Chapter 29 Exercises — The Shanahan System

Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall and understanding · ⭐⭐ application and recognition · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and independent film study.

All Outlaws, Sentinels, Stallions, Pioneers, and other teams and players are fictional. Situations marked hypothetical are practice scenarios, not games from Austin's season. Selected answers are in Appendix J.


Part A — Conceptual ⭐

A1. In one sentence, state the design rule that defines the Shanahan system. Then name the multiplier from this book's thesis (conflict, sequence, or illusion) that it expresses most directly.

A2. Name the defender each of these plays lies to, and what that defender keys: (a) Wide PA Boot; (b) Wide PA, Y Dig; (c) Yankee; (d) Z Crack Go.

A3. What's the difference between Boot and Naked in Austin's terminology? In "Wide PA Boot Left," which way does the run fake go, which way does the quarterback go, and who pulls?

A4. Give three reasons outside zone, rather than inside zone or power, makes the best "engine" for an offense built on illusion.

A5. Explain the phrase "a boot is a payment for runs you've already made." What is the "deposit," and what is the "withdrawal"?

A6. What does a condensed (Nasty) split give a receiver against press-man coverage that a wide split doesn't? Name the term.

A7. What is crack-replace, and why does a sound crack-replace rule create a play-action opportunity?

A8. Why did many defenses respond to the late-2010s version of this system by playing two high safeties, and what did they concede in exchange?

A9. What is a tite front (4i–0–4i), and which two parts of outside-zone blocking does it attack?

A10. Austin's borrow list rejects two items. Name them, and explain why neither is a rejection of the system's central idea.


Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐

B1. You pause the All-22 at 0.8 seconds after the snap. All five offensive linemen have taken a short lateral step to the right; the right tight end's helmet is outside the end; the quarterback, under center, has turned his back to the defense with the ball at the back's belly; the back is on a wide track to the right. On the left, the guard's second step is flat down the line toward the left. Run, play-action, or boot? Which single detail told you, and which defender on the field should have seen it?

B2. Describe what you would expect to see from the backside end and the Will linebacker on a successful Wide PA Boot Left against a single-high, eight-man box, and on an unsuccessful one. Use the words chase, squeeze, and flow.

B3. The diagram below shows a pre-snap alignment. Identify the formation family, the receivers' splits, and the defensive structure. Then name the two run-game advantages this alignment creates and the one pass-game advantage against press.

                              F
            C                                         C
                                              $
                      W         M
                 E        N      T   E   S
          X    U  LT  LG   C  RG  RT   Y
                           Q                    Z
                           R

📊 Diagram (described): A two-tight-end, under-center set with both wide receivers condensed to about four yards outside the tight ends. The corners have followed them inside. The defense shows one deep safety, a strong safety walked down outside the right tight end, a Sam on that tight end, four down linemen, and two inside linebackers.

B4. On film, a defense rotates its strong safety down toward the side of every jet motion. On the next jet, the quarterback fakes the sweep and hands the ball to the back going the other way for 9 yards. Name the motion job this play exploited, the two defenders who were moved out of the play, and the call in Austin's terminology.

B5. On a Naked Right against a two-high Quarters look, you see the nickel widen with the tight end's flat route and the boot-side safety settle over the outside receiver's clear route. The crosser from the far side is open at 11 yards. Why did the safety not drive on the crosser, and what would the quarterback throw if the nickel had dropped under the crosser instead?

B6. You watch a team run its tight end on a boot crosser three times in a game. On the first two, the linebackers' first two steps go toward the run fake, and the tight end is wide open. On the third, the linebackers drop straight back at the snap and the throw is contested. What changed, and what call does the third snap set up?

B7. A defense lines up with both defensive tackles on the inside shoulders of the offensive tackles, a nose head-up on the center, and two safeties at 12 yards. The offense runs outside zone; the back is tackled after 1 yard by a linebacker who scraped over the top untouched. Identify the front, the technique numbers, and why nobody blocked the linebacker.

B8. On film, a slot receiver starts in motion toward the formation, runs behind the quarterback at the snap, and keeps going toward the far sideline while the line and the back flow the other way on an outside-zone fake. The quarterback then rolls back toward the side the slot came from and throws the flat to him for 7 yards. Name the motion, explain why the defense's flat defender was late, and say how this differs from a jet fake.


Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

C1. Make the call ⭐⭐ (hypothetical). Week 12-style opponent: single-high, eight in the box, strong safety walked down. Second quarter, tied 3–3. 2nd-and-5 at the opponent's 41. You're in Twelve, under center. Your Wide Right has gone for 3 and 4 on the drive; on both, the backside end chased flat and the strong safety filled hard. The booth: "End chased twice. Safety's coming on the tight end's first step." Choose between Wide Right again, Wide PA Boot Left, Naked Left, and Wide PA Max, Yankee. Defend your call in three sentences.

Short answer

Wide PA Boot Left is the strongest call: the chase count says the end is ripe, the strong safety's fill empties the crosser's landing spot, and second-and-5 makes an incompletion cheap. Yankee is a strong alternative because the strong safety is committed and the middle safety is alone; prefer it if you want the shot and trust eight-man protection. Naked is defensible on two chases, but Boot is the safer version if the end has any history of looking for the guard. Another Wide is fine but leaves the evidence you just bought unspent.

C2. Draw it up ⭐⭐. Draw "Twelve, Under Ace Right, Wide PA Boot Left" against a Cover 1 (man free) defense with a five-man rush. Show the flat, crosser, and clear, the pulling guard, and each man defender. Then write two sentences on why the crosser is the best throw against man coverage.

Short answer

Your drawing should show the line stepping right, Moss (LG) pulling flat to the left edge, Brandt in the left flat at 3–5 chased by his man (often a linebacker or the strong safety), Harlan crossing right to left at 10–12 chased by his man through the flowing traffic of the run fake, and Sutton clearing the left corner deep with the free safety in the middle. The crosser is best because Harlan's defender has to run across the whole formation through linebackers flowing the other way, and Harlan catches the ball moving into open grass, where yards after the catch come from.

C3. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐ (hypothetical). Against a two-high Quarters defense with a six-man box and a nickel at apex. Third quarter, you lead 17–10. 1st-and-10 at your 38. Your Wide from Eleven has gained 5, 6, and 4 on the drive. The backside end chased once and squeezed once. Your offensive coordinator's instinct says it's time for a play-action shot. What do you call, and what do you tell him about the shot?

Short answer

Wide again, from Eleven. Two-high with a six-man box is a defense giving you the run; five a carry on first down is exactly what you want, and a shot into two deep safeties is what the defense wants. The chase count is one of two, so the boot isn't ripe; if you want a pass, it's a boot for the flat and the crosser in front of the safeties, not a shot. The shot belongs to single-high weeks or to a snap when motion has rotated a safety down.

C4. Draw it up ⭐⭐⭐. Draw "Twelve, Under Ace Right Nasty, Wide Right, Z Crack" against a single-high defense with the strong safety as the force player (pre-snap and post-snap). Then draw the Crack Go off the same look. In the post-snap picture, label the defender who is in conflict and his two jobs.

Short answer

Pre-snap: both receivers about four yards outside the tight ends; corners condensed with them; strong safety walked down. Post-snap (run): the line blocks Wide Right, Gaines cracks the strong safety from the outside, the corner comes downhill to replace as the force, Ruffin presses Harlan's outside leg. Crack Go: same first steps; Gaines takes two crack steps, the corner replaces, Gaines turns up the sideline, Sutton runs a post to hold the middle safety, eight protect. The conflict defender is the corner: force on the crack run, deep outside third on the pass.

C5. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐ (hypothetical). Fourth quarter, you lead by 4, about 6:30 left. 2nd-and-2 at your 46. The opponent has gone to a single-high, eight-man box to stop your four-minute runs. You're in Twelve under center. Your head coach asks you on the headset why you'd throw. Make the case for or against Yankee in four sentences that answer his real question: what does it cost if it fails?

Short answer

For: On second-and-2, an incompletion costs about five seconds of clock and a down you didn't need; you still have third-and-2 to run. The defense has committed a safety to the run, which is the structure Yankee is built for, and eight-man protection removes the sack risk that makes shots dangerous late. If it hits, the game is close to over. Against only if your protection or quarterback has struggled with play-action today, or if the middle safety has been playing deep and patient instead of leaning; then run it and make them stop you twice.

C6. Draw it up ⭐⭐. Draw the jet fake with Wide away: "Eleven, Under Doubles Right, H Jet, Wide Left" against a two-high nickel defense whose rule is to rotate a safety toward the jet. Show the motion (~~>), the rotation, and the run.

Short answer

Pre-snap: Powers in the left slot, jet motion to the right timed to arrive behind Vance at the snap; two safeties deep, nickel over Powers. Post-snap: the strong safety on the right rotates down toward the jet, the nickel runs with Powers, the free safety spins toward the middle; the line steps left and blocks Wide Left; Ruffin aims at the left tackle's outside leg, toward the side the rotation thinned out.

C7. Make the call ⭐⭐ (hypothetical, high school). Friday night, second quarter, tied 7–7. 1st-and-10 at your own 45, ball on the left hash. Your team runs outside zone from under center. Your Wide Right (to the field) has gained 6 and 4 on the drive; the press box reports that the left end (the boundary-side end, backside on Wide Right) chased on both. Your quarterback is a junior who has thrown well on the move in practice. Choose a call and say which direction it goes, and why the hash matters.

Short answer

Wide PA Boot Left (fake Wide Right to the field, quarterback boots left toward the boundary) is defensible: the left end has chased twice, and the boundary is short, so the flat and the crosser are quick throws with the sideline close. Keep it Boot, not Naked, unless he's chased more. The hash matters because the boot is going into the short side: there's little room for the clear route, so the read is really flat then crosser, and the quarterback's escape is out of bounds. Another Wide Right to the field is also a good call; Wide Left into the boundary is not.

C8. Draw it up ⭐⭐⭐. Draw "Twenty-one, Under I Right, Wide PA Boot Left, B Slice Flat" against a single-high Cover 3 with the strong safety walked down on the tight-end side. Show the fullback's full path, the pulling guard, the crosser, the clear, and the backside post. Then explain in two sentences why the fullback is often the first open receiver.

Short answer

The fullback (Fale) takes one step right with the run fake, then crosses back behind the line on the path of a slice block toward the backside end and leaks into the left flat at 3–5 yards; the left guard pulls flat to the left edge; Vance boots left behind him; Harlan crosses right to left at 10–12; Sutton clears the left corner deep; Gaines runs a post from the right. The fullback is open early because his path looks like a block, so nobody covers him until he passes the end, and the curl-flat defender on that side has usually flowed toward the fake.


Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐

D1. A young coordinator wants to make the boot Austin's "base pass" because it averages more yards per call than any other pass in the play-action family. Write a one-paragraph response explaining why the boot's average would fall if it were called more often. Use the idea of deposits and withdrawals, and name the defender whose behavior changes.

D2. Darius Vance is a right-handed quarterback whose scrambles mostly go to his right and whose best football comes from the shotgun against the blitz. List two ways the pure version of this system would underuse him and two pieces of the system that make him better. Then decide roughly what share of Austin's snaps should come from under center, and defend the number in terms of personnel.

D3. Naked leaves the most dangerous rusher on the field unblocked by design. Write a short policy (three rules) governing when your offense may call Naked, what the quarterback does if the end stays home, and how you practice it without exposing your quarterback to live hits.

D4. Condensed formations bring the corners closer to the run, too. Describe one situation in which a condensed formation helps the defense more than the offense, and what you'd call from a normal split instead.

D5. Two-high defenses offered "four a carry all day." Make the case that accepting that bargain is correct for an offense in the first half, and the case that it's wrong in the fourth quarter of a one-score game you're losing. What changes?

D6. Naked gives Vance a run option when the flat and crosser are covered and the end has chased. Austin also has a budget of about three designed quarterback carries a game (up to five in the playoffs with the head coach's sign-off). Should a Naked keep count against that budget? Argue one side in a paragraph, considering how often the keep happens, how much contact Vance takes on it, and what the defense learns if he never keeps.


Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

M1 (with Chapter 10). Chapter 10 taught the back's three answers on outside zone: bounce, bang, bend. For each answer, name the play-action or boot that punishes the defensive adjustment designed to take that answer away.

M2 (with Chapter 12). Chapter 12's threshold concept was "you can block a defender with a decision." Explain how Naked uses that idea, and how the chase count works like a pre-snap version of the quarterback's read.

M3 (with Chapter 19). Chapter 19's threshold concept was "the run game is the first half of every play-action pass." Using Case Study 1, explain why the Stallions' strong safety could be fooled by play-action in Week 2 even though Austin's runs weren't working, while their backside end couldn't be fooled by the boot.

M4 (with Chapter 4). Chapter 4 argued that personnel is how you choose the defender. Explain how Austin used Eleven and Twelve personnel against Sacramento's nickel and big nickel to decide which defender would be the force player against Wide, and why Twelve became the "boot personnel" in the divisional round.

M5 (with Chapter 7). Before the snap, the defense shows two high safeties; at the snap, the strong safety rotates down toward a jet motion. Is the middle of the field open or closed after the rotation? Which chapter 29 play does that rotation make possible, and which one does it take away?

M6 (with Chapter 18). Yankee is a shot play. Using Chapter 18's thinking about when to call shots, explain why Week 10's Yankee on 2nd-and-2 was a better decision than the same call on 3rd-and-6 would have been, even if the coverage were identical.

M7 (with Chapter 22). Chapter 22's threshold concept was "protection is arithmetic, and the quarterback is part of the protection." Do the arithmetic for Boot and for Naked off Twelve-personnel Wide action against a four-man rush: how many blockers stay on the line, who is unblocked on purpose, and what plays the role of the "hot" throw when the unblocked man comes free? Then explain why "never take the sack on a boot" is a protection rule, not just a quarterback rule.


Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐

E1. The first-second test. Choose an NFL team widely grouped with the Shanahan tree. On the All-22 or end-zone angle, collect 20 snaps that begin from the same under-center, outside-zone picture. For each, pause at the moment the quarterback turns his back and record your guess (run, play-action, boot). Then record what it was. Report your accuracy, and for every snap you guessed correctly, write down the single detail that gave it away (a lineman's step, the tight end's release, the back's track, the quarterback's shoulders). What you're looking for: which position on that team most often "breaks the picture" early.

E2. The chase count. For one game of any outside-zone team, track the backside defensive end on every outside-zone run: did he chase flat, squeeze and look inside, or stay home? Then track every boot or naked the offense called. Build a small table like Marisol's (boots after 0, 1, and 2+ chases on the drive) and record the result of each. With a sample this small you're not proving anything; describe what you saw and whether the offense appeared to call boots on evidence.

E3. How the defense adapted. Watch two games of the same team's defense, one from early in a season and one from late in it, against an outside-zone opponent. Chart the shell (one-high or two-high), the box count, and the front (look for 4i–0–4i "tite" alignments and for ends who squeeze). Describe in one page how the defense's answer changed, and what the offense did in response. Hedge every conclusion with your sample size.