Chapter 4 Exercises — Personnel Groupings
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and independent film study
Selected answers appear in Appendix J. Short answers to Part C are given in <details> blocks so you
can check your reasoning right away. Remember: in a Make-the-call item, the reasoning is graded, not the
answer.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. State the personnel notation rule in one sentence. Then write out what 10, 12, 21, and 22 personnel each put on the field (backs, tight ends, wide receivers).
A2. Our Heavy package is Odom, Harlan, Brandt, Fale, and Sutton. Fale is a fullback on the roster. Why do the Outlaws call this group 13 rather than 22, and why does the ambiguity help the offense?
A3. Explain the difference between personnel and formation in your own words. Give one example of the same personnel in two formations and one example of two personnel groups in the same formation.
A4. Name the defensive personnel group most commonly used against each of these offensive groups and say what the defense gives up by using it: (a) 11, (b) 12, (c) 10, (d) 21.
A5. What is a big nickel, and how is it different from a regular nickel? Which Sentinels players played which roles in Sacramento's big nickel?
A6. Describe the NFL principle that governs substitution. What does the defense get when the offense substitutes? What does it lose when the offense doesn't?
A7. In your own words, explain "heavy to throw" and "light to run." What is each one trying to make the defense's personnel do?
A8. Why did Marisol Vega call the zero in the Twelve RPO column a bigger problem than the 63 percent run rate? State her "kill the zeros" rule.
A9. Why does a lineman wearing number 70 have to report to the referee in our Jumbo package, and what strategic cost does that reporting create?
A10. What makes a player a "hybrid," and why do hybrids make multiplicity cheap? Name two Outlaws hybrids and the two jobs each can do.
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
B1. You see this before the snap:
U O O O O O Y
X Z
Q
R
📊 Diagram (described): Two tight ends attached to the line on either side of the five linemen, two wide receivers off the line out wide, and a quarterback with a back directly behind him.
(a) What personnel is this? (b) What's the Outlaws' formation name? (c) Count the players on the line of scrimmage. Is the formation legal? (d) What defensive personnel would you expect from a team that has not yet adjusted to you, and what from Sacramento after Week 6?
B2. Same personnel as B1, but now:
X U O O O O O Y
Z
Q
R
📊 Diagram (described): The X receiver is on the line outside the left tight end, so eight players are on the line; the right receiver is off the line.
What's wrong, which player is affected, and what's the simplest fix?
B3. On the All-22, you watch a substitution: number 84 runs on; the slot receiver runs off. On defense, the nickel runs off and a third safety runs on. A safety walks down over the tight end who is flexed in the slot. Name the offensive personnel, the defensive personnel, and the matchup the offense was probably hoping for that it no longer has.
B4. Pre-snap: Eleven personnel, two-by-two, tight end attached right, back offset left. Defense: two safeties at 11 yards, four down linemen, two linebackers, a nickel over the slot. Count the box defenders and the run blockers. Who must come downhill for the defense to win a numbers count on an inside run to the tight end's side?
B5. Pre-snap: Eleven personnel, gun, the back motions from beside the quarterback out to the left, ending inside the slot receiver. A linebacker runs out with him and stays inside him. What has the motion told you about the coverage, and which defender is now in a mismatch?
B6. Describe what you'd look for on a broadcast angle to tell the difference between 12 personnel in "Doubles" with the tight end flexed, and 11 personnel in "Doubles." What's the single most reliable cue? Why isn't the jersey number reliable on its own?
B7. A defense answers 12 personnel with base, and the strong safety rolls down outside the attached tight end before the snap, leaving one safety deep in the middle. Is the middle of the field open or closed? Which of our receivers is now most likely matched on a linebacker, and in what kind of coverage?
B8. Study this pre-snap picture:
F F
C W M * C
E T N E
U O O O O O Y
X Z
Q
R
📊 Diagram (described): Two tight ends attached, both receivers off the line, a pistol backfield. The defense shows two deep safeties, four linemen, two linebackers, and a fifth defensive back standing just outside the right tight end.
The player marked * is 6-foot-1 and about 210 pounds, and you've seen him play deep safety on other
snaps. (a) Name the defensive personnel. (b) Count the box and the blockers. (c) Why is a run to the *
side harder against this group than against a regular nickel? (d) Name one pass concept that makes the
* defender wrong whichever way he plays.
B9. You're charting a game and notice that every time the offense's fourth receiver (a speed player) enters the game, the defense's sideline signals immediately and a linebacker starts pointing toward the side the receiver aligns on. Four of the receiver's five snaps so far were jet sweeps. What has the defense learned, and what personnel mistake is the offense making? Give the fix in one sentence.
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
C1. Make the call ⭐⭐. A hypothetical snap: Week 6 vs. Sacramento (before their big-nickel rule). 2nd-and-5 at the SAC 41, first quarter, Outlaws lead 7–0. Your self-scout says Sacramento has answered two-tight-end sets with base about a third of the time and with nickel the rest. You have Twelve available. What formation do you put Twelve in, and what play do you call against each possible answer? (You may build it as a "Kill" call — two plays, Vance picks by look.)
Short answer
Line up "Twelve, Gun Doubles Right" with Harlan flexed in the left slot, so the defense must declare by who covers him. Kill call: vs. nickel (Vo over Harlan) → Zip Harlan to a wing and run inside zone at the nickel's side, seven blockers against a light box; vs. base (a linebacker over Harlan) → Y Option or a play-action seam to Harlan. This is the "either way they're wrong" structure from 4.5: the formation forces the defense's personnel answer into the open, and the call punishes whichever it is.
C2. Draw it up ⭐⭐. Draw "Twelve, Gun Trey Right" against a 4-2-5 nickel with two high safeties. Label the box count and the blocker count. Then draw an outside zone run to the Trey side and identify the defender who has the hardest job.
Short answer
Trey Right: Harlan attached right as #3, Brandt as a wing just outside him as #2, Gaines wide as #1; Sutton alone on the left. Against nickel with two high: box = 4 DL + 2 LB = 6, plus the nickel (or strong safety) pulled toward the Trey side. Blockers = 5 OL + Harlan + Brandt = 7. The hardest job belongs to whoever is the force/alley defender to the Trey side — usually the nickel or the strong safety — because two tight ends are working toward him and he's giving up 40-plus pounds to each.
C3. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐. A hypothetical snap: Week 15 at Sacramento, second quarter, 1st-and-10 at the AUS 27, trailing 10–7. Sacramento now answers Twelve with big nickel every time (Holloway at Star, Pruitt deep). In the first quarter your two Twelve runs gained 1 and 2. You still have Twelve on the field and the defense has matched. Do you stay in Twelve? If yes, what do you call; if no, what do you change to and why?
Short answer
A defensible answer: stay in Twelve once more but change the why — an RPO or play-action that attacks Holloway's dual role (e.g., duo with Harlan popping behind him), because Holloway can't both fit the run and cover Harlan. Another defensible answer: get out of Twelve entirely and go to Eleven, where Sacramento's answer is a regular nickel, then compress and run at Vo. The weak answer is "duo again" — it plays into the exact personnel answer Sacramento built.
C4. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐. Two-minute drill. 1:48 left in the first half, 1st-and-10 at your own 30, trailing 13–10, one timeout. The defense is in nickel against your Eleven and has been playing soft two-high zone. Your Twelve has been your best run group today. What personnel do you use for the drive, and do you substitute between plays?
Short answer
Stay in Eleven and don't substitute. Every substitution gives the defense the right to match and costs clock management time; Eleven is your most balanced group and keeps three receivers on the field against a nickel playing soft zone. Twelve may be your best run group, but a two-minute drive needs plays that stop the clock and attack the sidelines; the defense would also happily bring a bigger group in answer.
C5. Draw it up ⭐⭐⭐. Draw an Eleven "Peel" to empty from Gun Doubles Right. Show two post-snap versions: (a) a linebacker runs with the back (man), and (b) nobody runs with the back (zone). For each, draw one throw that beats it and name the defender being stressed.
Short answer
(a) Man: the linebacker following the back is the stressed defender; give the back an option route at 5 yards breaking away from his leverage (as in the Week 8 snap vs. Birmingham, Ruffin +11). (b) Zone: with no one following, the defense has left a hole where the back aligned; the stressed defender is the underneath zone player on that side (often the nickel), who now has two receivers in his area — throw to whichever he doesn't take, e.g., a quick out by the back with the slot running a seam to hold him.
C6. Make the call ⭐⭐⭐. Week 12 vs. St. Louis (single-high, eight-man boxes, rolls a safety down against every group). 3rd-and-1 at the STL 22, Outlaws lead 13–10, late in the third quarter. You have Jumbo, Heavy, Twelve, and Eleven available. Pick a personnel group and a play family, and explain what you expect St. Louis's personnel to be in answer.
Short answer
Several calls are defensible. Heavy with play-action is a strong one: Heavy draws their base or heavy group and an eight- or nine-man box; a play-action flat or a Harlan dig behind the rolled-down safety beats a defense selling out on the run. Twelve with a QB sneak or duo is also reasonable because three-and-one is short. Name what you expect them to bring and explain how your call stresses it — that's the graded part.
C7. Draw it up ⭐⭐⭐. You're building a Twelve package that will survive a big-nickel answer. Draw one play from each of these three families, all from the same formation ("Twelve, Gun Doubles Right" with Harlan flexed left and Brandt attached right), against a big nickel with the safety-type nickel over Harlan: (a) a run with an RPO tag; (b) a dropback concept; (c) a screen. For each, name the defender you are stressing and what he must choose between.
Short answer
(a) Inside zone left with a glance or stick tag to Harlan — the stressed defender is the safety over Harlan, who must choose between fitting the run to his side and covering Harlan. (b) A Y Option or seam by Harlan with Sutton clearing deep and Gaines on a dig — the stressed defender is the deep safety on Harlan's side, who must choose between helping on Harlan and staying over Sutton. (c) A Y screen or RB screen off inside-zone action — the stressed defenders are the run-triggering linebackers and the safety, who are taught to attack run reads and will run past the screen. Using one formation for all three keeps the defense from reading the play family from alignment.
C8. Make the call ⭐⭐. A hypothetical snap against the Portland Pioneers (disciplined Cover 2 / Tampa 2, "keep it in front"). 2nd-and-8 at your own 42, first quarter, 0–0. Portland plays nickel against everything with three or more receivers and base against two-tight-end sets. Its Mike linebacker runs deep down the middle in Tampa 2. Which personnel group and formation would you choose to make Portland's base defense cover a tight end, and where on the field would you try to throw?
Short answer
Twelve with Harlan flexed into the slot to draw base. In Tampa 2, the linebackers drop to hook zones and the Mike runs the deep middle, so a seam or a Y option by Harlan between the hook defender and the half-field safety puts a linebacker in coverage on a receiving tight end. Throw to the area between the underneath linebacker and the deep safety on Harlan's side, or take the run if base aligns light. The key reasoning: choose personnel to dictate the defensive group, then choose formation to make that group cover in space.
Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. Gus Ferrante argues that a 63 percent run rate from Twelve is "who we are" and shouldn't be changed. Marisol argues that the zeros make Twelve a tell. Write a one-paragraph case for each side, then a third paragraph with your recommendation. Use the Week 6 and Week 15 results in your argument.
D2. You have one roster spot. Option A: a third tight end who is a good blocker and an average receiver. Option B: a fullback who can lead-block, play H-back, and catch passes out of the backfield. Which one makes your personnel system more multiple, and why? What does each option do to your 13 and 21 personnel groups?
D3. Big nickel answered both "heavy to run" and "heavy to throw." List three ways an offense can respond, and for each one identify the cost (practice time, player health, tendency risk, or run efficiency). Which would you install first, and why?
D4. A high school coach tells you, "Personnel doesn't matter for us — the other team's defense never substitutes." Is he right? What does his offense lose and gain compared to an NFL offense, and where should he spend his effort instead?
D5. Your best hybrid (a move tight end) has played 68 snaps in each of the last three games and is blocking 270-pound ends on half of them. The playoffs start in two weeks. What do you change in practice and in your personnel plan, and what does it cost your game plan?
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (Chapters 3 and 4) In Chapter 3 you learned that strength is declared to the tight end's side. In Twelve with two attached tight ends, which side is "strength"? How should your strength rule handle a two-tight-end formation where one is attached and one is flexed? Write the rule in one sentence your receivers could say back to you.
M2. (Chapters 1 and 4) Rewrite one of your Offensive Philosophy non-negotiables from Chapter 1 so it says something about personnel. Example: "We will never have a personnel group with a zero in it." Then explain how that non-negotiable would have changed the Outlaws' Week 15 first half.
M3. (Chapters 2 and 4) Pick two eras from Chapter 2's timeline — for example, the run-and-shoot and the 2019 Ravens. For each, name the offense's main personnel group, the defensive personnel it forced, and what the defense's eventual answer was.
M4. (Chapters 3 and 4) The same silhouette, three personnel groups: "Gun Doubles Right" with Powers, Harlan, or Fale in the left slot. For each version, list (a) the defensive personnel Sacramento used in Week 6, (b) the defender over the slot, and (c) the play you'd most want to call. Which version gives the defense the hardest decision?
M5. (Chapters 1, 3, and 4) Walt Dupree's saying is "Every play is a question. Know what you're asking." Write the question each of these asks: (a) Twelve in Pistol Ace; (b) Twelve in Gun Doubles with Harlan flexed; (c) Eleven with Peel to empty. What answer from the defense is each one looking for?
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. The personnel chart. Watch one full NFL game on All-22 (or the most complete broadcast angle you have) and chart every offensive snap for one team: offensive personnel, defensive personnel, formation family (2x2, 3x1, empty, tight, two-back), and play type (run, RPO, play-action, dropback, screen). Build a personnel × play-type table like Marisol's. Then mark every zero. Write a half-page memo to the defensive coordinator who will play them next week: which personnel group is a tell, and what personnel answer would you bring?
E2. Heavy to throw in the wild. Over two or three games, find five snaps where an offense used 12, 13, or 21 personnel and then spread out to throw. For each: what defensive personnel answered, who covered the tight end or fullback, and did the offense win the matchup? Look especially for linebackers matched on tight ends in the slot. Describe what the defense did on the next snap of that personnel group.
E3. The defensive answer. Pick one defense and chart how it matches 12 personnel across a full game: base, nickel, or big nickel (look for a third safety coming on). Compare run results against each answer and pass results against each answer. Using public charting data (nflverse play-by-play, plus any personnel or participation fields available for that season, PFF or SIS where you have access), see whether your one-game picture matches that defense's season-long pattern. Write down at least two reasons the numbers might mislead you — for example, small samples and teams choosing when to run.