Chapter 3 Exercises — Formations

Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and original film study

The Austin Outlaws, Sacramento Sentinels, St. Louis Stallions, and every player and game named below are fictional. Use the Outlaws' formation words from the chapter: Doubles, Trips, Trey, Nub, Quads, Bunch, Stack, Nasty, Empty, Ace, Wing, Load, and the backfield words Under, Gun, Pistol, I, Offset, Split. Diagram notation follows the chapter: offense at the bottom, O for linemen, X Z H Y U R Q for the offense, and E T N M W * C $ F for the defense.

Selected answers appear in Appendix J.


Part A — Conceptual ⭐

A1. In one sentence each, define personnel, formation, and play. Then write a full Outlaws call ("Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside Slant" is the model) and label each word.

A2. What is the minimum number of offensive players who must be on the line of scrimmage at the snap, and which of those players are eligible to catch a forward pass?

A3. Why is the X receiver usually on the line and the Z receiver usually off it? Give two practical reasons, one about eligibility and one about motion.

A4. Number the receivers on each side of Gun Trips Right in the Outlaws' 11 personnel. Who is #3 to the right, and who is #1 to the left?

A5. Name the gaps from the center out to the right side in Gun Doubles Right with Harlan attached. How many gaps does this formation create in total across the whole line?

A6. What's the difference between the offense's strength word ("Right" in "Gun Doubles Right") and the defense's strength call? Why don't they have to agree?

A7. List the five things a formation can do to a defense (section 3.8). For each, name one formation from the chapter that does it well.

A8. What does "formationing" mean, and why does it save practice time?

A9. Explain in two or three sentences how a reduced ("Nasty") split changes the routes a receiver can run well.

A10. In the NFL, a player wearing number 70 wants to line up as an eligible receiver. What must happen first?


Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐

B1. Name this formation (backfield word, formation word, direction) and number the receivers.

           $                                       F
     C          *        W        M                      C
                    E    T     N    E
     X     H        O   O   O   O   O   Y       Z
                            Q  R

📊 Diagram (described): The split end and the slot are on the left. Five linemen are in the middle with the quarterback in the shotgun and the running back beside him. A tight end is attached to the right tackle and a flanker is outside him on the right. The defense is a nickel with two deep safeties.

B2. Name this formation and say what's wrong with it.

     X              O   O   O   O   O   Y   Z
              H
                            Q  R

📊 Diagram (described): The split end is on the line on the left. Five linemen are in the middle. The tight end is attached on the right, and the flanker has lined up on the line of scrimmage outside the tight end. The slot receiver is off the line on the left. The quarterback is in the shotgun with the back beside him.

B3. Austin lines up in Gun Nub Right. Before the snap, the defense moves its 3-technique tackle and both linebackers toward the three receivers on the left, and its strong safety walks down outside Sutton. What strength rule is this defense using? Which side has the defense declared light?

B4. Against Gun Trips Right, you see the backside (left) safety creep toward the middle of the field at the snap, and the left corner is alone over Sutton with outside leverage. What did the defense just do, and which receiver's route is now your best matchup?

B5. On end-zone film, the Outlaws are in Under Load Right. The defense lines up two defensive linemen on each side of the center, exactly as it would against a balanced line. Before the ball is snapped, what should Vance and the center notice, and what's the run call that punishes it?

B6. Draw (or describe in words) Gun Bunch Right with Harlan on the point. Then describe the two ways a man-coverage defense can play it, and which one the bunch beats.

B7. You see this on film for four straight third-and-medium snaps: the opponent lines up in 3x1 with the tight end as #3, and three of the four times the #3 runs a short drag. What is this tendency, and what single formation change would hide it?

B8. Identify the formation, count the box, and say whether the run count is even, short, or favorable for the offense.

                                  F
     C          $       W     M       S                C
                     E    T      T    E
     Z      U   O    O    O    O    O    Y               X
                     Q
                     R

📊 Diagram (described): Austin is under center with the back deep behind the quarterback. On the left, a second tight end is the end of the line next to the left guard. To the right of the center are three more linemen and then the tight end, so the line has three linemen right of the center and only one to the left. Both wide receivers are off the line. The defense has one deep safety and eight players near the line: four linemen, three linebackers, and a strong safety, aligned two linemen to each side of the center as if the line were balanced.

B9. Watch for this on film: a team lines up in 2x2 with its tight end attached, and the defense walks a safety down to eight yards outside the tight end while the other safety moves to the middle of the field at about twelve yards. Name the shell before and after the movement (MOFO or MOFC), count the box, and say which receiver is most likely to be without help.


Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

C1. Make the call. ⭐⭐ You face a defense built like Sacramento's in Game 1: it has set its front strength to the field on every snap. Ball on the right hash, 1st-and-10 at your own 40, first quarter, tied 0–0. You have 11 personnel. You want duo. Choose the formation and direction, and explain where Harlan goes.

Short answer

With the ball on the right hash, the field is to the left and the boundary is to the right. Put Harlan into the boundary, the right side: Gun Doubles Right, duo to the right. The field-strength front sets its 3-technique and strong-side structure to the left, so duo's double teams attack the nose and end on the right. Watch for the 3-technique walking over before the snap; if he does, have a check to the quick game toward the field.

C2. Draw it up. ⭐⭐ Draw Gun Trey Right against a two-high nickel defense. Then draw the post-snap picture if the defense's trips check rotates the backside safety toward the trips side. Mark the receiver who is now isolated, and name the route you want from him.

Short answer

Trey Right: X alone on the left; Y attached to the right tackle (#3), H in the slot (#2), Z wide (#1) on the right. If the backside safety rotates toward the trips side, the X is one-on-one with the backside corner and no safety help. Call a back-shoulder or fade if the corner plays off and outside, a hitch if he bails.

C3. Make the call. ⭐⭐⭐ Week 12 vs. St. Louis. 1st-and-10 at your own 38, second quarter, tied 7–7. The Stallions play single-high with eight in the box and set their front by counting from the center. You have 12 personnel (Harlan and Brandt). Choose a formation and a run, and explain the gap arithmetic.

Short answer

Under Load Right with outside zone ("Wide") to the overload. Moving the left tackle to the right side gives five gaps to the right of the center against a front aligned as if the line were balanced, so the defense is a gap short on the heavy side. (This is what Austin called; Ruffin gained 9.) Have the boot ready for when the defense learns to count.

C4. Make the call. ⭐⭐⭐ It's two weeks later. Your self-scout shows that every one of your scissors calls this year has come with Gaines in a reduced split, and your next opponent's defensive coordinator is known to chart splits. It's 2nd-and-9 at your own 38, third quarter, tied. You want an explosive. What do you call, from what alignment, and why?

Short answer

Several defensible answers. (a) Call the scissors from a normal split: slightly worse spacing, but the defense can't key it. (b) Call a play that looks like the scissors from the reduced split but attacks the defense's expected answer, such as the post-corner fake with the corner route converting to a deeper out, or a dig behind a safety who widens early. (c) Call the scissors from the reduced split anyway if this opponent hasn't shown it jumping the split: knowing a play is coming isn't the same as stopping it. Any answer is graded on whether it names the tell and accounts for it.

C5. Draw it up. ⭐⭐⭐ Draw Gun Empty (3x2) against a nickel with both linebackers walked into the A gaps. Count rushers and blockers. Identify the likely free rusher and draw the hot throw.

Short answer

Six potential rushers (four linemen plus two linebackers) against five blockers. If the line slides to take the Will and the four linemen, the Mike is free. The hot throw goes to the receiver running into the window the Mike leaves, typically a quick slant by the slot on the side he blitzed from, out in about a second.

C6. Make the call. ⭐⭐⭐ Third-and-goal at the opponent's 4. On film, this defense plays man coverage in the red zone and switches (in-out) against bunch and stack alignments; it does not chase. Your call sheet says "Bunch Right, Flat." Keep it or change it? If you change it, to what?

Short answer

Change it. Against in-out switching, a bunch-flat gets no rub: the outside defender simply takes the first receiver out, as Simmons did to Powers at the Sacramento 4 in Game 1. Options: run two receivers outside at different depths so the outside defender must choose; use the switch against itself with an out-and-up by the first man out; or get out of bunch and isolate your best red-zone receiver (Sutton's back-shoulder) with a normal split.

C7. Draw it up. ⭐⭐⭐ The Stallions have learned to count your unbalanced line: against Load Right they now bump their whole front one gap toward the overload and roll their strong safety down to that side. Draw the defense's adjusted alignment, then draw the play you'd call from the same Load Right look to punish the adjustment. Label the protection and the receiver who is open.

Short answer

The front slides right and the safety rolls down right, so the left side of the formation (where only the left guard and the second tight end are) is now thin and the left flat is empty. Austin's answer was "Load Right, Wide PA Boot": outside-zone action right to hold the slid front, the quarterback booting left, and the second tight end (Brandt) releasing into the left flat after a one-count block. He caught it for 14. Protection note: on a boot, the backside defensive end is the threat; the play-side action and the tight end's one-count block must slow him, or the quarterback must be ready to throw early.

C8. Make the call. ⭐⭐⭐ Two-minute drill, 1st-and-10 at the opponent's 45, 1:38 left, down by 3, one timeout. The defense has played two-high all game and checks to a balanced Quarters look against 2x2. You have 11 personnel and Quads in your playbook as a surprise formation you've never shown this opponent. Do you use it now? If yes, what do you want it to make the defense do, and what's the throw? If no, why save it?

Short answer

A defensible yes: Quads forces the defense to move a second defender (often a safety) across the formation or play the four-receiver side short. Against a staff that has never seen it, the risk is a busted alignment or a timeout; the reward is either a clean isolation on the single backside receiver or a numbers advantage on the quads side. Call a concept that reads one defender (the safety who must declare) so the quarterback isn't solving a new puzzle at 1:38. A defensible no: if your players haven't lined up in it at full speed this week, a pre-snap penalty in a two-minute drill costs more than the surprise is worth; save it for the red zone where the field is shorter and the alignment simpler. Grade the reasoning, not the choice.


Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐

D1. A new assistant proposes adding six formations this week, "to give them more to prepare for." Each would carry one new play. Write the staff-room response you'd give, naming two costs and one condition under which you'd say yes to one of them.

D2. Your quarterback is a second-year player who struggles to identify coverage from the shotgun, but your offensive line is excellent at drive blocking. Your head coach wants the offense to "look modern." How much under-center and two-back formation do you build in, and how do you explain the choice to the head coach?

D3. Empty formations make the defense declare its coverage, but they leave five blockers. Your left tackle has allowed three pressures in his last two games and your back is an excellent pass protector. On third-and-7, do you go empty? Defend your answer with the protection arithmetic and the information you'd gain or lose.

D4. An unbalanced line (Load) gains a gap but asks your left tackle to play on the right side of the formation. Gus Ferrante says, "My left tackle hasn't taken a right-handed stance since college." What are the risks, and how would you install Load so they're managed?

D5. You've found that your back's alignment in the shotgun predicts run direction on 75 percent of your gun runs. You can fix it by (a) running more same-side zone, (b) moving to Pistol, or (c) ignoring it because your runs are working. Weigh all three.

What a strong answer to Part D includes

Part D has no single right answer, but strong answers share four habits. They name the cost, not just the benefit: every formation choice gives the defense something too (empty gives up a blocker; Load asks a lineman to play on an unfamiliar side; new formations spend practice time). They use the chapter's arithmetic: box counts, rushers versus blockers, gap counts by side. They account for the people: a second-year quarterback, a tackle who has been beaten twice, a backup tight end who has never taken a wing alignment. And they think one move ahead: what will the defense do after it sees this twice, and what is the next question? For D5 specifically, a strong answer notes that (c) works only until the defense starts using the tell; that (a) keeps the shotgun's advantages but requires installing a same-side mesh and rep time for it; and that (b) removes the tell cleanly but changes the quarterback's depth and the timing of some protections and play-action fakes. Many coaches combine (a) and (b): Pistol on early downs where run direction matters most, gun with a mixed mesh elsewhere.


Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

M1. (Chapters 1 and 3) ⭐⭐ Take Lyle's thesis from Chapter 1: "Motion for information, the run for credibility, the pass for the kill." Which formation families in this chapter serve each part of that thesis? Name one formation for each phrase and say why.

M2. (Chapters 2 and 3) ⭐⭐ Clark Shaughnessy's T formation, the Pistol at Nevada, and Joe Gibbs's one-back/H-back sets each changed where players stood. For each, name which of the five formation effects (3.8) it was after.

M3. (Chapters 1 and 3) ⭐⭐⭐ Your offensive philosophy statement (Chapter 1) includes a non-negotiable: "We will never put our quarterback in a protection where the hot throw is his only answer on first down." Which formations in this chapter does that rule limit, and when could you still use them?

M4. (Chapters 2 and 3) ⭐⭐⭐ The Air Raid tradition is known for running a small number of plays many times. Erhardt-Perkins is known for naming concepts so they can be run from many formations. Which of those two is closer to "formationing," and what would an offense that combined both look like on its formation card?

M5. (Chapters 1 and 3) ⭐⭐ Chapter 1 lists six themes. Pick two of them ("Put the defender in conflict" and "Threaten what you don't want to do" work well) and, for each, describe one formation from this chapter that serves it and one way a formation choice could betray it. Example of a betrayal: a formation that only ever runs one play cannot "threaten what you don't want to do," because it threatens only one thing.

M6. (Chapters 1, 2, and 3) ⭐⭐⭐ Build a three-row table. Rows: Lombardi's power sweep tradition, the run-and-shoot, the Shanahan-tree wide-zone offense. Columns: the base formation family, the defensive problem the formation created, and the self-scout danger it carried.


Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐

E1. Formation family chart. Choose one NFL team and chart two full games (all offensive snaps). Tag each snap with its formation family (2x2, 3x1, empty, condensed, unbalanced, two-back) and its personnel if you can see it. Build a table like the one in section 3.5. Then write a paragraph: what does this team's formation distribution tell a defensive coordinator, and what does it hide?

E2. Strength-rule detective. Pick one NFL defense and watch the first two quarters of one game on the broadcast or All-22 angle. On each snap, note where the offense's tight end is, which side is the field, and where the defense set its 3-technique tackle (or its front strength). Can you identify the defense's strength rule? Find one snap where the rule left a side light, and describe what the offense did (or could have done) about it.

E3. Split tells. Choose one wide receiver and chart every snap he plays in one game: his split (normal, reduced, wide) and the route or block he ran. Look for any split that predicts one route or one play more than about two-thirds of the time. Write a one-paragraph self-scout memo as if you were that team's quality control coach, including one recommended tendency-breaker.

What to look for in E1–E3: Use the end-zone or high wide angle when you can; the broadcast angle often cuts off the outside receivers before the snap. Note the hash on every snap, because "field" and "boundary" change with it. Record the shell (one or two high safeties) at the moment the offense sets, not after the snap. Keep a column for motion: a formation that changes after motion is two formations for charting purposes (where it started and where it ended). And be honest about your sample size: a pattern in ten snaps is a lead worth following, not a law.