Chapter 22 Exercises — Protection: Keeping the Quarterback Alive

Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and independent research

All Outlaws, Sentinels, Forge, and Ospreys situations are fictional. Situations marked (hypothetical) are practice scenarios, not snaps from the season described in the chapter. Selected answers are in Appendix J.


Part A — Conceptual ⭐

A1. Define possible rushers, blockers, and the free man. In one sentence, state the protection's job when possible rushers outnumber blockers.

A2. What's the difference between a hot throw and a sight adjustment? Who must see the blitz for each to work?

A3. Explain "hot off the widest" in terms of distance and time. Use Darius Vance's hot-throw timing (about 1.0–1.3 seconds) and the two arrival times in the chapter (an A-gap rusher at about 1.9 seconds; a corner off the edge at about 2.4).

A4. In the Outlaws' "60 Left," which three linemen slide, which two block man, where does the back align, and what is his scan order?

A5. What does "look for work, outside first" mean? Which protections need it most, and why outside first?

A6. Why does slide protection handle a T-E twist almost automatically, while man protection needs a "Switch!" call?

A7. Name the cost of 80 Max and the defensive call that collects it.

A8. In the NFL, how far beyond the line of scrimmage may an ineligible lineman be when a forward pass that crosses the line is thrown? How does that rule shape a play-action protection? (Note how college and high school have historically differed, and why you should check the current code.)

A9. The Outlaws' protection card says "The center's point is a recommendation. The quarterback owns the final ID." Give two reasons the final say belongs to the quarterback.

A10. In your own words, state the chapter's threshold concept and give one "before" belief it replaces.


Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐

B1. On end-zone film you see the center step to his right at the snap, the right guard and right tackle step right with him, the left guard and left tackle each set on the man in front of them, and the back step up into the left A-gap. Name the protection family and the slide side in Outlaws terms.

B2. Study the picture and its description.

PRE-SNAP (Gun Doubles Right, Y attached, 60 Left called)

                         F
   C                                          $          C
               E   N        M    T    E   W
   X     H    LT   LG   C   RG   RT   Y            Z
                        Q   R

📊 Diagram (described): The protection called slides left. On the defense's right side, the Mike is in the right A-gap, a 3-technique is on the right guard, an end is outside the right tackle, the Will is walked up over the attached tight end, and the strong safety is down outside him. On the left there are only an end and a nose. The back is on the right.

(a) Count possible rushers on each side and the blockers on each side, as called. (b) What should the quarterback do before the snap? (c) After his adjustment, who is the free man, and where should the hot throw go?

B3. A defense shows both inside linebackers in the A-gaps, rushes four (both ends, the Mike, and the nickel), and drops the 3-technique straight back into the short zone over the slot. Name this kind of pressure. Which offensive blockers are most likely to end up blocking air in a half-slide protection that put the back on the Will?

B4. You see a rollout to the left after a run fake to the right. The left defensive end is never blocked, and the quarterback throws on the run as the end closes. Boot or Naked? What would you look for on the next snap to know whether the defense has adjusted?

B5. On a pressure, the slot receiver's defender blitzes, and the slot receiver keeps running his 12-yard dig. The ball goes to the spot where a quick slant would have been, and a linebacker intercepts it. Name the breakdown in this chapter's terms, and say who needed to see what.

B6. Study the picture and its description.

POST-SNAP (four rush, three drop, vs. a man protection)

             T drops          M drops     E drops
     E           D    N                         *
     X           X    X                       ==>
     LT   LG     R    C   RG          RT
                      Q

📊 Diagram (described): Nobody had a hand down before the snap. At the snap, the left end, a dime defender in the left A-gap, the nose over the center, and the nickel from the right apex rush. A defender off the ball on the left, the Mike, and the right end all drop. The left tackle, the back, and the center have the three inside rushers. The left guard, right guard, and right tackle have nobody in front of them.

Which blocker should pick up the nickel, and what rule tells him to? If nobody does, where does the hot throw go?

B7. On the Game 2 sack (Week 15, 3rd-and-7 at the Austin 38), list the two Outlaws blockers who blocked nobody, and name the defender who was in the hot window.

B8. On a zero-pressure snap, six defenders rush and the offense keeps the back and the tight end in. The tight end blocks for a count, then slips into a shallow route; two receivers run vertical routes; one runs a deep crossing route. Name the protection family in Outlaws terms, the reason the tight end may release late, and the defensive change that would most hurt this play.


Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

C1. Draw it up ⭐⭐. Draw "60 Right" against a nickel Under front (3-technique to the left, nose shaded to the right, both linebackers off the ball, the Will over the right B-gap). Show every blocker's assignment if the Will blitzes, and name the free man if the nickel blitzes too.

Short answer

In 60 Right the center, right guard, and right tackle slide right and take the right A-, B-, and C-gaps; the left guard takes the 3-technique and the left tackle the left end, man to man; the back, on the left, scans the Mike first (A-gap), then B, then edge. If the Will blitzes into the right B-gap, the right guard has him by gap, and the nose shaded right is the center's in the A-gap. If the nickel blitzes too, it depends on his side. From the left, the back's scan (A, B, edge) reaches him if the Mike stays home. From the right, he is outside the slide and beyond the right tackle's C-gap, so he is the free man by design, and the hot goes to the right slot he left.

C2. Draw it up ⭐⭐. Draw an empty formation with a five-man slide against a four-man front with two linebackers walked up in the A-gaps and a nickel over the left slot. Choose the slide direction, label the free men by design, and assign a hot on each side.

Short answer

Slide toward the A-gap threat that's more dangerous (or toward the field nickel's side if both are equal), so both A-gaps and the 3-technique are covered. The free men are the widest rushers: the nickel on one side and the end on the other. The hots: the left slot converts to a quick slant if the nickel comes; the backside quick route (a hitch or slant on the right) is the answer to the free end and the "other side" answer if a lineman drops into the left slot window.

C3. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐ (hypothetical). Against a Birmingham-style blitz team, third quarter, down 3, 3rd-and-6 at the opponent's 40. Six defenders walk up, nobody is in the deep middle, and the corners are pressed. Your wristband's zero bin has two hot throws and a max-protect deep over. Which do you want, and what does each ask of the protection?

Short answer

On 3rd-and-6, a hot throw is designed to beat six before the free man arrives, and a five- or six-yard hot converts the down if it's caught on time. The deep over asks seven blockers to hold for about three seconds against six and is a touchdown play — but at the opponent's 40 you may already be in field-goal range, so the down matters more than the shot. A reasonable answer: the hot throw, with the quarterback told which side is hot by the free man's side. If the defense has covered your hot with a dropper in this game, the deep over (seven blockers on six) becomes more attractive. Grade the reasoning, not the choice.

C4. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐ (hypothetical). Wild card at Oklahoma City, second quarter. Terrence Vail's Ospreys love simulated pressures: show six, rush four, drop a lineman into the quick windows. You want a 2nd-and-10 shot to Gaines on a post. Choose 60, 70, or 80 Max, and explain how a sim pressure changes your answer.

Short answer

Against sims, max protection's cost rises: you keep seven or eight in against four rushers, and the defense drops seven against your two- or three-man route. 70 (seven blockers, three or four in the route) is the common compromise for a post shot. Pair it with a check-release for the back so a four-man rush doesn't trap a blocker in the backfield, and a "look for work" rule for any lineman whose man drops.

C5. Draw it up ⭐⭐. Draw "Wide PA Boot Left" from Twelve personnel. Show the line's fake, who blocks the boot-side end, and where the crossing route arrives. Then redraw it as Naked and write the quarterback's rule for the unblocked end.

Short answer (C5)

On Boot, the line takes outside-zone steps to the right and the back fakes wide zone right; the U, attached on the left, kicks out the left end; the quarterback boots left; the Y, attached on the right, crosses the field and arrives on the left at about six to eight yards, with the X clearing deep and the Z on a deeper over or post. On Naked, nobody kicks out the end. The quarterback's rule: sell the fake so the end chases the back; if the end doesn't bite and closes, throw the first open route early on the run, or pull up and throw the backside route — never hold it waiting for the deep over.

C6. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐ (hypothetical). Next season against Sacramento. Third quarter, tied, 3rd-and-9 at your own 33. The Sentinels show their double-A mug with Weller walking to the boundary at about ten seconds — the Game 2 and Game 3 look. Your new mug rule is in place. Write the assignments for all six blockers, the two hots, and what changes if Bell and Ames both drop.

Short answer

Center on Bell, back on Ames, left tackle and left guard on Rollins and the nose, right guard on Coleman (looks for work if Coleman drops), right tackle widens to the widest field threat. Hots: Powers inside if the nickel comes and isn't picked up; Gaines's sight-adjust if Simmons comes; Harlan sits in the boundary if Weller rushes after walking (rule 5 says throw to the side he came from, which is the field — so the field answers come first). If both linebackers drop, the center and back look for work outside first, and the throw goes outside — away from the inside droppers. On 3rd-and-9, consider a call whose primary route already breaks outside.

C7. Whose fault? ⭐⭐⭐ (hypothetical practice rep). Thursday team period, 3rd-and-8 drill. The call is "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 60 Left, Mills." The scout defense shows a nickel walked up over the left slot and both linebackers off the ball. At the snap the nickel blitzes off the left edge, the Will blitzes through the right A-gap, and nobody else comes. Ruffin, on the right, picks up the Will. The left tackle blocks the left end. Powers, the left slot, keeps running his dig. The quarterback looks left, sees the nickel unblocked, and throws to where Powers's hot slant would be. Nobody is there. Interception. Whose fault?

Short answer (C7)

The protection was right: on 60 Left with the back on the right, the nickel off the left edge is the free man by design, and Ruffin correctly took the Will. The failure is the hot conversion: Powers's defender blitzed, so by rule he converts to a hot slant and gets his eyes to the quarterback. He kept running the dig. The quarterback was also wrong to throw to a spot rather than to a receiver; the rule is "throw the hot to a man who is there, or throw it away." Fix: a hot-conversion period in which the scout nickel blitzes on random reps and the slot must convert on the first step; grade both the receiver and the quarterback on every rep.

C8. Find the conflict ⭐⭐⭐. A defense aligns in a standing front from dime: nobody's hand is down. Seven defenders are within four yards of the line. Your rule is "Standing front: big on big, hot off the widest." (a) Who is "the widest," and why do you leave him free rather than the man in the A-gap? (b) Name the defender who is in conflict if the widest man rushes and your hot throw goes to his area. (c) Describe the sim the defense could run to escape that conflict.

Short answer (C8)

(a) The defender farthest outside, usually an apex nickel or a wide edge. He has the longest path to the quarterback, so he arrives last — leaving him free costs the least time. (b) The widest man himself: he can rush or cover his area, not both. If he rushes, the hot goes behind him. (c) Rush the widest man and drop a defender who looked like an inside rusher into his area, so the hot window is covered by someone the protection had counted as a rusher. The offense's answer is a second hot on the other side and "look for work, outside first" for the blocker whose man dropped.


Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐

D1. Rollins is beating your left tackle. Your options: (a) 60 with the back chipping him, (b) 70 with the tight end staying on his side, (c) slide the line toward him. For each, name what you gain, what you give up, and which coverage makes each option most expensive.

D2. Sacramento shows a double-A mug on about one third-and-long in four, and drops at least one of the mugged linebackers most of the time. Is it worth keeping six blockers in every time you see the mug? Argue it with the arithmetic, then argue the other side.

D3. Your quarterback has taken 14 hits in three games. Your head coach says "protect him more." Your analytics director says "get the ball out faster." Which do you choose, how do you check whether it's working, and what does each answer do to the rest of your call sheet?

D4. The Outlaws let the quarterback flip the slide and move the back but not change the play. Another staff lets the center make every protection decision and the quarterback none. Compare the two systems on speed, error rate, and what a defensive coordinator can attack in each.

D5. Write the strongest case you can that the Game 2 sack was the quarterback's fault. Then write why the chapter disagrees. Which argument would you make to your quarterback, and which to your staff?


Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

M1. With Chapter 5 (The Offensive Line). Chapter 5 said the line's job is "not to win more one-on-ones, but to make sure the one-on-ones exist." Restate that sentence for the whole protection — back, quarterback, and hot receiver included.

M2. With Chapter 7 (Understanding Defensive Structure). "The shell is not the coverage." Write the protection version of that sentence, and connect it to the mug rule "assume one drops."

M3. With Chapter 13 (RPOs). On an RPO, the line run-blocks and an unblocked defender is read. If a blitzer comes free on an RPO, who "protects" the quarterback? Compare the RPO's read to a hot throw.

M4. With Chapter 19 (Play-Action Passing). Play-action protection takes the run's name. Pick Inside PA and Wide PA. For each, name the run's unblocked defender and who in the protection must account for him on the pass.

M5. With Chapter 21 (The Quick Game). Take three quick-game concepts. For each, show how the leverage read (what the receiver runs with no blitz) and the sight-adjust (what he runs if his defender blitzes) work together. Which concept has no natural hot on one side?

M6. With Chapter 8 (The Language of Play Calling). The zero bin sits in the same spot on the Blue panel every week. Explain why that placement is a protection decision as much as a communication one.


Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐

E1. Chart a protection. Pick one NFL team and watch 20 of its third-and-long dropbacks on end-zone or All-22 film. For each, record: possible rushers, blockers, the center's first step, the back's path, the number of rushers who came, any blocker on air, the free man (if any), and where the ball went and when. Write that team's protection rules in plain sentences. Which rule would you attack as a defensive coordinator?

E2. Time to throw. Using a public source such as NFL Next Gen Stats, find several quarterbacks' average time to throw for a season. Then watch five of each quarterback's sacks. Classify each sack in Marisol's five buckets (lost the rep, held the ball, count, coverage, unblockable). Hedge your conclusions: what can't five sacks tell you?

E3. The double-A mug. Find three games in which a defense showed a double-A-gap mug on third down at least four times. For each mug, record which linebacker(s) rushed and which dropped, who blocked the A-gaps, and where the ball went. Does the offense's rule look readable from the outside? What would you change?