Chapter 2 Exercises — The Evolution of Offense

Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall and explanation · ⭐⭐ recognition and application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis, judgment, and design · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension, research, and film study

All Outlaws, Sentinels, Stallions, Pioneers, Forge, and Ospreys people, games, and numbers are fictional. Real coaches, teams, and games appear only as widely documented history; where a date or detail is uncertain, the exercise says "approximately" or asks you to describe the tradition rather than a precise fact. Selected answers are in Appendix J.


Part A — Conceptual ⭐

A1. This chapter asks three questions of every offensive era. Write them from memory, then apply them in one sentence each to the T formation with man-in-motion.

A2. Define the three "multipliers" of the offense's structural advantage (conflict, sequence, illusion). For each, name one system from the chapter that relied on it most heavily, and say why.

A3. Explain in plain English why the single wing's unbalanced line was an arithmetic answer to early defenses. Use the words "point of attack" and "blockers."

A4. Paul Brown is in this chapter even though he isn't known for a signature formation. What did he contribute to offensive football, and why does a modern quality-control coach like Teo Arriaga owe him his job?

A5. What is the difference between a numbered route system (Coryell tradition) and a concept-named system (Erhardt-Perkins tradition)? Give one advantage of each.

A6. In one paragraph, explain the West Coast idea of "the short pass as a run." Why does it make sense against a defense that plays deep and has a strong pass rush?

A7. What does it mean to say "the rulebook is a third party in the arms race"? Give two examples from the chapter of rule changes or rule differences that shaped offenses.

A8. Why did the read option fade as a base NFL offense after 2012 but survive as a tag?

A9. In the Pistol, where are the quarterback and the running back, and what problem with the traditional shotgun backfield did it solve?

A10. Lyle says "nothing in offensive football ever fully dies; it waits for the defense to forget how to stop it." Give two examples from the chapter of an idea that disappeared from the NFL and returned in a new form.


Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐

B1. Identify the era. A pre-snap picture: seven men on the line, with only one lineman to the left of the center and three to the right; an end on each side; a back just outside and behind the right end; three more backs behind the line, the deepest about five yards behind the center. The snap goes directly to the deepest back. Name the formation, the side of its strength, and the play it was most famous for.

B2. Identify the concept and the conflict defender.

POST-SNAP (right side only)

                                  F
                                         C
                                         ^ bails deep
                       M               v--+
                                          |  curl at 12
                                    ($)   |
                                          |
             O    O    O    O    O        Z
                       Q
                            R---------------------> flat

📊 Diagram (described): The flanker (Z) on the right runs 12 yards and turns back inside. The running back runs to the right flat near the line. The cornerback over the flanker bails deep, the free safety is in the deep middle, the Mike linebacker drops to the middle, and the strong safety stands between the curl and the flat.

B3. A described clip: the offense lines up with one back deep behind the quarterback, who is under center, and a tight end attached on the right. A second tight end-type player stands just off the line behind the left tackle. At the snap, the center, right guard, right tackle, and tight end all block to their left. The left guard and left tackle pull to the right. The back takes one step left, then goes right. Name the play, the coach and team most associated with it, and the illusion it creates.

B4. A described clip: four wide receivers, one back, no tight end. The defense shows two deep safeties. At the snap, the right slot runs vertically to about 11 yards, then bends inside between the two safeties. On the next play, the defense shows one deep safety in the middle, and the same slot stays straight up the seam. What system does this come from, what is the slot doing, and what happens if the quarterback and the slot read the coverage differently?

B5. On All-22 film of a modern NFL game, you see: (1) a receiver in jet motion crossing the formation just before the snap, (2) an outside-zone run to the side the motion came from, (3) on the next snap, the same motion and the same backfield action, but the quarterback keeps the ball and rolls away from the run with a tight end crossing the field. Assign each element to its branch of the family tree from the chapter.

B6. Look at this pre-snap picture and name the two branches of the family tree it combines.

PRE-SNAP

            F                                       $
   C         *         W         M                            C
                     E       T    T        E
   X         H        O    O    O    O    O    Y              Z
                               R   Q

📊 Diagram (described): The offense has one back and one tight end, in the shotgun, with two receivers on each side (a split end and slot on the left; an attached tight end and flanker on the right). The running back is beside the quarterback. The defense shows two deep safeties, a nickel over the left slot, two linebackers, and a four-man front.

B7. Describe what you would expect a T-formation team of the 1940s to learn from sending a halfback in motion to the right if (a) a linebacker ran with him, and (b) the defense simply widened its secondary a step. What modern Outlaws call depends on the same distinction?

B8. A described clip from an old film reel: pro set, two backs side by side behind a quarterback under center, tight end on the right. At the snap both guards pull to the right. The fullback blocks the defensive end; when the end fights outside, the fullback drives him outside, and the halfback cuts up inside the block. On the next run of the same play, the end squeezes inside, the fullback seals him, and the halfback bounces outside. (a) Name the play and the coach most associated with it. (b) Explain why the hole was in a different place on the two runs. (c) Which Outlaws run scheme carries the same idea, and what is Ruffin reading on it?

Short answer

(a) The power sweep, associated with Vince Lombardi's Green Bay Packers. (b) The blockers used option blocking: they blocked each defender in the direction he chose to go, and the back read the blocks. The defense decided where the hole was; the back found it ("run to daylight"). (c) Inside zone (and outside zone). On inside zone, Ruffin reads the first defender past the center on the play side and hits it front side, cuts it back, or bends it back depending on that defender's reaction.

B9. A film-room reader charts one quarter of an NFL offense and records: 14 snaps; 9 from the shotgun or Pistol, 5 under center; motion on 8 snaps; 3 snaps where the quarterback clearly read an unblocked defender; all 5 under-center snaps were either outside zone or play-action/boot off outside zone. Based on only this chart, which two branches of the family tree most likely dominate this offense? What is one caution about drawing conclusions from 14 snaps?

Short answer

The under-center outside zone with play-action and boot points to the Shanahan / Alex Gibbs branch; the shotgun snaps with unblocked reads point to the option / spread / RPO branch. Motion on more than half the snaps fits the modern hybrid. Caution: 14 snaps from one quarter is a tiny sample, heavily shaped by the game situation (score, field position, down and distance), so treat it as a hypothesis to check over several full games, not a conclusion.


Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

C1. Draw it up (⭐⭐). Draw the single-wing off-tackle power to the right against a six-man front: show the double-team, the kick-out, the pulling guard, the lead back, and the tailback's path. Then redraw the play in a modern form using Austin's 12 personnel with Sione Fale (#44) in the backfield. Which modern run family is the closest descendant?

Short answer

The closest modern descendant is a gap scheme such as power (a pulling guard leading through the hole, a kick-out on the end man, down blocks and double-teams at the point of attack). In Austin's version, Harlan and the right tackle double-team the play-side defensive tackle, Fale kicks out the end, Pete Lorusso (#64) or Kendrick Moss (#67) pulls and leads up on the linebacker, and Ruffin follows. Chapter 11 teaches power and counter in full.

C2. Make the call (⭐⭐⭐). Week 8 vs. the Birmingham Forge (fictional), second quarter, 1st-and-10 at the Austin 35, Forge leading 10–7. DC Dwight Seldon has played Cover 1 or Cover 0 on 6 of the first 8 snaps, with press corners. Using the chapter's lineage, identify which historical answers fit a man-press, blitz-heavy defense (consider the T's motion, the West Coast's timing, the run-and-shoot's option routes, and the RPO). Choose one call in Outlaws language and justify it in four sentences.

Short answer

Several defensible answers. A strong one: motion to confirm man (T-formation lineage), then a man-beater with timing (West Coast lineage), such as "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Zoom, Mesh" (the Air Raid's mesh as a man-beater), because crossing routes are hard for press-man defenders to trail and the motion tells Vance whether the coverage is really man before he commits. If the motion shows zone instead, Vance can use a "Both" call. An option route by Powers against a nickel in man (run-and-shoot lineage) is also good. Avoid long-developing play-action against a blitz-heavy team unless the protection is built for it.

C3. Draw it up (⭐⭐). Draw Austin's "Inside Slant" pre-snap and post-snap from Gun Doubles Right against the Sentinels' Home look. Label the read defender and both of Vance's answers. Then add one label to each part of the drawing naming the historical branch it comes from (at least five labels).

C4. Make the call (⭐⭐⭐). Week 10 at Portland (fictional), first quarter, 2nd-and-8 at the Austin 27, 0–0. The Pioneers' DC, Leon Marchetti, plays a disciplined Cover 2 with a squatting corner on each side. Choose a concept from the West Coast branch and draw it against Cover 2. Name the conflict defender and the throw you expect.

Short answer

A curl-flat or a hi-lo of the flat defender works well: in Cover 2 the corner squats on the flat, so the curl (or a hitch/corner combination, the concept Austin calls Smash) puts him in conflict. The expected throw against a disciplined squat corner is the route behind him (the curl, or on Smash the corner route under the half-field safety). Chapter 16 develops Smash against Cover 2 at Portland.

C5. Make the call (⭐⭐⭐). You're a high-school offensive coordinator. Your quarterback is the fastest player on the team, your line averages about 210 pounds, and the best team in your league plays a 4-4 defense with eight defenders near the line every snap. Pick two branches of the family tree that fit your situation. For each, describe one play and the defender it reads or attacks.

C6. Draw it up (⭐⭐⭐). Draw a bootleg off outside zone from 12 personnel against Cover 3. Show the line's run action, the quarterback's fake and boot, and three receivers at three depths on the boot side. Name the defender in conflict and describe the quarterback's progression.

Short answer

On the boot side against Cover 3, the cornerback bails to his deep third, the curl/flat defender (often the weak-side linebacker or a rotated safety) is the conflict defender, and the backside linebacker must first respect the run. Put the backside tight end or fullback in the flat (3 to 5 yards), the play-side tight end on a crossing route at 10 to 12 yards back toward the boot, and the boot-side receiver on a deep clear-out. The quarterback reads flat → crosser → deep: if the curl/flat defender jumps the flat, throw the crosser behind him; if he sinks under the crosser, throw the flat; the clear-out is an "alert" if the corner squats. If an unblocked edge defender doesn't bite on the fake, the quarterback throws the flat quickly or throws it away.

C7. Make the call (⭐⭐⭐). Wild-card round at Oklahoma City (fictional), fourth quarter, 3rd-and-2 at the Ospreys' 34, Austin leading 27–24, 6:40 left. The Ospreys' DC, Terrence Vail, plays aggressive press-man corners and loves simulated pressures (showing six at the line, then rushing four and dropping two into short zones). The Ospreys have stopped two of Austin's three short-yardage runs this game. You have 11 personnel on the field and one timeout. Choose a call from two different branches of the family tree, then pick one and defend it against the strongest objection a head coach like Wade Harmon would raise.

Short answer

Two strong families. West Coast / quick game: a quick timing concept against press (for example, a slant-flat or a stick concept), thrown on rhythm before a simulated pressure can matter; Wade's objection is that dropped linemen can sit in the short windows, so the concept must have a route behind those droppers. Option / RPO: a zone run with a quick-throw tag, so the quarterback can throw if the box is overloaded and run if it isn't; Wade's objection is that press-man corners take away quick perimeter throws, so the tag should be a route that beats man (a slant from a reduced split). Either is defensible if the reasoning matches the defense. What isn't defensible is a slow, long-developing shot that ignores the clock and the field-goal range you're already in.


Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐

D1. Lyle says Austin is "a motion team, not a tempo team." Using the chapter's discussion of the T formation and the K-Gun, explain why motion and tempo pull against each other. Then describe one situation in which Lyle would choose tempo anyway, and what he'd give up.

D2. The read option made headlines in 2012 and then faded as a base offense. Your quarterback is a gifted runner but your team's season depends on his health. Write a short policy (four to six sentences) for how many designed quarterback runs you'll call per game and in what situations. Use the chapter's player-safety guidance and the RPO alternative.

D3. Curtis Bale's offense borrowed plays from three eras without asking what each one solved. List three questions you would ask before adding any "cool" concept to your playbook, and apply them to a hypothetical decision to add a full run-and-shoot package to the Outlaws.

D4. Concept naming (Erhardt-Perkins) and numbered route calls (Coryell) each have costs. You're installing a new offense with a young roster and only six weeks of preseason practice. Which system do you choose, and why? What would make you choose the other?

D5. The modern two-high defense with post-snap rotation disguises its coverage after the offense reads it. Which branches of the family tree become less valuable against it, and which become more valuable? Justify each with a mechanism, not a slogan.

D6. The 2019 Ravens built a record-setting run game around a quarterback who was a true runner. Your quarterback is a good athlete but not an elite runner, and your backup is a pocket passer with a very different skill set. How much of the "quarterback as the plus-one" branch should you build into your base offense? Consider (a) what happens to the offense if the starter is hurt, (b) what the defense must do differently if the quarterback is a credible but occasional runner, and (c) which parts of the option tradition still work when the "option" is a throw instead of a keep.


Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

M1 (with Chapter 1). In Chapter 1 you wrote an Offensive Philosophy Statement. Take Lyle's thesis, "Motion for information, the run for credibility, the pass for the kill," and trace each phrase to at least one branch of the family tree in this chapter. Which phrase has the oldest roots?

M2 (with Chapter 1). Chapter 1 introduced the hierarchy philosophy → system → playbook → game plan → call sheet → call. At which level of that hierarchy did each of these contribute most: Paul Brown, Bill Walsh's scripting, Erhardt-Perkins naming, and the Air Raid's "few plays, many reps"? Explain each in one sentence.

M3 (with Chapter 1). Chapter 1 argued that a thesis must fit your quarterback and your line, not your ego. Pick two historical systems from this chapter that were built around a specific quarterback or line limitation (for example, the West Coast's origin story, or high-school option football) and explain how the system fit the personnel.

M4 (looking ahead to Chapters 3 and 12). The single wing and the option both rely on arithmetic at the point of attack. Before reading Chapter 12, write your own definition of the "plus-one" and show the count for Austin's zone read against a six-man box. Keep your answer; you'll check it against Chapter 12.

M5 (with Chapter 1, looking ahead to Chapter 19). In Game 1, Austin's tying drive ended with four plays from one look: inside zone, inside zone, play-action post, inside zone. Using Chapter 1's idea that every play exists to set up or constrain another, explain which two eras in this chapter that sequence borrows from most directly, and which multiplier (conflict, sequence, illusion) each of the four plays serves.

M6 (with Chapter 1). Chapter 1 asked what your offense will never do. Look at the chapter's list of eras and their defensive counters. Pick one historical system whose weaknesses make it a poor fit for your offense, and write the "never" sentence it implies (for example, "We will never run a four-wide base set without a run game that punishes a light box"). Then name the era whose counter convinced you.


Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐

E1. Lineage charting. Watch one full game of an NFL offense you follow (the All-22 or end-zone angle if you can get it). For every offensive snap, record: under center or shotgun/Pistol; motion (none, before the snap, at the snap); whether the quarterback reads an unblocked defender (zone read or RPO); play-action or not; and the formation's personnel. Then assign each snap to one or more branches of the family tree. Produce a one-page summary: which three branches dominate this offense, and what defense would trouble it most? Note your sample size honestly, since one game is a small sample.

E2. The defense's counter. Choose one era from the chapter (for example, the West Coast offense or the read option). Using published histories (see the further-reading list), describe how defenses answered it. Write 500 words structured as the chapter does: the defensive problem the offense created, the defense's counter, and what offensive answer that counter made possible next. Cite only sources you have actually read, and hedge anything you can't confirm.

E3. A high-school or college lineage. Watch a high-school or small-college game in your area (or a broadcast). Identify which traditions from §2.9 (option, spread, Pistol, Air Raid, Wing-T) appear, and explain how the rules and conditions of that level (hash marks, ineligible-downfield distance, practice time, quarterback durability) make those traditions more or less attractive than in the NFL.