Case Study 2 — Teo's Thirty-Eight Plays: An Install That Failed at a High School in El Paso
This case study is fictional. Teo Arriaga's high-school year, his head coach, and his players are composites; the school is not named.
Setup
Before he came to Austin as a quality-control coach, before his graduate-assistant years, Teo Arriaga spent one season as an assistant coach at a public high school in El Paso. He was twenty-two, a year removed from playing quarterback at a Division II school in New Mexico, and he was hired to coach the quarterbacks and receivers and to "help with the passing game." The head coach, Rudy Saenz, had run the same two-back, wing offense for eleven years and wanted to throw more. He handed Teo the passing game and one instruction: "Make it something the kids can run."
Teo brought his college offense with him. It was a good offense. He had played in it for four years and could draw every play from memory.
The resources were the resources of a high school:
| Item | Teo's situation |
|---|---|
| Practice time | About two hours a day after school, Monday through Thursday; a Saturday film and lifting session |
| Rules | Texas high-school football is played under rules adapted from the college code (check the current state association rules), with state limits on full-contact practice time and a heat-acclimatization period at the start of August |
| Players | 41 on varsity; 14 played both ways, including four starting linemen |
| Staff | Six coaches, two of them part-time |
| Scout team | Whoever wasn't playing offense on that rep — mostly sophomores |
| Quarterback | Adrian Molina, a senior: strong arm, quick feet, had never been asked to read a safety |
What happens
August: the install
Teo installed the way he had been installed in college: fast. In the first eight practices of August, he put in thirty-eight plays from six formations, each flipped both ways, with full-field progressions and two protections. He drew every play on a whiteboard in the team room in front of all the offensive players at once, handed out a forty-page playbook, and asked the players to learn it over the weekend.
He did not review. Every practice was a new install, because there was so much left to put in.
The scout defense was a group of sophomores holding up nothing. Teo didn't have time to draw cards, so he told the scout players in the huddle what to do: "Cover 3, and the linebacker blitzes sometimes." The scout linebacker blitzed when he felt like it.
Coach Saenz watched the first scrimmage from the end zone and said only one thing: "That's a lot of plays."
The opener
They lost the opener 27–6. The box score didn't show what the film did. Teo charted it on Sunday in the coaches' office:
| What went wrong | How often |
|---|---|
| Busted route (wrong depth, wrong route, or wrong side) | 9 times on 31 passes |
| Delay of game or a timeout to avoid one | 4 |
| Protection bust (two blockers on one rusher, one rusher free) | 5 |
| Molina's read went to a receiver who wasn't in that play's progression | 3 |
| Interceptions | 2 — both on a read he had never seen against a live defense |
Of the thirty-eight plays, they had called nineteen. Eleven had been repped at full speed against a scout defense fewer than three times. The offense scored its only touchdown on the wing power play Coach Saenz had run for eleven years.
Monday
On Monday afternoon Coach Saenz put Teo's forty-page playbook on the desk between them and handed him a red pen.
Saenz: Circle twelve.
Teo: Twelve plays?
Saenz: Twelve plays the kids can run on Friday against anything. You'll get more later. You don't get more now.
Teo: Coach, twelve plays — they'll know what we're doing.
Saenz: They already know what we're doing. We're the team that doesn't know what we're doing.
Teo circled twelve. It took him two hours, because he had to throw away plays he loved. He kept three formations, each run both ways: Coach Saenz's wing set, a two-by-two set, and a three-by-one set. He kept five runs (four of them Saenz's), three quick passes, two dropback concepts, one play-action pass off the wing power, and one screen.
"THE TWELVE" (Teo's El Paso card, Week 2) -- 3 formations, both ways
FORMATION RUNS PASSES
--------- --------------------- ----------------------------
Wing Power, Counter, Toss Power Pass (TE leak)
2x2 Inside Zone, Draw Hitches, Slants, Smash
3x1 Inside Zone Stick, Bubble (screen),
Flood
EVERY PLAY: one protection rule, one read, one picture to throw it vs.
📊 Diagram (described): A one-page play card with three formations listed down the left side — the wing set, a two-by-two set, and a three-by-one set — each run in both directions. Across from each formation are its runs and passes: power, counter, and toss with a tight-end leak pass from the wing; inside zone, draw, hitches, slants, and smash from the two-by-two; and inside zone, stick, a bubble screen, and flood from the three-by-one. That is twelve distinct plays in all. A note across the bottom says each play has one protection rule, one read, and one picture to throw it against.
Rebuilding the week
Teo rebuilt the week next. He counted from the off day, the way he'd later see the Outlaws do it:
| Day | Install and practice | Contact |
|---|---|---|
| Saturday | Film of Friday's game; correction with the players; lift | None |
| Monday | Base downs: the twelve against the opponent's base front and coverage | Light (bodies sore) |
| Tuesday | Third down and pressure; the opponent's two favorite blitzes | The heaviest contact the state limits allowed, spent mostly in the blitz-pickup period |
| Wednesday | Red zone, two-minute, and the "one new thing" of the week | Thud |
| Thursday | Walkthrough in shorts; Molina says every play's read aloud | Walk |
Every day began with a ten-minute review of the two previous days. Every new play — one a week at most — got a meeting, a walkthrough, and at least four full-speed reps before it could be called.
And Teo started drawing scout cards. He drew them at night on index cards, with the opponent's jersey numbers written big, and he made a mistake that Gus Ferrante would cross out in black marker four years later in Austin: he gave every defender two or three arrows. The sophomores ran whichever arrow was easiest. Coach Saenz's defensive coordinator, a quiet man who'd coached linebackers for twenty years, fixed it for him in Week 3 by holding up one card and saying, "Which one?" Teo didn't draw another card with two arrows that season. (He did, it turned out, the first week he got to Austin. Some lessons have to be learned twice.)
The rest of the season
The offense was smaller and better. Molina's interceptions dropped because every throw he made on Friday was one he'd made at least a dozen times that week against a scout defender who did one thing. The busted routes nearly disappeared. In Week 5 they added a thirteenth play: smash from the wing set. In Week 7 they added a fourteenth: a double move off the hitch, because the opposing corners had started squatting on the hitches.
They finished 6–4, winning four of their last six, and made the playoffs. Molina threw more touchdowns in the last six games than in the first four by a wide margin, and fewer interceptions in total over those six games than in the opener alone.
Analysis
The playbook was good. The install was the problem. Thirty-eight plays is not too many plays for a college offense with full-time players, many hours of meetings a week, and quarterbacks who've spent years reading coverages. It is far too many for a high-school senior who has two hours a day and a chemistry test. The question was never "how good is the offense?" It was "how many reps per call can this team afford?" With roughly a hundred full-speed offensive reps a week, thirty-eight plays meant fewer than three reps per play — and the first-time-ever reps of a new read, against a scout defense that did whatever it liked, don't count as preparation at all.
No review means no learning. Teo's August installed something new every day and never came back. The players heard each play once, ran it a couple of times, and moved on. By the opener, most of August was gone from their memories — not because they were careless, but because that's how memory works when nothing gets retrieved twice.
The scout team taught nothing. "The linebacker blitzes sometimes" isn't a look; it's a coin flip. Five protection busts in the opener came straight from a week in which the line never saw the same blitz twice in a row.
The fix was subtraction, then structure. Coach Saenz's "circle twelve" solved the volume problem in one afternoon. Teo's rebuilt week solved the structure problem: base before third down before situations, a daily review, a cap of one new thing per week, and cards with one arrow.
What transfers to the NFL. Lyle's offense installs far more than twelve plays — but the ratio is the same idea. The Outlaws run roughly one and a half full-speed reps per call per week because their players carry years of reps of the same concepts. The day a coordinator forgets that the ratio is the real constraint, he becomes Teo in August — at any level.
Discussion Questions
- Teo's offense was the offense he had played in. Why is "the offense I know best" a dangerous starting point for an install at a different level?
- Coach Saenz said, "They already know what we're doing. We're the team that doesn't know what we're doing." What does that line say about the relationship between volume and self-scouting at the high-school level?
- Compare Teo's rebuilt week to the Outlaws' week in 34.4. What's the same in the logic, and what changed because of two-way players and state contact limits?
- Teo kept four of Coach Saenz's runs and only one of his own college runs. What does that choice say about who should own the run game in a new staff?
- In Week 7 Teo added a double move off the hitch. Why was that the right moment, and how many reps should it have needed before it could be called?
Your Turn
You've just been hired as offensive coordinator at a high school with two hours of practice a day and a scout team made up of your own sophomores. Write your "Twelve": three formations, run both ways, and twelve plays. For each play, write one protection rule, one read, and the one defensive picture you will rep it against first. Then write the week's rule for adding a thirteenth play.