Case Study 2 — The Couch Chart: A Fan's Grades, Re-Graded
A hypothetical case. The teams, players, and drive below are invented to show a common pattern; they are not real games and not the Outlaws.
Setup
Every Monday during the season, people post their charts of Sunday's games: snap-by-snap grades of a coordinator's calls, usually with a verdict at the bottom. Some of them are very good. Most of them grade the result and call it the call. This case is built from the pattern I see most often, and it's worth working through slowly, because the most instructive mistake in it isn't the one you'd expect.
The game. A hypothetical Sunday. The visiting offense trails 20–16 with 2:18 left in the fourth quarter, one timeout, and the ball at its own 35. It needs a touchdown. A field goal doesn't help.
The defense. A coverage-first team that has played two-high shells most of the day and rotated after the snap a lot. Against the visitors' jet motion it has done the same thing every time: the safety on the motion side drops down toward the jet, and the other safety spins to the middle.
The chart. A fan, call him the charter, kept a good chart all game: down, distance, field, clock, personnel, formation, motion, and result. His motion column has a note he wrote in the second quarter: "Jet → their safety rolls down to it. 5 for 5." Remember that note.
Here's his chart of the final drive, with his grades.
| # | Clock | Situation | The play (his description) | Result | His grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2:18 | 1st-and-10, own 35 | Deep in-breaker to the No. 1 receiver | Tipped by the safety, caught by the slot, +22 | A "Clutch" |
| 2 | 2:04 | 1st-and-10, opp 43 | Inside zone | +1 | F "Why run in two-minute?" |
| 3 | 1:58 | 2nd-and-9, opp 42 | Quick out, out of bounds | +5 | B |
| 4 | 1:53 | 3rd-and-4, opp 37 | Jet sweep | −3 | F "Too cute" |
| 5 | 1:44 | 4th-and-7, opp 40 (after the last timeout) | Fade to the No. 1 receiver | Incomplete | F "Throw it to the sticks!" |
His verdict: "Coordinator lost the game on 4 and 5. Too cute, then too greedy."
Let's re-grade it with the method from this chapter: the situation, the pre-snap picture, the key, why this call now, and process before result.
What happens, re-graded
Snap 1: the "clutch" throw
What the film shows. The No. 1 receiver runs a deep in-breaking route into a bracket: a cornerback underneath him and a safety over the top, two defenders on one man. The quarterback stares at him the whole way and throws anyway. The safety gets a hand on it, and the deflection falls into the slot receiver's lap twenty-two yards downfield. The checkdown, the back in the flat, was open for five or six yards with room to get out of bounds.
Re-grade. The call is fine. A deep in-breaker on first down in two-minute is a normal call. The decision is poor: the quarterback threw into the defense's best-covered spot. Process: D. Result: A. That puts it in the "lucky" box. The danger isn't this snap; it's the lesson the offense might take from it. A quarterback who gets rewarded for forcing a bracketed throw will try it again, and the next deflection goes the other way.
What the charter missed: he graded the catch, not the throw.
Snap 2: the run "in two-minute"
What the film shows. The defense is in dime with five defenders in the box against five offensive linemen and a back. The visitors run inside zone; a defensive tackle splits the double-team and makes the tackle after a yard.
Why this call, now? Look at the clock: the snap is at 2:04. In the NFL, the two-minute warning stops the clock when it reaches 2:00, and if a play is running at that moment, the warning comes at the end of the play. So a run snapped at 2:04 costs the offense almost no time: the clock stops a few seconds later no matter where the play ends. And against a five-man box, inside zone has the numbers. It was a cheap way to make the dime defense respect the run for the rest of the drive.
Re-grade. Process: B+. The run was free on the clock and had the numbers. Result: failure, and an X (execution: the double-team didn't hold). Most of the charter's F was about something that wasn't true: the run didn't burn the clock.
What the charter missed: the two-minute warning, which was on the screen the whole time.
Snap 3: the quick out
Out of the two-minute warning, a quick out to the boundary for five, out of bounds at 1:53. Process: A−. Result: B+. It isn't a success by the strict second-down standard (it needed 60 percent of 9, about 5.4 yards), but it stopped the clock and made third down manageable. The charter's B was about right, for the right reasons. Not every snap is a trap.
Snap 4: the "too cute" jet sweep
PRE-SNAP (snap 4): 3rd-and-4 at the opp 37, jet motion vs. two high
F $
C * W M C
E T N E
X O O O O O Y Z
H ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~> (jet)
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): The visiting offense is in 11 personnel with the slot receiver (H) on the left, the tight end (Y) attached on the right, and the back beside the quarterback in the shotgun. Before the snap, H runs full-speed jet motion from left to right, just behind the line. The defense shows two high safeties, a nickel over the slot, two linebackers, and four down linemen.
POST-SNAP (snap 4): the rotation meets the sweep
F <-- spins to the middle
$
\ rotates down to
\ the jet side
v
(tackle, -3)
C E T N E ^ C
X O O O O O Y-] Z
Q ...> H==================='
📊 Diagram (described): At the snap the quarterback hands the ball to H as he crosses, and H runs the sweep wide to the right. The right-side safety ($) has dropped down toward the motion and meets H outside the tight end's block for a three-yard loss. The other safety (F) has spun to the deep middle. The rotation that the charter recorded five times earlier in the game is exactly what stops the play.
What the film shows. The jet motion starts, the motion-side safety rotates down exactly as he had on all five earlier jets, and he arrives at the edge at the same time as the ball carrier. −3.
Re-grade. The charter's grade was F, and his reason was "too cute." The grade is right, and the reason is wrong. There's nothing cute about a jet sweep on 3rd-and-4. Plenty of offenses convert short third downs on the perimeter. The problem is that the defense had already shown its answer to jet motion five times, and this call ran straight into it. Jet motion that predictably brings a safety down is information, and the offense should use it: a throw behind the rotated safety, a run back the other way, or the "both" idea from this chapter, a call that wins whichever way the defense answers. Process: D. Result: F. That's the "deserved" box, and it's a C on the result column: the call was wrong for the look.
What the charter missed: the answer was in his own motion column. "Jet → their safety rolls down to it. 5 for 5." He'd charted the tell and then graded the play as if he hadn't.
Snap 5: the "greedy" fade
What the film shows. After the last timeout, 4th-and-7 at the opponent's 40. The defense walks both safeties down: Cover 0, man coverage across the board with no deep safety, and six rushers against six blockers. The quarterback takes a short drop and throws the fade to his No. 1 receiver against a pressed corner with no help over the top. The corner stays in phase and gets a hand on the ball at the last moment. Incomplete. Game over.
Re-grade. Against Cover 0 the ball has to come out fast, and "throw it to the sticks" isn't the only right answer. A slant or a quick out at seven yards is one good answer. A fade to your best receiver, isolated against press with nobody deep to help, is another. It's the throw Cover 0 gives up by definition. The ball came out on time, the protection held long enough, and the throw was catchable. The corner won. Process: B+. Result: F. That's the "unlucky, or they made a play" box.
What can't be known from the broadcast: whether the fade was the call or a check; whether a quicker hot throw was built in; and whether this receiver had beaten this corner earlier in the game. That last one is in the chart, if the charter kept it.
Analysis
Put the two charts side by side:
| # | Charter's grade (result) | Re-grade: process | Re-grade: result | Box |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A | D | A | Lucky |
| 2 | F | B+ | F (X) | Unlucky |
| 3 | B | A− | B+ | Earned (small) |
| 4 | F | D | F (C) | Deserved |
| 5 | F | B+ | F | Unlucky / they made a play |
The charter's verdict was that the coordinator lost the game on snaps 4 and 5. The re-grade says something more useful:
- Snap 4 really was the bad call, but not because it was "cute." It ignored a five-for-five tell that the offense's own motion had produced. That's a planning failure. The coordinator may have had a reason we can't see, such as an injury on the perimeter or a check that failed, but on the evidence it's the snap that deserves the F.
- Snap 5 was a defensible answer to Cover 0 that lost a one-on-one. Calling it "greedy" turns a coin the offense was right to flip into a character flaw.
- The worst process on the drive was snap 1, the one the charter graded A. That's the snap the offense most needs to fix, because it's the one that will feel like a success in the film room.
- Snap 2 was charged with a clock cost it didn't have. The two-minute warning made it free.
The pattern is the one from 40.7. Result-grading puts every snap in the top-left or bottom-right box. The truth of this drive lived mostly in the other two boxes, the lucky first snap and the unlucky last one, and those are the boxes that teach.
And the best lesson is the charter's own note. He did the hardest part, charting the defense's answer to motion five times in a row. Then he didn't use it when he graded. A chart is only as good as the questions you ask it. If he'd asked "why this call, now?" at the snap of play 4, before the result, his own column would have answered: because the coordinator hadn't used what the motion told him.
🏫 Any level: The same re-grade works on a high-school Friday night, with two adjustments. The clock rules differ by code: high-school and college rules on clock stoppages and the two-minute warning are not the NFL's, so check your code before you charge a call for clock it didn't cost. And at lower levels, a "lucky" completion like snap 1 is even more common, because coverages are less disciplined. Grade the decision, not the catch, and your quarterback will thank you in the playoffs.
Discussion questions
- The charter graded snap 1 an A and the re-grade gives its process a D. Explain to the charter, in three sentences and without using the word "resulting," why the A is dangerous for the offense.
- Snap 2 depends on a rule detail: the two-minute warning. List two other clock rules that could change how you grade a late-game call, and say how each would change it.
- The re-grade says snap 4's grade was right for the wrong reason. Why does the reason matter if the grade is the same?
- Suppose that on snap 5 the receiver had caught the fade for a touchdown. What changes in the re-grade table, and what stays the same?
- The charter had the five-for-five tell in his own chart. Design one change to his chart's layout that would put that tell in front of him at the moment he graded snap 4.
Your turn
Find a late-game drive from any game this season that ended in a loss for the offense, ideally one that people argued about on Monday. Chart it in five columns: clock, situation, the play, result, and your process grade, written at the snap before you watch the result. Then add the "box" column (earned, lucky, unlucky, deserved). Count how many snaps landed in the two off-diagonal boxes. Then write the Monday verdict you'd post, in two sentences, that a coordinator would read and nod at.