Chapter 23 — Instructor Notes

What this chapter is for

Chapter 23 opens Part IV by moving the reader from the field to the film room. Part III taught concepts; this chapter teaches how an offensive staff decides which concepts a given defense will let it run. The hook sets the tone. It's 12:40 a.m. on the Friday of Week 5, and Teo says, "Coach. Look at forty-five." Jordan Ames came downhill on the first zone step 14 of 18 times. Lyle doesn't celebrate the tell. He says, "Show me the four," and the four exceptions produce Teo's note "Burned → sits." That note is the line that wins the second snap of Game 1.

Two arguments carry the chapter. First, a report is only as honest as its denominators: §23.4's shrinking denominator, 243 snaps down to 14 in the bucket that matters on Sunday. Second, every report expires, and the other coordinator chooses when (§23.9). The Week 6 "Kimbrough by situation" page and the divisional page, side by side, show three rows that held, one row the Outlaws changed themselves, three rows Russ changed, and one row that became a 29-snap streak and then a trap.

There's no threshold concept here, but there is a habit you want students to leave with: write "9 of 14," never "64 percent." That habit carries into everything they'll do in Chapter 28.

Teaching objectives

By the end of the session a student should be able to:

  1. State the three report questions and Lyle's fourth line (What do they do? What can't they do? What do they do when we do X? What will they leave, and is my guy better than theirs there?) and explain what each adds.
  2. Tag a snap in Teo's fields, including two shell columns (2H, 1H, 0, with an arrow for rotation), the box word, and "eyes / first step," writing "?" where the film doesn't say.
  3. Report every tendency as a count with its denominator and explain, in plain coin-flip terms, why 70 percent on ten snaps is a floor and not proof.
  4. Split a count by context. Explain why 15 of 26 third-and-long pressures became 7 of 17 against veteran quarterbacks.
  5. Write a "by situation" row with a count, a "since" date, and a decision column.
  6. Run a two-direction self-scout ("What does this look predict?" and "Where does this play come from?") and mark tendencies keep, break, watch, or accept.
  7. Explain why a perfect streak deserves a question mark, using the divisional Row 5.

Timing

In a 75-minute session: 10 minutes on the hook and §23.1 (report vs. game plan; the three questions). 15 minutes on §23.3, Teo's three passes and the "?" rule ("unknowns are data"). 20 minutes on §23.4: the shrinking-denominator table on the board, the 📈 coin-flip aside, then the 🧩 Productive struggle on the raw third-and-long pressure numbers. 20 minutes on §23.5: Rows 1, 6, and 8, then the 📋 Make the call (Game 1, 3rd-and-6 at the Austin 34, "Two high, six, nickel's creeping"). 10 minutes on §23.9's two-column table.

In a 150-minute block: add a tagging lab using Exercise B6 (one snap, all eighteen fields), then §23.6 and its 📋 Whose fault? (Week 2 at St. Louis, the right guard's eight-inch wider run split). Add §23.8's Thursday QB room scene and Case Study 2. If you have film, have pairs tag ten snaps of a real defense from the broadcast and count their own question marks.

What to cut when you're behind: §23.7 (the Monday-to-Saturday timeline) goes to reading; it's a schedule, and Chapter 24 re-teaches the week. Reduce §23.2's film diet and camera angles to one rule: sideline for coverage, end zone for fronts, fits, and eyes, broadcast only for the situation. Don't cut §23.4. It's the honesty section, and without it the "by situation" page is just a confident list.

Where students get stuck

Percentages without denominators. Students arrive fluent in percentages and suspicious of nothing. Diagnostic: Exercise A5. Ask them to rewrite "They blitz 80 percent of the time on third-and-short" the way Marisol would accept it. Intervention: the §23.4 coin flip. If a coach truly called something half the time, you'd see it at least 9 times in 14 about one time in five. Ames at 14 of 18 is about one in sixty-five. Seven of ten is about one in six, which is why Marisol calls 70-on-10 "worth a cut-up," not proof. Make every student say "a lean, not a law" out loud once.

The pre-snap shell is the coverage. Diagnostic: Exercise B4. An analyst tags "Cover 2" from a broadcast copy because two safeties were visible before the snap. Intervention: two shell columns, always, plus the Sentinels' own numbers: 92 of 243 snaps changed shell at the snap. Mention the unnamed intern who tagged "two-high on 70% of third downs" from a broadcast copy when the sideline film showed a little over 40%.

Exceptions are noise. Students throw away the snaps that don't fit. Diagnostic: give them "Ames downhill, 14 of 18" and ask what they'd do next. Most will say "call the RPO." Intervention: "Show me the four." One was a false step (noise), but three came on the snap right after a completion behind him. The exceptions told Teo what Ames would do on snap 2, and snap 2 went for 7 yards when he sat. "The exceptions are the report" is the takeaway to print.

Ignoring who the opponent played. Diagnostic: the §23.4 🧩 Productive struggle itself. Show 15 of 26 third-and-long pressures and ask what to expect. Intervention: split by opponent: 8 of 9 against a rookie-quarterback team, 7 of 17 against the other three. Case Study 2 is the same mistake from the other side. Lyle threw out the Week 6 film because the 35–0 opponent "can't throw," and the film he threw out was the new play-caller's.

A perfect streak is the strongest evidence. Diagnostic: quiz item 16. Intervention: §23.9's Row 5. Twenty-nine of twenty-nine had no exceptions to study, against a coordinator who knew he was being charted. The three post-divisional changes are the fix: a "since" column, a question mark instead of bold for streaks with no exceptions, and a post-snap answer on every third-and-long call (the middle-read tag).

Whiteboard / film-room activity

Tag the tell. Draw the end-zone view below and tell the room it's one of eighteen Week 6 clips of inside zone from 2x2 with Ames as the backside linebacker.

WEEK 6 TAG -- IZ right from Gun Doubles Right (end-zone view)
Field to tag: "eyes / first step" for the Will (#45)

   C       *          W(45)         M                     C
                        \           |
                         v          v
               E    T     N     T    E
   X     H     O    O     O     O    O    Y          Z
                    R  Q
                       ----> zone flow right

📊 Diagram (described): An end-zone view of the Outlaws in Gun Doubles Right: Sutton and Powers on the left, Harlan attached on the right with Gaines outside him, and Ruffin offset to Vance's left. The line is stepping right on inside zone. The backside linebacker, Ames, takes his first step forward and toward the line, downhill. The Mike steps straight ahead. The nickel is over Powers.

What to ask: "What goes in the field? Now it's 14 of 18. Is that a tell? What's your next step before it goes on the page? What does the play look like that wins whether he comes or sits?"

What a strong answer sounds like: "Eyes on the back, first step downhill. Fourteen of eighteen clears the threshold, but before it goes on the page I watch the four exceptions and write what they share. Three came right after a completion behind him, so the row reads 'downhill 14 of 18, sits after he's burned.' The play is Inside Slant: if he comes, throw the slant into the window he left; if he sits, hand off into the box he left." Then put up the shrinking-denominator table (243 → 59 → 26 → 14) and ask how much of Sunday's call sheet rests on 14 snaps.

Assessment notes

Assign: A1, A5, A6, and A9 for recall; B1 and B6 (the eighteen-field tag; reward honest question marks); B7 (is the clip one of the "9" or the "3"?); C1 and C2 (make the call from a page row); D1 (an 11-of-14 tell from the first two games only) and D6 (write the 22-straight streak the post-season way). M6, with Chapter 3, is the best self-scout item: design the sort that would have caught the reduced-split scissors tell.

Quiz: items 4, 7, 12, and 16 test the honesty material. Item 21 (the applied third-and-6 from Game 1) mirrors the 📋 Make the call. Students who score 11–14 should redo the two §23.5 Try-its, per the scoring guide.

The Project Checkpoint is the Scouting Template + Sentinels Defensive Tendency Report. Part 1 is a reusable template: at least 14 tagging fields, a field-zone map, the three-question block plus the fourth line, and the student's honesty rules. Part 2 is built from Appendix G with forms from Appendix F, and has five pieces: a profile table, an eight-row "by situation" page with a decision column, a four-percent list, a mirror of five self-scout tendencies, and three things per room.

A strong one has a denominator on every number, a "since" column filled in, and a decision column that names a call or a rule rather than repeating the tendency. Its four-percent list ranks rare calls by how badly they'd hurt, not by how rare they are (Exercise D5 is the right warm-up). The most common failure is bare percentages; return the page ungraded until every number is a count. The second is a mirror section that only sorts by formation. Ask for the reverse sort, by play.

Any-level adaptation

High school staff: the checkpoint's high-school track is one or two games, eight fields, a five-row page, and three things for the quarterback. Case Study 2 is the right story for this audience: film exchanged in a gas-station parking lot, about 150 snaps on a legal pad at a diner booth, and a new defensive play-caller after Week 5. The lesson transfers directly: when the play-caller changes, the sample starts over.

College class: require a field/boundary split on every row, since wider hashes make field and boundary tendencies much stronger than in the NFL. The tagging lab works well with three students per game, one per pass.

Analyst course: Exercise E1 (chart one defense from a televised game, counting your "?" tags) and E3 (a four-game self-scout from public play-by-play data). Make students write the chapter's last instruction into every page: one honest sentence about what the sample can't tell you.

Connections

Backward: Chapter 7 gave the shell marks and box words this chapter tags; Chapter 13's first-step test became the scouting tool that found Ames; Chapter 22's Row 6 mug count explains why the Game 2 sack "wasn't on this tape."

Forward: Chapter 24 turns the page into a plan and a script; Chapter 25 owns the Mills decision that §23.9 only previews; Chapter 28 formalizes sample-size honesty. Appendix E and Appendix H are the reference companions.