Chapter 1 Exercises — Offensive Philosophy

Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall and understanding · ⭐⭐ application and recognition · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension (research, film study, open-ended)

Selected answers appear in Appendix J. Short answers for Part C are included below in collapsible blocks so you can check your reasoning — but write yours first. The Austin Outlaws, Sacramento Sentinels, and other league teams in these exercises are fictional.


Part A — Conceptual ⭐

A1. State, in one sentence, the single structural advantage the offense has over the defense. Then name the three "multipliers" this book uses to enlarge it, and give a one-line definition of each.

A2. List the six levels of the offensive hierarchy from most durable to most specific. For each, give its typical lifespan.

A3. The chapter says "problems should be solved at the lowest level that can solve them." Give an example of a problem that belongs at the call-sheet level and one that belongs at the philosophy level.

A4. Explain the difference between a slogan ("Run the ball, stop the run") and a philosophy, using the chapter's two-coaches test.

A5. For each of the three families — run-first, pass-first, and balanced/multiple — name (a) its core belief, (b) its "safe" early-down play, and (c) the situation it fears most.

A6. What is a box count? Count the box and the blockers in this description, and say which side has the extra man: the offense is in 12 personnel with both tight ends attached and one back; the defense has four linemen, three linebackers, and the strong safety at seven yards outside the right tight end.

A7. Explain the quarterback-run "+1" in plain English. Why does a running quarterback change the arithmetic of the run game even on plays where he hands the ball off?

A8. What does "Motion for information" mean in the Outlaws' thesis? What are the two most common things motion tells the quarterback?

A9. The chapter lists six recurring ideas. Write each as a one-sentence rule a player could remember.

A10. What is the "zero bin," and why did the Outlaws' max-protect deep over sit third on that list rather than first?


Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐

B1. Study this pre-snap picture.

            F                                          $
   C               *         W       M                       C
                          E   T   N    E
   X          H           O   O   O   O   O   Y          Z
                              R Q

📊 Diagram (described): The offense has a split end and slot on the left, a tight end attached on the right with a flanker outside him, and a quarterback in the shotgun with the back on his left. The defense shows two deep safeties, two corners, a nickel defender over the slot, two linebackers, and four linemen.

(a) What personnel grouping is the offense in? (b) What is the defense's shell — MOFO or MOFC? (c) How many defenders are in the box, and how many blockers does the offense have if the tight end blocks? (d) Which defender would you most like to put in conflict on a run to the right, and why?

B2. A broadcast replay shows this sequence on one drive, all from the same formation: inside zone right for 5; inside zone right for 7; a play-action pass off identical inside-zone action, with a post thrown behind the strong safety for 35; inside zone right for a 4-yard touchdown. Identify which of the three multipliers each snap relies on most, and explain what the strong safety's behavior on the fourth snap tells you.

B3. Describe what the Will linebacker did on each of the first two snaps of the Outlaws' opening drive in Game 1 (the "Inside Slant" RPO), and where the ball went each time. Then draw (in words or a sketch) the post-snap picture for the snap where the Will sits.

B4. Here is a defensive picture before and after the snap:

BEFORE:        $ (13)                           F (13)
AFTER:     $ down to the flat/curl      F spins to the deep middle
           corners bail to deep thirds

📊 Diagram (described): Before the snap, two safeties stand about thirteen yards deep, one on each side. After the snap, one safety drops down toward the short zone near the sideline, the other spins to the deep middle, and the corners retreat to the deep outside thirds.

(a) What did the shell show pre-snap and what was the coverage post-snap? (b) Why is a post route built to split two safeties dangerous against this? (c) Name the Outlaws snap from this chapter where exactly this happened, with down, distance, and result.

B5. Watch for this on any broadcast: an offense comes out in two tight ends, and the defense immediately substitutes a defensive back for a linebacker. What does that substitution suggest the defense has learned about the offense's two-tight-end grouping? Connect your answer to idea 6 ("threaten what you don't want to do").

B6. You're charting an opponent's first three possessions. Of 22 snaps, the offense has motioned on 15. In 11 of those 15, a defender ran across the formation with the motion man. On those 11, the offense threw a man-beating concept 9 times. What is this offense using motion for, and what simple question can a defense ask itself to disrupt the pattern?

B7. Study this pre-snap picture and the two descriptions of what happened after the snap.

            F                                          $
   C               *        (W)       M                      C
                          E   T   N    E
   X          H           O   O   O   O   O   Y          Z
                              R Q

📊 Diagram (described): The offense is in 11 personnel, two-by-two, with the tight end attached on the right; the back is beside the quarterback. The defense shows two deep safeties, a nickel over the left slot, and the weak-side linebacker circled as the read defender.

Snap A: the line blocks inside zone right; the circled linebacker runs downhill into the backside A gap; the quarterback pulls the ball and throws a slant to the left slot for 17 yards. Snap B: same call; the circled linebacker drops toward the slot; the quarterback hands off and the back gains 7.

(a) What kind of play is this? (b) Which defender is in conflict, and what are his two jobs? (c) The defense wants to take this player out of the conflict. Describe one adjustment that would let him play only the run, and say which offensive player would then be the next one to attack.


Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

C1. ⭐⭐ Make the call (philosophy level). You inherit a high school offense. Your quarterback is a strong-armed pocket passer, 6-foot-2, who can't run. Your line is big and slow. You have two tight ends who can both block and catch, a good running back, and one average receiver. You get nine hours of practice a week. Which family is your home? Write a one-sentence thesis.

Short answer

A defensible answer is run-first with play-action, from multiple-tight-end personnel: "We run gap schemes behind our big line from two-tight-end sets, and we throw play-action to our tight ends when the defense commits to the run." The big, slow line suits power and counter more than zone; two capable tight ends make 12 personnel a genuine run-or-pass grouping; the pocket quarterback with a strong arm thrives on play-action from a stable pocket. The average receiver group means the passing game should feature tight ends and the back, not isolation routes outside. A spread philosophy would put your weakest players (receivers) in your most important roles.

C2. ⭐⭐ Make the call (call level). Game 1, fourth quarter, Outlaws trailing 27–20. You've run inside zone right twice from Gun Doubles Right, and the Sentinels' strong safety has filled the alley harder each time. It's first-and-10 at the Sacramento 39. Your sheet offers: (a) inside zone right again; (b) "Inside PA, Gaines Post"; (c) a quick hitch to Sutton on the left. Make the call and justify it in three sentences, including the protection.

Short answer

Call (b), "Inside PA, Gaines Post." The safety's behavior over two snaps says he is committed to the alley, and he will never be more committed than right now — running it a third time risks him adjusting on his own and wasting the setup. Use seven-man protection (the tight end stays in), which handles a five-man rush; the far safety is on the opposite hash with Sutton and can't help over the post. (In the game, the post gained 35 yards to the Sacramento 4.)

C3. ⭐⭐⭐ Draw it up. Draw the Inside Slant RPO from Gun Doubles Right against a two-high nickel defense: one PRE-SNAP diagram, and two POST-SNAP diagrams — one where the Will triggers, one where he sits. Label the read defender with parentheses, show the ball path with a dotted arrow, and write a described line under each diagram.

Short answer

Your pre-snap should show 11 personnel 2x2 (H and X left; Y attached and Z right), the back offset beside the quarterback, two deep safeties, a nickel over the slot, and the Will circled as (W) on the weak side. Post-snap 1: the line steps right on inside zone; the Will runs downhill into his gap; the slant angles in behind him; the ball path goes from the quarterback to the slant. Post-snap 2: the Will drops toward the slant window; the ball path goes from the quarterback to the back on the zone run. Every diagram needs a described line. Compare with the three diagrams in section 1.6.

C4. ⭐⭐⭐ Make the call (fourth down). First quarter, you lead 7–0. Fourth-and-goal at the opponent's 3. Your analyst says the model leans "go," but narrowly, and your own sample from the 3 is five attempts. Your three plays from inside the 6 just gained a total of three yards against three different looks. You have one short-yardage call you've been saving for the fourth quarter. Do you go or kick? Defend your answer with one argument from the data and one argument the data can't see.

Short answer

Either answer can be defended; the grading is on reasoning. Go: the model, built on large league samples, says the expected value favors going; three short gains against three different looks don't prove the next call fails, and the five-attempt team sample is too small to override it. Kick: the data can't see the value of a saved call in a likely close fourth quarter, nor how this defense's goal-line front matches your personnel; a 10–0 lead early is a modest but real gain. The key is not letting the result of the decision (whatever happens next) grade the decision itself.

C5. ⭐⭐⭐ Draw it up (box arithmetic). Draw two PRE-SNAP pictures of the same offense against two defenses: (a) 12 personnel tight vs. an eight-man box with one deep safety; (b) 10 personnel spread vs. a six-man box with two deep safeties. Under each, write the box count, the blocker count, and the one place each defense has conceded.

Short answer

(a) Box 8, blockers 7: the defense is plus-one against the run; it has conceded the perimeter (one-on-one outside) and the deep middle behind the eighth defender — play-action territory. (b) Box 6, blockers 5: still plus-one for the defense on a plain handoff, but a quarterback read evens it; the defense has conceded the run (relative to coverage) and the short areas underneath its two deep safeties.

C6. ⭐⭐⭐ Make the call (self-scout). Your self-scout shows that in 12 personnel you ran the ball 63% of the time, and opponents have started substituting a big nickel defender against it. Write three specific call-sheet changes that would make 12 personnel a credible pass threat without abandoning its run identity.

Short answer

Examples: (1) Feature a play-action pass off your best 12-personnel run on first down in plus territory — the tight end seam or a crosser. (2) Put a quick pass from 12 personnel in the second-and-medium box, such as a tight-end option route against the big nickel. (3) Detach one tight end into the slot and throw from a spread look, forcing the big nickel to cover in space. The goal is a run/pass split that no longer tells the defense the answer.

C7. ⭐⭐⭐ Make the call (the forty seconds). Second quarter, Outlaws lead 10–7. Second-and-6 at the Sacramento 45. Teo, from the booth: "Two-high, Holloway at eleven yards over the tight end; their end on the tight-end side has been squeezing inside on every run." The play clock reads 33. Your sheet's second-and-medium box offers: (a) inside zone to the tight-end side from 11 personnel 2x2, Harlan attached right, Ruffin offset; (b) a quick out to Powers; (c) a play-action shot to Gaines. You'd like the call in Vance's helmet by 25. Make the call, and write the one-sentence reason you'd give Vance.

Short answer

A strong answer is (a), inside zone to the tight-end side — with the reason "Their end is squeezing and their safety is deep; if the end crashes inside, the back can bounce it outside where the safety has the farthest to come." A squeezing end creates a cutback-or-bounce opportunity on zone, and a two-high shell keeps the extra run defender far away. (In Game 1, this exact situation produced Ruffin's 45-yard touchdown: the end squeezed, the Will filled the wrong gap, the strong safety took a flat angle, and Ruffin bounced it.) (c) is defensible as a sequencing call later, once the safety has started filling — but you haven't earned the shot yet.


Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐

D1. Volatility. You're a large underdog against a better team. Which family of philosophy, played to its extreme, gives you the best chance to win, even if it gives you a worse average result? Explain using the idea of variance. Then explain why the same choice would be a mistake as the favorite.

D2. The quarterback's health. Your quarterback is the league's best runner at his position and the only reason your offense works. Your option game produces your best plays. Write a policy — not a play — that governs how many designed quarterback runs you'll call per game and under what conditions you'll call more. What is the trade-off you're accepting?

D3. The tendency dilemma. Teo's page says a defense has played the same coverage on third-and-long 29 straight times. You have a play that destroys that coverage. What are the arguments for calling it on the biggest third down of the game, and what are the arguments for building in a check? Explain how the Outlaws' "middle-read tag" is meant to solve this dilemma.

D4. Ego. A respected former colleague tells you your offense is "boring" and that you should add more gadgets. Your team is winning with a narrow, sequenced offense. How do you decide whether he has a point? Name one kind of gadget that would strengthen your philosophy and one that would only satisfy your ego.

D5. Multiple vs. narrow. A new head coach wants you to be "multiple — a power team one week and a spread team the next." You have a young offensive line and eight installation days in camp. Write the argument you'd make to him for "multiple on the surface, narrow underneath."


Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

Because this is the first chapter, these questions mix this chapter's ideas with each other and with what you already know from watching football. From Chapter 2 on, Part M will draw on named earlier chapters.

M1. Combine sections 1.2 (the hierarchy) and 1.6 (idea 4, the conversation). The Game 3 interception was caused by a tendency trusted too long. At which level of the hierarchy did the failure start, and at which level is the fix (the middle-read tag) being applied? Is that the lowest level that can solve it?

M2. Combine section 1.3 (the three families) and section 1.4 (the five philosophies). Place each of the five traditions on a two-axis grid: run-first ↔ pass-first and narrow menu ↔ broad menu. Which two traditions sit closest together, and which two are farthest apart?

M3. Combine idea 2 (conflict) and idea 6 (threaten what you don't want to do). Explain why an RPO like Inside Slant is simultaneously a conflict play and a way to keep the run game credible against a defense that wants to drop seven into coverage.

M4. Combine section 1.7 (the forty seconds) and idea 3 (execution). List three things that must happen between the play clock reading 15 and the snap for the zero-bin deep over to succeed against a six-man pressure, and name the player responsible for each.

M5. Combine section 1.8 (fit) and the Curtis Bale story with idea 5 (analytics). Suppose Bale's analyst had shown him, midway through his second season, that his early-down pass rate was far above what his opponents' defensive structure justified and that his sack rate on long-developing throws was climbing. Using the chapter's language, explain why "analytics informs; it doesn't decide" would still have required Bale to change his philosophy, not just his calls.

M6. Combine section 1.5 (the Outlaws' personnel assumptions) with section 1.8 (the fit audit). Suppose Darius Vance misses six weeks with an injury and Ty Lindgren, a 34-year-old veteran backup who is accurate and decisive but cannot run and has an average arm, takes over. Go line by line through the Outlaws' thesis and non-negotiables. Which lines survive unchanged, which must be scaled back, and which belong at the game-plan level rather than the philosophy level during his starts? Write the two-sentence note you'd hand Rome Pettaway, the quarterbacks coach, on Monday.


Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐

E1. Infer a philosophy. Choose one NFL offense. Watch two full games (All-22 or end-zone film if you can get it; broadcast if not). Chart every snap: personnel grouping, formation family (2x2, 3x1, other), motion (yes/no), and play type (run, RPO, play-action, dropback, screen). From your chart, write that offense's philosophy in the format of this chapter's Project Checkpoint — thesis, non-negotiables, personnel assumptions, and the "never" list — and cite the evidence for each line. Then compare it to what the team's coaches have said publicly. Where do the chart and the words disagree?

E2. Sequence hunting. In one game, find three sequences of two to four plays in which an earlier play visibly set up a later one (the same formation, a defender's reaction changing, a play-action pass behind a defender who filled on earlier runs). For each, write down down, distance, field position, quarter, score, and the defender whose behavior changed. Use public play-by-play data (nflverse play-by-play, for instance) to confirm downs and yardage.

E3. The family tree in the box score. Using public charting or play-by-play data, compare two offenses with very different reputations — one widely described as run-first and one as pass-first — on early-down pass rate, play-action rate (if your source charts it), and use of 11 versus 12 personnel. Do the numbers match the reputations? Write a short note on where they don't, and on the limitations of your data source (what it charts, what it guesses, what it can't see).