Chapter 15 Exercises — Route Concepts

Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ recognition and application · ⭐⭐⭐ judgment and trade-offs · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and film research

Selected answers are in Appendix J. Short answers to Part C appear below each item.

All Outlaws, Sentinels, Stallions, Pioneers, Forge, and Ospreys people and games are fictional. Unless an item says it happened, treat each situation as hypothetical.


Part A — Conceptual ⭐

A1. Define route concept in one sentence. Then explain how it differs from "five receivers each running a route."

A2. State this chapter's threshold concept in your own words. Describe what a quarterback who hasn't crossed it does on a third-and-6, and what one who has crossed it does.

A3. What's the difference between a horizontal stretch and a vertical stretch (hi-lo)? Give one Outlaws concept for each and name the defender each one stresses.

A4. Why does the chapter say a read should be written in roles ("the flat defender") rather than positions ("the nickel")? Give an example where the same role is held by two different positions.

A5. Explain why an overload doesn't need a defender to make a mistake, while a conflict does need him to make a choice.

A6. What is a triangle read? Which two stretches does Snag combine, and against which two coverages does each part do its work?

A7. Give the Outlaws' spacing rule for receivers on the same level and explain what "splitting the difference" means.

A8. Match each drop to the depth of route it pairs with: catch-and-throw/one-step, three-step with a hitch, five-step with a hitch. Give an approximate ball-out time for each.

A9. Name the three traditions of concept naming described in the chapter (numbered, concept-word, descriptive). Give one advantage of each.

A10. Why is isolation (the "breaker") described as the opposite of conflict? What single pre-snap question decides whether the isolation throw is live?


Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐

B1. Pre-snap: two safeties at 12 yards, corners at 7 yards with outside leverage, a nickel over your slot. Post-snap: the field safety drives down toward the flat at about 8 yards, the boundary safety sprints to the deep middle, both corners bail. Name the coverage, and say which defender holds the curl/flat role on the field side.

B2. You're watching a curl-flat to the left against what looks like Cover 3. At the snap the left corner bails, the nickel widens hard with the flat route, and the Will linebacker runs from the hook toward the curl at about 10 yards. What's open, and what is the defense doing that the basic read didn't account for?

B3. Study the diagram and identify the concept, the coverage, and the key defender.

B3 (post-snap)

                              F                     C
                              ^                     ^   [DEEP 1/3]
                                               H    |
                                              /     |
                                            H       |
                                            |       Z
                         $       Z <--------|-------Z
                         ^                  |
                                            |   *------->
                                            |      Y-------->
                 O   O   O   O   O   Y      H       Z
                         Q   R

📊 Diagram (described): Three receivers to the right: Harlan attached as #3, Powers in the slot as

2, Gaines wide as #1. Gaines releases up the field and breaks inside at about five yards, settling at

six. Powers runs a corner route toward the pylon. Harlan releases to the flat. On defense, one deep safety is in the middle, the right corner bails into his deep third above Powers's corner route, the nickel widens with Harlan toward the flat, and the strong safety drops into the hook inside.

B4. A team runs Drive (drag under, dig over) against Tampa 2. On film the Mike opens and runs to the deep middle; the Will drops to about 11 yards and sits. Which route should the quarterback throw, and why is the Mike irrelevant to this read?

B5. In a "both" call, a receiver zip-motions toward the ball and the corner over him slides inside with him. Before the snap, what does this suggest? Which side of the "both" call should the quarterback expect to work?

B6. On All-22 you see a flood to the right against a coverage that started two-high. At the snap, the right corner sinks under the sail at about 14 yards and the deep safety to that side has rotated to the middle. Which of the three routes is open, and what's the risk in throwing it?

B7. You chart a quarterback's helmet on a stick concept: at the snap he looks at the stick receiver, holds his eyes there, and throws when the receiver turns around. The curl/flat defender had stayed inside, and the pass is broken up. Name the error in this chapter's language.

B8. A team runs four receivers on hitches at six yards, evenly spaced across the field, against a defense that drops five underneath defenders. Which principle is the offense relying on, how many receivers per underneath defender does the arithmetic produce, and what does the quarterback read to pick the throw?

B9. On the end-zone view you see the same Snag concept twice against the same team. On the first snap the field corner bails and the nickel widens; on the second the field corner squats at five yards and the nickel sits. Name the coverage on each snap and the correct throw on each. What does the pair of snaps tell you about why Snag is called a triangle?


Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

C1. Draw it up ⭐⭐. Draw curl-flat from Gun Doubles Left (the concept on the right, away from an attached Y on the left) against Cover 2, pre-snap and post-snap. Mark the key and both throws.

Short answer

Pre-snap: two high safeties, corners pressed or at 5–7 yards. Post-snap: the right corner jams the X and squats in the flat; the right-half safety retreats over the top; the outside hook defender drops inside. The X's curl settles at 10–11 in the hole between the corner, the hook defender, and the safety; the H releases to the flat at 2–3. Key: the right corner. Squats → curl. Sinks → flat.

C2. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐. Week 10 at Portland, third quarter, 3rd-and-5 at the Portland 46, Outlaws ahead by seven. Portland has played Tampa 2 on 11 of 13 third downs. Their Mike, Owen Talbert, runs to the deep middle every time; their corners squat. You have Eleven personnel. Pick a concept, name the key defender, and give the read.

Short answer

Strong options: Snag to the wide side (the corner squats on the flat, so the corner route is behind him; if he sinks, the flat) or Drive (the Will is the hook defender between the drag and the dig; Talbert is gone to the middle, so the hook is a one-man problem). Smash is also a good Tampa 2 answer. A weaker choice is anything that throws into the deep middle — that's where Talbert lives.

C3. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐. You're facing St. Louis: single-high on 80 percent of snaps; their nickel widens to any flat route "like he's paid by the yard." 2nd-and-7 at your own 42, tied 10–10, second quarter. Choose between curl-flat, stick, and flood. Justify it with the key defender's tendency.

Short answer

Any of the three can be right; the reasoning matters. The best fit uses the tendency: the nickel will widen, so pick a concept whose inside route is the throw when he does. Curl-flat (curl behind and inside him) and stick (stick inside him) both fit. Flood also works (the sail sits behind a widening nickel) but takes longer; on 2nd-and-7, stick or curl-flat gets the ball out on rhythm.

C4. Draw it up ⭐⭐⭐. Draw a flood from Gun Trips Right against Cover 3, labeling the three depths, the corner's and curl/flat defender's responsibilities, and the read table.

Short answer

1 go (corner carries), #2 sail breaking at 15–18, #3 flat at 2–3. Corner deep, curl/flat defender

underneath. Curl/flat widens → sail. Curl/flat sinks → flat. Corner jumps the sail with no help over the top → go (alert). Pressure from the flood side → flat now.

C5. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐. Game 2 at Sacramento, Q3, 3rd-and-5 at the SAC 21. The Sentinels have played a robber — a safety dropping down to sit in the middle at 8–10 yards — on two of your third-and-medium snaps today, both times breaking up an in-breaking route. What do you call, and what's your key?

Short answer

Pick a concept that either (a) works away from the robber — an out-breaking triangle such as Snag with the flat and corner routes outside the robber's area — or (b) puts the robber himself in a hi-lo, such as a dig under a post: if he comes down to the dig, the post is behind him. Read the robber as the key (or as key 2 after the curl/flat defender). The worst answer is the same in-breaking stick that the robber has already jumped twice (see Case Study 2).

C6. Whose fault? ⭐⭐⭐. Practice, team period. "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 60 Left, Curl-Flat." The scout defense plays Cover 3. Sutton's curl settles at eleven yards, but eight yards outside the numbers; Powers's flat flattens out at one yard and drifts wide. At the snap the scout nickel stands still, halfway between them, and breaks on the curl as it's thrown. Interception. Who is at fault — Sutton, Powers, the quarterback, or the call?

Short answer

Primarily the receivers' landmarks, with a share for the quarterback. The two routes ended up about four yards apart, so one defender could split the difference — the horizontal stretch had collapsed before the read could work. Sutton's curl should settle no wider than the top of the numbers; Powers's flat should aim at the bottom of the numbers at two to three yards. The quarterback's share: his key didn't commit to either route, which is the signal that neither is open — he should have gone to the next answer (a backside route or the free square) instead of throwing into a defender who never moved. The call was sound.

C7. Draw it up ⭐⭐⭐. Draw Drive (a drag at 2–3 under a dig at 12, both breaking the same direction) from Gun Doubles Right against Cover 3, pre-snap and post-snap. Identify the key defender (it is not the same man as against Tampa 2) and give both throws.

Short answer

Against Cover 3 the deep middle is held by the free safety, so the hook area under him is held by the two hook linebackers. The drag and the dig both break toward the side where the routes cross the hook defender's area — that hook defender (often the Mike, sometimes the Will, depending on which side the routes cross) is the key. Hook defender comes up on the drag → dig behind him (under the free safety, which is why the dig sits at 12, not 18). Hook defender sinks to the dig → drag. Watch the curl/flat defender on the far side: if he expands inside under the dig, he becomes key two and the drag is the throw.

C8. Make the call ⭐⭐. High school, your QB is a sophomore. The ball is on the left hash, so the field is to the right. The opponent plays Cover 3 almost every snap. You can install one concept this week. Which one, which side of the field, and how many keys does your QB read?

Short answer

Curl-flat or stick to the wide (right) side, where the horizontal stretch has room. One key: the curl/flat defender. Half-field only. Rep it from several formations rather than adding a second concept.


Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐

D1. Your quarterback is a veteran with elite processing. Your line is average, and you allow pressure on about a third of dropbacks. Should your third-down menu lean on half-field or full-field reads? Defend your answer with the time each kind of read needs and the protection it requires.

D2. Marisol's chart shows your best receiver gets 46 percent of third-down targets. Teo wants to make him the first read on every third-down concept. Lay out the argument for and against, and propose a compromise that keeps him involved without making him a pre-snap answer for the defense.

D3. A concept you love — smash — has worked against Cover 2 all season. This week's opponent plays Cover 3 on 75 percent of snaps. Do you keep smash on the call sheet? Under what conditions would you call it, and what would you carry beside it?

D4. The chapter's spacing rule says five yards minimum between receivers on the same level. When might you deliberately compress spacing (receivers closer together), and what are you trading away?

D5. Your rookie quarterback reads keys well in the meeting room but freezes on the field when the key defender does something unexpected (for example, he sits in between). What rule would you give him for "the key did neither," and how would you practice it?

D6. You have one hour of practice time this week for the passing game's new install. Option one: add two new concepts and rep each against Cover 3 only. Option two: add no new concepts and rep your three existing concepts against Cover 2, Cover 3, and man, with the scout team rotating after the snap on a third of the reps. Which do you choose for a game against a defense that rotates its safeties often? Explain the trade-off in terms of what the quarterback learns from each.

D7. A defense consistently plays a robber on third-and-medium. Your offensive line coach suggests keeping a seventh blocker in to buy time for a full-field read that ends on the robber's side. Your quarterbacks coach prefers a quick half-field concept that throws away from the robber in about 1.3 seconds. Lay out what each plan gives up, and choose — using the down, distance, and your quarterback's strengths as the deciding inputs.


Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

M1. (Ch 13 + Ch 15). Anchor A's "Inside Slant" RPO read the Will, Jordan Ames. Write it as a route concept read: name the concept's two "routes," the key defender, and the throw for each of his choices. What is the RPO's equivalent of the "flat" in curl-flat?

M2. (Ch 7 + Ch 15). A two-high shell rotates to Cover 3 at the snap with the strong safety coming down to the curl/flat. Using Chapter 7's charting marks (2H, 1H, and the rotation arrow), write the chart entry, then explain how the rotation changes the key for a curl-flat called to the strong side.

M3. (Ch 6 + Ch 15). Using the Outlaws route tree from Chapter 6, write the "Digits" call (X–H–Z order) for a play in which the X runs a curl, the H a corner, and the Z a post. Which principle does the X–H pair create against Cover 2? Which defender is the key?

M4. (Ch 8 + Ch 15). Under the Chapter 8 defaults, where does a one-side concept go when there is no motion, and where does it go when there is motion? Explain why that default matters for the key defender the quarterback must find.

M5. (Ch 3 + Ch 15). A reduced ("Nasty") split moves the #1 receiver closer to the formation. Explain how that changes the landmarks and spacing for (a) a curl-flat and (b) a smash to that side, and why a defense might treat the split as a tell.

M6. (Ch 5 + Ch 15). Your full-field concept needs about 2.8 seconds. Using Chapter 5's protection ideas, describe what the line must do for that to be realistic, and name one adjustment if the opponent's best rusher keeps winning in under 2.5 seconds.


M7. (Ch 4 + Ch 15). Twelve personnel usually draws a heavier defense (base or big nickel) than Eleven. Explain how the personnel you put on the field changes who holds the curl/flat role on a curl-flat called to the tight end's side, and why that might make the concept better or worse. Use the Sentinels' rule that Twelve always gets big nickel.

M8. (Ch 1 + Ch 15). Walt Dupree's line was "Every play is a question. Know what you're asking." Pick three concepts from this chapter and write each one's "question" as a single sentence addressed to the key defender. Then name the Outlaws non-negotiable from Chapter 1 that this chapter's threshold concept puts into practice.


Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐

E1. The painter's-tape study. Choose one NFL game with All-22 (end-zone or sideline coaches' film) available. Pick ten dropback passes. For each, pause one second after the snap with the receivers covered (a sticky note on the screen works). Predict the throw from the defenders alone. Then play it. Record: your prediction, the actual throw, the key defender you used, and whether you were right. Write one paragraph on which concept types you could predict and which you couldn't.

E2. The key-defender chart. Chart one team's third downs from a full game. For each passing play, record the concept (your best name), the coverage after the snap, the defender the concept stressed, what he did, and where the ball went. Count how often the throw went opposite the key. Compare a completion that went opposite the key with an incompletion that didn't.

E3. Drop-to-depth timing. Using public timing data (the league's Next Gen Stats publishes average time-to-throw by quarterback) and your own stopwatch on film, time twenty throws by route depth: 0–6 yards, 7–14, 15+. Do the times cluster the way this chapter's timing table suggests? Where they don't, note the reason you see on film — a hitch, a late read, pressure, a scramble.

E4. One concept, three systems. Pick one concept that appears across many offenses — curl-flat, stick, or smash. Find it on film from three different teams whose coordinators come from different traditions (for example, a West Coast-rooted team, a spread or Air Raid-influenced team, and a team widely grouped with the Shanahan tree). For each, record the formation it came from, whether it was run as a half-field or full-field read, the drop, and the coverage it was called against. Write a page on what stayed the same across all three (the principle and the key defender) and what changed (formation, protection, timing, and the tags attached to it). If you find a published name for the concept from any of those teams in a book or clinic talk, note it — but don't assume a name you can't confirm.