Chapter 39 — Instructor Notes
What this chapter is for
Chapter 39 is the capstone. It sorts thirty-eight deliverables into five binders, makes them agree, and runs the result against the Sacramento Sentinels. It opens on a Friday morning in April with card T-9, the divisional-week scout card that read 3RD & 9 — 2x2 — MILLS and Safeties stay high to the throw. Teo tapes it up, then lifts a second card with a pencil arrow on the strong safety and a question mark: "This package starts with the card I should have drawn."
The argument is that a capstone is not a stapler (§39.1). Assembly has three tests no single deliverable can pass: the napkin, parent, and receipt tests. The chapter shows the Outlaws' spine (§39.2), the 65-play core with its entrance exam and zero matrix (§39.3), the weekly process (§39.4), and the Game 3 plan graded box by box (§39.5). Then it hands students the template (§39.6), the 40-point rubric (§39.7), and a model of defending the work in a room (§39.8). There's no threshold concept, but the book's last 🪞 check-in is here.
Teaching objectives
By the end of the session a student should be able to:
- Sort the deliverables into five binders by rung and find two places where they contradict.
- Apply the napkin, parent, and receipt tests and say which rung each protects.
- Run a play through the six-question entrance exam and build a zero matrix with written accepted zeros.
- Fit a game plan to a rep budget at about two full-speed reps per call.
- Build a Sentinels contingency page with no blank rows, with a repped branch for the strongest streak.
- Score a capstone on the 40-point rubric and the five red flags, build before result.
- Present and defend one package under the four-step disagreement rule.
Timing
In a 75-minute session: 7 minutes on the hook. Spend 10 minutes on §39.1's three tests, then 12
on §39.3, starting with the 🧩 Productive struggle (students guess the run, screen, and gadget
counts before seeing 23, 5, and 3). Give 15 minutes to §39.5's contingency table and box-by-box
grading, 20 to §39.7 with the calibration exercise below, and 11 to §39.8's "argument I lost."
In a 150-minute block: add the whiteboard activity (25 minutes), the §39.5 📋 Try it — Find the
conflict (15), the §39.6 📋 Try it — Make the call (10), and Case Study 2 (15).
What to cut when you are behind: §39.4 and §39.9 go to reading; skim §39.2 to the napkin. Do not cut §39.5 or §39.7. Students can't self-grade without the graded Game 3 plan.
Where students get stuck
"A complete playbook means every deliverable is in the binder." Diagnostic: exercise A2. Intervention: Lyle's first college binder, with nine formation words on one sheet and eleven on another. The quarterback found every contradiction in July. Have students ask of two of their own pages: "What other page does this one have to agree with?"
"Built on the run means mostly runs." Diagnostic: quiz items 3 and 4. Intervention: "Count pictures before you count plays." Only 23 of the 65 core plays are run-side, but play-action, the boot family, and two of the three gadgets live inside run pictures.
"More calls means more prepared." Diagnostic: the §39.6 🔄 and exercise C5. Intervention:
the §39.3 🔍. Divisional week had 176 reps for a 112-call plan, and Marisol's caveated split favors
calls with two or more reps. Cut calls, not reps, but keep the branches for the strongest streaks.
"No blank rows" means every row has words in it. Diagnostic: quiz item 21, whose capstone has five full rows and none about third down. Intervention: "to be discussed Thursday" is "a blank row with better manners," and a missing row on the strongest streak is a blank row. The branch also has to be repped.
"The plan lost, so the plan was bad." Diagnostic: quiz item 14. Intervention: the §39.7 ⚠️. The Game 3 plan would score well on eight criteria and fail criterion 9.
Whiteboard / film-room activity
Draw both of Teo's cards, then make the room write the row.
CARD T-9 (divisional Thursday) THE CARD HE SHOULD HAVE DRAWN
3RD & 9 -- 2x2 -- MILLS 3RD & 9 -- 2x2 -- MILLS
$ (13) F (13) $ (13) ? F (13)
|
v
X Y O O O O O H Z X Y O O O O O H Z
R Q R Q
"Safeties stay high to "Safeties stay high" ... but
the throw." $ rotates down: one rep in 3
📊 Diagram (described): Two scout cards side by side, both for third-and-nine from two-by-two with Mills called. On each, the tight end is attached on the left beside the split end, the slot and flanker are on the right, the back is beside the quarterback, and both safeties stand at thirteen yards. The left card's rule line says the safeties stay high to the throw. The right card is the same picture with an arrow drawing the strong safety down at the snap, a question mark beside him, and a note that one rep in three rotates.
What to ask: "What does the second card cost on Thursday, and what does it buy on Sunday?" Then have each student write §39.5's missing contingency row from memory.
A strong answer sounds like: "It costs one of the six trunk reps. It buys one practiced look at the thirtieth snap. The row: if they rotate out of two-high on 3rd-and-7+ from a quiet front, instead of staying two-high (since the bye, with a question mark), the middle-read tag goes on every third-and-long call: eyes to the middle on step one, decide by step three, closed means dig or flat, never the post. One rotation rep in three, and the quarterback doesn't know which." Push anyone who writes the row without the reps.
Assessment notes
Quiz: 21 items, one point each (11 multiple choice, 5 true/false with justification, 4 short answer, 1 applied), banded 19–21, 15–18, 10–14, below 10. Items 2, 4, 5, 9, 13 and 14 test the core ideas. Item 21 is the best single item in the chapter. Give full credit only if the student finds all three problems (the old mug rule of "back on the Mike," no third-down rotation row, and Thursday repping only the trunk), names the red flags, and says the 37 doesn't stand.
Exercises: assign A2, A5, A9, B3, B4 (the six "stay high" cards), B8, C2, C5, D1 (retire Mills or keep it with the tag), D5, and M4.
Project Checkpoint: The Complete Playbook + Sentinels Game Plan. Part A is the playbook (spine pages, a core table of 60–70 plays at the pro level with picture, defender, partner, and source, the zero matrix, and the parking lot). Part B is the plan against Appendix G (five pages, call sheet, practice plan with rep budget). Part C is the game-day sheets and a self-grade and peer grade.
Grading the 40-point rubric
Each of the ten criteria scores 1 to 4: 4 = ready to call, 3 = needs a Tuesday, 2 = needs a spring, 1 = not yet (missing). The chapter's bands are 36–40 install it, 30–35 install after one more Tuesday, 24–29 take it into the spring, below 24 back to the philosophy page.
Grade in this order. Do it the same way every time and tell students the order in advance.
- Red-flag sweep first (five minutes). Check the five flags before you score anything: a blank contingency row on the strongest streak; a third-down box with one answer to its likeliest look; a protection with no answer for one more rusher; a call over ten words that isn't on the band; a play with no parent picture that's planned for more than one call. Any flag sends the capstone back whatever the total. Record the score anyway, so the student sees both.
- Score the build, criterion by criterion, with a page reference beside every score under 4.
- Never look at a result (a simulation, a scrimmage, a coach's opinion of the plan) until the build is scored.
Fast checks for each criterion:
| # | Criterion | The fast check | The usual "2" |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Philosophy fit | Hold one non-negotiable against the call sheet; find a violation in 30 seconds or none | A thesis that can't be checked: "a mood" |
| 2 | Language | Search for one route under two names; count words in five long calls | "Seam Out" and "Bender" both alive |
| 3 | Pictures | Count plays per base picture | Most formations carry one play (Bale's gallery) |
| 4 | Core completeness | Tick the ten families at the student's level size | A missing family with no written reason |
| 5 | Zero matrix | Every empty cell has a written accepted zero | Twelve with no RPO and no note |
| 6 | Protection | Pick three dropback calls; name the hot or sight-adjust for one more rusher | "We'll block it" |
| 7 | Traceability | Pick three boxes at random; ask for the counted row and its "since" date | Boxes built from favorites |
| 8 | Script and series | Every script slot asks a question with if A / if B | A script built to score |
| 9 | Contingencies | Find the strongest streak; find its row and its Thursday reps | A tendency with no branch |
| 10 | Week and game day | Calls times two against the rep budget; result column and halftime sheet present | 120 calls, 170 reps |
Calibrate before you grade. Have the class score the condensed Game 3 plan in §39.5 against the rubric first. Groups should land high on eight criteria, give criterion 9 a 1 or a 2, and send it back on red flag 1. A group that scores it low across the board is grading the result. Fix that before they grade each other.
Self-grade, then peer, then you. Where self and peer grades differ by two or more on a criterion, the two students settle it with the four-step rule, losing argument in the margin. That is §39.8 practiced on their own work.
Scale by level, not by standard. A high-school core of 20–30 plays can score 4 on criterion 4. A film-room capstone earns criterion 7 by marking every claim confirmed or inferred, with denominators.
A strong capstone reads like Teo's package: right-sized claims, the defense's best answer shown before anyone asks, credit given. The most common weak one scores 3s everywhere and hides one unwritten zero and one "to be discussed" row. Grade those hard.
Any-level adaptation
High school staff: run it as a summer staff project, one binder per assistant, with a two-page plan against your real rival and boxes split by hash. Check your state code on blocking below the waist, the ineligible-downfield distance, and two-point tries before any play enters the core.
College class: use field and boundary versions and run §39.8 as a graded staff meeting.
Analyst / film course: reconstruct one NFL team's core from four games, then write the plan you'd expect against a Sentinels-style defense, marking every inference.
Connections
Backward: Chapter 1 (the ladder and the napkin), Chapter 24 (the full Game 3 plan and the script's if A / if B), Chapter 25 (process and result grades), and Chapter 38 (the System Map and the tag).
Forward: Chapter 40 tests whether students can see all of this on film. Reference: Appendix L for the full Outlaws core and Appendix F for the plan and halftime templates.