Chalk-Talk and Simulation Guide

Chalk talks, the eleven-man say-back, the mock game-plan meeting, the 40-second simulation, and halftime

Reading about play calling is like reading about swimming. This guide gives you five activities that put learners in the water: chalk talks at the whiteboard, the eleven-man say-back (the Outlaws' rookie final exam), a mock game-plan meeting run on Austin's Tuesday rules, a 40-second play-calling simulation against a deck built from the Sentinels' tendencies, and a halftime-adjustment simulation built on the Game 2 halftime. Rubric 4 (chalk talks) and Rubric 5 (simulations) in rubrics grade them.

Everything here runs with a whiteboard, index cards, two six-sided dice, a phone timer, and printed copies of Appendix G and the Appendix F templates. No software.


1. Chalk talks

Format

A chalk talk is ten minutes at the board, one learner, one concept, in the book's notation (offense at the bottom moving up the page). Every talk has the same four parts:

  1. The pre-snap picture (two minutes): the offensive formation and personnel, and the defense being attacked, counted to eleven on each side.
  2. The post-snap picture (three minutes): every assignment, the read or conflict defender circled, and where the ball goes for each choice he makes.
  3. The rule in one sentence (one minute), followed by a plain-language description of the drawing, the same accessibility rule the book follows after every diagram.
  4. "How would I defend that?" (four minutes): a classmate playing Wade Harmon or Russ Kimbrough offers the defense's best answer; the presenter gives the offense's answer to the answer.

Part 4 is the one that separates learners. Wade asks "how would I defend that?" in every Outlaws staff meeting, and an offense that can't answer the answer to its play has drawn a play, not an offense (Chapter 38: an offense is a system of constraints).

Board rules

  • Count to eleven, both sides, every drawing. A drawing without eleven defenders loses the point automatically.
  • Pre-snap and post-snap are two drawings. Never one.
  • Number the receivers #1, #2, #3 from the outside in on each side.
  • Name the defender, not the receiver. "The ball goes to the hitch" earns nothing; "the corner squats, so the ball goes behind him to the corner route" earns the point.
  • Rules by level. Any RPO, play-action, screen, or rub drawn at the board must state the ineligible-downfield or contact rule for the presenter's chosen level, with "check your current code."

A bank of sixteen board drills

Use these as chalk-talk assignments, cold openers, or exam rehearsal. Each chapter note has its own board activity as well.

# Drill Chapter A strong answer includes
1 Draw three base formations; mark every eligible receiver 3 No covered tight end; seven on the line; the end man on each side named
2 Inside zone vs. Nickel Over, then vs. a bear front 5, 9 Covered/uncovered labeled; combos named with the backer each climbs to; the back's "bang, bounce, bend"
3 Outside zone to the tight end with Wide PA Boot off it 10 Reach and overtake rules; the boot-side guard pulls; the backside end's "chase" is the reason the boot works
4 Power Left and Counter Right from the same look 11 Who pulls, who kicks, who wraps; "counter always goes away from Harlan"
5 Zone read with the end unread; then Arc 12 The arithmetic of the plus-one; "If he can tackle Jalen, he can't tackle you"
6 Anchor A, both snaps 13 Ames named; his run fit and his slant window; Vo's outside leverage; linemen "hit, don't travel"
7 The goal-line pair: Jumbo Power Left and a pass from the same picture 14 Two plays that share a picture; the leak stays within the downfield limit
8 Smash vs. Cover 2, then vs. Cover 3 16 The corner is the hi-lo defender in Cover 2; in Cover 3 he bails and the hitch is the answer
9 Mesh vs. man, with the legal-rub explanation 17 Landmarks, not defenders; "H sets it, Y tops it"; eyes up through the mesh
10 Mills vs. two-high, then vs. the spin to single-high 18, 38 The post read off the middle safety; the middle-read tag's branch
11 Anchor D as four snaps 19 Same look each time; Holloway's two receipts; the play-action's second payment on snap 4
12 60 Left vs. a five-man overload 22 Rushers vs. blockers; the free man named; the hot and where it throws
13 Anchor C's protection vs. the mug corner fire 22, 25 Center on Bell, back on Ames, right tackle widening to Simmons; Gaines's sight-adjust hitch
14 The zero-bin deep over vs. Cover 0 17, 22 Six blockers (Ruffin in on Bell), Harlan's hold route, verticals clearing for Gaines's deep over
15 A jet-motion series: sweep, then a play off it 27, 33 "Every jet is a sweep until the ball is snapped"; the chasing defender named
16 A third-and-long box with a branch 24, 26, 38 One call for the likely look, one for the feared look, and the post-snap check written in

2. The eleven-man say-back

What it is

The rookie's final exam in Austin (Chapter 8): Teo reads a call; the rookie must say all eleven assignments, not just his own. "A receiver who knows the protection knows when he's hot. A receiver who knows the concept knows why his depth matters." Austin runs it the night before the first preseason game (Chapter 34). It is the best single check of whether the language has become understanding, and it takes about three minutes per learner.

How to run it

  1. Read a call once, at normal speed, in the book's six-slot grammar: personnel, formation, motion or shift, protection, play or concept, tags.
  2. The learner has fifteen seconds to think (a nod to the radio cutoff), then says all eleven assignments in order: the five linemen left to right, the back, the tight end, the receivers, the quarterback.
  3. One repeat is allowed, as in the Outlaws' huddle rule, where only the center may ask for one.
  4. Score one point per correct assignment, plus one point for naming the read defender or the protection's free man. Twelve points total; ten is a pass.

The model call

Use Chapter 8 §8.4's call for the first round, because the chapter walks it word by word and learners can check themselves afterward: "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Zip, 60 Left, Smash, X Fade, Alert Post."

Player Assignment
Left tackle, left guard, center Slide left: outside gap, B gap, left A gap; the center makes the Mike point
Right guard, right tackle Man: the down lineman over or outside the guard; the edge rusher for the tackle
Back Aligns right (the man side); takes the first linebacker who comes on the right; flat if no one comes
Y (attached right) Smash corner route: stem to about twelve, break to the pylon at about eighteen
Z Zip to a reduced split; smash hitch at six, settle facing the quarterback
H (left slot) Alert post (the alert belongs to the backside #2)
X Fade (the tag replaces his backside dig)
Quarterback IDs the Mike; watches the zip for man or zone; alert post if the middle opens; otherwise reads the right-side flat defender

The concept goes to the right because there is motion and a one-side concept goes to the motion man's side. Learners who put smash on the left have missed the side-concept rule; learners who give Sutton a dig have missed the tag.

Variations for later rounds

  • The Kill say-back. "Twelve, Gun Doubles Right, Inside Left, Kill, Y Option." The learner says the eleven jobs for both plays and the rule for choosing (Austin's Week 6 napkin rule: count the man over Harlan; a defensive back means run, a linebacker means throw).
  • The sound-alike round. Calls containing Fly, Flip, and Zip. Any call with Fly and Flip together must be rejected ("Fly and Flip never in the same call").
  • The student's own call. In the second round (Week 13 of the 15-week syllabus), learners hand you a call from their own Playbook Project and a classmate does the say-back. If the classmate can't, the call or the language is the problem, not the classmate.

3. The mock game-plan meeting

What it teaches

Austin builds its game plan at Tuesday 7 a.m. with a written disagreement rule (Chapter 24): proposals on paper first, a four-step process for disagreement, and dissent written in the margin. The Game 3 plan had 112 calls and a six-row contingency table whose last row was blank, and Rome Pettaway's margin note ("Post vs. two-high is pre-snap. Want a post-snap check?") is the most important sentence in the book. This simulation lets learners discover why the rule exists.

Roles (seven to nine learners per meeting)

Role Brings to the meeting
Lyle Petrakis (OC, chairs) The early-down mix and the opening script
Wade Harmon (HC) Fourth-down and clock positions; asks "how would I defend that?"
Gus Ferrante (OL) Run-game rules vs. the expected fronts; protection concerns
Rome Pettaway (QB) The third-down and red-zone reads; must write at least one margin dissent
Cal Boateng (WR) Matchups (Sutton vs. Brennan; Gaines vs. Simmons)
Marisol Vega (analytics) The self-scout: Austin's tells, with counts and sample sizes
Teo Arriaga (QC) The "Kimbrough by situation" page from Appendix G
Observers (optional) Track every claim made without a count

Materials and rules

Hand out Appendix G and, if you want the Game 1 setting, the Week 6 report numbers from Chapter 23: 243 Sentinels snaps, nickel on 170, two-high on 151, the shell changing after the snap on 92, five or more rushers on 66, Cover 0 on 1 of 26 third-and-7-or-longer snaps. Each role drafts a one-page proposal before the meeting.

The meeting runs forty-five minutes. Rules: proposals are read before discussion; nobody argues a number without its count; a disagreement that isn't settled in two exchanges goes in the margin with the dissenter's initials; and the plan can't leave the room with a blank contingency row.

Deliverables

A third-down box (short, medium, long, long-long) with a branch in every box; a 15-play script in which every slot asks a question with "if A / if B"; a "4th: P/K/G" box for three field positions; and the contingency table.

Debrief

Ask three questions. Which margin note would you most regret ignoring? Which row of the contingency table has the fewest practice reps behind it? Which of our boxes depends on a perfect streak? Then tell the Game 3 story: the box with no branch, the margin note, "Rule four covers," and the Thursday scout team that never showed the rotation.


4. The 40-second play-calling simulation

What it teaches

Play calling is decision-making under a clock, and the clock is the part learners have never felt. Austin's timeline (Chapter 25 §25.2, first laid out in Chapter 1):

Play clock What happens
40–34 The result of the last play, and Teo's read in the order "shell, box, one thing" ("Two high, six, Will at five")
34–28 The call and the personnel
28–20 The call goes into Vance's helmet ("Blue 34" if it's longer than ten words)
20–15 Huddle break; the radio cuts off at 15
15–~5 Mike ID and motion
Snap Target :06–:03

Roles and materials

  • The caller (rotates every drive), with a call sheet built from the learner's own project or the Appendix F template.
  • The booth (Teo), who reads the defense's card in "shell, box, one thing" and nothing else.
  • The head coach (Wade), who owns fourth down, timeouts, and two-point tries, and hears the analyst on a separate channel (the caller can't hear Marisol directly; Wade relays the chart).
  • The defensive coordinator, who draws defense cards from the situation deck below.
  • The clock, who runs a visible 40-second timer and calls out 34, 28, 20, and 15.
  • The scorer, who logs every call, the caller's one-sentence reason (written before the result), and the result.

The defense: a situation deck from the Sentinels' tendencies

Build three decks of index cards. The mix below is a classroom approximation built from the book's fictional Sentinels numbers (about 62 percent two-high pre-snap, about 38 percent rotation after the snap, pressure mostly on third-and-long). Adjust it freely; that's half the lesson.

Deck Cards Mix
Early downs 20 7 two-high Quarters ("Home"); 4 two-high rotating to single-high Cover 3; 2 Cover 6; 3 single-high Cover 3 with an eight-man box; 2 Cover 1; 2 five-man pressure from two-high
Third-and-short / medium 16 5 Cover 1 (press man); 3 two-high Quarters; 3 rotation to Cover 3; 3 five-man fire zone; 2 Cover 0
Third-and-long 16 9 two-high that stays two-high; 3 two-high that spins to single-high; 3 one-high mug with a corner fire zone (a lineman dropping into the hot window); 1 Cover 0

Each card shows the pre-snap picture the booth reports (shell and box), and on the back the post-snap coverage or pressure. The booth sees only the front of the card until the snap.

Resolving each snap

Each offensive call on the caller's sheet carries two short lists, written in advance: "beats" (the looks it is built for) and "dies against" (the looks that kill it). At the snap, the DC flips the card and the scorer checks the lists, then rolls two dice.

Matchup 2–4 5–8 9–11 12
Beats the look No gain Successful play (meets the down's success line) Explosive (run 12+, pass 20+) Explosive and a score if in range
Neutral Loss or incompletion Short of the success line Successful play Explosive
Dies against the look Sack or turnover (on a 2) / loss Loss or incompletion Short of the success line Successful play

Two modifiers keep it honest. A protection with no answer for one more rusher than it blocks turns any pressure card into a "dies against" result. A call with a written post-snap branch (a hot, a sight adjust, a middle-read tag) shifts a "dies against" result to "neutral," which is the whole case for the branch.

The clock and the penalties

If the call isn't into the helmet by :15, the caller must either burn a timeout or take a delay-of-game penalty. If the call is longer than ten words and isn't on the band, it is cut off at :15 (Week 2 at St. Louis: a fourteen-word call, a timeout spent to save it). After a 15-yard gain, the caller may go to "Fast" from a prepared row; a substitution after a big play is not allowed in Fast.

Drives and scoring

Play four drives per caller: one from the caller's own 25, one starting at midfield, one in the red zone from the opponent's 20, and a two-minute drive with one timeout. Track points, but grade the log: every call must have a written reason and a process grade before the result was known.

The self-scout reveal

The DC keeps a tally of the caller's calls by situation and formation. After the last drive, the DC reads it aloud: "On second-and-long you threw from Trips four of five times." It is the most memorable minute of the simulation, and it turns Chapter 23 §23.6 (the mirror) into something learners feel.

Debrief questions

  1. Which call did you make after :34? What did deciding late cost you?
  2. Which of your results were lucky, and which were unlucky? Use the earned / unlucky / lucky / deserved grid from Chapter 40 §40.7.
  3. Where did a written branch change a result?
  4. What did the DC learn about you that you didn't intend to tell him?

5. The halftime-adjustment simulation

The scenario

Game 2 at Sacramento, halftime, Sentinels 13, Outlaws 10 (Chapter 36). Austin's halftime is about thirteen minutes; the offensive block is about eight; Lyle's decision window runs from about 1:30 to 5:30 into the break, while Teo phones down from the booth. The medical staff owns the first minutes, and nobody is pulled out of an evaluation to hear an adjustment.

The handout (Teo's first-half notes)

  • 33 Austin snaps. Quick game 11 of 13 for 74 yards, long of 11.
  • Third downs 3 of 9. One explosive: a Sutton back-shoulder for 23.
  • Every quick throw came against off corners.
  • Twelve personnel: big nickel on all 9 snaps; low yield.
  • DeShawn Rollins (#94): 5 pressures on 17 rushes against the left tackle.
  • The end-of-half drive: a dig broken up at 1:12, a checkdown tackled in bounds, a timeout at 0:58, punt.

The task (twelve minutes, in groups of three)

Write no more than three changes, each run through the five-question triage filter of §36.4:

  1. Is it a pattern or a play?
  2. Who has to change?
  3. Can we say it in words we already have?
  4. What does it cost?
  5. What will they do to it?

Then fill in two lines the Outlaws added to the sheet after Week 15: "Their next move" (what Russ is changing in his locker room right now) and "Keep" (what you are deliberately not changing).

The reveal

Lyle's three changes: Trips with Sutton alone into the boundary and the tight end as #3 on a drag; chip Rollins with Ruffin; less Twelve. Russ's three changes, which Lyle learned only in the spring: corners pressed on about half of early downs, rotation from two-high on about half of early downs, and the mug corner fire zone live on third-and-7 and longer. The Monday audit: the second half finished 10–10, and the sack on 3rd-and-7 came from the third of Russ's changes. Lyle's own admission: at Sacramento he never filled in the "What would Russ do to it?" column.

Debrief

Which group predicted any of Russ's changes? Did any group write a change that required a new word or a new protection? (That's the "halftime install," the common mistake of §36.4.) Did any group spend a change on the end-of-half sequence (the "fixing the last series" mistake)? Close with Russ's spring line: "At halftime I don't fix what you did. I fix what you're going to keep doing."


6. Making it work in different rooms

Large lecture. Run chalk talks in groups of five with one presenter per group, and take one strong talk to the front board per session. Run the 40-second simulation as a demonstration with volunteers, while the rest of the room fills in the scorer's log and grades the process.

High school staff. Use your own call sheet, your own wristband, and a deck built from your next opponent's film. The say-back is the highest-value ten minutes you can spend in a staff meeting; every coach does it, including the head coach. Most high school programs signal or use wristbands rather than radios; run the simulation with your real signal system and your real play clock.

Analyst course. Make learners the booth and the scorer. Their job is to report "shell, box, one thing" in under six seconds and to grade every call by process before the dice roll.

Online or asynchronous. The say-back works by recorded video. The 40-second simulation works over video with a shared timer; the DC deals cards by message at :40.