Chapter 12 Exercises — The Option Game
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and film study
Selected answers are in Appendix J. Part C items have short worked answers here. The Outlaws, Sentinels, Pioneers, Stallions, and Forge are this book's fictional teams. Situations marked hypothetical didn't happen in their season and are there for practice.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. In one sentence each, define read key, conflict defender, and plus-one as they apply to the option game.
A2. On a normal shotgun handoff, why does the defense usually have one more run defender than the offense has blockers? Name the two offensive players who aren't blocking.
A3. State the zone-read rule Rome Pettaway gives Darius Vance in one sentence. Then explain why it's phrased in terms of the back and not in terms of the end's direction.
A4. List the Outlaws' five mesh rules. Which one exists mainly to protect the quarterback, and which one exists mainly to keep the read end honest?
A5. Define the scrape exchange. In the Sentinels' terms, what are Swap and Sit, and who owns the quarterback on each?
A6. What is the pitch relationship on the speed option, and why does its consistency matter more than its exact distance?
A7. Power read (inverted veer) reads a different end than the zone read and gives the back and the quarterback different paths. Describe both differences.
A8. Name the counter that beats each of these defensive answers: (a) Swap, (b) Sit, (c) the mesh charge, (d) a nickel assigned to the quarterback on a triple option.
A9. Why does the ineligible-downfield rule matter for an RPO but not for a bubble thrown behind the line of scrimmage?
A10. What is the Outlaws' quarterback-carry budget, what counts against it, and what doesn't?
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
B1. Describe the call. Pre-snap: 11 personnel, 2x2, tight end attached right, back offset left. Two-high shell, six in the box, nickel apex over the left slot. Post-snap: the left tackle steps inside and climbs; nobody touches the left end; the end crashes flat at the back; the quarterback pulls the ball; the Will linebacker's first two steps are lateral and outside. Name the offensive play, the defensive answer, and the likely result.
B2. Same pre-snap. Post-snap: the left end shuffles inside a step with his shoulders square and his eyes on the quarterback; the Will's first step is downhill toward the B gap. The quarterback hands off. Name the defensive call, who made the tackle, and whether the quarterback's read was correct.
B3. Look at this post-snap picture and identify (a) the play, (b) the read key, (c) the decision, and (d) who blocks the alley.
$
]
Y arcs
(E) steps up to take the QB
O O O O O \
--> --> --> --> --> \
Q -------> ......> pitch
R ----------->----------->
📊 Diagram (described): The line reaches to the right. The tight end releases outside and blocks the safety in the alley. The quarterback runs flat toward the right edge with the back outside and behind him. The unblocked end steps up toward the quarterback, and a dotted line shows the ball being pitched to the back.
B4. Describe the call. Pre-snap: back on the quarterback's right. At the snap the right guard pulls left, the left tackle, left guard, and center block down to the right, and the back runs flat toward the left sideline. The left end is unblocked. Name the play and say what the end must do for the quarterback to keep.
B5. On end-zone film of a zone read, the backside end is unblocked and the quarterback keeps for eight yards. A tight end aligned as a wing on the read side released outside the end and blocked a linebacker who was flowing outside. What tag was called, and what defensive call was it built to beat?
B6. On All-22 film, a defense faces the same zone-read look on three straight series. The end crashes on series one, sits on series two, and crashes on series three. The linebacker behind him scrapes on series one and three and fills on series two. What is the defense doing, and what does it tell you about how to call your next zone read?
B7. A shotgun team runs a zone read and, at the mesh, the backside end attacks flat and fast at the point where the quarterback and back are exchanging the ball. What is this called, and what is the quarterback's rule?
B8. Identify the play from this description and name the two defenders it reads: two backs behind the quarterback; at the snap one back hits the B gap while the quarterback rides him and watches the first defensive lineman outside that gap; the quarterback pulls the ball and runs at the next defender outside, with the second back four yards outside and a yard behind him; the tight end releases outside and blocks the safety.
B9. Whose fault? On a zone read, the end crashes, the quarterback pulls, and the ball comes loose at the mesh. On film, the back's arms are clamped over the ball before the quarterback's hands have left it. Who fumbled, which mesh rule was broken, and what drill fixes it?
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
C1. (Draw it up) Draw "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside Read Bubble" against Nickel Over with two high safeties, pre-snap and post-snap. Label dive, quarterback, and perimeter, and show which defender the offense expects to be in conflict on each.
Short answer
Pre-snap: X and H on the left, Y attached right with Z outside, back offset left. Defense: E-T-N-E, Will and Mike, nickel apex over H, two safeties. Post-snap: the line zones right, the LT steps inside (the left end is the first read), H bubbles left with X blocking the corner, and the nickel is the second read. Dive = the back on the inside-zone track. QB = the keep through the end's spot. Perimeter = the bubble. First conflict defender: the left end (dive or QB). Second: the nickel (QB or bubble). See 12.2 for the drawn version from the Game 1 touchdown.
C2. (Make the call) Hypothetical. Week 10 at Portland, second quarter, 1st-and-10 at your own 42, Austin up 14–7. Portland's Tampa 2 has scrape-exchanged three of your four zone reads, and on the fourth the end slow-played. The Mike runs to the deep middle on most early downs, so there are six in the box. You want a run. Choose among plain Inside Read, "Inside Read Right, Arc" from Wing Left, and Inside Read Bubble, and justify the choice.
Short answer
Arc is the best bet: three of four looks were the scrape exchange, and Arc puts Harlan on the scraping Will. The risk is the slow-play (one of four), where Harlan blocks air. With six in the box and the Mike bailing deep, even the give on Arc is a fair inside-zone run. Inside Read Bubble is a fine hedge if you believe the nickel is the help on the quarterback, but Portland's tape says the Will has him. Plain Inside Read keeps running into the defense's answer.
C3. (Make the call) Hypothetical. Your college team runs speed option to the field from the left hash. The opponent's field end has tackled your quarterback on every pitch in the first half, legally, and your quarterback has a sore shoulder. It's 2nd-and-6 at the opponent's 40 in the third quarter, up 10. What do you change, and why?
Short answer
Stop asking your quarterback to take the hit. Options: switch his pitch rule to "pitch on the first sign" (accept less yardage per carry); run the same look with the quarterback faking speed option and handing off to a back on the opposite path; or arc a tight end or wing to the end himself and read the next man out. The worst choice is the same call with the same rule. The opponent has told you its plan, and your quarterback is paying for it.
C4. (Draw it up) Draw "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Power Read Left" pre-snap and post-snap against an eight-man box with a strong safety walked down on the left. Show the puller, the down blocks, the back's path, and the read.
Short answer
The right guard pulls left and leads inside. The LT, LG, and C block down to the right. The RT and Y hinge. The back, starting on the quarterback's right, runs a flat sweep path to the left. The left end is unblocked and read. If he widens with the sweep, the quarterback keeps inside behind the puller. If he squeezes, the back gets the ball outside him. The walked-down safety is the next problem outside. On a give he's the force, and a well-designed version has Z or X crack him (see 12.7).
C5. (Make the call) Game 2, Week 15, at Sacramento. You've just seen Swap on 2nd-and-4 at the SAC 38 (Vance kept for 1). Hypothetical continuation: it's 3rd-and-3 at the SAC 37. Do you call another option on third-and-3? If yes, which one and why? If no, what kind of call, and why?
Short answer
A strong answer is no option on this down. The Sentinels just showed the exchange and mix their looks by series. On third-and-3 you want a call whose success doesn't depend on guessing the next look: a quick-game concept with a high completion rate, or a gap-scheme run with an extra blocker. A defensible yes is Inside Read Bubble, because the bubble punishes a nickel who helps on the quarterback, but you'd be betting on a look you just saw them use, and Russ rarely shows it twice in a row.
C6. (Make the call) Hypothetical. High school, Friday night. Your quarterback is your best player and also starts at safety. Fourth quarter, 3rd-and-4 at midfield, tied 14–14. He has kept the zone read four times already. Your back has 60 yards on 15 carries. What's your call, and what's the budget question you have to answer first?
Short answer
The budget question: how many more hits can he take and still play safety on the next series? Four keeps on offense plus a full defensive load is already a lot. A reasonable call is a zone read with a give-first rule (the quarterback keeps only if the end crashes hard and flat), or a gap run with a lead blocker that doesn't use him at all. If he keeps here, it should be because the read forced it, not because you called a keep.
C7. (Draw it up) Draw "Inside Read Bash" against a defense that slow-plays the read end (Sit), pre-snap and post-snap. Show where the back starts, his path, the quarterback's path, the end, and the linebacker who expects to fill on the dive. Then draw the same play against a scrape exchange and explain in one sentence why it's a bad call there.
Short answer
Pre-snap: the back starts beside the quarterback on the side away from the read end. Post-snap: the line zones away from the read side; the back runs flat across toward the read side and outside; the quarterback rides him and reads the end. Against Sit, the end stays square to take the quarterback, so the quarterback gives and the back is outside him with the filling linebacker inside, on the wrong side. Against a scrape exchange, the end crashes into the quarterback's inside path and the scraper runs to the back's side, so the quarterback keeps into a crashing end. It's the worst matchup in the chapter and a hit on your quarterback.
C8. (Make the call) Hypothetical. Two-point conversion, NFL, ball at the 2. The defense has shown goal-line Cover 0 on its last three two-point and goal-line snaps against you: every defender matched on a receiver, nobody spying the quarterback. Your quarterback is healthy and has two designed carries left in your budget. What option call fits, and what's the risk?
Short answer
Speed option toward the side with more grass. In Cover 0, every defender is turned to a receiver, so the quarterback and the pitch back are ball carriers nobody owns. The pitch key, usually the end, has to take one of them alone. The risk is the hit: the pitch key is taught to hit the quarterback whether he pitches or not. At the 2 with the game on the line, most coordinators accept that, and it's why the Outlaws keep speed option only on their red-zone and two-point panel.
Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. Lyle had Arc on his Week 15 call sheet after seeing Swap and didn't call it. Argue for and against that decision. Then say what information, from the booth or from the scouting page, would have made Arc the right call.
D2. "Make him tackle you" versus "pitch it early." Write a one-paragraph policy for each of these quarterbacks: (a) a 6-foot-4, 240-pound NFL starter with average speed; (b) a 5-foot-10, 170-pound high school junior who is also your punt returner; (c) a college quarterback with a backup who can't run.
D3. Marisol's chart shows the zone read's keep success rate (about 52%) only slightly higher than the give success rate (about 46%), on 27 keeps. A staff member says, "The keep isn't worth the hits; cut the zone read." Respond using the idea that the threat has value even when it isn't called. What would you chart to prove or disprove that value?
D4. The option gains numbers by leaving the best defender unblocked. When is that a bad idea? Give two situations where you'd rather block the read end than read him.
D5. Your head coach asks for a budget: "How many designed quarterback runs a game, and who decides when to break it?" Write the rule in three sentences, including the playoff exception and the injury exception.
D6. Russ Kimbrough alternated Swap and Sit by series, and Teo's page caught the pattern. Should an offense ever bet on a pattern the opponent knows it is charting? Describe one situation where you would (what would have to be true about the score, the down, and the cost of being wrong) and one where you wouldn't.
D7. A college head coach wants to add power read because "it was unstoppable on the film we watched." Your quarterback is 6-foot-1 and 195 pounds, fast, with a history of shoulder trouble. Write the memo you'd send back: what you'd install instead, why, and what would have to change for you to add power read later.
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (Chapters 12 + 9) Inside zone's back reads "bang, bounce, bend." On the zone read, the back's track and read are the same, but one blocker is missing. Explain which of the back's three options is most affected by the unblocked end, and why a crashing end makes the quarterback's keep and the back's cutback compete for the same space.
M2. (Chapters 12 + 7) Using Chapter 7's box words (light, neutral, loaded), say when you would prefer (a) plain inside zone, (b) the zone read, and (c) a run-pass option. Include what the shell (MOFO or MOFC) tells you about where the defense's extra run defender is coming from.
M3. (Chapters 12 + 5) Count the gaps for "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right" with the tight end attached. Then count them again with the quarterback as a runner. Which defender owns the extra gap in the Sentinels' Swap, and which in Sit?
M4. (Chapters 12 + 11) Power read is a gap scheme with a read. Compare it to the Power Left you built in Chapter 11's Gap Scheme Sheet: who kicks out the end on Power Left, and what replaces that kick-out block on Power Read? What does the offense gain and lose by making that substitution?
M5. (Chapters 12 + 4 + 1) Chapter 4 showed that 12 personnel draws big nickel from the Sentinels. Chapter 1 listed the non-negotiable "every featured run has a play-action from the same picture." Design a three-play sequence from 12 personnel that includes one option, one gap or zone run, and one play-action pass, all from the same formation. Explain what each play teaches the defense and what the next play does with that lesson.
M6. (Chapters 12 + 8) Using Chapter 8's call grammar (Personnel → Formation → Motion/Shift → Protection → Play/Concept → Tags), write the full call for: (a) the zone read with a bubble from doubles; (b) the zone read with Arc from a wing; (c) power read to the left. Which word in each call is the tag, and which is the play?
M7. (Chapters 12 + 6) Chapter 6 gave every Outlaws back the same mesh rules and gave Ruffin an inside-zone aiming point and read. On the zone read, the back doesn't know whether he'll get the ball. Explain why "same track, same speed" is the most important of his rules on this play, and describe what the read end learns if the back slows at the mesh on gives but not on keeps.
M8. (Chapters 12 + 2) Chapter 2 traced the single wing's direct-snap runner to the shotgun zone read. Using this chapter's arithmetic, explain what the single-wing tailback and the zone-read quarterback have in common, and what the zone read adds that the single wing didn't have.
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. Chart a defense's option answers. Choose one college or NFL game featuring a team that runs the zone read at least eight times. For each zone read, record: the read end's action (crash, sit, charge, widen), the quarterback's decision, the first step of the linebacker behind the end (scrape or fill), any safety or nickel involvement, and the result. At the end, answer: Did the defense have two looks? Did it mix them by series, by down, or randomly? Did the offense ever counter (arc, bash, slice, a third option)? What would you call next if you were the offensive coordinator? Use All-22 or end-zone film if available. Broadcast angles often cut off the backside end.
E2. Service-academy pitch phase. Watch a Navy, Army, or Air Force game (any recent season) and chart 10 option plays that reach the pitch phase. For each, record the pitch key, whether the quarterback pitched or kept, how far the pitch traveled, and whether the quarterback was hit after the pitch. Write a half-page on what the pitch relationship looks like when it's coached at its purest and what it would cost to ask an NFL quarterback to do it twenty times a game.
E3. The 2012 read-option moment, then and now. Using public play-by-play data (for example, the nflverse community's play-by-play), or broadcast film if you can't work with data, compare designed quarterback runs for two NFL teams of your choice: one from the 2012 season and one from a recent season. Describe how often each called designed quarterback runs, what kind (zone read keep, power read, draw, sneak), and in what situations. Be careful: public data often can't tell a designed run from a scramble without film, so say how you classified each play and how confident you are.