Chapter 23 Exercises — The Scouting Report

Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall and concepts · ⭐⭐ recognition and application · ⭐⭐⭐ judgment and trade-offs · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension: research and film study.

Situations marked (hypothetical) are practice scenarios, not snaps from the Outlaws' season. The Outlaws, Sentinels, Pioneers, Forge, and Stallions are fictional. Selected answers are in Appendix J.


Part A — Conceptual ⭐

A1. Name the three questions every scouting report should answer, and Lyle's fourth line. For each, write one sentence explaining what it adds that the previous one doesn't.

A2. What's the difference between a scouting report and a game plan? Which one says "Inside Slant on the first snap"?

A3. Teo tags every snap in three passes. Name each pass, the camera angle it uses, and two fields filled in during it.

A4. Why does the Outlaws breakdown keep two shell columns (before and after the snap) instead of one coverage column? Use the Sentinels' rotation rate in your answer.

A5. Define denominator in your own words. Rewrite this sentence the way Marisol would accept it: "They blitz 80 percent of the time on third-and-short."

A6. Marisol's working threshold for a tell is about 70 percent on ten or more snaps. Why does she call it a floor rather than proof? (Hint: how often does seven of ten happen by pure luck?)

A7. What's a self-scout, and why does Marisol build it from the last four games?

A8. Explain "tells we accept." Give the Outlaws' example and one example of your own.

A9. What does "the exceptions are the report" mean? Use the Ames 14-of-18 count as your example.

A10. Why does each player room get "three things" and not the whole report?


Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐

B1. You're tagging an opponent's snap from the sideline view. Before the snap: two safeties at 12 and 10 yards, one over each hash. At the snap: the 12-yard safety runs to the middle of the field, the 10-yard safety drives down to about 6 yards outside the tight end, and both corners bail deep. Fill in: shell pre, shell post (with the arrow), coverage family.

B2. Here's an end-zone freeze from an opponent's game, one frame after the handoff on an inside zone to the offense's right:

END-ZONE FREEZE: one frame after the handoff (IZ right)

            W                  M
             \                 |
              v                v
          E    T     N     T    E
          O    O     O     O    O    Y
                     Q   R-->

📊 Diagram (described): An end-zone view of an inside zone to the right. The backside (weak) linebacker's first step goes forward and toward the line, downhill. The Mike's first step is straight ahead. The ball has just been handed to the back, who is moving right.

What do you write in the "eyes / first step" column for the Will? If this happens on 12 of 15 similar snaps, what's the next thing you watch?

B3. Teo's quiet-window line from the booth is "Two high, six, nickel's creeping." Translate each of the three parts into the tagging fields from 23.3.

B4. On a broadcast copy, the camera is tight on the quarterback at the snap and pans to the ball only after the throw. A young analyst tags the coverage "Cover 2" because two safeties were visible before the snap. What two columns should he have filled in instead, and with what?

B5. Look at this pre-snap picture on third-and-8 (hypothetical):

PRE-SNAP: third-and-8, two backers walked into the A gaps

          F                                 $
  C           *                                            C
                  E    T   M   W   T   E
  X          H       O   O   O   O   O   Y                 Z
                             Q  R

📊 Diagram (described): Two deep safeties; the nickel over the left slot; both inside linebackers standing in the A gaps on either side of the center; two tackles in the B gaps and two ends outside the tackles. Six defenders threaten to rush.

Name the look in Outlaws words. Which row of the Week 6 "by situation" page covers it, and what were the two outcomes that row counted?

B6. Tag this snap in all eighteen fields from 23.3 (write "?" where the description doesn't tell you): An opponent's game, second quarter, 9:40, the defense leads by 3. Second-and-7 at the offense's own 42, ball on the right hash. The offense is in 11 personnel, 3x1 to the field, with the slot receiver motioning across to make it 2x2. The defense is in nickel, Under front, six in the box. Two high before the snap; at the snap the safety to the motion side drops down and the other spins to the middle. Four rushers. The quarterback throws a curl for 9; the Will makes the tackle.

Answer

Clip # ? · Q2, 9:40, +3 · 2-7 · own 42, open field · hash R · personnel 11 · formation 3x1 to the field, motion to 2x2 (slot across) · play family dropback (curl) · defense nickel · front Under, strength ? (not stated) · box 6, light · shell 2H→1H · coverage Cover 3 family (rotated toward the motion) · rushers 4 · eyes / first step ? (needs the end-zone view) · result +9, Will tackles · flag: rotation to the motion side, cut it up with every other across-motion snap. The two question marks are the honest part of the answer: the description never told you the front's strength or anyone's eyes.

B7. A Sentinels clip shows the nickel walking from over the slot to about four yards inside, eyes on the quarterback, with five seconds on the play clock. At the snap he backs out and drops into the hook. Is this clip part of the "9" or the "3" on the Week 6 page? What detail should the quarterback watch to tell the two apart?


Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

C1. Make the call ⭐⭐ (hypothetical). Game 1, first quarter, 1st-and-10 at your own 40, up 7–0. You have the Week 6 page. Teo: "Two high, six, Will at five, eyes on the back." You're in 11 personnel, Gun Doubles Right. Your Red panel has Inside Slant, a plain inside zone, and "Inside PA, Gaines Post." Which do you call, and which row of the page drove the decision?

Answer

Inside Slant. Row 8's first tell (Ames downhill on the first zone step, 14 of 18) and Row 1 (two-high, six-man box) both say the Will is in conflict and the box is light. Inside Slant reads him: if he comes, throw the slant; if he sits, hand off into a light box. A plain inside zone ignores the tell, and the play-action post is better saved until Holloway has been made to fill a few times (Row 1's rotator).

C2. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐ (hypothetical). Week 10 at Portland. Teo's bye-week chart: the Pioneers' corner Josh Kiel squatted on the #1 receiver against hitch–corner pairs on 17 of 21 snaps; Tampa 2 on 11 of 16 third-and-mediums. It's 3rd-and-5 at the Portland 34. What concept do you call, and what's the read?

Answer

Smash to the side Kiel is on: hitch by #1 at 6, corner route by #2. The scouting says Kiel squats on the hitch on most snaps (17 of 21 clears the threshold), so the corner route over him is the likely throw, under the half-field safety. The read is Kiel: if he squats, throw the corner; if he sinks, throw the hitch. On third-and-5, the hitch at 6 is also a conversion, which is why smash fits the down. Watch the Tampa 2 Mike running the middle; he doesn't change the smash read but takes away a seam or dig.

C3. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐ (hypothetical). Week 8 vs. Birmingham. Teo's Forge page: Cover 0 on 9 of 17 3rd-and-4–6 snaps in their last four games; safeties walk down to 7–8 yards inside :10. It's 3rd-and-5 at your own 45. Write the call (or the class of call) and the one-sentence rule you want Vance to carry.

Answer

A zero-bin call: a quick concept with built-in hot throws (Slants or Hitches) and a protection that accounts for six with the ball coming out in about a second. Nine of seventeen isn't quite a tell by the 70-on-10 line, but zero is the most dangerous coverage on the field and the walk-down at :10 is a live indicator. Vance's rule: "Safeties walk inside :10, it's zero: count them, point the Mike, throw hot."

C4. Draw it up ⭐⭐⭐. Using Row 1 of the Week 6 page (two-high, field safety comes down on most rotations), draw the pre-snap and post-snap of a play-action pass that attacks the rotator. Label the safety's two jobs and where the ball goes.

Answer

One good answer is the Outlaws' own: "Inside PA, Gaines Post" from the same Gun Doubles Right look as the inside zone.

PRE-SNAP: Gun Doubles Right vs. two-high (Holloway = field safety)

         F (Royce)                         $ (Holloway, ~10)
  C           *          W        M                       C
                  E        N       T   E
  X          H       O   O   O   O   O   Y                 Z
                             Q
                         R

📊 Diagram (described): Austin in Gun Doubles Right with the tight end attached on the right and Gaines wide right. Two safeties deep: Royce on the left, Holloway on the right at about ten yards, with a deep quarter of the field as his pass job and the alley as his run job.

POST-SNAP: Holloway fills on the fake; the post goes behind him

                                     ^  post, caught deep
         F                          /
  (far hash, with Sutton)          /
                                  /    $
                                 /      \  (bites: fills the alley)
                                 |       v
                  E        N     | T   E
  X          H       O   O   O   O   O   Y                 Z
                             Q  ...      (seven-man protection)
                         R ====> (inside zone fake right)

📊 Diagram (described): Vance fakes the inside zone to Ruffin going right, and the line blocks it like a run with seven protecting. Holloway, reading run, comes downhill into the alley, which is his run job. That leaves his deep quarter empty. Gaines runs a post from the right into exactly that space, and Royce is too far away on the opposite hash with Sutton. The ball goes to Gaines behind Holloway.

The scouting row found the rotator; the sequence made him commit. Call the inside zone first so that his fill is a habit by the time the fake comes.

C5. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐ (hypothetical). Game 1, Q2, 2nd-and-6 at your own 45. Marisol's self-scout has your 12 personnel at 42 of 49 run or run fake. Row 2 of the page says the Sentinels have played base on 18 of 31 snaps against two-tight-end sets. You're in Twelve and they've matched with base. Run or pass? Name the matchup you want.

Answer

Pass, to Harlan. Base personnel puts a linebacker in coverage on your best receiving tight end, and your own tendency means the base defense is playing run first. A Y Option or play-action to Harlan attacks both the matchup and the tendency. It also starts to break the 42-of-49 pattern before the defense answers it with a group built to cover Harlan.

C6. Draw it up ⭐⭐. Draw the Week 6 "creeping nickel" picture pre-snap and the post-snap hot throw into the side he walked from. Include the ball's path and the release time.

Answer

Your drawing should show: two high safeties; the nickel walked from over the slot to about four yards inside with his eyes on the quarterback; at the snap, his blitz path (==>) toward the quarterback; the slot receiver (Powers) releasing and breaking inside on a quick slant into the space the nickel left; and the ball's path (...>) from the quarterback to the slant at about 1.1 seconds. The described line should say why the throw is open: the defender responsible for that window just became a rusher. Compare your drawing with the pair in 23.5.

C7. Make the call ⭐⭐ (hypothetical). Game 1, Q2, 3rd-and-1 at the Sacramento 37. Row 3 of the page: one-high man with the field corner pressed (10 of 14); zero only on 3rd-and-1, twice. The ball is on the right hash. Name a run and a pass you'd be comfortable with, and the side you'd throw to.

Answer

A run that gets a hat on the defenders in the box (a duo or a sneak if the A gaps are open) is the default on 3rd-and-1. For the pass, choose a man-beater away from the pressed field corner: with the ball on the right hash, the field is to the left, so throw a slant or quick out into the boundary on the right, or a stack release where the second receiver gets a free release. Because zero showed up twice on 3rd-and-1 in the sample, the call should have a hot answer if the safety walks down: the zero bin lives on the band for exactly this snap.


Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐

D1. Teo finds a tell that clears the threshold at 11 of 14, but the clips all come from the opponent's first two games, and the last two show nothing either way. Do you put it on the page? How would you word the row?

D2. Your self-scout shows a tendency you like, the first play of drives from 2x2 is your RPO on 7 of 11, and the defense can surely see it. Lyle kept his. Under what conditions would you break it instead? Name one.

D3. The opponent's newest game was a 31–3 blowout in which the defense played backups for the whole fourth quarter. How much weight do you give it, and which snaps do you throw out? Defend your choice.

D4. Your quarterback loves numbers and asks for the full third-down table. Your quarterbacks coach says "Show him clips, not percentages." Who's right? Is there a version where both are?

D5. Your Week 6 report lists five rare calls (each under 5 percent of the sample): Cover 0 on third-and-long, a corner blitz from the boundary, a three-man rush with eight in coverage, a fake mug where both linebackers drop, and a goal-line seven-man pressure. You have practice time to rep answers to two of them. Which two, and what's your rule for choosing? (Think about how badly each would beat you if you had no answer, not just how rare it is.)

D6. A defense has stayed two-high on third-and-long against your 2x2 sets 22 straight times since its bye. It's the fourth quarter of a playoff game, third-and-9 at your own 38, down 3. Write the row the way the post-season version of the page would, and name the safeguard you'd build into the call.


Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

M1 (with Chapter 7). The threshold idea in Chapter 7 is "the defense tells you where to go." Show how each of the first three rows of the Week 6 page is an application of it: what does each structure leave open?

M2 (with Chapter 13). Teo's "first-step test" is described in Chapter 13 as an RPO tool. Explain how it became the scouting tool that produced the Ames tell, and why the end-zone view is required.

M3 (with Chapter 22). Row 6 counted the mug: both backers came on 6 of 10, one dropped on 4. The protection rule was "six-man, back on the Mike." Using Chapter 22's protection arithmetic, explain what happens to that rule when an end walks out late and the back has to move to his side. What scouting fact would have warned you?

M4 (with Chapter 4). Chapter 4's Monday-night meeting found the zero in the Twelve RPO column. Write the self-scout row for it in this chapter's format (tendency, count, threshold, keep/break/accept) and explain why "accept" was the wrong label for it.

M5 (with Chapter 16). Teo's Portland chart showed Kiel squatting on 17 of 21 hitch–corner pairs. Use that count to explain how a scouting tendency becomes the read for a specific concept, and what the Pioneers' halftime fix ("Marchetti fixes Kiel") did to the count.

M6 (with Chapter 3). The scissors tell (every scissors from a reduced split) was a reverse tell. Explain why Marisol's original self-scout missed it, and design the extra sort that would have caught it.


Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐

E1. Chart a defense. Pick one NFL defense and one full televised game. For every third down, tag: down and distance, field zone, the offense's formation (2x2, 3x1, empty), shell before the snap, shell after (write "?" if the broadcast cuts away), and number of rushers. Then write a five-row "by situation" page with counts and denominators. What fraction of your coverage tags are question marks? What does that tell you about the broadcast copy?

E2. Follow a tendency forward. Using the page you wrote in E1, predict three things the same defense will do the following week. Chart the next game and grade your predictions. Which held? Which broke? Were the broken ones foundations or adjustable rows (the distinction in 23.9)?

E3. Self-scout a team you love. Using public play-by-play data (for example, the nflverse community's play-by-play files) or your own charting, build a four-game self-scout for one offense: personnel by play family and first play of each drive. Find one zero and one tendency above 70 percent on ten or more snaps. Write the keep/break/accept decision for each as if you were that team's coordinator.

What to look for in Part E. Use the sideline (All-22) angle when your source offers one; it's the only reliable way to tag the shell after the snap. Tag the hash on every snap, because field/boundary tendencies are often the strongest a defense has. Don't round: write "6 of 9," not "two-thirds." When you find something that clears 70 percent on ten or more snaps, go back and watch every exception before you write it down, and note what the exceptions have in common: the score, the previous snap, the offense's motion, a substitution. If you're charting a defense whose coordinator changed during the season, start your sample at the change and say so at the top of the page. And when you finish, write one honest sentence about what your sample can't tell you. Every good scouting report has that sentence somewhere, even if only the coaches ever read it.