Five minutes and fourteen seconds. Week 12, at home against the St. Louis Stallions (fictional, like
In This Chapter
- The Hook: Six Power Lefts and One Lie
- 11.1 What a Gap Scheme Is: We Pick the Hole
- 11.2 Power: Tell Them Where, Then Keep the Promise
- 11.3 Counter: Two Pullers and a Step the Wrong Way
- 11.4 Trap: If Nobody Blocks You, Somebody's Coming
- 11.5 Duo, Dart, and Pin-and-Pull: The Cousins
- 11.6 Pullers Are Keys — and Keys Can Lie
- 11.7 Gap or Zone? The Trade-offs
- 11.8 QB Power and QB Counter: The Plus-One
- Spaced Review
- Project Checkpoint: Gap Scheme Sheet
- Chapter Summary
- What's Next
Chapter 11 — Gap Schemes: Power, Counter, Trap, and Creating a Specific Hole with Physical Blocking
The Hook: Six Power Lefts and One Lie
Five minutes and fourteen seconds. Week 12, at home against the St. Louis Stallions (fictional, like every team and player in our world), and we were up 23–16 with the ball on our own 25 after their punt. They had two timeouts left. We had a seven-point lead and one job: never give the ball back.
Coaches call this the four-minute offense: the offense with a lead trying to end the game by running the clock while still making first downs. It's the one time all season that everybody in the building knows what I'm going to call. The fans know. The Stallions know. Frank Ostrowski, their defensive coordinator, has known since the third quarter, and he'd already sent his answer onto the field: eight men in the box, the strong safety walked down to six yards outside our tight end, one safety deep in the middle.
I said it into Darius Vance's helmet anyway. "Twenty-one, I Left, Power Left."
Marcus "Moose" Odom, number 33, our short-yardage and four-minute back, was in for Jalen Ruffin. Sione Fale (#44) was at fullback in front of him. Brooks Harlan (#87) was attached on the left. At the snap, Harlan blocked down on the end inside him, Ben Achterberg and Kendrick Moss drove the 3-technique back off the ball, Aaron Szabo blocked back on the nose, Fale kicked out their end man on the left, and Pete Lorusso — number 64, our right guard — pulled across behind the center, turned up through the crease, and hit the first linebacker he saw. Moose followed him. Six yards. St. Louis called timeout.
Same call. Three yards. Their last timeout.
Third-and-1 at our 34. Same call. Moose put his face behind Lorusso's back and fell forward for four. First down at our 38, five minutes left, and now the clock was ours.
That's when Teo's voice came up from the booth. Mateo Arriaga is our quality control coach; on game day he sits upstairs with a laptop and a better view than mine.
Teo: "Fifty-five's leaving with Fale. Every snap. He's gone before Pete pulls."
Fifty-five was Hollis Mabry, the Stallions' Mike linebacker. Ostrowski teaches his linebackers to read the fullback in two-back sets — the near back, the old-school key — and Mabry is very good at it. On all three Power snaps he'd seen Fale's first step go left and beaten Lorusso to the hole by half a step. We were still getting four and five yards, because a double team and a pulling guard will move a pile even when the linebacker knows. But he knew. He knew because Fale told him.
I've said it to Russ Kimbrough and I'll say it to you: "Every linebacker has a key. My job is to find out what it is and make it lie."
"Twenty-one, I Left, Counter Right."
Same personnel, same huddle, same formation, same Fale. At the snap Fale stepped left, exactly as he had three times, and blocked their Sam linebacker on the backside. Moose took a jab step left, exactly the Power path, then planted and came back right. And Kendrick Moss and Ben Achterberg — our left guard and left tackle — pulled to the right, Moss kicking out the end and Achterberg wrapping up into the hole. Mabry ran left with Fale. He was gone before Moose cut.
Odom, fourteen yards, to their 48.
Then we went back to Power. Two yards. Three yards. Third-and-5 at their 43 with a little under three minutes left, and Wade Harmon, our head coach, came onto my channel.
Wade: "Run it. We don't get it, we punt, and they've got no timeouts and ninety yards."
Power Left. Lorusso pulled, Fale kicked, and Moose fell forward for six. First down at their 37. The two-minute warning came and went, Vance took three knees, and the clock ran out before we had to snap it a fourth time. Final, 23–16.
Seven runs. Six of them were the same play, and the defense knew it was coming every time. One of them was a different play built to look like the first one for exactly one step. They never got the ball back.
That drive is this chapter. The six Power Lefts are what a gap scheme is: you pick the hole before the snap, and you bring more of your blockers to that hole than they have defenders, at angles they can't fight. The Counter Right is the other half: the moment the defense starts to read how you bring those blockers, you show them the same picture and send the blockers somewhere else.
🏃 Fast Track: If you've coached gap schemes, skim 11.1 and the Power rules in 11.2, then spend your time on 11.3 (our counter and the formation-flip rule), 11.6 (pullers as keys and how to make them lie), and the Game 2 counter in Case Study 1 — it's the one that got stopped.
🔬 Deep Dive: The full gap-scheme rules by front are in Appendix B. The line's vocabulary — down, pull, kick, wrap, back block, hinge — is built in Chapter 5. Play-action off these runs gets its full treatment in Chapter 19.
📺 Film Watcher: This Sunday, watch the guards for the first second of every run. If one leaves his spot and runs flat behind the line, it's a gap play — and the linebackers on the side he's running toward should move with him. Count how often they're there first.
11.1 What a Gap Scheme Is: We Pick the Hole
Every run play answers one question: who decides where the ball goes?
In zone — inside zone in Chapter 9, outside zone in Chapter 10 — the line blocks an area, everybody steps the same way, and the back reads how the defense reacts. The defense decides the hole after the snap.
In a gap scheme (also called man/gap or power blocking), the offense decides the hole before the snap. Every blocker has a specific man or a specific gap. The line blocks down and back — at angles, away from the hole — and one or two extra blockers arrive at the hole from somewhere the defense didn't count: a pulling guard, a pulling tackle, a fullback, a tight end coming across. The back doesn't read much. He runs to a spot, behind a specific blocker, and trusts that the hole will be there.
That's the trade. Zone asks the back to be smart. Gap asks the line to be physical and on time.
The vocabulary, one more time
You met these words in Chapter 5. Here they are as a gap scheme uses them, in the order you'll hear them in a meeting:
| Block | What it means | Why it matters in a gap scheme |
|---|---|---|
| Down block | Block the defender aligned to your inside, driving him away from the hole | You hit him from the side, which is easier than hitting him head-on; down blocks build the inside wall of the hole |
| Double team | Two linemen drive one down lineman vertically, then one comes off to a linebacker | Moves the biggest body at the point of attack and lets you account for a linebacker without a free hat |
| Back block | Block back toward where a puller just left | Fills the hole a puller leaves behind; without it, the defense chases the play from behind |
| Pull | Leave your spot at the snap and run flat behind the line to block somewhere else | The extra blocker the defense didn't count before the snap |
| Kick-out | Block the end man on the line of scrimmage outward, toward the sideline | Builds the outside wall of the hole |
| Wrap (or lead) | Turn up inside the kick-out and block the first linebacker who shows | Clears the second level so the back meets nobody until the safeties |
| Hinge | Backside tackle steps inside, then sets back like pass protection to wall off the backside end | Keeps the backside end from chasing the play down the line |
The end man on the line of scrimmage — coaches say "EMOL" — is the last defender on the line on the play side. He's whoever the kick-out blocks, whether he's a defensive end, an outside linebacker walked up, or a safety who crept down onto the line.
Two pieces of geography from Chapter 5 that you'll need constantly. Gaps run A (center–guard), B (guard–tackle), C (tackle–tight end, or outside the tackle with no tight end), and D (outside the tight end). Technique numbers tell you where a defensive lineman aligns: 0 is head-up on the center, 1 a shade of the center, 2i the inside shade of a guard, 2 head-up on a guard, 3 the guard's outside shoulder, 4i the tackle's inside shade, 4 head-up on the tackle, 5 the tackle's outside shoulder, 7 the tight end's inside shade, 6 head-up on the tight end, 9 the tight end's outside shoulder. Some systems swap 6 and 7; we use 7 for the inside shade of the tight end.
Every gap play is the same five parts
Power, counter, trap, and their cousins look different on a whiteboard. Strip them down and they're all built from the same five parts:
- A wall on the play side — down blocks and a double team that drive defenders away from the hole.
- A back block to fill whatever space the pullers vacate.
- A kick-out on the end man, which makes the outside edge of the hole.
- A wrap through the hole to the linebacker.
- A backside that gets cleaned up — a hinge, a fullback, a tight end, or a quarterback's fake — so nobody catches the play from behind.
Change who does part 3 and part 4 and you change the name of the play. On Power, a fullback or tight end kicks out and the backside guard wraps. On counter, the backside guard kicks out and the backside tackle wraps. On trap, the defender you kick out isn't the end man at all; he's a defensive lineman you left alone on purpose. That's the whole family.
🔍 Why this works: A gap scheme wins two ways that have nothing to do with being bigger than the defense. The first is angles. A down block hits the defender from his side; he has to turn to fight it, and a man who turns can't hold his gap. The second is arithmetic that the defense can't see before the snap. When the defense counts the box, it counts each of our linemen as one blocker standing in one place. A pulling guard is a blocker who was assigned to a gap that the center's back block now covers — he's been freed up to arrive somewhere else. The defense lined up with, say, three defenders on the left side against our three blockers on the left side. At the snap it has three defenders against four. Nobody got bigger. One of ours just moved.
The cost
Nothing in football is free, and gap schemes have three costs you should know before you install one.
They're predictable once you know the key. A guard who pulls tells every linebacker who's watching him where the ball is going. A fullback who steps left tells them too. That's why half of this chapter is about making those keys lie.
They need timing. The back has to arrive after the puller, not before; the puller has to arrive before the linebacker. A half-step early or late and the hole is full of bodies.
They give the defense a target. A defense that knows you'll kick out the end man can tell the end man to wreck the kick-out. That technique has a name — the wrong-arm — and it's the reason the counter in Case Study 1 went for one yard.
🔄 Check your understanding: On a gap play, which two blocks build the inside and outside walls of the hole, and which block clears the second level?
Answer
The inside wall comes from the down blocks and double team on the play side; the outside wall comes from the kick-out on the end man on the line. The wrap (the puller or lead blocker turning up inside the kick-out) clears the second level by blocking the first linebacker who shows. The back block and the hinge aren't walls of the hole; they keep the backside from chasing the play.
11.2 Power: Tell Them Where, Then Keep the Promise
Power is the oldest blueprint in the gap family and the one every defense in football knows by sight. Gus Ferrante, our offensive line coach and run-game coordinator, likes to say Power is a promise: "You tell them where. Then you keep it."
Our rule set comes from Chapter 5, and it never changes: on Power, Pete Lorusso pulls. When we run it from Twenty-one personnel, Sione Fale kicks out. Here's the four-minute look from the hook.
PRE-SNAP: "Twenty-one, I Left" vs. Stallions 4-3 Over, eight in box
Week 12, Q4, Outlaws lead 23-16, 5:14 left
F
$
C M W C
S E T N E
Y LT LG C RG RT X
Z Q
B
R
📊 Diagram (described): The Outlaws are in the I formation: Harlan, the tight end, attached on the left; Gaines off the ball wide left; Sutton split wide right on the line; Vance under center with Fale behind him and Odom behind Fale. The Stallions have a 4-3 Over front set to the tight end. From left to right on the line: the Sam linebacker walked up on Harlan's outside shoulder, a 5-technique end on the left tackle's outside shoulder, a 3-technique on the left guard's outside shoulder, a nose in a shade on the center toward the right guard, and a 5-technique end outside the right tackle. The Mike stands over the gap between the left guard and the center, the Will over the gap between the right guard and the right tackle. The strong safety is walked down outside the Sam; the free safety is alone deep in the middle. Eight defenders are in the box.
POST-SNAP: Power Left -- kick, double, back block, pull and wrap
F
$ <- unblocked: the force player
M <-- LG climbs W scrapes over the top;
S E T N E RG wraps to him
x x x x x
^ Y LT==LG C RT
| down double back hinge
B kicks out S
^
| the hole: inside B, outside the double
|_____________________________ RG pulls flat,
then turns up
R Odom: aim at the double, then
cut off Fale's block
📊 Diagram (described): At the snap Harlan blocks down on the 5-technique end inside him. The left tackle and left guard double-team the 3-technique and drive him back; the left guard comes off the double to the Mike. The center blocks back on the nose, filling the space the right guard leaves. The right tackle hinges to wall off the backside end. Fale runs from the I to the left and kicks the Sam, the end man on the line, out toward the sideline. The right guard pulls flat behind the line, turns up through the hole between the double team and Fale's kick-out, and blocks the Will, who is scraping over the top from the backside. Odom aims at the double team and cuts up off Fale's block. The walked-down strong safety is the one defender nobody blocks; he has to come inside the kick-out to make the tackle.
Count it
Eight in the box. Seven blockers: Harlan, five linemen, Fale. Someone is free, and it's the strong safety. This is the most important idea in Power against a loaded box: you can't block everybody, so choose who's free. Power leaves the man farthest from the hole unblocked, and makes him travel through traffic to get there. The strong safety in the hook had to come inside Fale's kick-out to make every tackle. That's why Odom's runs ended at four, six, three — not at zero. An unblocked defender in the right place costs you a short gain. An unblocked defender in the wrong place costs you the play.
The Outlaws' Power rules
These are the rules a lineman says back to Gus in August. Each is written as a list of options in order; the blocker takes the first one that applies. That's how most gap teams teach it.
| Blocker | Power rule (in order) | In the hook vs. 4-3 Over |
|---|---|---|
| Play-side TE (Y) | Down: first defender inside you on the line; if none, the backer | 5-technique end |
| Play-side tackle | Gap–down–backer: anyone in your inside gap; else the first down lineman inside; else the backer | 3-technique (double with the guard) |
| Play-side guard | Gap–down–backer; on a double, eyes on the backer — climb when he commits | Double on the 3-technique, climb to the Mike |
| Center | Back: the backside A-gap — fill the space the pulling guard leaves | Nose |
| Backside guard (Lorusso) | Pull and wrap: flat, depth one yard, turn up inside the kick-out, first backer who shows | Will, scraping |
| Backside tackle | Hinge: step inside, set back, wall off the backside end | Backside end |
| Kicker (FB, H-back, or crossing TE) | Kick out the EMOL, inside-out; if he squeezes too far inside, log him (seal him inside) and tell the back | Sam |
| Back | Aim at the outside hip of the double team; cut off the kicker's block | — |
| QB | Hand off, carry out a fake away from the play | — |
The kicker's "log" option matters. If the end man crashes so far inside that kicking him out is impossible, the kicker turns his hips and seals him inside, and the hole moves one gap wider. The back sees it happen and bounces. That's the only real read in Power, and it's the back's: inside the kick or outside the log.
What the back sees
Lonnie Briggs, our running backs coach, teaches Power with one sentence: "Press the double, then go where the fullback says." The back aims at the double team on purpose. Pressing it holds the linebackers inside for half a step and gives the puller time to arrive. Then the kicker's block tells him where the hole is. If the kicker drives the end out, the back cuts inside the kick. If the kicker logs the end, the back bounces outside the log, and the puller has to see it too and turn out instead of up.
What the back must never do is beat the puller to the hole. A back who outruns his guard arrives at a linebacker with nobody in front of him. Lonnie times it with a stopwatch in camp — the back's first step is a "bucket step" or a short lateral shuffle that costs him a beat on purpose — and the drill ends only when puller and back hit the line within a step of each other.
⚠️ Common mistake: the banana pull. A puller who takes too much depth — swinging back three yards and arcing around like a banana — arrives late and outside, and the linebacker beats him to the hole. In a training-camp scrimmage two summers ago, one of our backup guards bananaed every pull; on one rep the scout-team Mike met the back two yards deep, and the guard ran past the play. Fix: "Flat and tight." The pull step opens the hip and gains about a foot of depth, then the puller runs flat, close enough to the line that his hand could brush his linemen's backsides, and he turns up at the first daylight inside the kick-out. Gus's coaching cue is "Shave the butts."
🩺 Player safety: The kick-out and the wrap are high-speed collisions between big men, and the puller arrives running. Teach the kicker and the puller to strike with the hands and the near shoulder, eyes up, head across the front of the defender (the kicker's head goes inside, so the defender stays outside), never leading with the crown of the helmet. Rules on blocks below the waist have tightened at every level over the years and differ between the NFL, college, and high school; do not teach a puller or kicker to go low unless your current code clearly allows that block in that location, and check the rulebook every season.
Power against other fronts
The hook was Power against an even front (four down linemen). The rules don't change when the front does — that's why they're rules — but what the rules produce changes, and you need to see it before the defense shows it to you.
| Front | What changes | Who's the problem | Our adjustment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Even (4-3 Over, nickel Over) | The double lands on the 3-technique; the center backs on a shaded nose | A fast backside linebacker scraping over the top | None — this is Power's best picture |
| Odd / "tite" (4i–0–4i) | Play-side tackle and guard double the 4i; the center backs on a head-up nose, which is harder | The nose who follows the puller if the center's back block is late | Center and backside tackle "zone" the nose and the backside end together; or run Power away from the 4i |
| Bear (3–0–3, both guards and the center covered) | No uncovered lineman means no natural double; every block is one-on-one | The backside 3-technique: the center can't reach him after the guard pulls | Backside tackle blocks down on the 3-technique; leave the backside end for the fake; or check out of Power |
| Eight-man box, single-high | One defender will be free | The walked-down safety | Make him the one farthest from the hole; or throw behind him (11.6) |
The bear front deserves a sentence of its own. Bear — three interior defenders covering both guards and the center — is designed to take away the double teams that power football depends on. Against it, you either run Power with the backside end left to chase (and hope the back is fast enough that the end can't catch him from behind), or you get out of it. In Week 8 against the Birmingham Forge we saw more bear than any team all year, and Chapter 9 shows what it did to our inside zone. Against bear, gap schemes are a coin flip. Trap (11.4) is better.
🔄 Check your understanding: In the hook, Ostrowski had eight in the box and we had seven blockers. Who was left unblocked, and why was that the right man to leave free?
Answer
The walked-down strong safety, aligned outside the Sam on the play side. He's the right man to leave free because he's farthest from the hole: to make the tackle he has to come inside Fale's kick-out, through traffic, after the back has already gained ground. Power can't block eight with seven, but it can decide which defender is free — and an unblocked safety arriving late makes a four-yard gain, not a loss.
11.3 Counter: Two Pullers and a Step the Wrong Way
Counter is Power with misdirection. The back takes a step away from the hole — the counter step — and then cuts back behind two pullers. In the most common version, the GT counter, the backside Guard kicks out the end man and the backside Tackle wraps through the hole to the linebacker.
The play's fame in pro football belongs to Joe Gibbs's Washington teams of the 1980s and early 1990s, whose version, the counter trey, pulled the backside guard and tackle behind a line widely known as "the Hogs." It was a signature play of those offenses, and nearly every NFL and college playbook since has carried some form of it. Gibbs's teams also used the H-back as a puller in some versions — which is where the "GH" variant you'll see below comes from.
Our rule from Chapter 5 is fixed: on Counter Right, Kendrick Moss and Ben Achterberg pull. Moss is our heaviest, most powerful guard — the man we trust to stand up a nose tackle — and a kick-out is a power block. Achterberg is six-foot-six with long arms and quick feet, which makes him a natural wrapper: he has to cover ground and then engulf a linebacker in space.
We flip the formation, not the linemen
Here's a question every gap team has to answer: if Moss and Achterberg are your best pullers, what happens when you want to run counter to the left?
Some teams flip their linemen — the "strong" guard and "quick" guard switch sides by formation, so the same men always pull. We don't, because Gus doesn't want Achterberg pass-blocking from the right side of the line on the next snap. Our rule is simpler: we flip the formation, not the linemen. Counter goes away from Harlan. When we want Counter Right, Harlan is attached on the left, and Moss and Achterberg pull. When Harlan is attached on the right, the play is Counter Left, and the mirror pair — Lorusso kicks, Darnell Fitch wraps — pulls. We rep both. We rep the first one about twice as often.
That rule has a consequence you should already be suspicious of. If counter always goes away from the tight end, and the back always aligns on the tight end's side for it, the defense has a tell. Hold that thought until 11.6.
Counter Right from the gun
Here's the version we run from Eleven personnel, against the look Sacramento's defense showed us most: nickel, an Over front set to Harlan, two high safeties. (Austin's names for what we saw were descriptive during the season; Russ Kimbrough told me later what they called it.)
PRE-SNAP: "Eleven, Gun Doubles Left, Counter Right" vs. Nickel Over
Harlan attached left; Ruffin offset LEFT, toward the tight end
$ F
C C
M W *
E T N E
Z Y LT LG C RG RT H X
R Q
📊 Diagram (described): The Outlaws are in a two-by-two shotgun set with Harlan attached on the left and Gaines wide left, Powers in the right slot and Sutton wide right. Vance is in the shotgun with Ruffin offset to his left, the tight end's side. The defense is in nickel with an Over front set toward Harlan: from left to right, a 5-technique end outside the left tackle, a 3-technique outside the left guard, a nose shaded on the center toward the right guard, and the weak-side end outside the right tackle. The Mike is over the left A-gap, the Will over the right B-gap, and the nickel is in the apex between the right tackle and Powers. Two safeties are deep; the strong safety is on Harlan's side.
POST-SNAP: Counter Right -- two pullers, one counter step
$ F <- alley, late
M <------ RT comes off the double
W <-- LT turns up and wraps to him
E T N E *
x x x x x
Y LT LG C RG==RT | H stalks the *
hinge pulls back double|
|
LG _______________|> kicks out the E
LT ____________> turns up inside the kick
R
jab left, then back right -- inside the kick
📊 Diagram (described): At the snap Harlan blocks down on the 5-technique end, sealing the backside. The center blocks back on the 3-technique, who is now alone because the left guard has gone. The right guard and right tackle double-team the nose and drive him back; the right tackle comes off to the Mike on the backside. The left guard pulls flat to the right and kicks out the weak-side end, the end man on the line. The left tackle pulls behind him, turns up inside the kick-out, and blocks the Will. Powers blocks the nickel. Ruffin takes a short jab step to his left, toward the tight end, then cuts back to the right and follows the left tackle through the hole just inside the kick-out. The free safety on that side is the last defender, coming down late as the alley player.
| Blocker | Counter Right rule | Against Nickel Over |
|---|---|---|
| Backside TE (Harlan, attached left) | Hinge/down: first defender on or inside you on the line | 5-technique end |
| LT (Achterberg) | Pull and wrap: flat, follow the guard, turn up inside the kick-out, first backer inside-out | Will |
| LG (Moss) | Pull and kick: kick out the EMOL on the play side; log him if he crashes | Weak-side end |
| C (Szabo) | Back: the backside A-gap, then the B-gap if the guard's man is a 3-technique | 3-technique |
| RG (Lorusso) | Gap–down–backer | Nose (double with the RT) |
| RT (Fitch) | Gap–down–backer; on a double, climb to the backside backer | Nose → Mike |
| Play-side slot (Powers) | Stalk the apex defender (nickel); stay on him, don't hold | Nickel |
| Play-side #1 (Sutton) | Run off the corner — go route, sell it | Corner |
| Back (Ruffin) | Counter step toward the tight end, then aim inside the kick-out; follow the wrapper | — |
| QB (Vance) | Hand off, then fake a keep to the left | — |
Notice who carries the hardest block. It isn't either puller. It's Szabo, blocking back on a 3-technique who was lined up outside the guard who just left. That man is two gaps away from the center at the snap, and he's the defender most likely to chase the play from behind. If the center loses him, the 3-technique follows Moss into the backfield and tackles Ruffin on his counter step. Everything else on counter is a better angle than this one.
🧩 Productive struggle: Before you read the next paragraph, solve the center's problem. The 3-technique is outside the left guard. The left guard and left tackle both pull right. The center has to keep the 3-technique from chasing the play. What makes that block possible — and if your center can't make it, what would you change about the play?
Work it, then read on.
Three things make the back block possible. First, the 3-technique's own rule usually helps the center: a good 3-technique who sees his guard pull is taught to flatten down the line behind him (defenses call it "pull-pull"), which means he runs across the center's face, and the center only has to get his body in the way. Second, the center gets help from the hinge: Harlan's down block narrows the space the 3-technique can chase through. Third, the back's counter step buys time: the ball isn't going right until the second step, so a center who is a step late still isn't too late.
If your center can't make it — a smaller high school center against a quick 3-technique, say — you have three common fixes. Pull the guard only and wrap with an H-back (the GH version), which lets the backside tackle stay home and block down on the 3-technique. Pull the tackle only and kick with a fullback. Or run counter only when the 3-technique is on the play side, so the center's back block is on a shaded nose instead. Each one trades a little of the play's power for a block your players can actually make.
The variants
| Name | Who kicks | Who wraps | When you'd use it |
|---|---|---|---|
| GT counter (our Counter) | Backside guard | Backside tackle | Base. Most power at the point of attack |
| GH counter | Backside guard | H-back or tight end from the backside | Center can't back-block a 3-technique; or you want your backside tackle home against a great edge rusher |
| Counter Y (our word for the GY version from attached Harlan) | Moss | Harlan, from the backside | Same as GH; also changes what a guard-reading linebacker sees (11.6) |
| Counter with a fullback | Fullback | Backside guard | Two-back sets; looks like Power for one step |
| Counter bash / counter read | Same pullers | Same | The quarterback reads the backside end and the back runs the other way — the option version, which Chapter 12 owns |
What it beats: the back-reader
Counter has one specific victim: the linebacker who reads the back. If his eyes are on Ruffin, Ruffin's counter step takes him the wrong way for one step, and one step is all the wrap needs. Week 10 at Portland was the cleanest example we had all season. Leon Marchetti's Pioneers play the most disciplined Cover 2 in our league, and his linebackers are taught to flow fast with the back — their Mike, Owen Talbert (#52), is the fastest flow linebacker we saw all year. Fast flow is how Tampa 2 linebackers get to the outside run and still get to their pass drops.
Week 10 at Portland, late first quarter, 7–7, 2nd-and-6 at our 39. "Eleven, Gun Doubles Left, Counter Right." Ruffin jabbed left. Talbert stepped left with him, hard. Moss kicked out the end, Achterberg turned up into the hole and found nobody in it, so he kept climbing to the backside safety. Ruffin +11 to midfield.
We ran it once more that day, in the third quarter, and got two yards. Talbert didn't step with the jab the second time. He'd seen it once, and once was enough. That's not a failure of the play. That's the defense telling you it's learning, which is the most useful thing a defense can tell you, because a linebacker who has stopped stepping with the back has started looking at something else. Somebody on the Pioneers' sideline had told Talbert to watch our guards instead — and a linebacker who watches guards has a different weakness, which is where 11.6 picks up.
🔄 Check your understanding: Why do we pull Moss and Achterberg on Counter Right instead of flipping linemen so the same two men pull both ways — and what tell does our "flip the formation" rule create?
Answer
We keep each lineman on his own side so he never has to pass-protect from an unfamiliar stance and side on the next snap; Moss's power suits the kick-out and Achterberg's length and feet suit the wrap. To run counter the other way we move Harlan, not the linemen. The tell: counter always goes away from the tight end, and the back aligns on the tight end's side for it. A defense that charts our back's alignment relative to Harlan can predict counter — exactly what Sacramento did (11.6).
11.4 Trap: If Nobody Blocks You, Somebody's Coming
A trap leaves a defensive lineman unblocked on purpose, lets him charge into the backfield, and then hits him from the side with a puller he never saw. The ball goes through the space he just left.
Defensive line coaches have been teaching one sentence for as long as anyone has run trap: if nobody blocks you, somebody's coming. A disciplined defensive tackle who's left alone is supposed to stop, squeeze down, and look inside for the trapper. Trap works against the tackle who forgets that sentence — usually because his coaches have told him, all week, to get upfield and make plays.
Which tells you who trap is for. Trap is for penetrators: the one-gap 3-technique who's paid to get into the backfield, the tackle on a slant, the defense that sends its front four upfield and lets the linebackers clean up. It's a poor play against a patient, two-gapping nose who sits and reads.
The Tampa 2 tackle
Week 10 at Portland. Cover 2 and Tampa 2 defenses — Portland's specialty — are built on speed: the defensive tackles are one-gap penetrators who rush upfield on every snap, because the coverage behind them needs a fast four-man rush and fast-flowing linebackers. Portland's 3-technique, Dion Pratt (#96), was the best upfield tackle we saw all season. On first down he came off the ball like the snap was a starter's pistol.
Week 10 at Portland, third quarter, Outlaws lead 17–10, 1st-and-10 at our 29. "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Trap Right."
PRE-SNAP: "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Trap Right" vs. Pioneers Over
Week 10, Q3, Outlaws lead 17-10, 1st-and-10 at the Austin 29
F $
C C
* W M
E N T E
X H LT LG C RG RT Y Z
R Q
📊 Diagram (described): The Outlaws are in a two-by-two shotgun set with Harlan attached on the right and Gaines wide right, Powers in the left slot and Sutton wide left. Ruffin is offset to Vance's left. Portland is in nickel with an Over front set toward Harlan: from left to right, the weak-side end outside the left tackle, the nose shaded on the center toward the left guard, Pratt in a 3-technique on the right guard's outside shoulder, and the strong-side end outside the right tackle, inside Harlan. The Will is over the left B-gap, the Mike over the right A-gap, and the nickel over Powers. Two safeties are deep, in Portland's Cover 2 shell.
POST-SNAP: Trap Right -- leave him alone, then hit him from the side
W <------------- RT releases inside, climbs to W
M <----- RG releases inside: "influence"
E N E
x x x
LT C RG RT Y <- Y blocks the end
hinge back
T <- Pratt: untouched, shoots upfield
LG ________x Moss pulls short and traps him
R ..^ Ruffin hits the hole Pratt left
📊 Diagram (described): At the snap the right guard releases inside without touching Pratt and climbs to the Mike; the right tackle also releases inside and climbs across to the Will. Nobody blocks Pratt, so he charges upfield into the backfield. The left guard pulls a short distance behind the center and hits Pratt from the inside, driving him out toward the sideline. The center blocks back on the nose to fill the space the left guard left; the left tackle hinges on the backside end; Harlan blocks the strong-side end. Ruffin takes the handoff moving right and cuts straight up through the B-gap Pratt vacated, inside Moss's trap block.
Lorusso's inside release is the whole play. He doesn't just leave Pratt alone — he leaves him alone in a way that invites him. Coaches call that an influence release: the guard flashes inside, away from the defender, so the defender reads "they're down-blocking somebody else; my gap is free" and attacks. Some teams influence with a pass set instead: the guard shows a pass-protection kick, the tackle reads pass and rushes upfield to beat it, and the trapper arrives.
Pratt shot upfield. Moss pulled two steps behind Szabo and hit him in the hip. Ruffin +13 to the Austin 42 — an explosive by our definition (a run of 12 or more). Portland's two safeties were the first men to touch him.
Notice what trap did to Portland's arithmetic. Six in the box. We blocked five of them with five blockers and blocked the sixth — Pratt — with a guard who started his day two gaps away. Trap is the cheapest double count in football: one defender is blocked by being allowed to beat himself.
Trap rules
| Blocker | Trap Right rule | Against Portland's Over |
|---|---|---|
| Play-side TE (Harlan) | Base: block the man on you or outside you; don't let him squeeze | Strong-side end |
| RT (Fitch) | Inside release to the backside backer; never touch the trap man | Will |
| RG (Lorusso) | Influence: release inside to the play-side backer; never touch the trap man | Mike |
| C (Szabo) | Back: the backside A-gap — the space the trapper leaves | Nose |
| LG (Moss) | Trap: pull short and flat; kick out the first defender past the center | Pratt |
| LT (Achterberg) | Hinge on the backside end | Weak-side end |
| Back (Ruffin) | Downhill now; aim at the trap man's original spot; cut inside the trap | — |
Trap is fast. Power and counter take a beat to develop because the pullers travel; trap's puller travels two or three yards, and the back is in the hole about as fast as on an inside run. That's why trap is a natural fit in short yardage and against blitzes that send linebackers into the line: the ball goes through before the second wave arrives.
The trap family
| Version | Who traps | Who's trapped | Use it when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Short (guard) trap | Backside guard | Play-side 3-technique or 2i | Penetrating 3-technique; our base |
| Long trap | Backside tackle | A play-side end or 5-technique | The end is the penetrator; you need more distance to build up speed |
| Influence trap | Backside guard, after a pass-set fake by the play side | The tackle who rushes the "pass" | Third-and-medium against a rushing front |
| Wham | A tight end or H-back coming across | A defensive tackle | You want both guards to climb to linebackers (Chapter 9's "Y Wham" is the inside-zone cousin) |
🔄 Check your understanding: Why is trap a poor call against a two-gapping nose tackle who sits and reads, and a good call against a one-gap 3-technique told to get upfield?
Answer
Trap blocks its target by letting him beat himself: he must charge upfield past the hole so the trapper can hit him from the side. A one-gap penetrator does exactly that. A two-gapper who sits, squeezes, and looks inside meets the trapper in the hole, and the play collapses into a pile.
🛡️ The defense's view: Defensive coaches don't fear trap. They fear forgetting about it. The answer is technique, not scheme: when the guard in front of a tackle releases inside, the tackle closes down flat behind him, shoulders square, eyes inside, and meets the trapper with his inside shoulder — "wrong-arming" him, so the trapper's block collapses into the hole and the back has to go around the pile. A defensive tackle who does that once makes trap a two-yard play. A defensive coordinator who gets his tackles to do it every time has also made them slower upfield on every passing down, which is a trade most coordinators won't make. That's the bet trap makes: you can't coach a man to be both a penetrator and a trap-reader at full speed.
📋 Try it — Whose fault? Thursday team period, the week after Portland. Scout-team defense in an Over front with a 3-technique on our right guard. "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Trap Right." At the snap Lorusso steps inside and chips the 3-technique with his outside hand before releasing to the Mike. The 3-technique stops, squeezes inside, and meets Moss in the hole. Ruffin runs into the pile for no gain. Moss says he pulled flat and on time. Lorusso says he barely touched the guy. Whose fault — and what's the fix?
Answer
Lorusso's. The trap's whole premise is that the trap man is untouched — the influence release tells him his gap is free, so he charges upfield and runs past the hole. Any contact, even a chip, tells a good defensive tackle that someone is playing with him, and his coaching ("if nobody blocks you, somebody's coming" — and if somebody touches you, something's wrong) makes him stop and squeeze. Once he squeezes, Moss meets him in the hole instead of beside it, and the back has nowhere to go. The fix: the play-side guard's rule says "never touch the trap man." Gus drills it with the guard's hands at his chest and the first step pointed at the linebacker's inside knee. If your guard needs to chip because the 3-technique keeps beating the center's back block, you're running the wrong play into that front.
11.5 Duo, Dart, and Pin-and-Pull: The Cousins
Three more runs live at the edges of the gap family. One of them is the most argued-about play in our building.
Duo: two double teams and no puller
Duo gets its name from its two double teams — one on each side of the center, both aimed at the two interior defensive linemen, both working up to the two linebackers. Nobody pulls. Nobody kicks out. The back aims inside, presses the double teams, and reads the play-side linebacker: whichever gap the linebacker fills, the back goes to the other one.
Is duo a gap play or a zone play? Coaches genuinely disagree, and you'll see it filed both ways in playbooks and charting services. The case for gap: the linemen use gap blocking rules — down and double, drive the man vertically, no lateral zone step — and the play is aimed at a specific gap before the snap. Many coaches call it "power without the puller." The case for zone: the back reads a second-level defender after the snap and picks his hole, which is the soul of zone. In our building, Gus calls duo a gap play and teaches the line accordingly. Lonnie Briggs teaches our backs to run it like inside zone. Both of them are right about their half of it. That's not a cop-out; it's the most useful thing to know about duo. The line plays gap; the back plays zone.
Duo is a staple for us from Twelve personnel: in the four-game sample the Sentinels charted before Week 6, it was 11 of our 31 Twelve-personnel runs, second only to outside zone. Here's an Eleven-personnel duo from Game 1 that went for 13 yards.
Week 6 vs. Sacramento (Game 1), late in the first quarter, Outlaws lead 10–7, 1st-and-10 at our 34, ball on the left hash. "Eleven, Gun Doubles Left, Duo." Harlan attached to the boundary on the left. The Sentinels set their front to the field, away from him — in Game 1 their strength went to the field, not to the tight end.
PRE-SNAP: "Eleven, Gun Doubles Left, Duo" vs. Nickel Over to the field
Game 1, Q1, Outlaws lead 10-7, 1st-and-10 at the Austin 34
F $
C C
W M *
E N T E
Z Y LT LG C RG RT H X
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): The Outlaws have Harlan attached on the left, toward the boundary, with Gaines wide left; Powers is in the right slot and Sutton wide right, toward the field. Ruffin is offset to Vance's right, away from the run. The Sentinels have their Over front set to the field: Rollins, the weak-side end, outside the left tackle and inside Harlan; the nose shaded on the center toward the left guard; Coleman in a 3-technique outside the right guard; the strong-side end outside the right tackle. Ames, the Will, is over the left B-gap; Bell, the Mike, is over the right A-gap. The nickel is over Powers, and two safeties are deep.
POST-SNAP: Duo Left -- two doubles, the back reads the backer
W <-- LT comes off M <-- LG comes off
^ ^ (whoever he fills)
E | N T E
x | x x x
Y==LT LG==C RG RT
double double man man
^
| Ruffin: press the doubles, read the Mike --
| bang it where he isn't
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): Harlan and the left tackle double-team Rollins and drive him straight back; the left tackle comes off the double to Ames when Ames commits to a gap. The left guard and center double-team the nose; the guard comes off to Bell. The right guard blocks Coleman, the 3-technique, by himself, and the right tackle blocks the strong-side end by himself. Nobody pulls. Ruffin takes the handoff moving left, presses the two double teams, and reads Bell: he runs to whichever side of the double teams Bell doesn't fill.
Bell filled the A-gap; Ruffin hit the B-gap off the outside double. Ruffin +13. The Sentinels played it soundly, and it still went. That's duo at its best: two double teams moving two big men backward, and a back who doesn't have to guess.
Duo has one obvious rule of thumb that most teams share: run it away from the 3-technique. The 3-technique is the defender a single blocker struggles most to handle alone. Run duo at him and your guard has to block him one-on-one at the point of attack; run it away from him and he's the backside guard's problem, where losing a little ground hurts less. Our sample matched the common teaching: away from the 3-technique, duo was one of our most reliable early-down runs; at it, much less so.
Dart: Power with the tackle pulling
Dart is our word for one-back Power in which the backside tackle, not the guard, pulls and wraps for the play-side linebacker. The backside guard blocks back with the center. Why would you pull a tackle instead of a guard? Two reasons. First, the guard reader we'll meet in 11.6 sees his guard stay home and reads "zone" or "pass," which buys the tackle a step. Second, it keeps your guards in their stance and on their defenders, which matters against a front with two big interior tackles who will walk your center backward if the guard leaves.
| Blocker | Dart Left rule |
|---|---|
| Play-side TE/tackle/guard | Same as Power: down, double, climb |
| Center and backside guard | Back block together on the backside interior defender(s) |
| Backside tackle | Pull and wrap — longer path; aim inside the play-side double, first backer |
| Backside end | Unblocked: held by the quarterback's fake, or the H-back hinges on him |
| Back | Same aiming point as Power |
The cost is obvious: a tackle has farther to travel than a guard, so Dart is slower, and the backside end has a free run at the back unless somebody holds him. We carry it in about one game plan in four, when the opponent's linebackers are guard-readers.
Pin-and-pull: gap blocking on the perimeter
Pin-and-pull is the gap family's outside run. The common teaching: each play-side blocker looks at the defender aligned on or near him. If a teammate outside him can pin that defender — block him down, inside — the blocker pulls around and leads to the perimeter. If not, he pins the man inside him himself. The result is a wall of down blocks on the inside and two or three pullers running to the edge, like a sweep. Rules vary a great deal from staff to staff; the principle is constant: angles on the inside, extra bodies on the outside.
You've seen its ancestor. Vince Lombardi's Packers power sweep — both guards pulling around the end, the back reading their blocks and "running to daylight" — is the most famous gap-blocked outside run in football history. And you've seen our version in Chapter 6: "Twelve, Under Ace Right, Toss Right, Z Crack" in Week 12, where Gaines cracked the walked-down strong safety and our right tackle pulled around to block the corner who replaced him — Ruffin, 14 yards. That's a pin-and-pull cousin called crack-replace: the receiver pins from the outside, and the puller replaces him on the man he left. Outside zone does the same job by reaching, which is why Chapter 10 and this section are two answers to one question: how do you get to the edge before the edge gets to you?
🩺 Player safety: Crack blocks — a receiver blocking back toward the ball on a defender inside him — are legal in the NFL only above the waist and only when the defender can see it coming in the way the rule describes; a crack-back below the waist is a foul and a dangerous one. College and high school codes have their own restrictions on blocks below the waist outside the tackle box, and they have changed repeatedly. Teach receivers to crack with the hands, eyes up, aiming at the near number, and check your current code before you install any perimeter blocking.
🔄 Check your understanding: A coach on your staff says duo isn't a gap scheme because "the back reads it." Another says it is because "nobody zone-steps." Who's right?
Answer
Both are right about their half, and coaches genuinely file duo both ways. The line blocks it with gap rules — down, double, drive vertically, no zone step — and the play is aimed at the interior gaps before the snap. The back reads a second-level defender after the snap (the play-side linebacker) and picks the gap he didn't fill, which is zone thinking. Teach it accordingly: the line plays gap, the back plays zone.
11.6 Pullers Are Keys — and Keys Can Lie
Here is the uncomfortable truth about every play in this chapter. A pulling lineman is the loudest signal in football. He leaves his spot at the snap and runs, flat and fast, toward the hole. Every linebacker who's watching him knows where the ball is going, and most linebackers are taught to watch him.
What the linebacker is reading
A linebacker's key is the player or players he reads at the snap to tell him run or pass and which way. The most common keys are the guards and the backs. Russ Kimbrough told me at a long dinner in the spring that his linebackers coach, Dre Whitaker, has a rule laminated on the linebacker-room door in Sacramento:
"Uncovered guard — read the guard. Covered guard — read the back. Both tell you something — read the triangle."
It's a very good rule, and you should understand exactly why. An uncovered guard — one with no defensive lineman on him — has nobody to block at the line, so his first step is the most honest signal on the field: if he pulls, the ball is going where he's going ("pull = go"); if he pass-sets, it's a pass. A covered guard is busy with a lineman and can fake a double team, so the back's track is more honest. The triangle is the guard, the back, and the quarterback at the top — the full read for a linebacker who has time to learn it.
Now look at what each play in this chapter does to each key:
| Key | What gap schemes do to it | The play that makes it lie |
|---|---|---|
| Uncovered guard ("pull = go") | Power and counter tell him the truth — he runs with the puller and beats him to the hole | Dart (guard stays home, tackle pulls); Counter Y (only one guard pulls; the wrapper comes from the tight end); Power PA (the guard pulls and the ball goes over his head) |
| The back | Counter's jab step lies to him by design | Counter (that's its job); counter is only stopped by a back-reader who stops reading the back |
| The fullback (in two-back sets) | Power tells him the truth — the fullback goes to the hole | Counter with the fullback stepping like Power (the hook) |
| The triangle | Hardest to fool; sees guard and back disagree | Sequence — the same look, three plays, so the triangle reader has to process all three (below) |
🔍 Why this works: No key is honest against every play, and that isn't a weakness of the defense's teaching — it's the nature of keys. Against inside zone, a covered guard can lie (he shows a double team) and the back tells the truth. Against counter, the back lies and the guard tells the truth. A defense that teaches its linebackers one key has, by definition, picked which plays it will be fooled by. The offense's job is to find out which key — on film, before the game — and to have the play ready that makes it lie.
The hook, again: making the fullback lie
The Stallions' Mike was a fullback reader. Here's what Counter Right looked like to him.
POST-SNAP: "Twenty-one, I Left, Counter Right" -- the fullback lies
(pre-snap: identical to the Power picture in 11.2)
F <- the last defender
$ (backside: chases)
M <------- RT comes off the double
S E T N W E
x x x x x x
B Y LT LG C RG==RT |
^ hinge (pull)(pull) back |
| |
Fale steps left -- the Power LG ___|> kicks out the E
path -- and blocks the Sam LT __> turns up to the W
R
Odom: jab left (the Power path), then cut right
📊 Diagram (described): From the same I formation and the same Stallions alignment as the Power diagram, Fale steps left exactly as he did on Power and blocks the Sam on the backside. Harlan blocks down on the 5-technique end inside him. The left tackle and left guard both pull to the right; the left guard kicks out the end outside the right tackle, and the left tackle turns up inside him to the Will. The center blocks back on the 3-technique. The right guard and right tackle double the nose, and the right tackle comes off to the Mike — who has run to the left with Fale and is now behind the play. Odom jabs left on the Power path, then cuts back right behind the two pullers. The walked-down strong safety is on the backside and can only chase; the free safety is the last defender.
Mabry read Fale. Fale went left. Mabry went left. The play went right. Odom +14. No one on the Stallions made a mistake by their rules. Their rules had picked the play they'd be wrong about, and we'd waited three snaps to call it.
Power PA: the guard pulls and the ball goes over him
The most common way to punish a linebacker who reads the pulling guard is to pull the guard and throw. Here's the call we had ready for the next snap if Mabry had stopped reading Fale and started jumping Lorusso instead.
PRE-SNAP: "Twenty-one, I Left, Power PA" -- same picture as Power
F
$
C M W C
S E T N E
Y LT LG C RG RT X
Z Q
B
R
📊 Diagram (described): Exactly the four-minute picture from 11.2: the I formation with Harlan attached left, Gaines wide left off the ball, Sutton wide right on the line, Fale and Odom stacked behind Vance; the Stallions in a 4-3 Over with eight in the box and one deep safety.
POST-SNAP: Power PA -- the pull is real; the hole is behind the backers
Z: post from the left ^ F <- held by the post
/
<------------------------------------ X: dig at 12
/ from the right
$ M <-- W <-- both backers fill toward "Power"
S E T N E
x x x x x
B Y LT LG C RG RT
kick hold big on big hinge
^
|_____________________ RG pulls, STOPS at the line,
blocks the first man to show
Q fake to R, set at 7, throw the dig
R fakes Power, checks the backside
📊 Diagram (described): Everything up front looks like Power for the first second: Fale kicks the Sam, Harlan and the left side block down, the center blocks back, and the right guard pulls left. But the right guard stops at the line of scrimmage and blocks the first defender who shows at the edge, instead of turning up the hole, and the other linemen hold their men at the line in pass protection. Odom fakes the Power handoff and then checks the backside. Both linebackers see the pull and fill hard toward the left. Gaines runs a post from the left to hold the free safety, and Sutton runs a dig at 12 yards from the right, into the space the linebackers just left. Vance fakes, sets at about seven yards deep, and throws the dig.
One rule shapes this play more than any other: the ineligible-downfield rule. In the NFL, an ineligible lineman may not be more than one yard beyond the line of scrimmage when a forward pass that crosses the line is thrown (college and high school codes have historically allowed a little more — check your current code). On the run, Lorusso wraps through the hole and up to a linebacker. On the pass, he can't. So on Power PA his pull is real but his finish is different: he stops at the line and becomes the edge protector. That's also why the best Power PA throws come out quickly and land behind the linebackers: the longer Lorusso has to "block at the line" while looking like a run, the sooner the linebacker notices he isn't climbing. Chapter 19 owns the rest of play-action; for this chapter, remember that Power PA is a key-breaker before it's a pass play.
False pulls and changing the puller
You don't need a pass to make a guard key lie. Two other tools do it on the ground.
A false pull is a pull that goes somewhere the ball isn't. The most common version is in the option game: the guard and tackle pull exactly as on counter, the linebackers fly with them, and the quarterback reads the backside end and hands the ball the other way — "counter bash" and its cousins, which Chapter 12 teaches. Another version pulls a guard on a zone play away from the run, purely to drag a guard-reader. It costs you a blocker on the backside, so it's a once-or-twice-a-game call, not a staple.
Changing the puller is cheaper. Dart pulls the tackle, so the guard reader's key stays home and reads "zone." Counter Y pulls one guard and wraps with Harlan from the backside, so the linebacker sees one guard leave instead of a guard and a tackle. Neither play fools a linebacker for long. Each one only has to make him hesitate. A step slow at linebacker is a first down.
The Sentinels' answer — and what I learned at dinner
This is where I tell you about the counter that didn't work.
🛡️ The defense's view: Russ Kimbrough's staff charted something about us after Week 6 that I didn't see until our own self-scout caught up with it: when Ruffin aligned offset toward Harlan in two-by-two, the run went away from Harlan — counter — most of the time. It's our "flip the formation" rule from 11.3, showing up on their film. Their staff had already been coaching Jordan Ames, their Will, to read the back in their Bull front, because guard-reading had gotten him beaten on our 45-yard inside-zone touchdown in Game 1. But a back-reader is exactly the man counter is designed to fool. So, as Russ explained it to me, they built a narrow tag: on that one backfield alignment, Ames keys the guards and runs with the pullers over the top. Their weak-side end, DeShawn Rollins, wrong-arms the kick-out — he attacks the pulling guard's inside half and spills the play outside. The linebacker in the hole spills the wrapper. The backside end stays home for any quarterback keep. The ball has nowhere to go but outside, where the scraping linebacker, the nickel, and a safety are waiting.
That's what happened in Game 2. We ran counter twice at Sacramento, and neither went for more than five yards. The one I remember is the third-quarter snap at their 42 — second-and-5 — where Rollins wrong-armed our kicking guard, the hole filled with bodies, Ruffin bounced, Marcus Bell met him outside the pile, and their nickel, Kenny Vo, turned him back in. Plus one. Case Study 1 walks through it frame by frame.
In the spring I told Russ what I'd seen on the film: "That's what I saw in Game 2. Your Will stopped stepping with my back. He was watching my linemen. So I didn't get my step." And then the line I'd give any young coordinator who wants to understand gap schemes: "That's the game. You can't give a linebacker a key that never lies. You can only give him a key that lies to a play you're ready for. You had a tag for counter and a pair alert for play-action. I had to find a fourth thing."
He asked if I had. I said, "Ask me next year."
Here's what I can tell you. Marisol Vega, our director of analytics, pulled the number the Monday after Game 2. In our first fourteen weeks, Ruffin had aligned offset toward Harlan in two-by-two on first or second down 19 times; 14 of them were counter or counter play-action. That's 74 percent, over her 70-percent line for a tell. We'd been running inside zone from that alignment too, just not enough of it. Never let a tendency outlive its evidence — it's on my whiteboard in red — and the corollary is the one I learned at Sacramento: never let a rule of yours become their evidence. This spring our counter install has the back in both offsets, and Counter Y gives a guard-reading Will a different picture from the same alignment. Whether that's the fourth thing, Russ will tell me in September.
The three-play test
Gap schemes don't live alone, and the reason is in that dinner conversation. The defense's whole answer to a key-breaker is to change keys. So the offense's answer has to be a set of plays from one look, each one beating a different key. Russ's staff has a name for how I do it — the three-play test — and it goes like this, all from one formation and one backfield alignment:
- Inside zone with a "show" double team. The double team drives the 3-technique and, for half a second, shows a guard-reading linebacker a seam behind it. If he takes the seam, the back bounces outside him. (That's our 45-yard run in Game 1.)
- Counter off the same look. If the linebacker stops reading the guard and starts reading the back, the counter step takes him the wrong way.
- Play-action off the same look. Once he's been punished on the run, he fills fast — and the throw goes where he used to be.
I don't need any of the three to work on a given Sunday. I need the linebacker to think about all three. A linebacker who's thinking is a step slow.
📋 Try it — Find the conflict: Week 10 at Portland. Leon Marchetti's Pioneers are in their nickel Over front with two deep safeties. On film, Owen Talbert, their Mike, is aligned over our play-side A-gap on most early downs with our guard uncovered in front of him. On counter, he beat our wrap to the hole once already today — he stopped stepping with Ruffin's jab and ran with our pulling guard. Name the conflict defender, name the key he's using now, and name one play from this chapter (and one from another chapter) that makes that key lie.
Answer
The conflict defender is Talbert. He's responsible for a run gap and a deep-middle pass drop in Tampa 2, and he's now reading the uncovered guard ("pull = go") rather than the back. Plays that make that key lie: Dart (the guard stays home and the tackle pulls, so his key says "zone" or "pass" while the wrap arrives) or Counter Y (only one guard pulls; the wrapper comes from Harlan). The strongest answer from another chapter is Power PA or counter play-action (Chapter 19): pull the guard exactly as on the run and throw the dig or the seam into the hook area Talbert vacates when he runs with the puller. A Tampa 2 Mike who fills on the pull can't also run to the deep middle in time.
🔄 Check your understanding: Using Dre Whitaker's rule, which key would a linebacker use if both guards in front of him are uncovered — and which play in this chapter most directly attacks a linebacker who reads only the back?
Answer
With both guards uncovered he reads the guards (and, ideally, "the triangle": guard, back, and quarterback). The play that attacks a back-only reader is counter: the back's jab step goes one way, and the pullers — whom he isn't watching — go the other.
11.7 Gap or Zone? The Trade-offs
Every coordinator eventually gets asked which one he is: a zone guy or a gap guy. It's the wrong question. The right question is which one this week's defense is worse at, and whether your players can run both well enough for the answer to matter.
| Zone (inside, outside) | Gap (power, counter, trap) | |
|---|---|---|
| Who picks the hole | The defense, after the snap | The offense, before the snap |
| What it beats | Fast-flowing, slanting, and penetrating fronts that run past the cutback; defenses that set the edge hard | Squeezing, reading, two-gap fronts; linebackers who read the back; defenses you can out-angle |
| What beats it | Penetration that kills combos; spill-and-fill fronts that build a wall | Wrong-arms that spill the kick-out; linebackers who beat the puller to the hole; bear fronts that remove doubles |
| The back's job | Read the blocks; patience | Follow the puller; timing |
| Physical demand on the line | Lateral movement, communication | Power at the point of attack; pullers who can run |
| Predictability | Every zone looks alike — good for play-action | Pullers are loud keys — good for key-breakers, bad if you never break them |
| Practice cost | High: combos and reads take thousands of reps together | Moderate: clear assignments, but pullers and backs need timing reps |
| Short yardage | Good with a big back | Better — angles and an extra hat |
| Its play-action child | Boot and naked off wide zone (Chapters 10, 19) | Power PA, counter PA — key-breakers (11.6) |
Most good offenses are built on one and seasoned with the other. We're a zone team: inside zone and duo from Eleven, outside zone and duo from Twelve. Over the season, Marisol's chart had power, counter, trap, and Dart together at a little under a quarter of our designed runs, and that share nearly doubled in the fourth quarter when we were ahead, because a gap scheme is the best clock-killer in football: everyone knows, and it still goes four yards.
Why carry both? Because each one makes the other better. A linebacker who has been taught to beat zone by flowing fast is exactly the linebacker counter is built to fool. A defensive tackle who's been told to penetrate to kill our zone combos is exactly the tackle trap is built to punish. And a front that squeezes and wrong-arms to stop our gap runs has to play its run fits differently on every snap, because the next snap might be zone. The two families are each other's constraint plays. That's Theme 1 — offense is a system — with a guard pulling through the middle of it.
📈 By the numbers: Charting services such as PFF and Sports Info Solutions tag NFL runs by blocking concept, and public analysis of that charting has generally found that neither family holds a large, stable yards-per-carry edge over the other across seasons. The comparisons are tangled up with situation: gap runs are used more often in short yardage, in four-minute offense, and near the goal line, where the yards available are small and the defense expects a run. Treat any single season's "zone vs. gap" split with suspicion, and look at what each did in the situations you call it. Our own numbers suffered from the same problem — most of our Power carries came against eight-man boxes in the fourth quarter, which makes four yards a carry a very good number.
🏫 Any level: Gap schemes are the backbone of high school football for good reasons. The assignments fit on a card — one rule per position — and they don't depend on five linemen reading the same defender the same way, which takes the thousands of reps that a high school staff doesn't have. The Wing-T traditions many high school coaches grew up with are built on pulling guards, traps, and buck sweeps. In my first season as a high school coordinator in northeast Ohio, we started four wide, lost two of our first four, and rebuilt in Week 5 around two-tight-end wing Power; we won five of the last six. Two cautions at that level. First, hash marks: high school hashes sit about 53 feet from each sideline, so the field side is wide and the boundary is short; Power into the boundary runs out of grass fast, and counter away from the boundary can turn into a long run. Second, low-block rules: high school and college codes restrict blocks below the waist by location and timing, and they've changed often — check your code before you teach any kick-out or puller to go low. In college, the quarterback run turns gap schemes into power read and counter read (Chapter 12), and the wider college hashes (40 feet apart) make the field-side counter more dangerous still.
🔄 Check your understanding: Why does carrying both zone and gap runs make each family better, rather than just giving you more plays?
Answer
Because each family's best defensive answer creates the other family's best picture. Linebackers coached to flow fast against zone become victims of counter; tackles coached to penetrate against zone combos become victims of trap; fronts coached to squeeze and wrong-arm against gap runs have to fit differently when the next snap is zone. The two families constrain each other.
11.8 QB Power and QB Counter: The Plus-One
The last gap idea in this chapter is the simplest piece of arithmetic in the run game. When the back carries the ball, the quarterback is a spectator; he hands off and carries out a fake. When the quarterback carries, the back becomes a blocker. You've added a blocker without adding a player. Coaches call it the plus-one.
QB Power is Power with the quarterback as the runner and the back as the kicker. From the gun, the back crosses the quarterback's face at the snap and kicks out the end man on the play side; the backside guard pulls and wraps; the quarterback follows them.
PRE-SNAP: "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, QB Power Left" vs. Nickel Over
F $
C C
* W M
E N T E
X H LT LG C RG RT Y Z
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): Two-by-two with Harlan attached on the right and Gaines wide right, Powers in the left slot and Sutton wide left. Ruffin is offset to Vance's right. The defense is in nickel with an Over front set to Harlan: the weak-side end outside the left tackle, the nose shaded toward the left guard, the 3-technique outside the right guard, and the strong-side end inside Harlan. The Will is over the left B-gap, the Mike over the right A-gap, and the nickel over Powers.
POST-SNAP: QB Power Left -- the back becomes the kicker
F <- alley $
* <- Powers stalks him
W <-- RG pulls and wraps to him
E N T E
x x x x
^ LT==LG C RT Y
| double back hinge
|
R <---------- Ruffin crosses Vance's face, kicks out E
^
|________________ RG pulls flat
Q follows the puller, inside the kick
📊 Diagram (described): At the snap Ruffin crosses in front of Vance and kicks out the weak-side end on the left. The left tackle and left guard double-team the nose; the guard comes off to the Mike if he flows over. The center blocks back on the 3-technique. The right tackle hinges on the strong-side end, and Harlan helps or climbs on the backside. The right guard pulls left and wraps up to the Will. Powers stalks the nickel. Vance keeps the ball and follows the right guard through the hole inside Ruffin's kick-out. The free safety on that side is the last defender in the alley.
QB Counter works the same way from the counter family: the backside guard and tackle pull, and the back either kicks out (so both pullers can wrap) or runs a fake the other way to hold the backside linebacker. It's the quarterback version of everything in 11.3, and it carries the same tell problem.
What it costs
The plus-one is real, and so is the bill. On QB Power, your quarterback runs between the tackles, into linebackers, and he doesn't get to slide before contact the way he can on a scramble. Every one of those hits counts.
🩺 Player safety: A quarterback on a designed inside run takes linebacker-level contact. Our rules for Vance: QB Power and QB Counter live inside the opponent's 10-yard line and on third- or fourth-and-short — the places where one yard is worth the hit — and nowhere else without a reason Wade and I have agreed on before the game. Once he's past the line to gain, he gets down. In practice, designed quarterback runs are walk-through or thud tempo, never live tackling. At high school and college levels, where the quarterback may also be your best runner, count his carries by the week, not the game. Chapter 31 builds the full quarterback-run budget.
In the four games the Sentinels charted before Week 6, Vance ran QB Power twice — six yards and a touchdown. That's about right. It's a goal-line and short-yardage weapon, and its value comes as much from the defense knowing it's there as from calling it. A defense that has to account for our quarterback as a runner inside the 5 can't play the same goal-line front it plays against Moose Odom.
🔄 Check your understanding: On QB Power, where does the "plus-one" come from?
Answer
From the running back. On a normal handoff the quarterback is a non-blocker carrying out a fake; on QB Power the quarterback carries and the back becomes the kick-out blocker, so the offense has one more blocker for the same eleven players.
🎬 Film room: To spot QB Power on All-22, watch the running back, not the quarterback. On a handoff, the back's first step goes toward the mesh. On QB Power, his first step crosses the quarterback's face toward the play-side edge, and he arrives at the end man like a fullback. If you see the back kick out the end and a guard pulling behind him, the quarterback has the ball.
📋 Try it — Make the call: Game 1 at home against Sacramento, first quarter, 4th-and-goal at the Sacramento 3, Outlaws lead 7–0. The previous three snaps: Twelve personnel duo at the nose, +2 (the Sentinels answered Twelve with five defensive backs, not base); a back-shoulder fade to Sutton against press, broken up; a bunch concept to the right, with Powers tackled at the 3. Marisol's chart said go. Wade kicked the field goal (that's his decision, and he owns it). Suppose he'd gone for it. Pick a run from this chapter, give the personnel and formation, and say who is unblocked and why that's acceptable.
Answer
There's no single right answer — the reasoning is graded. A strong one: "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, QB Power Left." Why: the Sentinels have shown a nickel-type defense on the goal line against both Eleven and Twelve; a gap scheme gives us angles and a puller at the point; and QB Power adds the plus-one — Ruffin becomes the kicker, so we have a blocker for every defender in the box except one safety, who has to come from depth through traffic. Three yards with a quarterback who hasn't been hit all day is a reasonable bet. The cost: a linebacker-level hit on Vance in the first quarter, which is exactly the trade our safety rule allows (inside the 10, short yardage). A good alternative is Jumbo Power Left with Kalu reporting eligible (Chapter 14) — more size, less surprise. A weak answer is any outside run: on the goal line, the field is short, and the sideline is a defender. For the record, the play I'd have called was QB Power Left. Wade's field goal made it 10–0, and we won by seven, so he gets to keep that one.
Spaced Review
Try each question before you read the reminder under it.
1. From Chapter 9: In inside zone, who decides the hole, and what does the line do with a linebacker? The defense decides, after the snap, by how it reacts; the back reads it. Uncovered linemen combo with a covered teammate on a down lineman and climb to the linebacker when he commits. Compare that with this chapter: in Power the hole is chosen before the snap, and the linebacker is the pulling guard's job. The combo and the double team look similar for one step — which is exactly why a guard-reading linebacker can be fooled by either one.
2. From Chapter 7: How do you count the box, and what does a gap scheme do to the count? Count defenders within the box (an apex nickel counts as "half"); six is light, seven neutral to heavy, eight loaded. Then count your blockers. Zone needs the numbers to be close, because everyone blocks an area. Power changes the count after the snap — a puller arrives where the defense counted one blocker — and when it can't win the count (eight against seven in the hook), it chooses who is left free.
3. From Chapter 4: What does Twenty-one personnel force the defense to do, and why did that matter in the hook? Two backs and one tight end usually draw base personnel, with three linebackers and bigger bodies in the box. That's the defense you want to run gap schemes into late in a game with a lead: Odom and Fale are built to run into it, and a fullback in front of the back is a blocker the defense can't move. It also gave Ostrowski's linebackers a fullback to read, which is why Counter Right worked on the fourth snap.
Project Checkpoint: Gap Scheme Sheet
Last chapter you built your Outside Zone Install Sheet: reach and combo rules, the back's track, and the boot tie-in. Your zone is in. Now you need the plays that pick the hole: this checkpoint produces your Gap Scheme Sheet, one page per play, for Power, Counter, and one Trap.
For each play, write:
- The call in your grammar, with your formation-flip rule (do you flip linemen or formations?).
- A rules table by position — who pulls, who kicks, who wraps, who back-blocks, and who hinges — against an even front and an odd/tite front. Add a bear-front line that says what you'll do (adjust or check out).
- The back's aiming point and read in one sentence.
- The key it beats and the key it fears (Dre Whitaker's rule is a good checklist: guard, back, triangle).
- Its key-breaker partner: the play from the same look that punishes the linebacker who has figured out this one (counter for Power, play-action for counter, and so on).
- The "call it when" trigger: the front, box, down and distance, or tendency that puts it on your call sheet.
A worked piece (pro level):
| Counter Right | |
|---|---|
| Call | "Eleven, Gun Doubles Left, Counter Right" (Harlan attached left; counter goes away from the TE) |
| Pullers | LG kicks the EMOL; LT wraps to the first backer inside-out |
| Back block | C on the backside A-gap — a backside 3-technique is the hardest block in the play |
| Play side | RG and RT gap–down–backer; RT climbs to the backside backer |
| Backside | Y hinges on the first man on or inside him; QB fakes the keep |
| Back | Jab toward the TE, then inside the kick; follow the wrapper |
| Beats | Back-readers; fast-flow linebackers |
| Fears | Guard-readers who run with the pullers; ends who wrong-arm the kick |
| Partner | Counter PA from the same look; Counter Y to change the guard picture |
| Call it when | First or second down vs. two-high, six-man box, linebackers stepping with the back on film |
Choose your level:
- High school: Power and one trap only, from one formation family, with one rule per position that fits on a wristband card. Write your low-block rules at the top from your current state code.
- College: Power, GT counter, and trap, plus a QB version of one of them if your quarterback can carry the load. Note the college hash width and how it changes which way you run counter.
- Pro: all three plus Duo or Dart, both formation directions, and a self-scout line: what tell does your formation-flip rule create, and what plays from that alignment break it?
- Film-room: pick an NFL team, find ten gap runs on All-22, and chart who pulled, who kicked, and what the play-side linebacker read. Write that team's gap sheet from the film.
Next chapter, you'll leave one defender unblocked on purpose — not to trap him, but to read him — and build your Option Package: zone read plus one more option, with who is read and why.
Chapter Summary
A gap scheme picks the hole before the snap and wins with angles and an extra blocker the defense didn't count. Its weakness is that its extra blockers are visible — so the best gap offenses carry a play that makes each key lie.
| Play | Kick | Wrap / lead | Back block | Best against | Beaten by |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Power | FB, H-back, or TE (or the RB on QB Power) | Backside guard (Lorusso on Power Left) | Center | Even fronts; eight-man boxes when you choose who's free | Wrong-arm spill; a backer who beats the puller; bear |
| Counter (GT) | Backside guard (Moss on Counter Right) | Backside tackle (Achterberg) | Center — on a 3-technique, the hardest block | Back-readers; fast flow | Guard-readers who run with the pullers; wrong-arms |
| Counter Y / GH | Backside guard | Tight end or H-back | Center; tackle stays home | Same as counter; protects your backside tackle | Same |
| Trap | Backside guard traps a DL left alone | — (play-side linemen climb) | Center | Penetrating one-gap tackles; Tampa 2 fronts | A tackle who closes flat and wrong-arms |
| Duo | None | None — two double teams climb | — | Even fronts, run away from the 3-technique | Penetration at the doubles; a free backside 3-technique |
| Dart | FB/H or none | Backside tackle | Center and backside guard | Guard-reading linebackers | A free backside end |
| Pin-and-pull | First puller | Second puller | Pins inside | Edge defenses you can out-angle | Penetration through the pins |
| QB Power / QB Counter | The running back | Backside guard (and tackle) | Center | Goal line and short yardage: the plus-one | Hits on your quarterback |
A decision framework for any gap call: (1) What front? Even fronts invite Power; penetrating tackles invite trap; bear fronts tell you to check out. (2) What box? Count it; if you can't block them all, choose who's free and make him the farthest from the hole. (3) What's the key? Guard, back, fullback, or triangle — find it on film. (4) What's the partner? Never call a gap play you can't follow with the play that punishes the linebacker who has figured it out. (5) What's your own tell? Check your self-scout — your rules are their evidence.
What's Next
Every play in this chapter blocked every defender who mattered — or chose, carefully, the one who wouldn't be. Chapter 12 does something stranger: it leaves a defender unblocked on purpose and reads him, so that whatever he does is wrong. The counter step you just learned becomes a pitch, a keep, and a give — and Jordan Ames, again, becomes the man we're asking a question.