Syllabus — Seeing Offense: Film Recognition, Charting, and Honest Numbers
A course for analysts, media, and fantasy and betting students
Who this is for. Students in sports-analytics, journalism, broadcasting, or sport-management programs; team and media analysts in training; and the fantasy and betting crowd who want scheme-level context instead of box-score narratives. Most will never call a play. All of them will spend careers explaining plays to people who weren't watching closely, and the most common failure in that work is the same: the camera follows the ball, the commentator follows the camera, and nobody says which defender the play was built to beat or what the caller knew when he called it.
What it produces. Students learn to run the Chapter 40 checklist at broadcast speed, find the conflict or read defender on any snap, chart an offense on twelve fields, build a tendency report with honest sample sizes, and write a "why this call, now?" breakdown that grades process and result separately. The Playbook Project runs at film-room level: every deliverable becomes a viewing, charting, or grading product rather than an install.
Format. Twelve weeks, one 150-minute meeting a week (a 60-minute concept block and a 90-minute film block). The film block uses the eight labs in the film-lab guide, plus four memo-workshop weeks.
Prerequisites. Basic football knowledge and comfort with percentages. No coding is required or taught; the book contains none. Students who already work with play-by-play data may use it in their memos, under the writing standards below.
Text. NFL Offensive Coordination (free, CC-BY-SA-4.0), following the front matter's Path 3 (the analyst and media reader) with additions.
Learning outcomes
By the end of the course a student will be able to:
- Run the seven-item pre-snap checklist (situation, personnel, formation and strength, shell, box, leverage, motion and reaction) on a broadcast copy and say what the structure cannot defend.
- Identify the play family from the line's first step, and find the read or conflict defender within the first two seconds after the snap.
- Distinguish shell from coverage in every chart, with separate before and after columns.
- Do the arithmetic the book uses: box counts, blockers vs. defenders, the option "+1," rushers vs. protectors, success rate by down, and expected-points intuition, always in plain English.
- Chart a game on twelve fields, turn charts into tendencies with counts, sample sizes, and "since" dates, and say how much each number can be trusted.
- Write a "why this call, now?" breakdown that grades the decision before revealing the result, and assign fault by first cause (call, rule, or execution).
- State the limits of outside analysis: what the broadcast hides, what only the staff knows, and when a number is a lean rather than a fact.
Assessment
| Component | Weight |
|---|---|
| Film-lab charts (Labs 1–8) | 25% |
| Four analyst memos (800–1,200 words each) | 30% |
| Playbook Project at film-room level (six selected deliverables, see below) | 15% |
| Final practical: chart and grade one full drive cold, plus the Chapter 40 ten-snap self-test | 20% |
| Participation (film-room argument, peer review of memos) | 10% |
Rubric 3 (film grading) and Rubric 6 (participation) in rubrics apply directly. The midterm and final can be used as recognition-heavy subsets (each has a subsetting note), and the assessment bank supplies weekly check-ins.
Film-room Playbook deliverables. Students produce six: the Defensive Recognition Card (Ch 7) as a viewing card; the Concept Framework (Ch 15) as a "what to watch on each concept" sheet; the Scouting Template + Tendency Report (Ch 23) on a real NFL defense from public film, with every number counted and qualified; the Offensive Metrics Dashboard (Ch 28) for one real offense, built from public data with its definitions stated; the System Map (Ch 38) of a real offense as an outsider can see it, with an explicit "can't know" column; and the Film Grading Rubric (Ch 40).
Weekly schedule
Unit 1 — Learning to see (Weeks 1–3)
Week 1 — The one advantage, and how to watch. Ch 1 (§1.1, §1.6), Ch 40 (§40.1–§40.2, read first, out of order), Ch 3 (§3.2, §3.4, §3.5). Film: Lab 1, seeing the whole field. Broadcast and All-22 copies of the same snaps side by side: what does each angle hide?
Week 2 — Personnel and the defense's answer. Ch 4 (§4.1–§4.3, §4.6, §4.8), Ch 7 (whole chapter). Film: Lab 2, shell, box, and leverage. Two shell columns, every snap. "That's a two-high look."
Week 3 — The line decides the family. Ch 5 (§5.3–§5.5, §5.8), Ch 9 (§9.1–§9.3, §9.6), Ch 10 (§10.1, §10.4), Ch 11 (§11.1, §11.6). Film: Lab 3, the first step tells you the family. Memo 1 due: "The run that wasn't the call": pick one explosive run from a recent NFL game, explain which defenders made it explosive and how much of it was design. Model: Chapter 40's grade of the Game 1 45-yard run (Snap 1 of the self-test).
Unit 2 — The read defender (Weeks 4–6)
Week 4 — Option and RPOs. Ch 12 (§12.1–§12.4), Ch 13 (whole chapter; Anchor A). Film: Lab 4, the read defender. Find the unblocked man and decide: bust or design?
Week 5 — Reading a defender in the pass game. Ch 15 (whole chapter), Ch 16 (§16.1–§16.3, §16.5), Ch 17 (§17.1, §17.3–§17.6). Film: Lab 5. Smash, flood, and levels against two-high and single-high; one man-beater cutup. Who was the throw read off?
Week 6 — Deep shots and play-action. Ch 18 (§18.1, §18.4–§18.5, §18.8), Ch 19 (whole chapter; Anchor D). Film: memo workshop: peer review of Memo 2 drafts. Memo 2 due: "Who bit, and why": one play-action explosive from a recent NFL game. Name the defender whose key the fake was aimed at, find the earlier snaps that taught him to bite (if any), and say what you can't know from outside.
Unit 3 — Protection, the quick game, and the numbers (Weeks 7–9)
Week 7 — The ball as a blocker. Ch 21 (§21.1–§21.2, §21.6), Ch 22 (whole chapter), Ch 20 (§20.1, §20.6). Film: Lab 6, protection arithmetic. Count rushers and blockers, name the free man, find the hot. Then grade three sacks: call, rule, or execution?
Week 8 — Scouting and honest numbers. Ch 23 (whole chapter), Ch 28 (whole chapter). Read Appendix H alongside. Film: memo workshop: build a tendency table from four games of one real defense's third downs. Memo 3 due: "The tendency report": a one-page "by situation" page in the Chapter 23 format on a real defense, with counts, denominators, "?" counts, and a "since" date on every row. Graded more on honesty than on insight.
Week 9 — Situations and the clock. Ch 26 (§26.1–§26.3, §26.6–§26.7), Ch 32 (§32.1, §32.3, §32.8–§32.9), Ch 14 (§14.1, §14.8). Film: Lab 7, sequences. Chart a whole drive and answer "why this call, now?" on every snap.
Unit 4 — Calls, systems, and the grade (Weeks 10–12)
Week 10 — The call as a bet. Ch 25 (whole chapter; Anchor C), Ch 24 (§24.6–§24.9), Ch 27 (§27.1, §27.4, §27.7). Film: memo workshop: run the 34-second fence on five fourth-quarter third downs from a recent game. Memo 4 due: "Process before result": grade one high-profile NFL call (a fourth down, a two-minute decision, or a goal-line call) on Marisol's four process questions, written in full before you state the result.
Week 11 — Systems. Ch 29 (§29.1, §29.3–§29.5), Ch 30 (§30.2, §30.8), Ch 31 (§31.1, §31.4), Ch 38 (whole chapter). Film: Lab 8, charting a game and grading it honestly. The twelve-field chart on one offense, three passes through the film.
Week 12 — The limits of watching from outside. Ch 40 (§40.5–§40.10), Ch 33 (§33.1–§33.2, §33.8). Film: the Chapter 40 ten-snap self-test, cold, then argued. Final practical in the exam slot.
Writing standards for memos and reports
These are the standards the book holds itself to, and they are graded.
- Counts before percentages. "11 of 17" before "65%." A percentage without a denominator loses credit.
- Say how much to trust it. Use the book's language: about 70 percent on ten or more snaps is a tell; less than that is a lean; a handful of snaps is a story. Write which one you have.
- Every tendency gets a "since" date. A defense that changed its coordinator or its safety three weeks ago is a different defense. The 29-for-29 streak that ended Austin's season had a "since" date; Russ knew it better than Austin did.
- Two shell columns. Never write a coverage from a pre-snap frame.
- Process first, result second. Write what the caller knew and what the call was trying to do before you write what happened. Use the four process questions and the earned / unlucky / lucky / deserved grid from Chapter 40 §40.7.
- Fault by first cause. Call, rule, or execution, and the evidence for it. "The quarterback threw a pick" is a result, not an analysis.
- Name what you can't know. The call sheet, the protection rule, the injury report, and what was said on the headset are invisible from outside. A good memo has a "can't know" sentence.
- No invented precision about real people. Never attribute a statistic to a real player or team unless it comes from a source you can name and you have checked it. League-wide magnitudes are hedged ("in recent seasons," "most public charting finds"). The book's Outlaws and Sentinels numbers are fictional; use them to practice method, never as evidence about the NFL.
Data and film sources
In recent seasons the NFL's subscription service has offered All-22 and end-zone film; check what is currently offered and on what terms. Public play-by-play data (the nflverse community's datasets and nflfastR) supports expected points and success rate; NFL Next Gen Stats, Pro Football Focus, Sports Info Solutions, and FTN publish charting and tracking-derived measures, each with its own definitions. Teach students to state which source and which definition they used. Success rate in this book is the 40 / 60 / 100 percent rule by down; some sources use EPA above zero instead, and a memo must say which. Appendix H is the book's reference for every definition.
Footage is copyrighted. Use it in class under your institution's guidance, don't redistribute cutups outside the course, and see the film-lab guide §7 on responsible use.