Chapter 33 Exercises — Trick Plays, Gadgets, and Calculated Deception
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension (film study and research)
All teams, players, and game situations below are fictional unless they are the historical plays named in the chapter (the Philly Special and Boise State's 2007 Fiesta Bowl). Situations marked hypothetical are practice scenarios, not games from the Outlaws' season. Selected answers are in Appendix J.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. In one sentence each, define a trick play and a gadget as this chapter uses the words. Why is every gadget a trick play, but not every trick play a gadget?
A2. What is a gadget's parent play? Explain why a reverse with no jet sweep in your offense is a weaker play than a reverse off a jet sweep you run every week.
A3. Finish the sentence from the chapter's "cool play" test and explain what each blank requires: "This works because number ___ does ___ on ___ out of ___ snaps."
A4. List the three conditions for calling a gadget. For each, give one sentence on what goes wrong if it is missing.
A5. Distinguish a reverse from an end-around: how many exchanges, what the defense sees go the wrong way, and which kind of backside defender each one punishes.
A6. State the three rules that shape every double-pass or throwback gadget: how many forward passes are allowed per down and from where; what happens if the first throw drifts forward; and what happens when a backward pass hits the ground.
A7. Why does the chapter say a flea flicker is for a defender who keys the ball, while ordinary play-action is for a defender who keys run action? Why does that matter for which play you call?
A8. What is a look-check on a fake punt or fake field goal, and who uses it?
A9. Why does Lyle say novelty is "the only advantage that's guaranteed to expire"? Connect your answer to Curtis Bale's first and second seasons.
A10. Why does the gadget card include both "evidence" and an "in-game trigger"? Give an example of a gadget whose evidence is strong but whose trigger never shows up.
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
B1. Describe what you see:
PRE-SNAP
F
C C
W M $
E T T E
X H O O O O O Y Z
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~>
R Q
POST-SNAP (what the left side of the defense does)
^ (corner bails)
C E -----------------> W ------>
📊 Diagram (described): The offense is in two-by-two with the tight end attached right and the slot receiver on the left starting jet motion to the right. The defense shows one deep safety. After the snap, the left corner runs to his deep third, the left defensive end chases flat down the line toward the jet, and the Will linebacker scrapes toward the jet.
(a) What habit is the left defensive end showing? (b) Which two other behaviors make this a reverse look, not just a chasing end? (c) Name the gadget, and name one thing that would make you not call it even with this picture.
B2. On film, a safety aligned at 13 yards takes two steps forward on every inside-zone handoff, but on play-action passes he stays at 13 and drifts to the deep middle. What is he keying? Which gadget does he invite, and which ordinary play is unlikely to fool him?
B3. You're watching a bubble screen. The outside receiver runs at the corner to stalk-block him. The corner explodes downhill, takes on the block at the line, and forces the bubble back inside. You see this on three straight bubbles. What gadget is this corner inviting? What must be true of the first throw for the gadget to be legal?
B4. Watch the broadcast of the Philly Special (Super Bowl LII). Before the snap, what does the quarterback do that looks like ordinary football? After the snap, which defenders move toward the ball, and who, if anyone, is watching the quarterback? Write two sentences on why the play worked as a mechanism, not as luck.
B5. A punt-return unit on film: on 14 of its last 18 opponent punts, the two defenders over the offense's wide gunner turned and ran back toward the returner before the ball was kicked. What does this habit invite, who on your staff owns the decision, and what would the look-check be?
B6. A team lines up for an extra point with the snapper and holder alone in the middle and five players split far to the right. The defense sends two players out to cover them. What should the offense do? What if the defense sends five?
B7. Describe what you see:
POST-SNAP
F (13 yds, steps forward 2)
W ---> M ---> S ---> $ --->
E T T E
U-] O O O O O Y-]
Q <. . .
R (has taken the handoff, turning back)
📊 Diagram (described): After the snap, the offense has two tight ends attached and has handed the ball to the back, who is turning around to pitch it back to the quarterback. The linebackers and the strong safety are flowing toward the run, and the deep safety has taken two steps forward.
(a) Name the play. (b) Which defender's reaction decides where the ball goes? (c) What must the offensive linemen not do on this play, and why?
B8. On All-22 film, a backside defensive end squeezes two steps down the line on a jet sweep, then stops, opens his hips back toward the side the jet came from, and waits. Two weeks earlier, on the same team's film, he chased flat on every jet. What changed, and what does it tell an offensive coordinator about that team's opponents in the last two weeks?
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
C1. Make the call (hypothetical). Week 5 vs. a fictional opponent. First quarter, 0–0, first-and-ten at your own 39. Their backside end chased 16 of 20 jet sweeps over their last four games. You've run one jet sweep today; he chased it, and it gained four. Your reverse off the jet has had twelve clean reps this week. Do you call it now? If not, when?
Short answer
Not yet. The evidence (80% on 20) is strong, but the card's in-game trigger is two chases, and you've seen one. Run the jet once more (it's working anyway). If he chases again, the reverse is live on the next first down or second-and-short between the 35s. Calling it now spends the gadget on half the confirmation the card requires.C2. Draw it up. Draw the Outlaws' Z Reverse (pre-snap and post-snap) against a two-high defense instead of Albuquerque's single-high. Mark the exchange point. Which defender becomes the biggest threat to the reverse when there are two deep safeties, and how would you account for him?
Short answer
With two high safeties, the backside safety (the one on the reverse side) is now the most likely tackler: he isn't moving toward the jet in the middle; he's on that side. Account for him by having the X stalk the corner and Ruffin lead to the safety (not "first color"), or by calling the reverse only if the defense rotates toward the jet at the snap (a rotation trigger). If the backside safety holds his ground on every jet, the reverse is a poor call against this defense.C3. Make the call (hypothetical). Fourth-and-goal at the opponent's 2, second quarter, you lead 14–10. Marisol's chart says "go." Wade agrees to go. Your goal-line package has a power run, a play-action pass to the tight end, and a direct-snap gadget in which the quarterback slips out (your version of a "Philly Special"). The opponent's goal-line defense has flowed hard to the ball on 11 of 12 snaps inside the 5 this season, and nobody has been assigned to your quarterback on any of them. What do you call?
Short answer
The direct-snap gadget is defensible: the down is one where every play is a bet (fourth-and-goal), the habit (flow to the ball, no one on the QB) is above the line at 11 of 12, and failure costs a turnover on downs at the 2, which leaves the opponent pinned. The power run is also defensible if your line has won all day. What's graded is naming the habit and the reason the situation pays for the risk. Confirm the gadget has its twelve clean reps and that the quarterback's alignment makes him eligible under your code.C4. Draw it up. Draw a flea flicker from your base personnel against a Cover 1 defense (one deep free safety, man coverage underneath). Which defender is the target, and which route do you throw? What additional danger does man coverage create for the pitch back?
Short answer
The target is still the free safety, the only deep player; if he steps up on the handoff, the post or a deep over behind him is open. In man coverage the corners are watching their receivers, not the backfield, so the corners are rarely fooled; the throw goes to the route that wins *behind the safety*, not past a peeking corner. The extra danger: in Cover 1 the defense often has a "rat" or "robber" (a defender in the middle at linebacker depth) or a linebacker assigned to the back. When the back stops and pitches, the defender covering him is free to come straight at the quarterback during the pitch. Keep the back in to block after he pitches, and use max protection so a rusher doesn't come free during the second and a half the ball spends going back and forth.C5. Make the call (hypothetical). Two-minute drill, end of the first half, eight seconds left, ball at the opponent's 46, you trail by three. Your kicker's range is about 52 yards. Options: a Hail Mary, a hook-and-lateral, or a sideline throw to set up a long field goal. Choose and defend.
Short answer
From the 46, a completion to the sideline around the 34 with the clock stopped puts a ~52-yard kick at the edge of range; with eight seconds, it's realistic only if the throw is quick and out of bounds. The hook-and-lateral needs space and time to work and is better saved for the final play from farther out when only a touchdown helps. The Hail Mary gives the touchdown chance but no field goal. If three points tie or meaningfully help, the sideline throw is the best percentage; the gadget is the end-of-game play when only a touchdown matters.C6. Make the call (hypothetical). Your H Bubble Pass has been on your card for six weeks without a trigger. This week's opponent's field corner attacked the stalk on 8 of 9 bubbles over the last four games. In the first quarter, on your first bubble, he sits at six yards and doesn't attack. What do you do with the gadget today?
Short answer
Leave it in the box for now. The evidence (8 of 9, just under the ten-snap line) put it on the card; today's first look contradicts it. The defense may have installed a rule for this game, or he may have been playing a different coverage call on that snap. Run another plain bubble later (the parent play should be fine against a sitting corner if your stalk block is good) and watch him again. If he attacks on two later bubbles, the gadget is live; if he keeps sitting, consider the play his habit invites instead: the receiver running past a corner who sits at six (a "Bubble Go"-style release with the quarterback throwing it himself).C7. Draw it up (hypothetical). Design an end-around for a defense whose backside linebacker and backside end both flow hard with your outside zone (on film, the end flowed on 13 of 16 outside-zone runs to the other side; the backside linebacker on 15 of 16). Draw it pre-snap and post-snap from your base outside-zone formation. Who gets the ball, who blocks the edge on the end-around side, and what does the quarterback do after the handoff?
Short answer
Use the outside-zone formation you run most (for the Outlaws, Twelve, under center or pistol, with the tight end attached). The receiver on the back side (the side away from the outside zone) comes behind the quarterback at the snap and takes the ball directly from him while the back fakes outside zone the other way. The line blocks outside zone for a full count. The backside tackle lets the flowing end go (as on the reverse) and works to the second level; the backside tight end or a receiver blocks the first defender outside. The quarterback carries out a boot-style fake or simply drifts with the zone action. He does not block. Because the exchange is from the quarterback, the end-around reaches the edge faster than a reverse; it relies on the backside flowing with the *backfield*, which 13 of 16 and 15 of 16 confirm.Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. Your quarterback is your franchise. A staff member proposes a throwback in which the quarterback throws a lateral, runs into the flat, and catches a pass from the receiver, likely taking a hit as he does. Weigh the reward against quarterback health. What rules or changes would make it acceptable, if any?
D2. "Gadgets are for teams that can't run their offense." Argue for and against this statement, using the Week 13 reverse and Curtis Bale's second season as evidence.
D3. Your special-teams coordinator wants a fake punt in your own territory because the opponent's return unit bails early. Wade owns the call. Lay out the case for and against calling it at fourth-and-four at your own 34 in the second quarter of a tied game. What would Marisol need to show Wade?
D4. You have practice time for one gadget this week. Option A is a reverse aimed at a backside end with a strong chasing habit; Option B is a double pass aimed at a corner with a moderate habit (about 65% on 12 snaps), but the double pass would also serve as next week's "next layer." Which do you practice, and why?
D5. Your best receiver is the only player who can run the reverse well. He's also your No. 1 pass target, and he's been playing through a sore ankle. The reverse's trigger appears early in the second quarter of a close game. List what you weigh (his health, the exchange risk, what the play is worth compared with his next ten targets) and decide whether the play stays live today.
D6. After the Week 13 reverse, Kittredge stopped chasing and the jet sweep gained eleven. Explain how a gadget can be "worth" more than the yards it gains. Is there any way to measure that value with the kinds of data Marisol keeps?
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (Ch 33 + Chapter 19, Play-Action Passing). Compare the "two receipts" rule for play-action with the in-game trigger on a gadget card. Why might a gadget need more receipts than play-action, not fewer?
M2. (Ch 33 + Chapter 12, The Option Game). The zone read leaves the backside end unblocked and reads him after the snap. The Z Reverse leaves the same kind of defender unblocked and doesn't read him at all. Explain both choices. What does the reverse rely on instead of a read?
M3. (Ch 33 + Chapter 22, Pass Protection). A flea flicker holds the ball roughly a second and a half longer than a normal play-action pass before the quarterback can look downfield. Using Chapter 22's protection arithmetic, explain why the flea uses eight blockers when ordinary inside play-action uses seven. What is the quarterback's "hot" answer if a rusher comes free during the pitch back?
M4. (Ch 33 + Chapter 27, Motion and Shifts). Austin's jet motion has a "job." List three jobs jet motion can do on Jet Right and the Z Reverse. Then explain how a tendency in who runs the jet motion (Jaylen Cross early in the season) can turn motion into a tell.
M5. (Ch 33 + Chapter 14, Short Yardage and Goal Line). Austin's two-point base play is "Sprint Right, Snag." Design a gadget for the two-point try that shares its first second with Sprint Right, Snag. Name the victim and habit you'd need to see on film.
M6. (Ch 33 + Chapter 24, Building the Game Plan, and Chapter 23, The Scouting Report). The divisional-round plan carried two gadgets in a box with 112 calls. Describe where the gadget box's inputs come from in the scouting report (which fields Teo would need to tag on every opponent snap), and how the gadget box interacts with the opening script: should a gadget ever be scripted? Defend your answer with the in-game trigger idea.
M7. (Ch 33 + Chapter 28, Analytics). Marisol says, "Five is not a sample. It's five stories." How should an offense evaluate its gadgets at the end of a season if the results are too few to analyze statistically? Propose two process measures (not results) she could track.
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. The trick-play log. Over three weekends of NFL or college games, log every trick play you see: the family (use the chapter's table), the down, distance, field position, score, and result. For each, rewind the broadcast or All-22 and look for the victim doing the habit on a normal play earlier in the game. Classify each gadget as "evidence" (you found the habit) or "unknown." What share of the gadgets that worked fall in each group?
E2. The parent-play audit. Pick one NFL team you can watch weekly. Chart its jet motion (or another motion it uses often) for four games: how often the motion man gets the ball, and how often the defense's backside end and backside linebacker chase. If you were that team's coordinator, would you have a reverse on the card? Write the gadget card's evidence field.
E3. The Boise State night. Watch the final minutes of regulation and the overtime of the 2007 Fiesta Bowl (Boise State vs. Oklahoma). For each of Boise State's three trick plays, record the down and distance (as best the broadcast shows), what the defense was keying, and why the conventional play had poor odds in that situation. Do not rely on memory or on secondhand descriptions; record what the film shows.