Chapter 31 Exercises — The Quarterback Revolution
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and film study
Selected answers are in Appendix J. Part C items have short worked answers here. The Outlaws, Sentinels, Pioneers, Stallions, Forge, and Ospreys are this book's fictional teams. Situations marked hypothetical didn't happen in their season and are there for practice.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. Define plus-one as it applies to the run game. On a plain shotgun handoff, which two offensive players are not blocking anyone?
A2. What's the difference between a scramble and a designed quarterback run? Give one example of each from the Outlaws' season.
A3. Name the three "taxes" a running quarterback charges a defense, and for each, name what the defense gives up when it pays it.
A4. Define rush lane, contain, and launch point in one sentence each. Then explain in one more sentence why a contain-first rush is often called a "mush rush," and why Sacramento couldn't use that word in its own calls.
A5. List the three kinds of spy and what each one costs the defense.
A6. State Rome Pettaway's four scramble rules from memory. Which rule tells the quarterback what to do when the middle of the field is in doubt?
A7. State Darius Vance's three finish rules for any quarterback run.
A8. What is the Outlaws' quarterback-carry budget in the regular season and in the playoffs? What counts against it, what doesn't, and who tracks it?
A9. Why is the QB draw a good call against upfield rushers and deep-dropping linebackers, and a poor call against a contain-first rush?
A10. Where do QB Power and QB Counter live for the Outlaws, and why there?
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
B1. Pre-snap: two high safeties, four down linemen with both ends aligned wide, two linebackers at six yards. Post-snap: both safeties stay high, both linebackers turn and run to fifteen yards, both ends rush up the field past the quarterback's depth, and nobody covers the middle of the field below ten yards. Name the designed quarterback run this picture invites, and name the one thing the offensive line must do in the first second for it to work.
B2. You're watching All-22 of a third-and-9. At the quarterback's third step, one linebacker is square to the quarterback at six yards, moving laterally as the quarterback slides in the pocket. He neither drops nor rushes. The running back stayed in to block. Name what the linebacker is doing, the kind of spy it most likely is, and how you'd confirm it on the next third-and-long where the back releases.
B3. A four-man rush. Both ends rush outside the tackles and, at about seven or eight yards, turn back toward the quarterback instead of continuing past him. The tackles bull-rush straight back. No twists. Behind it, the defense plays a zone coverage with every underneath defender facing the quarterback. Name the rush and two ways the offense can punish it.
B4. Read this diagram and identify the read defender, the play, and what the quarterback does.
POST-SNAP
W M $
x x x
(E) N T E
| x x x
v O O O O O Y
\ Q < > R
'--> crashes on the back
📊 Diagram (described): Six offensive blockers have blocked the nose, the 3-technique, the right end, both linebackers, and the strong safety. The left end is circled and unblocked, and he crashes down the line toward the running back at the mesh.
B5. A pre-snap picture: 11 personnel, Gun Doubles Right, tight end attached right, back offset left. Post-snap: the left guard and left tackle both pull to the right; the back takes a hard inside-zone step to the left; the quarterback keeps the ball and follows the second puller. Name the play and the job of the back's fake.
B6. Game 1, fourth quarter, third-and-11 at the Austin 37. The left tackle kicks deep and wide against a speed rush, the end plants and spins inside, and the quarterback steps left and runs for twelve. In two sentences, explain why the end "won his rep and lost the down," and what rush rule would have prevented it.
B7. On film, a right-handed quarterback breaks the pocket to his left and runs. A cornerback in zone coverage on that side immediately leaves his receiver and comes up. Is the corner making a reasonable bet? Explain using the throwing-hand logic from 31.3.
B8. Read this pocket diagram. Name the rush, identify which rusher has broken its rule, and say where the quarterback should go.
POST-SNAP (pocket view)
E turns at E rushes
| Q's depth N push T loops \ past
v \ <---. \ the
LT LG C RG RT '-- (B gap v QB
\ | / now empty)
[ Q ]
📊 Diagram (described): The left end turns in at the quarterback's depth and the nose pushes straight back. The 3-technique loops outside instead of pushing his gap, leaving the right B gap empty, and the right end rushes past the quarterback's depth instead of turning in.
Answer
It's meant to be a contain rush, but two rules are broken on the right side: the 3-technique looped instead of pushing his gap (Lanes allows no twists), and the right end ran past the launch point. The door is on the right, through the empty B gap and outside the end who overran. A right-handed quarterback escaping right can still throw on the move, so rule 2 sends every receiver to his side.
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
C1. Make the call ⭐⭐ (hypothetical). Week 12 vs. St. Louis-style defense: single-high, an eight-man box with the strong safety rolled down, Cover 3 behind it. 1st-and-10 at your own 35, Q2, tied. Your quarterback has one designed carry so far. Do you call Inside Read? Count the box with and without the read, and say where the defense's free tackler is in each case.
Answer
Count: eight in the box against six blockers (five linemen and the tight end) — on a handoff, the defense has two free tacklers. Inside Read takes one back: you read the backside end, so six blockers handle the other seven box defenders minus one — still one short. The read alone doesn't fix an eight-man box; it turns minus-two into minus-one. Better answers: throw. An eight-man box with Cover 3 behind it is the classic play-action and RPO look ("Seven or fewer, run it; eight, take the throw," the Outlaws' rule from Chapter 9). If you want the quarterback involved, an RPO with a perimeter throw or a boot off the run fake attacks the eighth defender's vacated space without spending a carry.
C2. Draw it up ⭐⭐. Draw "Eleven, Gun Doubles Left, QB Counter Right" against a Nickel Over front set to the tight end. Show both pullers, the back's fake, the play-side down blocks, and where the quarterback runs. Then write one sentence on why the counter goes away from the tight end in the Outlaws' system.
Answer
The left guard (Moss) pulls and kicks out the end man outside the right tackle; the left tackle (Achterberg) pulls and wraps inside the kick-out to the play-side linebacker; the right guard blocks down on the nose; the right tackle climbs to the backside linebacker; the center blocks back on the 3-technique; Harlan hinges on the left end; the back fakes inside zone to the left to hold a linebacker; the quarterback follows the second puller. The counter goes away from the tight end because the tight end can hinge on the backside end when the tackle pulls — "we flip the formation, not the linemen."
C3. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐ (hypothetical). 3rd-and-6 at the opponent's 41, Q3, up 3. The defense has shown, on the last four third-and-medium snaps, man coverage with one deep safety and its Mike mirroring your quarterback at six yards. Four-man rush. Your quarterback has scrambled twice already today, both times into the Mike. Give the call (personnel, formation, protection, concept) and the quarterback's read.
Answer
The Mike is a dedicated spy, so the short-middle "rat" is gone. Attack the space: "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 60 Left, Mesh" (two crossers at five to seven yards through the spy's area). Read the spy: if he stays on the quarterback, throw the crosser in front of him; if he jumps a crosser, the other crosser or the quarterback's run is open. On 3rd-and-6, a crosser caught at five with a trailing man defender and no rat converts often. Avoid a called quarterback run into a defender whose only job is the quarterback.
C4. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐ (hypothetical). Two-point try, NFL (snap from the 2). The defense shows Cover 0 man with six rushers. You're in Eleven. Your Green panel includes "Eleven, Gun Trips Right, Sprint Right, Snag," QB Power Left, Inside Read, and Speed Right. Pick one and justify it using the plus-one and the defense's coverage.
Answer
Two strong answers. Speed Right: in Cover 0 every defender is assigned to a receiver, so the quarterback and pitch back are two ball carriers nobody covers; the rushers are the only defenders near them, and the pitch-key hit is a one-snap cost on a two-point try. Sprint Right, Snag: moves the launch point away from the six-man rush and gives the quarterback a run-pass read on the flat defender, who in man is chasing the flat route with his back turned. QB Power is weaker: six rushers plus man defenders who can fill on a run give the defense numbers inside.
C5. Draw it up ⭐⭐. Draw the Game 2 first-quarter third-and-11 at the Austin 44 from Sacramento's side: two-deep man, Ruffin stays in, Bell becomes the spy, Weller over-rushes on the right, Vance escapes right. Mark where Bell meets Vance and the line to gain. Then redraw it with Ruffin released on a route and say what Bell's job becomes.
Answer
In the first drawing, Bell mirrors at five to seven yards and meets Vance seven yards downfield at the Austin 51, four short of the line to gain at the Sacramento 45. In the second, Ruffin's release means Bell's man is running a route; under "back blocks, you spy," Bell must cover Ruffin, so there is no spy, and Vance's escape lane past Weller has nobody facing him.
C6. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐ (hypothetical). High school. 2nd-and-7 at midfield, ball on the right hash. Your quarterback is also your starting safety and has six designed carries in the first three quarters (your weekly budget is ten). The defense's backside end has crashed on every zone read. Call a zone read, and specify the direction of the zone and which end you read. Explain your choice with the hash.
Answer
Run the zone to the right (the boundary, toward the near sideline) and read the left, field-side end. When he crashes, the keep goes to the wide side, which on a high-school field has nearly twice the room of the boundary side. That puts the quarterback's keep in open grass and away from the sideline, and it keeps his carry worth the budget it spends.
C7. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐ (hypothetical). 3rd-and-11 at your own 30, Q4, tied. Film says the defense plays Lanes behind Quarters on every third-and-long and never spies. Do you call the QB draw? If not, what? Give one deep-concept answer and one moving-pocket answer.
Answer
No draw: Lanes keeps every rusher in his gap, and Quarters linebackers read the quarterback. Deep answer: a concept that needs time, protected by the slower contain rush — for example a max-protect dig or a post-dig ("Mills") with the back in, because the defense isn't paying the spy tax and the rush won't arrive fast. Moving-pocket answer: a sprint or boot that turns the far-side contain rusher into a chaser and gives a run-pass read on the flat defender, though on 3rd-and-11 the routes must reach the sticks.
C8. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐ (hypothetical). Divisional-round week, Thursday walk-through. The scout card says the opponent plays Swap (end on the back, Will scrapes to the quarterback) on every zone read in the first half and Sit (end on the quarterback, Will on the back) after halftime. Your quarterback has five designed carries approved. Write a four-call zone-read plan: which counter you call in the first half, which in the second, which one you hold back, and how many of the five carries the plan expects to spend.
Answer
First half, against Swap: Arc — the tight end releases around the end and blocks the scraping Will, so the keep has a lead blocker on the man assigned to the quarterback. Second half, against Sit: plain Inside Read, give-first — the end sitting on the quarterback makes the give automatic, and the back gets the gap the end left; Bash once if the end starts squeezing the back while sitting. Hold Power Read for third-and-short or the red zone. A sound plan expects to spend two or three carries, not five: the budget is a ceiling, and against Sit the read should produce gives. The reasoning that earns full credit names the defender each counter beats and admits what it loses to (Arc loses to Sit; Bash loses to Swap).
Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. Lyle says the scramble is "a play you build for but never call." Write a paragraph arguing for or against putting a scramble line on a third-down call sheet, using the Game 1 and Game 2 numbers (four scrambles for 38 yards and three first downs; two for 10 and none).
D2. Your head coach wants to raise the regular-season budget from three designed carries to six, because your quarterback averages more yards per designed carry than your back. Write the reply you'd give him, including what the yards-per-carry comparison leaves out and what you'd want to know before agreeing.
D3. Releasing the back on third-and-long takes away the green-dog spy but turns six-man protection into five-man. When is that trade worth it, and when isn't it? Use a contain rush, a five-man pressure, and a double-A mug as your three cases.
D4. A pocket quarterback who keeps the zone read twice a month for four yards each time "buys his running back hundreds of yards." Explain the mechanism, and then explain what happens if the quarterback's keeps disappear from film for six weeks.
D5. Case Study 1's fix included "Spy, shallow first." What risk does that rule create if the defense learns it? How would Russ attack it, and what would your answer be?
D6. Your starting quarterback is a true runner; your backup is a pocket passer who can't run. It's Week 9, and the starter has taken more hits than any quarterback on your schedule. Write the memo to your head coach proposing how to change the offense for the second half of the season. Address: the budget, which designed runs you keep, what you'd add to protect the starter (moving pockets, the quick game), and what you'd install now so the backup isn't running an offense built for someone else if the starter gets hurt in November.
D7. Lyle admits that after Game 2 he erased the scramble note from the call sheet but not from his head. Describe a staff process — a question on the Tuesday game-plan agenda, a self-scout column, or a rule for the call sheet — that would catch a "hidden assumption" like that before game day. Explain why a process works better than a resolution.
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (Chapter 12 + this chapter) Chapter 12's threshold concept is that you can "block" a defender with a decision. Explain how a dedicated spy is the defense's version of the same idea, and why it costs the defense a coverage player while the read costs the offense nothing.
M2. (Chapter 22 + this chapter) Chapter 22 says protection is arithmetic and the quarterback is part of the protection. Using the Game 1 third-and-11 and the Game 3 third-and-7 (Case Study 1), explain when a quarterback's legs act as the "extra blocker" and when a defense can take that blocker away.
M3. (Chapter 17 + this chapter) Chapter 17's scramble drill gave Rome's rule 1 a man-coverage emphasis. Explain why a scramble against man coverage is more dangerous to the defense than one against zone, and what a spy does to change that.
M4. (Chapter 10 + this chapter) In the spring Russ told Lyle, "You never booted us." Using the moving-pocket table in 31.7, explain why a boot is especially effective against a defense built around a contain rush and a spy, and connect it to the boot that tied Game 3.
M5. (Chapter 11 + Chapter 14 + this chapter) Compare QB Power, the QB sneak, and Power Read as short-yardage calls: where the plus-one comes from, the hit cost to the quarterback, and which defensive front each one beats.
M6. (Chapter 8 + this chapter) Write the wristband placement (panel and a one-line note) for five quarterback runs in your own package, using the Outlaws' Red / Blue / Green panel logic.
M7. (Chapter 7 + Chapter 28 + this chapter) Chapter 7 says the defense tells you where to go. Chapter 28 says analytics informs but doesn't decide. Marisol's LEGS slide (two games: 4 scrambles for 38 yards and 3 first downs, then 2 for 10 and none) is a two-game sample. Write the paragraph you'd present in the staff meeting: what the numbers suggest, what they can't prove, what the film shows that the numbers don't, and what decision you'd make anyway.
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. Chart the spy. Pick one NFL defense playing against a mobile quarterback. Chart every third down for two games: shell, rush count, whether any defender spied (and which kind — dedicated, rat with a quarterback rule, or green dog), whether the back stayed in, and what happened when the quarterback broke the pocket. Write one paragraph on which tax the defense paid by down and distance.
E2. Designed vs. scrambles. Using public play-by-play data (nflverse) or your own charting, separate one quarterback's designed runs from his scrambles across four games. Note down and distance, field zone, result, and how each ended (slide, sideline, hit). Then estimate the budget his staff seems to be using. Note the caveat: data sources don't always separate designed runs from scrambles cleanly, and your charting decisions should be written down.
E3. History cut-up. Watch available film or highlights from a mobile-quarterback era of your choice (the scrambling quarterbacks of the 1970s through 1990s, the 2012 read-option season, or the 2019 Ravens). For ten plays, label each as scramble or designed run, and for designed runs, identify the read defender or the plus-one. Write a page on how the defensive answers you see compare with Lanes and the spy in this chapter. Use only facts you can verify from the film or well-documented sources; don't invent statistics.