Grading Rubrics
These rubrics grade the work that matters most in this course: the Playbook Project, the Chapter 39 capstone, film grading, chalk talks, the simulations, and participation. They share one principle, the book's own: grade the reasoning, not the call. The book never claims one concept, one protection, or one system is universally right. A learner who chooses levels where you'd have chosen smash, and defends the choice with the shell, the leverage, the down, and the opponent's tendency, has done the job. A learner who copies Austin's call without being able to say which defender it stresses hasn't.
Level choice. Every learner declares a level at the start: high school, college, pro, or film-room. The level changes what a deliverable looks like, never the standard it's held to. A high school RPO Menu is built under that learner's state code; a pro RPO Menu under the NFL's one-yard ineligible-downfield rule; a film-room RPO Menu is a viewing guide (how to find the conflict defender on film and what his choice proves). Read each deliverable against its declared level.
How the rubrics map to the syllabi.
| Rubric | 15-week university | HS staff development | Analyst and film study | Self-paced |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 — Project Checkpoints | Six milestones (35% with Rubric 2) | Informal staff standard | Six film-room deliverables | Each stage checkpoint |
| 2 — Capstone | Week 15 | Optional, on the staff's own opponent | Not used | Stage 8 |
| 3 — Film grading | Labs, Lab 8, final practical | Monday film grading | Labs and final practical (central) | Stage 8 |
| 4 — Chalk talk | Two talks | Session board work | Optional | Recorded talk at each stage |
| 5 — Simulations | Say-back, game-plan meeting, 40 seconds, halftime | Say-back and halftime | Booth and scorer roles | Self-run 40 seconds and halftime |
| 6 — Participation | 5% | Not used | 10% | Not used |
Rubric 1 — Project Checkpoint rubric (The Playbook Project: Build Your Offense)
How the project is graded
Learners produce one deliverable per chapter, forty in all. In the 15-week course they are graded at six milestones plus the capstone; individual deliverables inside a milestone are marked complete or revise, and the milestone as a whole is scored on the five criteria below. Late milestones cascade (a learner without a Nomenclature System can't build a wristband), so be strict on the milestone date and generous on revisions.
The scale
The scale borrows the book's capstone language from Chapter 39 §39.7.
| Score | Label | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| 4 | Ready to call | A coach at the declared level could install or use it this week |
| 3 | Needs a Tuesday | Sound; one gap that a single working session would close |
| 2 | Needs a spring | The idea is there; the rules, reads, or answers aren't |
| 1 | Not yet | Missing, copied without understanding, or wrong at its core |
General criteria (use for every milestone; 20 points)
| Criterion | 4 — Ready to call | 2 — Needs a spring |
|---|---|---|
| A. Accuracy and notation | Every diagram in the book's notation, offense at the bottom moving up, pre- and post-snap, eleven on each side, receivers numbered; every diagram has its plain-language description | Diagrams missing a side, a count, or a post-snap picture; terms used loosely |
| B. Fit | Every piece traces to the learner's Chapter 1 philosophy, personnel assumptions, and level | Pieces borrowed because they're famous; contradicts the philosophy page |
| C. Defender-centered reasoning | Names the defender each play stresses, his job(s), and where the ball goes for each choice he makes | Describes plays by where the ball goes, not by whom it beats |
| D. Answers and branches | Each concept states what it "beats" and what it "dies against," and carries the answer to the defense's answer | One answer per problem; "we'll run it anyway" |
| E. Honesty and safety | Numbers have counts, samples, and "since" dates; league-wide claims hedged; rules stated by level with "check your current code"; contact levels and quarterback-carry budgets present wherever relevant | Percentages without denominators; a low block, rub, or quarterback run with no legality, contact level, or budget |
Safety override. Any deliverable that teaches a cut, chop, or crack block, a quarterback run, or a contact drill without its legality by level, its contact level (walk, on air, thud, control, live), or a quarterback-carry budget is marked revise regardless of its score.
Milestone notes by part
Part I — Offensive Foundations (Deliverables 1–8). The Philosophy Statement has a thesis that says how the offense creates advantages, 3–5 checkable non-negotiables, personnel assumptions, and a "never" list; slogans ("run the ball, stop the run") score 2. The Lineage Map names, for each borrowed idea, the defense it beat and the defense that later beat it. The Formation Family has no covered tight end, a written on/off-the-line rule for every position, and at least one run and one pass per formation. The Personnel Packages & Role Cards include a "tell risk" line on every card. The OL Rules Sheet defines covered and uncovered and names the Mike-point owner. The Route Tree gives depths and landmarks as numbers, not "about six." The Defensive Recognition Card reads safeties first, then the box, then the front, and has separate pre- and post-snap steps. The Nomenclature System & Wristband v1 has one word for one meaning, a call that fits ten words or goes on the band, and a 24-call band organized by situation.
Part II — The Run Game (Deliverables 9–14). The Inside Zone Install Sheet has rules against even, odd, and bear fronts, the back's read, and three tags, with the box-count rule stated. The Outside Zone Install Sheet ties the run to its boot and states who pulls on the boot. The Gap Scheme Sheet names who pulls, who kicks, and who wraps, and a key-breaker from the same look. The Option Package names the read defender and why, and carries a quarterback-carry budget. The RPO Menu names the conflict defender, his run job and his pass job, the throw window, the quarterback's rule ("key plus window"), and the ineligible-downfield distance for the learner's level. The Short-Yardage & Goal-Line Package pairs plays that share a picture and keeps leak routes legal.
Part III — The Passing Game (Deliverables 15–22). The Concept Framework teaches reads as defenders, not receivers. The Core Coverage-Beater Set states the read for smash, flood, and levels against Cover 2, 3, and 4, including what each does against the coverage it wasn't built for. The Man-Beater Package teaches the rub as spacing with landmarks, never as a block. The Shot Package has its "when we call it" rule and protection. The Play-Action Package marries each pass to a base run from the identical look and names the defender whose key the fake is aimed at. The Screen Package gives each screen its "call it when" trigger. The Quick Game has hot rules and leverage reads. The Protection Plan has an answer for one more rusher than every protection blocks, hots on both sides, and sight adjusts named. Check that every play-action protection names who takes the run's unblocked defender.
Part IV — Game Planning and Play Calling (Deliverables 23–28). The Scouting Template and Sentinels Report has two shell columns, counts with denominators, a "?" policy, and "since" dates, and labels each tendency tell, lean, or story. Game Plan v1 and the 15-Play Script: every slot asks a question with "if A / if B"; the contingency table has no blank rows. Call Sheet v1 and Pregame Checklist: organized by situation, two calls ready per box. The Situational Package re-landmarks conversion routes ("sticks plus one") and carries a "4th: P/K/G" box. The Motion & Shift Menu gives every motion a job and never treats a slide as proof of zone. The Metrics Dashboard and Fourth-Down / Two-Point Chart defines every metric (success rate by the 40/60/100 rule or EPA, stated), shows sample sizes, and treats the chart as information the head coach weighs.
Part V — Modern Innovations (Deliverables 29–33). Each borrow list says what is adopted, adapted, or rejected and why it fits the philosophy page. The QB-Run Package carries a carry budget, a hits column, and a slide plan. The Tempo Package has triggers, vetoes, and a four-minute plan with kneel math. The Gadget Package has a trigger condition held to at least the tell line, an in-game confirmation, and a practice plan, with the quarterback never blocking.
Part VI — Coaching and Leadership (Deliverables 34–37). The Installation Calendar labels every period with a contact level, keeps quarterbacks at the bottom of the ladder, and puts no new protection in after Friday. The QB Development Plan separates decision, delivery, and clock in grading. The In-Game Adjustment Protocol limits halftime to three changes in existing words and includes "Their next move." The Coordinator Interview Binder opens every tab with the rule that generates its plays.
Part VII — Synthesis (Deliverable 38). The System Map shows every constraint play with its parent and the defender who makes the pair work, and closes at least one empty arrow (the book's example is the middle-read tag). Deliverables 39 and 40 have their own rubrics.
Rubric 2 — Capstone rubric (Chapter 39: The Complete Playbook + Sentinels Game Plan)
The capstone assembles a 60–70 play core offense and a complete game plan against the Sacramento Sentinels from Appendix G. Grade it in two parts: the build (40 points, using the book's own rubric) and the defense of the build in a staff-meeting presentation (20 points). Grade the build before you look at any simulated result.
Part A — The build (40 points): the book's rubric from §39.7
Score each criterion 1–4 (4 = ready to call, 3 = needs a Tuesday, 2 = needs a spring, 1 = not yet).
| # | Criterion | 4: ready to call | 2: needs a spring |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Philosophy fit | Every non-negotiable is checkable and visible in the core and the plan | Philosophy is a mood; plays contradict it |
| 2 | Language | One name per thing; defaults written; every call fits ten words or the band | Two names for one route; tags eat concepts |
| 3 | Pictures | Each base picture carries several plays that read different defenders | Most plays have their own formation |
| 4 | Core completeness | Run, option/RPO, quick, dropback, man-beater, shot, PA, screen, situational, and gadget families present at the level's size | A family missing with no written reason |
| 5 | Zero matrix | No unwritten zeros by personnel | A personnel group that predicts its play family |
| 6 | Protection | Every call answers one more rusher than it blocks; hots and sight adjusts named | "We'll block it" |
| 7 | Report → plan traceability | Every box traces to a counted row with a "since" date | Boxes built from favorites |
| 8 | Script and series | Every script slot asks a question with if A / if B; series cards have triggers | A script built to score |
| 9 | Contingencies | No blank rows; the strongest streak has a branch and practice reps | A tendency with no branch |
| 10 | Week and game day | Rep budget fits the plan; result column, drive log, and halftime sheet ready | A plan that can't be repped |
The five red flags (from §39.7) send the capstone back for revision regardless of total: a blank contingency row on the opponent's strongest tendency; a third-down box with one answer to its most likely look; a protection with no answer for one more rusher; a call that can't be said in ten words and isn't on the band; a play with no parent picture that the plan calls more than once. Add a sixth for this course: a quarterback run, low block, or contact period with no legality, contact level, or carry budget.
Part B — The staff-meeting defense (20 points)
Modeled on Teo's presentation of his third-down and red-zone package in §39.8. Each learner presents one package for about twelve minutes and is questioned by two classmates playing Wade Harmon ("how would I defend that?") and Rome Pettaway (the quarterback's read and the margin dissent).
| Criterion | 5 | 3 | 1 |
|---|---|---|---|
| The case | States the problem from the Sentinels report with counts, then the package as the answer | States the package, then finds data to support it | Presents favorite plays |
| The defender | For each call, names the defender stressed and where the ball goes for each choice | Names the coverage but not the defender | Names the receiver |
| The answer to the answer | Has Russ's likely adjustment and a prepared branch, with practice reps | Has the adjustment, no rep plan | "They won't do that" |
| Handling dissent | Takes the strongest objection seriously; accepts, rejects with a reason, or writes it in the margin | Defends every point equally | Treats questions as attacks |
Reading the total (60 points)
| Total | Grade guidance |
|---|---|
| 54–60, no red flags | Install it. Excellent |
| 45–53, no red flags | One more Tuesday. Strong |
| 36–44 | Take it into the spring. Satisfactory with revision |
| Below 36, or any red flag | Return for revision; the problem is usually on the philosophy page or in the contingency table |
Rubric 3 — Film-grading rubric (Chapter 40: the ten-snap self-test and the Film Grading Rubric)
Use this for film-lab charts, Lab 8, the final practical, and Deliverable 40 (the learner's own Film Grading Rubric). It follows Chapter 40: the seven-item pre-snap checklist (§40.2), four things at the snap (§40.3), "why this call, now?" (§40.4), and the honest grade (§40.7).
| Criterion | 4 | 3 | 2 | 1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Checklist order | All seven items, in order, shell before box, on every snap | One item skipped occasionally | Order ignored; box counted before shell | Watches the ball |
| Shell before / after | Two columns every snap; "?" when the angle hid it | Two columns, occasional guess | One column with coverage names | Coverage named from the pre-snap look |
| The read or conflict defender | Named on every snap, with what he did and why it decided the play | Named on most snaps | Named only on obvious snaps | Grades receivers |
| Why this call, now? | Uses the down, field, score and clock, and what the last three snaps bought | Uses the situation, not the sequence | Mentions the situation | Treats each snap in isolation |
| Process vs. result | Process written before the result; uses earned / unlucky / lucky / deserved correctly | Separates them but lets the result color the process grade | Mentions both, merges them | Grades by result |
| Fault by first cause | C / R / X assigned with evidence; the fix written at the level of the cause | Correct mark, thin evidence | Blames the nearest player, with hedging | Blames the nearest player |
| Honesty | Counts, samples, "since" dates; a "can't know from film" sentence on every graded call | Mostly | Percentages without counts | Invented certainty |
Score out of 28. For the Chapter 40 ten-snap self-test itself (30 points: scheme, key, and grade on each snap), use the book's bands: 27+ watching like a coordinator; 21–26 a first-year quality control coach; 15–20 keep charting; below 15, reread §40.2–§40.4.
Deliverable 40 (the learner's own Film Grading Rubric) earns full credit when it is usable by someone else: fixed fields, a definition for each, a success-rate rule written at the top, a process grade and a result grade, and a worked example on at least three snaps.
Rubric 4 — Chalk-talk presentation
Ten minutes at the board, in the format of the chalk-talk and simulation guide §1. 20 points.
| Criterion | 4 | 2 | 0 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pre-snap picture | Eleven on each side; formation legal; receivers numbered; defense named | A count or legality error | Missing a side |
| Post-snap picture | Every assignment drawn; read or conflict defender circled; ball's path for each choice | Assignments partial | One drawing for pre- and post-snap |
| The rule in one sentence | Clear, correct, and says it back without notes; plain-language description given | Correct but long or read from notes | Missing |
| "How would I defend that?" | Names the defense's best answer and the offense's answer to it | Names the answer, no reply | Can't answer |
| Level and safety | States the downfield, motion, or blocking rule for the level, with "check your current code," where relevant | Mentions it when prompted | Teaches an illegal technique as legal |
Rubric 5 — Simulations
From the chalk-talk and simulation guide. Each simulation is graded on its own 12-point scale.
5a — The eleven-man say-back
One point per correct assignment (eleven), plus one for naming the read defender or the protection's free man. 10–12 pass; 7–9 redo next session; below 7, back to Chapter 8 §8.3–§8.4. A learner who puts a one-side concept on the wrong side, or ignores a tag, loses the points for every affected player.
5b — The mock game-plan meeting
| Criterion (3 points each) | Full credit |
|---|---|
| Proposal | One page, in before the meeting, every claim with a count |
| Disagreement | Uses the four-step process; at least one margin dissent written (Rome's role must write one) |
| Branches | The learner's boxes all carry "if A / if B"; no blank contingency rows |
| Listening | Changes or defends a position in response to a specific objection |
5c — The 40-second play-calling simulation
| Criterion (3 points each) | Full credit |
|---|---|
| Clock | Every call into the helmet by :20; no call after :34 except after a turnover or injury |
| Language | Every call ten words or a band number; no sound-alike collisions |
| Reasons | One-sentence reason logged before every result; the reason names a defender or a situation |
| Grading | Debrief separates process from result and identifies one lucky and one unlucky call honestly |
Points scored in the simulation are not graded. A learner who scores 21 with no logged reasons earns less than one who scores 6 with a clean log.
5d — The halftime-adjustment simulation
| Criterion (3 points each) | Full credit |
|---|---|
| Triage | Three changes or fewer, each run through all five filter questions |
| Existing words | No new protection, formation, or word; every change built from things already repped |
| Cost and counter | Each change has its cost written and an answer to "What will they do to it?" |
| Their next move and Keep | Predicts at least one of the opponent's likely changes and names what is deliberately kept |
Rubric 6 — Participation (discussion and film lab)
Grade participation on evidence, not volume. 10 points per grading period.
| Criterion | Strong (full credit) | Developing | Weak |
|---|---|---|---|
| Football language | Uses terms as the book defines them; names defenders, levels, and counts | Mostly accurate | Vague ("he got beat") |
| Reasoning | Supports claims with the board, the film, or a number with its sample | Supports some claims | Opinion only |
| Listening | Builds on or challenges a specific classmate's point | Responds generally | Talks past others |
| Film-lab argument | Commits to a mark before the discussion; changes it when shown evidence | Commits but won't change, or changes without a reason | Waits to hear the answer |
| Respect for the other side | Treats defensive coaches and defensive answers as smart | Occasionally dismissive | Sneers at defenses |
The last row is deliberate. The book's narrator calls Russ Kimbrough the smartest coach he faces, and the course should sound the same way.
Quick formative check — any single deliverable
When you have five minutes and a stack of drafts, ask three questions of each one:
- Which defender does this beat, and what does it do when he plays it right? If the deliverable can't answer, it's a 2.
- Can a rookie say it back in July? If the language needs the author to explain it, it's a 2.
- What does it assume that might stop being true, and where is the branch? If there's no branch, it's a 2, and on a third-down or contingency page, it's a revise.
Write one sentence of feedback per question. That's usually enough to move a deliverable from "needs a spring" to "needs a Tuesday."