64 min read

Week 10, at Portland. Second quarter, 10:52 on the game clock, tied 7–7. Second-and-six at the

Chapter 16 — Smash, Flood, and Levels: The Core Route Concepts That Beat Every Coverage

The Hook: Kiel's Feet

Week 10, at Portland. Second quarter, 10:52 on the game clock, tied 7–7. Second-and-six at the Portland 31.

The whistle blows on Jalen Ruffin's four-yard run, and Teo's voice is the only one in my headset. He gives me three things, in the order he always gives them: "Two high. Six. Kiel at five."

Shell, box, one thing. The shell was two deep safeties. The box was six defenders, which meant Portland wasn't worried about our run. And the one thing was the reason we'd spent part of our bye week on a single cornerback.

His name is Josh Kiel, number 23. He plays the left side for the Portland Pioneers, and he plays it for Leon Marchetti, whose Cover 2 is the most disciplined coverage we'd see all season. During the bye, Teo cut up every snap in Portland's last four games where an offense put a short route and a deep outside route on Kiel's side. There were twenty-one. On seventeen of them, Kiel did exactly what his coach asks: he jammed the outside receiver, gave ground to about five yards, and when that receiver stopped short, Kiel's feet stopped too. He squatted, eyes on the quarterback, ready to drive on the short throw and make the tackle.

"He doesn't guess," Teo had said on the Wednesday of the bye, freezing the tape on Kiel's planted feet. "He does his job. Every time."

"Good," I said. "Then we know where he'll be."

Back on the sideline, the play clock reads 33. The call is already on my sheet, circled since Tuesday night: "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 60 Left, Smash." It goes into Darius Vance's helmet at 28. The huddle breaks at 19. Vance walks to the line, points into the middle of the defense, and shouts, "Fifty-two's the Mike!" That's Owen Talbert, Portland's middle linebacker. The line slides left. Ruffin sets on Vance's right.

Here's what happens in the next two and a half seconds.

Devonte Sutton, our split end on the left, runs six yards and turns around to face Vance. That's the hitch. Kiel's feet stop. Inside Sutton, our slot receiver Mekhi Powers runs straight up the field to twelve yards, then breaks hard toward the left pylon. That's the corner route. Darnell Price, the safety on the left half of the field, is standing on the hash with his eyes on our tight end, Brooks Harlan, who is running a seam aimed right between Portland's two safeties. Price has to respect Harlan for one beat. One beat is all we need.

Vance doesn't look at Sutton. He doesn't look at Powers. He looks at Kiel. Kiel's feet are planted on the hitch. So the ball goes over Kiel's head, on Powers's break, and lands at the Portland 13, where Price is a step too late and Kiel is five yards too shallow. Powers catches it in stride and walks into the end zone.

Thirty-one yards. Touchdown. 14–7.

That's the snap everybody remembers. The one I teach came in the third quarter. We called the same play again. This time Marchetti had told Kiel to sink when the slot ran vertical, and Kiel did. He turned and ran under Powers's corner route. So Vance threw the hitch to Sutton, who caught it with nobody within eight yards of him and gained eight.

Kiel did nothing wrong on either snap. He did his job the first time and his coach's adjustment the second time. The corner must choose, and both choices lose. That's not a trick. It's arithmetic: one defender, two receivers, two depths. Whatever he takes, he gives you the other.

This chapter is about three concepts built on that idea: smash, flood, and levels. Each one puts a different zone defender in the same impossible spot. Learn them together and you'll see what I see when I look at a defense: not eleven men, but three or four defenders who have more grass to cover than they can reach.

🏃 Fast Track: If you already teach smash, flood, and levels, skim 16.1 and 16.2 and go straight to 16.3 (smash from five formations), 16.5 (why smash weakens against Cover 3 and Quarters), and 16.8 (how the three concepts cover for each other). The read tables in 16.5, 16.6, and 16.7 are the reference you'll come back to.

🔬 Deep Dive: Appendix C has every concept in this chapter with its protection and its read against each coverage. For the coverages themselves, go back to Chapter 7. For the man-coverage answers these zone-beaters don't give you, read Chapter 17 next.

📺 Film Watcher: This Sunday, find the cornerback on a short-side throw and watch his feet, not the ball. If he stops at five yards and the ball sails over him to the sideline, you just watched smash beat Cover 2. If he's sprinting backward and the receiver in front of him catches a six-yard hitch, you watched the other half of it.


16.1 Three Concepts, One Idea: Make One Defender Wrong

Every zone coverage hands each underneath defender a piece of grass and a set of eyes. His job is to stand in his grass, read the quarterback, and break on the ball. He's good at it. NFL linebackers and corners break on a thrown ball faster than you'd believe until you stand next to them.

But a zone defender has one weakness you can't coach out of him. He can only be at one depth at a time. Put one receiver in front of him and another behind him, and he has to pick. The quarterback waits for the pick, then throws to the other man. Coaches call this a hi-lo: one receiver high, one low, the same defender in between. It's a vertical stretch, because it stretches one defender up and down the field.

Its cousin is the horizontal stretch: one receiver inside a defender, one outside him, at about the same depth. Hi-lo and horizontal stretch are the two basic ways to beat a zone. Most good pass concepts use one or both.

The three concepts in this chapter are all hi-lo concepts. What separates them is which defender they attack. That's the first thing to learn, and it's the thing most playbooks bury.

Concept Who runs what (the core) The defender in conflict Best against Weaker against
Smash #1 hitch at 6; #2 corner route to ~18 The flat defender — in Cover 2, the cornerback Cover 2, Tampa 2, the half side of Cover 6 Cover 3 (corner bails), Quarters (safety takes #2)
Flood A clear-out deep, a sail at ~12–18, a flat at ~2–4 — three levels to one side The curl/flat defender — in Cover 3, the outside linebacker, nickel, or rotated safety Cover 3, rotations to single-high, boot vs. any zone Quarters with an aggressive flat player; man
Levels A vertical clear; two in-breaking routes, ~5 and ~12 yards The hook defender — the inside linebacker or nickel in the middle Cover 3, Quarters, Tampa 2 (with a vertical to carry the Mike) Man (unless the routes win); heavy middle-robber coverages

Read the third column again. Smash attacks the corner. Flood attacks the man just inside and under the corner. Levels attacks the man in the middle. That's three different defenders, so three different coverage weaknesses. That's why we teach them as a set.

💡 Coach's point: Don't learn a concept by its routes. Learn it by its victim. "Smash" doesn't mean "hitch and corner." It means "make the flat defender choose." The routes are just how we do it today.

A word on names. Concept names vary by system. Many systems call these three smash, flood, and levels. Some call flood "sail," some call smash "cover 2 beater," and I've worked on staffs where levels was called something I won't print. In our building, these are the words, and they're the words in the rest of this book. All the teams and players in this chapter — our Austin Outlaws, the Portland Pioneers, the Sacramento Sentinels — are fictional, but the coverages and the rules they live under are real.

You also need one more piece of language from Chapter 15: the read key, or conflict defender. That's the one defender the quarterback watches after the snap. He doesn't read receivers. He reads the defender, and he throws where that defender isn't. Every concept in this chapter has a read key, and every read table names him.

🔍 Why this works: Count the defenders in Cover 2. Four rush, two play deep halves, five play underneath. The two deep safeties start near the hashes, about twelve to fifteen yards deep. The corner plays the flat at five or six yards. Now look at the sideline at about eighteen yards. Who's there? Nobody. The corner is twelve yards below it, and the safety is fifteen or more yards inside it. That hole is in the coverage on purpose. It's the price of putting a corner in the flat and two safeties deep. Smash doesn't create the hole. It forces the only man who could close it, the corner, to commit to something else first. The hole is a feature of Cover 2; the hi-lo makes it usable.

🔄 Check your understanding: A defense plays Cover 3. You run a concept that puts two receivers on the hook defender in the middle of the field, one at five yards and one at twelve. Which of the three concepts are you running, and why wouldn't smash put the same defender in conflict?

Answer

That's levels: two in-breakers at different depths stressing the hook defender. Smash attacks the flat defender with an outside short route and an outside deep route. Against Cover 3 the corner isn't a flat defender at all. He bails to the deep third, so smash's hi-lo lands on a different man (the curl/flat player) and the corner route runs into the bailing corner. Each concept is built for a particular defender; change the coverage, and the defender in conflict changes too.


16.2 Smash: Anatomy of the Anchor

Smash is the oldest concept in this chapter and the one every young coach installs first. That's because it's the simplest hi-lo there is: two receivers on one side, one short, one deep, and the defender between them is the one who matters most in Cover 2.

The routes

We use the route tree from Chapter 6. Evens break in, odds break out.

Player (Anchor B call) Route Depth and landmark Coaching point
#1 (Sutton, X) Hitch (our 0) Six yards; settle and face the QB Don't drift. Six, not eight. A deeper hitch gives the corner time to sink and still drive on it.
#2 (Powers, H) Corner (our 7) Stem to about 12, break to the pylon, ball arrives around 18 Stem vertical. If the stem bends outside early, the corner knows. The break must get over the corner's depth.
Backside #2 (Harlan, Y) Seam (smash's default) Vertical; against two-high, aim between the safeties His job is to hold the safety on the smash side. He's a decoy who scores when the safety doesn't respect him.
Backside #1 (Gaines, Z) Dig (smash's default) Twelve yards, square in The dig gives Vance a throw if the hook players run with the seam.
Back (Ruffin) Check, then release Man side (right) in 60 Left; release to the flat The checkdown. If both smash routes are covered, he's open.
Line 60 Left Slide left, man right Six-man protection; Vance has time for the corner route.

Two things about that table deserve emphasis.

First, the six-yard hitch. When I was a high school coordinator in Ohio, I lost a regional semifinal because my split end ran his hitch at eight yards. The corner sank, saw it, drove back down on it, and returned it the other way for a touchdown. The concept was right. The depth was wrong, and two yards is the whole difference between a corner who can't get there and a corner who can. We told that story in Chapter 6; I'm telling it again because it's the most common way smash fails.

Second, the backside seam. Smash is usually drawn as a two-man concept, and on a whiteboard it is. But in a real Cover 2, the half-field safety on the smash side doesn't stand still. If nothing threatens him, he widens toward the sideline at the snap and gets over the corner route. Our smash has a rule for that: the backside #2 runs a seam, and against two high safeties, he aims between them. Many systems call that kind of seam a "divide" route, because it divides the safeties. Now the smash-side safety has a receiver coming at the middle of the field he shares with the other safety. He has to wait a beat to see whether that receiver is his. On the touchdown at Portland, that beat was Price's.

The read

Vance reads the flat defender. In Cover 2, that's the corner on the smash side.

What the corner does What it means Throw
Squats on the hitch (stops his feet at 5–7 yards, eyes on the QB) He's taking #1 Corner route to #2, over his outside shoulder
Sinks under the corner route (turns and gains depth) He's taking #2 Hitch to #1, right now
Splits the difference (drifts back at 8–10, flat-footed) He's guessing Hitch. The hitch is the safe answer; the corner route is the explosive one.
Presses and runs with #1 (man) Not Cover 2 Go to the man read (16.5)

The timing matters as much as the read. From the gun, Vance takes a three-step drop and hitches once. On the first step, he finds the corner. If the corner is sinking, the hitch is thrown on rhythm, at about 1.3 seconds. If the corner squats, Vance hitches up and throws the corner route on Powers's break, at about 2.4 seconds. The protection only has to hold that long.

Anchor B: the touchdown at Portland

Here is the snap from the hook, drawn the way we drew it on the board the Monday after.

PRE-SNAP: Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 60 Left, Smash
          (Week 10 at Portland, 2nd-and-6 at the POR 31, 7-7)

        F Price                              $ Moffitt
        ~13, left hash                       ~13, right hash

 C Kiel        *          W       M                    C Okoro
 ~5, outside                     Talbert
                   E    T    T    E
 X          H      O  O  O  O  O  Y                  Z
 Sutton     Powers           Q  R           Harlan     Gaines
                                Ruffin

📊 Diagram (described): Before the snap the Outlaws are in two-by-two. On the left, Sutton is split wide on the line and Powers is in the slot. The tight end, Harlan, is attached to the right tackle, and Gaines is split wide right. Vance is in the shotgun with Ruffin on his right. Portland shows two safeties about thirteen yards deep, one over each hash: Darnell Price on the left and the strong safety on the right. The left corner, Josh Kiel, is about five yards off Sutton with outside leverage. A nickel is over Powers, two linebackers (Talbert is the Mike) are in the middle, and four defensive linemen are on the line.

POST-SNAP vs. COVER 2: Kiel squats, Price is held, ball to the corner

  TD <___ caught ~POR 13
          \_ H corner          ( F ) Price          $
            \_                 held on the hash  [DEEP 1/2]
              |  .             by the Y seam
              |    .                      ^
              |      .                    | Y seam
              | breaks ~12                | (aims between
 ( C ) Kiel   |        .   W     M        |  the safeties)
   SQUATS     |  *       .                |   <------+ Z dig 12
     ^        |            .              |          |
     | hitch 6|              .            |          |
     X        H        O  O  O  O  O      Y          Z
                       <== slide left.
                                  Q   R --> check, then flat
                       (. . . = the throw, over Kiel)

📊 Diagram (described): After the snap the line slides left and Ruffin checks the right side before releasing to the flat. On the left, Sutton runs a six-yard hitch. Kiel, the left corner, squats in front of it. Powers stems straight up to about twelve yards and breaks toward the left pylon. Harlan runs a seam from the right aimed between the two safeties, and Price, the left safety, holds on the hash with his eyes on Harlan. Gaines runs a twelve-yard dig on the right. The two linebackers and the nickel drop to the hook areas. The dotted line shows Vance's throw going over Kiel and landing near the Portland 13, where Powers catches it in front of Price and scores.

🎙️ On the headset: Second-and-six at their 31, 7–7, 10:52 in the half. Teo says "two high, six, Kiel at five." Six in the box on second-and-six means Marchetti thinks we'll throw, and he's playing it with two deep halves and five under. That's his Cover 2. It's also the coverage smash was built for. Kiel has squatted on the hitch seventeen times in twenty-one. If he squats, it's a touchdown or close. If he doesn't, Sutton has an eight-yard hitch and it's third-and-short. I'll take both outcomes. The only bad ending is a sack, and 60 Left gives us six blockers against a four-man rush. Call it.

Why did it score instead of gaining eighteen? Two reasons, and neither is luck.

Price was held. Harlan's seam aimed for the middle of the field between Price and the other safety. In a straight Cover 2, both safeties share that middle, and a seam splitting them is each man's problem until it isn't. Price waited to see whether Harlan would bend to his side. That wait put him a step late to the corner route, and a step late at eighteen yards means the receiver catches it with his feet under him.

Kiel squatted hard. Portland's corners are coached to rally and tackle — "keep it in front" is the whole philosophy. That's why Kiel drives on hitches, and that's why Portland gives up so few yards after the catch. It's also why, when the ball goes over him, nobody is underneath to slow Powers down.

🛡️ The defense's view: Put yourself in Leon Marchetti's chair. His Cover 2 rule for the corner is simple: re-route #1, sit in the flat, and break on anything short. He knows the sideline hole exists. He's betting his safeties can close it from the hash and his corners can make you pay for every short throw. Over a season, that bet wins more than it loses; most offenses won't throw an eighteen-yard corner route against a disciplined two-deep team on second-and-six. His answers to smash, in order: tell the corner to sink when #2 releases vertical (which he did in the third quarter); widen the half-field safety earlier ("cheat the corner route"); or rotate to Cover 3 before the snap so the corner is deep. Each answer costs him something, and that's the point of the next few sections.

The second smash

Third quarter, Austin's first drive. 12:20 on the clock, Austin leading 14–10. First-and-ten at our own 46. Same call, same personnel, same formation. Portland in the same two-high look.

This time, when Powers released vertical, Kiel turned his hips and sank. Marchetti had made the adjustment at halftime, the way any good coordinator would after giving up a touchdown to one concept. Vance saw Kiel's hips turn on his first step, set his feet, and threw the hitch on rhythm. Sutton caught it at the Portland 48, turned upfield, and was tackled at the 46. Eight yards on first down. The drive went on to a field goal.

POST-SNAP vs. COVER 2 (sink): Kiel takes the corner, ball to the hitch

  <__ H corner (Kiel under it)
     \_                         F Price
       \                         widens late
  ( C ) |  Kiel SINKS
    ^   |                       W      M
    |   |
    |   |   *
  hitch 6 <. . . . . . . . . . .
    ^   |                        .
    |   |                          .
    X   H              O  O  O  O  O     Y              Z
                                  Q   R
                (. . . = the throw, Q to the hitch)

📊 Diagram (described): Same play, same alignment. This time, when Powers runs vertical, Kiel turns and sinks under his corner route, and Price widens late to help over the top. That leaves Sutton alone at six yards with Kiel now eight or more yards away and still moving backward. The dotted line shows Vance throwing the hitch to Sutton on rhythm.

Eight yards isn't a highlight. It's better than that. It's proof the concept has an answer no matter what the corner does — and the touchdown made Kiel's coach tell him to give it to us.

⚠️ Common mistake: reading the receivers instead of the corner. A young quarterback sees Powers break open in the first quarter and decides, in the third, that smash means "throw the corner." He stares at Powers, Kiel sinks under him, and the ball goes into Kiel's chest. Fix: the corner route is not the primary receiver. The corner is the read. Rome Pettaway drills it with one rule: "Your eyes belong to the corner until his feet tell you something."

🔄 Check your understanding: Why does smash's backside seam matter in a two-high coverage, even though the ball almost never goes to it?

Answer

Because the half-field safety on the smash side is the only defender who can get over the corner route in time. If nothing threatens him, he widens at the snap and the corner route runs into him. A seam aimed between the two safeties makes him wait a beat to see whether it's his. That beat is what lets the corner route land in the hole. At Portland, Price's wait on Harlan is why Powers scored instead of being tackled at the 13.


16.3 One Conflict, Five Formations

If smash only worked from Doubles, Marchetti would have answered it before we got off the bus. He would have told Kiel: "When they're in two-by-two with the slot off the line, sink." A concept that lives in one formation is a tendency, and Chapter 3's lesson about formations is that a tendency is a gift to the other sideline.

So we teach smash as a relationship — a short outside route under a deep outside route, attacking the flat defender — and we carry that relationship into every formation family we use. The defender in conflict stays the same. What changes is how the defense sees it coming, who else is in the picture, and what the formation costs us.

You've seen formation one: Doubles, the Anchor B picture in 16.2. Here are the other four, each against the same Cover 2 shell, each with what it adds and what it costs.

Formation two: Trips — "smash-seam"

Call: "Eleven, Gun Trips Right, 60 Left, Smash Right." In Trips there's no two-receiver side away from an attached tight end, so the concept needs a direction word (Chapter 8's rule). Gaines steps onto the line as the right end, so we still have seven on the line: Sutton, the five linemen, and Gaines.

PRE-SNAP: Eleven, Gun Trips Right, 60 Left, Smash Right (vs. Cover 2)

        F                                       $
        ~13                                     ~13, shaded to trips

 C                        W      M     *                     C
 ~6                                   (over H)             ~5, outside
                    E    T    T    E
 X                  O  O  O  O  O       Y        H           Z
                          Q  R

📊 Diagram (described): Three receivers to the right: Harlan (Y) detached as the inside receiver (#3), Powers (H) in the middle (#2), and Gaines (Z) on the line wide right (#1). Sutton is alone on the left. Vance is in the shotgun with Ruffin on his right. The defense shows two safeties at about thirteen yards, the right one shaded toward the trips; a nickel over Powers; two linebackers; a four-man front; and corners at five to six yards.

POST-SNAP vs. COVER 2: the #3 seam holds the trips-side safety

                                       ^ Y seam
                                       |  (the safety's own
          F                            |   problem now)   ( $ )
                                       |                 __> H corner
                                       |               _/
  +--------> X dig 12                  |              /
  |                                    |             |  ( C ) squats:
  |                  W         M       |             |    throw corner
  |                       *            |             |  ^ sinks:
  |                                    |             |  |  throw hitch
  X                  O  O  O  O  O     Y      H         Z  hitch 6
                     <== slide left
                           Q   R --> check, then flat

📊 Diagram (described): After the snap, Harlan runs a seam straight up from the inside of the trips, right at the safety on that side. Powers runs the corner route and Gaines runs the six-yard hitch. The right corner, Cover 2's flat defender on that side, is caught between them. Sutton runs a twelve-yard dig on the left. The line slides left, and Ruffin checks the right side before releasing.

What Trips adds: the safety-holder is now on the same side as the smash. Many systems call this "smash-seam." In Doubles, the backside seam has to hold the smash-side safety from across the field. In Trips, #3's seam runs right at him. If he widens to the corner route, Harlan is open up the hash at twenty yards. If he sits on Harlan, the corner route is open behind the corner. That's a second conflict stacked on the first: the corner is in a hi-lo, and the safety above him is in his own two-way bind.

What Trips costs: the backside is one receiver, Sutton, against a corner and a safety. You've given up the backside seam that made Doubles a two-sided play. And the defense sees three receivers to one side, which tells a good coordinator where the concept is going. Marchetti answers Trips by rolling his coverage to the trips side, so we use this smash when Portland has stayed balanced against it.

Formation three: Trey — play-action smash

Call: "Eleven, Gun Trey Right, Inside PA, Smash Right." In Trey the tight end is attached as #3, so the formation looks like a run formation. Gaines is the flanker, off the line; Harlan is the right end on the line; Sutton is the left end.

PRE-SNAP: Eleven, Gun Trey Right, Inside PA, Smash Right (vs. Cover 2)

        F                                    $
        ~12                                  ~12

 C                      W       M      *                  C
 ~6                                   (over H)          ~6
                   E    T    T    E
 X                 O  O  O  O  O  Y          H              Z
                        R  Q

📊 Diagram (described): Harlan is attached to the right tackle as #3. Powers is in the right slot (#2) and Gaines is wide right off the line (#1). Sutton is alone on the left. Ruffin is offset to Vance's left, the side away from the inside-zone fake. The defense is in the same two-high shell, a little shallower on the safeties.

POST-SNAP vs. COVER 2: the fake pulls the corner up; throw over him

                                 ^ Y seam (late, after
          F                      |   a one-count fake block)   $
                                 |                         __> H corner
                                 |                       _/
                   W      M      |                     _/ ( C ) comes
  +-------> X dig     ^     ^    |                    |   UP on run:
  |                   |     |    |                    |   throw corner
  |                    run fit   |                    |  ^ Z curl 10
  |                     *        |                    |  | (low route
  X                O  O  O  O  O Y              H        Z   on PA)
                   inside-zone flow ===>
                        R <. Q  (fake)

📊 Diagram (described): The line blocks inside zone to the right and Vance fakes the handoff to Ruffin. Both linebackers step up toward the run. Harlan blocks for a count and then releases up the seam. Powers runs the corner route; Gaines runs a curl at about ten yards instead of a six-yard hitch. In Cover 2, the right corner is a run-force player, so the fake pulls him up toward the line, and the corner route opens behind him. If he stays back, the curl is open in front of him.

What Trey adds: a run fake changes what the Cover 2 corner is thinking. In most Cover 2 teaching, the corner is the force player on a run to his side: he's the man who turns the ball back inside. When the run fake comes toward him, he has to come up. Now the hi-lo has help from the run game. The linebackers step up too, which empties the hook zones for Sutton's backside dig.

What Trey costs: time. A play-action fake takes about a second, so the low route can't be a six-yard hitch; it would be standing still with a corner driving on it before Vance turns around. On our play-action smash, the hitch becomes a ten-yard curl by rule. The hi-lo is now a curl and a corner. Harlan also releases late, so his seam holds the safety a beat later than it does in Doubles. Chapter 19 teaches the rest of what play-action asks for; the short version is that this smash only works if the inside zone it imitates has been working.

Formation four: Bunch — the cluster smash

Call: "Eleven, Gun Bunch Right, 60 Left, Smash Right." Three receivers in a tight triangle about six yards outside the right tackle: Powers on the line at the point, Gaines off the line outside him, Harlan off the line inside him.

PRE-SNAP: Eleven, Gun Bunch Right, 60 Left, Smash Right (vs. Cover 2)

        F                                   $
        ~13                                 ~13

 C                      W       M       *         C
 ~6                                              ~5, inside the
                   E    T    T    E              bunch, not outside
 X                 O  O  O  O  O         H
                         Q  R          Y   Z

📊 Diagram (described): Three receivers bunched on the right, about six yards outside the right tackle. Powers is on the line at the front of the triangle. Harlan is a yard behind and inside him, and Gaines is a yard behind and outside him. Sutton is alone on the left. The right corner has to align over the bunch, much closer to the formation than he would over a wide receiver, which leaves a lot of grass between him and the right sideline.

POST-SNAP vs. COVER 2: the corner starts inside; the sideline is huge

                                          ^ Y seam
          F                               |              ( $ )
                                          |                    __> H
                                          |                  _/ corner
  +-------> X dig 12                      |               _/
  |                  W       M            |             _/
  |                                       |            |    ( C )
  |                        *              |            |  squats on Z
  |                                       |      Z hitch  ^
  |                                       |    (bends out |
  X                O  O  O  O  O          | to 6 on the numbers)
                   <== slide left       Y    H
                         Q   R --> check      Z

📊 Diagram (described): From the bunch, Harlan runs a seam straight up, Powers breaks from the point toward the right pylon, and Gaines pushes outside to about six yards near the numbers and turns back for the hitch. Because the right corner started over the bunch, his flat responsibility is now far outside him, and the grass toward the sideline for Powers's corner route is much wider than in any other formation.

What Bunch adds: three things. First, free releases: a corner can't press three men stacked a yard apart, so Powers gets off the line clean. Second, identification trouble: the defense has to decide who is #1 and who is #2 before it knows who is going where. Many Cover 2 teams use an "in-out" call against a bunch — the corner takes the first receiver who goes outside, the nickel takes the first who goes inside — and smash makes both outside routes, so the corner has two "outside" receivers at once. Third, grass: the corner aligns inside his usual spot, so the hole on the sideline gets bigger.

What Bunch costs: a longer throw. The corner route starts six yards from the tackle and has to cross to the sideline, and Vance throws it from the opposite hash if the ball is there. Gaines's hitch is also less clean, because he's working outside across the corner's face. We like bunch smash from the middle of the field or the near hash, and we don't call it from the far hash.

Formation five: Empty — "Double Smash"

Call: "Eleven, Gun Empty Right, 50 Left, Double Smash." Ruffin aligns as the inside receiver of a three-man side. Smash runs on both sides. Vance chooses the side before the snap.

PRE-SNAP: Eleven, Gun Empty Right, 50 Left, Double Smash (vs. Cover 2)

          F                                    $
          ~13                                  ~13

 C              *          W      M                 *?   C
 ~5                                                     ~6
                   E    T    T    E
 X          H      O  O  O  O  O       R      Y           Z
                         Q

📊 Diagram (described): No back in the backfield. On the left, Sutton is wide and Powers is in the slot. On the right, three receivers: Ruffin inside, Harlan in the middle, and Gaines wide. Vance is alone in the shotgun. The defense shows two high safeties, a nickel over Powers, two linebackers, a four-man front, and corners on both sides. Against empty, Portland sometimes walks a linebacker or a dime defender out over the three-man side, marked with a question mark.

POST-SNAP vs. COVER 2: two smashes, two corners in conflict

   <__ H corner                                        Y corner __>
      \_       F                                $            _/
        \                                                   /
         |        W       M     ^ R stick                  |
 ( C )   |   *                  | at 5, sit                |   ( C )
   ^     |                      | vs. zone                 |     ^
   | X   |                      |                          |     |  Z
  hitch  |                      |                          |   hitch
   X     H        O  O  O  O  O R                          Y     Z
                 <== 50 slide left
                        Q   (no back: hot = the stick, then a hitch)

📊 Diagram (described): Both sides run smash. On the left, Sutton's hitch and Powers's corner put the left corner in conflict. On the right, Gaines's hitch and Harlan's corner do the same to the right corner. Ruffin, the inside receiver on the right, runs a five-yard stick route in the middle and sits against zone. All five linemen slide left in five-man protection. Vance has picked one side before the snap and reads only that corner; Ruffin's stick is the hot throw if a sixth rusher comes.

What Empty adds: Cover 2 has five underneath defenders and you've put five receivers in front of them. Nobody can double anybody. Both corners are in the same hi-lo, so the defense can't sink one corner without leaving the other side open, and Vance picks the softer one. His pre-snap rule: pick the side where the corner is shallower and the safety is farther inside. After the snap, he reads only that corner.

What Empty costs: protection. In 50 we block five, so a sixth rusher is unblocked. Vance's answer is the ball: Ruffin's stick, then the hitch on the blitz side. Against a team like Portland that blitzes rarely, that's a fair trade. Against the Birmingham Forge, who blitz on almost every passing down, it's a different call, and that's Chapter 17's world.

The five formations at a glance

Formation Flat defender in conflict The extra problem it gives the defense What it costs When we call it
Doubles (Anchor B) Smash-side corner Backside seam holds the smash-side safety Nothing special; it's the base Any time two-high shows balanced
Trips (smash-seam) Trips-side corner #3 seam puts the trips-side safety in his own bind One receiver backside; trips tips the side Two-high defenses that don't roll to trips
Trey (PA smash) Trey-side corner, who is also a run-force player Run fake pulls the corner and hooks up Time; the hitch becomes a curl After the inside zone has been gaining
Bunch Bunch-side corner, aligned inside Releases vs. press; "in-out" calls see two outs A longer corner throw Middle of the field, or near hash
Empty (Double Smash) Both corners Five-on-five underneath; QB picks a side Five-man protection Low-blitz, two-high teams

🔄 Check your understanding: You call smash from Trey on first down with the inside-zone fake. Why do we change the low route from a six-yard hitch to a ten-yard curl, and what does the run fake do to the Cover 2 corner?

Answer

The fake takes about a second, so a six-yard hitch would already be stopped, and covered by a driving corner, before Vance could throw it. The ten-yard curl arrives at the right time. The fake matters because the Cover 2 corner is usually the run-force player on his side. When he sees the run coming at him, he has to come up to turn it inside. That pulls him toward the line and opens the corner route behind him. If he doesn't come up, he's deep, and the curl is open in front of him.


16.4 Smash Variations: Divide, Smash-Seam, and China

Every good concept grows variations, and each variation answers a specific defensive adjustment. That's the right way to think about them. A variation isn't decoration; it's a reply.

Variation What changes The defensive adjustment it answers
Divide (our smash's built-in backside seam) The backside #2's seam reads the shell: two high, aim between the safeties; one high, stay on the hash and bend away from the safety A smash-side safety who widens early to the corner route
Smash-seam (Trips, 16.3) #3 runs the seam on the smash side The same, but stronger: the safety-holder is on his side
China (our inverted smash) #1 runs the corner from the outside; #2 runs a short in-and-out to the flat A corner told to sink when #2 goes vertical
Smash, X (or Z) Stop-Go #1 fakes the hitch and goes deep ("zero-nine") A corner who's been jumping hitches all day

Divide you've already met; it's why Price waited. The name describes the job: the seam divides the two safeties. Against single-high, there's nothing to divide, so the same receiver stays on the hash and bends away from the middle safety. One route, two shapes, decided by the shell.

China needs a word of care, because the name means different things in different systems. In ours, it's the inverted smash. The outside receiver runs the high route, a corner from the outside. The slot runs the low route, a china route: three hard steps inside to about five yards, as if he's running a slant or a drag, then a sharp break back out to the flat.

POST-SNAP: Doubles, Smash Left with "China" vs. Cover 2 (sink rule)
           (pre-snap picture: the same as Anchor B in 16.2)

      __> X corner (from the outside)
    _/                     F (no #2 vertical:
   /                          nothing to divide;
  |                           he stays on the hash)
  |
  |   ( C ) Kiel: no #2 vertical,
  |         so the sink rule never
  |         fires; he squats
  |      <------.
  |  H china:    \  ~5 in, then out
  |  the flat     \
  X              H     O  O  O  O  O   Y            Z
                                 Q   R

📊 Diagram (described): The play starts from the same Doubles look as the touchdown. This time the outside receiver, Sutton, runs the corner route from the outside, and the slot, Powers, takes three hard steps inside to about five yards and then snaps back out toward the left sideline. The corner, taught to sink when the slot goes vertical, never sees the slot go vertical, so he stays shallow to play the flat, and the corner route goes over him. If he gains depth with Sutton, Powers is open in the flat.

Here's the point of China. Marchetti's halftime fix was "sink when #2 goes vertical." That's a trigger-based rule; it fires on something the offense does. China takes the trigger away. The slot never goes vertical, so the corner never gets the signal to sink, and he's back in his old conflict with a new picture. We didn't run China at Portland; the hitch was there all afternoon. But it was on the wristband, and it's how you stay a step ahead of a corner who's been coached on your smash.

🧩 Productive struggle: It's the fourth quarter. Kiel has now sunk on every vertical release by Powers since halftime, and he's started jumping the hitch too: he sinks two steps, then plants and drives on Sutton the instant Sutton turns around. He broke up a hitch on the last drive. Before you read on, decide: what's your smash-family call against this corner, and why?

Think about what he's doing with his eyes and feet. He's not covering a receiver. He's covering two routes by reacting to the one that stops.

Answer

A corner who sinks and then drives on the hitch is the one who most fears the hitch, so make the hitch the lie. "Smash, X Stop-Go" (Sutton's "zero-nine") keeps the picture identical for six yards. Sutton stops and turns, Kiel plants and drives, and Sutton turns back upfield past him. Powers's corner route holds Price on the outside, so Sutton's stop-go is up the sideline, alone, with the corner's momentum going the wrong way. A second sound answer is China, which takes away the vertical-#2 trigger he's using to decide when to sink. A wrong answer is "keep throwing the hitch": his technique is built to beat exactly that. The hitch is only free when the corner is truly gone.


16.5 Smash Against Everything Else

Here is the truth that sells fewer clinic tapes: smash is a Cover 2 beater, and it is noticeably weaker against everything else. It isn't useless. It has an answer against every coverage, which is why we carry it. But its explosive answer — the corner route — only exists when the corner is the flat defender. Let's walk the other coverages.

Cover 3: the corner isn't in the flat anymore

In Cover 3 the corner on each side bails to a deep outside third. He doesn't care about the hitch. He's backpedaling to get over everything vertical, and Powers's corner route runs straight into the grass he owns. The flat now belongs to the curl/flat defender — a nickel, an outside linebacker, or a safety rotated down.

PRE-SNAP: Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 60 Left, Smash (vs. single-high)

                            F   (~14, middle)

 C                *          W       M         $            C
 ~7                                          (~7, walked     ~7
                    E    T    T    E           down)
 X         H        O  O  O  O  O  Y                     Z
                          Q  R

📊 Diagram (described): The same Outlaws formation as Anchor B. Now the defense shows one safety deep in the middle at about fourteen yards and the strong safety walked down near the tight end at about seven yards. Both corners are off at about seven yards. The middle of the field is closed.

POST-SNAP vs. COVER 3: no corner in the flat; the hitch is the answer

   C [DEEP 1/3]                 F [DEEP MIDDLE]       C [DEEP 1/3]
   bails over the                                       ^
   corner route  __> H corner                           |
            ^  _/    (into the corner's                  | Z (dig)
            | /       third: NO)                         |
            |/          ^ Y seam, one-high:              |
           ||           |  stays on the hash, bends      |
 ( * ) curl/flat        |  away from F     W    M  $     |
  widens? -> hitch      |                                |
  jumps hitch? -> Y seam or the dig                      |
   hitch 6 ^            |                                |
   X       H         O  O  O  O  O         Y             Z
                           Q   R --> check, flat

📊 Diagram (described): After the snap the defense plays Cover 3. Both corners bail into deep thirds and the free safety takes the deep middle. Powers's corner route runs right into the left corner's deep third, so it isn't a throw. The left curl/flat defender, the nickel, is the read now. If he widens or carries Powers vertically, Sutton's six-yard hitch is open under the bailing corner. If he jumps the hitch, Vance goes to Harlan's seam, which against one high safety stays on the hash and bends away from the free safety, or to Gaines's dig.

So against Cover 3, smash turns into a hitch-or-elsewhere read. That's a good play — you saw it in Chapter 8, when the same smash against the St. Louis Stallions' Cover 3 gave us a seven-yard hitch to Gaines on second-and-eight. But seven yards on purpose is a different animal from thirty-one yards on purpose. Against a Cover 3 team, if you want to stress the curl/flat defender, the concept built for him is flood (16.6).

Quarters: the safety takes #2

In Quarters (Cover 4), each safety reads the #2 receiver on his side. If #2 goes vertical, the safety takes him. Powers's stem looks vertical for twelve yards, so the safety is already driving on him when he breaks for the pylon, from an inside-out angle. The corner, meanwhile, plays #1 from depth, so he's off Sutton and will drive on the hitch but won't be in position to stop it before the catch.

POST-SNAP vs. QUARTERS: the safety drives on #2; the hitch is small
           (pre-snap: the same two-high shell as Anchor B)

  <__ H corner: COVERED
     \_     ( F ) reads #2: vertical,       $ reads his #2
       \      so he drives on the
        |     corner route from inside
  C     |                          W       M
  deep  |
  1/4,  |   *
  off X |
   v    |
   ^ X hitch 6 (open; corner drives and tackles)
   |    |
   X    H            O  O  O  O  O   Y               Z
                           Q   R ---> flat: open early, small

📊 Diagram (described): Against Quarters, the left safety reads Powers, the #2 receiver. Powers's stem is vertical, so the safety drives on him and is in position when Powers breaks toward the pylon. The corner route is covered. The left corner is playing deep on Sutton, so the six-yard hitch is open, but the corner drives on it quickly and tackles. Ruffin's release to the flat is also open early, because Quarters has fewer defenders underneath, but it gains only a few yards before the linebackers rally.

Against Quarters, smash is a short-gain play: the hitch or the checkdown. Our last smash of the season came on the final drive of the divisional playoff at Sacramento — second-and-ten at our own 37, against the Sentinels' Quarters. The corner route was covered, the hitch was tight, and Vance checked it down to Ruffin, who was tackled by Marcus Bell for one yard. That made it third-and-nine, and you know what happened next if you've read Chapter 7. I don't blame smash for that interception. I do blame myself for calling a Cover 2 beater on second-and-ten against a team that had played Quarters on the down for a month. Against Quarters, the concepts that hurt are the ones that make #2 lie to the safety — the bender, scissors, post-dig — and those belong to Chapter 18.

Man coverage and Cover 0

Against Cover 1 (one deep safety, man underneath), smash stops being a zone read and becomes two one-on-ones. The corner route is a strong man route against a slot defender with inside leverage, because the route breaks away from where he's standing. The hitch works against off coverage. Against press, it's harder, because Sutton has to win his release and then stop. The read changes from "watch the flat defender" to "watch leverage": throw the route that is breaking away from its defender.

Against Cover 0 (no deep safety, everybody rushing or in man), you shouldn't be in smash at all. Vance should have used the zero bin (Chapter 8). If he can't, the hitch is the hot throw, and it has to come out at about 1.2 seconds.

The smash read, every coverage

Post-snap coverage The read key Throw, in order Explosive possible?
Cover 2 Smash-side corner (flat) Squat → corner route. Sink → hitch. Yes — the corner route into the hole
Tampa 2 Smash-side corner Same as Cover 2; the Mike runs with the seam, so the safety can widen earlier — hitch more often Sometimes
Cover 6 (Quarters one side, Cover 2 the other) The corner on the Cover 2 half Smash to the half side: as Cover 2. Smash to the quarter side: as Quarters Yes, to the half side
Cover 3 Curl/flat defender Widens or carries → hitch. Jumps hitch → seam (on the hash) or dig. Rarely
Quarters Smash-side safety, then corner Safety drives on #2 → hitch or checkdown Rarely
Cover 1 Leverage of each defender Corner route vs. inside leverage; hitch vs. off Yes, if the slot defender is inside
Cover 0 None — the ball must come out Hitch, hot, ~1.2 s Only after the catch

📈 By the numbers: Marisol charted every smash we called this season (all numbers are from our fictional season, and the samples are small, so treat them as directions, not laws). We called it 38 times. Against Cover 2 and Tampa 2 — 11 snaps — Vance completed 9 for about 12 yards per attempt, with two touchdowns. Against Cover 3 — 13 snaps — almost every completion was the hitch, at about 6 yards per attempt. Against Quarters — 9 snaps — about 4 yards per attempt, including two checkdowns. The other five were against man. Her note at the bottom: "Same play. Three different plays." Teams choose their coverages for a reason, of course, so some of that spread is about when we called it.

🔄 Check your understanding: Against Cover 3, why does Powers's corner route usually not get thrown, and which defender becomes the read?

Answer

In Cover 3 the corner on that side bails to the deep outside third, which is exactly where the corner route is going, so the route runs into a defender who is already deep and over it. The flat now belongs to the curl/flat defender (often the nickel or a rotated safety), and he becomes the read: if he widens or carries #2 vertically, throw the hitch; if he jumps the hitch, go to the seam or the dig.


16.6 Flood: Three Levels to One Side

Smash attacks the corner. Flood attacks the man just inside him and below him: the curl/flat defender. In Cover 3, that's the defender who owns the area from the curl (ten to twelve yards, inside the numbers) out to the flat (short, near the sideline). On a strong-side flood he's often a strong safety rotated down; on the weak side, a nickel or an outside linebacker. Whoever he is, he's the most overworked man in Cover 3, because his zone is shaped like a slice of pie and he's supposed to cover the whole slice.

Flood puts three receivers into his part of the field at three depths.

The routes

Level Who (typical) Route Depth and landmark Job
Deep #1 Clear (our 9, the go) Vertical in the fade lane, 4–6 yards from the sideline Take the corner deep. In Cover 3 he must carry #1, because he owns the deep third.
Middle #2 (or the Y) Sail Stem to about 12, break out and bend toward the numbers, ball arrives at 14–18 Land under the corner and over the curl/flat defender
Low #3, the back, or the TE Flat 2–4 yards deep, get to the sideline; width before depth Pull the curl/flat defender down or make him pay for staying up

The sail in our tree is a deep out that finishes at fifteen to eighteen yards. On flood, how deep it finishes depends on the corner: against a corner who bails hard, it can bend higher; against one who stays shallow, Cal Boateng teaches it to flatten at about fourteen so it stays underneath him. Many systems call the whole concept "sail" for that route. In our call sheet, "Flood" is the concept and the sail is its middle route.

The read

What the curl/flat defender does Throw
Widens and sinks under the sail (gains depth toward the numbers) Flat — he's above it, and nobody else is near
Jumps the flat (comes down early toward the shortest route) Sail — behind him, in front of the bailing corner
Sits in between at eight to ten yards Sail if the window is clear; otherwise flat. The flat is the safe ball.
Corner squats (refuses to carry #1) Clear — rare, but it's a touchdown when it happens

Most coaches teach the flood read high to low: clear (only if the corner squats), sail, flat. Vance's eyes start on the curl/flat defender and his feet are set to throw the sail. If the defender takes the sail away, the flat is right there and the ball comes out without a hitch.

Flood against Cover 3: the sail in Game 1

Week 6, the first Sacramento game, third quarter. Second-and-seven at our own 30. We broke the huddle with a Kill call — "Eleven, Gun Doubles Left, Inside, Kill, Flood Left" — which meant Vance would run the inside zone unless he saw a reason to switch. Harlan was attached on the left, with Gaines wide on the same side, and Ruffin set on Vance's left. Vance used his hard count. Tre Holloway, the Sentinels' strong safety, flinched: on the first sound, he started down from his two-high spot toward the line.

That was all Vance needed. A two-high safety who starts creeping down at a hard count is telling you the shell is going to rotate. He shouted "Kill, kill," and we ran flood left into a rotation to single- high. (Russ told me in the spring that they call that rotation "Spin 3." In-season, we called it "two-high rotating to three.")

PRE-SNAP: Eleven, Gun Doubles Left, Inside, Kill, Flood Left
          (Game 1, Q3, 2nd-and-7 at the AUS 30)

        $ Holloway                            F Royce
        ~11, creeping                         ~12

 C                  W      M      *                         C
 ~7                                                        ~7
                E    T    T    E
 Z           Y  O  O  O  O  O                 H            X
 Gaines Harlan        R  Q
                   Ruffin

📊 Diagram (described): The Outlaws in two-by-two with the tight end attached on the left. Gaines is wide left off the line and Harlan is attached to the left tackle. Powers is in the right slot and Sutton is wide right. Ruffin is on Vance's left. The Sentinels show two high safeties, but Holloway, on the left over the tight end, has started to creep down. Two linebackers, a nickel, four down linemen, and corners at about seven yards.

POST-SNAP vs. COVER 3 (rotation): Holloway jumps the flat, sail +19

  C [DEEP 1/3]                 F Royce [DEEP MIDDLE]
  carries Z    ^               (spun to the middle)
               | Z clear
               |
   Y sail  <___|___
   (+19)       |   \__
       ......  |      |  Y stems to ~12
             : |      |
   ( $ ) Holloway     |          W      M
   JUMPS the flat     |
      v               |
   <------ R flat     |
   Z                  Y   O  O  O  O  O          H          X
                          ==> slide right
                               R Q
                   (. . . = Vance's throw to the sail)

📊 Diagram (described): After the snap the safeties rotate. Royce spins to the deep middle and Holloway comes down into the left curl/flat area. The left corner carries Gaines's clear-out deep. Ruffin checks and releases to the left flat, and Holloway jumps him. Harlan stems to about twelve yards and bends toward the left sideline, landing behind Holloway and in front of the deep corner. Vance throws the sail. Harlan gains nineteen.

That's flood doing exactly what it promises. Holloway was a good player doing his job: rotate down, take the flat, keep it in front. But in Cover 3 the curl/flat defender is the only man who can play both the flat and the sail, and you can't play both at once.

🎬 Film room: On the end-zone copy, watch the curl/flat defender's first two steps. If he opens his hips to the sideline and gains depth, he's protecting the sail; the flat will be there. If his shoulders stay square and his feet chop toward the line, he's going to jump the flat; the sail will be there. You can see it before the receivers declare. That's what Vance sees.

Flood against Cover 2 and Quarters

Against Cover 2, flood behaves a lot like smash. The corner is the flat defender again, so the flat-and-sail pair puts him in the hi-lo, and the sail lands in the same sideline hole the corner route does. The clear-out by #1 runs into the half-field safety and mostly just keeps him honest. Flood is a fine Cover 2 call; it's just a less precise one than smash, because the sail's landing spot is a little closer to the safety.

Against Quarters, flood has a hard time. The corner and safety on that side are playing #1 and #2 with match rules, so the clear and the sail are each covered by a deep defender, and the flat is open but short. Sacramento taught us that lesson twice in Game 2, on third downs we expected to convert. Case Study 2 tells that story, because it's the clearest picture I have of a concept dying against the coverage built to stop it.

Boot flood: the same triangle on the move

Flood's best friend is play-action. Our boot off outside zone — the "Wide PA Boot" — has a flood built into it, so we never add the word "Flood." The quarterback fakes the outside-zone run one way and boots out the other. The backside tight end releases late into the flat. The playside tight end crosses the field at about twelve yards and keeps working toward the far sideline. The split end clears deep. Three levels, one side, and the quarterback is already outside the pocket on that side.

Week 10 at Portland, second quarter, tied 7–7, about 11:40 left in the half. First-and-ten at our own 42, two snaps before the smash touchdown. In Teo's four-game chart, Portland had played single-high on 14 of 19 first downs against 12 personnel, so we came out in it: "Twelve, Under Ace Right, Wide PA Boot Left."

PRE-SNAP: Twelve, Under Ace Right, Wide PA Boot Left
          (Week 10, Q2, 1st-and-10 at the AUS 42, tied 7-7)

                            F   (~13, middle)

 C              W          M        S           $             C
 ~7                                            (~8)           ~7
                   E    T    T    E
    X           U  O  O  O  O  O  Y                  Z
    Sutton   Brandt        Q    Harlan             Gaines
                           R

📊 Diagram (described): Twelve personnel, under center, one back. Cody Brandt is attached to the left tackle and Harlan to the right tackle. Sutton is wide left and Gaines wide right, both off the line. Ruffin is directly behind Vance. Portland is in its base defense with three linebackers and one deep safety in the middle, the strong safety at about eight yards on the right, and corners off at about seven.

POST-SNAP vs. COVER 3: outside-zone fake right, boot left, flood left

  C [DEEP 1/3]  ^ X clear      F [DEEP MIDDLE]
  carries X     |
                |   <______
                |          \___ Y crosses at ~12,
                |              \__ keeps working
                |                  \__ toward the sideline
       ( W ) curl/flat               \_____________ (+23)
        jumps the U                                \
          v                     M        S          \
    <--- U flat (late)                               Y
    Q boots <.......  O  O  O  O  O  ===> R (fake, wide right)
    left              (line steps right, outside zone)

📊 Diagram (described): The whole line and Ruffin flow right as if it's outside zone, and Vance fakes the handoff and boots out to the left. Sutton clears deep up the left sideline and takes the left corner with him. Brandt blocks for a count and slips into the left flat. Harlan runs across the field from right to left at about twelve yards. Portland's weak-side linebacker, Nate Odegaard, the curl/flat defender on that side, sees Brandt and comes down to the flat. Harlan's crossing route arrives behind him. Vance throws on the move for a twenty-three-yard gain.

Harlan caught it at the Portland 41 and got to the 35. Ruffin ran inside zone for four on the next snap, and then came second-and-six at the 31 and the smash in this chapter's opening. Notice the order: Marchetti played single-high on the first down and two-high on the second, and each concept went at the defender his coverage left exposed. The boot only works because the outside zone works, and Chapter 19 owns that relationship. For this chapter, notice that the read is the same man: the curl/flat defender. Flood is flood, whether Vance is standing in the pocket or running toward the sideline.

⚠️ Common mistake: the flat runner going upfield too early. A back or tight end who releases to the flat and immediately turns upfield at three yards ends up at six yards, inside the curl/flat defender's drop. Now one defender covers the flat and the sail with a single step. Fix: Lonnie Briggs and Cal Boateng teach it the same way — width before depth. Get to the sideline first. The flat route's job is to stretch the defender horizontally and vertically, and it can only do that from the sideline.

🔄 Check your understanding: In flood against Cover 3, the curl/flat defender opens his hips and sinks toward the sail. Where does the ball go, and why is the clear-out by #1 still necessary even though it's almost never thrown?

Answer

The ball goes to the flat, because the defender who owns it has taken himself away from it. The clear-out is necessary because without it, the Cover 3 corner wouldn't have to bail deep. He could sit at twelve to fifteen yards and take the sail himself, freeing the curl/flat defender to drive on the flat. The clear-out takes the corner out of the picture so that only one defender is left to handle two receivers.


16.7 Levels: Two In-Breakers Under a Vertical

Smash and flood work the outside of the field. Levels works the middle. It attacks the hook defender: the inside linebacker, or a nickel playing inside, who drops to ten or twelve yards in the middle and reads the quarterback.

The routes (from Trips Right)

Player Route Depth Job
#3 (Harlan) Seam (vertical clear) Vertical up the hash Carry a safety, or in Tampa 2 the middle linebacker, out of the dig window
#2 (Powers) The low in Five yards, flat across The low half of the hi-lo; settles in the first open window against zone
#1 (Gaines) Dig (our 6) Twelve yards, square in The high half; crosses behind the hook defender
Backside #1 (Sutton) Curl (our 4) Stem to 12, back to 10–11 The answer if the hooks all flow to the trips
Back (Ruffin) Check, then release Man side in 60 Left Checkdown

On levels, the concept sets Powers's depth: his in is at five yards, not at the ten our slots usually use for in-breakers. The concept owns the depths when it needs to. That's the job of a concept.

The read

Vance reads the hook defender inside Powers. In Cover 3 against trips, that's usually the Will, or the Mike if the defense has slid its linebackers.

What the hook defender does Throw
Jumps the low in (drives forward on Powers) Dig behind him
Sinks under the dig (gains depth, eyes on Gaines) Low in in front of him
Runs with the seam (Tampa 2 Mike) Dig — the window behind the hooks is now empty
Everyone flows to trips Backside curl to Sutton
PRE-SNAP: Eleven, Gun Trips Right, 60 Left, Levels (vs. single-high)

                              F   (~14, middle)

 C                    W       M        *         $              C
 ~7                                            (~8)            ~7
                 E    T    T    E
 X               O  O  O  O  O         Y      H              Z
                       Q  R

📊 Diagram (described): Trips right: Harlan detached as #3, Powers as #2, Gaines on the line wide right as #1. Sutton is alone on the left. The defense shows one deep safety in the middle and the strong safety rotated down on the trips side at about eight yards; a nickel over Powers; two linebackers; four down linemen; and corners off at about seven.

POST-SNAP vs. COVER 3: hi-lo on the hook defender

  C [DEEP 1/3]              F [DEEP MIDDLE]                C [DEEP 1/3]
                                     ^ Y seam: holds F
      X curl                         |
      10-11  ^                       |
             |      <----------------|------------------+ Z dig 12
             |                       |                  |
             |        ( W ) jumps?   |                  |
             |          -> dig       |                  |
             |        sinks?         |   $ curl/flat    |
             |          -> low in    |                  |
             |       <---------------|------+ H in 5    |
             X           O  O  O  O  O     Y      H           Z
                         <== slide left
                               Q   R --> check, flat

📊 Diagram (described): Harlan runs a seam up the right hash, holding the deep middle safety. Powers runs a flat in-route at five yards across the middle. Gaines runs a twelve-yard dig across the field above Powers. The Will linebacker, the hook defender, is between them: if he jumps Powers, the dig is open behind him; if he sinks under Gaines, the low in is open in front of him. Sutton runs a curl at ten to eleven yards on the left as the backside answer.

🔍 Why this works: Hook defenders are taught to "wall" or "collision" anything crossing their face at short depth, then get back to their landmark at ten or twelve yards. That's two jobs at two depths with one set of feet. Levels times the two routes so they arrive in his area about a half-second apart: the low in first, the dig right behind it. If he plays the first one, he can't recover to the second. If he skips the first to wait for the second, the first is a catch with room to run.

Levels against Quarters

Against Quarters, levels is harder but still works, and it's why the card on our call sheet says "levels vs. two-high, rhythm only." The trips-side safety reads #2. When Powers breaks in short, the safety knows #2 is no longer his problem and looks for #1, so he'll come down on Gaines's dig if he's free. Harlan's seam is what keeps him from being free: a vertical #3 is somebody's job in every Quarters trips check, often that same safety's. The hook defender is still the read, but the dig window closes faster. The ball comes out on the dig's break, or it goes to the low in.

Levels against Tampa 2: one failure and one touchdown

Here's the second half of the Portland game, the part that taught me the most.

Third quarter, after the second smash. Third-and-six at the Portland 23, Austin leading 14–10. Teo's chart said Marchetti's one regular pressure on third-and-medium came from the tight-end side, so I kept Harlan in to block and called "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 70, Levels Left": Sutton's dig at twelve, Powers's in at five, and nobody vertical inside them.

Marchetti called Tampa 2. In Tampa 2, the middle linebacker — Owen Talbert, number 52 — runs down the middle of the field at the snap to take away anything vertical between the safeties. But there was nothing vertical between the safeties. Harlan was blocking. So Talbert ran to about fourteen yards, found nobody to carry, stopped, and looked straight at the dig window. Will linebacker Nate Odegaard jumped Powers's low in, which by our rules meant "throw the dig," and Vance did. Talbert broke on it from above and knocked it down. We kicked a 41-yard field goal: 17–10.

That one was mine. Vance read it right. The receivers ran it right. I built a levels without the vertical, against a defense whose middle linebacker exists to play the vertical. Take away his vertical, and he's a free hook defender at fourteen yards sitting on top of your dig.

Fourth quarter, 12:05 left, Austin leading 17–13. Second-and-eight at the Portland 23. Same concept, but this time from Trips Right, with Harlan as #3 on the seam: "Eleven, Gun Trips Right, 60 Left, Levels." Pre-snap, the same two-high shell you saw in the Trips smash in 16.3.

POST-SNAP vs. TAMPA 2: seam carries Talbert; dig goes behind Odegaard

        F Price [DEEP 1/2]   ( M ) Talbert             $ [DEEP 1/2]
                               runs the middle
                               WITH the Y seam ^
                                               |
                     <-------------------------|---------+ Z dig 12
   TD! caught ~POR 11                          |         |  (23 yds)
                                               |         |
                         ( W ) Odegaard JUMPS  |         |
                              the low in       |         |
                               v               |         |
              *          <---------------------|--+ H in 5
   X                 O  O  O  O  O             Y     H        Z
                     <== slide left
                           Q   R --> check, flat

📊 Diagram (described): Portland plays Tampa 2. The two safeties take deep halves. Talbert, the middle linebacker, runs down the middle of the field with Harlan's seam. Odegaard, the Will linebacker, drives forward on Powers's five-yard in. That leaves the window behind Odegaard and in front of the safeties empty, and Gaines's twelve-yard dig crosses into it. Vance throws the dig; Gaines catches it around the Portland 11, turns upfield, and scores.

Talbert did his job: he ran with Harlan. Odegaard did his: he jumped the shallow route crossing his face. And Gaines walked into the end zone from twenty-three yards out. 24–13. The concept was the same as the third-quarter failure. The difference was one route: the vertical that gave Talbert somewhere else to be.

💡 Coach's point: "Two in-breakers under a vertical" isn't a description of levels. It's the definition. If you take the vertical out, you're not running a lighter version of levels. You're running a different, worse play.

Drive: levels' crossing cousin

Drive puts the same two depths on the hook defender, but from opposite sides of the formation. One receiver runs a shallow cross (two to five yards, all the way across), and a receiver from the other side runs a dig at twelve right behind where the shallow came from. Against zone, it's a hi-lo on the hook defender, read just like levels. Against man, the crossing routes run away from the defenders chasing them, which makes Drive more of a man-beater than levels is. That's why the shallow cross gets its full treatment in Chapter 17.

POST-SNAP: Drive from Doubles Right vs. Cover 3
           (pre-snap: the single-high picture in 16.5)

  C [DEEP 1/3]          F [DEEP MIDDLE]               C [DEEP 1/3]
   ^ X clear                     ^ Y seam
   |                             |
   |   Z dig 12 <----------------|-----------------------+
   |                             |                       |
   |              ( M ) hook: jumps the shallow? -> dig  |
   |                    sinks under the dig? -> shallow  |
   |                             |                       |
   |      +-------------------------------> H shallow ~4 |
   |      |                      |                       |
   X      H          O  O  O  O  O  Y                    Z
                           Q   R

📊 Diagram (described): Powers, from the left slot, runs a shallow crossing route at about four yards all the way across the formation to the right. Gaines, from the right, runs a twelve-yard dig back toward the left, crossing above where the shallow is going. The Mike linebacker in the middle has the shallow under him and the dig over him and must choose: if he jumps the shallow, the dig is open behind him; if he sinks under the dig, the shallow is open in front of him. Sutton clears deep up the left side and Harlan runs the seam.

🔄 Check your understanding: Why did levels fail on third-and-six in the third quarter at Portland and score on second-and-eight in the fourth, when Vance threw the dig both times?

Answer

Against Tampa 2, the middle linebacker runs the deep middle to carry anything vertical. On the third down, Harlan stayed in to block, so nobody ran vertical inside the in-breakers, and Talbert stopped at about fourteen yards with nothing to cover except the dig window. He broke up the dig from above. On the touchdown, Harlan ran the seam from #3, Talbert had to carry him, and the dig window behind the Will was empty. The read was the same; the structure had changed. Levels needs its vertical.


16.8 How the Three Fit Together

Now step back from the routes. You have three concepts, and each stresses a different zone defender:

  • Smash — the flat defender (the Cover 2 corner).
  • Flood — the curl/flat defender (the Cover 3 outside underneath player).
  • Levels — the hook defender (the middle underneath player).

Here's why that matters more than any single concept. A defense can stop one of them by moving a defender, but every move opens something else. That's what I mean when I say a play call is the next play's reason to work.

If the defense does this… …to stop this It opens this
Tells the corner to sink when #2 goes vertical Smash's corner route Smash's hitch; flood's flat; China
Tells the corner to squat on everything short The hitch and quick game Smash's corner route; flood's sail; stop-go
Widens the hook defenders to help the curl/flat Flood's sail Levels and Drive — the middle is thin
Tells the hook defenders to sink under the digs Levels' dig Levels' low in; the shallow; the stick
Widens the half-field safety early Smash's corner route The seam (divide) and the post behind him
Rotates two-high to single-high Smash (the corner bails) Flood, and smash's hitch
Plays Quarters Smash and flood (deep defenders on #1 and #2) Levels on rhythm, the flat, and the routes that make #2 lie (Chapter 18)

That table is the reason these three concepts sit next to each other on our call sheet, often from the same formation. If the corner beats the smash, he's told you something, and flood or China can use it. If the hook defenders take the flood away by widening, levels goes into the space they left. The coordinator across the field is making his moves too, and the conversation goes back and forth all day.

Portland was that conversation in one afternoon:

When Austin's call Portland's answer Result
Q2, 1st-and-10, AUS 42 (7–7) Boot flood vs. single-high Curl/flat (Odegaard) jumped the flat Harlan +23 to the POR 35
Q2, 2nd-and-6, POR 31 (7–7) Smash (Doubles) Cover 2, Kiel squats Powers 31-yard TD, 14–7
Q3, 1st-and-10, AUS 46 (14–10) Smash again Cover 2 with the sink adjustment Sutton hitch +8
Q3, 3rd-and-6, POR 23 (14–10) Levels, no vertical Tampa 2; Talbert free Incomplete; FG, 17–10
Q4, 2nd-and-8, POR 23 (17–13) Levels from Trips with the seam Tampa 2; Talbert carries Harlan Gaines 23-yard TD, 24–13

We won 27–13. Case Study 1 walks the second half of that game snap by snap from my sheet and Marchetti's adjustments.

📋 Try it — Make the call: Hypothetical: second-and-seven at your opponent's 38, second quarter, tied 10–10. You're in 11 personnel. Your quality-control coach's chart says this defense has played Cover 3 on 64% of second-and-medium snaps (31 of 48), usually with the strong safety rotating down to the tight-end side late. Its other main look is Cover 2 (22%). Its weak-side corner squats hard in Cover 2. Choose one of smash, flood, or levels, and a formation, and explain what you'll do if the defense plays the other coverage.

Answer

A strong answer: flood to the tight-end side — for example, "Eleven, Gun Trey Right, 60 Left, Flood Right," with Gaines on the clear, Powers on the sail, and Harlan releasing to the flat. Against the Cover 3 that shows up nearly two-thirds of the time, the rotated-down strong safety is the curl/flat defender on that side, and he's in the hi-lo between Powers and Harlan. Against Cover 2, the corner is the flat defender instead, the flat and sail put him in the hi-lo, and the sail lands in the Cover 2 sideline hole. So the call has a good answer against both. Smash is defensible if you put it on the weak-side corner who squats, but against the Cover 3 that shows most often, it becomes a hitch read. Levels is also sound against Cover 3, but it attacks the hook defender, who isn't the player the chart says is moving late. The reasoning is graded, not the choice: name the defender in conflict and say what happens against both coverages.

📋 Try it — Find the conflict: A defense lines up two-high and plays Cover 6: Quarters to the field (the wide side), Cover 2 to the boundary (the short side). The boundary corner sits at five yards in the flat; the boundary safety plays a deep half. You have the ball on the left hash, so the boundary is to your left. Name the defender in conflict and draw the concept that attacks him.

Answer

The boundary corner is the Cover 2 flat defender on the half side, so smash to the boundary puts him in the hi-lo. Our call: "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 60 Left, Smash" with the strength to the field, which sends the smash left into the boundary by our default.

```text ANSWER: Smash to the Cover 2 side of Cover 6 (boundary on the left)

<__ H corner F [DEEP 1/2] | $ [DEEP 1/4] C [1/4] _ (half side) | (reads #2) | | | | Quarters side: ( C ) squats? -> corner W M | the backside ^ sinks? -> hitch | Z dig / Y seam | hitch 6 | are the answers X H O O O O O Y Z (boundary) Q R (field) ```

📊 Diagram (described): The ball is on the left hash, so the short side of the field is on the left. The defense plays Cover 2 on the left (a corner in the flat, a safety playing a deep half) and Quarters on the right. Smash goes left: Sutton's six-yard hitch and Powers's corner route put the left corner in the hi-lo, and the deep-half safety must cover the whole left side of the deep field. On the right, the Quarters side, the backside routes are the safer secondary answers.

The boundary sideline hole is shorter than a field hole, so the corner throw is quicker and more accurate, but the target area is tighter. Against Cover 6, don't run smash into the Quarters side: the safety there reads #2 and will be on the corner route.

📋 Try it — Whose fault?: Thursday before Portland, the "Kiel" period. The scout-team corner is told to squat on every hitch. The call is "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 60 Left, Smash." Sutton runs his hitch at six. Powers stems to nine yards, breaks for the pylon, and drifts flat toward the sideline. Vance sees the corner squat and throws the corner route. The scout-team safety, who started on the hash, closes and intercepts at the 14-yard depth near the numbers. Who's at fault, what's the rule, and what's the fix?

Answer

Powers. The rule is "stem to twelve, break to the pylon," and he broke at nine and flattened. A corner route that breaks at nine and flattens finishes lower and closer to the safety's path, and it arrives sooner, before the safety has been held by anything. The squatting corner was beaten; the safety wasn't. Vance's read was right — the corner squatted — and Sutton did his job. Fix: Cal Boateng puts a cone at twelve yards for the break and a second cone at eighteen near the pylon line; the route must pass the first and aim at the second. "The break tells the truth," Cal says, and nine is a lie.

🏫 Any level: In the NFL the hash marks are close to the middle of the field, so the "field" side and the "boundary" side aren't very different. In college, and even more in high school, they are. A high school ball on the left hash leaves only about eighteen yards between the hash and the left sideline and about thirty-five to the right. Three adjustments follow. First, the corner throw: a high school corner route to the wide side, thrown from the far hash, can travel thirty-five yards or more in the air, which many young quarterbacks can't make on time. Run smash into the boundary, where the throw is short. Second, flood: the field side has room for all three levels; the boundary side often doesn't, so the flat and the sail end up on top of each other. Run flood to the field. Third, the read: many high school defenses play "Cover 3 sky" or match coverages taught simply, so the curl/flat defender is often a safety rotating down late. Flood is often the best of these three concepts at that level. And keep the hitch at six yards; I learned that one the hard way.

🔄 Check your understanding: A defense has stopped your flood by telling its hook defenders to widen early and help on the sail. What concept goes into the space they just left, and which defender does it attack?

Answer

Levels (or Drive). When the hook defenders widen toward the curl/flat area, the middle of the field between ten and twelve yards empties. Levels puts a five-yard in and a twelve-yard dig into that space and attacks whichever hook defender is still inside, and he now has even more grass to cover because his partner left.


Spaced Review

Before you read each answer below, answer it yourself.

From Chapter 7: the shell is not the coverage. Week 6's flood began with Holloway in a two-high shell. Why did the flood work against what started as a two-high look? Because Holloway rotated down into the curl/flat after the snap. MOFO pre-snap became MOFC post-snap, so the right concept was a Cover 3 beater, not a Cover 2 beater. Vance's hard count made Holloway show the rotation early, and the Kill call let him pick the concept that fit the coverage that was coming.

From Chapter 8: side concepts have a home. In "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 60 Left, Smash," why does the smash go left, and what would "Smash, X Fade" do to it? With no motion and no direction word, a side concept goes to the two-receiver side away from the attached Y. In Doubles Right that's the left, so Sutton is #1 and runs the hitch. "X Fade" would take away the hitch, which is the low half of the hi-lo. Tags can't eat the concept.

From Chapter 3: receiver numbering. In Bunch Right, with Powers on the line at the point, Gaines behind and outside him, and Harlan behind and inside him, who is #1, #2, and #3? Numbering goes outside-in: Gaines #1, Powers #2, Harlan #3. That's why Powers runs the corner and Gaines the hitch in bunch smash, even though Powers is the man on the line.

From Chapter 15: the quarterback reads a defender. Name the read key for each concept in this chapter against its best coverage. Smash vs. Cover 2: the corner. Flood vs. Cover 3: the curl/flat defender. Levels vs. Cover 3: the hook defender. If you named a receiver, go back and say it again with a defender.


Project Checkpoint: Core Coverage-Beater Set

Last chapter you built your Concept Framework: how your concepts are named, taught, and read. Now you put three concepts into it — the three that, together, attack every underneath zone defender.

This chapter's deliverable: a Core Coverage-Beater Set. One page per concept (smash, flood, levels), each with the same five parts:

  1. The concept in one sentence, naming the defender it attacks ("Smash: make the flat defender choose between the hitch and the corner").
  2. The call in your grammar, from your base formation, plus at least two more formations you'll run it from (Doubles, Trips, Trey, Bunch, Empty — pick what fits your personnel).
  3. Assignments by position — every eligible receiver's route with depth and landmark, the protection, and the back.
  4. The read vs. Cover 2, Cover 3, and Cover 4 — the read key, and the throw order for each. Add Cover 1 and Cover 0 if your level sees them.
  5. One variation and the defensive adjustment it answers.

A filled-in piece, from our set:

Coverage Read key Throw order (Levels from Trips)
Cover 2 / Tampa 2 Hook defender inside #2 Will jumps → dig. Will sinks → low in. Tampa Mike carries the seam → dig.
Cover 3 Hook defender inside #2 Jumps → dig. Sinks → low in. Hooks flow to trips → backside curl.
Cover 4 Hook defender, then the trips safety Dig only on rhythm; the low in if the safety comes down.

Variation: "Levels from Doubles with the Y seam backside" — answers a defense that rolls its coverage to the trips side. Rule: never run levels without a vertical inside the in-breakers.

Levels for your project: - High school: two concepts done well beat three done halfway. Install flood and smash first; add levels when your quarterback can read a linebacker. Draw the hash marks of your field on every page. - College: all three, with the five-formation smash table; mark which side of the hash each one goes. - Pro: all three plus variations (China, smash-seam, Drive) and a "what it opens" row on each page. - Film-room: pick a team you watch and chart its smash, flood, and levels calls for three games: coverage faced, the read key's reaction, and the result.

Next chapter, these zone-beaters meet their limit: man coverage. You'll build a Man-Beater Package — mesh, shallow cross, and a legal rub tag — for the snaps when nobody is reading the quarterback at all.


Chapter Summary

The three core hi-lo concepts, at a glance:

Smash Flood Levels
Victim Flat defender Curl/flat defender Hook defender
Core routes #1 hitch 6; #2 corner (12 → ~18) Clear (go); sail (12 → 14–18); flat (2–4) Vertical; low in (5); dig (12)
Best vs. Cover 2, Tampa 2, Cover 6 half side Cover 3, rotations, boot vs. any zone Cover 3, Tampa 2 (with the vertical), Quarters on rhythm
Weaker vs. Cover 3, Quarters Quarters, man Man, middle-robber looks
The read Squat → corner. Sink → hitch. Jumps flat → sail. Sinks → flat. Jumps low → dig. Sinks → low in.
What makes it fail Hitch too deep; corner route breaks early; QB reads receivers Flat runner goes upfield early; no clear-out; flat short of the sticks on third down No vertical (Tampa Mike sits on the dig); routes arrive together instead of in sequence
Key variation Divide, smash-seam, China, stop-go Boot flood, flood from Trips Drive (crossing hi-lo)

The decision framework, in four questions:

  1. Who is the flat defender after the snap? If it's the corner (Cover 2), smash. If it's a curl/flat linebacker or safety (Cover 3), flood.
  2. Is the middle of the field thin? If the hook defenders are widening or running with verticals, levels.
  3. What did the defense do to my last concept? Every answer opens something; look it up in 16.8's table.
  4. Does my call have a sensible ending against the coverage I'm not expecting? If not, change the formation or the concept until it does.

The corner must choose, and both choices lose. So must the curl/flat defender, and so must the hook defender. That's the whole chapter.


What's Next

Every concept in this chapter assumes the defender in conflict is reading the quarterback. Against man coverage, nobody is. In Chapter 17, the Birmingham Forge blitz on nearly every passing down and play press-man behind it, and we answer with mesh, the shallow cross, and the legal rubs that create separation through traffic.