It was a Thursday night in April, a little after ten, and I was carrying two coffees down the hall to the quality control office because that's what I do at ten o'clock. The season had been over for almost three months. The league meetings were...
In This Chapter
- The Hook: The Phone Face-Down on the Desk
- 37.1 The Ladder: What Every Rung Actually Teaches
- 37.2 Two Ladders That Cross: NFL, College, and High School
- 37.3 Twenty-Two Years: My Path, Rung by Rung
- 37.4 The Coaching Tree: Mentorship, Lineage, and "Who You Know"
- 37.5 The Grind: Hours, Money, Family, and the Firing Cycle
- 37.6 The Interview and the Coordinator Interview Binder
- 37.7 The Rooney Rule and Diversity in Coaching
- 37.8 Building a Staff
- 37.9 Fired, and Coming Back
- 37.10 Practical Advice for an Aspiring Coach, at Any Level
- Spaced Review
- Project Checkpoint: Coordinator Interview Binder
- Chapter Summary
- What's Next
Chapter 37 — The Coaching Career: From Graduate Assistant to Offensive Coordinator — The Coaching Tree, the Grind, and the Dream
The Hook: The Phone Face-Down on the Desk
It was a Thursday night in April, a little after ten, and I was carrying two coffees down the hall to the quality control office because that's what I do at ten o'clock. The season had been over for almost three months. The league meetings were behind us. I'd spent most of the spring on the thing I'm calling the middle-read tag, my answer to the interception that ended our year, and Teo Arriaga had spent most of the spring helping me break it.
Teo's phone was face-down on the desk. It buzzed while I watched, and he didn't turn it over. He's twenty-six. Twenty-six-year-olds turn their phones over.
"Coffee," I said, setting it down on top of a stack of cut-up sheets. "You look like you just found a tell nobody else has."
"Coach." He rubbed his eyes. "Can I ask you something that isn't about football?"
"Nothing's not about football. Go."
"A head coach called me tonight. FCS program." He said the name of the school. I'm not going to, because if this goes the way I think it will, that man is going to be Teo's boss, and he deserves to make his own introductions. "Their passing-game coordinator took an NFL job in March. He wants me to come coach the quarterbacks and coordinate the passing game. He wants me on campus next weekend."
I laughed. I always laugh before people finish, and Teo has learned not to take it personally. I wasn't laughing at him. I was laughing because I could see the whole next six weeks of his life laid out like a call sheet, and because seventeen years ago I'd sat in the back booth of my parents' diner in Youngstown, Ohio, on a phone cord stretched as far as it would go from the register, telling a retired shop teacher named Ray Kessler that I was quitting the best high-school job I'd ever have to go be a graduate assistant for almost no money, two states away, at twenty-nine years old.
Ray had said, "Don't embarrass us." Then he'd said, "Fix it by Friday," which is what he said about everything, and hung up. That was his blessing.
"What did you tell him?" I asked.
"That I'd come see the place, and he'd have my answer after our last spring practice." Teo turned the phone over finally, looked at it, and turned it back. "I want you to tell me what to do."
"No."
He waited for the laugh. It didn't come this time.
"I'm not going to tell you what to do," I said, "because the guy who tells you what to do owns the answer when it goes wrong, and you need to own this one. But I'll tell you how I'd think about it. I'll tell you every job I took and why, and the one where I got fired without calling a single play, and what Walt Dupree told me when I took a step down in title to get into this league. And then you're going to build the thing you'd hand that head coach next weekend, and I'm going to grill you on it like Wade grilled me."
"The binder."
"The binder."
He opened a new document on his laptop and typed a title. I could see it from where I was standing: Arriaga — Passing Game. Then he deleted "Passing Game" and typed What I Believe.
That's a better first page than mine was.
This chapter is the conversation we had over the next two weeks, cleaned up and extended for you. It isn't a chapter about schemes, although you'll find a whiteboard in it. It's about the career that sits underneath every scheme in this book: how people actually become offensive coordinators, what each rung of the ladder teaches you, who pulls you up, what it costs, what happens when the floor gives way, and why the profession has had a hard time letting everyone onto the ladder in the first place. All of the Outlaws and everyone around them are, as always, fictional. The ladder is real.
🏃 Fast Track: If you're already coaching, skim 37.1–37.2 (the ladders), read 37.6 (the interview and the binder) and 37.8 (building a staff) closely, and do the Project Checkpoint. That binder is the most practical thing in this chapter.
🔬 Deep Dive: The binder pulls from everything you've built: your philosophy from Chapter 1, your lineage from Chapter 2, your install calendar from Chapter 34, and the game-plan templates in Appendix F. Re-read your own deliverables before you start Section 37.6.
📺 Film Watcher: This January, when a team hires a new offensive coordinator, look up who he worked under and what his last offense did on early downs, in the red zone, and on third-and-long. Then watch his new team's first four games and see how much of the old offense came with him. You'll be watching a coaching tree grow in real time.
37.1 The Ladder: What Every Rung Actually Teaches
Every coaching career is a ladder, and the first thing to understand is that the rungs aren't titles. They're skills. A title is what's printed on the door. The skill is what you can do at 1 a.m. on a Tuesday when the head coach walks in and asks you a question you can't look up.
Here are the rungs on the offensive side, roughly from the bottom up. Titles vary from team to team and school to school, and the order isn't a law, but the skills stack in about this order.
| Rung | What you actually do | What it teaches you | How you get off it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Volunteer / freshman staff (high school) | Run the scout team, drive the van, tape ankles, coach whatever position nobody else wants | That the job is mostly logistics, and that fourteen-year-olds learn by doing, not by listening | Show up every day for a season and coach a group well |
| High-school position coach / coordinator | Coach a room, call plays on Friday night, teach a class during the day | How to teach a scheme to people who didn't choose it, with no time and no film budget | Win, keep good film, and get noticed by a college staff |
| Student assistant / recruiting staff (college) | Answer phones, mail film, set up practice, shadow the coaches | How a big program actually runs, and who decides what | A GA spot, usually through someone who vouches for you |
| Graduate assistant (GA) | Break down film, build scout cards, script practice, coach a position group in practice, take graduate classes | The film room. You learn to see everything because you have to tag everything. | A full-time job, often with a coach you served |
| Quality control coach (QC) / offensive assistant / analyst | Opponent breakdowns, self-scout, cut-ups, the call sheet's guts, wristbands | How a weekly game plan gets built from raw film; where the tendencies are | Promotion to assistant position coach, or a title somewhere else |
| Assistant position coach | Half a room: the young receivers, the backup linemen | How to coach a technique to a pro who's better at it than you were | Taking over a room |
| Position coach | Your own room: the quarterbacks, the line, the receivers | Accountability. Your players' mistakes are your mistakes in the Monday grade. | A coordinator title or a "game-coordinator" title |
| Passing-game / run-game coordinator | Own one half of the game plan; often still coach a room | Building half a plan and defending it in the staff meeting | A coordinator job, usually somewhere else |
| Offensive coordinator (OC) | Own the system, the plan, and (usually) the calls | Living with every call in public | A head job, a better OC job, or the door |
| Head coach | Own everything, including the defense and the media | That the call sheet is now the least of your problems | Winning, mostly |
A few things about that table aren't obvious until you've climbed it.
The bottom rungs teach the most transferable skills. A GA or a QC learns to break down a defense snap by snap, which is the skill every coordinator uses every week for the rest of his life. Teo tags eighteen fields on every opponent snap and watches each game three times, which takes him five to seven hours a game. Nobody admires that work. Every good game plan in this book started there.
The middle rungs teach you to coach people. A QC can be brilliant and still never have stood in front of a room of grown men and told them they were wrong. A position coach does that every day. Rome Pettaway, our quarterbacks coach, played in this league as a backup quarterback for years and has never once raised his voice in the QB room, and he's still the hardest grader in our building. That's a skill you learn by having a room.
The top rungs teach you to live with outcomes you don't control. Wade Harmon owns fourth downs. I own the call. On the Game 1 fourth-and-goal from the Sacramento 3, Marisol Vega's chart said "go, close," I'd have gone, and Wade kicked. We were both making defensible decisions with the same information, and only one of us gets the phone call from the owner if it goes wrong. The higher you go, the more of your week goes to decisions somebody else will judge on a single result.
💡 Coach's point: Don't judge a job by its title. Judge it by the skill you'll be forced to learn there that you can't learn where you are.
The table also hides a structural fact: the ladder is a pyramid. Every NFL team has one offensive coordinator and a handful of offensive assistants. The NCAA has historically capped the number of full-time on-field assistants in the top division, which is a big reason programs grew large off-field analyst staffs; those rules have been changing, so check them. High schools have the most jobs, most of them tied to a teaching position. Most people who start at the bottom never reach the top. That isn't failure. Plenty of the best coaches I know chose a rung and stayed there on purpose.
THE THREE LADDERS (typical offensive path; titles vary by employer)
NFL COLLEGE HIGH SCHOOL
--------------------- --------------------- ----------------
Head coach Head coach Head coach
^ ^ ^
Offensive coordinator Offensive coordinator Offensive
^ ^ coordinator
Pass-game / run-game Co-coordinator, or ^
coordinator position coach + title Position coach
^ ^ (usually also
Position coach Position coach a teacher)
(QB/WR/TE/OL/RB) ^ ^
^ Analyst (off-field) Volunteer /
Assistant position coach ^ freshman staff
^ Graduate assistant (GA)
Quality control (QC) / ^
offensive assistant Student assistant /
^ recruiting staff
Fellowship / intern
<-- the ladders connect sideways at almost every rung -->
📊 Diagram (described): Three vertical ladders stand side by side, labeled NFL, college, and high school, each climbing from the entry rung at the bottom to head coach at the top. The NFL ladder climbs from a fellowship or internship through quality control, assistant position coach, position coach, passing-game or run-game coordinator, and offensive coordinator. The college ladder climbs from student assistant through graduate assistant, off-field analyst, position coach, and co-coordinator to coordinator. The high-school ladder is the shortest: volunteer or freshman staff, position coach who is usually also a teacher, coordinator, and head coach. A line at the bottom notes that coaches move sideways between the ladders at almost every rung.
🔄 Check your understanding: Teo is a QC. Name the one skill the QC rung teaches better than any other rung, and the one skill it can't teach him no matter how long he stays.
Answer
The QC rung teaches film breakdown and game-plan construction from raw film: tagging every snap, finding tendencies, and building the pieces a plan is made from. It can't teach him to coach a room, which means standing in front of players, owning their mistakes, and changing their behavior. That only comes from having players who are yours. Notice that this is exactly what the FCS job offers him.
37.2 Two Ladders That Cross: NFL, College, and High School
The three ladders look alike on paper. They don't feel alike when you're on them.
What's different about college
Recruiting. A college assistant is a salesman for half the year, and his job security depends as much on the players he brings in as on the ones he coaches. As a college receivers coach, I spent more hours recruiting than coaching receivers. The transfer portal and athletes being paid for their name, image, and likeness have changed what recruiting means, and the details move every year, so don't trust anything about them that's more than a season old, including this.
The GA year. The graduate assistant is a college institution with no NFL equivalent. You're a graduate student, enrolled in classes, and you're also a coach. Many programs pay the GA's tuition plus a modest stipend. In practice the stipend is closer to a part-time wage than a salary, and you'll work more hours than anyone in the building except the head coach. In return you get the film room, the practice field, and a head coach who knows your name. It's an apprenticeship that pays you in access.
The hash. College hashes are 40 feet apart, 60 feet in from each sideline; NFL hashes are 18 feet 6 inches apart, 70 feet 9 inches in. A college coordinator lives on the hash, with field and boundary as different worlds. When I came to the NFL, my boundary concepts didn't have a boundary, and it took me a year to unlearn them.
What's different about the NFL
No recruiting, all film. An NFL assistant doesn't sell to eighteen-year-olds. He studies. The volume of film work at the bottom of an NFL staff is enormous, and the QC is the person doing most of it. Teo's Week 6 report on Sacramento covered 243 defensive snaps. He builds a report like that every week, working a week ahead, while also helping Marisol self-scout us.
Short contracts, and a head coach's fate is yours. NFL assistant contracts are commonly short, often two or three years, and a new head coach usually brings his own staff. That's how I got fired without calling a play. We'll come back to it.
The entry door is narrow. Many NFL coaching careers start in a fellowship or an internship, or in a QC job that someone vouched for you to get. The league has formal programs aimed at widening that door. The best known is the Bill Walsh Diversity Coaching Fellowship, which grew out of the minority coaching internship Walsh began with the 49ers in the late 1980s. Section 37.7 covers why that door needed widening.
What's different about high school
You teach. Most high-school coaches are teachers first. The coaching stipend is a supplement, and in many districts it works out to a few dollars an hour once you divide it by the hours you actually put in. Your real job is in a classroom from 7:30 to 3:00, and football happens before and after. When I was in Ohio, I taught social studies, and my first film room was a TV cart in the back of my classroom during my free period.
You coach whoever walks in. No recruiting, no draft. The high-school coordinator's genius is fitting a scheme to the kids he has. My first season I tried to run a four-wide spread with a junior quarterback who could throw twelve yards accurately and not much farther. We lost 14–7 and 21–6, and in the second of those games we gave up six sacks. In Week 5, Ray Kessler made me rebuild around two-tight-end wing Power. We won that week 20–13, and we won five of the last six. Chapter 1 tells that story in full. The lesson was a career lesson as much as a football one: your system serves your players, not your résumé.
The calendar is the school's. You can't practice whenever you want. In many states, offseason contact and summer practice are regulated by the state association, and the rules differ widely. Check your state's.
Crossing between the ladders
The ladders connect, and the best careers often cross them. I went high school → college → NFL. Teo went small college player → high-school assistant (one 6–4 season in El Paso under Rudy Saenz, coaching a quarterback named Adrian Molina) → college GA → NFL QC, and now a college program is calling him back across. Both directions are common. College coaches move to the NFL for the depth of the passing game and the protection world. NFL coaches move to college for a bigger title, a room of their own, or the chance to call plays sooner.
Here's the rule I gave Teo the first night: a move across ladders is almost always a trade of title for learning, or learning for title. When I left a college coordinator job to become an NFL quality control coach, I traded the biggest title I'd had for the steepest learning curve I'd ever been on. If Teo takes the FCS job, he trades the NFL's learning curve for a title and a room. Neither move is wrong. You have to know which one you're making.
🏫 Any level: If you're a high-school coach who wants to coach college, the crossing usually runs through a GA spot, a camp or clinic relationship with a college staff, or a high-school program good enough that college coaches spend time in your building recruiting. If you're a college coach who wants to coach in the NFL, it usually runs through a QC or assistant job somebody vouched for, often from a coach you worked with who went to the league first. Neither crossing happens through a job posting alone.
37.3 Twenty-Two Years: My Path, Rung by Rung
You can't give career advice in the abstract, so here's mine, with the warts. I'm forty-six. I've been coaching for twenty-two years. I've been fired once, and I didn't call the plays.
LYLE'S PATH: 22 YEARS, ONE FIRING (fictional; ages approximate)
AGE ROLE WHERE
------- ------------------------------------ ---------------------
24 Volunteer, freshman staff NE Ohio, half an hour
25 - 29 High-school OC (HC Ray Kessler) from Youngstown
|
v the leap: pay cut, age 29
29 - 31 Graduate assistant (two years) Big-conference program
|
v a phone call to Dale Brockway
31 - 33 Receivers coach (HC Dale Brockway) Mid-major spread/RPO
33 - 36 Offensive coordinator (called plays) program
|
v the "step down": OC -> QC
~36 Quality control (one year) NFL team No. 1
~37-39 Quarterbacks coach |
~39-41 Passing-game coordinator (Walt |
Dupree's staff) v
X head coach fired; staff out
~41 Passing-game coordinator NFL team No. 2
| (wide-zone staff)
v
42 - 46 Offensive coordinator (four seasons) Austin Outlaws
📊 Diagram (described): A vertical timeline of Lyle's twenty-two years in coaching, with his approximate age on the left, the role in the middle, and the place on the right. At 24 he volunteers with a freshman staff in northeast Ohio, and from 25 to 29 he is a high-school offensive coordinator there under head coach Ray Kessler. An arrow marked "the leap: pay cut, age 29" leads to two years as a graduate assistant at a big-conference program, from 29 to 31. An arrow marked "a phone call to Dale Brockway" leads to about two years as receivers coach under head coach Dale Brockway at a mid-major spread and RPO program, starting at 31, and then about three seasons as that program's offensive coordinator, calling plays, from about 33. An arrow marked "the step down: OC to QC" leads to the first NFL team: about a year as quality control coach at 36, quarterbacks coach from about 37 to 39, and passing-game coordinator on Walt Dupree's staff from about 39 to 41. An X marks the firing, when the head coach was fired and the staff went with him. At about 41 Lyle spends one season as passing-game coordinator on a wide-zone staff at a second NFL team, and from 42 to 46 he is offensive coordinator of the Austin Outlaws for four seasons.
Ages 24–29: Friday nights in northeast Ohio
I played quarterback at a small Division III college in Ohio, a school with more cows than scholarships, and I wasn't good enough to do anything with it except understand what my coaches were asking me to do. I came home, got my teaching license, substitute-taught, worked the diner grill beside my father, and at twenty-four volunteered with a freshman team for a fall, which is when I started counting my years in coaching. Then a consolidated high school half an hour from Youngstown hired me to teach social studies and coordinate its offense, at twenty-five, under Ray Kessler. Ray was a retired shop teacher who had coached defense for thirty years, and he had two sayings: "Don't embarrass us" and "Fix it by Friday."
Those five seasons taught me almost everything that still matters to me about teaching. I learned to fit the scheme to the kids, and I learned it the hard way, in that 14–7 and 21–6 start. I learned that a rival can read your signals if you never change them. A coach named Ray Szymanski did exactly that to us in a conference-title game in the rain. I learned that a line meeting is worth more than a pep talk. In my second season, a slanting fifty front held us to 41 rushing yards on 28 carries, and I switched from man blocking rules to zone area rules. We beat that same front 17–14 in the playoffs. And I learned that last week's film is the film that counts: a 17–13 loss came from me discounting what a defense had just changed.
By my fourth and fifth seasons, we were good. Across those two seasons we lost one game. Then I quit.
"Why would you leave after that?" Teo asked me. It's the right question.
"Because I'd stopped being scared," I told him. "I could call that offense in my sleep. I knew every defense in the league, and they knew me. The only thing I was still learning was how to beat the same eleven coaches, and that's a skill that's only worth something in that league. I wanted to know what I didn't know."
That's the first test for any move, and I'll say it plainly: are you still learning where you are? If the answer is no, staying is comfortable, and comfortable is how good coaches stop getting better.
Ages 29–31: the GA years
Leaving cost me. I took a pay cut so steep that my wife, Dana, a nurse, became the household's main income for two years. Dana and I married during my fourth season, and our daughter, Sophia, was born during my second season as a GA. I was twenty-nine when I started, sharing an office with three twenty-three-year-olds, and I was the oldest graduate assistant on a big-conference staff by a long way.
I got the job the way most people do: half merit, half a phone call. I'd mailed film and a letter to more than thirty programs. Two answered. The one that brought me in for a visit did so because its offensive line coach had played college football with Ray Kessler, and Ray picked up the phone. Case Study 2 tells that story, including the part where my first letters went nowhere.
The GA years were the film room. I tagged every snap of every opponent. I built scout cards. I learned that a big program has a process for everything, including the order in which coaches eat lunch. And one spring, at a coaching clinic, I stood in line after a talk by an NFL offensive coordinator named Walt Dupree and asked him who'd drawn the concept he'd just shown first. He laughed and told me nobody had invented it, everybody had, and he drew me the family tree on the back of a clinic handout. I sent him a thank-you note with a play drawn on it. I sent him one every Christmas after that. That's not a strategy, by the way. I just liked him. But it's how the tree starts.
Ages 31–36: receivers coach, then coordinator
After my second season as a GA, with my master's degree finished, the co-coordinator I'd worked for picked up the phone and called Dale Brockway, the head coach at a mid-major spread and RPO program, who needed a receivers coach. Dale was an Air Raid coach whose whole passing game fit in a nineteen-page playbook, and I learned more from those nineteen pages than from the thousand I'd tagged as a GA. Chapter 30 tells that story.
After about two seasons, Dale's offensive coordinator left, and Dale gave me the job. I was about thirty-three and calling plays for a college team. I wasn't ready, and I've told some of the evidence in this book. My first season, a quarterback named Eli Navarro and I beat a tite front 24–17 after a halftime fix, and lost 27–20 on a boundary-seam interception. My second season, our signature RPO, "Inside Seam," produced a 31-yard touchdown to a tight end named Dawson Pike that came back for an ineligible lineman downfield, and we lost 27–23. My third season, a sophomore named Jonah Pell and I led a team coached by a defensive coordinator everyone called "the Professor" 17–7 at the half and lost 27–24. I learned the RPO and the tempo world on that staff. I also learned that calling plays in public is a different job from designing them in private.
Our son, Alex, was born my first year as coordinator. I missed his first birthday for a recruiting trip. I'd do the trip again. I wouldn't do it the same way.
Ages 36–41: the step down, and Walt
After my third season as coordinator, Walt called. He needed a quality control coach. It was a step down in title by any measure: from the man who calls the plays to the man who makes the cut-ups for the man who calls the plays. It was also the only way I was going to learn what an NFL protection meeting sounds like.
The first thing I did on Walt's staff was walk in with a cut-up of forty college RPOs I was proud of. Walt had me freeze each one at the release. On only 11 of the 40 was every lineman within the NFL's one-yard limit for an ineligible lineman downfield. "Right now you're asking the official," Walt said. Those eleven seeded the RPO menu we run in Austin today (Chapter 13 tells it from the scheme side).
I was a QC for a year, then quarterbacks coach for about two seasons, then Walt's passing-game coordinator for about two more. Walt was a West Coast–tree coordinator, and he gave me most of my sayings. "Every play is a question. Know what you're asking." "Script the first fifteen to learn, not to win." He gave me the three questions every scouting report has to answer, and every Tuesday he made his two youngest assistants each hand in a one-page script before he built his own. For two seasons, those two assistants were me and Curtis Bale.
Curtis was brilliant. He'd stay late drawing things nobody had ever seen. His script was always titled "Score in 15," and it had five shots in it. Mine had fifteen questions and no answer column. Walt read both aloud every week. You've met Curtis throughout this book. His first season as a coordinator produced the league's most-talked-about offense. In his second, defenses played deep, he abandoned the run, his quarterback took sacks, and he was fired before the next season. He's the reason I keep a list of things I'll never do.
After my fifth season or so in that building, the head coach was fired on the Monday after our last game. A new head coach was hired within two weeks and brought his own staff. Walt retired. I was out of work.
Age 41: the wide-zone year
I was out of work for nineteen days. The offensive coordinator of a wide-zone team had been borrowing from Walt's dropback passing game for years, and he said so cheerfully. He called me on the fourth day. He wanted that passing game married to his run game, and he wanted somebody who could teach it. I spent one season as his passing-game coordinator, and it rearranged my brain. The line coach on that staff made me take the outside-zone reach step myself, in sneakers, in the parking lot, until he was satisfied. Our twelve-personnel world in Austin, outside zone and duo with Wide PA Boot behind it, came from that year.
Ages 42–46: Austin
That January, Wade Harmon called. He'd been a defensive coordinator for most of his career before becoming a head coach, and his interview felt like a game plan meeting with the opponent. I'll show you the whiteboard in Section 37.6. My second week on the job, he took me to breakfast and asked, "What do you believe? One napkin." He still has the napkin on his desk. Four seasons later, here we are: 11–6, a wild-card win in Oklahoma City, and a divisional loss in Sacramento, 20–17, on an interception I called and Darius Vance threw and both of us own.
🔄 Check your understanding: Lyle made two moves that looked like steps backward: high-school coordinator to GA, and college coordinator to NFL QC. What did each "backward" move buy him that the "forward" option couldn't?
Answer
The GA move bought him a bigger problem to learn on. He'd mastered his high-school league, and he'd stopped learning. The GA years gave him a big program's film room, its process, and access to coaches who could pull him up, including the clinic where he met Walt. The QC move bought him the NFL's passing and protection depth. That included the ineligible-downfield lesson in the 40-clip test, which a college coordinator could never have learned by staying a college coordinator. Both moves traded title for learning, deliberately.
37.4 The Coaching Tree: Mentorship, Lineage, and "Who You Know"
A coaching tree is the family of coaches who worked under one head coach or coordinator and went on to lead staffs of their own. Fans like to draw them like royal bloodlines. Coaches know they're messier than that: you can work under someone for one season and learn nothing, or for three weeks at a clinic and learn your whole philosophy. But trees are real, and the reason they're real is the most important thing to understand about how coaching jobs get filled.
Documented trees, told carefully
Some trees are well enough documented that you can name the branches without guessing. I'll stay with the links that are widely reported and leave the rest alone. Any "complete" tree you see online is somebody's argument.
| Tree | Root | Widely documented links | What tends to travel with it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Walsh | Bill Walsh (49ers, 1980s) | Mike Holmgren and George Seifert coached under Walsh in San Francisco; Holmgren's Green Bay staffs in turn included Andy Reid, Jon Gruden, and Steve Mariucci | Timing and footwork married to the drop, horizontal stretch, scripted openings, detailed teaching of the quarterback |
| Reid (a Walsh–Holmgren branch) | Andy Reid (Eagles, Chiefs) | Assistants who became head coaches include Doug Pederson (who won Super Bowl LII with the Eagles), John Harbaugh (special-teams coach under Reid in Philadelphia), and Matt Nagy, among others | West Coast roots, creative screens and motion, adapting the system to the quarterback rather than the reverse |
| Parcells | Bill Parcells (Giants and later teams) | Bill Belichick (his Giants defensive coordinator), Tom Coughlin (a Giants assistant), and Sean Payton (an assistant on his Dallas staff) | Discipline, situational football, a demanding culture; the branches went in very different schematic directions |
| Shanahan | Mike Shanahan (Broncos) | Gary Kubiak; Kyle Shanahan; Sean McVay and Matt LaFleur are widely grouped with the tree through their time with Kyle Shanahan | Outside zone, boot, and play-action from identical pictures; motion at the snap |
Notice two things about that table. First, trees carry ideas, but not one idea. The Parcells branches look nothing alike on the whiteboard. What traveled was a way of running a building. Second, the Reid tree grew out of the Holmgren branch, which grew out of Walsh, so the West Coast ideas Walt Dupree taught me came through several generations of coaches who learned them by sitting in rooms, not by reading. Chapter 2 traces the scheme lineage. This chapter is about the human one.
The tree from the inside
Here's what a tree looks like when you're a leaf on it.
A TREE FROM THE INSIDE (fictional people; real trees work the same way)
WALT DUPREE
West Coast-tree OC (composite); retired
/ | \
/ | \
LYLE PETRAKIS CURTIS BALE other QCs and
Austin OC OC, two seasons assistants Walt
| (unnamed team) trained
|
TEO ARRIAGA --------> FCS passing-game coordinator?
Austin QC (the decision in this chapter)
GRAFTED ON (people who weren't my bosses for long, but shaped me):
Ray Kessler ........ "Fix it by Friday" (high school)
wide-zone OL coach . the reach step, in sneakers (one season)
Wade Harmon ........ "What do you believe? One napkin."
📊 Diagram (described): A family-tree chart with Walt Dupree, a retired West Coast-tree offensive coordinator, at the top. Three branches come down from him: Lyle Petrakis, now the Austin offensive coordinator; Curtis Bale, who was a coordinator for two seasons at an unnamed team; and a group of other quality control coaches and assistants Walt trained. Below Lyle is Teo Arriaga, the Austin quality control coach, with an arrow pointing to a possible FCS passing-game coordinator job, which is the decision in this chapter. A separate list at the bottom shows people "grafted on" to the tree who shaped Lyle without being long-time bosses: his high-school head coach Ray Kessler, the wide-zone offensive line coach who taught him the reach step, and Wade Harmon with the napkin question.
The bottom of that diagram matters as much as the top. Your real tree isn't only the people you worked under for years. It's everyone who changed how you think. Ray Kessler coached defense and never drew an offensive play for me in five years, and "Fix it by Friday" is the most-used sentence in my office.
🔍 Why this works: Why do coaching jobs travel through trees instead of open searches? Because a coordinator hire is a bet made fast, on incomplete information, about how someone will behave under pressure you can't simulate. A head coach usually hires a coordinator in days, in January, while every other team is hiring too. He can watch film of the candidate's offense, but he can't watch the candidate in a Tuesday-night staff meeting when the plan is wrong. Someone from his own tree is a person he has already seen under that pressure. And there's a second reason: a shared language. When Walt's former assistants talk about "the question this play asks," they mean the same thing. A coordinator from your tree needs no translation in the first week, and the first week of a new staff is when the playbook gets written. The mechanism is trust plus vocabulary. Notice what it costs, though: if every hire comes from people you've already seen, the profession reproduces itself, and the people who never got in the room never get seen. Section 37.7 is about that cost.
What "who you know" really means
Young coaches hear "it's who you know" and conclude the game is rigged and networking is the answer. Half of that is right. Here's the version I give Teo:
"Who you know" is really "who has seen your work." Walt didn't hire me because I sent Christmas cards. He hired me because years of cards each had a play drawn on them, and somewhere around the third card he started writing back with questions about them. The cards were a portfolio, not a greeting. When Walt needed a QC, he already knew how I thought.
You don't network up. You work across and down. The coaches who'll hire you in ten years are mostly the GAs and QCs sitting next to you now. The co-coordinator I worked for as a GA made the call that got me to Dale Brockway. The wide-zone coordinator who called on day four knew my work through Walt. The FCS head coach calling Teo was the offensive coordinator at the college where Teo was a GA. Your peers are your future employers. Be the person they want in the room.
Mentorship has to be earned in both directions. Walt gave me his time because I gave him my best work, on time, without being asked twice. A mentor is not a sponsor you collect. It's a relationship with obligations on both sides. Walt still gets a phone call from me every Sunday night in the offseason. During the season he calls me, usually Monday morning, and usually to ask why I didn't run the ball more.
⚠️ Common mistake: Mistaking proximity for mentorship. A young assistant spends two seasons on a famous coach's staff, puts the name on his résumé, and expects the tree to carry him. In the interview the head coach asks, "What's one thing you'd do differently from him, and why?" The young coach has no answer. He was in the building but never in the conversation. Fix: keep a notebook for every boss you have. Write down what he does, what you'd keep, and what you'd change, and why. When the interview comes, you'll have your own opinions about your own lineage, and that's what a head coach is actually hiring.
🔄 Check your understanding: Explain in two sentences why head coaches tend to hire coordinators from their own coaching trees, and name the cost of that habit.
Answer
A coordinator hire is a fast, high-stakes bet on how a person behaves under pressure, and someone from your own tree is someone you've already watched under that pressure who also speaks your system's language from the first day. The cost is that the profession reproduces itself: people outside the existing networks, historically including many minority coaches, never get seen, so they never get the chance to be trusted.
37.5 The Grind: Hours, Money, Family, and the Firing Cycle
Every young coach has heard that the hours are long. Almost none of them understand it until the first October. Here's an honest accounting.
The hours
AN IN-SEASON WEEK: HOURS IN THE BUILDING (our fictional staff)
LYLE (OC) TEO (QC)
Mon ############## 14 ################ 16
Tue ################# 17 ################## 18
Wed ############## 14 ############### 15
Thu ############# 13 ############## 14
Fri ########### 11 ############ 12
Sat ######## 8 (+ travel) ######### 9 (+ travel)
Sun ########## 10 (game day) ########## 10 (game day)
------------------------- -------------------------
about 87 hours about 94 hours
📊 Diagram (described): A side-by-side bar chart of hours spent in the building on each day of an in-season week, for Lyle as coordinator and Teo as quality control coach. Lyle's bars run from 8 hours on Saturday, plus travel, to 17 hours on Tuesday, when the game plan is built, for a total of about 87 hours. Teo's bars are longer almost every day, running from 9 hours on Saturday to 18 on Tuesday, for a total of about 94 hours. Sunday is game day for both, at about 10 hours.
That chart is our building, and it's fictional like everything else about the Outlaws, but the shape is typical of what many NFL assistants describe: weeks well past seventy hours in season, with the youngest staff members working the longest. Tuesday is the long day for both of us. The players are off, the game plan gets built, and I'm usually there past midnight. Teo is longest of all because he works a week ahead. On Monday night, his breakdown of next week's opponent is already on my desk, while he's still finishing this week's self-scout with Marisol.
The hours aren't the hard part. The hard part is that they're non-negotiable at the exact times life happens. School plays are on Tuesday nights. Thanksgiving is a game week. Your kid's birthday falls on a road Saturday about one year in three.
The money (described, not quoted)
I'm not going to print salary numbers, because they vary enormously, change every year, and anything I wrote would be wrong somewhere by the time you read it. Here is the shape:
| Rung | What the money is like |
|---|---|
| High-school assistant | A stipend on top of a teaching salary. Divided by the hours, it's often a few dollars an hour. You coach high school for love and a pension, not the stipend. |
| College GA | Tuition plus a modest stipend. Many GAs live with roommates, and some take a second job in the summer. |
| College analyst / entry staff | A real salary, but a modest one, often the lowest full-time pay in the building. |
| NFL QC / offensive assistant | A living. Usually more than a GA, often less than people assume, and in an expensive NFL city, it doesn't go far. |
| Position coach (college or NFL) | Comfortable, sometimes very, and it rises fast at big programs and in the NFL. |
| Coordinator | Very well paid by any normal standard at the top levels, with short contracts and no security. |
| Head coach | Large, and attached to the shortest leash in the building. |
The money pattern that matters for your planning is this: the pay is lowest exactly when you're youngest and moving the most. The GA and QC years are the years you're most likely to move, least likely to own a house, and most likely to be starting a family. Plan for that. Dana and I lived mostly on her nurse's pay for my GA years, with a newborn by the second one. We could do it because her license and her skills could move with us, and because we'd saved during my high-school years with the specific goal of affording two bad years. Not every family can, and the profession loses a lot of good young coaches at exactly that point. That loss is a big part of why the coaching ranks don't look like the players.
The family
Here's the ledger for my family, and I asked Dana's permission to print it.
We've moved five times since we got married. Sophia was born in the GA town. She spent her toddler years in the mid-major town and her elementary years in the first NFL city. She went to sixth grade in one state, during the wide-zone year, and seventh grade in Texas. She's sixteen now and she's told me, very calmly, that if I take a job somewhere else before she graduates, she's staying with a friend. I believe her. Alex is thirteen and has never lived anywhere longer than about six years.
Dana has started over at five hospitals. She's very good at it, and she shouldn't have had to be.
I'm not telling you this for sympathy. Plenty of jobs move people. I'm telling you because the family pays the cost of the career in a currency the coach never sees on his own ledger, and the young coaches who last are the ones who put that cost on the table before the job offer, not after. When Teo told me about the FCS call, the second question I asked him, after "Do you want it?", was "Who else does this move?" He's single, his parents are in El Paso, and the FCS school is a day's drive from them. That's part of the calculation, and it's allowed to be.
💡 Coach's point: Before you take any job, write down the three things your family gives up for it. If you can't write them, you haven't asked.
The firing cycle
Coaching staffs are fired as units. When a head coach is fired, his coordinators and assistants are usually gone too, because the new head coach wants his own tree. That's what happened to Walt's staff, and it's the most important structural fact of the profession. Your job security is mostly someone else's win-loss record.
📈 By the numbers: In most recent NFL offseasons, somewhere between a handful and roughly ten head-coaching jobs have opened, which means several dozen assistant jobs change hands each January before anyone has evaluated those assistants individually. The exact count swings from year to year. Coordinator turnover adds to it, because coordinators are also fired, promoted, or hired away on their own. Treat any precise "average tenure" number you see with care: it depends on what's counted and over which years.
The firing calendar is predictable even when the firing isn't.
THE HIRING-AND-FIRING CALENDAR (approximate; shifts with the schedule)
NFL Day after the regular season .. firings ("Black Monday")
January ...................... head-coach searches; staffs
hired fast; playoff teams'
assistants interview mid-run
February ..................... staffs mostly set by the
Combine
Spring/summer ................ fellows, interns, late moves
COLLEGE November ..................... late-season firings
December ..................... new head coaches build
staffs; recruiting and
transfer windows collide
January-February ............. coordinators move; NFL
staffs hire college coaches
Spring ....................... late openings (like Teo's)
HIGH Winter-spring ................ jobs posted through districts,
SCHOOL usually tied to a teaching
vacancy
📊 Diagram (described): A three-part calendar showing when coaching jobs open and fill at each level. In the NFL, firings come the day after the regular season ends, the day nicknamed "Black Monday." Head-coach searches and fast staff hiring follow in January, with assistants from playoff teams interviewing during their playoff run, and staffs are mostly set by the Combine in February. Fellows, interns, and late moves fill the spring and summer. In college, late-season firings come in November, new head coaches build staffs in December while recruiting and transfer windows collide, coordinators move in January and February when NFL staffs also hire college coaches, and late openings like Teo's appear in the spring. High-school jobs are posted through school districts in winter and spring, usually tied to a teaching vacancy.
Two features of that calendar shape careers. First, the NFL hires fast. Walt's replacement had his staff assembled in about two weeks. If you aren't already known to the people hiring, you're too late. Second, the college and NFL calendars overlap in January, so college coaches get hired away in the middle of recruiting season, and a spring opening like Teo's is often the downstream effect.
Also know the rules about interviews while you're under contract. The NFL's anti-tampering policy governs when a team can block an assistant under contract from interviewing elsewhere. In recent seasons, the league has generally not let a team block an assistant from interviewing for a promotion, such as a coordinator or head-coaching job, but the details have changed more than once. Check the current policy, and always tell your boss before you take the call.
🔄 Check your understanding: Why can an assistant coach who did excellent work still lose his job in January, and what's the one career habit that best protects him?
Answer
Because staffs are usually fired as a unit when the head coach is fired. The new head coach brings his own tree, regardless of how well any one assistant performed. The best protection is having your work seen across the profession before you need it: peers on other staffs, coaches you've helped, and a body of work (cut-ups, a philosophy, a binder) that someone outside your building already knows. In the NFL, staffs are hired in about two weeks, so the relationship has to exist before the firing.
37.6 The Interview and the Coordinator Interview Binder
A coordinator interview isn't a conversation about your résumé. The head coach already knows your résumé. It's a test of how you think, and most head coaches run it at a whiteboard.
What Wade asked me
Wade's interview lasted most of a day. The first hour was talk: who I'd worked for, what I'd learned, what I'd do differently. Then he stood up, uncapped a marker, and drew a defense.
"First-and-ten," he said. "Eight in the box. Go."
PRE-SNAP (Wade's whiteboard: "First-and-ten. Eight in the box. Go.")
F
C C
W $
M S
E T T E
X H O O O O O Y Z
R Q
📊 Diagram (described): Before the snap, the offense on Wade's whiteboard is in 11 personnel, two-by-two from the shotgun: the split end and slot receiver on the left, the tight end attached on the right with the flanker wide outside him, and the back offset to the quarterback's left. The defense shows a single deep safety in the middle, cornerbacks over both wide receivers, and four down linemen. Behind them, the Mike linebacker is over the left guard and center, the Sam is over the right side, and the strong safety is walked down over the tight end. The Will linebacker is aligned on the weak side in an apex position, halfway between the left tackle and the slot receiver. That makes seven and a half defenders in the box, which Wade called eight.
I counted out loud, which is how I was taught. "Four down, Mike, Sam, and the safety over the tight end. That's seven. Your Will is in an apex between my tackle and my slot. I count him as a half. You're calling it eight."
"I'm calling it eight because he'll play the run like he's eight," Wade said. "What do you call?"
The answer I gave him became the first play of our RPO menu, and you know it already: Inside Slant, the RPO from Anchor A in Chapter 13. I didn't know yet that, in my fourth season, it would be the first two snaps of our first game against Sacramento. I drew it like this.
POST-SNAP (Inside Slant: zone right; the quarterback reads the Will)
F
^ C C
| /> $
| /
| / (W) M S
| | v E T T E
X H O> O> O> O> O> Y-->]
R-->Q--> mesh: QB's eyes on (W)
(W) triggers on the run -> QB pulls, throws the slant behind him
(W) sits in the window -> QB hands off: five blockers on five
📊 Diagram (described): After the snap, all five offensive linemen step to the right for inside zone, and the tight end releases outside to block the strong safety. The split end runs straight up the left sideline as a clear-out, taking the cornerback with him. The slot receiver takes one step and breaks inside on a slant toward the space where the Will linebacker started. The back runs across the quarterback toward the right on the inside-zone path, and at the mesh the quarterback's eyes are on the Will, who is circled because he's read rather than blocked. If the Will triggers downhill toward the run, the quarterback pulls the ball and throws the slant into the window the Will just left. If the Will sits in the window, the quarterback hands off and the run has five blockers for the five remaining box defenders.
"Your Will can't be right," I told him. "If he fits the run, the slant's behind him. If he sits on the slant, I've got five blockers on five in the box, and the back reads the rest. You told me eight in the box. I'm telling you one of them has two jobs."
Then Wade did the thing that made me want to work for him. He erased my slant and drew his nickel walking over my slot with outside leverage.
"Now what?"
"Now the slant window belongs to the Will alone. Your nickel can't get inside the slant from outside leverage. Same call."
"And if I put the nickel inside?"
"Then he's taken himself out of the run fit, and I've got a seven-man box and a back I trust. I'll run the ball. Or I'll take the bubble outside him. I'd tag that."
He capped the marker. "Okay. Show me what you'd do on third-and-seven against two-high when I've got a guy who can rush." That was the next hour.
🛡️ The defense's view: Wade told me later what he was actually testing. Every coordinator knows an RPO, so it wasn't Inside Slant. It was three things. First, did I count the defense the way his defense counts itself? My half-man apex count told him I'd sat in defensive meetings. Second, when he changed the defense, did I change the play or the read? Changing the read keeps the offense small and the quarterback's job stable. Third, would I tell him what beats me? Without being asked, I'd said that a Will who sits plus a safety who comes down late is the look Inside Slant hates, because the handoff hits a full box. "That's when you need the next play." Wade says that answer got me the job. A defensive coach trusts an offensive coach who can name his own weaknesses, because it proves he's watching the defense and not just his own plays.
📋 Try it — Draw it up: You're in a coordinator interview. The head coach draws a Cover 2 shell: two deep safeties splitting the field in halves, cornerbacks rolled up on the outside receivers, and two linebackers plus a nickel underneath. He gives you 11 personnel, 2x2, second-and-six at his 31, and four minutes with a marker. Draw a concept that puts one defender in conflict, name that defender, and give the quarterback's read in one sentence. Then the head coach rotates the defense to Cover 3 (a single deep middle safety, both cornerbacks bailing to deep thirds). Say whether your concept is still good, and why.
Answer
Smash is the textbook answer, and it's what we ran at Portland in Anchor B (Chapter 16). On one side, the outside receiver (#1) runs a 6-yard hitch, and the slot (#2) runs a corner route that stems to about 12 yards and breaks toward the pylon at about 18. The conflict defender is the Cover 2 cornerback, whose rule makes him the flat defender. The read is one sentence: "If the corner squats on the hitch, throw the corner route over him; if he sinks under the corner route, throw the hitch." Put a seam or a dig on the backside so the safety on that side has someone to hang on.
Against Cover 3, smash is much weaker. The corner bails to his deep third, so he's already on top of the corner route, and the hitch only works if the flat defender is slow. In the interview, say exactly that, then name what you'd tag or switch to against Cover 3, such as a hitch or curl-flat side that attacks the flat defender instead. What's being graded is the same thing Wade graded: did you name the conflict defender, did you give a one-sentence read, and did you volunteer what beats you?
🔄 Check your understanding: On Wade's whiteboard, the nickel moved over the slot with outside leverage, and Lyle kept the same call. Then Wade asked about inside leverage. Why does Lyle's answer change only in the second case?
Answer
With outside leverage, the nickel can't get inside the slant, so the slant window still belongs to the Will alone. The Will still has two jobs, and the read is unchanged. With inside leverage, the nickel takes the slant window himself but removes himself from the run fit. Now the Will is no longer in conflict, but the box is lighter, so Lyle runs the ball or attacks outside the nickel with a bubble tag. The defense moved a different defender into or out of the conflict, so the answer moved with it. That's "change the read before you change the play."
The other questions
A coordinator interview has non-whiteboard questions too, and the good ones are always about process under pressure:
- "Walk me through your Tuesday." (They want a weekly process: when the plan is built, who contributes, how disagreements get settled.)
- "Tell me about a call you'd take back." (They want honesty plus a mechanism, not a confession. Mine is the Mills call in Game 3. The mechanism is trusting a tendency longer than the evidence supported it, and the fix is the middle-read tag.)
- "Who would you hire?" (They want a staff philosophy, not names you haven't asked yet.)
- "How do you handle a quarterback who's struggling?" (Chapter 35 is the answer.)
- "What do you need from me?" (They want to know you understand that the head coach owns fourth downs, timeouts, and the final word.)
The binder
The coordinator interview binder is the packet you hand the head coach, or leave behind, that shows your whole system on paper. Some coaches bring a physical binder, some a tablet, and many bring both. The format matters less than the contents, and the contents matter less than one rule: every page has to be something you could install on Monday. A binder full of highlights is a scrapbook. A binder full of rules, calendars, and sample plans is a job.
| Tab | Contents | Built from |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Philosophy | One page: thesis, non-negotiables, what you'll never do | Chapter 1 |
| 2. System overview | Personnel, formation families, core runs and passes, the constraint map | Ch 3–4, Ch 38 |
| 3. Language | Call grammar, a sample wristband panel | Ch 8 |
| 4. Install | The camp install calendar and a game-week practice plan | Chapter 34 |
| 5. Game plan | A sample plan and 15-play script against a real opponent's defense | Ch 23–24 |
| 6. Call sheet | One sample call sheet with situation boxes | Ch 25–26 |
| 7. Quarterback plan | Meeting schedule, game-management card, confidence plan | Ch 35 |
| 8. Measurement | The dashboard you'd track and how you self-scout | Ch 28 |
| 9. Staff | The roles you'd want filled and what each voice adds | Section 37.8 |
| 10. First 90 days | What you'd do from the day you're hired to the first day of camp | This chapter |
I'll be honest: the binder I brought to Wade was too long. It had 140 pages, and he read four of them: the philosophy, the third-down page, the protection page, and the first-90-days page. That's useful information. The binder isn't read. It's sampled. The head coach flips to the page he cares about, and that page has to be good. So the job is not to make the binder big. It's to make every page strong enough to be the one he opens.
⚠️ Common mistake: The binder that's all answers. A candidate brings a binder with a call for every situation and no explanation of how the calls were chosen. The head coach asks, "What if my quarterback can't throw the out?" and the binder has no page for it. Fix: every section opens with the rule that generates the plays, such as "On third-and-medium, at least one route breaks at the sticks," before it lists the plays. A head coach hires a process he can trust when the plays stop working.
37.7 The Rooney Rule and Diversity in Coaching
Section 37.4 explained why coaching jobs travel through trees: trust and a shared language, under time pressure. That mechanism has a cost the profession has argued about for more than two decades. If you only hire people you've already seen, and the people already in the room mostly look like you, the room keeps looking like you.
What the rule is
The Rooney Rule is an NFL policy, adopted in 2003, that requires teams to interview minority candidates for certain senior jobs before filling them. It's named for Dan Rooney, the Pittsburgh Steelers' chairman, who led the league committee that pushed for it. A widely cited 2002 report by the attorneys Cyrus Mehri and Johnnie Cochran helped prompt it. The report argued that Black head coaches had been held to a different standard in hiring and firing.
The original rule covered head-coaching vacancies: a team had to interview at least one minority candidate. Within its first year, the league fined the Detroit Lions for not doing so. Since then, the rule has been expanded and revised several times. It has been extended to general-manager and senior front-office jobs. In recent years, it has required more than one minority candidate for head-coaching interviews, required interviews for coordinator vacancies, and added rules about in-person interviews. Recent versions have also counted women as qualifying candidates for some positions. The league has added incentives alongside the rule, including compensatory draft picks for teams whose minority assistants or executives are hired away to lead other teams, as well as measures aimed at the offensive pipeline, such as requiring each club to employ a minority or female offensive assistant. The details have changed often enough that you should check the league's current policy rather than trust any summary, including this one.
What the debate actually is
Honest people disagree about the rule, and the disagreement is mostly about what it can reach.
The case for it: it forced teams to interview people they might never have considered, and in the years after it took effect, the number of minority head coaches rose. When Tony Dungy's Colts met Lovie Smith's Bears in the Super Bowl after the 2006 season, they were the first two Black head coaches to reach the game. Supporters argue that being interviewed is itself a career asset: you get seen by an owner, you get practice at the hardest interview in the sport, and your name enters the next search.
The case that it isn't enough: critics, including advocacy groups such as the Fritz Pollard Alliance that work with the league on these issues, point out that hiring numbers have risen and fallen since 2003, and that a required interview can become a box checked after the decision is already made. In 2022, the former Dolphins head coach Brian Flores filed a lawsuit alleging discriminatory hiring practices, including interviews he described as not being genuine. The teams and the league disputed his claims. The case's progress is a matter of public record, so check its current status rather than relying on anything written here.
The pipeline argument, which is the one that matters most to anyone reading this book: in recent years, many head coaches have been hired from the offensive side, often from coordinator and quarterbacks-coach jobs. Those are exactly the jobs where minority coaches have historically been scarce. If the head-coaching pool is drawn from offensive coordinators, and offensive coordinators are drawn from the trees in Section 37.4, then a rule that governs only the final interview arrives decades too late. The decisions that matter were made when somebody was or wasn't offered a GA spot, or a QC job, or a seat in the quarterbacks room.
Women in coaching face a version of the same pipeline problem, with an even narrower door. A few have been visible. Katie Sowers became the first woman to coach in a Super Bowl, as an offensive assistant with the 49ers, and two women on the Buccaneers' staff, Lori Locust and Maral Javadifar, won a Super Bowl the following season. They were visible because they were rare.
What a coordinator can actually do
I don't make the league's rules. I do make hiring decisions, and so will you. The tree mechanism is a habit, and habits can be changed by people at every rung.
- Post the job and test the work. Our QC search starts with a posting and a written test everyone takes, not with phone calls to my friends. Section 37.8 describes the test.
- Ask every candidate the same questions, in the same order, and write the answers down before you discuss them. A structured interview is harder to bend toward the person you already liked.
- Look outside your tree on purpose: clinic talks and practices from coaches you don't know.
- Mentor across the line. If everyone you mentor looks like you, the tree you grow will too.
🔄 Check your understanding: A head coach says, "We follow the Rooney Rule. We interviewed two minority candidates for coordinator." Using the pipeline argument, explain why that sentence might be true and still not answer the real problem.
Answer
The rule governs one moment, the final interview. The pipeline argument says the candidate pool for coordinator and head-coaching jobs is built years earlier through GA, QC, and position-coach hires that travel through existing trees. If minority coaches were rarely offered those early offensive jobs, especially in quarterbacks rooms and play-calling roles, then few will have the résumés that make them finalists, however fairly the final interview is run. Complying with the interview requirement doesn't fix who got onto the ladder.
37.8 Building a Staff
When you become a coordinator, you inherit part of a staff and you hire part of one. In the NFL, the head coach usually makes the final call on position coaches, and the coordinator's influence varies widely. What you can always control is what you're hiring for.
My rule: hire for the voices you don't have. A staff of people who agree with you is a staff that will be wrong together. Here's ours, drawn as the system it is.
THE OUTLAWS' OFFENSIVE STAFF AS A SYSTEM (fictional)
WADE HARMON
head coach: 4th downs, timeouts
|
MARISOL VEGA ------- LYLE PETRAKIS ------- (defensive staff:
analytics: OC; calls plays "how would I
"how sure are we?" | defend that?")
+----------+-------------+-----------+------------+
| | | | |
GUS ROME CAL LONNIE TEO
OL / run QBs WRs / pass RBs QC (booth)
game
"five men, "rule four: "the break "go where "shell, box,
one the free tells the the FB one thing"
heartbeat" square" truth" says"
📊 Diagram (described): An organization chart of the fictional Outlaws offensive staff. Wade Harmon, the head coach who owns fourth downs and timeouts, is at the top. Below him in the center is Lyle Petrakis, the coordinator who calls plays. Lyle is connected on the left to Marisol Vega, the analytics director, whose question is "how sure are we?", and on the right to the defensive staff, whose question is "how would I defend that?" Below Lyle, five coaches branch out, each with the phrase that captures his voice: Gus Ferrante for the offensive line and run game, "five men, one heartbeat"; Rome Pettaway for the quarterbacks, "rule four: the free square"; Cal Boateng for the receivers and passing game, "the break tells the truth"; Lonnie Briggs for the running backs, "go where the fullback says"; and Teo Arriaga, the quality control coach in the booth, "shell, box, one thing."
Look at what each voice does to me. Gus is a zone purist who grumbles every time I add an RPO, and his grumbling keeps the run game honest. Marisol gives sample sizes and caveats, and she wins arguments with me with them. Rome wrote "Want a post-snap check?" in the margin of our Game 3 plan, and I answered, "Rule four covers." He was right, and I wasn't. Every good staff needs someone whose dissent is written down, which is why our Tuesday meeting has a four-step disagreement rule and keeps the dissent in the margin. That's what Chapter 24 is about. You don't hire a staff to agree with you. You hire it to catch you.
Hiring the QC
The QC hire is the one most coordinators make most personally, and it's the one most often made through a phone call to a friend. Here's how Teo got his job, the August before last. The QC we had then left in July for a college job. Teo had sent us a breakdown of our own third-down offense, unasked: twenty pages with three tendencies we didn't know we had, one of them wrong. A coach on his GA staff, who'd worked with me at the mid-major, called to vouch for him. I hired him because of the breakdown, including the one he got wrong. He'd marked it with a question mark and written "small sample — check," which told me he knew the difference between a tell and a coincidence. The phone call got his twenty pages read. The twenty pages got him hired.
When Teo got the FCS call, the first thing he did, before deciding anything, was start writing the test he thinks his replacement should have to pass, whenever that day comes. His draft has four parts:
- Tag thirty snaps of an opponent's defense on twelve fields, in two hours.
- Find two tells and state each one with its sample size and a "since" date.
- Write one row of a "by situation" page in plain English a quarterback could read on a Saturday.
- Defend it at the whiteboard against a defensive coach for fifteen minutes.
There's no résumé section. "If they can do those four things," Teo said, "I don't care where they went to school." That's the most useful hiring sentence anyone has said in our building this year.
🔄 Check your understanding: Teo was hired partly because of a tendency he got wrong. Explain why that helped him, and connect it to one part of the QC test he drafted.
Answer
He'd marked the wrong tendency with a question mark and "small sample — check." That showed he could tell a tell from a coincidence, which is the judgment a QC's work depends on. His test asks every candidate to state each tell with its sample size and a "since" date for the same reason: the habit of doubting your own evidence matters more than finding the tell.
🏫 Any level: A high-school coordinator rarely hires anyone. His "staff" is the teachers who'll stay after school, a volunteer or two, and whoever the head coach brings in. The principle survives anyway. Give each assistant a voice and a job he owns, such as the scout team, the self-scout tally, or the second-half adjustments sheet. Then ask him for his dissent on Thursday, while it can still change Friday. In college, the GA is your QC. Hire GAs on work samples, not on who called you, and give them a real room in practice.
37.9 Fired, and Coming Back
The morning Walt's staff was let go, he called all of us into the meeting room, sat on the edge of the table, and said, "They fired the staff. They didn't fire the work. Take the work with you." Then he went home and, as far as I know, never coached again.
Here's what I did in the nineteen days that followed, and what I'd tell anyone in the same chair:
- Don't say anything in public you'll want back. Every person who fires you is someone you'll coach with or against again. The profession is small, and it remembers.
- Cut your film while it's fresh. Within the week, I'd cut the twenty best examples of our passing game with a one-line explanation of the rule behind each one. That cut-up was in the wide-zone coordinator's hands on day five.
- Call the people who've seen your work, and ask for information, not jobs. "Who's hiring a passing-game coach?" is a question people can answer. "Can you get me a job?" is one they mostly can't.
- Take the job where you'll learn, even if it's a lateral title. Passing-game coordinator on a wide-zone staff was the same title I'd just lost. It was also the year that gave Austin its whole twelve-personnel identity.
Curtis Bale's firing went differently. After his second season as a coordinator, he was out for more than a season, and when we finally had a long dinner, he wanted to talk about the officiating, the injuries, and his quarterback. Somewhere in the second hour, he asked me what I thought had happened, and I told him: the defenses changed and his offense didn't have a next play. He was quiet for a while. That conversation was the first time I'd seen him look at his own film the way he looked at everyone else's. The firing is not the end of a career. The refusal to learn from it usually is.
🧩 Productive struggle: Before you read my advice to Teo, decide what you'd tell him. His inputs: he's 26, single, and in his second season as an NFL QC. His film work is excellent, but he's never coached his own room. The FCS offer makes him passing-game coordinator and quarterbacks coach, with recruiting duties, under a head coach who was the coordinator at the college where Teo was a GA. The school is a day's drive from his parents in El Paso. If he stays, the next rung is assistant position coach in one to three seasons, maybe here, maybe not. The pay is roughly a wash once he counts the cost of moving. What questions would you need answered before you'd advise him, and what would you tell him?
Here's what I told him, in the form of four questions. They are the same four I'd ask about any job at any level.
- What will I learn there that I can't learn here? For Teo: how to coach a room, how to build half a game plan and defend it, how to recruit. He can't learn any of those as a QC, no matter how long he stays.
- Who will I learn it from, and how secure is he? He knows the head coach, and the head coach knows his work, which is the tree working the way it should. The risk is the one from Section 37.5: if that head coach is fired, the whole staff goes. Teo should ask him, directly, how long his contract runs and what the administration expects.
- Who else does this move? For Teo, nobody else gives anything up, and his family gains a son who's closer to home. For me at twenty-nine, the answer was Dana, and the baby we were already hoping for, and that changed the math.
- Can I come back? This is the question young coaches skip. Teo will leave the NFL with two seasons of QC film work that I'll vouch for, the "Kimbrough by situation" template he built, and a phone number in Austin that'll answer. NFL staffs hire college quarterbacks coaches every January. The door behind him isn't locked.
And one rule that goes on top of all four: never take a job to get away from one. Take it to get toward something. Teo isn't running from anything. He's running toward a room.
"So you think I should go," Teo said.
"I think you already know what you're going to say on Monday," I told him. "I think you wanted somebody to check the math. The math checks." Then I went and got two more coffees, because that's what I do, and because I didn't want him to see my face for a minute.
How it ends belongs to the last chapter of this book.
📋 Try it — Make the call: A high-school offensive coordinator, 31, is in his sixth season at a school where he's won two league titles. He's married, his spouse teaches at the same high school, and they have a two-year-old. He has two offers. (A) A GA spot at a big-conference program three states away: tuition and a modest stipend, a two-year commitment, and an offensive coordinator who's openly mentoring him. (B) The head-coaching job at a smaller high school twenty minutes away, with a raise in the coaching stipend and a teaching job for him, but no job for his spouse. Run the four questions and make the call. The reasoning is graded, not the answer.
Answer
Q1, what will he learn? (A) teaches the film room, a big program's process, and access to a college tree. (B) teaches running a whole program: discipline, scheduling, parents, and a defense. Both are real learning, so the tiebreak is where he wants to end up. If the goal is college or the NFL, (A) is the only door. If the goal is a career as a high-school head coach, (B) is the next rung and (A) is a detour.
Q2, who will he learn from? (A) has a named mentor, which is worth a lot. Ask how secure that coordinator is, because GAs can lose their spots when a staff turns over. (B) has no mentor, so he'd be the top of the tree immediately.
Q3, who else moves? In (A), his spouse gives up a teaching job and needs a new one three states away, on top of a toddler and a large pay cut for two years. In (B), the family stays put, but they're no longer at the same school.
Q4, can he come back? From (A), yes. Successful high-school coaches return to high-school jobs all the time, often with more to offer. From (B), the college door gets harder to reopen the longer he stays, because college staffs hire GAs young.
A defensible call: if he and his spouse want college or the NFL, and they can afford two lean years, take (A), but only after the spouse has a realistic job plan in the new town. If either condition fails, take (B) and build a program good enough that college coaches come to his building. Both answers are fine. What isn't fine is deciding without asking Q3 out loud.
37.10 Practical Advice for an Aspiring Coach, at Any Level
You may be reading this as a high-school assistant, a former player, a film-room analyst, or a fan who's wondered all season whether he could do this. Here's where each of you starts.
| Where you're starting | First rung to aim for | What to build now | The trap to avoid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Teacher or high-school assistant | A position group you own, then the coordinator job | Clean game film, a one-page philosophy, a self-scout habit | Copying a college playbook your kids can't run |
| Former college player | GA or high-school assistant | A notebook on every coach you played for: what to keep, what to change | Thinking playing taught you to coach. It taught you to be coached. |
| Analyst or film-room person | College analyst, NFL QC or fellowship, or high-school volunteer | Breakdowns of real games, with sample sizes and "since" dates | Showing off data without a recommendation a coach could act on |
| Career changer | High-school volunteer or assistant | Your teaching ability and your adult habits, which young coaches lack | Expecting the ladder to skip rungs because you're older. It won't, but it can go faster. |
One habit covers all four rows: stay a learner. The day you stop being scared of what you don't know, it's time to move rungs, even if the next rung pays less.
🔄 Check your understanding: Of Lyle's four job questions, which one do young coaches most often skip, and why does it matter more in coaching than in most careers?
Answer
"Can I come back?" It matters more in coaching because jobs are filled fast through networks and short hiring windows. A move that takes you out of the networks that hire for your goal, or out of the age range a ladder usually hires from (such as GAs), can close a door permanently. Knowing whether the door behind you stays open tells you how big a risk the move really is.
Spaced Review
Answer each question before you read the answer below it.
1. From Chapter 36: how many adjustments should a halftime fix contain, and why? Two or three at most. Players can absorb only a few changes in roughly a dozen minutes, and an adjustment the line can't execute is worse than none. Notice that the same triage logic applies to a career decision: Lyle's four questions are a halftime sheet for a job offer. A long list of pros and cons is the coaching equivalent of nine adjustments: nobody can execute it.
2. From Chapter 23: what are Walt Dupree's three report questions, and why did they belong to a mentor's lineage? What do they do? What can't they do? What do they do when we do X? (Lyle added a fourth of his own: what will they leave, and is my guy better than theirs there?) They reached Austin because Lyle sat in Walt's room as a QC. That is the coaching tree from Section 37.4 working at the level of a single sheet of paper, with ideas traveling through people rather than books.
3. From Chapter 1: what did Wade Harmon ask Lyle to write on a napkin, and where does that napkin belong in this chapter's binder? "What do you believe? One napkin." Lyle wrote four lines: motion for information, the run for credibility, the pass for the kill, and every play is the reason the next one works. That's Tab 1 of the interview binder, the philosophy page. If yours doesn't fit on a napkin, it won't survive a head coach flipping to it for thirty seconds.
Project Checkpoint: Coordinator Interview Binder
Last chapter you built your In-Game Adjustment Protocol: series charting and a halftime template for two or three adjustments. That protocol becomes one page of this deliverable, because head coaches ask about halftime in almost every coordinator interview.
This chapter's deliverable: the Coordinator Interview Binder. It's the packet you'd hand a head coach, sized to be sampled, not read.
Format. Ten tabs, as in the table in Section 37.6, no more than 30 pages in all. Each tab opens with a one-sentence rule ("On third-and-medium, at least one route breaks at the sticks"), then the material that rule generates. Each tab should come from a deliverable you've already built: your philosophy (Ch 1), formations and personnel (Ch 3–4), call grammar and wristband (Ch 8), install calendar (Ch 34), game plan and script (Ch 24), call sheet (Ch 25), QB plan (Ch 35), dashboard (Ch 28), and your new Staff and First 90 Days tabs.
Worked example (Tab 10, First 90 Days, from Teo's draft for his FCS interview):
Rule: install the language before the plays. Days 1–14: meet every quarterback alone; watch every snap of last season's passing game; write the "since" page on our own offense. Days 15–45: teach the call grammar and the route tree to the QB room. Pass/fail test: the "eleven-man say-back." Days 46–75: spring install, three concepts per week, each tied to the run it imitates. Days 76–90: first self-scout; cut anything the quarterbacks can't explain in one sentence.
Choose your level: - High school: Add an academics and eligibility page and a feeder program page, and cut Tab 8 down to a one-page self-scout tally. Your audience is a head coach and often a principal or athletic director. - College: Add a recruiting plan (the positions you'll recruit and what you'll look for) and a field and boundary page, because of the wide college hash. - Pro: Keep all ten tabs. Make Tab 5 a real game plan against the Sacramento Sentinels using Appendix G, because that's how a head coach will test whether you can plan against a coverage-first, pressure-on-purpose defense. - Film room: Build a binder for a real coordinator hire this January. Use only public film and public information to fill the ten tabs as you'd expect that coordinator's to read, then grade his first four games against it.
Next chapter: Tab 2 of your binder needs a System Map: one diagram showing how your run, pass, screen, play-action, RPO, and tempo pieces answer each other. That's the deliverable for Chapter 38.
Chapter Summary
The ladder. The skills stack: film work (GA, QC) → coaching a room (position coach) → owning half a plan (passing-game or run-game coordinator) → owning the calls (coordinator) → owning everything (head coach). Judge a job by the skill it forces you to learn, not by its title.
The trees. Coordinator hires travel through coaching trees because they're fast bets on people the head coach has already seen under pressure, people who speak his language. Documented trees (Walsh → Holmgren → Reid, Parcells, Shanahan) carry ideas and habits, but not one scheme. "Who you know" means "who has seen your work."
The grind. In-season weeks often run far past seventy hours, with the longest for the youngest. Pay is lowest when you're youngest and moving most. Families pay costs the coach never sees on his own ledger. Staffs are fired as units, and NFL staffs are rebuilt in about two weeks.
The interview. It's a whiteboard test of how you think. Count the defense the way it counts itself, change the read before the play, and volunteer what beats you. The binder is sampled, not read, so every page must be installable.
The Rooney Rule. Adopted in 2003 and revised many times. It governs interviews. The pipeline into GA, QC, and quarterbacks-room jobs is where the profession's makeup is really decided.
The decision framework, for any job at any level:
| Question | What you're really asking | Red flag |
|---|---|---|
| 1. What will I learn there that I can't learn here? | Is this the next skill on my ladder? | "Nothing new, but the title's bigger" |
| 2. Who will I learn it from, and how secure is he? | Is there a teacher, and will he be there in a year? | A boss on the hot seat with a one-year contract |
| 3. Who else does this move? | What does my family pay? | Nobody at home has been asked |
| 4. Can I come back? | Does the door behind me stay open? | Leaving the only network that hires for your goal |
| Overall rule | Am I moving toward something? | Taking a job to get away from one |
What's Next
Every page of Teo's binder, and of yours, depends on one diagram he hasn't drawn yet: how all the pieces of an offense answer each other. Chapter 38 builds that System Map, revisiting all four of our anchor plays as one system. It's where the central idea of this book gets its fullest form: an offense is a system of constraints, and every play is the answer to the defense's answer to another play.