Chapter 8 Exercises — The Language of Play Calling
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall and explanation · ⭐⭐ application to a described picture · ⭐⭐⭐ judgment with trade-offs · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension, research, and film study.
All Outlaws, Sentinels, Stallions, Pioneers, Forge, and Ospreys people and games are fictional. Use the Outlaws defaults from Chapter 8, section 8.3, unless a question says otherwise. Selected answers appear in Appendix J; short answers to Part C are given below each item.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. Name the five jobs a play call must do. For each, give one way a badly designed call fails that job.
A2. Put the six slots of the Outlaws call grammar in order. Then explain in two or three sentences why tags come last, using the idea of a radio cut-off.
A3. Define concept, tag, and default. Use the call "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Zip, 60 Left, Smash, X Fade, Alert Post" to give one example of each.
A4. Compare a numbered system and a concept system. Where does each one put the learning load? Which one better tells a receiver why his route matters, and why?
A5. The Air Raid tradition is often summarized as "few plays, many reps." What does a minimalist system gain from that, and what does it give up to the defense?
A6. State the NFL facts that set the time limits on communication: the play clock after most plays, the play clock after certain stoppages, and the moment the coach-to-quarterback radio cuts off. How many seconds of radio time does a coordinator have on a normal snap, roughly, and why is it less than that in practice?
A7. Explain the difference between an Alert, a Kill, and a Check. Rank them by how much authority they give the quarterback, and say which one requires no communication at the line.
A8. Why does the Outlaws wristband scramble its numbers and change them every week, when the defense can't hear the radio? Give at least three reasons.
A9. State the rule "tags can't eat the concept" in your own words and give an example of a tag that breaks it.
A10. "Meaningful words help memory; arbitrary words help concealment." Explain how the Outlaws resolve that tension, and why the line of scrimmage is the dividing line.
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
B1. Read the picture and name the coverage the defense played. Then say which receiver Vance should throw to on the call "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Zip, 60 Left, Smash, X Fade, Alert Post."
B1 (post-snap):
C (deep 1/3) F (deep middle) C (deep 1/3)
* (curl/flat) W (hook) M (hook) $ (curl/flat, widening
hard to the hitch)
X H O O O O O Y Z
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): After the snap, both corners are deep in the outside thirds and the free safety is in the deep middle. The nickel and the strong safety play the curl-to-flat areas, and the strong safety on the right is widening hard toward the Z's hitch. Two linebackers drop to the hook areas.
B2. Before the snap, the Z starts his zip motion toward the ball. The right cornerback runs with him, staying in press position until the Z settles. What has Vance learned? What changes in his expectations for the play?
B3. Read the picture. The call was "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside, Kill, Slants." Should Vance stay on the first play or kill to the second? Show the arithmetic.
B3 (pre-snap):
F $
C * W M C
E T N E
X H O O O O O Y Z
R Q
📊 Diagram (described): Two deep safeties, a nickel over the slot, two linebackers, and four down linemen: six defenders in the box. The offense has five linemen and an attached tight end.
B4. You are watching end-zone film from the press box level. On a third-and-seven, the quarterback stands outside the huddle with his hand on the side of his helmet until the play clock reaches 17. In the huddle, he glances at his left wrist. What does each detail suggest about the call?
B5. Read this huddle call and identify each word's slot: "Gun Trey Left, H Return, 70, Flood, Y Bender." Which motion word in the Outlaws system always needs a letter in front of it, and why?
B6. On film, a quarterback yells the same word to both sides of the line on six straight snaps, and the play changes on only two of them. What is the offense doing, and what would a defensive staff need to do to beat it?
B7. Read the Outlaws call "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 60 Left, Smash" against this picture and name the conflict defender and the throw.
B7 (post-snap):
F (deep half) $ (deep half)
(C) sinks under the corner route
H corner breaks at 12, (C) is on top of it
X hitch at 6: nobody within 5 yds
X H O O O O O Y Z
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): A Cover 2 picture with two deep-half safeties. On the left, the cornerback sinks under the slot's corner route, leaving the split end's six-yard hitch uncovered with no defender within five yards.
Short answers to B1, B3, B5, and B7
B1. Cover 3 (three deep, four underneath). The middle is closed, so the alert post is off. The right curl/flat defender is widening hard to the hitch, so Gaines is covered; the throw is Ruffin in the flat behind the widening safety, or Harlan if the curl/flat defender left him early and the corner is late to the deep third. The read in 8.4 says: widens to the hitch → flat.
B3. Stay on Inside. Six in the box (four down linemen and two linebackers) against six blockers (five linemen and the attached tight end) gives a hat for every hat. Two safeties deep means the pass would be throwing into more coverage than the run is running into. Vance still says something at the line: the week's dummy word, so the defense can't tell he stayed.
B5. Gun (backfield) Trey Left (formation and strength) · H Return (motion) · 70 (protection: seven-man, tight end stays in) · Flood (concept) · Y Bender (tag). Return always needs a letter because, unlike Zip, Jet, or Flip, it has no default owner; any receiver can go and come back. Notice also that 70 keeps the tight end in to block, so "Y Bender" conflicts with the protection: the Y can't both stay in and run a route. A good staff catches that on the whiteboard.
B7. The conflict defender is the left cornerback, Cover 2's flat player. He has sunk under the corner route, so the throw is Sutton's hitch at six yards. That's the second half of the Week 10 lesson at Portland: the corner must choose, and both choices lose.
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
C1. Draw it up. Draw "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Zip, 60 Left, Smash, X Fade, Alert Post" against a Cover 4 (Quarters) shell: two safeties at about ten yards, corners at about eight yards, a nickel, two linebackers, four down linemen. Show pre-snap and post-snap pictures and mark the throw.
Answer
Against Quarters, the corners and safeties both play deep quarters, so Harlan's corner route runs into two deep defenders. The flat on the right belongs to the curl/flat player (often the nickel or an apex linebacker in Quarters) or is left soft. Gaines's six-yard hitch from his reduced split is the likely throw, under a corner who is retreating. The alert post is on only if the backside safety bites on Powers's stem or widens to Sutton's fade. Your post-snap diagram should show four deep defenders across the field, underneath defenders at hook and curl/flat depth, and the ball going to the hitch.
C2. Make the call. 2nd-and-3 at the Stallions' 45, first quarter, 0–0. St. Louis has played single-high with eight in the box on 11 of 13 snaps. You want an RPO. Write the full call in Outlaws grammar, name the conflict defender, and explain why your call is under ten words.
Answer
One good answer: "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside Slant." The conflict defender is the weak-side linebacker (or whichever second-level defender fits the backside A/B gap and also owns the slant window). Against a single-high, eight-man box, the slant behind a triggering linebacker is the pressure valve. The call is five words because "Inside" carries the whole blocking rule and the RPO default tells every unnamed receiver to clear or block. A defensible alternative is "Inside Glance" if the safety rotation leaves the skinny post open. Either way, the reasoning about the box and the conflict defender is what's graded.
C3. Make the call (clock). Third-and-nine at your own 31, two-minute drill, 1:12 left in the half, no timeouts, the clock running. You go no-huddle. The call you want is twelve words long and is on the Blue panel as number 52. What exactly goes over the radio, and what happens if the radio fails on this snap?
Answer
"Blue 52," two words. In no-huddle, Vance signals the formation and play to receivers and Szabo gives the line the protection. If the radio fails, the sideline's live signaler sends 52 by hand signal (the dummy signaler sends something else), and Vance reads the band. The point is that the wristband plus signals give you a second channel that doesn't depend on the radio. A team without one is out of options in this exact situation.
C4. Draw it up. Draw "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside Slant" against the Sentinels' nickel Over front with two high safeties. Label the read key, the five blockers' direction, the back's alignment and track, and both outcomes of the read.
Answer
Your pre-snap picture should show Ruffin offset to Vance's left, the line and Harlan ready to zone right, Powers in the left slot, Sutton wide left, Gaines wide right, and the Will linebacker (Jordan Ames, #45) circled as the read. Post-snap: the line steps right; Ruffin crosses for the mesh; Sutton runs off the corner; Powers runs a quick slant behind the Will. Outcome 1: Ames triggers on the run → Vance pulls and throws the slant (Game 1, snap 1: +17). Outcome 2: Ames sits in the window → hand off (Game 1, snap 2: +7).
C5. Make the call. A hypothetical game against a Birmingham Forge–style blitz defense: third-and-two at their 34, third quarter, you lead 17–13. They have shown Cover 0 on 4 of 6 third downs today. You call "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside, Kill, Slants." Before the snap, they walk six to the line and both safeties creep to eight yards. Should Vance stay, kill, or go to the zero bin? Justify it with arithmetic.
Answer
The zero bin. Six on the line plus two safeties at eight yards means there may be no deep defender at the snap. Against Cover 0, inside zone is outnumbered (more defenders near the line than six blockers can handle), and plain slants from a six-man protection leave too many rushers for the protection if all six come. The zero bin's first plays are hot throws designed for exactly this picture; Vance doesn't need permission to go to it. If the safeties bail at the snap, the hot throw is still a completed short pass on third-and-two, so the cost of being wrong is small.
C6. Build a band. Using Outlaws abbreviations, write a six-row "3rd MEDIUM (4–6)" box for a game against a defense that plays mostly Cover 3 on third down. Scramble the numbers and write only what differs from defaults.
Answer
Sample: "33 Trp Rt Flood," "08 Trp Rt Z Dig," "47 Dbl Rt Zip Smash," "12 Trey Rt Stick," "29 Bnch Rt Snag," "54 Dbl Lt Y Cross." Flood and stick both stress the curl/flat defender in Cover 3; the dig attacks the hook-to-curl window; smash with the zip gives a hitch under a bailing corner. Grading looks for: situation-appropriate concepts, scrambled numbers, consistent abbreviations, and no unnecessary words.
C7. Whose fault? Week 12 against St. Louis, a hypothetical snap. The call is "Eleven, Gun Trips Right, Fly, 60 Left, Flood." The radio cuts out at "Sixty Left." Vance, with eight seconds on the play clock, calls "Flood" anyway because it's the most common concept from Trips Right on second down. The actual call was "Flood, Z Bender." Gaines runs a dig instead of the bender, and the ball is thrown to the spot where the bender should have been. Interception. Who is at fault, and what are the two fixes?
Answer
Mostly the coordinator, then the quarterback. The coordinator let a call run long enough that a tag was at risk, then didn't use the band. The quarterback guessed a play instead of using a reliable tool: calling timeout, checking to a known play, or running the base concept without throwing to a route he hadn't heard. Here's the subtle part: Vance actually guessed the concept correctly. What he didn't have was the tag. The grammar did its job, putting the tag last so the play survived. His mistake was throwing to the tag he hoped had been called. Fix 1: the ten-word rule: call the band number, plus at most one tag. Fix 2: a quarterback rule: "If you didn't hear the tag, there is no tag." Throw the base concept to its default routes.
Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. Your new quarterback is a rookie with a strong arm and slow pre-snap recognition. Your veteran receivers have played in a concept system for six years. Design the quarterback's authority at the line: which of Alert, Kill, Check, and zero bin do you give him in Week 1, and which do you add by Week 10? Defend each choice in terms of the risk of a wrong decision.
D2. A coordinator argues: "Dummy words are a waste. Defenses don't really listen at the line." Using the defensive view in 8.8, write a one-paragraph reply. Then name one real cost of dummy words to your own offense.
D3. Your offensive line coach wants every run call to include the blocking scheme and the direction ("Inside Right"), even though the formation already sets strength. Your quarterback coach says the extra word is noise. Who's right? Consider which players listen to which slots, sound-alike risk, and how often you run away from the strength.
D4. A head coach asks you to cut your playbook vocabulary by a third before the season because "the rookies are drowning." What do you cut first: concept words, tags, formations, or motions? What do you protect? Explain how defaults can replace some of what you cut.
D5. You discover in Week 7 that two words in your system, "Sail" and "Snag," are being confused in road games. You can't rename them midseason. Propose two rules that separate them for the rest of the year, and say what you'd do in the offseason.
D6. Marisol's chart says your team used four timeouts for communication in 17 games, three of them before the bye. Your head coach says, "Four timeouts in a season is nothing; leave it alone." Your quarterback coach says, "Every one of those was a timeout we didn't have in a two-minute drill." Weigh both views. What would you need to know about when those timeouts were used to settle the argument, and what does the small sample let you conclude?
Answer sketch
Both have a point. Four is a small number, and a sample that size can't tell you how often the problem will happen next year. But the cost of a timeout isn't spread evenly. A first-quarter timeout costs little; a fourth-quarter timeout in a close game can cost a possession. So the key data is the game situation for each one: quarter, score, and whether the team later needed a timeout it didn't have (as in St. Louis). The trend matters too. Three before the bye and one after suggests the ten-word rule and the quiet window helped, but four events can't prove it. The analytics informs; it doesn't decide.
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (Chapter 3 + Chapter 8) Call "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Zip." Count the players on the line of scrimmage, name the eligible ends, and explain why the zip motion is legal in the NFL. Then explain what goes wrong if the Z lines up on the line outside an attached Y in a different formation.
M2. (Chapter 4 + Chapter 8) The Outlaws come out in "Twelve" instead of "Eleven," with Cody Brandt (U) replacing Powers. Rewrite "Gun Doubles Right, Inside Slant" so it still works with two tight ends, and explain what the defense's personnel response does to your conflict defender.
M3. (Chapter 5 + Chapter 8) In "60 Left," which linemen slide and which block man? Where does the back align, and whom does he block? Then explain how Szabo's Mike call ("Fifty-four's the Mike!") changes the protection's starting point.
M4. (Chapter 6 + Chapter 8) A receiver in a numbered system receives a "7." A receiver in a concept system receives "Smash" and lines up as #2. Which receiver is more likely to adjust his depth correctly against a squatting corner, and why? What does your answer say about where to teach route relationships?
M5. (Chapter 7 + Chapter 8) The Alert Post in the chapter's sample call depends on the middle of the field being open. Describe a pre-snap look that would tempt Vance and a post-snap rotation that would punish him. Then write a one-sentence Alert rule that protects against that rotation.
M6. (Chapter 1 + Chapter 8) Lyle's thesis is "Motion for information, the run for credibility, the pass for the kill." Pick one word from each of three slots (motion, play, tag) that serves each part of the thesis, and explain the link.
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. The radio clock. Watch one full NFL game on television or on a replay service with a visible play clock. For 20 offensive snaps of one team, record when the quarterback takes his hand away from his helmet (or otherwise stops listening), when the team breaks the huddle, and when the ball is snapped. Calculate the average snap time and how many snaps ended with five or fewer seconds left. What does the pattern suggest about that team's call length or communication?
E2. The kill hunt. On film with audio (broadcast field mics, mic'd-up segments), track every word a single quarterback shouts at the line for one half. Mark which plays appear to change after the shout. Do you see evidence of dummy words? Write up what you can confirm and what you're guessing, and keep the two separate.
E3. Systems in public. Using books and well-documented coaching interviews you can verify, compare how one team in the West Coast tradition and one in the Erhardt–Perkins tradition describe their play calls. Don't quote anything you can't source. Summarize in a table: call length, where the learning load lives, and how the system handles formation changes.