Chapter 12 Key Takeaways — The Option Game

Key Takeaways

  1. On a normal handoff the defense has an extra man. The quarterback and the back don't block, so the defense's alley safety or nickel is free. The option fixes the math by making the quarterback count.
  2. You can "block" a defender with a decision. A read defender is accounted for: whatever he chooses, the ball goes to the other place. Reading the backside end turns six-on-six into six blockers on five box defenders, plus a decision on the sixth.
  3. The zone read ("Inside Read") is inside zone minus one block. The backside tackle steps inside; the end is read. Rule: "If he can tackle the back, he can't tackle you." Read shoulders and hips, not feet.
  4. The mesh is half a second. It's the quarterback's ball until he lets go, the back keeps the same track and speed, ride from back hip to front hip, decide by the front hip or give, and carry out the fake.
  5. The defense's only real answer is a second defender. Scrape exchange ("Swap": end takes the dive, linebacker scrapes to the QB), slow-play ("Sit": end takes the QB, linebacker fills on the dive), mesh charge, a QB player in the alley. Good defenses mix them by series.
  6. Every counter beats one answer and loses to another. Arc beats Swap, loses to Sit. Bash beats Sit, loses to Swap. Slice beats the mesh charge. A third option (bubble, pitch, RPO throw) stresses whoever the defense uses as help.
  7. Speed option is the pitch phase. The QB attacks the pitch key; the back holds a fixed relationship (commonly 4–5 yards outside, 1 deep). The read is sharp, but the QB takes the hit.
  8. Power read reverses the jobs. It reads the play-side end; the back sweeps outside and the QB runs inside behind a puller. A widening end means keep.
  9. The lineage: veer (two reads), wishbone and I-option, flexbone, spread zone read, Pistol, inverted veer, and the RPO, where the pass becomes the option (Chapter 13).
  10. The option has a bill. Every keep is a hit. Set a quarterback-carry budget before the season (Austin: about three designed carries a game, more in the playoffs with the head coach's approval). The threat is often worth more than the carries.

Action Items (this week)

  • Install the mesh drill with a live read defender who moves on a coach's signal, including late moves, so the quarterback learns "front hip, otherwise give."
  • Write your read rule in one sentence and make your quarterback say it back.
  • Chart your next opponent's option answers: for every zone read on their last four games of film, record the end's action and the linebacker's first step. Do they have two looks? Do they alternate?
  • Put one counter on your call sheet for each answer you expect, and label which answer it beats.
  • Write your quarterback-carry budget and say who can break it.
  • Rep the slide. Teach your code's rules for quarterback protection, and practice the slide every week.

Common Mistakes (and the fix)

Mistake What happens Fix
Reading the end's feet QB pulls on a shuffle step and runs into an end who never left him Read the near shoulder and hips; ask "can he tackle the back?"
Late pull Fumble at the mesh, or QB hit by end and LB together Decide by the front hip; otherwise give
Back clamps early Back "steals" the ball on a keep read Soft pocket until the QB's hands leave
No fake after the give End stops honoring the QB and chases the back Three hard steps after every give, every rep
Arc against Sit Tight end blocks air; zone run loses a front-side blocker Call Arc only when you believe the scrape exchange is coming
Bash against Swap Crashing end meets the QB on the inside path, a costly hit Save Bash for a defense that has shown the slow-play
Power read with a light QB Inside carries into linebackers pile up hits Match the option to the QB's body: zone read and speed option for lighter QBs
No budget QB runs 12 times in a close game and misses the next one Write the budget before the season; track it on the call sheet

Decision Framework: calling an option

  1. Count the box. Can you block everyone? If yes, a plain run may be enough. If the defense has its plus-one inside, the read is how you cancel it.
  2. Choose the key. Read the defender who's hardest to block, or whose hesitation helps the next play (usually the best edge rusher).
  3. Ask "who has the quarterback?" Check the film and the booth: Swap, Sit, charge, or a QB player? What did they show last series?
  4. Call the counter to the answer you believe: Arc for Swap, Bash for Sit, Slice for the charge. If you can't tell, call the hedge: a third option (bubble, or an RPO reading the linebacker who has a run job on both looks).
  5. Check the budget. Is this carry worth a hit on your quarterback, now, in this game?
If the read end... Zone read Power read Speed option (pitch key)
Crashes / squeezes inside Keep Give (sweep outside) n/a (attack him: he's taking the QB → pitch)
Sits square, eyes on QB Give Give Attack inside shoulder until he commits
Widens / rushes upfield Give Keep (inside behind the puller) Keep, turn up inside him
Charges the mesh Keep, two hands, around his back Keep inside n/a