Case Study 2 — Curtis Bale's Sixty Formations: When Multiplicity Becomes a Tell
Curtis Bale, his team, and every game and number in this case are fictional. Bale's team is left unnamed on purpose; this is a lesson about an approach, not a person.
Setup
Who. Curtis Bale is one of the most talented play designers Lyle Petrakis has ever worked with. They were young assistants on Walt Dupree's staff together, the two guys who stayed latest, drew the most plays, and argued about all of them. Bale draws beautiful football. He sees angles nobody else sees. He loves the cool play: the gadget, the shot, the formation nobody has ever lined up in.
The job. A few seasons ago, Bale got his first NFL offensive coordinator job. He had a good young quarterback, a deep receiver room, and a head coach who wanted the offense to "be impossible to prepare for."
The idea. Bale's answer was formation volume. If defenses build their call sheets by formation, he reasoned, then show them formations they've never seen, and their call sheets are blank. He installed new formations every week: unbalanced lines with four receivers to the other side, wings outside of bunches, the tight end flexed into the backfield and then shifted to the line, two-back sets that turned into empty with two separate motions.
What the early tape said. It worked, at first. Through the first eight games, by the count Lyle's staff kept while scouting them, Bale's offense showed 61 distinct formations. It scored a lot of points. Analysts loved it. There was a stretch of three weeks when every television breakdown led with a Bale formation.
Lyle, then a passing-game coordinator on a staff that would play Bale's team later that season, charted all 61 with his staff. He was the one who noticed what the analysts didn't.
What Happens
The chart
The staff's quality control coach sorted Bale's 61 formations by how many different plays each one carried in those eight games.
| Plays run from the formation | Number of formations |
|---|---|
| 1 play | 38 |
| 2 plays | 12 |
| 3–5 plays | 7 |
| 6+ plays | 4 |
Thirty-eight of sixty-one formations had carried exactly one play. Many were used once or twice. A defense that had charted Bale didn't need to know what the formation was called; it needed to know that this picture had always meant that play.
Lyle remembers saying it out loud in that staff room: "He's not hiding his plays. He's labeling them."
The game
Midseason, Bale's offense played a veteran defensive staff, a disciplined, rule-based single-high team whose coordinator had been calling defenses for two decades. That staff had done the same chart. Its plan was almost boringly simple:
- Against any formation we've seen before, play the call that stops the one play it carries.
- Against any formation we haven't seen, count the line, set the strength to the most receivers, and play a basic Cover 3 with a sound run fit. Make them beat us with execution, not surprise.
- Line up fast and stay still. Make the offense spend its time on alignment.
Snap by snap, the pieces that mattered
First quarter, first drive. Bale opened with a formation the defense had never seen: a wing outside a three-receiver bunch, with the tight end attached. The defense lined up in its default call. Nobody panicked. The play was a screen to the wing; the defense's rule-based alignment had a defender over him, and it gained 2.
First quarter, second drive. A formation the defense had seen, twice, both times with a play-action deep cross. The defense's safety sat on the cross from the snap. The pass was knocked away.
Second quarter, the penalty that hurt most. Bale called a newly installed formation, "Wing Trips Right Nasty," on 2nd-and-6 near midfield. The design was clever: a wing outside the tight end, with three receivers in reduced splits outside him. But the wing, a second-year tight end playing his first snaps in it, lined up on the line of scrimmage instead of a yard off it.
BALE'S "WING TRIPS RIGHT NASTY," as it was supposed to look vs. as
it was actually aligned
SUPPOSED TO:
ON LINE: X O O O O O Y
OFF LINE: W' H H2 Z
Q R (W' = wing, a yard off)
ACTUALLY:
ON LINE: X O O O O O Y W'
OFF LINE: H H2 Z
Q R
(wing on the line: Y is covered and ineligible)
📊 Diagram (described): In the drawing as installed, the tight end is attached on the right end of the line and the wing stands a yard behind and outside him, so the tight end is still an end and still eligible; three receivers line up in tight splits outside them. In the actual alignment, the wing stepped up onto the line next to the tight end. That made the wing the end of the line on that side and covered the tight end, turning him into an interior lineman who could not legally catch a pass.
The play was a tight end seam. The quarterback threw it; the tight end caught it for 31 yards. Flag. The referee announced it: the tight end had been covered up, and an ineligible player had caught a forward pass. The gain came off the board. The drive ended in a punt.
The rest of the half. Two more pre-snap penalties: an illegal formation (only six players on the line, after a receiver who should have been on the ball set a yard deep) and an illegal shift (two players still moving when the ball was snapped, after a double shift into empty). Three penalties, all alignment-related, all in formations installed that week.
The final. Bale's offense scored 10 points, its lowest total of the season to that point. Of its 58 offensive snaps, by Lyle's later count from the film, 11 came from formations installed that week, and those 11 snaps produced three penalties, one negative play, and a total of 9 yards.
After
The rest of that season, more defenses ran the same plan. Bale's offense finished well, on the strength of its talent and his genuine creativity, and he was praised as a rising star. The next year the league had a full season of his tape. The one-play formations became an index of his playbook, the young players kept making alignment mistakes in new formations, and his offense fell from near the top of the league in scoring to the bottom third. He was fired after that second season.
Lyle called him the week he was fired. Bale's first sentence, as Lyle tells it, was, "They knew what I was running before I did."
Analysis
Why it failed
1. A formation that carries one play isn't a disguise. It's a signature. The whole point of formationing is that the picture doesn't predict the play. Bale did the opposite: a new picture for almost every play. Early in the season, before defenses had film, that looked like multiplicity. Once defenses had film, it was a key to his call sheet. Every formation the defense had seen before became a tell. Every formation it hadn't seen, it played with a sound default.
2. Novelty is cheap for the defense to answer. A defense doesn't have to solve a new formation. It only has to align soundly against it: count the line, set strength by a simple rule, play a coverage with no holes. Bale's new formations needed the defense to make a mistake. The veteran staff's rules made sure it didn't have to think, so it didn't make one.
3. Alignment is a skill, and Bale spent it. Every new formation is a new set of alignment rules for eleven players, learned in a week, executed on a 40-second clock with a crowd screaming. The covered-up tight end, the six-man line, and the illegal shift are what happen when installation volume outruns practice time. Danny Kostas's flag from Lyle's Ohio years, the one in this chapter's opening, is the same mistake; Bale just made it at scale.
4. Practice time spent on new formations is practice time not spent on execution. Theme 3 of this book says scheme creates advantages but execution wins plays. Bale's scheme created confusion for his own players, and his execution paid for it.
What Bale got right
This case isn't a story about a villain. Bale's best ideas were genuinely good. His quads look with a wing, four receivers to one side and a wing tight end to the other, gave defenses real trouble for most of that first season, because it carried four different plays and defenses couldn't key it. Austin's own Quads package, the one Lyle carries as a two-minute and red-zone surprise, started with a drawing Bale made on a whiteboard when they were both young assistants. Lyle's version carries three plays, and it gets an alignment rep every Friday.
Lyle's approach, side by side
| Bale's approach | Lyle's approach | |
|---|---|---|
| Formation words | 60+ in eight games | 12 formation words, 6 backfield words, 2 directions |
| New formations per week | Several, each with 1–2 new plays | Rarely; any new one must carry two existing plays first |
| What changes week to week | The formations | The tags, splits, motions, and the plays chosen from the same families |
| What the defense learns from film | "This picture means this play" | "This family carries many plays" |
| Alignment practice | Assumed | An alignment rep for every new look before any play rep |
| Self-scout | None formal | Every Monday, by formation and split |
Lyle's approach is not automatically right, either. A formation-heavy offense with a great install process can be very effective; plenty of successful NFL offenses use many formations. The difference is whether each formation carries enough plays that the picture stops predicting the call, and whether the players can line up in it without thinking.
Discussion Questions
- Bale's 61 formations scored a lot of points in the first eight games. What was the defense missing early in the season that it had later, and why did that matter so much?
- The veteran staff's plan against unseen formations was "count the line, set strength to the most receivers, play sound Cover 3." Which of the five formation effects (section 3.8) is that plan most vulnerable to, and how could Bale have attacked it?
- Three alignment penalties in one half came from formations installed that week. Design a practice rule that would have prevented at least two of them.
- "They knew what I was running before I did." What does Bale mean? Connect it to the reduced-split tell in section 3.9 of the chapter.
- Is there a number of formations that's "too many"? Argue for a principle rather than a number.
Your Turn
Take your own Formation Family from this chapter's Project Checkpoint (or, if you're in the film-room track, the formation chart you built of an NFL team). For every formation, list every play you plan to run from it. Then:
- Circle every formation that carries only one play. For each, either add a second play (one run and one pass is ideal) or cut the formation.
- Mark every formation your players have never lined up in at full speed. Write the alignment rep you'll run before its first play rep.
- Write one sentence for each formation that a defensive coordinator, after charting four of your games, would say about it. If that sentence is "it means play X," you've found a tell.