Chapter 18 Exercises — Four Verticals, Post-Safety, and Deep Passing
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ apply the idea · ⭐⭐⭐ judgment and trade-offs · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension, research, or film study
Selected answers are in Appendix J. Part C items include short worked answers here. Every Outlaws, Sentinels, Stallions, Pioneers, and Forge situation in Parts C, D, and M that isn't described in the chapter is hypothetical: a practice scenario, not a snap from our season.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. Define MOFO and MOFC. Name two coverages that usually show each before the snap.
A2. How many deep defenders does each of these coverages have: Cover 3, Cover 2, Tampa 2, Quarters, Cover 1, Cover 0?
A3. In one sentence, why is four verticals against Cover 3 called "four on three"? Which defender is in conflict?
A4. What is a "match" Cover 3, and why does it make plain four verticals harder to complete?
A5. Explain the difference between a fade and a back-shoulder throw. What does the corner's position tell the quarterback about which one to throw?
A6. What's a post-safety concept? Name three from this chapter, and give the two routes that create the conflict in each.
A7. Why is Quarters the hardest coverage to beat with plain four verticals? What does the Outlaws' "convert" rule do about it?
A8. What is the look-off, and what does Rome Pettaway mean by "Eyes buy the step. Feet throw the ball."?
A9. List the five triggers in the Outlaws' "when we call it" shot rule.
A10. What does "the shell is not the coverage" mean, and which snap in this chapter shows it most expensively?
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
B1. Pre-snap, the defense shows one safety at 15 yards in the middle and corners at 7 yards. At the snap the corners bail, the safety stays in the middle, and the two linebackers and nickel drop to spots without running with any receiver. The offense runs four verticals. Identify the coverage, the conflict defender, and the throw if the safety opens his hips to the left.
B2. Pre-snap: two safeties at 12 yards. At the snap both corners jam and squat at about 5 yards, the middle linebacker turns and runs straight down the middle with the right seam, and the right safety widens toward the right go. What's the coverage, and where should the quarterback look?
B3. Study this post-snap picture.
^ X go $ sits at 11, F sits at 11, ^ Z go
| C runs eyes on H eyes on Y | C runs
| ^ ^ |
| | H seam | Y seam |
E T N E
O O O O O
Q
📊 Diagram (described): Both corners run with the outside go routes. Both safeties sit at about 11 yards, flat-footed, with their eyes on the two inside receivers, who are running seams straight at them. Underneath, three defenders cover the width of the field.
Identify the coverage. What should #2 do under the Outlaws' rules, and where is the quarterback's best throw if both safeties carry the seams?
B4. Pre-snap: two high at 13. Post-snap: the strong safety drops toward the curl zone and the free safety spins from the right hash to the deep middle. The offense is running Mills to the right: Z post, H dig. Name the defensive movement, and say which route should get the ball and why.
B5. A receiver alone on the backside runs a go. At 12 yards the corner is on his upfield shoulder, back to the quarterback, running hard. The free safety is 20 yards away on the far hash. What's the throw, and where is it placed?
B6. On film, a single-high safety starts each snap in the middle of the field at 14 yards. On every snap you chart, the quarterback looks at the left seam on his first two steps and throws to the right. On eight of ten snaps the safety took a step left first. What is the quarterback doing, and what does that tell you about this safety?
B7. In Game 1, Powers motioned across to make trips against Quarters, and the Sentinels had a check that sent the backside safety to the middle. Draw (or describe) the post-snap picture if every defender had executed the check. Where would Vance's eyes have gone?
B8. Study this post-snap picture from a play-action pass.
^ X post F stays in the middle,
\ / over the post
\_____________/
C sits <=============================== Z deep over
deep (about 20 yds) \
S W M step up to the run fake |
E T T E Z
U-] O O O O O [-Y
Q ..fake..> R
📊 Diagram (described): After a run fake, three linebackers step toward the line. The X runs a post from the left; the only deep safety stays in the middle over it. The Z runs a deep over from the right, crossing at about 20 yards behind the linebackers and in front of the left corner, who stays deep in his outside third. Both tight ends and the back stay in to block.
Name the concept, the coverage, the defender the quarterback reads, and the throw. Then say what the safety would have to do to make the other route the throw.
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
C1. Draw it up ⭐⭐. Draw All Go from Gun Doubles Right (Harlan attached right) against Cover 2. Show the quarterback's pre-snap choice of a side, the half-field safety's conflict on that side, and both possible throws. Include the described line.
Short answer
Pick the side with the wider or shallower safety, or the better matchup, say the left (Sutton and Powers). The left safety has Sutton's go outside him and Powers's seam inside him. If he widens to the go, throw Powers's seam inside him. If he stays on the seam, throw Sutton's go in the hole over the squatting corner at 18–22 yards. If the corner sinks under the go instead of squatting, the flat is free underneath. The described line has to say that the corners squat, each safety has two vertical routes in his half, and the quarterback reads one safety.
C2. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐. Hypothetical. Week 10 at Portland (fictional). Second quarter, Outlaws 7, Pioneers 7. 2nd-and-2 at our 46. Teo's chart says Portland's Mike, Owen Talbert, carries the seam to our strength on almost every two-seam snap, and the Pioneers have played Tampa 2 on most second downs. Personnel: Eleven. Choose between (a) All Go, Harlan attached right; (b) Yankee from Twelve off Inside PA; (c) inside zone. Say which defender you're asking a question, and why.
Short answer
(a) All Go, worked to the weak side. It's a free down in the shot zone. Against Tampa 2 the Mike takes the strong seam (Harlan's), so the read is the weak-side safety: Powers's seam inside him or Sutton's go in the hole outside him. Yankee is a single-high beater and Portland is mostly two-high here; inside zone is defensible but wastes a free down against a defense that's keeping two safeties deep. The defender you're asking is the weak-side half-field safety.
C3. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐. Hypothetical. Against the Sentinels' "Home" (nickel, Over, Quarters, four-man rush). 1st-and-10 at our 40, third quarter, tied. You want an explosive. Choose and justify: (a) plain All Go; (b) scissors from Gaines's reduced split; (c) scissors from a normal split; (d) post-wheel to Powers's side.
Short answer
(c) Scissors from a normal split or (d) post-wheel. Both attack Quarters by giving the safety over
2 a route that takes him away from #1's post (scissors) or by drawing the corner inside to leave the
sideline for the wheel (post-wheel). (a) is four on four against Quarters. (b) is the right concept from the wrong look: the reduced split was a known tell, and the Sentinels had it before Game 1.
C4. Draw it up ⭐⭐. Draw Dagger from Gun Doubles Right, run to the left, against Cover 3. Label the seam, the deep dig's depth, and the defender the seam is supposed to move.
Short answer
Powers (H, left slot) runs the seam up the left hash; Sutton (X) runs a dig at 15–16 yards behind it, breaking toward the middle. The seam moves the hook defender (who carries it) and holds the free safety over the top. The dig crosses behind the hook defender and under the safety. Backside: Harlan check-releases, Gaines runs a go. Read: seam → dig → checkdown.
C5. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐. Hypothetical. Week 8 vs. Birmingham (fictional). Fourth quarter, Outlaws ahead by 4, 2nd-and-7 at the Birmingham 38. The Forge are in press Cover 1, with the free safety centered rather than shaded to trips. You have "Trips Right, Stick, X Fade" ready. What's Vance's rule on the snap, and what are the two most likely outcomes?
Short answer
"X Fade" reads the corner and the safety. If the safety stays centered or drifts to trips and the corner is on top, it's the back-shoulder to Sutton. If the safety drifts toward Sutton, it's the front side: the stick to Harlan. The two most likely outcomes are a back-shoulder of 12–18 yards or a 5–7-yard stick. Notice the field position: at the Birmingham 38 you're in Dorsey's range, so this tag is attractive because it's a quick throw that rarely risks a sack.
C6. Draw it up ⭐⭐⭐. Draw Yankee from "Twelve, Under Ace Right, Inside PA" against Quarters. Show why it struggles. Then name one change (formation, route, or concept) that would make it better against Quarters.
Short answer
Against Quarters there are four deep defenders. The post runs into a safety or a corner who's already deep, and the deep over runs into the opposite corner and safety, who don't need to bite on the run fake. One fix: replace Yankee with scissors or post-wheel, which attack how Quarters assigns
2. Another: keep play-action but turn the deep over into a deep dig under the safeties at 15 and use
the post only as a clear-out.
C7. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐. Hypothetical. Sudden change: your defense has just intercepted a pass and returned it to the opponent's 44. Second quarter, you lead 10–7. The opponent's defense has played two-high on every first down today, and Teo's booth note says their safeties rotated after the snap on 4 of 9 first downs. Your best rusher matchup problem is on the left side. Choose a first-down call from your shot box and defend it in four sentences: the concept, the protection, the defender you read, and what happens if they rotate.
Short answer
A strong answer is All Go with conversions from 60, chipping or sliding to the left-side rusher, because it reads the middle after the snap: if they stay two-high, read the half-field safety (or convert against Quarters); if they rotate to one high, throw the seam away from the safety who arrives in the middle. Sudden change and the shot zone both say "shot," and 4 of 9 rotations says you can't pick a two-high-only concept. Mills or scissors are defensible only with a post-snap middle read built in. A Yankee call bets on single-high, which they haven't shown on first down. Whatever you call, the protection has to account for the left-side rusher, because a sack here gives back the field position the interception just won.
C8. Draw it up ⭐⭐. Draw scissors from "Eleven, Gun Doubles Left, Z Nasty" against Quarters, with the ball on the left hash. Label the safety over #2, show his reaction to the corner route, and show where the post goes. Then redraw it from a normal split and explain why the normal-split version is harder for a defense to predict.
Short answer
Powers (#2) runs vertically and breaks toward the right pylon at 12; Gaines (#1, reduced split) runs a post that crosses inside him. The right safety, reading #2, widens with the corner route, and the post goes into the space he left. From a normal split, Gaines starts wider, so the post takes slightly longer to cross, but the defense can't use Gaines's alignment as a tell. A reduced split that predicts scissors most of the time gives the safety a head start; a normal split forces him to read it after the snap.
Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. Marisol's shots box numbers: 46 calls, 19 completions, 14 explosives, 3 sacks, 2 interceptions, 4 pass interference flags drawn. Her summary: "The median shot is an incompletion." Write a short paragraph for your head coach explaining why you'd keep calling shots anyway, and one situation where you wouldn't.
D2. Your quarterback has taken more hits than usual over three weeks, including two on deep throws. Your analytics director says your shots are still worth it on average. Your quarterbacks coach wants fewer seven-step shots. Who's right? Design a compromise using protection, concept choice, and timing.
D3. Lyle called Mills on 3rd-and-9 because the Sentinels had stayed two-high on twenty-nine straight third-and-long snaps. In 150–250 words, argue that the call was reasonable. Then, in another 150–250 words, argue that it was incomplete, using the idea of a post-snap middle read.
D4. Curtis Bale's offense led its conference in explosive plays one season and got him fired the next. Name two things his call sheet was missing, based on this chapter, and say how each would have changed what defenses did to him in year two.
D5. You're a high school coordinator with a quarterback who can throw a seam 22 yards on time but can't throw a field fade from the hash. Build a two-play shot package that fits his arm, and explain your "when we call it" rule.
What strong Part D answers have in common. They name a defender, not just a concept. They state what an incompletion, a sack, or an interception would cost in that situation, not just what a completion would gain. They separate the decision from the result: D3 in particular should grade the Mills call on what Lyle knew and what the call asked Vance to do, not on the interception. And they offer a concrete change (a protection, a tag, a rule on the call sheet) rather than "call better plays." For D1, a good paragraph uses the numbers honestly: 14 explosives and 4 interference flags on 46 calls is a lot of value from a play that usually fails, but 3 sacks and 2 interceptions are the price, which is why the shot needs a free down and a real protection. For D2, the compromise usually keeps the shots but changes their shape: fewer long-developing dropbacks, more play-action shots from seven- or eight-man protection, and more quick isolation throws (back-shoulders) that get the ball out before the hit arrives. For D4, think about sequence (nothing on Curtis's sheet made the shot look like anything else) and the two-high answer (when defenses took the deep ball away, he had no plan for the underneath space they gave him). For D5, build around what the arm can do on time, and measure your hash geometry first.
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (Chapters 16 and 18) ⭐⭐. Smash attacks the Cover 2 corner with a hitch under him and a corner route over him. All Go attacks the Cover 2 safety with a go outside him and a seam inside him. Explain how these are the same idea in two different directions. Which defender in each concept is in conflict, and which direction is the conflict (vertical or horizontal)?
M2. (Chapters 7 and 18) ⭐⭐⭐. Using the idea that "the shell is not the coverage" from Chapter 7, explain why All Go beat the Sentinels' rotation on 1st-and-10 in the fourth quarter of Game 3 while Mills lost to the same rotation on 3rd-and-9. Your answer has to talk about when each concept reads the safety.
M3. (Chapters 13 and 18) ⭐⭐⭐. In Anchor A of Chapter 13, the conflict defender was the Will linebacker, Jordan Ames: run fit or slant window. Identify the equivalent conflict defender in (a) Mills against Quarters and (b) Yankee against Cover 3. For each, say what he's "keyed" to and how the offense makes his key lie.
M4. (Chapters 8 and 18) ⭐⭐. The Game 1 41-yard post was fourteen words long, so it went in by band number. Write it the way it would appear on the Red panel of the wristband (number, short label, full call), and explain which of Chapter 8's rules forced it onto the band.
M5. (Chapters 15 and 18) ⭐⭐⭐. Chapter 15's threshold concept is that the quarterback reads a defender, not a receiver. Rewrite the read for each of these as a single sentence that names only defenders: All Go vs. Cover 3, Mills vs. Quarters, Yankee vs. single-high, and "X Fade" vs. press Cover 1.
M6. (Chapters 5, 18, and 22) ⭐⭐⭐. For the Game 1 zero-bin deep over, the Sentinels sent six. Using the protection vocabulary from Chapter 5 and this chapter, explain how many blockers Austin needed, who the sixth rusher was assigned to, and why the deep over sat third on the zero-bin list instead of first.
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. The deep-ball chart. Pick one NFL team and watch two of its games on All-22 (or the best wide-angle broadcast replays you can find). For every pass that travels 20 or more yards in the air, chart: down and distance, field position, the shell before the snap (MOFO, MOFC, or zero), the coverage two seconds after the snap, the number of blockers, where the quarterback's eyes went on his first two steps, the target, and the result. With 15 or more throws charted, write that team's "when we call it" rule as if you were its coordinator. Public play-by-play data (for example, the nflverse community's play-by-play, which includes air yards) can help you find the deep throws; the film tells you why they happened.
E2. The safety study. Pick one starting free safety. Chart 25 snaps where the offense threw beyond 15 yards. For each, note where he started, which way he opened his hips first, and whether the quarterback's eyes went to his side before the throw. Then answer: does this safety follow the quarterback's eyes? Would the look-off work on him? Which post-safety concept from this chapter would you call against him, and why?
E3. Hash geometry. Watch one college or high school game and chart every four-vertical-type throw (two or more seams) by where the ball was spotted: left hash, middle, or right hash. Does the offense change its landmarks or its read from the hash? Does the defense's boundary corner play differently from its field corner? Compare what you see with Case Study 2.