Chapter 29 — Discussion Guide
Opening question
"Your bootleg averages about ten yards a call. Your outside-zone run averages about four. Why wouldn't you call the bootleg more?"
Let the room argue it for a few minutes. Many students will say "you should," a few will say "the defense will catch on," and almost nobody will say "because the boot's ten yards were paid for by the run's four."
Why it works: it is the chapter's 🧩 Productive struggle asked out loud, and the wrong answer is the
one a smart, numbers-minded young coach gives. The fix is Marisol's boot table: 10.2 yards a call when the
backside end had chased twice or more on the drive, 4.5 after one chase, 1.8 with none. Write the
room's answers on the board. After §29.4, come back and ask which row each answer would push Austin into.
Discussion questions
Level 1 — Recall
1. State the system's design rule, and name the defender each of these plays lies to: Wide PA, Y Dig; Yankee; Wide PA Boot; Z Crack Go. Listen for: everything starts as the same run for as long as possible. The dig lies to linebackers who flow; Yankee to the alley safety who fills; the boot to the backside end who chases; Crack Go to the corner who replaces. Probe: "Which of those four defenders is doing his job correctly when he's fooled?" (All of them, which is the point.)
2. What's the difference between Boot and Naked in Austin's terminology, and what is the chase count? Listen for: the word after "Boot" is the quarterback's direction; on Boot the boot-side guard pulls to the edge; on Naked nobody pulls and the end is unblocked by design. The chase count is the booth's tally of how often the backside end chased the zone action on this drive, and Teo brought it in the week after Week 2. Probe: "Why is Naked called only when the end has 'proven' it, while Boot needs two chases?"
Level 2 — Analysis
3. In Week 2 at St. Louis the boot went incomplete. In Week 12 the same call against the same end went for 18. What changed? Listen for: evidence. In Week 2, Grange had seen one Wide all day, a bad one. He squeezed, looked inside, saw the guard and stayed home. In Week 12, Wide went 3, 2 and 4, and Grange chased Ruffin from behind on all three; then he chased the fake. Same call, same defender, opposite outcome. Probe: "Was the Week 2 call wrong, or only early?" (Case Study 1 asks what call would have attacked Grange's stay-home habit.)
4. Russ's ends "squeeze and look for the guard." Walk through the conversation that follows. Listen for: the §29.4 sequence. Your end chases, so I boot; my end looks for the guard, so your boot is a rollout; then I won't pull the guard (Naked); then my end stays home on every Wide; thank you, my cutback just got bigger. Every answer opens a door. Probe: "Why did the Game 3 boot touchdown come after Rollins had chased five straight times on the drive?"
5. Two-high defenses offered "four a carry all day." Why is accepting that bargain sometimes right and sometimes wrong? Listen for: six blockers on six box defenders with safeties at 10–11 yards is a good run look, and a coordinator who gets bored and throws into two safeties gives the defense what it wants. But down a score late, four a carry may not be enough (exercise D5). The system's tools: run it, pick the force defender with personnel, make the boot efficient rather than explosive, and use motion to pull a safety down. Probe: "In the divisional round, why did Austin run Wide from Eleven and save Twelve for the boot?"
Level 3 — Judgment and ethics
6. Naked leaves the most dangerous rusher on the field unblocked by design. Is it fair to your quarterback? Listen for: it can be, with rules: call it only on evidence, give him the rule "flat now, or throw it away; never take the sack on a boot," and practice it without live hits on him (exercise D3). The Thursday Whose fault? drill shows the play caller owns most of a first-snap Naked against a stay-home end. Probe: "Teo's El Paso quarterback lost a fumble on a Naked sack. What changed in that staff's rule, and why does 'never make the end miss' protect the player as much as the ball?"
7. Austin rejects backside cut blocks. Should a high-school staff that admires this system teach
them?
Listen for: the chapter's 🩺 note and borrow list: rules on blocks below the waist have tightened at
every level, and Gus teaches cutoff with the feet and hands. Students should check their own code, not a
video. Probe: "What part of the Denver-era run game can you keep if you remove the cut block?"
8. "Borrow reasons, not plays." Teo asked, "Why aren't we them?" Was Lyle's answer honest, or a rationalization? Listen for: Gus said "Because we've got Darius," Wade pointed to the Stallions' ends practicing against the boot every day in August, and Lyle named the principle. A strong student tests the answer against evidence: Vance's best football is in the gun against the blitz, and the boot table supports "rare and earned." Probe: "Name one thing on Austin's 'Adapt' list that you think should be 'Adopt,' and defend it with a 'because.'"
Structured role-play: "Why aren't we them?"
Setup: the Tuesday of Week 11, a little after midnight, the staff room before the Week 12 game against St. Louis. Teo has been watching the Stallions' offense, wide zone and the boot as pure as anyone's, and asks Lyle why Austin doesn't run it.
Roles: - Teo: argues for adopting the pure system: more under center, more boots, more Wide. He must use at least one number from the chapter. - Lyle: argues for Austin's adapted version and must defend one "Adopt," one "Adapt" and one "Reject" from the §29.10 list. - Gus: speaks for the line: what changes for his five if Austin goes under center on most snaps. - Marisol: may only present evidence (the boot table, boots per game, the sample size) and must say what the numbers don't know. - Wade: asks each speaker one question from a defensive coordinator's point of view.
Rules: no one may describe a play the other side "can't stop." Every claim has to name a player, a practice limit or an opponent. Six minutes, then Teo and Lyle trade roles.
Debrief: have each student write their own one-line answer to "Why aren't we them?" for the offense they're building. That line becomes the first sentence of page 2 of the Project Checkpoint.
Connecting to the case studies
Case Study 1, "St. Louis, Twice — The Boot You Haven't Paid For," sets the Week 2 boot (Q3, first down at the Austin 17, Grange stays home, incomplete, three-and-out) beside the Week 12 boot (three Wides, Grange chases, Harlan +18). Use exercise M3 here: the Stallions' strong safety could be fooled by play-action in Week 2 even though Austin's runs weren't working, but the backside end couldn't be fooled by the boot. Ask why the two defenders need different evidence.
Case Study 2, "Friday Nights in El Paso," is Teo's high-school year installing the system on high-school hashes: Wide only to the field from a hash, two line calls, the chase count in the press box, and a quarterback rule rewritten after the Week 4 Naked sack-fumble. Set the two cases against each other. Austin had to earn the chase from a disciplined pro end; El Paso had to make the system fit a quarterback, a line and practice time it was never built for. Both are borrow lists in action.
Closing synthesis prompt
"Pick one play-action or boot from your playbook. Name the run it imitates, the defender it lies to, and the evidence you need before you call it. If you can't name the run, what does the line coach in the hook say about it?"
Students who can't name the run have found Lyle's Trips boot. Close by returning to the opening answers and the line coach's sentence: "You built a play. We build pictures."