Chapter 35 Exercises — Managing the Quarterback

Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and original research.

All Outlaws, Sentinels, and other team situations are from our fictional season unless marked hypothetical. Selected answers are in Appendix J.


Part A — Conceptual ⭐

A1. Name the three roles the quarterback plays for his coordinator at the same time, and give one way each can go wrong if the coordinator forgets it.

A2. List every grant on the Outlaws' authority map (Alert, Kill, Check, zero bin, protection, timeouts). For each, write the one thing the quarterback may not do.

A3. Finish the sentence from the Outlaws' protection card: "The center's point is a recommendation; …" Then explain what Darius Vance may change at the line and what he may not.

A4. What does "grant authority in proportion to evidence" mean? Give one example from the chapter of authority growing and one of authority staying the same after a mistake.

A5. Recite Rome Pettaway's four scramble-and-decision rules in order. Which one is "the free square," and what does it say?

A6. What is the "blind grade," and why does Austin do it before the coach's grade instead of after?

A7. What is the Friday test ("Friday stills")? What went wrong with it the week of Game 3, and what rule was added in the spring?

A8. Why does Lyle call rule four "a doubt rule"? In one sentence, why couldn't it prevent the Game 3 interception?

A9. State the three parts of what a quarterback needs from his coordinator right after a bad play, in order.

A10. What is "Ty's twenty," and where did it come from?


Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐

B1. You're watching an All-22 clip. Before the snap: two safeties at about 13 yards, a quiet four-man front, an offense in 2x2 with the tight end attached left, third-and-9. At the snap: the left-side safety stops and comes down; the right-side safety turns his hips and runs to the middle. (a) What did the shell become? (b) If the offense ran a post-dig concept, which route is now open and why? (c) At what point in the quarterback's drop should he have known?

B2. Read this sideline picture and name the problem.

PRE-SNAP (described from the end zone): 3rd-and-7

        $                                F
   C          E   E    T   M   W   T     E        *          C
   X     Y      LT   LG    C    RG   RT          H           Z
                         R  Q

📊 Diagram (described): An offense in two-by-two with the tight end flexed off the left tackle. Two defensive ends are outside the left tackle, both inside linebackers stand in the A gaps beside the center, and the field corner is up on the outside receiver to the right. Two safeties are deep.

Name the defensive look, the Outlaws' protection answer after Week 15 (who blocks whom), and the hot.

B3. A quarterback on film climbs into the pocket every time both edge rushers run past his launch point. On one snap, he climbs and is sacked by a linebacker who never crossed the line until he stepped up. What was the defense doing, and what is the practice answer the chapter describes?

B4. Watch this description of a scramble drill: the coverage holds, the quarterback escapes to his right, the outside receiver on the right stops his go route and comes back toward him, and the slot on the left keeps running his crossing route to the left sideline. Which of Rome's rules did each receiver follow or break?

B5. A quarterback scrambles left, stays inside the tackle box, and throws the ball into the turf at a running back's feet with no defender near the back. The back is three yards behind the line. Is that legal under the NFL's intentional grounding rule as described in this chapter? What would have made it legal?

B6. Look at Rome's Game 3 grade table in Section 35.7. Find the two snaps that share the same decision error. Describe the error in one sentence a quarterback could repeat.

B7. You have Rome's grade sheet for one quarter of a hypothetical game: five dropbacks. Snap 1: a hitch for 6 on 2nd-and-8, ball out at 1.4 s. Snap 2: a throw-away on 3rd-and-11 from outside the tackle box at 3.6 s, with two defenders closing. Snap 3: a dig completed for 14 on 3rd-and-7, thrown at 2.6 s into a window the robber had left. Snap 4: a post intercepted on 2nd-and-10; the free safety was in the middle before the snap and never moved. Snap 5: a screen for −2 when the defensive end retraced. Grade each snap's Decision as + or −, and explain why the result column and your decision column don't match on at least two of them.

Short answer

Snap 1 +; Snap 2 + (the alternative was a sack — the incompletion is a good result for a dead play); Snap 3 +; Snap 4 − (the middle was closed before and after the snap — this is an eyes/decision error, not a disguise); Snap 5 is probably + for the quarterback (he threw the screen as called — the retracing end is a blocking or call problem). The mismatches are Snap 2 (incomplete, but a plus) and Snap 5 (negative yards, but not his decision error).


Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

C1. Make the call (sideline version). Hypothetical next-season game against Sacramento. Third quarter, you trail 13–10. On 2nd-and-8 at your own 41, Darius throws a dig behind Powers, and it's tipped and intercepted. He comes to you on the sideline and says, "My fault — I was late." The film you saw on the sideline tablet shows he was late because the right guard got pushed into his throwing lane. Write the exact twenty seconds you'd say. Then explain each part.

Short answer

Something like: "I heard you. The guard got pushed into your lane, so part of that's protection, and we'll look at both halves Monday. Next series, what do you like first?" Receipt — he owned it, so you acknowledge it rather than arguing. Division — specific and true (the push in the lane) without taking his half (he was late, and he can own timing). No diagnosis — "Monday," not a tablet session now. Next decision — hand him a choice. Do not say "That's not on you" (it partly is) or "You've got to get that out" (diagnosis at the numbers).

C2. Make the call (line version). Hypothetical. Third-and-6 at your own 47, second quarter, tied 10–10. Call: "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 60 Left, Stick." At :11 a sixth defender walks to the line on your right and both safeties drop to eight yards; at :07 the left nickel creeps inside. In order, list what the quarterback says and decides before the snap. Then identify which of those decisions belong to him under the Outlaws' authority map, and which, if any, would be a full audible.

Short answer

(1) Declare the Mike out loud (echo or overrule the center). (2) Flip the slide toward the walk-up — "Sixty Right! Sixty Right!" — and move the back to the left. (3) Identify the leftover (the creeping nickel) as the hot; the ball goes to the area he leaves. (4) If it's true Cover 0 — no one deep, more rushers than blockers — go to the zero bin's top play. All four are his grants. Changing to, say, a flood concept that isn't on the wristband would be a full audible, which Austin doesn't allow.

C3. Draw it up. Draw "Eleven, Gun Trips Right, 60 Left, Y Cross" against Cover 1. Then draw the same play after the quarterback escapes to his right at 3.2 seconds, showing how each receiver applies Rome's rules 1–3. Label the throw-away option under rule 4 and state where the quarterback must be for it to be legal under NFL grounding rules.

C4. Make the call (the next play). Week 12–style home game, hypothetical. First quarter, 0–0. On 3rd-and-3 at the opponent's 40, your quarterback holds a slant against press for 2.8 seconds and is sacked for −8. Punt. Your next possession starts at your own 22. Using the "first call after" rule from 35.7, choose the first call and justify it. What would be the mistake of calling a two-yard swing pass "to get him going"?

Short answer

Choose a play he has already beaten this defense with today or in earlier meetings — for Austin against a pressing defense, a zoom-motion quick out (gets the receiver a release on the move) or a concept with a built-in checkdown he's completed before. The rule is "not a gimme": a two-yard swing tells him and the defense that you're worried, and it doesn't rebuild evidence; it just delays the next real decision.

C5. Build the page. You have a 110-call game plan. Write the quarterback's one-page rules sheet for a hypothetical opponent that plays two-high Quarters on early downs, rotates late on about a third of third-and-longs, and shows a double-A mug on 3rd-and-7+. Maximum eight lines. At least one line must be a post-snap branch.

C6. Draw it up — the middle-read tag. Draw the middle-read tag on "Mills" against (a) a two-high shell that stays two-high and (b) a two-high shell that rotates to one-high at the snap. On each drawing, mark where the quarterback's eyes are at step 1 and step 3, and the throw.

C7. Make the call (clock). Hypothetical. 1:52 left in the fourth quarter, you trail 20–16, no timeouts, 2nd-and-10 at the opponent's 41. Your quarterback escapes right, is outside the tackle box, and the nearest open receiver is at the 36, in bounds, with a defender closing. The clock is running. Throw the ball away past the line, or take the five yards in bounds? Write the rule you'd want him to carry for this situation.

Short answer

With no timeouts, a completion in bounds for five yards costs roughly the time it takes to line up and spike (often 15–20 seconds) and leaves 3rd-and-5; a throw-away stops the clock and leaves 3rd-and-10. Down four, you need a touchdown, so time and down both matter. Many staffs' rule: "No timeouts, inside two minutes, outside the numbers or away." A five-yard gain that stays in bounds is acceptable only if you have a "Clock" call ready and enough time for at least three more snaps. The point of the drill is that the quarterback should know the rule before the play; it's a game-management grant, written on his card.

C8. Make the call (the backup). Hypothetical. It's Wednesday morning. Your starter sprained an ankle on Sunday and won't play. Your backup is a 31-year-old veteran: quick release, good pre-snap processor, below-average runner. Your plan, built Tuesday night for the starter, has 104 calls, including 6 boots and sprints, 2 Kill calls, a three-play Check menu, 3 Alerts, and 9 designed quarterback runs across all boxes. Using Case Study 1's lessons, list what you cut, what you keep, and what you say to the offense at the 8:30 install.

Short answer

Cut the boots and sprints toward the side a pass rusher can chase him down on (or all of them if the backside end hasn't bitten all season), every designed quarterback run except perhaps a sneak, one of the two Kill calls (keep the one with the simplest count), and one play from the Check menu. Keep the Alerts only if each has a pre-snap condition he can see early. Build his twenty from the quick game, rhythm throws, and play-actions with the ball out on time; put them in a separate column. To the offense: "This week we're running his plan inside our plan. Everything you've learned still works; fewer things move." Tell the truth — not "nothing changes."

C9. Draw it up — the Climb period. Draw a practice rep for the Climb period: a four-man rush with both edges taking wide arcs past the launch point, and a scout linebacker who either sits at five yards (a "rat") or rushes late through the A gap. Show the quarterback's two answers: throw on the climb if the linebacker sat and then dropped, tuck and slide if he came. Write the coaching point you'd shout on the first rep.


Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐

D1. Peyton Manning's Colts are widely described as giving their quarterback broad control at the line. The Outlaws allow no full audibles. Make the strongest case for each approach. Under what conditions would you move Austin toward Manning-style control, and what would you give up?

D2. Darius struck "Speed" from the Green panel before Game 3 because he'd seen Rollins sit on the pitch. Lyle took it off the sheet without argument. When should a coordinator refuse a quarterback's strike? Name two situations and the cost of overruling him.

D3. The QB-carry budget is about three designed runs a game, up to five in the playoffs with the head coach's sign-off. Argue for raising the playoff number to seven for a quarterback like Darius. Then argue against it. Include player-safety and roster arguments, not just yards.

D4. After the Game 3 interception, Lyle told Darius, "This one we split." A colleague argues that a coordinator should always take the full blame publicly to protect the quarterback. Respond, using the ownership ledger. Is there a difference between what you say to the media and what you say in the quarterback room?

D5. Rome wrote his dissent in a margin and later said, "I should have said them out loud in the room." Design a staff rule that would have turned that margin note into a real check on the Mills box without slowing down the game-plan meeting.

D6. Your quarterback has graded his own interception as a "+" decision in the blind grade. Your grade says "−." He says the safety disguised it. You believe the safety's turn was visible by his third step. Write the conversation you would have, in five lines of dialogue, and say what you'd do if after watching it together you still disagree. What does the disagreement tell you about his picture of the play — and about what you've been teaching?

D7. A local reporter asks you, after a playoff loss, whether your quarterback "made the wrong read" on the game-ending interception. Write a two-sentence answer that is honest, doesn't throw him under the bus, and doesn't claim all the blame falsely. Then explain why the quarterback room hears a fuller version of the same answer.


Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

M1. With Chapter 22 (Pass Protection). "Protection is arithmetic, and the quarterback is part of the protection." Explain how the Game 2 sack ("I did it right, Coach") and the Game 3 Anchor C snap show the same quarterback executing the rules perfectly with opposite results. What changed between them — the quarterback, or the rules?

M2. With Chapter 8 (The Language of Play Calling). Chapter 8 says "more than ten words, call the band." Connect that rule to the forty-second timeline in this chapter: how does call length affect what the quarterback owns after :15, and what happened in Week 2 at St. Louis when the rule was broken?

M3. With Chapter 24 (Building the Game Plan). Chapter 24's contingency table had a blank last row: rotation on 3rd-and-7+ from a quiet front. Trace how that blank row reached the quarterback: the whiteboard box, Rome's margin note, the scout team, the Friday test, Saturday's circles, and the snap at 2:41.

M4. With Chapter 12 (The Option Game). Darius's three keep rules and the carry budget come from the option chapter. Write a one-paragraph explanation for a high-school quarterback of why "outside the 10, the first down is enough" is a game-management rule, not just a safety rule.

M5. With Chapter 15 (Route Concepts) and Chapter 7 (Understanding Defensive Structure). "The quarterback reads a defender, not a receiver" and "the shell is not the coverage." Use both ideas to explain why the third-quarter bender in Game 3 (Simmons's eyes stayed on #2) and the Mills snap were the same kind of error.

M6. With Chapter 34 (Installing the Offense). Using Chapter 34's practice week, show where the quarterback-first meetings, the Friday stills, the Climb period, and the scramble period fit. Which one would you cut first in a short (Thursday-night) game week, and why?

M7. With Chapter 25 (Play Calling) and Chapter 28 (Analytics). Marisol bucketed Darius's 11 regular-season interceptions: rotation 4, forced late 3, tipped 2, quick outs jumped 2. Using the idea that "a call is a bet on a distribution," explain why the rotation bucket matters most to a defensive coordinator who is planning a playoff game against Austin, and what a coordinator should do with a bucket that a defense can schedule. Then state the sample-size caveat Marisol would attach.

Short answer

A defense can't schedule a tipped ball or a receiver's drop, but it can schedule a post-snap rotation on the down and distance where the quarterback's pre-snap read is most predictable — and the Sentinels did, on the 30th third-and-long after 29 straight two-high shells. The coordinator's answer is to build the branch into the calls on those downs (the middle-read tag) and to test it in practice. Caveat: four interceptions is a tiny sample; the bucket is a lean, not a law, and the buckets themselves are judgment calls.


Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐

E1. The five seconds after. Pick three NFL games this season. For every interception, watch the broadcast and any sideline shots for the next five minutes of game time. Chart: (a) who the quarterback talks to first; (b) whether a coach approaches him with a tablet; (c) the first play call of his next series — a throw, a run, or a screen — and its result. Look for a pattern, and be honest about how much broadcast footage you actually have.

E2. Infer the authority map. Choose one NFL quarterback and watch two full games on All-22 (or the widest broadcast angle available). Chart every snap where the quarterback appears to (a) change the protection (pointing, re-declaring, moving the back), (b) choose between two plays (a pause, a hand signal, the offense resetting), or (c) change the play entirely. Write the authority card you think his coordinator gave him, and list the snaps that support each line. Public charting services such as Next Gen Stats (time to throw) and Pro Football Focus can help with timing; describe what you used.

E3. A famous pairing, carefully. Read about one well-documented coordinator–quarterback or head coach–quarterback relationship (for example, Bill Walsh and Joe Montana, or Andy Reid and Patrick Mahomes) in a book or a reputable long-form source. Write two pages on how the quarterback's authority and the system changed over their first three seasons together. Use only facts you can source; do not invent quotes.