Chapter 27 Exercises — Motion and Shifts
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and independent film study
Situations marked (hypothetical) are practice scenarios, not snaps from the Outlaws' season. Selected answers are in Appendix J.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. Define motion and shift. What is the one rule that applies after a shift but not after motion by itself?
A2. Name motion's three jobs. For each, give one Outlaws motion word that most often does that job, and say why.
A3. Under NFL rules, which of these are legal at the snap? (a) The Z moving parallel to the line toward the ball. (b) The H moving at an angle toward the line of scrimmage. (c) The Y and the H both moving. (d) The running back moving backward and outward from the backfield. Explain each.
A4. Why does the Z usually line up off the line of scrimmage in a motion offense? What would the X have to do before he could go in motion?
A5. In your own words, explain "early to learn, late to win." Give one motion that belongs on each clock.
A6. List the three basic defensive answers to across-the-formation motion, using the Outlaws' in-season words (not the Sentinels' words). Then add the fourth answer from the chapter's table.
A7. What is a "Both" call? State the Outlaws' rule for which side of the formation gets the man side and which gets the zone side, and explain the reasoning behind each.
A8. Why is a slide not proof of zone coverage? Use the word exchange in your answer.
A9. Marisol Vega's two self-scout rules for spotting a tell are "about 70% on ten or more snaps" and "kill the zeros." Explain each, and explain why a motion sort that passes both tests can still hide a tell (think about Powers's feet).
A10. What does the rule "Fly and Flip never in the same call" protect against? What happened in Week 2 at St. Louis that made it a rule?
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
B1. Gun Doubles Right against a two-high shell. Powers zooms from the left slot and sets outside Harlan. The nickel who was over Powers runs across the formation behind him and lines up over him on the right. What coverage family is this most likely to be, what does the left side of the formation look like now, and what does Vance do with a "Mesh, Kill, Both" call?
B2. Same formation and motion as B1. This time no defender crosses. The nickel slides a step inside. The linebackers shuffle a step toward the motion. The safeties stay at twelve yards and re-center. List two coverages this picture is consistent with. What is Vance's first post-snap look in the Outlaws' post-Week 15 rule?
B3. Describe what you see in this pre-snap picture, and name the answer:
F ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~> F
C * W M $ <~~ creeping down
E T N E
X O O O O O Y H Z
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): Two-by-two that has become three-by-one after Powers motioned from the left slot to the right. As he crosses, the left safety drifts toward the middle of the field, and the right safety creeps down toward the line on the motion side. The nickel and linebackers stay roughly where they were. Sutton is alone on the left.
B4. On film, a receiver goes in motion toward the ball, stops for about half a second, then the tight end shifts from one side to the other, and the ball is snapped as the tight end gets set. The officials throw a flag. What was the foul, and what was the sequence the offense needed?
B5. You're watching end-zone film of your own offense. On jet sweeps, your jet man's motion reaches the near tackle in what looks like the same time every snap. On Fly calls, he looks a touch slower. What is the risk, what's the fix, and how would you measure it?
B6. Against empty, after the back peels out, the walked-up linebacker in the A gap holds his position until the snap, and then bails to the flat as only four rush. What is the defense doing, what throw does it want you to make, and what throw beats it?
B7. Describe what you see, and say what the offense should expect after the snap:
PRE-SNAP: Z zips toward the ball and stops a yard behind the Y
(a stack built by motion), vs. two defenders over the pair
F $
C (5 yds, directly behind)
* (press, on the Y's nose)
E T N E
X H O O O O O Y
Z <~~~~~~ Z
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): Gaines zips in from wide right and stops a yard behind Harlan, making a stack. The defense puts its nickel pressed on Harlan's nose and its corner about five yards off, directly behind the nickel, both inside the same lane. Two safeties are deep.
B8. The Week 12 Stallions game (fictional): Gaines zips in on "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Zip, 60 Left, Smash, X Fade, Alert Post," and the right corner stays outside. What did the corner tell Vance, and which coverage family did St. Louis turn out to be in on that snap?
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
C1. Make the call (hypothetical). ⭐⭐ Next season, against a Sacramento-style defense. Second-and-four at the opponent's 37, first quarter, 0–0. Eleven personnel. On your first snap you ran jet motion, and the safeties rolled toward it (the motion-side safety came down, the far safety spun to the middle). What do you call now, and which motion?
Answer
Use the roll. A jet-path motion that you expect to pull the motion-side safety down and the far safety to the middle gives you two good choices: an inside run away from the jet (the backside alley just lost its safety) or a play-action throw away from the roll to the isolated backside receiver. On second-and-four, a run that only needs four yards is a strong call, and it keeps the play-action for a later second-and-short. Something like "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Jet, Inside Left" is a sound answer. The reasoning is graded, not the exact words: you must name the backside as the weakness the roll creates.
C2. Make the call (hypothetical). ⭐⭐⭐ Third-and-two at the opponent's 33, second quarter, Austin up 7–3. Your third-short page says: single-high man on 3rd-and-1–3, the field corner pressed on your Z. Last time you threw a slant against that press, it took too long and you were sacked. What motion do you use, which clock is it on, and what route?
Answer
The Game 3 answer: motion on the late clock, a Zoom tagged "Live," so the Z is still moving at the snap. The pressed corner can't press a receiver moving sideways, and whoever inherits the Z has to play off with a leverage choice. Run a quick out (or an out-breaking route) away from inside leverage. If the defender inherits him with outside leverage instead, the slant on the move is the answer. The key is that the motion is the release, not information.
C3. Draw it up. ⭐⭐ From Gun Doubles Right, draw the Outlaws' base "Both" call with a Z Zip: label the zone side and the man side, every route with its depth, and the protection. Then draw the post-snap picture against Cover 3 and say where Vance's eyes go.
Answer
Zone side left: X curl at 10–11, H flat at 2–3. Man side right: Z slant (from his tightened split), Y flat. 60 Left protection with Ruffin on the man side. Against Cover 3 (nobody followed the zip), Vance reads the left curl-to-flat defender: if he widens to the flat, throw the curl; if he sits under the curl, throw the flat. If the defender over Sutton turns and runs with him at the snap, it's man after all, and Vance's eyes go to the slant.
C4. Make the call (hypothetical). ⭐⭐⭐ Your opponent this week chased jet motion with its nickel on 20 of 23 snaps on film, but its coordinator is known for halftime changes. Build a first-half motion plan of three calls and a second-half plan of two calls that assumes the chase becomes an exchange.
Answer
First half: (1) a jet question on an early snap, with a sound run away; (2) the jet sweep toward the wide side against the chaser; (3) the jet fake with inside zone away, or a Fly flood that turns the chaser into a decoy. Second half: (1) a return motion that changes the formation family (2x2 → 3x1) and comes back late, so the exchange must be made and unmade; (2) a "Both" call off zoom motion, with the snap deciding. Case Study 2 is a worked version.
C5. Draw it up. ⭐⭐⭐ Draw a "shift to see it, move late to beat it" pair. Snap 1: a Y Flip that makes the defense re-declare strength. Snap 2 (later in the game): the same Y Flip plus a motion at the snap that outnumbers the side the strength just left. Show both pre-snap pictures and the snap-2 post-snap play.
Answer
Snap 1: "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Y Flip, Inside Left," a run to the new tight-end side after Harlan flips left (the formation is now Trey Left with Gaines alone on the right). Watch the front and the coverage re-set toward Harlan's new side. Snap 2: "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Y Flip, H Zoom Live, 50 Left, Hitches." Harlan flips left, everyone sets a full second, and then Powers zooms from the left slot back toward the right and is still moving at the snap. The defense has re-declared its strength to the left, so the right side, where Gaines and the arriving Powers are, now has two receivers against fewer defenders than the rule expected. The hitches to that side are the throw. Grade it on the legality (the one-second set after the flip, then one man moving) and on whether the motion attacks the side the defense left.
C6. Make the call (hypothetical). ⭐⭐ First-and-10 at your own 30, third quarter, tied. You want to know whether a new opponent's corners will travel with motion, and you don't want to give up a down learning it. Pick a motion and a play.
Answer
Use an early-clock Zip or Zoom with a run that's sound against both answers: for example, a Z Zip with an inside run. The motion asks the question; the run doesn't care about the answer. Write down the answer ("traveled," "slid," "rolled") for the next call.
C7. Make the call (hypothetical). ⭐⭐⭐ Second-and-seven at your own 45, fourth quarter, up three, 9:30 left. The opponent has answered every across-the-formation motion today with a slide, and your booth says two of those slides were man exchanges (the defender who picked up the motion man ran with him after the snap). You want a completion and you don't want a negative play. What motion, what clock, and what concept?
Answer
A late Return that changes the formation family is the aggressive answer: send the H across to make trips, bring him back late, and make the exchange happen twice. If you'd rather not risk a busted communication on your own side with a lead in the fourth quarter, the conservative answer is an early motion with a "Both" call and a post-snap key, which completes the ball against either coverage. Both are defensible. The grading point is whether you named the cost you're attacking (the exchange is a conversation) and matched your risk to the score and clock.
C8. Draw it up. ⭐⭐ Draw the Orbit path from Gun Wing Left on an Inside Read Right, showing the mesh, the read end, and the orbit man's depth behind the back. Label the depth rule from the chapter's Whose-fault drill and explain what the orbit man adds to the option arithmetic.
Answer
The orbit man crosses behind the mesh at least two yards deeper than the back's heels (roughly seven yards behind the line in the gun) and arcs toward the far flat. He adds a third threat on the side the quarterback pulls to: the read end must play the back or the quarterback, and now a pitch or swing player appears outside, so the defense needs one more player on that side to cover all three.
Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. Lyle says the Game 2 "Both" call was a sound idea with a process flaw. Make the strongest case you can that it was simply a bad call on third-and-eight, and then answer that case.
D2. Your motion rate is 70%, much higher than Austin's. Marisol's sort shows your no-motion snaps are 60% third downs. What does a defense learn from that, and what would you change?
D3. A motion offense uses play clock. Name two situations (one clock-related, one crowd-related) where you would cut motion from your plan, and explain what you lose by doing it.
D4. Jet and orbit motions put a ball carrier at full speed into the perimeter, and they often pair with crack blocks. What safety teaching must go with them, and why do you tell your staff to check the current rule every season?
D5. You discover a motion tell in your own offense with four games left in the regular season. Option A: break it now. Option B: keep it until the playoffs, then use it to set up a counter. Argue both sides, then choose.
D6. Russ Kimbrough tagged "Roll" only in the down-and-distance and formation cells where Austin's jet sweep and motion-side flood clustered, and played a silent slide everywhere else. Evaluate that policy from the offense's side. Where would you look to find the cells he didn't tag, and how would you use them?
D7. Your quarterback is a rookie. Your motion menu has eight words and a "Both" call with a post-snap key. Which two pieces would you remove for his first four starts, and why? What does your offense lose, and how would you get it back?
Short answer to D7
A reasonable answer removes the "Kill" on diagnostic motions (so the rookie isn't choosing plays at the line under noise) and the Return motion (which depends on precise timing and on reading a defense's second answer). Keep a jet family and one early-clock diagnostic motion with a single pre-planned answer per look. You lose the ability to switch plays by the motion answer, so you get some of it back by calling plays that are sound against both answers and by moving that decision to the sideline: Teo reads the answer from the booth, and the next call uses it.
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (Chapters 27 and 7.) Chapter 7 says "the shell is not the coverage." Rewrite that idea for motion in one sentence. Then give an example where the motion answer was true before the snap and the coverage was something else after it.
M2. (Chapters 27 and 8.) Write the full Outlaws call for this play in correct grammar: Eleven personnel, Gun Doubles Right, Powers motions across without getting the ball and becomes the flat runner, six-man protection sliding left, the concept is Flood, and the X runs a fade tag. How many words is it, and how would it get to Vance?
M3. (Chapters 27 and 13.) The Inside Slant RPO reads the Will linebacker. How could a motion before the snap change who the conflict defender is? Give one motion that would make it the nickel instead.
M4. (Chapters 27 and 17.) Explain how a Zip that builds a stack at the last second turns the stack into a man-coverage diagnostic. What do you learn if the two defenders over the stack line up one behind the other?
M5. (Chapters 27 and 22.) Peel motion takes the running back out of the protection. What must your protection rules say about Peel, and what did the Game 2 Echo snap teach about the hot throw from empty?
M6. (Chapters 27 and 24.) The Game 3 script opened with a jet sweep for one yard. Using Chapter 24's idea of the script as a list of questions, explain why that one yard was a success and how it fed a later call.
M7. (Chapters 27 and 25.) Chapter 25's threshold concept says a play call is a bet on a distribution, not a promise of an outcome. Apply it to Case Study 1's three-and-out in Game 2. Which of the three snaps would you grade as good decisions, regardless of their results, and why?
M8. (Chapters 27 and 3.) A shift moves the Z up to the line outside the attached Y. What happens to the Y's eligibility, and what would your quarterback need to know before throwing to him? Use the covered-receiver rule from Chapter 3.
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. The motion audit. Watch one full NFL game on All-22 (or any broadcast with a wide view). For every snap with motion, chart: the motion type (across, short, return, back out, tight-end shift), the clock (moving at the snap or set), the defender over the mover and his reaction (travel, slide, rotate, freeze), and the play family. At the end, answer: what were this defense's motion rules, and where did they cost something?
E2. The self-scout. Pick one offense and chart three games of its motion by motion type and play family. Apply Marisol's two tests (about 70% on ten or more; any zero). Then watch the motion man's speed on his own carries versus his decoy motions. Did you find a tell? Present it in a one-page table with a recommended fix.
E3. The history thread. Using a well-documented source on football history (the Pro Football Hall of Fame's materials or a book such as Tim Layden's Blood, Sweat and Chalk), write a page on the man in motion in Clark Shaughnessy's T formation and the 1940 Bears' 73–0 championship win. What did the motion do to the defenses of that era, and which of motion's three jobs (information, advantage, constraint) does it fit best? Don't invent quotes or numbers; cite only what your source says.