: with Ruffin offset toward Harlan in 2x2 on early downs, Austin ran counter or counter play-action on 14 of 19 snaps. (a) Is that a tell by her standard? State the standard. (b) Explain how Austin's rule "flip the formation, not the linemen" helped create it. (c) Give two fixes the chapter supports.

B7. (Ch 12) Explain the threshold concept "you can block a defender with a decision" using the arithmetic of inside zone vs. a six-man box. Then: Teo's Sentinels page shows the scrape exchange on 5 of 9 zone reads and the slow-play ("Sit") on 4 of 9, alternated by series. Which two counters do you carry, which answer does each beat, and why can't you carry just one? Finish with the quarterback-carry budget and who can raise it.

B8. (Ch 15, 16) State the Chapter 15 threshold concept in one sentence. Then explain why Chapter 15 insists that reads be written in roles, not positions, using flood: name the defender flood attacks, who that defender is in Cover 3 versus Cover 2, and what the quarterback throws when that defender jumps the flat and when he sinks.

B9. (Ch 17) Austin's mesh is "H sets it, Y tops it." (a) Explain how mesh beats man and how the same concept survives zone. (b) Give Lou Ventresca's three questions for judging a rub, and state the NFL line between a legal rub and offensive pass interference, hedged correctly. (c) Name the defense's answer to stacks and bunches and the offense's counter.

B10. (Ch 20) Week 10 at Portland, 4:58 left, Austin leads 24–13, 3rd-and-12 at the Portland 28. Teo's chart: Portland played Tampa 2 or Cover 2 on 14 of its last 17 third-and-10-plus snaps. Lyle calls "Eleven, Gun Trips Right, Middle." Ruffin gains 9 to the Portland 19, and Evan Dorsey kicks a 36-yard field goal. Was the screen right? Judge it by the job it was called for, name the coverage feature the middle screen attacks, and contrast it with what Lyle's father meant by yelling "Past the sticks!"


PART C — Draw It Up (40 points, 10 points each)

Each item gives you the pre-snap picture. On your answer sheet, draw the post-snap picture in the book's notation — eleven offensive players and eleven defenders, every assignment or route labeled — then answer the sub-questions and write one plain-language "described" sentence for your drawing. Suggested time: 35 minutes.

Scoring for every Part C item (10 points): count and legality — eleven on each side, correct symbols, a legal formation (1) · post-snap assignments, routes, and the key defender's reaction (4) · sub-questions (3) · the described sentence, which must let someone who cannot see your drawing reconstruct it (2).

C1 — Anchor A: "Inside Slant" and the linebacker who can't win (Ch 7, 12, 13)

Game 1, Austin's opening drive, 1st-and-10 at the Austin 32. The call is "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside Slant." The Sentinels show their two-high nickel "Home" look.

PRE-SNAP: Game 1, 1st-and-10, AUS 32 -- "Eleven, Gun Doubles
Right, Inside Slant" vs. two-high nickel

          F                                    $
  C           *                                          C
                    W         M
                 E     T    N     E
  X        H       O   O   O   O   O   Y                 Z
                         R Q

📊 Diagram (described): Austin has Sutton (X) wide left and Powers (H) in the left slot; five linemen with the center in the middle; Harlan (Y) attached on the right and Gaines (Z) wide right; Vance in the shotgun with Ruffin beside him on his left. The Sentinels show two deep safeties, Royce on the left and Holloway on the right; corners over both wide receivers; the nickel, Vo, over Powers with outside leverage; Ames (Will) on the left and Bell (Mike) in the middle at linebacker depth; and four down linemen, with Weller as a 5-technique on the right tackle's outside shoulder.

(a) Draw the post-snap picture twice, side by side: once when Ames triggers downhill on the zone flow, once when Ames sits and bails to the slant window. Show the run blocking, Harlan's assignment, the slant, the mesh, and the ball's path in each. (b) Name the conflict defender and state his two jobs. Why is it "five on five" when he sits? (c) What must the three backside linemen do on the throw side, and why — name the rule and the distance under your level's code.

C2 — Inside zone against an odd front (Ch 5, 9)

The call is "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside Right." The defense shows an odd front with a single-high safety.

PRE-SNAP: "Inside Right" vs. odd front, single high

                               F
  C            *                                        C
                      W           M
            E     T      N      T      E
  X       H     LT    LG    C    RG    RT   Y            Z
                         R  Q

📊 Diagram (described): Austin is in two-by-two with the split end and slot on the left, the tight end attached on the right, and the flanker wide right; Ruffin is in the gun on Vance's left, away from the run, as Austin aligns the back on gun runs. The defense has one deep safety in the middle; corners over both wide receivers; a nickel over the slot; two inside linebackers; and five men on the line — an end outside the left tackle, a 4i on the left tackle's inside shoulder, a nose head-up on the center (a 0-technique), a 4i on the right tackle's inside shoulder, and an end outside the tight end.

(a) Mark every lineman covered or uncovered, then draw the post-snap blocking: both combos, who climbs to which linebacker, the left tackle's job, the tight end's job, and the back's aiming point and read. (b) Count the box against your blockers. Which defender is unblocked by design, and how does the play handle him? (c) The nose is a strong two-gap player who stalls both combos on the first two snaps. Give the chapter's two answers.

C3 — Anchor B: Smash against Cover 2 (Ch 8, 15, 16)

Week 10 at Portland, second quarter, 2nd-and-6 at the Portland 31, tied 7–7. The call is "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 60 Left, Smash." The Pioneers show their Cover 2 look.

PRE-SNAP: Week 10, 2nd-and-6, POR 31 -- "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right,
60 Left, Smash" vs. Cover 2

           F                                     $
    C                                                     C
             *         W          M
                    E     T    T     E
  X        H        O   O   O   O   O   Y                 Z
                          Q  R

📊 Diagram (described): Austin is in two-by-two: Sutton (X) wide left and Powers (H) in the left slot, five linemen, Harlan (Y) attached on the right, Gaines (Z) wide right, Vance in the gun with Ruffin on his right. Portland shows two safeties at about thirteen yards on the hashes — Darnell Price on the left — and two corners rolled up at about five yards, Josh Kiel over Sutton on the left; a nickel over Powers, two linebackers, and a four-man front.

(a) Draw the post-snap picture: the smash routes with their depths, the backside routes, the protection's back, and Portland's Cover 2 drops. Label the hi-lo defender and the two throws. (b) On the touchdown, what did Kiel do and where did the ball go? What did he do on the next smash call in the third quarter, and what was the result? (c) Why does this concept go to the left side with no direction word, and what would adding "X Fade" to the call have done?

C4 — Protection math: "60 Left" against a five-man overload (Ch 5, 7, 17)

The call is "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 60 Left," a dropback pass. The defense shows nickel with the strong safety walked down outside Harlan and the Mike in the right A-gap.

PRE-SNAP: "60 Left" vs. a walked-down safety and an A-gap Mike

                               F
  C            *                                         C
                        W                    $
            E      N     M  T       E
  X       H     LT    LG    C   RG    RT   Y             Z
                            Q  R

📊 Diagram (described): Austin is in two-by-two with the tight end attached on the right and the back on Vance's right, the man side of "60 Left." The defense has one deep safety and the strong safety walked down just outside the tight end at about five yards; corners over both wide receivers; a nickel over the slot; the Will stacked at linebacker depth on the left; the Mike walked into the right A-gap; and four down linemen — an end outside the left tackle, a nose shaded to the left guard, a 3-technique on the right guard's outside shoulder, and an end outside the right tackle.

At the snap the defense rushes five: the nose, the 3-technique, the right end, the Mike, and the strong safety off the edge. The left end drops into the boundary flat; the Will and the nickel drop; the free safety and the corners play three deep.

(a) Draw the post-snap protection: every blocker's assignment under "60 Left," every rusher's path, and every dropper. Mark any blocker who blocks air and any rusher who is free. (b) Do the arithmetic: rushers, blockers, blockers who end up on rushers, free rushers. Where does the ball go, to whom, and how fast? (c) Vance flips the slide to "60 Right" before the snap. Does that fix the free rusher? Explain, and give one pre-snap protection change that does.


PART D — Film Scenario: "Whose Fault?" (35 points)

Write a structured essay for each. For every player or rule you grade, give the assignment, what happened, the rule followed or broken, and a grade. Then name what the coaches should change. The chapters' "whose fault?" drills grade the first cause, not the player nearest the ball. Suggested time: 25 minutes.

D1 — The Game 2 sack (20 points) (Ch 5, 7, 8)

Week 15 at Sacramento, third quarter, 6:51 left, tied 13–13. 3rd-and-7 at the Austin 38. Austin is in 11 personnel, two-by-two: Sutton wide to the boundary, Harlan flexed about four yards off the left tackle, Powers in the field slot, Gaines wide to the field, Ruffin in the gun on Vance's left. The call is a six-man dropback, "60 Left," with the rule Austin used against a double-A mug in Games 1 and 2: "six-man, back on the Mike." Lyle sends the call at 27 seconds; the radio cuts off at 15. At about 10 seconds Grant Weller walks out over the boundary side. Vance moves Ruffin out to the edge to take him. At the snap Weller drops to the boundary curl/flat; Rashad Coleman (3-technique) takes one step at Lorusso and drops into the field hot window under Powers; Simmons blitzes off the field edge and Fitch picks him up late; Marcus Bell comes through the right A-gap untouched. Vance's shoulders open to the hot at about 1.1 seconds, close when he sees Coleman, and Bell sacks him at about 1.9 seconds. Minus 9, punt. Lorusso, afterward: "I blocked air, Coach."

Grade the play. Who, or what, is at fault? Grade each of the six blockers and Vance. Name the first cause, explain why "nobody missed a block" and the protection still failed, and state what the chapter says about the weakest link. Then give the Game 3 protection — all three changes — and the receiver adjustment that went with it, and its result.

D2 — Choose ONE (15 points)

D2-A. Anchor D: why it worked (Ch 9, 19). Game 1, fourth quarter, Austin trails 27–20. From the Austin 49, Lyle calls four plays from the identical look — 11 personnel, Gun Doubles Right, Harlan attached right, Ruffin offset left — against the Sentinels' two-high nickel with Tre Holloway the strength-side safety at about ten yards. Inside zone right +5; inside zone right +7; "Inside PA, Gaines Post," +35 to the Sacramento 4; inside zone right, 4-yard touchdown, 27–27 with 7:31 left. Explain why the sequence worked. Name the lied-to defender, his assignment and key, what each snap taught him, why the fourth snap worked because of the third, and what the protection had to do on snap 3. Was Holloway at fault? Use the Chapter 19 threshold concept and the "two receipts" rule.

D2-B. The ineligible-downfield flag (Ch 5, 13). A preseason practice tape shows "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside Glance": inside zone right, with Powers running the glance (a skinny post) as the throw. The Will triggers downhill. Vance rides the mesh long — the ball leaves his hand at about 1.7 seconds — and hits the glance for 19 yards. The center, who has climbed toward the Mike on the zone rules, is about two and a half yards past the line when the ball is thrown. Flag: ineligible man downfield. The center says, "I blocked my zone rule." Whose fault — the center, the quarterback, the design, or the coaching? Give the rule at the NFL level and at your own level (hedged), the two quarterback rules from Chapter 13 that the snap broke, the line's throw-side rule, and the fix you would install on Wednesday.


Answer Key and Marking Notes

Part A

Part A answers (1 point each)
# Ans Ch Note
A1 D 1 Lifespans shrink from years to forty seconds. Solve every problem at the lowest level that can solve it.
A2 C 1 Conflict (one defender, two jobs), sequence (every play makes another better), illusion (plays that look alike until it's too late). Plus the thing no scheme replaces: eleven executing on the same count.
A3 A 2 The 1940 Bears' 73–0 title game is the documented showcase for Shaughnessy's T with a man in motion (§2.3).
A4 A 19 Two receipts: the lied-to defender has shown the reaction twice, from the same picture, in this game. One is a coincidence, two is a habit, three is a risk (§19.8).
A5 C 3 A receiver on the line outside the tight end covers him up. The classic formation trap; "In Ace, both receivers off" is the role-card fix (Ch 4).
A6 C 3 The five: force a strength call, remove a defender from the box, create leverage, isolate a receiver, add a run gap (§3.8). Formations ask questions; they guarantee nothing.
A7 A 4 First digit backs, second digit tight ends, receivers are the remainder. "Heavy" is 13; "Jumbo" is goal-line 23 with Rodney Kalu reporting.
A8 A 4 Draw big defenders with heavy personnel and make them cover; draw small ones with light personnel and make them fit the run (§4.5).
A9 B 5 2 = head-up on the guard; 2i = inside shade; 3 = outside shade. (Some systems swap 6 and 7 at the tight end; not relevant here.)
A10 C 5 Five linemen make six gaps; each attached tight end or wing adds one. A running quarterback adds a "plus-one."
A11 C 20 "Throw it forward or don't throw it." A backward pass that hits the ground is a live ball; if the screen is covered, eat it at his feet. Never throw downfield after the linemen release.
A12 D 6 Evens break in, odds break out: 6 dig at 12; 4 curl; 5 out; 8 post. The H runs 4/5/6 at 10.
A13 D 6 "In doubt, sit and face the quarterback." Every option route needs a tie-breaker the quarterback also knows.
A14 A 7 MOFC = one deep safety (Cover 1, Cover 3). Cover 2, 4, and 6 are MOFO; Cover 0 has nobody deep.
A15 C 7 Safeties first, then box, then front. Reading the front first is a named mistake in the chapter.
A16 C 7, 5 "Assume one drops." Game 2's sack was a mug in which a tackle dropped into the hot window. Treating a mug as one thing is a named mistake.
A17 D 8 The order is protection: a radio cut-off costs the least important words (the tags).
A18 B 8 The radio cut at 15 leaves about 25 seconds of radio on a normal snap. A long call goes as a band number.
A19 A 8 In a Kill, Play A is live; "Kill, kill!" switches. Vance says "Kill, kill" or the week's dummy word every time so the defense learns nothing (§8.8).
A20 B 9 Aim at the play-side guard's outside leg, read the first down lineman play-side of the center: bang, bounce, or bend. Aiming points vary by coach — a common teaching, not a law.
A21 D 9 Bear covers the center and both guards, so there are no combos and no climbs. Answers: Wham (from Twelve) or check out.
A22 A 10 Covered men reach ("Run him!" if he widens); uncovered men combo and overtake; backside men scoop or cut off.
A23 D 10 The word after "Boot" is the quarterback's direction; the boot-side guard pulls; nobody pulls on Naked. Wide fakes left, Vance boots right.
A24 B 11 Counter always goes away from Harlan. Counter Right: Moss kicks, Achterberg wraps. Counter Left mirrors it (Lorusso kicks, Fitch wraps).
A25 B 11 Influence him with a clean inside release or a pass set; never chip him.
A26 A 12 If the end can tackle the back, he can't tackle the quarterback. Read near shoulder and hips, not feet; decide by the front hip.
A27 B 12 Arc beats Swap and loses to Sit. Bash beats Sit and loses to Swap. Slice beats the mesh charge.
A28 C 13, 20 The limit applies to forward passes that cross the line. A screen caught behind the line carries no depth limit. College has historically allowed three yards and high school two — check your current code.
A29 D 13 Ames bailed, so Vance handed off into the box Ames left: five blockers on five (Harlan arcing to the alley safety, Weller a 5-technique). Ames was wrong both times — that is the design.
A30 B 14 Count the A gaps: empty of linemen → sneak; filled by shooters or a mugged Mike → wedge, power, or a pass.
A31 A 15 Quick (5–6 yards) ~1.0–1.3 s; intermediate (10–12) three-step and hitch ~2.3–2.7 s; deep (15–18) five-step and hitch ~2.7–3.2 s.
A32 C 16 Levels: a vertical, a low in at 5, a dig at 12. Without the vertical, the Tampa 2 Mike sits on the dig.
A33 D 16 Against Cover 3 the corner bails to the deep third, so the corner route has a defender over it; smash becomes a hitch read. Be precise about which coverage a concept attacks.
A34 D 17 A press corner on the X is a man defender, not a spare. Spares: rat, robber, lurk, spy, extra rusher — each a zone defender you can put in conflict.
A35 A 18 Both seams land in the free safety's third. Read his hips; throw away from him, on time.

Item analysis tip. If more than a third of the class misses A16 or A20, the "count, then read" habit is not in place; re-run the Chapter 7 six-reads table at the board before Part IV, because Chapter 22 assumes it. If many miss A19 or A23, the call grammar is fuzzy — that will bite in the 40-second simulation and in Chapter 25.

Part B

Part B model answers and marking (4 points each)

B1. The middle-read tag lives at the call level — a tag carried in the playbook and on the call sheet — a post-snap middle-of-the-field read attached to every third-and-long call that depends on a two-high tendency (1). Rewriting the philosophy would be the wrong level because the philosophy already said the right thing — read defenders, not receivers — and the failure was one call that decided before the snap with no post-snap check; changing the top of the hierarchy after one bad result is the named mistake "solving at the wrong level" (2). The "never" violated: "Never let a tendency outlive its evidence" — twenty-nine straight two-high snaps became the interception on the thirtieth (1). Accept "game plan" or "call sheet" for the level if the student explains that the fix is a tag built into specific calls. Award nothing for "the philosophy was wrong."

B2. (a) One running back, two tight ends, two wide receivers (1). (b) Austin varied Twelve's formations, but the group itself predicted a run action; personnel counts roster positions, and the defense sees it during the substitution, before any formation is shown, so Sacramento could answer with a group built for runs and play-action — big nickel, with a safety who can play Harlan in space and still fit the run (1). (c) Kill the zeros: any group with zero snaps of a play type is a tell, so install the missing families — dropback, RPO, screen — from Twelve before the defense builds the answer (1). The spring Twelve install was Duo Pop, Gun Empty, and Y Screen (1).

B3. Threshold: the defense tells you where to go — every shell, front, and pressure is a set of commitments, and every commitment leaves somewhere the defense can't be; run the play where they aren't (1). (a) Six blockers (five linemen and Harlan) against six in the box: the run is "right" (1). (b) Seven in the box against six blockers — one man is free. Throw (an RPO or a Kill to the pass), read him (make him the option key), or add a blocker (1). (c) Week 12 against St. Louis, 2nd-and-8 at the STL 40: a Twelve Kill call, a late safety creep after the count, Ruffin −2. The habit: count twice — at the line and at the end of the cadence — and have the linemen and back echo late changes (1).

B4. Slots (2 — all six correct; 1 for four or five): Personnel Eleven · Formation Gun Doubles Right · Motion Zip · Protection 60 Left · Concept Smash · Tags X Fade, Alert Post. (a) A one-side concept's home is the two-receiver side away from the attached Y — here the left, where Sutton is #1. With motion it goes to the motion man's side: Zip is Gaines's short motion toward the ball, so smash moves to the right and Gaines becomes the hitch. Without the Zip, smash would sit on Sutton's side and "X Fade" would replace the hitch — no hitch, no hi-lo: "tags can't eat the concept." Against Cover 3 the corner bailed and Vance took the hitch, Gaines +7 (1). (b) "Alert ___" belongs to the backside #2 unless a letter is named — with smash moved right, that is Powers in the left slot (1).

B5. Covered: a defender is on you or in your play-side gap; a shade belongs to the man he shades (1). Uncovered: nobody is — you combo the nearest covered teammate's man with your eyes on the linebacker and climb when he commits (1). Hands before climb: the double team moves the down lineman first; the blocker nearest the linebacker's path leaves only when the linebacker declares. Climbing early — Lorusso's "Early" at St. Louis — lets the down lineman through for a loss (1). Inside runs into eight-man boxes in Week 2 at St. Louis went 5 carries for 6 yards; the rule became "Seven or fewer, run it; eight, take the throw" (1).

B6. (a) Yes. Marisol's standard for a tell is about 70 percent on ten or more snaps; 14 of 19 is 74 percent on 19 snaps (1). (b) Austin flips the formation, not the linemen, so counter always goes away from Harlan; the back's gun alignment then put Ruffin on Harlan's side whenever counter was coming, and Sacramento built a tag around that alignment (Counter Left in Game 2 was spilled for +1) (1). (c) Any two (2): run plays other than counter with Ruffin offset toward Harlan, and run counter from the other alignment ("run the counter-tendency from both looks"); add a "backfield alignment by play" column to the self-scout; use Pistol to hide the back's side; carry the key-breaker from the same look.

B7. On a normal handoff the quarterback and the back don't block, so with six blockers against six box defenders the defense's alley player is still free; reading the backside end instead of blocking him leaves five blockers on five box defenders, plus a decision on the sixth — whatever he chooses, the ball goes to the other place (1). Carry Arc (beats Swap, loses to Sit) and Bash (beats Sit, loses to Swap) (1). You can't carry just one because the Sentinels alternate by series and each counter beats one answer and loses to the other; the booth names the answer from the first series and you call the counter that beats it (1). Budget: about three designed quarterback carries a game, up to five in the playoffs with Wade Harmon's sign-off; the threat is often worth more than the carries (1).

B8. Threshold: the quarterback reads a defender, not a receiver — a concept stresses one defender, and the throw goes wherever that defender isn't (1). Reads are written in roles because the same role belongs to different players in different coverages; the role survives a coverage change and a position doesn't (1). Flood attacks the curl/flat defender: in Cover 3, the outside underneath player on that side (the nickel or apex defender); in Cover 2 the flat belongs to the squatting corner (1). If he jumps the flat, throw the sail (12, breaking to 14–18); if he sinks under the sail, throw the flat (2–4 yards, width before depth); the clear-out keeps the deep defender off the sail (1).

B9. (a) Two shallow crossers meet over the ball with a sit route behind them; against man the chasers must go around each other, so traffic creates separation; against zone the crossers settle in windows and the sit finds the hole between hook defenders (1). (b) Lou Ventresca's questions: spot or man? hands or shoulders up? kept running? (1). In the NFL, blocking a defender more than a yard downfield before the pass is offensive pass interference; incidental contact while both players run their routes is legal. Officiating emphasis varies by year and other levels differ — check your code. Teach the rub as where you run, never whom you hit (1). (c) The defense answers stacks and bunches with in-out / banjo (switch) coverage; the counter is same-way routes or a Pivot (H Pivot) (1). Austin's switch-release tag, "Lace," is a bonus, not a substitute.

B10. Yes, it was right (1). A third-and-long screen is judged by what the snap has to buy: up 24–13 with under five minutes left and already in field-goal range, a sack or a turnover costs far more than a conversion gains, so the job was to protect the field goal, keep the clock moving, and take whatever yards came — the 9 yards shortened Dorsey's kick to 36 and made it 27–13 (2). The middle screen attacks a Mike who runs to the deep middle in Tampa 2, emptying the middle; Teo's 14-of-17 number said that's what Portland would play (1). "Past the sticks!" judges every third down by the conversion alone — right when only the conversion matters, wrong here. Full marks need the job, the coverage feature, and the score-and-field-position logic. A student who adds Lyle's line for a true give-up screen, "a punt with extra steps," shows the contrast well.

Part C

C1 — Anchor A, Inside Slant: model answer and marking
POST-SNAP, SNAP 1: Ames (W) fills -> Vance pulls, throws the slant

  C <-- X: go, clears the corner              $ <-- Y arcs to him
                  H  <- catch in the window
                 /      Ames just left       M <-- RG/C combo
                /        :                         climbs to him
               /         :  (W) ==> fills backside A/B gap
   *          H          :
  (wide,                 :  E    T    N    E
   outside)              :  ]    ]    ]    ]
                         : LT   LG    C   RG   RT    Y
                         :...... R <-> Q  (mesh; Q pulls)

📊 Diagram (described): On the first snap the line blocks inside zone to the right; the four down linemen and the Mike are blocked, and Harlan arc-releases to the strong safety. The Will, Ames, reads the zone flow and fills the backside gap. Vance rides Ruffin at the mesh, sees Ames commit, pulls the ball, and throws the slant to Powers in the window Ames just left, while Sutton's go clears the corner and the nickel stays wide with outside leverage. Powers gains 17.

POST-SNAP, SNAP 2: Ames (W) sits -> Vance hands off, five on five

  C <-- X: go                                 $ <-- Y arcs to him
       (W) <-- bails to the slant window
   H  slant: covered                     M  ]  <- climbed to
   *
                     E    T    N    E
                     ]    ]    ]    ]
                    LT   LG    C   RG   RT    Y
                           Q ...> R  -->  hits the box Ames left

📊 Diagram (described): On the second snap the blocking is identical. Ames sits and drops toward the slant window, so Vance hands the ball to Ruffin. With Ames out of the box, five linemen block five box defenders — the four down linemen and the Mike — and Harlan has the strong safety; Ruffin runs into the space Ames left and gains 7.

(b) The conflict defender is Jordan Ames, the Will (#45): his run fit is the backside A/B gap and his pass job is the slant window — on the same side, in opposite directions (1). When he sits, the box is five defenders (Rollins, the two tackles, Weller as a 5-technique, Bell) against five linemen, because Harlan is arcing to the alley safety and Vo is outside with leverage — wrong regardless (1). (c) Throw-side linemen block at the line — "hit, don't travel" — because an ineligible lineman may be no more than one yard downfield when a pass that crosses the line is thrown (NFL; college has historically allowed three yards and high school two; check your current code). The slant must be out on rhythm, about 1.0–1.3 seconds (1).

Marking. Four drawing points: two per branch (blocking and the key's reaction; the ball's path). Common errors: blocking Ames (then there is no read — it's a slant with a lineman on the conflict defender); reading Vo or Powers (reading the receiver, a named mistake); drawing Harlan blocking Weller (on Anchor A Harlan arcs and the tackle has Weller); Ruffin offset right (he is offset left); no go on the backside #1 (the unnamed RPO receiver runs a clear-out go by default).

C2 — Inside Right vs. an odd front: model answer and marking
POST-SNAP: Inside Right vs. odd -- (c) covered, (u) uncovered

                      W                 M
                      ^                 ^
                      |  LG climbs      |  RG climbs
          E       T        N         T        E
       (held by   ]       XX        XX        ]
        the fake) |      /  \      /  \       |
                 LT    LG    C    RG   RT     Y
                 (c)   (u)  (c)   (u)  (c)
               cuts off  LG+C on N  RG+RT on 4i
                 the 4i
                      R ...> aim: RG outside leg, read the 4i
                         Q (carries out the fake)

📊 Diagram (described): The center is covered by the nose and both tackles are covered by the 4i's; both guards are uncovered. The left guard and center double the nose and the left guard climbs to the backside inside linebacker; the right guard and right tackle double the play-side 4i and the right guard climbs to the play-side inside linebacker; the left tackle cuts off the backside 4i; the tight end blocks the end outside him. Ruffin, aligned on Vance's left, takes the handoff aiming at the right guard's outside leg and reads the play-side 4i; the backside end is left unblocked and held by Vance's carry-out.

(a) Covered: C, LT, RT. Uncovered: LG, RG (1 for the marks; the rest counts in the drawing points). (b) Box: five on the line plus two inside linebackers = seven, with the nickel apexed off the slot (the book counts an apex nickel as "half"); six blockers. The backside end is the play's designed free man, held by the quarterback's carry-out — or read on Inside Read, kicked on Slice, or bluffed on Bluff (1). (c) A two-gap nose who stays square stalls both combos so neither guard climbs. Chapter 9's answers: run Inside away from the side he favors, and get to duo, which puts two double teams on the front side on purpose (1). Partial credit for "check to outside zone or a gap run" only if the student explains the stalled-combo problem.

Common errors. Calling a tackle "uncovered" against a 4i (a shade belongs to the man he shades); climbing both guards at the snap (no "hands before climb"); aiming the back at the C-gap (that's outside zone's landmark); Ruffin aligned on the right (Austin aligns the gun back away from the run).

C3 — Anchor B, Smash vs. Cover 2: model answer and marking
POST-SNAP vs. COVER 2: Kiel squats -> throw the corner route

 ball ~18 . . .
  (pylon) ^       F Price                         $
           \      (held a step by the seam)
            \                 ^ Y seam aims between
             H  stem to 12,   |   the two safeties
             |  break to      |
             |  the pylon     |        <--------- Z dig at 12
   X  hitch 6|                |
   ^         |   [HOOK]   [HOOK]       [FLAT]
  (C) Kiel   H    W        M            C
   squats         (* walls H)
                  E    T    T    E
                  O    O    O    O    O    Y           Z
                               Q    R (man side: checks the Mike)

📊 Diagram (described): Sutton runs a hitch at six yards and Powers stems to twelve and breaks to the left pylon. Kiel, the Cover 2 corner, owns the flat and squats on the hitch, so he can't get depth on the corner route. Harlan's seam from the right aims between the two safeties and holds Price, the left half-field safety, on the hash a step too long. Gaines runs a dig at twelve on the right. The linebackers and nickel drop to the hooks, the right corner to his flat, the safeties to the deep halves; four linemen rush, and Ruffin, on Vance's right, checks the Mike. Vance throws the corner route over Kiel and in front of Price.

(b) On the touchdown Kiel squatted on the hitch (his flat rule) and Vance threw the corner route over him and under Price — Powers 31 yards, 14–7. On the next smash call in the third quarter Kiel sank under the corner route and Vance threw the hitch — Sutton +8. The corner must choose, and both choices lose (1). Teo's Portland chart had Kiel squatting on 17 of 21 smash/hitch looks (a bonus, not required). (c) With no direction word or motion, a one-side concept goes to the two-receiver side away from the attached Y — the left (1). Adding "X Fade" would replace Sutton's hitch with a fade: no hitch, no hi-lo on the corner. "Tags can't eat the concept"; move the concept with a direction word or motion instead (1).

Marking notes. The corner route must show the stem to about 12 and the break toward the pylon at about 18; a route that breaks at nine and flattens lands near the safety (a named mistake). A hitch drawn at eight yards loses a drawing point (the chapter's pick-six mistake). The read must be written as the corner's action, not a receiver's name. A student who adds "against Cover 3 this becomes a hitch read" earns no extra points but deserves a note.

C4 — "60 Left" vs. the overload: model answer and marking
POST-SNAP: "60 Left" vs. the overload -- 5 rush, 6 block, 1 free

 [DEEP 1/3]             [DEEP 1/3]              [DEEP 1/3]
     C                      F                        C
 [FLAT]        [HOOK]                  [CURL/FLAT]
   E (drops)     W (drops)               * (drops)

                      N          M     T       E        $
                      v          v     v       v      ==>  FREE
                      ]          ]     ]       ]
        LT      LG    C          R    RG      RT      Y --> hot
       (air:  (air:  (A gap:   (back,  (man:   (man:
        C gap) B gap) nose)    on M)   3-tech)  end)
                           Q  -- ball to Y, ~1.0-1.3 s

📊 Diagram (described): Under "60 Left," the center, left guard, and left tackle slide left and take the A, B, and C gaps. The nose is in the center's A-gap and is blocked; nobody comes through the left guard's B-gap, and the left end drops to the flat, so the left guard and left tackle block air. On the man side the right guard takes the 3-technique, the right tackle takes the end, and Ruffin, scanning inside-out, takes the Mike in the A-gap. The strong safety comes off the right edge untouched. The Will, the nickel, and the left end drop underneath; three defenders play deep. Vance throws hot to Harlan in the area the strong safety vacated.

(b) Arithmetic (2): rushers 5; blockers 6; blockers who end up on rushers 4 (center, RG, RT, Ruffin) — LT and LG block air; free rushers 1, the strong safety. "Count blockers who end up on rushers. An air block is a blocker you didn't have." The ball goes hot, to Harlan — the receiver nearest the area the blitzer left — on rhythm, about 1.0–1.3 seconds (1). Accept a sight-adjust by another receiver on the blitz side if the student names the vacated area correctly. (c) No (1). "60 Right" makes the center, right guard, and right tackle slide to the right A, B, and C gaps — the Mike, the 3-technique, and the end — while the man side takes the nose and the dropping left end and the back, now on the left, checks the Will. The strong safety is a fourth rusher outside the C gap, so he is still free: the slide covers only three gaps. Fixes that work: "70" — Harlan stays in and takes the edge, seven blockers, nobody free, at the cost of a receiver; or keep 60 and make the hot real (Harlan's hot route called and repped). A student who applies the Chapter 22 overload rule — slide to the most bodies, set the back to the same side, make the leftover your hot — earns full credit.

Common errors. Counting the dropping end as a rusher (draw what happened, not what was assigned); having Ruffin take the strong safety and leaving the Mike free (the back scans inside-out — A, B, edge); no hot named ("the hot has to be open, not just assigned").

Part D

D1 — The Game 2 sack: model answer and marking (20 points)

Grades (8 points — 1 per player graded, plus 1 for "nobody missed a block").

Player Assignment after Vance's adjustment What happened Grade
Achterberg (LT) Slide: Rollins Blocked him Plus
Moss (LG) Slide: the nose Blocked him Plus
Szabo (C) Slide: Ames in the left A-gap Blocked him Plus
Lorusso (RG) Man: Coleman Coleman stepped in, then dropped — air Rule-correct ("I blocked air, Coach")
Fitch (RT) First threat outside: Simmons Picked him up late Minus on timing; not the cause
Ruffin Moved by Vance to Weller Weller dropped — air Rule-correct
Vance Bell free by design; throw hot Correct read; shoulders opened at ~1.1 s, closed when Coleman appeared in the window; sacked at ~1.9 s Correct process; a 0.4-second hesitation, but the hot was covered

Nobody missed a block. On paper the protection was right: Bell was free by design and Vance had a hot.

First cause (5 points). The protection rule and the plan around it — a coaching problem, not a player problem (2). "Six-man, back on the Mike" was predictable, and Sacramento built a pressure to attack it: two men who looked like rushers (Weller and Coleman) dropped, two Austin blockers blocked air, and the dropping tackle sat in the hot window (2). The chapter's line: the weakest link can be a player or a rule — the defense chooses your worst matchup or your most predictable protection rule (1).

The clock (2 points). Weller walked at about 10 seconds, after the radio cut off at 15. From then it was Vance and Szabo alone with the rules they had been given, which is why the fix had to live in the rules, not in a call from the sideline (Ch 8). Chapter 7's mug rule — "assume one drops" — is the recognition half of the same lesson.

The Game 3 fix and result (5 points). Take the mugged linebackers directly: center on the Mike (Bell), Ruffin on the other A-gap backer (Ames), and the right tackle widens to the corner (Simmons) (3). The receiver half: Gaines sight-adjusts to a 6-yard hitch if his corner blitzes (1). Result, Game 3, 3rd-and-7 at the Austin 41 (Anchor C): the Sentinels called the same pressure, zero free rushers, Gaines hitch +10, first down; the drive ended in the field goal that tied it 10–10 (1).

Deduct up to 4 points for naming Vance or Lorusso as the first cause. The play is in the book to teach that a sack can be nobody's missed block. Chapter 22 develops the protection rules in full; a student who cites its "two hots, two sides" rule earns a note, not points.

D2-A — Anchor D: model answer and marking (15 points)

The lied-to defender (3). Tre Holloway (#31), the strength-side safety in the two-high nickel. His assignment: the alley run fit to the tight-end side, with a deep quarter behind it if the play is a pass. Weller aligned as a 9-technique outside Harlan, and Harlan blocked Weller on all four snaps — so Holloway was the unblocked alley player by design. His key was the run action: the mesh and the guard's first step.

What each snap taught him (5). Snap 1, inside zone, +5: he filled the alley — the first receipt. Snap 2, inside zone, +7 and a first down: he filled harder and earlier (he had been coming downhill since his flat angle on the 45-yard run in the second quarter) — the second receipt, and the two receipts rule now permits the play-action. Snap 3, "Inside PA, Gaines Post," from the identical look: Holloway triggered on the fake and Gaines ran the post behind his vacated deep quarter; Royce, on the far hash with Sutton, ran him down at the 4 — +35. Snap 4, inside zone again (a fast-mode snap; the Sentinels stayed in nickel): Holloway, burned, hesitated — one step, then stop — the alley opened, and Ruffin scored from the 4. The fourth snap worked because of the third: the defense's correction to the pass was the wrong answer to the run.

The protection on snap 3 (3). Zone play-action can't hold the backside end with a fake, so it must block him: seven-man protection, with the left tackle hinging on Rollins. The linemen fire out like the run but stay within the legal distance on a pass that crosses the line — aggressive at the line, not past it. Gaines faked a block for three steps before releasing, copying the run for the eyes that mattered.

Fault and threshold (4). Holloway's assignment was right every time; the offense beat his order of operations. "You can't lie to a man with one job" — Holloway had two (2). Chapter 19's threshold: the run is the first half of every play-action pass — the pass is only as good as the run it imitates and the run's history in this game. You don't call play-action; you cash it (2).

D2-B — The ineligible-downfield flag: model answer and marking (15 points)

The rule (3). In the NFL an ineligible lineman may be no more than one yard beyond the line when a forward pass that crosses the line is thrown. The glance crosses the line, so a center two and a half yards downfield is a foul under the NFL rule. College has historically allowed up to three yards (so the same snap might have been legal under that number) and high school two (still a foul); these numbers have been debated and changed — check your current code. A screen caught behind the line would carry no limit.

Whose fault (6). The center is rule-correct: on the RPO the throw-side linemen block at the line ("hit, don't travel"), but the front-side center may climb on his zone rules, and a climbing lineman crosses one yard roughly a second after the snap (2). The first cause is the quarterback's timing: the ball came out at about 1.7 seconds after a long ride, when an NFL RPO throw that crosses the line must be gone by roughly 1.2 (2). The rules broken: decide by the time the ball reaches the front hip (the late pull) and "pull means throw or run, never hold." Accept "key plus window" if the student argues Vance waited to see the receiver — reading the receiver is a named mistake (2).

The fix (6). On Wednesday, rep "pull, hop, throw" against a manager who steps forward or back on a signal, with a coach timing the release; count the rep only if the ball leaves before a climbing lineman reaches the one-yard line (2). Teach the late-pull rule: if the ball isn't out on rhythm, hand off or run — never throw late (1). Put your level's distance at the top of the RPO page and re-check it every season (1). Design option: if the glance needs more time, move it into a play-action version with real pass protection where the linemen stay home (1). Grade the coaching, not only the player: the throw-side rule was taught, but the timing rule was never drilled against a clock (1).

Deduct up to 4 points if the student blames the center alone. Chapter 13's preseason flag on Szabo and Lyle's college "Inside Seam" touchdown called back are the book's own examples; students who cite them accurately earn a note, not points.


Point distribution summary

Part Chapters emphasized Points Share
A — Multiple choice All twenty, 1–3 items per chapter 35 23%
B — Short answer 1, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, 15, 16, 17, 20 40 27%
C — Draw it up 5, 7, 8, 9, 12, 13, 15, 16, 17 40 27%
D — Whose fault? 5, 7, 8, 9, 13, 19 35 23%
Total 150 100%

Grade bands (suggested). 135+ = ready to install an offense on a staff; 120–134 = solid, revisit the weakest part; 105–119 = can label but not yet apply — re-teach the threshold concepts with board work before Part IV; below 105 = schedule a one-on-one board session (draw C1 and C4 together, then re-grade D1 orally).

Returning the exam. Hand back Part C with the model diagrams beside each student's drawing and have students redraw any item scoring below 7. The redraw is due with their next Playbook Project milestone. Diagram fluency compounds: Chapters 21–40 assume it on every page, and the Chapter 24 game plan and the Chapter 25 call sheet are built from exactly these four pictures — the RPO, the inside run, the coverage-beater, and the protection with its hot.